We Compete to Make the Most SATISFYING CGi #3

[@joebrim]

IDEA!! “Don’t let them know you’re next move” render challenge. The render that was the most unexpected wins. Gotta keep ‘‘em guessing!

[@poolkrooni]

This would be lit 🔥

[@andreszarmach554]

Oh my god that would be sick. It perfectly plays to their strengths too imo

[@j_scumbag1762]

Yessss

[@wesublime]

Love this idea

[@cesarmolina5028]

Like that one really weird commercial soap

[@TheRumpletiltskin]

They need to do a WRENDER challenge where each one has to involve Wren.

[@xRockLobster75x]

100% agree

[@sbordi]

This is what the people want

[@mischief.brewed]

Yeah guys... Wren are you gonna do this?

[@mohammadmanhar8839]

That'd be my salvation

[@beaclaster]

wren breathing fog

[@BadgerByNature]

Would love to see a "Most Unexpected" render, where a seemingly-normal render is interrupted by something unexpected. That leaves a lot of room for interpretation, and it should probably still lean towards either the satisfying or humor angles.

[@YannickFilms]

Yesss🔥

[@Periwinkleaccount]

I quite like this idea. Maybe a cannonball being fired from a cannon, and then the camera becomes centered on the cannonball, which then becomes part of a ginormous eyeball.

[@besknighter]

Their take on the meme "Never let them know your next step" but with renders! Yes, I like this idea.

[@TacoMan99]

+Upvote

[@pmdesigns5798]

Great idea. Only downside is that everyone would be expecting something unexpected to happen.

[@adamreynolds3863]

Clint nailed it with the background of the city, giving the "up in the clouds" effect, also the sound of the trucks in the ramps BOOM that was awesome

[@iantaakalla8180]

It has the same effect of those ads for bad mobile games, but it seems to be more in the vein of “you can achieve this level of perfection easily” sort of gameplay instead of “this player sucks which entices the player to buy the game to see how it really would go” gameplay.

[@aeiou1738]

@@iantaakalla8180 I thought I was the only one lmao

[@chaosfire321]

Hearing Clint talk about tackling time management with his render has to be one of the most satisfying things of the vid, especially in light of his recent gripes over failing to do so with an older render. He got what he needed to do strong and early, and spent the rest of the time polishing it up. Perfectly satisfying!

[@simonj4071]

Yes!

[@poolkrooni]

I loved his the most as well, it created such a unique world

[@nickolasdaff6217]

That swimming at the end of the loop like in dream is so satisfying, and render atmosphere is so light. This one is the best for me!

[@JKMeZmA]

Missed Clint

[@zwd7898]

I was really hoping that when they asked "So who had the most satisfying render?" It was gonna be really dramatic and Niko was going to last minute say "Me! Roll the tape." And have just one amazing one to leave on.

[@yakomo84]

Glad I'm not the only one lol

[@Tirryna]

I was yelling for him to get out of there 😄

[@belugay5413]

Ngl I expected that too

[@alexanderg.larsson1456]

I thought so to. Honestly i was disapointed when he won i thought there were more renders

[@AidanS99]

If Jordan’s basketball simulation had that iconic “Swish” sound when the basketballs dropped in, it would be perfect! Also giving the net it’s own physics instead of just being stagnant.

[@MastaJ3di]

Definitely agree with the net sim, when he said the net was plastic I was kind of disappointed.

[@magics902]

I do think that'd be better. However the plastic net fits with the fact it's a children's toy so I understand why (and also saving time on it) it would be plastic.

[@kayce851]

100% agree, a missed opportunity. A cloth sim on the net and a great swish sound effect would've taken that from a 7 to at least a 9.

[@bradleythatcher2869]

Agreed. Net simulation would have been perfect.

[@Blynat]

@@magics902 Everyone is missing the point that you mentioned. IT'S A LITTLE TOY SIM NOT A FULL BASKETBALL COURT. It is unsatisfying that people miss this.

[@KontactMusic]

These are all awesome but I personally feel Jordan missed a gold mine by making the net of the basketball hoop plastic and rigid. The satisfaction of hearing a perfect swish as the ball glides through?! Top tier satisfaction

[@-Junx-]

thinking the same thing

[@siukong]

The fact that there wasn't a single swish was profoundly UNsatisfying.

[@skateify31]

IKR when he said "it's rigid and it rattles around" I thought he was gonna follow up with "so I'm gonna fix that and add a cloth sim with a nice snug *swish*" but instead he was like yup that's what's satisfying about a basketball shot... I was shouting at my phone

[@KontactMusic]

@@skateify31 I’m glad it wasn’t just me losing my mind over this. I left the video stressed not satisfied 😂

[@IgroSome]

i like how it sounds as it is, but yeah it's missing what's satisfying about basketball itself

[@matheusohara9050]

I would feel so much more satisfied with some net physics and the "swish" sound in the basketball one

[@ElNaxxi]

Yes, I was fully expecting it! My expectations ruined the satisfaction.

[@damncat2793]

Yeah, it's kinda disappointing

[@smittysbuilds]

i thought the same exact thing, it needed a swish.

[@zerefragn5626]

agreed

[@GCCJN123]

True. If Jordan actually use real life basketball sfx instead of plastic toys then it will be much more satisfying.

[@b4n8x56]

Honestly, had jordans basketball net been a "real" net with the real sound. Would have been top tier

[@Ambar42]

In my opinion it's already pretty perfect.

