Melanie Gibb's entire interview with Nate Eaton

[@mandystrong8196]

This interview drove me nuts. Melanie kept saying “people had to pass on. Pass away.” They were murdered! There is a big difference between passing away which is from natural causes and being murdered!

[@lisalancework7999]

To me that just shows you that Melanie probably still believes a lot of that garbage that death isnt anything -just a thought

[@shelleygold4923]

You took the words right out of my mouth

[@briardan9226]

How dumb was she that no red flags came up when realised no one in her family was a zombie, no one in others families were zombies. ONLY the ones who stood in Lori and Chad's way! No red flag when told Lori and Chad can't divorce? No question on if insurance policies effected that?

[@59Martita]

Amen!

[@bonnytaylor7558]

Spot on!

[@evanb0869]

Anyone who looks at chad and thinks “I wanna learn from this guy” has something seriously wrong with them

[@MitchellGWhitehead]

He looks like someone that might have trouble writing his own name.

[@yourinnerlawyer4035]

@@MitchellGWhitehead I know, makes it more surprising he is a decent writer so I heard. He wrote a series that made $

[@MitchellGWhitehead]

@@yourinnerlawyer4035 It really is crazy. He is obviously more disciplined in at least that than I will ever be. He had to be charismatic as well to convince more than a few people that he was a prophet.

[@MitchellGWhitehead]

@N D these people that follow him are like puppy dogs follow someone with a milk bone. I not trying to be mean but I have two australian shepherds and a blue heeler that have more problem solving skills than these people.

[@MitchellGWhitehead]

@N D do you have an Instagram account? My account is B3 Exotics. I have snakes as well

[@anastasiabeaverhausen2996]

People didn’t “pass away”, Melanie. They were murdered.

[@ariemarkell8365]

Right?!

[@cheekyrose8045]

He did "pass away" which is the act of dying. "Murder" is the manner in which he allegedly "passed away". Having worked for a medical examiner, there is a difference and BOTH are true.

[@kaybrown7541]

Correct 👍

[@mariellewills9086]

"God is on my side" I don't think so, Melanie. You quote the writings of a larger cult which are bound right into the book bindings of a holy bible: one that was "retranslated" by a cult leader to curse all black people. The binding together is sinful. The doctrines are sinful--Smith advocated plural marriage only after he got caught sleeping around with multiple women of his congregation while still married. History proved he wasn't capable of translating anything. Mormon (μωρμον) is an ancient demon of nightterrors. Moroni (מןרןנ) is a member of the youngest members of Satan's army referenced in the Bible as the "young men who pissed against the wall. Moron comes from this word and is not a slang word, but a term for a lower level of intelligence. When Moroni (tail) is on the wall, the head (Satan's general) is in the Holy of Holies. Black people ARE NOT CURSED by God. None of these liars are prophets. There are no multiple probation. Iit is appointed unto every man ONCE to die.

[@songbirdsinging1878]

i was getting really ticked about her using the term "Passed away" too. I wonder though, after thinking about it, if she doesn't want to say "murder" since they will be on trial soon and are Presumed Innocent until a jury makes their decision?? but, they were, in fact, murdered by someone!!

[@bronwyn117]

If my father remarried days after my mother’s death, I would NOT support my father in any way.

[@Luluisraging.86]

I’m afraid most if not all of Chad’s kids will support HIM 💯% ! They have the wool pulled over their eyes, and have probably been taught his screwed up ways from a young age. And WHO KNOWS WHAT CHAD WAS SAYING TO THEM IN THE HOUSE WHEN THEY WERE GATHERED TOGETHER RIGHT AFTER TAMMY DIED, when nobody else was there?! 🤷‍♀️

[@onemanstrash8233]

I lived this sort of life.. I promise you these kids are simply doing what they need to survive. Did you hear Emma (while Chad is in the cop car and they are digging up the yard) she says You raised us well.. we will be fine… WITH YOUR WALLET! That says so much. You see, I walked away, giving up much $ that could have changed my life. My brothers stayed and the golden child reaped many many benefits and the other one got the leftovers. Those leftovers had his children stay loyal to him. Money talked folks. If you have no “character” you will stay where the money is. Just my opinion.

[@Faith_Plays_Toys]

His kids have been brainwashed from a young age..

[@sheslikethewind8999]

@@onemanstrash8233I heard her loud and clear and took from her Convo that she knows what he did and prob, very likely knew more even before.

[@lauragibb6014]

Yeah I really feel for his kids. They have got to be so so troubled, especially the son who actually admitted to a coworker at the time that he found his mother dead and has now clearly lied to try to help his fathers narrative.

[@constantinoferrer7420]

This reporter deserves an Emmy for endurance and professionalism.

[@G274Me]

Definitely, listening to this bull crap story took an amazing amount of patience

[@kimmoore0427]

Nates the best

[@jimrickert1856]

I agree he's good but he should talk to her more about her lying about JJ being with her to the police. She's a brain washed idiot also , if Chad and Lori never got caught she would still be side by side with them.

[@maggiemoonpie2168]

@@jimrickert1856 she said I wondered why they did such a sloppy job leaving a trail but I realized they think the world will end. She knew Lori's husband was seeking a divorce and that he was afraid for his life and she had to know they wanted to hurry and kill him for insurance money. The kids were still missing when this aired- she doesn't watch the news yet just basically stated they did a sloppy job or poor planning like she knew they did it. People planning on an apocalypse don't take out life insurance policies worth millions of dollars.

[@veronicarubio1657]

Absolutely the best in the Biz!

[@MultiPetercool]

As the father of a 21-year-old autistic son I would love five minutes alone with Chad Daybell and a baseball bat. Children with autism are not possessed by the devil!

[@nurseprac.nikki513]

Which is why, I believe, she stopped JJ’s meds. To exacerbate any symptoms he may have suffered with. She knew exactly what she was doing to try and convince people of that poor baby being a “zombie”. Truly evil at work here.

[@shellytarbet3677]

Cant imagine the turmoil JJ went thru. Any child would have been afraid and feeling like their world had been tipped upside down. His dad dies and there are a bunch of people at a pool party.WTH? Then all the moves his dog being taken away even if it wasn't a service dog any child would be upset. Lastly his sister being gone and his mom off busy with Chad while he is left with Alex. So very sad when you then add into it that he was autistic.

[@LauraLancealot]

I'll tag team with you buddy need to catch your breath tag me in I got your six

[@necieden]

I hear you sister!! I would live to meet CHAD myself. I work with children also Bless you mother be encouraged!!!

[@cellison9414]

Yes, I'm so sad for both kids. I don't believe for a moment that Lori was ever a good guardian, mom, to these kids. No, I think these kids endured so much chaos brought on and orchestrated by this woman...these kids were not her priority.

[@ackhak]

I watched this interview when it first came out. But I decided to listen to it again because of the trial. It is making me so mad that she keeps referring to evil things as “unusual” or “different”. She refuses to say that anything Lori & Chad did was wrong. Probably because it would reflect badly on her. “Oh, I thought it was unusual that they were lying in order to go to the temple. It was unusual that they were committing adultery. It was unusual that they murdered the kids and Chad’s wife.” No, MG, it’s not “unusual” or “different”. It’s wrong. It’s bad. It’s evil. 😡

[@seasonofthewitch7249]

💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

[@jeanettecoleman-mz7ie]

If people have any sense they'll stay well clear of those female, she KNEW WHAT WAS GOING ON.

[@susanbajjada2960]

​@@jeanettecoleman-mz7ie 💯

[@carolleeames6659]

I am in no way excusing what happened. She is however, describing her thoughts and actions as things were unfolding. Not after the fact, when bodied started popping up and people were disappearing. At that time, she is simply trying to digest the crazy that is Chad Daybell.

[@theplantlady-southafrica9161]

I don't believe anything she says anymore after the court case. In the police interview she said slept in a separate room from David but in the court case she said she was back and forth between rooms🙄

[@tammykelsey7877]

Can you imagine that in this interview, Melanie is only telling us what she wants to tell us. She knows MUCH MUCH more!

[@ajordan1976]

I said this 3 years ago when I first watched. She's so transparent. She is a horrible person and a liar.

[@j4kgang921]

Yup

[@whetstone-h4c]

During this interview she’s matching up with publishers

[@BradJames878]

The only way that Nate was able to get Gibb to sit down with him is if he made major concessions. There was to be no implicating of the Mormon Church allowed, and they have been murderers from the start. And there was no mention of the love affair between Lori and Gibb allowed. It's all a crock, throw this woman in prison.

