COURTROOM INSIDER | Emotional testimony, a secret call, what Chad said and more

[@TeaSpiracy]

Can we all just take a moment to appreciate Nate and his humble kindness and hard work? This case has been tough, and Nate has truly been a light in the dark.

[@darcy2965]

Definitely. He's my favorite. And I always think "now here's a really nice & special guy"

[@juvi6787]

100 % agreed! Thank You so much, Nate Eaton! Excellent work!!

[@doreendaykin6693]

Amen🙏💙

[@strawberryjam119]

Absolutely, I couldn’t have said it better, Nate, is putting his heart and soul into this case and everything he does and I have nothing but respect for him! God bless, Nate, we love him! ❤

[@deb6415]

Thank you, Nate! I look forward to your updates! Bless you!

[@Soffity]

Pity Chad didn’t have visions about being in Jail. Might have given him pause when planning murders.

[@pattih7]

My favorite moment, as well! I could have hugged her for that!

[@beachfly8066]

His visions were as reliable as his own worth

[@Noellevrr]

Hahaha! Yes!

[@alisonsonderfan7576]

I literally laughed out loud, excellent

[@TheTruth-kh2im]

Exactly 💯

[@hilary729]

The most damaging evidence was given by Jason when he said that Chad said ‘ My children are good at keeping secrets ‘. To me this statement has proved that the children’s evidence will have no credence.

[@GymMomof3]

Absolutely!! 💯

[@PatDe-zj4et]

Alex was in their house that Night. Chad let him in.

[@PatDe-zj4et]

Alex is key to it all. If Alex had died the night before shooting Charles...then they would all still be Alive. Just think about that

[@PatDe-zj4et]

Alex was the Killer but Chad and Lori directed his actions.

[@PatDe-zj4et]

This is the Craziest story ever. It will be made into a Movie.

[@tracyhopson2180]

I was so happy when Samantha came back so fast and said the exact date of that phone call. My heart broke for her today. 💐

[@johannawigg6921]

She did her sister proud !! I teared up when she was saying they used to make stories about how they'll be old ladies living next door to each other 😢

[@SerenDipity64711]

@@johannawigg6921 me too..

[@ValeskaTruax]

Very strong witness

[@SKinSKorea]

Tammy’s family is amazing. They have risen above their shock and grief. I hope Tammy’s children come around and reconcile with their mother’s family. That to me is the saddest part (well, not counting everyone who was murdered).

[@Happy-du5ex]

❤

[@irishmclass2042]

Jason Gwilliam is a Hero! He was excellent on the recorded call, playing along with Chad and Lori! Samantha is a Hero and is Tammy’s GREATEST Advocate!! I am sad for Samantha and Jason for their huge loss of Tammy. May Tammy rest in peace, and may justice be served. The Gates of Hell will not prevail! Bravo, Lindsey Blake!!!

[@Noellevrr]

Agreed!

[@SleutherStrode]

I heard the channel True Crime Squad criticising him and I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. They are ex Mormons who are very anti Mormon now but even so I thought it was judgemental.

[@SerenDipity64711]

well said👏

[@TheScratchingKiwi]

He is not a hero. He is a good witness who believes he owns his family because of religious beliefs of 'stewardship'. It is no wonder his wife is tough, she is property just as Tammy was. Every time that man said "My wife" using that tone of voice, he meant it literally and my skin crawled. You can tell he thinks a lot of himself. No wonder he and Chad got on so well!

[@jackselle4607]

@@TheScratchingKiwithis is a very judgemental comment, it’s common for a husband to want to protect his family, I think you misinterpreted his testimony.

[@SageWhite-Rose]

Chud absolutely HATES any woman who can think for herself. He tried to keep his brother from marrying Heather too. What a GREAT day on court.

[@kimbomarsh4931]

😂 Chud

[@LadyScaper]

Best comment.

[@mistersaintjohn]

Chad saying to Jason “my kids are good at keeping secrets” kind of discredits the Daybell kids’ testimonies before they even take the stand for the defense. That was the most profoundly effective statement, in relation to the case, that I took from today’s testimony.

[@Juke582]

Yes! Told is all those kids will be liars in this trial or not tell any facts! Disgusting they had a narcissist father but accept it and don’t question it! I rebelled against my narcissist father bigtime! Everything he said was OFF normal logical thinking! I couldn’t stand him! 😡

[@kathik]

I bet the jury will keep that statement in mind, during deliberations.

[@kateashby3066]

And guess who is about to testify! The prosecution didn’t put Jason on the stand right before them for nothin’!! 😄

[@ChristineKramer66]

Samantha, if you read this, I want you to know your testimony brought tears to my eyes today and you did your sister proud. You gave her a voice. I have no doubt she is so grateful and honored and proud of your testimony today. I am so sorry for your loss. I only have one sister who lives 600 miles from me and I am ashamed to say we don’t keep in continual touch. But your testimony today inspired me to make a greater effort to be in more constant touch with my sister instead of once or twice a month. I pray for you and your family and I pray that justice will be served upon this disgusting man who robbed you all.