[@b4n8x56]

@@Ambar42 It's very good already indeed. But it just needed that cherry on the icing

[@naughtmare]

Totally agree with both of you! Jordans are usually my favourite, and if I had to guess I'd say the fact that it is plastic is the right call for time management and theme. But man... nothing but net would have been on another level.

[@owen823]

The launching sound is irritating for me, not sure if I'm alone on that. Conceptually, I felt that Jordan was on top though. Simple machines are pretty damn satisfying.

[@bitchass9073]

Yup, only reason it wasn’t top tier for me was because it looked like it could fail at some point

[@eucolecionodinossauros]

Wren's is kinda unsatisfying, because instead of the knife cutting, it is just ripping the cloth. Not a nice clean cut, so can't satisfy me. Instead it makes me feel annoyed the knife isn't sharp and is doing a horrible job

[@Verosa1410]

true, I was expecting something like when you use a scissor and that thing would just slide through without you doing anything, that's the good shit. but I guess wren just wants to use and show off the new cloth sim, and it does a good job of doing that. my personal pick is Clint render.

[@fromthegamethrone]

Agree

[@3n3my33]

I agree. The cloth ripped in such a jagged way that I was rather unsatisfied.

[@mbi.studio]

exactly, i think they were just nice to each other :)

[@Isnogood12]

Definitely the most un-satisfying one. I much prefer the skateboard and the basketball.

[@Geckomayhem]

I have to admit: the way that Wren's knife pierced through the cloth was wicked. But the knife looked thick and blunt. My vote would be for Clint's. When the skateboard (and skateboarder) reaches the apex and _just_ glides to start over. /chefskiss

[@TL-sk6xf]

fully agree

[@SovietPenguins]

Clint or Jordan's was so much better imo Wrens cloth was also too thin. The best satisfying gifs are the ones that look like they could be real.

[@Ch33secakeGaming]

Fully agree

[@107zxz3]

The knife was also missing resistance from the cloth.

[@jesseferreira3590]

I agree, sadly I think Wren missed the importance of using a blunt object in order to simulate a satisfying tear and not a cut. But having a knife that isn’t making a clean cut almost makes unsatisfying

[@mariothingy]

The basketball render really does check all the boxes. The sound design, the chamfered edges, the tilt-shift, the color palette, the physics, the design of the tracks.. There's not one bit of jank anywhere to be found. That would've been my winner, personally.

[@Dysan72]

Same. The part that killed the knife one for me was the blend between the two sheets. or lack of blend I should say.

[@Adrischa]

I didn't like the sound design and it qas a bit too hectic in my opinion

[@jemandetwas1]

For me it really lacked physics on the net. I also couldn't stop thinking about how one the balls might miss the timing, because it was so close so often.

[@comradeblin7782]

The only thing unsatisfying about this was that paramount thought their show was good enough to sponsor these guys.

[@comradeblin7782]

@@AbiDextrous not even the CGI was all that great 😞

[@tturi2]

They call New Alexandria "Reach City" on Planet Reach like that's the least imaginary name for a place with a great name already, uggh, triggering the poor writing in that show

[@MMMHOTCHEEZE]

@@AbiDextrous Nah, him not having his helmet on in every scene is truly the most unsatisfying thing about the show.

[@rgneelam3793]

agreed dude i was like loling the whole time

[@Mavve69]

SO TRUE

[@sgartner]

Almost everyone is afraid of heights. Challenge: Make the most vertigo-inducing render.

[@UndertakerNeverDies]

I feel like to get the full effect of what you’re suggesting would have to be seen through VR. It just wouldn’t be the same with just seeing it on a screen like they usually do.

[@Rujewitblood]

that's a good idea, maybe an 'anxiety inducing' one, a lot you could do with that

[@stevetennispro]

I'm sure they would take that to... new heights. ;)

[@smackfanxion]

HELL! YEAH! I WANNA FEEL MY GUTS JUMP!

[@vAmmonite]

Everyone is born with two fears; falling and loud noises. We often group heights and falling together but in actuality they're separate, falling is a given and heights is the fear of being up high, even if you know you're safe.

[@Cloud.210]

Jordan’s render actually gave me tingles down my back. It was like watching ASMR. The ball that went around the rim and in right before the other ball went in was the most satisfying for me.

[@raphaelmorgan2307]

yup, his was the most satisfying for me (although the sound design on the skateboard one makes it a close second)

[@NazmulhossainTahsin]

These are some of the best satisfying renders but the "puzzle piece" is still the best wrender for me.

[@chaosthebaryonyx6344]

'wrender'

[@marselo1316]

aint no way someone said they liked the cloth ripping more than the puzzle piece one. There’s no way

[@averywhitaker3513]

Nice

[@728GT]

The duality of satisfying renders with the most unsatisfying TV series is genius.

[@Robopup325]

was looking for comments mentioning this

[@MyHeadHz]

That show just reveals how lazy showrunners have become. They try and have it both ways by attempting to market to the built in audience of an existing IP, but obliterate what made it special to try and appeal more broadly. As the adage goes: if you try to pleas everyone, you please no one.

[@JonathanLaRiviere]

So satisfying that our favorite KZbinrs are getting paid by our least favorite video game TV show.

[@AlexKavazArt]

oxymoronic

[@samnicole3619]

You guys should do one where you connect the satisfying renders to make one big, satisfying render.

[@ShotgunFistfight1408]

Clint does that on his other channel pwnisher

[@XhanAnimations]

Big brain

[@armpit_farts7327]

@@ShotgunFistfight1408 Was gonna say the same thing. THats literally Clints channel lolol. (not all of it, but you know what I mean).