[@ajordan1976]

@@BradJames878 the love affairs between Lori Fibb Warwick and Daybell? Or the love affair between Lori and Fibb?

[@pierreninow9377]

"Lori loves the Lord" - Married 5 times, Husband 3 & 4 dies under suspicious circumstances, 2 Kids dead - I call BS on all of it!

[@holden3]

Dont forget cheating on Charles & coveting Tammy's husband

[@SunnyDay335]

How could she have been a good mother? My definition must be different.

[@elainemurley9509]

I think God would not approve of them Lots of forgiveness from God is needed for those 3 killers

[@sharondavis258]

"The Lord" is not any of this nonsense.

[@lesliematteis8010]

Lori loves herself. She’s a greedy slut!

[@marsargoxmiso1695]

You know what is insane is that she knew what was going to happen when Lori called her children “zombies” she did nothing didn’t call the cops didn’t alarm anyone for intervention.

[@susanporter105]

Let he who is without sin cast the first stone!!!!!

[@marciajones2993]

@@susanporter105 Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities.😢

[@BethStoss-zt4dm]

These gals are out of their minds! This one should have gone to the police asap!

[@sueg2286]

@@susanporter105 Let he who is a complete idiot, make that comment...

[@wisdomseeker3362]

Agree. They could have placed her on a 51/50 hold.

[@mandie1111]

Nate Eaton, your skill in interviewing people is admirable, and you've done an amazing job covering this CRAZY tale.

[@moniquegarces]

Who is here back watching now that chads trial is moving?

[@barbararuell8199]

Yes rewatching during Chads trial she was also a wife in previous probations I have no frickin doubt

[@garyross1279]

Yes

[@j4kgang921]

Here. Amd this woman should be in jail too

[@HippieChick60]

Go back and watch the three interviews done by hidden true Crime with Heather Daybell if you haven't already.

[@raincadeify]

What's the consensus: Was Chad the mastermind or Lori?

[@HuntClubBarbie]

This woman is complicit in the murder of those innocent children and at least 2 adults. She is very objective and matter of fact about all these heinous crimes. She is only "sorrowful"for Lori who has lost her fun-loving freedom. Gibb only cares about protecting herself.

[@Emy53]

She's a looney tune. Religious fanatics at this level are dangerous. She possibly believes in past lives too. Lori wasn't faithful to Charles neither was Chad to his wife. It's a crazy cult and she believes in it.

[@katieshort8162]

She also had a whole lot of emotion describing the moment when her life changed, it's difficult for her to talk about, how hard her life became... When it came out the kids were dead. As in, no remorse for her inaction, regret for enabling or grief for children, just woe is me.

[@cowgirl2989]

Yes she knows Far more than she pretends. She is Very involved & should be charged!! Her, David was thick as thieves! Her & Lori two peas in a pod!! She deserves death penalty as well in my opinion she was last person to see kids alive! Other than Alex. She helped with all of the Plans!! She help plan the murders! Sick two face evil witch!

[@vickyvictoriawilliams3254]

I hate that she's laughing throughout this interview the emotional response is so displaced .. why would you be enjoying this interview so much knowing children have died. Her reactions and silly giggles are like her friend's..

[@HuntClubBarbie]

@@vickyvictoriawilliams3254 She's appalling AND she's enjoying the attention

[@gigia9515]

This woman is a piece of work. Her grinning. smiling, pretending she didn't really believe a lot of this herself, is a manipulator like Lori. I'm sure she knew of the murders all along.

[@corinnehernandez4549]

I agree with you. She's disgusting! I can't stand her smirk and laugh as she talks about the details leading to their horrific crimes. I honestly don't know how the interview can tolerate sitting across her.

[@lisalancework7999]

Agree 💯Melanie on true crime network has a taped phone conversation Which gives you a completely different look on Melanie gift and it’s not good she seems just as guilty as the rest of them honestly

[@gregthomas2448]

Hopefully we see this woman arrested soon. Wow. She’s so involved. Undeniable 💯

[@chuckmallard75]

Agree, she’s the one who introduced Lori to Chad. She was a follower before Lori.

[@mandie1111]

​@@chuckmallard75 This is such an important part of everything!

[@christierella]

The moral of this story is: Don't be so open-minded, that your brain falls out.

[@stephanieadams3747]

No, the moral of the story is, when someone tells you to lie to the police, immediately go to the police and tell them everything you know!

[@bugsea54]

well said!

[@michellejohnsen912]

Lol!

[@harlowjademermaid1882]

Naive, not open minded

[@jewel.s.journey]

@@stephanieadams3747 yes she def should have talked to them immediately.

[@Mzzz-v2m]

The constant smiling during an interview with such a horrific topic is very unsettling.

[@mfregeau59]

Exactly

[@maggieclendenin6740]

Agreed

[@joettatennison5929]

Indeed

[@j4kgang921]

Creepy ass lady

[@laura-cg7vl]

According to body language experts it’s an indication that she’s uncomfortable; nervousness.

[@cambriavictory]

"He's a good guy", no Melanie. No. He's not. He has murdered his wife and 2 children. That is not a good guy".

[@nifflofair6685]

I know! And in thi reporters latest interview outside the hearing, he is patronising the posters from this vide for calling her out for this and knowing what happened to Lori first husband because he was a "Zombie" ! She's a cult member and he's turning on the readers?

[@kiki29073]

Her she is still being deprogrammed. I would like to see Nate reinterview now and see what she says.

[@ladyrasta5757]

She's and idiot!

[@elle262]

Lady Rasta: and totally complicit.

[@sethstine4698]

This woman is just as crazy, if not more crazy than Lori. The way she smirks and laughs when talking about what happened. She is a truly fucked up individual and its really frightening to hear her speak...

[@steveconnor3311]

This lady really annoys me. She's not as innocent as she puts on. She knows more of what went on but does not want to make herself look bad.

[@laurenmay2098]

She is innocent, Lori and chad are the evil ones that murdered everyone. She is awful because she is from a religion that is very crazy, lds make people that way. That’s all, she is not evil like Lori and chad.

[@AproapeG0l]

Totally! I also think she gives a very self righteous vibe

[@shamekaaponte2980]

I agree

[@Elegant_Sausage]

Yeah I picked up on some deceptive vibe for sure, she's not genuine

[@leannabedore]

Exactly! I also didn't like how she said Lori talked about JJ and how hard it was taking care of him because of his autism. Almost like she was just as frustrated or frustrated for her. KNOWING what that evil woman did to them.

[@kate_is_great]

This reporter does an amazing job. He never makes her feel ashamed and get defensive or shut down. He is top notch.

[@cathleencavanaugh8351]

Gee I wish someone would get thru to her about who she actually is

[@debbienedeloff9473]

Yes I agree he doesn't talk over that's a good reporter I love him he gets to the point

[@rulistening7777]

Who walks around Hawaii carrying a clear bag full of money? Just in time to be filmed by some TV News reporter from Idaho, he just happens to be on hand, with cameras. And then films her arrest. So that we all get a front row seat ?

[@missiris1234]

Yes he know what to say

[@janicemetzger6338]

Wonder where he went to school. He's an excellent interviewer. Just excellent!

[@laurenmay2098]

Melanie, Melanie, people didn’t passed away, they were murdered, what a way of saying it.

[@Anonymoususerx-y6o]

It’s ok. They were dark. Also just a drug baby and some girl that didn’t like her.

[@StellaFl]

@@Anonymoususerx-y6oPerfectly summarized 👏👏

[@mariac.9727]

She can't say killed or murdered. That's typical of people who are guilty of such a crime. So she has to say passed.

[@twistoffate4791]

Melanie doesn't seem to understand that those who know the Bible know that she IS in a cult, believing blasphemous things. I feel no pity for her. She should know better.

[@amandaduerk5866]

37:14 her nonchalance is FRIGHTENING. The way she talks about these INSANE things like “zombies” and “unclaimed spirits” like it’s just simple common knowledge is FKCING NUTS. Calling them “different” or “unusual” and downplaying these maniacal situations. This is a very scary person.

[@valeriereneeharper]

Most LDS people are very unusual

[@sunshinegal4294]

YES! My thoughts exactly! She believes what she’s saying. 😬

[@7beauties161]

She is much more animated in the Rexburg PD interview, interesting to see her different personas and how she casually talks about the deaths of these innocent children. IMO she is just as nuts as Lori

[@basiahellwich3505]

exactly, she's a co conspirator!

[@joserivas2623]

​@@7beauties161 she is a cute mormon thou.😅

[@LVGirl4]

Have you noticed there’s still a lot she won’t say? She’s very guarded in a lot of her answers. There’s a lot more to this story we aren’t being told.