[@CatskillsGrrl]

Right on. Couldn’t say it better.

[@JulieMatthews-b8y]

@@CatskillsGrrlAgree, you certainly hit the nail on the head 👏👏👏👏

[@onemoreyeartoretirement]

The most interesting part of the trial today for me was learning that the wedding was planned so far in advance. Tammy had to be killed and buried so quickly so that the wedding could go forward as planned.

[@jessicabalam4344]

I was impressed by how well Stephanie knew everything about Tami. When Prior was grilling her on cross she was just firing off answers. Prior had no clap back. I loved it.

[@madsdee7803]

@@jessicabalam4344 they were a very close and loving family. He thought he got away with isolating her by having her move there. They'd believe whatever rubbish he told them...he was wrong.

[@madsdee7803]

He had Tammy go to visit her family for that day because he knew that would be her last time with her family. He's a sneaky b word.

[@Luluisraging.86]

@@madsdee7803go ahead! Say that B word! We are ALL THINKING IT! 🤬

[@julietchristensen3957]

I do hope the person who officiated the wedding is tracked down to testify for this.

[@crystaldawn9255]

Chad wasn't even just bragging about his new wife he was only bragging about her physical appearance which is just sickening that that's the main point or even the only point

[@GrizzlyUrsusArctos]

That’s what I thought too. Her physical appearance was most important to him. So banal.

[@carolerichard5250]

Thinking with his STORM! Only reason all these sweet good people are gone!!! 😡😡😡😡

[@madsdee7803]

Her physical appearance was all she had going for her too. She used it her whole life to get away with things obviously. even her own mother just talks about how beautiful she is.

[@madsdee7803]

Little blonde damsel in distress who needed rescuing from every man she was with (they were all abusers when she left and Charles was (projection) "cheating". All these people felt like heroes saving her when she was a con artist.

[@judieversaul4274]

Chad was going through man-o-pause.

[@crystaldawn9255]

It's literally like Chad was giving her back to her family like I don't want her anymore here you take her

[@loveforeignaccents]

Yep. Disgusting.

[@Trish.Norman]

He had no problem taking her life insurance money.

[@lxartworks9456]

Something I thought was interesting is- Chad had been so open about how “Utah would be destroyed” so they all needed to leave. Then he brought his wife’s body back there to be buried.

[@yatibailey2580]

He is so so misguided..to no remorse nor shame nor guilt nor accountability.. washing his hands 🙌 off Tammy as if she is of no value to him in his life.. yet he produced 5 kids.. who are manipulated n coerced to his life choices n decisions. So emotionally abused n knows nothing better unless someone else heals them n shows them the moral of right n wrong in life.. so so so sad ..

[@beachfly8066]

Did I hear it correctly? Chad did not have his name on gravestone?

[@victoriousgavi7736]

I’m starting to think the Daybell children knew what was going on.

[@Kirra2122]

Should be interesting when they take the stand

[@BobbiGail]

I think they are in hook line and sinker about the light and dark scale. It doesnt seem like Slug HID that from anyone. Plus he groomed everyone to believe that Tammy would die young. If she wasn't deep in her religion, I wonder if Tammy would have split w Slug (the normal, legal, ethical way).

[@mariajara8165]

Of course, they knew, and I think they were involved in the crimes

[@irishmclass2042]

They will perjure themselves for their disgusting father! Apples don’t fall far from the tree.

[@moniqueratelle-babin2155]

Especially Garth and the daughter that lived accross street from her dad.

[@dawndesrosiers3850]

Erica, you are an awesome wife and mother holding it all together while Nate is away doing his job!!! Nate is so talented explaining everything to those of us who emotionally can not handle watching the actual trial. Thank you both!!!

[@pamcollins1651]

I completely agree with you!💯 Both Nate and Erica are a beautiful couple who you could sit and watch/listen to for hours! I sympathise with Erica having to be both mum & dad while Nate covers the horrific crimes of “Chump and Liar” as my husband travelled a lot while we were raising our three boys! But I hope they know how grateful we all are! I live in Australia and have watched this story evolve from the beginning! It still boggles my mind the depravity two (or actually 3) people can scoop too!

[@9eyeswideopen]

I’m so grateful to the ones that have stood up to support Tammy, so her voice can be heard that she was not the lazy person that Chad tries to make her out to be.

[@juliewick]

“It’s separate from the Tammy situation…” !!!!! Holy omgggggg that was SUCH a revealing statement made by Chad! He outed himself and reveled that the “Tammy situation” is 100% related!!! Wow. Im shook. And the whole just tell the police to call us…they have NEVER once called us. WHAT?!?!

[@DVD927]

Yes, “the Tammy situation”…ugh

[@marcijewell2195]

Chad is not human, no emotions, no reaction, no sympathy or empty . Chad is the real DEMON ZOMBIE with a black soul . Ditto Lori and Alex. RIP Tammy, Tylie and JJ

[@loislane856]

If anyone is dark in this flop house of cult members it’s def Chadley. Lori is just a narcissist manipulator. She uses her body to make money.