[@anthonybrancati4475]

Always a Wren fan and nothing beats the puzzle pieces but damn I really was hypnotized by Jordan's on this one! Love the channel and keep these satisgying renders coming!!

[@BrooksHolt]

That basketball one was so satisfying

[@PNWAffliction]

if the net did a swish it woulda been icing

[@MrPruske]

Looks kinda V like to me

[@handleerror]

@@MrPruske came here just to see if anyone else thought it looked like a v or ovaries 😭

[@florvince9025]

The skateboarding one was by far my favorite- beautiful background and sound design, and the loop was perfect

[@SozBoz]

The entire show can be summed up in five seconds of your sponsor. Paramount: Do you know where a good story comes from? Wren: Video games? Paramount: (Disgusted) No!

[@uglynerfherder]

The show sucks man, I wished it didn’t so badly…

[@Florkl]

That was probably my favorite bit in the video. I can’t believe they kept it in.

[@728GT]

😂😂😂 accurate

[@blastergames1]

@@Florkl And the best part is that I dont even know if it was planned. Wren said it so genuinely!

[@kevinthiago413]

Super unsatisfactory series

[@5MadMovieMakers]

Someday we will be able to animate camera positions in real time using our phones or VR headsets / controllers

[@cristianarreola7246]

You just started learning blender, maybe you could try your hand at this soon!

[@5MadMovieMakers]

@@cristianarreola7246 I used the VirtuCamera app on iPhone to do this! Can't wait to look into performance capture stuff for characters

[@lonelylama5222]

We already can though

[@Wayne_wood97]

It’s ironic that a satisfying video is sponsored by the most unsatisfying streaming series

[@HypeTrains]

IMO the knife not finishing the piece of cloth really hurt at the end. I thought the basketball and skateboard renders were the best. All cool stuff!

[@ipraytovodka]

yeah surprised me that he won after that - it really pulled me out of the experience

[@SztywnyPatyk]

@@ipraytovodka they went for satisfying him after his After Effects experience

[@chichennn]

For me its the uneven cutting edges of the cloth, showing that the knife isn't that sharp to cut through smoothly. Kinda pained me

[@fabricioaf89]

And the way the cloth wrinkles under the knife

[@blowc1612]

@@chichennn exactly, the fact the cloth sagged, meh. it should be pulled a nice tight cut going down like a great paper being cut in the middle.

[@ashvinvaidyanathan7239]

Nah, Clint won this one ez clap. That slight half a second delay before it loops has you waiting for the skater to go down and when she does it just hits that itch perfectly.

[@JD2jr.]

Yeah, the one aspect that no one verbalized was the anticipation and relief. That's why no one was mentioning the liquid one, it just kinda... happened. With nothing around it.

[@prgnify]

And that sound design hnnnnnng

[@BlueFlash215]

After seeing the third satisfying render challenge I feel like I have only seen on truly satisfying render. That was Wren's puzzle piece fitting exactly. They show so many perfect examples of satisfying videos/renders. I guess their creative minds make them leave that path and do something.... creative? Most are not really satisfying but I can appreciate the work and dedication

[@lonelylama5222]

Jordan's one was pretty dang good though, but I guess we all have different tastes and that's okay.

[@jakegrenz4437]

Can we just acknowledge how Jordan confidently pronounced Kobe as “Colby”

[@DesignByKirk]

I came looking for this comment as soon as I heard it ... wtf Jordan ... lol

[@ghgg2]

I got second hand embarrassment from that. I had to rewind it to make sure I heard it right

[@aisforannihilation1662]

I thought I heard that too. Could've just been a speech error like we all have daily as we fumble thru words we know well or perhaps he's unaware of 1 of the biggest ballers names. Who knows? 🤓

[@iveharzing]

For me one of the satisfying parts of ripping cloth is the fact that it's a perfect line, and Wren's simulation didn't have that, it had all kinds of random bits flying around, so the other 3 were a bit more satisfying to me.

[@Jarekthegamingdragon]

The basketball and skateboarding ones were waaaaay better than the others. No way wren's should have won lol

[@aefinn]

100% I didn't find the knife satisfying at all. I feel like the fact what they do for living factored a lot to that since doing those cloth simulations have not been that easy before so it was more satisfying because of that instead of actually because of the content.

[@malfaroangel3896]

Yeah the cloth one looks kinda stop motion due to ripped cloth. Clint had the best one

[@haramberinokripperino7770]

It’s almost like everyone has a different satisfaction theme, for example I usually don’t find satisfying anything that involves human motions, idk why, maybe I like mechanics things that are able to move smoothly

[@highdefinition450]

Lmao ikr

[@louisrobitaille5810]

If you factor in the difficulty of simulation, cloth becomes #1 by far.

[@JohnnyBit]

Wren's render is unstatisfying totally - the dull knife with dull rip instead of cloth cut is rage inducig, like "AAAAAaaaargh sharpen the f... knife!"

[@the-walker]

I agree so much

[@einarschwentke7813]

And the way it’s cutting through those wrinkles was giving me anxiety. If he would’ve angled the knife so the handle was down and the tip was up it would’ve pulled the cloth taught and made a nice cut. That would’ve been way more satisfying. The way it was cutting through those wrinkles didn’t look natural.

[@trinhedman8854]

Also, do you know the cost of material? He ruined the entire piece. But I appreciate the time he put into it.

[@sarchiba]

@@trinhedman8854 well, it is only a 3d render, so no wastage of course!

[@tavobragachannel]

yes. not satisfying at all. a super sharp knife effortlessly cutting paper (instead of cloth) would have been perfect 👌

[@memethanYT]

Suggestion: confusing renders that mess with perception, maybe AI generated stuff, etc.