[@ellensmith4347]

Maybe LE asked her to keep some of her info under wraps ...the whole story will come out in court ....believe it

[@kiki29073]

She's embarrassed that she fell for it. If she wasn't under there i fluence, she would have understood the reality of it all. I believe she would have said something. But, if she wasn't a follower she would have never been privy to it all. She wouldn't have been in the position ro witness any of it. She is just coming out of it.

[@lilbit68oreo]

there is only SO much she CAN say since it is and has been an ongoing investigation!! we wouldnt want her to give everything up , could jeopardize the case and im sure nONE of us want them to get off scott free

[@tammyduke4213]

I agree

[@edithbell8955]

Yes

[@oldisgood2587]

I never trust a person sporting a perpetual grin especially when discussing death.

[@salishseas]

Mormons.

[@valeriebellomo3573]

Yes..freaking weird isn't it? Damned grin

[@sdfotodude]

Mormons gotta Morm

[@debbiemaclean4232]

Just another day for her to.Very strange.

[@missiadams3305]

Satan, the whole crazy bunch

[@joydrews3822]

It cracks me up that Melanie is preaching to us, like we would stock in ANYTHING she has to say.

[@sharonb9199]

Who's watching this AFTER Chad's arrest and finding the bodies buried in his property?? The interview makes a lot more sense now. RIP Angels xx

[@salishseas]

She says "Chad is a good person. I love him" at the end of the interview. I'd like to see her interviewed today post the bodies of those children being dug up.

[@missbevpowers]

Yes I am. I’m enthralled for lack of a suitable word. Almost half way through this time. Saw it a few weeks or whenever it came out. Love this Eaton fella

[@barbaradelauz5427]

@Des Harris Nope she says she feels they've passed and she was also told that Tammy needed to pass and then she did and still she never came forward until the interview over 6 months later.

[@kathleenstutzman5381]

Maybe she gave the police enough info to figure it out. These interviews would help a lot!

[@nancygerger5015]

I am listening to this today. I’m so glad Ms. Gibs went to police before it was released to the public. RIP children, the angels will care fore now.

[@arbedreka]

Chad has NO VISIONS. He is delusional.

[@tiffanylove8335]

Poop 💩 score for me

[@etodd568]

I call what these false prophets hear in their heads SCHIZOPHRENIA and they can get meds to stop hearing the voices they call VISIONS

[@victoriapapesh6892]

AGREE 💯👍

[@pinkpugginz]

@@etodd568 he doesnt have schizophrenia he is in complete control. Hes lying. Theres a difference.

[@jnagarya519]

So are all those who believe all this religiononsense.

[@ejones610]

Who else's back here watching this again after she testified in Lori's case?

[@hollyramsay6449]

Yes

[@glynn3331]

Yeppers

[@jeanettecoleman-mz7ie]

Done, wiping it off my comp, if I never have to see those ugly murderers again it will be too soon.

[@siggc]

Me!!

[@janroach1852]

Her testimony was also very self-serving. But the truth came out in Zulema's testimony and in the texts. She and David were the last people to see JJ alive. He was either dead at 10 pm when Alex brought him back to the house "asleep on his shoulder" or killed early the next day. David even asked to see JJ as he felt something was off. This woman's dismissal and contempt for the victims is palpable. No compassion. When asked about Tylee she said "Tylee didn't like people. She didn't like anybody." Chad's exact words he spoke about Tylee to a neighbor. And look at how she described JJ, "he was always hyper and angry or crying and chill." She could care less about these kids. JJ was so loving and sweet as I saw in his videos. Hyper, yes. Special needs child. But very loving to others. It was most likely Tylee who had the total care of JJ after Charles died. Tylee stayed with Lori to protect JJ. She fought back against Lori's teachings. In fact, everybody else looked after the kids, not Lori. She was always out doing her own thing. First nephew Zach took care of the kids for three years. Then Charles took most of the care of JJ. Then Tylee. Then Alex. Then the babysitter. Melanie lied to the police even though she is making fun of the beliefs and had doubts. Plus she knew when you were a zombie you died. She is an accomplice to murder. She belongs in jail.

[@dsbond8048]

Every time I see Melanie Gibb speak, I think of Kay Woodcocks statement: "they scatter like cockroaches in the light"

[@doreendaykin6693]

100% AGREE!!!👏👏👏👍

[@taylorellison2719]

This is a grown woman with terrible boundaries, terrible insight and brainwashed. “Cult” isn’t an opinion. She describes every characteristic of a cult in this entire video- love bombing, undue influence, limit to outside education, charismatic leader…. I’ll say it again. Cult is not an opinion. Nate did fantastic research!

[@kendram1893]

The way she smiles like she’s just sharing the neighborhood gossip is just creepy. She was knee-deep in all of this and is now just trying to cover herself- she should be on trial as an accomplice to murder and obstruction of justice.

[@pamelaunderwood2925]

Yes, you can tell she's always been a gossip monger!

[@hollyhawx9481]

I don't understand Melani's definition of "good people." Good people don't cheat on their spouses. Good people don't support their friends who are cheating on two innocent human beings.

[@cathleencavanaugh8351]

But as long as you are right with the church ,you're good , eh Melanie G.

[@Karen_G.]

Holly Hawx* Yes! Good people don’t call their loved-ones, dark, or zombies, especially a SEVEN YEAR OLD CHILD!! Good people don’t act unresponsive, when police are doing a wellness check, and ask you where your child is. They don’t tell you to lie when LE knock on your door or call you in regards to where their child is. They don’t ask you to show a contrived picture you took to dupe LE that your friend’s child was with you! Melanie, you had lots of red flags, at a time when the children’s welfare was at stake! How is Chad and Lori seeing one another BEFORE his wife was dead- that Lori moved to Rexford BEFORE Tammy’s death, and that she died 10 days after someone (Alex) shot at her w/a gun, w/a silencer on it! It wasn’t a paint gun- where was the paint? Like what happened to Brandon Boudreaux, it was a missed hit on her life, by Alex, who had a gun w/a silencer on it. Melanie needs to be concerned that she was willing to move to Rexford, when her having close friendship w/Lori and Chad gave her an up close and personal view to what they were teaching, a teaching that included zombies, and who “see” people dying that also happen to be in their way and expendable! She needs to be concerned about her willingness to go along with such “beliefs” that are so contrary to the beliefs she espoused as a LDS member, and had continued to sit and worship in a LDS church. It goes beyond being “open-minded” as the beliefs that Chad and Lori espoused was CRAZY talk! Melanie needs to do some soul searching as to why those “teachings” were worth moving to Rexford for. How is what anything they say even having a ring of truth to it? She should be concerned with her falling for the things that Lori and Chad were saying and doing. Scary!

[@meghanheinrich5243]

O-M-G......want to know my gut feeling, Melanie??? You knew and or were involved! She is freaking acting and deflected for 5 minutes carrying on about the day HER whole life changed, when they called telling her to say she had JJ. She really expresses no concern about JJ. Her gut feeling let her hang up the phone with Lori without demanding to know why she the police were looking for JJ! and demanding to know where he really was! She had the nerve to try to blame religion could drive someone to chop up their own children. mentioned so many times how much of a handful JJ was. She is soooooo putting on such an act to look innocent

[@ernakammer7886]

Im german and just stumbled over this case. I’m shocked about that woman and how she’s trying to minimize her guilt. She believed in whatever these crazy people said and even made that weird podcast with lori. The zombie theory meant that possessed people could only be cured when they die - only way to make the demon leave the body - she knew about that and could figure what would happen to the children and Charles or Tammy. She knew that they had to die to be healed. Furthermore she says “they passed away” which tells all….

[@snowwhite2524]

💯

[@di3486]

Did she kill anyone? No. Don’t be so fast to judge.

[@maggieclendenin6740]

I love a good German common sense comment!! I am the daughter of a strong German woman and I completely agree with you. Also want to point out why is she smiling and laughing during this horrible interview! She and her bonehead husband knew exactly what happened to their so called "zombies" ugh.

[@maggieclendenin6740]

​@@di3486we don't know what this lunatic knows!

[@ernakammer7886]

@@maggieclendenin6740 thx for your comment ♥️

[@Anonymoususerx-y6o]

She only started to care when she was asked to lie to the police. If that didn’t happen she would’ve continued along with all the zombie BS and magical thinking

[@vanceriddle4191]

She lied to the police. She started to care when the FBI began investigation.

[@keitafoxy7428]

@@vanceriddle4191 yes exactly. She was already lying to the police and helping Lori make the false claims about charles

[@samsmom400]

According to her.