[@janelsara6404]

He is demon possessed!

[@thatonegirl4676]

Don't forget the RIP for Joe Ryan and Charles Vallow.

[@raydunn8262]

That's how serial killers act.

[@doreendaykin6693]

Amen…!

[@ShellyDaviss]

Erica you are so good about letting Nate be gone so much. What a special person you are to be so sweet about. Hope the rest of the time goes by quickly for you and that your kids will be on their best behavior to make it as easy as possible on you!

[@Luluisraging.86]

Ditto to that! Thank you Erica. (Um Nate, don’t you mean TAMMY ran the publishing company, while Chad sat on his LAZY BUM and wrote his BAD NOVELS?!)

[@acemarie3613]

MUCH RESPECT MUCH LOVE ERICA. ONE STRONG 💪 WOMAN!!❤

[@nancyhammond389]

​@@Luluisraging.86EXACTLY

[@beachfly8066]

Yes, Erica as beautiful as Nate and their children. Their team effort in providing us all the fabulous insights and coverage is greatly appreciated 🌻💛🌻 love from Australia

[@Noellevrr]

This! Happy Mother’s Day, Erica 🩷

[@MimiDidi121]

I’ll never understand how a dead body fell off of bed and that didn’t raise mini red flags! Someone who’s been dead for four hours doesn’t roll off the bed. Tugging on a sheet will not roll them off the bed. SMH.

[@linzlulubell]

Especially when her blood had already pooled on her back showing she was laying flat for some time after she died.

[@sharontolbert1112]

Exactly!!!

[@deadmanswife3625]

Maybe Alex who lori says can't do anything right dropped her. Chad's story and timeline means nothing so I suppose it's possible Alex did drop her in his haste

[@722dabba]

How could people believe this for a second. Its astounding to me that professionals did not automatically treat this as a potential crime scene.

[@jasmin0930]

And the coroner not performing an autopsy is something I will never understand. She was young, in good health and it’s a sudden and unexpected death at home. Have they not seen Dateline!!!

[@anilasharma2371]

Chad was bragging about Lori's physical fitness, blonde and all that , it makes anyone's stomach churn.

[@SerenDipity64711]

Hideous.What a slap in the face for Jason who must have been utterly disgusted.

[@susannacafarelli8336]

Tammy was the one training for a marathon. Dollars to donuts she was in better shape than Lori.

[@Fullmoonfever]

Lori isn’t a blonde any more 😉

[@Karen.cook424]

Chad definitely wasn’t being lead by any “religious callings”….we know what he was being lead by - his male appendage!

[@sueannnatter5295]

She was all looks and no substance...now she is neither one

[@sharondrury5676]

My favorite part was, Samantha’s comment, “It was December 13”. God bless that beautiful woman. Thank you, Nate and Erica. Nate, I've been praying for your mental health for the last four years, especially hard since last week.

[@Hatchification]

Chad was non responsive in the hot tub? What is Chad like when he’s non responsive??..flat lining??

[@Trish.Norman]

LOL Great observation!

[@Captainslog2024]

Ohhhhh i lolled at that so hard

[@adoral.libertucci2647]

😂😂😂💥

[@astrialindah2773]

😂😂😆😆😆

[@JY-tq8dr]

Bahahaha

[@katherinetruitt9835]

Chad is a cold blooded killer. Frightening guy. Shows little to no emotion.

[@SerenDipity64711]

and the lies slip so easily from his mouth. Lori, too.

[@kateashby3066]

That’s because he’s a psychopath. They pretty much only feel pride, anger, and excitement (and only that for a short while)

[@christieprince6991]

Samantha came across as Grieving deeply. By her testimony she honored her sister's memory.

[@robingoff322]

Watching from Kennewick, WA……I love when the judge overrules Prior’s objections! I wish he would do it more! My husband died almost 7 years ago, I still cry and I can’t even imagine kissing a different man, let alone marry somebody else! Before he died, he said, I want you to be happy and meet someone new…..even with that, I feel I can’t do it. I consider myself still married. And when Jason said that Chad told him his kids were good at keeping secrets?! Those kids should not be allowed to testify if Prior calls them, for that statement alone. And how can 3 dead people be considered as simple situation?!

[@viveller2115]

Probably told them it's OK to lie if the spirit tells you too

[@loveforeignaccents]

First of all, sorry for the loss of your husband. But frankly, Chad has the right to have a defense, which includes having his children testify.

[@Make.it.a.great.day2024]

Sorry for your loss……I gasped when I heard that statement about keeping secrets. The jury will remember that.

[@Monica-gene1]

❤❤❤

[@personofinterest8731]

Same here, my husband died 10 years ago. Chad makes me sick. Ice in his veins.