[@girlnado]

this is a great idea! crisp renders like these but they're optical illusions would be so cool!

[@MobiusStudiosJack]

Yeah -- that or like misleading ones... ones that make you think it's going one way and totally goes an unexpected route. "We Compete to make the most UNEXPECTED Renders" or something like that.

[@girlnado]

@@MobiusStudiosJack that'd be super cool

[@Shaderox]

From what i've heard about the Halo tv show, Chief has more total screentime wearing the helmet in this ad space than in the show.

[@bomdoboy]

Seen 9 episodes and I regret it

[@noah3369]

Right rough sponsor this one

[@noah3369]

Inspired was a bit of a long shot

[@THEEDAB710]

Worst show I’ve ever seen. It’s a pile of shit

[@elias_xp95]

@@noah3369Get the bag, who cares if paramount gets the views. bag secured.

[@ZhaneX24]

Clint's was my favorite personally. The sound of the wheels on wood was a great touch, and I loved the way it transitions and loops.

[@mr.tartar]

Who else noticed the way they flinched at the beginning of the first CGI clip, I couldn't stop laughing LOL.

[@HeyMan96]

bro i was wondering who else saw that

[@rustyanvile]

Jordan's was definitely the most satisfying for me, all the other ones had weird parts that just didn't quite work, Wren's had cloth pieces acting weird, falling off and sticking to the knife, Clint's skateboarder movements seemed a bit too jerky and not fluid enough like on the first jump, there's just a sudden acceleration to do the backflip instead of it being consistent the whole way through, and Fenner's had parts of the liquid seemingly disappear to nowhere. All of them really good and I think those issues were more of an uncanny valley effect where because the rest was so good, the slight issues stood out more.

[@terragthegreat175]

The only thing about Jordans was that it was kind of chaotic. Like I wasn't really sure What to look at or follow

[@blowc1612]

yeah, its called MOMENUTM.

[@will-in-a-million1146]

Alright, here’s a fun idea: Shapeshifter rendering challenge. Having an object transform it’s shape into something else. Whichever is the most fluid transformation wins.

[@The_Wosh]

Animorphs

[@mariothingy]

That's a great idea. It's specific enough to marry all the renders together under a common theme but gives plenty of latitude for how to approach the actual transformation

[@JTAI2]

Master chief: "What is one thing you love about your greatest movies" Ren: "Good story telling " Master chief: "exactly, and you know where a good stories come from" Ren: "Video games" Master chief: "No" would have been perfect if they ended it there with, "watch Halo on paramount plus"

[@SirWrender]

It’s not that hard to spell my name lol

[@stevealford230]

@@SirWrender It is if one doesn't know that it's spelled that way.

[@RDR911]

@@stevealford230 it comes up like once a video, did the dude just not watch? I mean there’s definitely a middle ground here but even still, the name is everywhere.

[@JTAI2]

@@SirWrender Sorry, I shant make that mistake again, and too agree that you had the most satisfying CGI

[@stevealford230]

@@RDR911 Most people don't even notice script or subtitles on videos unless the flow of the video forces their eye to it or the context requires them to read it. It may be natural to you and me, but it's not the norm.

[@max_power8510]

Clint's render was by far the most satisfying.

[@knight_bear]

I'd be interested in seeing some constraints on the renders, like everyone having to do fluid simulations or having to achieve a certain objective in different ways, like having to get a golf ball into a hole in the most creative way, for example. Another idea could be making the most tense renders, like being _just_ about to fall off a tall building. But I'll still keep coming back, I love watching these!

[@jonaslande2523]

clint have had some big render competitions on his chanle with this. It is amazing!

[@johnenright]

@@jonaslande2523 got there ahead of me Jonas!

[@JaPls]

That was the hardest one to pick a favourite. They were all really great, but I think just how the loop ends and starts, I have to go with Clint's

[@dratomik]

Agreed, there's something REALLY satisfying about the climb to the top of the ramp, then the sudden inertia of gravity. Clint is amazeballs.

[@tbrickman]

It was great, but I felt like the physics of the jumps themselves needed some tweaking. Also some more animation on the skater so you can really see how she moves under the inertia

[@PWN_Nation]

Yes... +1 to Clint.

[@bluefootedpig]

I think Clint took the top, the sound of the skateboard and the loop. The cutting, the cloth looked wrong to me, like how it would tear above the cut at the start. The basketball one is my 2nd fav, if it only had a tad bit better sound, but it was so much more fun to watch.

[@Whatthetrash]

I like Clint and Fenner's the best. I actually found Wren's to be the most unsatisfying - but that's just my two cents. A super-sharp knife piecing the fabric I think would have helped wren's and net physics (as well as a satisfying 'swish' as the balls went through the hoop) would have made Jordan's better to me. Great video, all! ^_^

[@wordsinahandle]

The basketball one could've had smoother sounds and swish and splash of the bball in the net

[@wordsinahandle]

The skateboarding one was the best sound wise but for some reason was lacking

[@wordsinahandle]

The fluid simulation of the corridor logo was great but the colour and sound were jarring a bit

[@wordsinahandle]

I guess in that light Wrens render was the cleanest.. but yeah we just expect a lot more.. the puzzle piece one is still up there over these.