[@miam1074]

she is still deep into magical thinking. the version that suits her

[@joycemeadows1821]

She didn't want to go to jail herself for lieing to detectives.

[@sue1048]

There are actual people like this that exist and dwell among us- let that sink in

[@kateashby3066]

I lived with someone like this. Err like Lori anyway. Extremely manipulative and loved a double life. She way a good church goer and a volunteer at a veteran’s society, but in secret she was a fraud and when she sensed people finding her out, she got ahead of it and turned everyone against that person. Turns out I’m 99% sure she has BPD, aka borderline personality disorder. She let her 35 year old sun live in the cupboard under the stairs where he would shoot up heroin. When I found out and tried to move out because of it, she flipped the script and told everyone I was the drug user, and she was kicking me out because of it. This woman ruined my entire life for about 2 years. I’m finally got mine when I took her to court and proved my case. But it caused me a series of emotional and mental breakdowns. It’s so scary how women like melanie, who can look perfectly normal, are secretly batshit crazy and conspire to do insane shit in the name of (whatever they use to justify their nonsense). There’s a lot more of these people than we are aware of.

[@2cents577]

Scary!

[@suzannek4723]

It’s psychotic

[@tigerlily9981]

That’s why I stay home a lot.

[@cassieblack1776]

Absolutely! And clearly this lady and Melanie are still out there and prosecuted for their connections. Which is confusing because I thought this interview was Melanie? Who is the cousin that was married to the guy Brandon or something and they tried to shoot him. Isn’t she intertwining all this is definitely knows a lot more.

[@misstuxbrandi]

You can't convince me Melanie wasn't involved in dark, occult practices and she didn't know those children were "sacrificial lambs".

[@lauriestaltari7107]

Agree her day will come this will boomerang back to her.

[@gregthomas2448]

This woman is involved. She’s guilty as F too.

[@jimrickert1856]

I agree 100%... she was so into their beliefs if some how Lori and Chad got away with these murders and attempted murders she would still be side by side with those two devil's

[@heartlights]

Ok we can't tell you that sounds good

[@gregthomas2448]

@@jimrickert1856 Agree still her wacko BFF. This woman is no different than Lori. She just hasn’t been caught yet. Cuffs and a jail cell await this lunatic too

[@lindseybrindel5497]

She is so nonchalant, it’s disturbing. What a weird lady. I’ve never watched someone so gullible and unemotional about all the crazy things and events she witnessed. She knows more.

[@lisalancework7999]

And now her and her husband are divorced and I wonder if they got married so they couldn't testify against one another they were there the night JJ disappeared. I think they know more. At least this woman knows more. She's so contradict herself all over the place and the police interview.

[@sarahwynn6486]

@@lisalancework7999they aren’t divorced they’re still married just live in different states

[@lisalancework7999]

@@sarahwynn6486 it will be interesting to see if they divorce now once the trial is over with

[@I.C.Weiner6969]

Melanie every few sentences: "does that make sense?" "does that make sense?" Me: *NO Melanie, actually it DOESN'T make sense.*

[@patriciatreslove146]

She is every bit as bad as them, she enabled them, she fed into their insanity, what she is doing now is damage control on her own reputation.

[@yama5182]

Yeah, I hate it when when people use that phrase. 🤣

[@yama5182]

@@patriciatreslove146 ...Yeah, somewhat but she wants the truth to come out too.

[@Saybleu]

YOU just made me laugh my ass off reading. Thanks. I spewed diet Pepsi out of my nose laughing. 😜

[@Saybleu]

@@yama5182 The worst is, "know what I'm sayin'?" Or "you feel me!". Those people need to be put away lol

[@y2ksurvivor]

While I appreciate hearing Melanie Gibbs' viewpoint, it's clear she's still struggling with many levels of denial. Understandable - to a point. This entire group is a study in "wtf" psychology.

[@shrutefarms4741]

mannequin she is disturbed and repulsive.

[@shesheshe9389]

Yesss and yazzzzz

[@stevielynn5197]

Exactly manniequin! I was LDS for many years and it took many to get out!! This is manipulation and indoctrination to the point blind people will admit and follow. I am proud to say I AM NOT LDS, FLDS, RLDS or any other cult

[@shrutefarms4741]

J. C oh yes... we wouldn’t want to betray Loris’ trust. That would just be the worst! Melanie spent more time lamenting how Lori must feel and how she looks in prison then she spent on worrying about what Lori and chad have done to the kids and their behavior. She is so worried about how she comes across and spent the last 5 minutes preaching and giving ridiculous advice. She couldn’t be more off kilter. Scary! She went on to say she just couldn’t believe Chad hadn’t seen all of this in his visions and he’s a really nice guy but maybe he’s lost his way 🤮. But yes you’re right. Great job Melanie🙄

[@beckydennis6591]

@@stevielynn5197 I guess I should do some research because I don't understand LDS. I'm a Christian and I don't understand believing zombies and reincarnation. Where do they get that from? Do they believe teachings outside the Bible?

[@keriosborne3872]

Nate’s “what, like a box?” when asking about the portal in the closet is everything. 🤣

[@laurenmay2098]

😂😂😂😂

[@dianarubia9039]

For some reason 🤔 I pictured Clark Kent changing into Superman in a “Portal” when I heard that Chad made the portal for Lori in a closet

[@crisspauley436]

This reporter is very professional. He conducts himself in an excellent manner.

[@donnar9864]

This is an EXCELLENT interviewer.. this woman is just as guilty, I wish she could go to prison as well, she knew too much and said NOTHING!! RIP to all the innocent people affected by these crazy monsters..

[@mariamaria2751]

Agreed. Well said

[@carolyndymond4065]

Yes but she did she went to the police after asking where jj was.

[@LilyBecca]

Nate Eaton is with East Idaho News and has absolutely given the best coverage on this case. During the trial, he went to court every day and did recaps every night. It was fantastic!

[@janetcampbell9286]

It's easier to just be passive & not say or do anything! When you check your brain & will to a false cult leader, you become very passive in many other areas. You do have to check your will to be passive when your critical mind says this seems weird or somethings not right, but you denounce that & choose to keep going with the "elect" & she had known them in a previous life. This is the common thread that is in every "cult." Pages of people who have been in previous lives at higher levels is a scam!!! What a con man!!!!

[@aishamccraw7699]

​@@carolyndymond4065 no she lied to the police initially told them JJ was with her and then came clean.Shes a piece of work this one.😊

[@LadyOaksNZ]

Empathy for the murderers but zero concern for the kids who just happened to disappear and mysteriously "pass away"... Blood on her hands

[@lillianvirolas1877]

I could not agree more.

[@jenniferwarhawk7301]

👏👏👏 Yes, EXACTLY! This woman is very disturbing too. Very disturbing!

[@lynahiacampbell8232]

Yep she’s also to blame !

[@lindahoffman2692]

Lady, COMPLETELY AGREE!!

[@lillianleigh7316]

She knew what they did to zombies. Lori told her JJ was a zombie.

[@lmpfunk]

Her very first response tells me everything I need to know. She decided to come forward only once she feared for her own safety. She is guilty for aiding and abetting!!!! And her smug little attitude is so disgusting. The fact that she’s just living in society is terrifying.

[@TeeJayNZ]

Plus she was a believer in all chad’s BS visions etc for over a year before Lori was so who led who both evil bitches imo

[@karasteynberg636]

That comment, Alex? that one surprised me so that means she knew about the other deaths!

[@lisalancework7999]

Agree and she could’ve saved 0:05 Charles‘s life by going to the police when he cried to her and told her that Lori and them we’re going to try to kill him but she didn’t-kzbin.info/www/bejne/a4vScn9qqK2KaLs

[@glynn3331]

Good point she feared for her own safety she should have gone to cops earlier about kids

[@ajbarnett9345]

I have always felt she was guilty. Form the first time I saw her on stand and was so rude to the attorney asking her questions. Did she think the attorney was going to ask her what her favorite color was?? This lady is nuts!

[@MrDavenez]

Its really devastating that Melanie didn't say a word until her own fate was on the line !!

[@chefbetsy9094]

How Melanie Gibbs wasn't investigated perplexes me almost as much as Nicole Kessinger not being in shackles

[@ann-marieblaney2552]

I 100% agree with you!

[@katliese]

This religion is beyond disturbing. People did not pass away, they were murdered!

[@cherirussell9641]

Please keep in mind they are not living the true principles of the mainstream Mormon church. The fact that they were seeing each other alone while married to other people is strongly frowned upon, and if they were having an affair and it was found out about they could have been excommunicated from the church, etc, etc, etc.