[@personofinterest8731]

Thank you Nate and Erica. We are your elderly South African 🇿🇦 fans. We are sisters who follow missing children and thats how we found this case. Justice for JJ, Tylee and Tammy and Charles! ❤ Your hard work and big heart are appreciated.

[@beachfly8066]

Samantha did an amazing job on the stand and the two years not two weeks comment was the best comment so far. Bravo Samantha 💛

[@lynhanna917]

Love to see Erica and hear her opinions. Here's a fun fact, l worked 300 km northeast of Yellowknife in tne Northwest Territories of Canada and one winter's night two of the Inuit men took me out to the farthest point to see the northern lights. It was beautiful. Then one of the men whistled and the northern lights started to dance. He said that if you whistle and the lights come down and touch the ground that it will take your soul into the sky! So he said you never whistle long or hard. Enjoy the sight of these beautiful lights.

[@silviamtz8961]

Wow! What an interesting and beautiful anecdote. ✨✨✨

[@Noellevrr]

Wow! I love that. Thank you for sharing

[@caseyconatser7926]

That's incredible about the northern lights thank you for sharing this. My husband was talking about something going on that's going to allow some places in America to see the northern lights. He went outside looking tonight. I was doubtful but I didn't crush his hopes.

[@caseyconatser7926]

I have gotta show him your comment. Wow 😮

[@dellie5614]

I sincerely want Mr Prior to do a good job defending Chad. The reason why?… because I don’t want any reason for Chad to get a mistrial or grounds for appeal.

[@kateashby3066]

that’s not what appeals are based on 99% of the time. Appeals review problems with the JUDGE primarily. Prior will submit a series of his objections that were overruled and argue that they should have been sustained and bc the ruling was unjust, it changed the course of the trial and made it unfair to his client. They will also look at evidence that was allowed in that should not be, per the rules of evidence. This is how Harvey Weinstein just won his appeal. The only way he could claim insufficient counsel is if his lawyer like completely forgot the law and made critical and obvious LEGAL (not strategic) mistakes that cost him his trial, and personally I’ve never seen that happen. Even with terrible lawyers, it’s not a thing unless the lawyer is beyond bad- they must be incapable of practicing law. Not just a poopy lawyer.

[@dellie5614]

@@kateashby3066 thank you for the insight! I appreciate it!

[@InfiniteStars107]

The FBI agent needs an immediate raise! Can you imagine having to read that poorly written Morporn aloud?!? She was cool & professional throughout, *and* has to come back on Monday. She's a total BOSS! Also, I predict Chad/Prior lost the case today with the in-laws testimony. Bye Chudslug, I hope you DON'T get the death penalty. Let it live 50 more years-- alone, forgotten, afraid.

[@miltdta]

Morporn 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@kateashby3066]

Jason did a great job in that recorded call- didn’t give himself away at ALL, unlike MG who was super obvious about it and even got called out for recording the call.

[@rsr4099]

As always, thanks Nate. I just can't make myself watch this trial so these updates nightly are so appreciated.

[@kateashby3066]

I think the worst is over. All the main law enforcement have testified with the bad details already and this epics have already been discussed. Now we seem to be onto misc witnesses.

[@LA-gg7mg]

So fun to have you and Erica together tonight - it was so fun! And, I loved that Erica wants to make you that ring tone - hilarious! I hope she does it. And, then your daughter's nickname for you on your phone - SO cute! Thanks for sharing yourselves and all you do. You are appreciated!!

[@savannahthomas9841]

Chad described Lori’s physically from head to toe but failed to describe her brain and heart.

[@kateashby3066]

Lori’s best qualities: hot body, great hair, and she pumps up chads ego- everything Chad has ever wanted in a woman!

[@nickinurse6433]

Chad was moving right next to his brother because he planned to steal his property. He was jealous of his beautiful house and property. He was planning to somehow get his hands on it. Not sure if his brother and his wife were going on the dark list or what the exact plan was but his walk and his brother's backyard with his other girlfriend clearly pointed to some future plan that involved his brother's land

[@stephanieallangarman5598]

Absolutely 👍🏼

[@Trish.Norman]

I don’t believe he was going to steal it but he was definitely looking for people to bankroll his stupid vision and tent city.

[@ChaCha-lt8rx]

Tent City ?

[@Juke582]

I don’t think so? His brother was very different than him and his wife hated Chad too! Chad moving there to invade them was pretty nasty though and shows Chad was always the wicked narcissist devil! He intentionally upset the cart everywhere and had the nerve to call others evil when he is a murderer! 🤦‍♀️

[@kateashby3066]

Narcissists are entitled to things they didn’t earn. They’re also delusional and assume they will get them.

[@robingoff322]

Sadly this story has made it world wide…..Justice for Tylee, JJ, Tammy, and Charles. Thoughts and prayers for all who need them.

[@indialukeluke690]

Don't forget joseph Ryan....I truly believe he was the beginning of this lori & alex journey.

[@sandraconnor4019]

Samantha was fuming their was no stopping her ,she was a warrior for her sister's death❤

[@Juke582]

Yes! Proud of her showing evil Chad he wasn’t getting away with what he did to Tammy!!