[@butter_nut1817]

if he had some mechanical arms pulling the fabric up through a steady blade it would have been a lot better

[@MegaBoxer1314]

Some ideas that come to mind: -Jump Scare Render -Best Journey Render(Take camera from point a to b, tell a story) -Best Twist Render(most surprising/weird turn of events) -Perpetual Motion Renders -Wrendivor(a survivor type show where contests compete to make different categories of Renders and the Renders with the least amount of votes gets kicked off the "island". Also Wren has to host the show. -Building Render(create a Render showing something being built from start to finish -Switcheroo (everyone needs to compete to create a Render but they have to use a software that they have either never used or have rarely used. -Crappy Software Challenge: Create a Render using niche/not industry standard packages. -Minimalist Challenge(compete to make the best Render with either the least amount of polys/tris or just objects in general.

[@danthiel8623]

Jump scare render hmmm

[@katiekennedy8461]

I would love to see them make jump scares

[@formallyknownasj.a.2074]

Ah the irony of Master Chief talking about good story telling. Had only somebody had that talk before they started shooting on the show.

[@jakezimmer7256]

they just told a story that didn't come from the games

[@formallyknownasj.a.2074]

@@jakezimmer7256 … The story they “chose” was crap. There’s so much more lore from books and other sources that they could have written something good that actually felt like they were telling a Halo story.. but they didn’t.

[@hankarnold244]

Sorry Halo TV Series, not even a sponsorship with corridor crew can save you.

[@StayFractalesque]

lmao, weren't they rippin' on the show the other day on their podcast?

[@mercenary1106]

Agreed

[@nandraaprianto5026]

Is it really that bad??

[@ConanOG]

That Master chief is unrecognizable. Cancelled my subscription because I know I don't want any other season of the same thing.

[@WallEWorld]

@@StayFractalesque It might be why Paramount only "sponsored a portion of this video"... hmm interesting.

[@Farnciss]

Try "the most funniest CGI renders" would be interesting, thinking about what would the crew think of

[@Isnogood12]

Wren's would be something horrifying and gruesome, and then he'd be like "Wait, you don't think this is funny?" with a sad face.

[@roguevector1268]

I think having a 'theme' makes these challenges better, since what's 'funny' is veeeery broad and would induce choice paralysis.

[@AndrewDembouski]

Jordan has gotten up there as one of my favorites in the group, despite being relatively new. He kills it every time, no matter what the project is, and his personality is great

[@didnt_ask_for_handle]

I feel like Wren always has a somewhat different idea of what's satisfying than what people usually consider. The cutting cloth or fabric idea is good but it should have been in the context of a tailor, like a very measured and clean cut. Especially since that also makes a much softer, pleasant sound. Could have been paper cutting too, and folding it over itself to start the loop again

[@MrIse2]

Or heated blade comming through nylon, burning and cauterizing material. With the sound of grilled bacon.

[@Original-Phantom]

satanic influences made him win lol

[@armpit_farts7327]

In all fairness, "satisfying" is kind of biased in nature. I LOVEEEEE how Wrens render sounded. I think that clean cut scissor to paper sound is way less satisfying then tearing fabric. Cutting paper makes me think of school, tearing fabric makes me think of my gma sewing. I think thats fair enough lolol.

[@didnt_ask_for_handle]

@@armpit_farts7327 A sharp extendo blade through a folded paper is very satisfying. Unlike scissors it's one continous swish sound. It's usually easier than using scissors too. And then you can make the animation form something with the cut up pieces before looping

[@LDSG_A_Team]

Wren's fabric sim was cool and all, but I didn't find it satisfying, because there is very little that is more frustrating than a dull knife. That thing did not cut. It only tore through things. The sound design was great, though.

[@JathTech]

Agree 100%. I hate dull knives, and this was the dullest I've seen. IT was BAD.

[@rapflapfl]

Yep, I agree

[@SirWrender]

Yeah this is interesting feedback and I find myself agreeing. I’m still learning this new cloth system and it wasn’t tearing as cleanly as I would’ve liked. Truthfully I was just kinda stoked I could get the cloth to rip at all haha 😛

[@LDSG_A_Team]

@@SirWrender fair enough, my good sir! And like I said before, the sound design was fantastic.

[@rapflapfl]

@@SirWrender haha, ok, I too would've been extremely stoked, if I'd be able to make the cloth rip apart

[@XistoKente]

Jake wearing a Master Chief costume is by itself better than the Paramount Halo series.

[@wardogbobby2974]

At least here, they actually wear the suit

[@AyaxRo]

@@wardogbobby2974 Right? I was worried Jake would come out NAKED to be true to the series....... :/

[@DCHeat]

These r the best corridor vids

[@Siggvard]

Jordan should've won. All I could think about with Wren's render was how dull the knife seemed.

[@blowc1612]

Jordan's was the worst, the fact that not a single shot was a swoosh, was annoying. Knife 2nd. The water was meh, thought we would see like water going down a drain, but nope... only Clint's was satisfying.

[@CablixMoreWow]

@@blowc1612 the net is solid tho

[@blowc1612]

@@CablixMoreWow not for basketball players. How he did not add the most satisfying sound in all sports, the swoosh.

[@Siggvard]

@@blowc1612 Clint's was good but the second trick killed it for me. It looked unnatural and too floaty.

[@bgpiper]

Jordan's had the potential to be the most satisfying, but I didn't like the sound design, and I thought it would be better if the net had physics and made the "swish" sound-I didn't like how the balls kind of bounced around instead of just dropping right through. I actually found Clint's to be the most satisfying, mainly because of the sound design and the pacing of the loop; the perfect rotations and landings on the tricks truly felt satisfying. I thought Wren's loop was kind of clunky, and because the cloth tears messily instead of cuts cleanly it isn't very satisfying-the sound design was nice though. Fenner had a good concept, but I don't think it was executed very well.

[@toseltreps1101]

fenners was outright shit.