[@TheSassleburger]

cheri Russell they were having an affair. Have they been ex’d?

[@cydkriletich6538]

Kathy Liese Not a religion. A cult. And like all cults, based on lies and bullshit.

[@Brenda-qm4sy]

@Jennie Hughes lol

[@Brenda-qm4sy]

@Des Harris Read my comment. SHE'S INVOLVED.

[@wisewillow5731]

They weren't "allowed" to divorce, because they both wouldn't get their dead spouses life insurance if they did that..

[@wisewillow5731]

@@joycereeck2866 oh yes I know, thank goodness, but according to Chad and Lori!

[@susanna8612]

But in that whole religion divorse is not allowed, alltho what comes to these 2, I agree that the motive was money and zombies.

[@lovemewhite3939]

Indeed the truth

[@Libbertyone]

Why in the hell didn’t she stand up at that point and confront Lori” her friend” and tell her, this affair is wrong and I’m not okay with it!!!

[@DarlingBo-bannie]

Yep!

[@corkys6263]

Anyone else watching this 3 years later, after Lori's sentencing?

[@nikki7962]

Yes

[@eileenbytheway3684]

Yes

[@mimimutti8760]

Yup

[@Julia-uh4li]

It's just about 4 years later for me. Chad's trial is nearing the end now. Then Lori's new trial will start in Arizona sometime this summer. She's already there being held in their jail. Thank goodness. I hope the jury also finds her guilty of Charles death!

[@mrsCRD]

Watching this during Chad's trial. Gibb should be in prison along with them!

[@annwood6812]

Kudos to the interviewer for getting through a majority of this discussion with a straight face.

[@KS-op5hb]

And being very respectful when I’m sure it was tough

[@cathleencavanaugh8351]

Hard to find humor , discussing 2 kids being killed

[@cathleencavanaugh8351]

@Joyce Curtin yes it is good you weren't interviewing .it's way too sad .she doesn't mention regret cuz kids were killed but feels sorry for ' Lori being in jail & not looking as pretty as Lori would like to look '. This woman is definitely off her rocker .

[@lauragibbons2629]

He was probably in disbelief hearing all of this garbage , and how far they veered off the religion since he himself is a member of the lds church

[@andiNZ2020]

Two minutes in and I would have slapped her smug face

[@efsmoore2274]

This is the type of person I taught my children to steer clear of in this life. Anyone, male or female, who are so knee deep in a religion of any name that they cannot navigate their life on their own. This case is utterly heartbreaking. The woman talking here is still delusional.

[@valeriereneeharper]

Honestly, it’s those who believe they have some secret knowledge about spiritual things that are the dangerous/creepy/deceived people. People who just straight up believe the Bible still grasp reality, it’s the ones who think they’re special and have some secret knowledge others don’t that lose grip of reality badly.

[@melaniebrown7703]

​@@valeriereneeharper it's those types of ppl such as Chad and Lori Daybell who are so delusional and off track with their religion and clearly suffering from some sort of mental illness and hides it very well and as they pass judgement on other's and secretly speak of others ie friends, family,and loved ones about how individuals are rated and classified as evil beings and zombies when it's in fact them that are evil and dangerous and has veered off track from their religion and have seriously lost touch with reality to where Lori and Chad being the most off their rockers and actually extremely dangerous to anyone involved with them put themselves at top of the list as these clean superior beings ranking themselves as perfect when in fact they're the ones that are most dangerous and slaughtering HER children and family notice how it was only her family/children that was evil and needed taken out and never any of Chad's family or children with exception of his wife of 34yrs but Lori Daybell killed/allowed her own children to be violently slaughtered, her own flesh and blood all to be with a man of delusions without the burdens of her children.. That's tragic and sad and as a mother I just can't comprehend how you could allow that😢 funny how all Chad's children were grown and barred no responsibility of them having to be bothered by them however Lori's kids being young, minors, and JJ being special needs was a burden and hassle for him and her to where they couldn't run around freely just the two of them so Chad convinces her that her children are on highest level of zombie beings and must be eliminated/killed to save their souls when in reality truth was he just didn't wanna be stepfather to or burdened with dealing with a combative teenager and an autistic child tagging along, he killed his wife to marry Lori and travel about and he had no intention of her children being in that picture.. The problem with Mormonism and their religion is that they shun and threaten to excommunicate those from the church who divorce or speak of it which over hundreds of years has lead to many unexplained unnatural deaths among married Mormon couples and shockingly many got away with it until DNA came about and more spoke up demanding exhumations and autopsies.. it's mind boggling how so many for so long for away with so much BS.. Chad and Lori Daybell along with her brother Alex were in fact the sick evil ones.. they dismembered and burned those poor children and then buried them with animals on Chad's property leaving Alex to clean up the mess while they ran off to Hawaii the two of them just happy as can be.. they're the sick ones and looking back now Lori was excellent at convincing others ie friends family and police and lying she seemed completely sane and as for poor Charles Vallow he desperately tried to warm everyone and those incompetent Arizona "cops" treated him just awful and it's almost as if the cops bought Lori's crap hook line and sinker which allowed for Lori Chad and Alex to carry out their grand plan and kill Charles Vallow and setting him up however Chad and Lori were furious when finding out Charles Vallow changed the beneficiary from Lori to his sister just weeks prior. Seriously tho the Arizona police department allowed these crazies to do whatever and believed every explanation they told them, they were the true incompetent idiots and should be held accountable.

[@energeticpets]

Every church is a cult,if you can get the big three religions to worship a god that demands blood sacrifice,and murdered millions according to the bible,asks his chosen one Abraham the guy that married his sister,funde Sodom and Gomorrah,, almost killed his son out of obedience to god,and were surprised about Lori??JC what's wrong with Ppl..

[@23Dawnay]

@@valeriereneeharper well didn’t the idiot that started Mormonism nothing but a liar and deceiver. Golden tablets my ass lol nothing but lies

[@heartlights]

Just for the sake of conversation, can any of you describe one thing about what this lady said that sounded delusional to you? I can wait.

[@crystalcorley]

He's a nice man....who just so happens to be a part of multiple murders, two of which were children who have been found buried in his yard. I have no words to describe this woman at this point.

[@keelsmac01]

Crystal Corley this interview was before the kids were found. You understand this fact...right? How could she even imagine her best friend could do this. I want you to look at your best friend, who you trust. Would you ever believe she could do something like this? Especially before this case..it would never even enter your mind...THATS darkness most people can't fathom.

[@abbyluxemburg8968]

I'm pretty sure she doesn't think he's a good man now. This interview was BEFORE they found the kids.

[@crystalcorley]

@@abbyluxemburg8968 I know and there were plenty of deaths before this interview as well.

[@simileesimmons3102]

Ratchet comes to mind.

[@pommiebears]

@@abbyluxemburg8968 she thought he was a good man after he married Lori two weeks after she died? Is that what a good man does? Stop it with your BS.

[@albin2232]

She knows everything, but will never tell anything.

[@jamessingleton5191]

She seems to have more compassion for Lori and Chad than for the children who were murdered.

[@jackD441]

When this interview was taken place no one knew the kids were dead in Chad's backyard....remember the reporter asked this blond bimbo...do u think Lori will ever give up info on where those kids are at?..she said no..and I don't think she ever will...learn how to listen before posting

[@stormidavis270]

@@jackD441 why you gotta be rude? Maybe she ment she has more compassion for lori and Chad over the kids period..cause she sure don't mention them unless she's asked bout them

[@Love_maui_2017]

stormi Davis exactly

[@TheSkydiverphoenix]

Good observation. I was thinking the same thing. I think she is a believer and only did the interview to deflect her own culpability in this mess..

[@TheSkydiverphoenix]

@@jackD441 You must be one of the LDS nut job supporters. What the post said was right on the money. That women caired more about Lori and Chad than those children..

[@markcoxen8563]

How this reporter is not continually rolling his eyes in shocked disbelief is a testament to his professionalism.

[@jenniferr5934]

He belongs to the same cult

[@Stronggrl]

@@jenniferr5934 NO HE DOESNT, why would you say that?? Hes been a intregal part of why this case got so much coverage & put pressure on Chad + Lori. He should be commended, not shamed.

[@Stronggrl]

Hes an awesome reporter & I think bc he had such a connection with the story he wanted all the answers bc he knew this would likely be a 1 shot thing. Hes the 1 who was putting pressure on Chad + Lori inc in Hawaii & got alot of awareness.

[@robinmaynard1640]

He is going to need therapy just being close to this and having to suspend disbelief in order to get the results. Great job.