[@judysibley1066]

I can’t believe the way Chad and Lori were speaking as if it’s quite normal for the kids to be missing and it was nothing for anyone to be concerned about. Were they thinking people would just forget and move on?

[@Juke582]

So totally delusional and their laughing about it all was really mental too!

[@kathik]

They were invincible......so they thought 🤯

[@kateashby3066]

Yes! Because they’re both narcs and Lori also has. A delulu disorder so they def thought that.

[@SageWhite-Rose]

The words " DECEMBER 13TH!!!" will stay with me for a while.

[@helenjohnson7583]

Erica lends an extra air of professionalism to this. Nice way to finish up for the week! Thanks!

[@suzannewhite3552]

Omg, changing Nate's ringtone to "Loin fire" made me laugh so hard. 😆😆 Shes awesome.

[@ruthmichigander]

😂😂Erica🤣🤣

[@IridescentJen]

LOVE Erica co-hosting! You two are a great team and we want more Erica! Mahalo from Maui.

[@SerenDipity64711]

..the way Jason played along with Chad on the phone call was very insightful. He must have been squirming inside hearing Chad and Lori laughing and giggling, like the missing children, was no big deal🤮

[@ann-marieblaney2552]

Watching from Southern California. Nate, thank you for your hard work and being gone so much from your family. I have been married almost 39 years (2 children) and my husband has done that most of our married life. When he was living in Twin Falls ID for 7 months, he was only able to come home every other weekend. Erica, it doesn’t get easier but is a marriage strengthening period. I’m here for you 😊

[@april6214]

Nate, I have been watching EIN’s daily uploads of the testimonies and your nightly talks. From the Texas Panhandle, I appreciate all that you, your wife, and team do to bring us the most up-to-date and in-depth analysis!

[@Twinkle_Toes88]

Thanks from Colorado ❤

[@vernareed2692]

@april I used to live in Pampa and Amarillo! Still have family living out there!

[@Elisa-tru1nu1]

@twinklet_toes88 first off I love that name. I call my hubby that. Also watching here from Colorado. In Denver. Hey Nate and Erica. I love you too. She is so beautiful you're a lucky man Nate dawg! ❤

[@Jag...]

The way Nate and Erica looks at each other 🥰 I really can feel the love between them. It exudes from them. It's beautiful to see ✨❤️

[@soraidasallette8499]

I love that the jurors are going to be thinking about the reading of his book all weekend ! Wow what an ending!

[@thatonegirl4676]

Tammy's family should sue the coroner for signing off on the no autopsy... She was a 49 year old woman with no health issues.

[@NurseSue425]

I cannot figure out why they don’t have an md do the coroner job. That’s crazy

[@mcrabtree4488]

The family didn't want one

[@nikki7962]

@@NurseSue425state of Idaho laws. Sad to say

[@Lynnard208]

In fairness, Idaho does not require a coroner to have any sort of medical background whatsoever. It’s an elected position. That poor woman has said this case will forever remain her greatest mistake. She was so new and so uneducated. Poor woman did her best with what limited knowledge she has.

[@jasmin0930]

Idaho needs to change that law. If this isn’t an excellent argument for that case I don’t know what is. Poor Tammy she needs Justice ⚖️ RIP Tammy 🕊️

[@lindanasca8301]

Please remember Charles too!😢

[@Alexis84DE]

Nate does sometimes reference him, but Charles is not part of this trial. Chad is not accused of any connection with his death so he really shouldn’t be mentioned in this context.

[@glennpearce7093]

Hello Linda yes I have not forgotten Charles ,I remember seeing the police cam of him telling the police about his worries for me it’s so sad that he was I believe brutally killed by Alex lorry and daybell.much respect for your comment Glenn from New Zealand 🇳🇿

[@CatskillsGrrl]

We will all be focusing on Charles when his trial comes in Arizona. This trial is for JJ, Tylee and Tammy.

[@kateashby3066]

He’s not a part of this trial! Please stop acting like he’s being insensitive. LORI is going on trial for Charles, not Chud. This trial is only about Tammy and the kids.

[@GigiWright]

If only Charles multiple times of calling authorities and having Lori's metal state challenged was taken more seriously we wouldn't all be here discussing the atrocities that followed.

[@rebeccatreadwell546]

Truly Folks, Nate and East Idaho News Deserve a Journalism Award, GBY Bro ❤

[@helenussery4756]

Erica you are a great co-host with Nate and I love it when you come on.

[@helenstockman3499]

Does anyone remember Chads text that he wanted to develop his abs, grow out his hair, and get a full body tan. That really gives an insight into how Chad saw himself and his future. Ugghhgg!

[@kathik]

LIKE THAT WOULD HAVE HELPED HIM 😳 😂

[@stacitowery4461]

Good Lord, literally polishing a pig's ass, or putting lipstick on a pig😂

[@snowwhite2524]

He saw himself the way that Lori demanded that he be. Tammy loved Chad for who he was and his obesity and buzz cut didn't matter. Lori lusted for who she wanted Chad to become. Chad and Lori are both evil monsters and they deserved each other.