[@APEX_FUEGO]

The idea was to imitate a toy he saw as a child & re-living that moment. So as shown, it's meant to represent a toy.

[@alexanderjohansson2671]

Seeing again and again that ball that almost didn't get in, left me frustrated rather than satisfied.

[@TheSuperDoum]

you read my thoughs

[@Axle-F]

Sums up the video perfectly, making me satisfied that I’m not the only one 👊🏻

[@RellekEarth]

I feel like Wren could've done the scissors gliding across paper. The sound design for that one alone would've been satisfying enough. Then had a couple different materials that it glides by each with their own physics and sounds. Missed opportunity. I think Wren's was the least satisfying personally.

[@owen823]

I'd agree that Wren's is the least satisfying...unevenly cutting fabric with a dull knife could win the unsatisfying challenge lmao. Whats weird (or maybe not?) is that I also thought of scissors on paper during this video. Specifically, scissors on wrapping paper. That sweet, clean, basically perfect glide rushes dopamine to my brain. Conversely, for the next Unsatisfying challenge, imagine a really nice scissor glide interrupted by a snag. Bleh.

[@georgerosebush9754]

Also, that little hole at the start, plus all the little bits left on the knife, really off putting

[@0741921]

i just commented the same thing, haha

[@someone-nf3ui]

If Jordan made the balls perfectly get into the holes without them bouncing around it would have destroyed the competition

[@morfy2581]

He wanted to try out the new cloth sim.

[@isaacbuttigieg583]

16:13 97% of players cannot beat this level

[@jamodonnahan610]

This Halo ad is better than the series itself! At least Jake kept on the helmet ^^ And his clothes. Spoilers: And he did not .... kill himself ....

[@thenuggetlord4290]

I haven’t seen anything related to the show but this is already to much information for my comfort

[@RDR911]

@@thenuggetlord4290 master chief has sex with a Prisoner of War. Need any more reasons not to watch other than that war crime?

[@WallEWorld]

Wtf? First time I'm not mad about a spoiler but I am confused.

[@Real28]

I spent all of Halo 3 with my buddies loading into Social playlists and betraying/suiciding. So if he did kill himself that's accurate 😂

[@nybergsgarage]

@@Real28 he didn't kill himself as far as I know. however, he was rather fond of mooning the audience... hence where his new nickname, master "cheeks" comes from.

[@Henricky.]

18:05 "All the balls dude! Hmmm!" Has to become a meme🤣🤣

[@ixiTimmyixi]

Would love to see either The Scariest VFX challenge or an Inception Challenge. Where everyone has to make worlds inside of worlds. Love you guys, keep inspiring the Masses

[@telisto]

Scariest VFX is a great Idea

[@ixiTimmyixi]

@@telisto Thanks. I bet they would make some crazy stuff.

[@tatyannafrancis9935]

Worlds inside of worlds would be sick

[@grimnartusk265]

8:50 That theme song ALWAYS gives me goosebumps, even when y’all sing it lmao. Then that guitar chord hits, BOYYYYY I get hype!!! I’ll never forget playing Halo CE for the first time.

[@localkauf]

1. I would've liked wren's if the knife cut was clean and if the cloth had been fully cut. 2. I will never understand why Jordan decided that his basketball nets should be rigid??! The swish sound would've been so so good. 3. I like the fluid sim, but it was a bit too abstract so as to find it completely satisfying. 4. For me, Clint's was the best. Whilst the idea was perhaps the most basic of the four, the excecution was the best

[@angrypotato_fz]

In regards to 2. - I also would prefer a standard net, but I think the case is it the whole contraption was meant to be a child toy, and these usually were all plastic (like for example Mouse trap tabletop game) 3. Agreed too! I'd like it more if it was more realistc. And I think it would be cool if the logo was firstly the material "poured" into a mold and then funneled down to solidify as the new mold.

[@neXib]

The anticipation in the looping part and the sound and details made Clint's the best for me too.

[@mrebbesen]

I agree on all your points

[@ADAAMantium]

14:38 lmfao the jump scare on wren and clint

[@SvedishProductions]

Half of the satisfaction of making a basket is the sound of the "swish" when the basketball passes through the net!!! Great render, but missed opportunity.

[@RickyKejmusic]

1) Skateboard 2) Basketball 3) Knife 4) Liquid

[@saqibanjummasoodi]

Some quality content incoming, cant wait to see what Peter doesn't finish this time

[@kidzvidz3262]

Lmao

[@ImKairyu]

@@schebbi kinda the joke?

[@saqibanjummasoodi]

@@schebbi Why. Whats wrong with commenting beforehand

[@donjohnson5424]

Paramount... let me give you a hint. If you're going to make a show based on the most popular video game series of a generation, make sure the creators are fans of the game. It's unbelievable that you chose creators who literally brag about never playing the game. It's almost like you were trying to offend the fans that would have made you show a success.

[@maddog2314]

Just like Star Wars. Sequel trilogy? Trash by non-fans. King Filoni comes in and creates masterpieces.

[@GuadaMada]

PREACH

[@BensonBoy2019]

They want our money, but they look down on us. F them.

[@RDR911]

For anyone reading this confused: The Halo TV series was shit. On the whole I think it probably deserves a 4/10.

[@spazoq]

If you want the original story play the game. Problem solved. You are welcome. (I loved the TV series, they did a great job)

[@SmeddyTooBestChannel]

from what i've heard, the Halo show being "based on Halo 1" is nothing short of false

[@Milesofgaming]

I think they flat out said they didn't look at the games or anything, and that's very obvious. Paramount said it wouldn't be canon, hence the "silver" team, being part of the silver timeline

[@chattaboxxx2332]

in all fairness, despite the controversy the halo show is actually doing really well in terms of viewership. in fact i think so many people complaining has actually helped draw in a bigger crowd... ironic huh?