[@ryansgirl2002]

He does a well enough job professionally, all things considered. However, i do believe he could've taken the interview to an unprecedented legendary level by commencing to issue her the biggest, most grandiose snap-slap right across ye olde melted wax face to conclude the interview. You know, just as a public service or whatever. Just my 2 cents.

[@sharondavis258]

For a women who has found out that "her friends" or her "spiritual leaders" or whatever you want to call have committed 4 murders, she smiles too much. Her eyes are shinning while she does it too. It is almost as if she is proud and likes the attention. That is how she comes off to me.

[@lisalancework7999]

Agree

[@kateashby3066]

Tylee was a teen and it sounded like she was a fireball as many teens are. She HATED Melanie. Now don’t get me wrong, I remember being an angsty teen and had an attitude half the time but I never loathed my mothers friends. Tylee got to see the side of Melanie that she is trying not to show us. This version of MG is disgusting and it’s heavily censored. I bet Tylee had good cause for hating her.

[@leahjones9626]

That’s the same EXACT thing I said! Her excitement surrounding the topic. And this fucking TWINKLE in her eye 🙄🙄🙄. UGHHH!!!

[@lillianvirolas1877]

She is a zombie

[@SabrinaMeShell]

Melanie Gibb shows more of the attention seeking, self righteous personality in this interview with the AZ police. She is a big time liar, only interested in protecting her own behind. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fWOYeGx-aahknNU

[@letsgetlit2829]

How could this women hear and see all these weird things for over a year and continue to be friends with Lori.

[@Anonymoususerx-y6o]

Because she’s a pathetic joke. And has no self awareness.

[@j4kgang921]

Cuz she was A Witch Too!

[@cynthiaholmes8070]

She was in agreement with everything, and that zombie crap was every single one of them, including this ones excuse to commit m--der for the sake of money. What kind of church is the LDS.

[@TASmith-ou3is]

I can't believe this woman got on national television, talked about her close friendships with insane people, without realizing how bad she looks.

[@dawnb3194]

She doesn’t care as long as she’s not arrested ;0)

[@Emy53]

No God makes you kill unless your God is evil. These people are brain washed. This women is as ccx total looney tune.

[@glossypots]

She is still a believer.

[@joyceengland8781]

Is she being paid?

[@TASmith-ou3is]

@@joyceengland8781 I don't know.

[@greenhouse777]

Kinda bothers me throughout this entire thing her main concern is lori. Lori being without Chad. What about Tylee and JJ? My goodness!

[@Love_maui_2017]

Greenhouse Gathering EXACTLY

[@Scrappitydoodah]

I think she’s in love with Lori.

[@TheSassleburger]

Melanie obviously needs additional help. But I suspect she focuses on Lori because she sorta knew the kids were gone, even if not how/when/where. She probably thinks they are in a celestial heaven (not sure I’m getting the LDS terms correct)...So now she has to worry about saving Lori’s soul. Just a guess.

[@keelsmac01]

Greenhouse Gathering the first thing she said was it was for the kids Charles and everyone not here.

[@enlightened1wright928]

Well- you know she doesnt want to get them to angry at her! She's hoping and praying that when which ever one crumbles and starts talking they don't let the fact out that while she may not have exactly had any hands on as far as the murders- she was full aware of their missions and what was being carried out! That I guarantee. She should have come forward long ago! Think about it- She knew about Tammi, she knew about Charles, yet the fate of the "Zombie kids" would be different"? Lori; "JJ is a zombie- he's in my way- I'm going to send him to Kay's"- "not even sure if Kay will take him"? Later Lori-"I had to put JJ in a safe place, cause Kay is trying to kidnap him, it's a custody battle" "I have to protect him from Kay"! SURE Melani that wasnt any flag to you was it?! Yep! Melani you best get right with God because he knows that you may not have "pulled the trigger" but you sure sat back and let these murders happen! While you may have been "nieve" enough - you werent so niece that you didnt keep reminding them that you didnt want to know anything! It was all so obvious no need for details! Hope your asking for forgiveness!

[@kkheflin3]

The comment she said that sent chills down my spine was when Nate asked her, "What did you think when you heard about Alex Cox dying,?" Her response was, "I was surprised. I didn't SEE THAT ONE COMING." Did she see the rest of the murders coming?

[@brendabacon2465]

She sure as hec should have.

[@Anonymoususerx-y6o]

Yes, she states, ‘their plan’ ‘I don’t know how they did it’ statements like that, she knew people were going to die,

[@froggiesilver22]

She sure as hell had pre-knowledge of all the murders and did nothing to save anyone. She’s a wolf in sheep clothing

[@hammergamingcoc2375]

Fucking psychos walking freely among ppl..this woman is also one of them

[@beentheredoneization]

Hindsight is 20/20 .. Sometimes we're too close to see the big picture and I'm sure all of us can recall a time in our lives when we were fooled by one or more that we felt we pretty much trusted implicitly and may have even compromised ourselves to even a small degree before we completely realized the ramifications of our 'loyalty' to another person. Though each of our personal experiences more are probably nothing to the extent of this case regardless we have to bear in mind that as observers we're in the position of seeing the bigger picture because of the coverage and unfolding of this whole story where someone who is much closer and involved bit by bit, day by day it takes longer for that picture to materialize and complete itself and for all the pieces to fall into place. As observers we're sitting at a completely different vantage point. When Melanie initially lied to the police she was buying time to answer some questions of her own about the players involved while still being alive and fresh in what she felt was a basically good and meaningful friendship so initially mitigating anything negative until she could figure out more was almost understandable though humanly flawed as it was.

[@michaelsimson8976]

Find it interesting that she spoke to Alex every time she got bad news. She called him when she heard about Brandon being shot at, when she heard Tammi was dead and when they asked her to lie, she called Alex. What the fuck for? She should have been calling the police not Alex. She was in hook line and sinker. The way she said “Tammi was not supposed to be alive by then” WTF! Like fate was supposed to intervene in Tammi’s life so Lori and Chad could be together. Well fate did and his name is Alex. She is a looney tune…

[@Mrs.T.Rusch25]

Mr. Eaton, you are one of the only true investigative reporters out there. You don't show opinion, you do heavy research and ask probing yet not slanted questions. We love your work and are extremely impressed with you. This is what journalism USED to be!!

[@lauragibbons2629]

Exactly.. and trust me it would be very difficult to not give his opinion since he is Mormon also

[@jgirl345]

@@lauragibbons2629 wow I didnt know he was also Morman, by the way he asks questions, sounds like hes unfamiliar with that religion

[@karengiorella2690]

He gets to the point with his questions. I don't usually watch any long investigative reporting videos. But his manner with his questions probed into the subject in a respective way. I watched the whole thing. Glad I did.

[@AshleyTDaylee]

first video on this I saw was him in Hawaii first I saw

[@Susan17578]

Agree wholeheartedly! Even of journalism isn’t seen anymore. Bravo Nate Eaton!

[@nottthereyet4872]

I'm a woman and so tired of women acting like they have no thoughts or mind of their own.

[@justanotherguy469]

Addendum: When it works in their favor.

[@dearcole123]

I was gonna say, I’m a woman and have quite a few thoughts of my own, and especially a few thoughts And choice words I’d like to share with this woman Melanie G and Lori and chad. They are disgusting. And police just found those poor children in chads property... 😞

[@CarriSue]

Way too much sugar coded talk. She is still in a bubble.

[@TheSassleburger]

Well, she’s still with David Warwick. 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@cathleencavanaugh8351]

Exactly ! How can she be so happy / bubbly knowing what happened to kids & she totally did .

[@Wistful77]

Some people might even eat sugar coated poop if it was offered by their idol.

[@jackiebilder5183]

@@Wistful77 haha

[@cookie_dough_hangover]

Absolutely.

[@loryhartland2977]

This is where it started for me. After this interview there was no going back. Fantastic journaling skills!!

[@earlsmypearl5949]

The sympathy she has for Lori is disgusting

[@lyndaczika6327]

It’s so disturbing.

[@Truth17John17]

And Chad.... claiming still that he's "a nice man." Melanie Gibb is a very sick, evil woman.

[@Vixenspirit]

I think she's rationalised what Lori did by telling herself she was being led by 'the adversary'. I don't know if her opinions have changed since, but at this point I think she still believed all Chad's/Rowe's teachings but its okay because this only happened because Lori was deceived by the devil (essentially). But its okay that she believes it because she's 'light' and she's special in comparison. Essentially she takes away all agency and accountability both for herself and the murderers and group of believers by Essentially saying 'the devil did it.' I don't think there's any introspection on the beliefs and how dangerous they are because that's harder. If she did that she has to admit she aided and abetted and is partially to blame for this. Goes back to how people fall into cults. They make people feel special. I think in her eyes she can believe she didn't kill, she wasn't deceived. She's special. She's 'light' so it's okay.