[@JulieMatthews-b8y]

I don’t remember any testimony regarding this text by Chad.

[@Melsgottagreenthumb]

Nate, I love that your wife Erica comes on and expresses her support in your work and contributes to the conversation. What a sweetheart. Isn’t it wild how one “story” has changed your life. Best wishes to you all.

[@kacie1567]

I saw a vision today that Chad is a level 5 demon… oh wait… I’ve watched that during this entire trial.

[@glennpearce7093]

Shit I thought he was aye 4.2 haha 😂

[@JOJo-ci3uw]

7 dark 😂 he's basically a zombie sitting in court cuz that lazy coward is dead...

[@Piper.0317]

Happy Mother's Day Erica!!! You deserve so much for giving up Nate's help to you during these long trials! I hope you have a wonderful day celebrating.

[@jillpierce3008]

Love when Erica joins in & shares her thoughts. Hope you have a wonderful weekend celebrating Mother's Day together!!!

[@ginamcgrew9955]

It was so fun having Erica chime in! She's such a a beauty and it's fun watching you two interact and getting her take on the facts that we learn! Thank you both for your teamwork that brings the news to us🙂

[@EmAyTea6]

Anyone else hear the disdain in Tammy's sisters voice?

[@ChaCha-lt8rx]

Yes,I thought at one point she was going to speak directly to Chad and give him a piece of her mind.

[@KayLou209]

Thank you for describing Samantha leaving the stand. Samantha did awesome!

[@cynthiabowen7092]

Way to go Samantha! Totally spot on, so proud of you strong woman that you are! Strong research, strong testimony.

[@RobbieJayOne]

I still have difficulty with Idaho’s coroner setup. I live in Utah, my brother died when he was 36 in 1980. We weren't asked if the family wanted an autopsy and we didn't expect to be asked. You're informed it's the law: unless someone is elderly, or the person had a verified terminal illnes the decedent is going to have an autopsy.

[@SassyCathy1968]

Does he really believe the jury is going to believe in his innocence? Samantha & Jason did a great job on the stand.

[@kateashby3066]

Narcissists are very delusional. So maybe. Does prior think that? No way. His main job now is to keep Chud off of death row. Life in prison is the goal.

[@patriciafoster3347]

Chads expression never changes. Ever.

[@kateashby3066]

He smiled and nodded when his brother came into court. But yeah that’s about it.

[@squeakywright8743]

Thank you so much for providing all of this information to the public. It matters.

[@lorrainelaneres-zh1ut]

I’m a gubbed nightshift nurse from Glasgow Scotland and if I do manage to get a a break I’m playing catch up with Nate every time 🙌❤️🙌and it’s a treat when Erica pops on🙏🙏🙏you two are so cute together ❤ can I say Erica you have such beautiful eyes😍 do you have Irish ancestry in your family? You have Irish eyes😍 as for Samantha and Jason 🙌❤️🙌such powerful testimony from both of them! They did Tammy proud and I’m thinking they sealed the deal for DP for Chubbychad no neck Dumbdaybell 🙏 Nate have the best quality time with beautiful Erica and your adorable kids🩷your family have become a part of so many families around the world family ❤ love love love you guys so very much! Thank you for all your sacrifices to ensure we are always updated on this horrific case🙏🙏🙏

[@donnaduncan3781]

I wanted to express to you how much your videos mean to me. A year ago I was sitting in my dad's living room as we were waiting for him to pass away. The ONE thing that gave me focus was the fact that I knew after all the chaos of the day with family & friends coming in & out all day, I would be able to lay down at the foot of my daddy's bed & listen to your calming voice. It has been said several times before how crazy it is to listen to murder documentaries or stories to find peace but it is true. Especially if you find someone with a calming voice like you. Someone who is detailed like you. And especially someone who is dedicated like you are to spend all this time away from your wife & kids just to report the information that people like me rely on just to hear your voice & to hear the story. So just know that you do make a difference. You are loved by so many. You are very good at what you do. And the most important to me is you do give me peace even in the hardest times of my life. Last year as I spent the last moments with my daddy & a year later as I remember those memories. You are a part of them. Thank you Nate Easton & East Idaho News for ALL the hard work & dedication y'all put into everything that y'all do. Donna Duncan New Boston, Texas

[@shannonkimmet967]

he uped her insurance. then when she passed he remarried in two weeks. Lied about her having kids. Then they find the kids bodies on his property. Honestly his ass is guilty. Even if he did not kill them. He knew they were not alive. How did they think they would get away with this.

[@Juke582]

Narcissists fantasize about everything and don’t deal with any reality they are so screwed up in the head! They just live in denial all their life!