[@bananawingz8624]

@@chattaboxxx2332 dude stop copy and pasting your reply to every halo comment lol

[@elck3]

@@chattaboxxx2332 dude stop

[@NomaDI0I]

It's an utter garbage of a show.

[@jesterlampoon-t1j]

Y'all should do "Sound Designers React!" Like: How they made the T-Rex or Godzilla roar; How they make body sounds for creatures that don't even exist; Even the subtle ways they have to add basic clothing, movement, and walking sounds into animated films. You know those punching sounds in old action movies? WHAT IS THAT?

[@carterlavering2553]

Agreed! I'd love to see more sound design content!!

[@DECODEDVFX]

The T-rex's roar was a slowed down baby elephant trumpet, mixed with a tiger's snarl and the noise of an alligator.

[@Jigsaw407]

For me Wren's animation was quite unsatisfying to be honest. It would have been satisfying if the blade had been super sharp and cut through the cloth perfectly. Unfortunately it wasn't sharp and ripped the cloth more than it cut it. :(

[@Jathorian]

the cloth also continues to split apart for a bit after the blade is pulled out, that ruined it for me.

[@thejomah]

I 100% agree

[@BHolyCow]

Same I agree, the knife seems dull, the fact that it's more so dragging the cloth along at the bottom of the blade edge, rather than just a clean smooth cut.

[@radiofloyd2359]

I kinda really liked it, it felt like a stop motion

[@Theepicgamerkid]

I kind of liked the not quite clean cut (not the first one), but yeah, if it was a perfectly clean cut, I would have liked it more.

[@MrSpannners]

Love Wren, but let's be honest, Jordan won here. His was the most satisfying and Fenner's was the coolest.

[@SytanOfficial]

hard agree

[@Goku-cr2bi]

@@SytanOfficial Knife animations to me are only satisfying if the knife is really sharp and cuts through things like butter. His knife was the dullest knife lol

[@jakehix8132]

@@Goku-cr2bi looking at it more like a cloth anim made it more satisfying, but I liked his puzzle one from before more.

[@Herlgar]

You can tell Jordan won just by the way everyone is dead silent during his animation, just mesmerized

[@drewmanzara5731]

If you look at the replay/watch time chart Fenner absolutely obliterated the competition

[@mdoerkse]

The last two were the best. The last one fits the usual satisfying render style the best, but the skateboarding one was unique and the best artistically.

[@aksharaghav9657]

"They repair that back at the ship. It's fine."🤣🤣

[@senshi_dev_art]

The entire video was satisfying, too bad Paramount Halo had to invade the studio, God I hope they didn't hold any of you hostage XD

[@Emil_96]

I could TOTALLY see the second half of Fenner's Render becoming the official intro for the Corridor Channel 🔥

[@RyanConnell5150]

Wren's by far was the least satisfying. The knife didn't finish cutting the cloth before looping. The basketball one was the best.

[@24cptjohnson]

The knife does not even cut with the sharp side

[@alexanderjohansson2671]

I'd rank the ball last due to one of the balls almost not getting in. Left me frustrated, rather than satisfied.

[@SytanOfficial]

100% agreed. I liked nothing about the cloth one

[@stealthyfang3660]

@@24cptjohnson lol you’re right

[@sagesmith8443]

In my eyes, the basketball render won. Although everyone did way better than I ever could, that's insane dedication.

[@terencedigan3932]

Do a “dumbest render” challenge, where you compete to make the highest quality render that makes you feel like you’re becoming dumber when you watch it.

[@theCreativeSav]

Just go watch cocomelon

[@AngryApple]

When the sponsor section for the new Halo Show is more exciting than the show itself 😂

[@hztrg]

This is worth more than the whole Halo season.

[@tweeters211]

THE KNIFE?! Cmooooon. We all know that basketball court was nearly perfect. Basketball for the win!

[@alexander0the0gray]

The crew all confused “satisfying” with “awesome” because that cloth cut was NOT satisfying. It was just simply a great new tool all the VFX guys want to play with.

[@andrewparker318]

Bro what you talking about, I got some serious tingles from that render. The sound, the movement, it all just worked

[@kaydenspressurewashing]

Thank you! Totally not satisfying

[@wibblewobbler9104]

Agreed, the whole ethos of the satisfying aspect as highlighted in the first of these videos they did was that it had soothing calming satisfying feel to it. This was just technically brilliant, but didn't fit the brief.

[@DevinDTV]

was highly unsatisfying because the fabric was folded so much, the knife "felt" dull, like it was just dragging the cloth down. it wasn't cutting through it like a razor, which would have been satisfying.

[@judewaide8328]

No idea what you're all talking about. The sound of the knife ripping through the cloth was just mhmmmmm

[@DavyBrando]

The knife one was terribly unsatisfying.

[@ryanlansford4129]

When they both jumped at the same time on the liquid logo one, perfect!

[@Hazlius]

I’m very glad to see the Halo show sponsored you because hopefully it means they’ll run out of money more quickly and it won’t get a second season

[@WhatsMikeUpTo]

Hahaha. Truth

[@TapTapClick]

This is my least favorite sponsorship ad ever. The writing for that show was garbage. Cgi could have used some more work in some spots. Everything else I feel was well done (sets/costumes)

[@mlenz2553]

The most satisfying render, sponsored by the least satisfying show!