[@niktaco]

​@@Vixenspirit 100% Agree... well said..

[@lindahoffman2692]

Vixenspirit, ELOQUENTLY expressed!! You perfectly encapsulated the PSYCHOPATHY of these people INCLUDING this Piece of Work!! They couldn’t even make ONE LIFE WORK let alone dozens! This woman says on one hand “it sounds crazy” while EXPLAINING IT PERFECTLY because she BELIEVES the exact SAME lunacy! SICKENING and FRIGHTENING and the bottom line is IF THIS WOMAN HAD DONE ANYTHING AT ALL to HELP Tylee and JJ THEY WOULD STILL BE ALIVE TODAY!!!

[@dragonflydreamer13]

If this bizzare woman doesn’t scare the hell out of you, nothing will. Wolves dressed up in sheep’s clothing pretending to be whatever you want them to be. How is she not a conspirator?

[@reesee9669]

Exactly. She is smiling and giggling. She will be put in prison along with her girlfriend that she loves so much. Betcha they are all fucking. She's covering for her friend's knows what they did with the kids. She's not in hiding. She's listed as a witness because the feds busted her lying. She's playing the dumb role, when she is still an elite cult member. She better get an attorney and put away her narcissistic ego or she's gonna get more years.

[@sharonclemons6502]

Susan Davis I agree! I listened to the video/audio of the day this Melanie accompanied Tylee & Lori to the police department (Charles was still alive at that point). Completely different voice. Strange! She sounded like a completely different person. I wondered if I had the “Melanies” mixed up-your wolf in sheep’s clothing comment is so right on!

[@yanifree114]

Spot on.

[@pryorbishop2957]

Sharon Clemons would love to see this. Can you point me to it?

[@grannyseven7256]

She seems to know an awful lot she's playing the fiddle.

[@TaraVanflower]

The fact that she still feels sorry for these people who murdered people is INSANE. She can call Chad Daybell a nice man??? Wow.

[@MissMala]

I thought that same thought but then I remembered this was before they found the kids so she didn’t know how badly he was involved.

[@anthonydelgrosso4818]

​@@MissMala plus shes heart broken for the fact that chad and lauri cant be together sickening

[@tracycamarillo1760]

She Belongs In Prison!

[@griffin2263]

I heard her say in one taped call "Alex bless his soul" after she knew he killed Charles in cold blood..this woman is a nut job

[@Fee212]

She says, "I still love him." Oh dear Lord. These people are the adversary's army. 😵‍💫

[@Pete-z6e]

She’s complicit in this whole bloody mess….saving her own skin.

[@j4kgang921]

Yup sneaky ass

[@gorgeousfrazier5903]

She was 100% brainwashed , if my best friend said everyone was a zombie and they were all dying. Nope to the police I go

[@cambodianrefugee6305]

Who uses the term "pass away" to describe someone who has been murdered? There's something not right with that.

[@gigib8849]

At the very least it’s denial.

[@calwilliams1506]

Every Mormon I know minimizes and lives in denial. It’s mind boggling.

[@gigib8849]

Ylfa Petursdottir Soussa “Passed away” is merely a euphemism to make it sound better. Those children didn’t pass away-they DIED! They are DEAD, MURDERED. That’s not passing away.

[@vwchick24]

Passes away it how I spoke about my Grandparents, friends, other family members. When I think of Tylee and JJ, Murder. Nicole Simpson, Murder. Casey Anthony, Murderer. CeCe, baby Niko*, Shanan, Bella; murdered. Somethings wrong with her brain.

[@ladyrasta5757]

She is bat$hit crazy!

[@notifysend1015]

When your friends tell you their kids are zombies and they'll marry when their spouses are dead soon and you kind of let it marinate.

[@TheSkydiverphoenix]

I am no buying it. I think this woman is a wack job..

[@IrishHoopers]

Nuts

[@michelejordan4115]

TheSkydiverphoenix I agree.

[@sharondianneb]

👍

[@wandac4021]

@@TheSkydiverphoenix she totally is!

[@leahjones9626]

This lady makes having a “murderous bestie” sound like she really committed a string of petty thefts. Just a wayward best friend. Full of so much Hope and love for her “friend”… and no disgust, fear or horror, wrenching sadness… to be so entangled in maniacal killings/sacrifice. Literally, human sacrifice. She’s so serene, yet with a joy. I don’t wish anyone to be living in fear and pain, but she could EXPRESS that raw and true pain. But she doesn’t. She really NEVER strikes that chord. Her humanity is - OFF. AND THE WHOLE TIME she talks in the tense that the children are dead.. everyone’s gone, passed… no longer… she refers to the kids “missing” but still puts them in past tense… and even admitted she thinks they are gone off this earth. SO WHAT THE FUCK LADY. YOUR FRIEND MURDERED HER CHILDREN.

[@serenalee2187]

You're so right! It's terrifying. She knew what was going on and was a part of this group. She was with Lori and Tylee at the Gilbert Police Station when Lori stole Charles' truck, possessions etc. Just think how she could have helped save those kids if she'd told the police something, anything, then!!!

[@seasonofthewitch7249]

YOUR ON THE MONEY 💯

[@tracycamarillo1760]

@Leah Jones. 💯

[@tracycamarillo1760]

I Absolutely Love Your Comment, Pretty Much Encompassed It All. Even Audrey @ Trial Said She Didn’t Think They Were Praying To God. Poor Nate Has To Tread Lightly And Massage Her Sick Deluded Mind. I Never Think Of Everything In My Comments But You Did!

[@efsmoore2274]

It's jaw dropping, isn't it!

[@duketta]

Thank you Nate at East Idaho News! 👍

[@helenstockman3499]

I’m so sick of this woman. She should face charges for following Lori’s direction and not answering the phone when police called.

[@seasonofthewitch7249]

So sick of her!!!!

[@susanbajjada2960]

Absolutely!

[@rachaelmccarl]

Yess

[@lyndaczika6327]

Not to mention lying to authorities.

[@yvonnehummel7323]

Still you gotta give her some credit for recording that call with the two of them, giving the prosecution some huge damaging evidence.

[@missycat5783]

1:28:40 "Doctrin" my foot. Call it what it is, 'Cold Blooded Premeditated Murder'.

[@3ittybittypiggiesstorytime547]

There have been and always will be various doctrines of death, "for god..."

[@peterpan05]

And this ‘poor Lori’ crap- she killed her own children. That’s not doctoring! Disgusting.

[@rachelw821]

missy cat it’s “doctrine” but yeah

[@jillianperry5404]

Wow. Rewatching this interview after her testimony 😂 "I knew them better than anyone" to "I wasn't close to them". She is just as guilty!!

[@lindahoffman2692]

She is ONLY focused on trying to JUSTIFY her IMMUNITY DEAL!!

[@lillianleigh7316]

​@@lindahoffman2692Did she get immunity? What about Melanie that tried to get her husband murdered?

[@muthaship2992]

And the tens of thousands of dollars for this interview

[@Munjajane]

She is so annoying. She wants to be in the limelight just not accused of anything. Shes trying to come off as so Knowledgeable now - about these things. As she says. She followed Lori around like a puppy dog.

[@Wattsupwithhybristophilia]

@@muthaship2992did Nate pay her? I know it happens however, checkbook journalism, is unethical. Upstanding news stations have policies against it. Nate’s network is very small.

[@wend5678]

They didn’t pass away Melanie, they were murdered.

[@HippieChick60]

It's code. She still believes this stuff. She believes they willingly passed on after being released from their zombie infested bodies. That's why she uses that vernacular. She will never admit that they were murdered. She knows that eventually her part in it will be found out. She needs to look innocent and bewildered, as if she didn't know what was really going on. It's her only hope. I just wish they were coming after her. I think her immunity deal is protecting her. I also think the church is making promises to her if she keeps her mouth shut.

[@BjarneReksten]

What on earth does any church have to do with this?? Please!

[@wend5678]

@@BjarneRekstenhave I mentioned any church whatsoever in my comment? Show me where I’ve said that please! I said those people were murdered and did not simply ‘passed on’ like she’s framing it.

[@sophieh9387]

Nate is an incredible Reporter. He by far, has done the best coverage of any missing persons/crime reporting I have ever seen. Nate is passionate about the truth!!

[@California92122]

He was also researching little DeOrr Kunz's disappearance, right?

[@Del-Tye5434]

O

[@desertrose00]

She sounds more like an accomplice.