[@Adriansmommyyy]

In my opinion they could have if it was just Tammy and Tylee. Tylee was 17 almost 18 while it is sad and heartbreaking no one noticed she was gone. They could’ve said she ran away, choosing to be free and and against the religion, many other things and maybe even get away with it for a few years before they got caught but what really set it off was JJ missing and having active grandparents in his life. That was their BIGGEST mistake thinking they wouldn’t care even with all the calls Kay and Larry where making to her even before he was murdered.

[@kateashby3066]

They’re narcissists. Aka they’re delusional.

[@sallyethridge1393]

I'm glad you got home! Enjoy you family this weekend.

[@salemthorup9536]

It's really sweet the way you talk about and to and look at your wife. Men who are loyal, loving husbands make their wives and many other women feel safer and more secure. Good on you.

[@pattyolson3842]

Thanks Erica for stopping in to co-host and with your honest, down to earth responses. I hope the sick children are feeling better by now and Nate gets to drive for the Saturday soccer game. And I hope you have a great Mother's day Erica! 💐

[@sadieluck]

Nate, you and Erica give me so much confidence in the future. Chad and Lori bring me down but you guys are the light that brightens us up. Have a great weekend!

[@jazzquebec2847]

Yeah you're right.

[@patriciaoconnell488]

You have the best summary of the trial i have seen. Thank You much. Have a good weekend..

[@rebcol4926]

The initial coroner fell down on the job.

[@SleutherStrode]

She did she was so inexperienced too but I fault the coroner system in Idaho even more. These Elected Coroners just don’t have the knowledge. Experience or budgets to investigate unattended deaths properly. It seems like they were suspicious but still didn’t insist on a postmortem.

[@alisonsonderfan7576]

Lack of experience

[@sheilabrown780]

Lack of medical or criminal education. It's ridiculous for that position not to be filled by a physician.

[@CatskillsGrrl]

Any community served by an elected coroner is at a disadvantage, if you ask me.

[@kathik]

I feel a coroner is way too important to held by any Tom Dick or Harry off the street. No real true credentials needed to be elected. This doesn't feel right. 😤

[@nickinurse6433]

The heart and lungs are a connected system. When one is damaged the other is damaged. If you have a bad heart the fluid will back up in your lungs. Conversely if you are unable to breathe the heart continues to pump blood to the lungs expecting that air will be there to oxygenate the blood. With the heart pumping strong but no air being delivered a serous fluid will leak into the lungs. RIP Tammy. It was so moving to hear her sister speak of her. It seems like her sister is the only one who misses her. God forgive her children for being perfectly fine with her death because daddy said it was meant to be.

[@loveforeignaccents]

Obviously her dad and her other siblings miss her and her coworkers and other friends and family. I'm sure her children do, too; they're just brainwashed by their father like the other women who surrounded him were: Lori, Melanie P., Melanie Gibb, Zulema.

[@nightwithout-stars1951]

So many family members cooperated with police to bring these demons to justice. Lori’s brother Adam has an audio on here where he tells police that his own brother and sister murdered Charles. Gwilliam recorded a call with Chad for the police, and so did Ian. Bravo to all those who tried to help!

[@kateashby3066]

Lori’s family are all sick people and seeking fame and money on the backs of dead kids. Her sister is likely the only semi decent one. And she is pretty quiet. Remember- narcissists crave attention. Lori and Alex weren’t sociopaths out if the blue- that’s developed in childhood as the result of serious abuse. And abuse runs in families because hurt people- hurt people

[@mamaindy61]

Thank you for all your hard work Nate.

[@susannacafarelli8336]

This trial has revealed not only that Chad was the master manipulator and that Lori came second to him but also that he’s been manipulating his whole life. He thinks he’s going to manipulate the jury.

[@gomphrena-beautifulflower-8043]

Thanks Nate and Erica from Tennessee!

[@jenniferrueger1694]

Thanks Nate from Indiana!

[@juliespencer9673]

People who have evil intentions are always targeting those who truly have light within they cannot stand the light at all.

[@madsdee7803]

​​I love your humour bouncing off each other. Stay well guys I hope your kiddies are feeling better. Love from us here in Western Australia. xx

[@loislane856]

I’m from Perth and this trial is insane 😊

[@HapticFrequencies]

Does anyone have a working theory on why Chad's children initially & currently will not speak with Tammy's side OR the Daybell side of the families??

[@Maisiewuppp]

Because Chad runs his family like a cult and they are very well controlled.

[@kristibi7971]

Plus grief and mindblown and confusion and trying to live a life 💔💔💔

[@kathik]

Pryor probably advised them to keep silent

[@snowwhite2524]

IMO they don't talk to their family because they want to keep their heads in the sand and live in denial that their father is a murderer. I think they are afraid to hear the evidence from their loved ones that proves that their Dad murdered their loving mother. I also agree that they are tightly controlled by their father who has forbidden them from speaking to their extended family because they are all dark and they are part of the frame job.