[@117chris9]

A M

[@skyrose6816]

when i heard Master Chief cucked Cortana with a prisoner of war, i gave up entirely of that series (side note apparently having sex with a poisoner of war is considered rape, as prisoners cannot fully consent as there captives are in control of there lives)

[@wyattwilliams9087]

Wow. I genuinely found Wren's UNSATISFYING. The way the knife struggles to puncture the fabric, they way the fabric rips all jagged. Didn't feel nice at all

[@pathologicaldoubt]

Wren is always so confident about everything and this render just speaks to why he shouldn’t speak so authoritatively. The idea might’ve been satisfying but his execution certainly wasn’t

[@PhoutianPhill]

You guys had Master Chief in his helmet for more screen time than the whole show so far. Paramount failed.

[@OpenMind3000]

I must say that I liked the skateboard one the most

[@alexwardlow178]

Your Halo add segment was better than the show itself. To bad that paramount had to add what they thought was "heart-wrenching" story, but really it is just heart-wrenching to see them ruin a fan favorite universe.

[@nicklewis876]

Live action halo films/shows are just cursed

[@alexwardlow178]

@@nicklewis876 Forward Unto Dawn was not bad actually. If Paramount did a whole season like that, then it would have been entertaining

[@chattaboxxx2332]

in all fairness, despite the controversy the halo show is actually doing really well in terms of viewership. in fact i think so many people complaining has actually helped draw in a bigger crowd... ironic huh?

[@alexwardlow178]

@@chattaboxxx2332 it is ironic. And I watched it all so I'm part of the problem. But I watched it all simply in hopes it got better and it didn't. I watched it all because I love halo, but this show turned out not to be halo. I sincerely hope they get better writers for the next season, or look at the halo books for story points. The books are way better than the standard sci-fi drama story they tried to make.

[@steveogrills6646]

@@chattaboxxx2332 are you just going through all the comments to just copy&paste that reply.

[@zero3633]

When confronted with the final decision I half expected it all to be a setup for Niko to go “mine” and turn the tables with his own satisfying render

[@LukaSauperl]

Why wasn't Wren's knife doing a nice smooth perfect cut? Why did it rip so much :/ Maybe do a most confusing render challenge? :D

[@gest_hiddenlook]

Wonna say thank you guys! Just found you on KZbin week ago and can't stop watching. I'm professionally not in filmmaking or any visuals, but you really inspire me to do my own things and getting better. Also I just love your way of living, interacting, working. And of course your art. Love you guys!

[@srirajvysyaraju1995]

The renders got waaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyy more satisfying than the ones from first challenge. These guys got REAL good. I am at a point where I can't pick the most satisfying. Everyone did great!

[@Enerjy]

Same dude same

[@The-Middleman]

But if we’re being honest, Jordan definitely should’ve won, right? 🧐

[@Enerjy]

@@The-Middleman I mean, maybe, but clint’s render creates tension that leads to a satisfying resolution. And wrens was also satisfying enough to grab him the win. So between those three, I can’t really pick

[@The-Middleman]

@@Enerjy Jordan’s render is literally perfect. It can start and loop at any point and it just works. Clint’s was kinda cool, and Wren’s was nothing special. I really feel like Niko just picked Wren so he could win for once 😂

[@tigbrown4293]

I love Clint’s render. I wish it could use it as a background for my Home Screen.

[@thehappychappy6396]

Do a challenge like the game where someone draws a head on a piece of folded paper, hides it and then passes it to the next person to draw the body and then the next person does the legs etc to make some kind of weird creature person, but obviously instead of drawing on piece of paper, it'd be digital version and wouldn't have to be a person could do anything, or maybe you each do different parts to a short film with the same storyline and character that flow, could even make the main character a model of what you come up with if you did the paper version of the game, or just do a completely new scene altogether each and see what happens 😂

[@Blemonade1]

That‘s a really cool idea

[@hemorrhoidlover9197]

Kinda like Clints render challenges?

[@retrobro_]

8:55 that was the most unsatisfying rendition of the halo theme

[@COCSensai]

Dad - i Got basket ball For u, Kid Kid-17:31

[@reaper2604]

You know, Paramount says that the halo show has a heart-wrenching “story” But if a HALO TV SHOW is just “story” then it’s not qualified to be a Halo tv show.

[@shazarakk]

It's heart-wrenching how badly they massacred the lore and story of the games.

[@reaper2604]

@@shazarakk I haven’t even really played them and even I can tell they screwed up.

[@pathologicaldoubt]

Clint’s was the only one that actually was satisfying

[@Cosmitzian]

Clint nailed the feeling of it, the pacing, expectation and fulfillment of the expectation, with just a bit of subversion/fear that it /wouldn't/ happen, so that when it DID happen, it was extra gratifying. Jordan's was technically and executively exquisite. Wren's had more work to do to fully translate what it was trying to do. It was technically impressive but more the tech than the implementation. Fenner's would'ave been really good, i liked the concept, but the execution just didn't really work for me. Audio was neat but yeah. Plus it seemed like one of those logo transforms that we see everywhere.

[@nicholasbachelder3563]

Totally the basketball loop felt the best. Knowing the physics/specie effecties could I guess technically make wrens the winner… but the feel and motion+sound of that “snap”, and no obv start over of the loop made the basketball loop the winner for sure! (So sorry I’m drawing a blank on your name now and don’t want to rewind and listen for your name again, but I see you, def the up and comer over there the last few months, mr stained glassman)

[@creativespace8637]

They should do a Meme render challenge, where they must take their favorite meme and interpret it into 3D