[@tytypartridge3135]

Because they know some things especially Emma and garth it’s beyond burying their heads in the sand. One or two perhaps can be in denial but all of them? They don’t seem the least bit grief stricken about their mother. Nor are they surprised dead bodies were falling all over the place in regard to Lori and Chad. What kind of brain washing allows you not to question your father marrying some random woman two weeks after your mother is dead? Or saying your mother is lazy at her eulogy at her funeral and not wanting his name on his grave stone? That would mean Chad was teaching them family and their mother wasn’t important from their childhood… which doesn’t align with how close chad was with Jason family up until his crazy teachings. They may be controlled but they are not surprised Emma even tried to lie about the cause of her mother death.

[@SherryIrvin-l8c]

Ty Nate for the updates. Appreciate it.

[@IAmALawyerToo]

I’m an attorney; repulsed by the evidence concerning Chad. BUT, AMEN to the defense lawyer’s daughter whose email Nate read re our legal system. Wonderful email; beautiful way to honor your father! Thanks!

[@terranwilliams89]

We love you Erica! Thank you for sharing Nate with us

[@joannadechenne6368]

Nate you have the rare and magical quality of a true and legendary reporter. You stay neutral and yet we feel your thoughts. Very much a mix of Keith Morrison and Diane Sawyer vibe. With the highest compliments. PS - Erica could be a young Brandi Carlie's sister!! beautiful.

[@Noellevrr]

I thought she resembled her too!

[@doreendaykin6693]

Gratitude for your insight, comments & commitment Nate! I look forward to them every evening. What stood out to me today was that Mr. Prior actually began to look tired, weary particularly after Samantha’s testimony.

[@teritanner7921]

Thank you for your summary. I listened to the whole “thing” today but your summary is so solid.

[@laurapalmer3954]

Glad you are home with your family!! Thank you!!

[@nellfensterle253]

Ma'am....you have the most wonderful way of pointing things out. Thank you for sharing your take on all the things.

[@kimzwolinski9919]

Samantha did a wonderful job. I was at home watching her testimony by myself. There were 3 times that I was cheering out loud for her. The most memorable for me was when she immediately responded with the date after Prior objected lol. Everything about her testimony today was so impactful. Thank you Nate and Erica ❤

[@TamelaZoss]

I’m in Florida also… I watch you Nate daily. Thank you for keeping on top of this trial.

[@NiAudaxNeObstes]

The only thing better than Nate reporting, is Nate and Erica reporting! Thanks for another show and excellent coverage of the highlights; these trials are truly grueling, and we're grateful for all you do to keep us informed on the highlights of each day!!

[@TaniaChristina]

If I was Chad and innocent, I would be screaming from the rooftops that I didn't hurt the children (or my wife). Thanks again for great reporting! So lovely to see you and your wife together ❤ 🇬🇧

[@kateashby3066]

Plenty of guilty people have down that too. Chris watts is the first example to pop into mind. He even offered to take a lie detector test. He isn’t very smart.

[@Mystlyn26]

Thank you from California. Have a great weekend!!

[@KellytheCoach]

I appreciate your commitment and sacrifice you make to be at the trial, and the way xtra sacrifice of doing courtroom insider. The travel, sleeping hotels, eating out and the most difficult is being away from your family. Thanks!

[@kristaconley7542]

Samantha you are incredible. Truly what bravery and complete injustice that you have had to be this part of your sisters justice. Whatever happens through going through this process I hope you know that you are simply remarkable in your devotion to your sister. Prayers, kind thoughts, and strength to you. I’m so very sorry you have had to go through this.

[@CanadianBeaver42]

The Gwilliams cemented Chad’s fate. They testified so well, I was in awe of both of them. I was slightly comforted to know that Tylee was at least buried in a place created by Tammy out of love, and not some Stephen King style pet cemetery. RIP to Joe, Charles, Tylee, JJ, and Tammy. All were victims of severe abuse and mental torture by Lori before their deaths. Much love to all from Canada 🇨🇦

[@freedomandcoffee]

"they went to Leah's house threatening her... we are not totally sure what they are trying to accomplish." Maybe they are trying to FIND MISSING KIDS??!

[@kateashby3066]

They were playing dumb. Or not (playing) 😂

[@indialukeluke690]

Thank you, nate & east idaho news

[@acemarie3613]

Before I got married. My Uncle who was like my father to me, sat me down. He told me that taking care and supporting my husband would be hard but a must to enable my husband to do his job. Erica, you are a STRONG, BEAUTIFUL WOMAN!! MUCH RESPECT!! MAY YOU AND YOURS RECEIVE MANY BLESSINGS ALWAYS. ❤🙏 🤗

[@Lollipop_Lexi]

Did he sit your husband down and tell him that he needed to support you?

[@prentfaiyaz]

​@Lollipop_Lexi right... that's weird

[@ShyFly1000]

I cannot imagine losing any of my siblings and to then find out the man my sibling loved was remarried 2 weeks later! Super sus.

[@Who-Dunnit]

49:29 ....holy shit....those kids are a different level of horrid. I could not imagine doing this during my mother's funeral luncheon. How could anyone? How could ANYONE with a heart do this?