[@kiki29073]

I don't think so. She is a very naive gullible person. That was totally blinded by their lies. They manipulated her. The other woman is totally batshit crazy.

[@3ittybittypiggiesstorytime547]

Oddly she herself believes in the highest risk factors here, leading to death, bullying, abuse (revelation, end of world, obedience...) but blames these deaths all on reincarnation??? Yes, reincarnation can be twisted by those other factors, and I suppose blamed, but, this is blame shifting big time. This lady still believes the world is going to end imminently, by god's power which you must not question, as given by only his Chosen Ones. Can you say, Julie Rowe + a long list of others? It's so much like Marxism: "All those other countries did it wrong and failed, but, We are smart and inspired Chosen Ones, and can do it right and not fail! (jumps over cliff, expecting god to save them)"

[@bobjolly7795]

Can you imagine even finding one person within a 5000 mile radius that would buy into this shit...and yet this woman knew OTHERS...? scary beyond belief

[@waywardangel6356]

@jayden bonilla yep! You can tell in her demeanor when they talk about the weekend she visits, and Tylee is not there & JJ turns Zombie.. she knew!!

[@Madmarsha]

I think unknowingly she was, but not to the death of the kids.

[@jenihansen7201]

Been going over the Vallow-Daybell case prior to Lori's trial. Nate, you did such a great job here, as always. We appreciate you so much. You are kind, attentive, positive, and just an all around great reporter. Thank you Nate.

[@karenhirschkorn2360]

I agree… I’d add that he never interrupts too!

[@carliemccracken5089]

She appears to show far more emotional concern for Lorrie being in jail and not getting to be with Chad than she does for any of the innocent who were murdered. Her responses suggest that she is still very much brainwashed and that she lacks empathy for the victims. Unnerving to watch.

[@joecervantes4637]

This lady is out of touch with reality. Your best friends killed their wife, husband, daughter, son and possibly their brother too. And she is worrying about Lori not being able to be with Chad while in jail? What she wanted most was to be with Chad? Kidding me? What about her children?

[@jeanjones1846]

Universal laws of human stupidity. This whole pack of course, insane beyond belief. To the educated mind, it seems inconceivable that this pack of people would choose rabid ignorance and childish fantasy over, say, a polar bear. Melanie, read your bible. In the meantime stay away from my kids and family. You obviously have the brain of a snail... and just about as slow for thought.

[@rakesfunnyfarm]

No she feels bad that Lori did all this to be with Chad. That Lori needs to come clean. Chad is not worth it. He lit the fire!

[@klutzykate123]

Jean Jones ~ this woman is so inappropriate, the way she laughs while she’s answering zombie questions and many other times has floored me. It’s almost like in a morbid way she is watching and hearing all of these things and enjoying watching all of it as if it’s a drama/mystery movie on TV. I would have severed the relationship after hearing 30 minutes of this bizarre.....WAY BIZARRE stories. She should have gone to the police much sooner. This woman in my mind is an accessory if Chad or Lorie get convicted of any crimes. I can barely watch this woman speak.....unfathomable 😰

[@leeannwitt5380]

Just to think Chad had s portal and predicted people's deaths!!really lady!!!crazy

[@oui-nonmaybe2127]

​@@klutzykate123 They all smirk and smile and slip and say deceitful self protective answers don't they. Creepy as hell, the whole lot! Kay include~ Everyone trying so hard to look innocent in their actions and come across as anything but insane and delusional.

[@jeanneanne3095]

Nate deserves a journalism award for his work on this case.

[@kathysherman4958]

A portal to use the burner phone! This is so crazy. Those poor children, Tammy and Charles.

[@angeleyes3386]

😂 The idiocy

[@alyssiaamador7594]

This women should have never gotten immunity. She even stated in her secret recording her turning point was when police questioned her about the children. Not when Charles died, not when she knew the kids where dead or even Tammy. It’s disgusting. Charles came to her in tears worried for his life and she knew Lori’s plan to murder him. How can anyone in good faith know what she knew and watch someone in completely agony? And do absolutely nothing. Melanie Gibb you’re the same as Lori, Chad, Alex and Zulema. You and Zulema should have never gotten immunity. Y’all both should be behind bars thinking of your choice to follow Chad and Lori. This is disgusting.

[@sharonpuryear4466]

The niece needs to go to jail too she was in on everything

[@vickifyock8279]

And don’t forget Lori’s ( mini me Marlene P)

[@vickifyock8279]

@@sharonpuryear4466 and tried until she was thrown in jail to get her kids to Alex and Chad and Lori for sacrifice murder

[@LauraLancealot]

Nate is a great reporter I hope this opens him up to national markets

[@nishasathiyanathan6302]

Greg check your facts dear Greg! He is not! Nate is a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. Lori Vallow has created something totally different! 🤣

[@bartholomew1608]

He left some questions unanswered

[@shrutefarms4741]

303bred&born completely disagree with this interview. He may have went after this story but his religious beliefs are definitely in the way of his ability to have insight into what an imbalanced person Melanie is. He babied her and feed her answers through this entire interview. He should have taken her to task on almost everything this idiot said.

[@jenniferr5934]

Nisha all religion is a cult

[@bgirl8565]

Of ALL the things Chad 'saw', he didn't 'see' his ass sitting in jail? JS..

[@nacho_ncam]

😂😂

[@sallyscott9172]

thanks for the laugh...about a horrible topic. But you are right...yea, he was looking under the wrong veil.

[@meh5085]

👊

[@kimberlysisk6410]

🤣😅😂🤣😅🤣

[@debbienedeloff9473]

They need to be there Im waiting for one or another to turn

[@misskitty1977]

She's more concerned about lori being away from Chad than the death of innocent children and Tammy and the kids father. What a messed up religion

[@DocTJB]

This is an AMAZING interview. Nate, you are truly a treasure!!!

[@Truth17John17]

You did a great job with this interview, Nate! I don't know how you sat in the presence of such evil and maintained your professionalism -- kudos to you, and for helping bring to light who Melanie Gibb truly is: a sociopath, just like her so-called "friends".

[@SR-om4kr]

The fact that she can sit there with a straight face on national TV and explain the rationality of zombies and portals I -

[@doneestoner9945]

Because when you believe in the LDS bullshit, you'll believe anything. They believe that Joseph Smith was a prophet, when in fact he was a conman. There are records from that time period.

[@hotpinkjalapenos]

Right ..

[@LT11721]

I agree, she is a loon and her LDS group looks like the create people like this. Her apparent serenity while discussing these horrible events and people, while not mentioning the children with any remorse just supports her being a different person than she appears….. just like Lori & Chad!! No, I don’t think she had anything to do with it but she was a watcher for sure

[@jemimadan]

@@LT11721 My Spidey senses have been tingling throughout, watching this. Yep, something is seriously wrong with this lady. Her affect is decidedly odd.

[@maryk.radcliff3948]

Melanie Gibb was an accomplice to the devil.. How does she sleep at night knowing she had a hand in hiding the kids being murdered.....

[@larrybassin211]

C'mon Mel, Chad didn't know Tammy was gonna pass away from information on the other side of the "vail". He knew because he was planning to get rid of her.

[@tysparks598]

*veil

[@honeybee6858]

Ikr ! Puppet master

[@theclawsoncrew13]

Bingo!

[@TheAtl198]

Dur...

[@tjm8128]

Everything Melanie says is about self preservation. She absolutely did not care about those poor babies. She knows a lot more than what she lets on. So does her “husband”. If you really listen to this interview, you will see that she is a bad bad person.

[@Tracy-hm3yi]

"I know you're suffering in jail without Chad who you love " WTF lady?! What about them kids?!

[@StellaFl]

How weird is it that this woman does not shed a single tear for the two children she says she knows are dead? Instead, she gets all teary for her friend Lori because she's in jail without Chad whom she loves? I cannot wrap my head around that :(

[@StellaFl]

@@claudialu Lori's mother even lied on TV saying that she spoke to JJ on the phone in October when we know he was dead :(

[@stevesengpraseuth7707]

Hahahaha, just the type of cult to join when you don't want child support

[@StellaFl]

@@stevesengpraseuth7707 Morbid but true. All of them abandoned or killed their children .......

[@nifflofair6685]

She knows more than she lets on as she rarely speaks the kids' names and says those two murderers are good people!!!

[@magalipearl7]

She don't wanna compromise herself of course. But I feel that she believed as much as anyone.

[@maryleung1425]

It is called distancing behavior ...look it up

[@Eva-vv7ox]

Lock her up... She said she knows them better than anyone

[@GotMySnarkyNanaPantsOn]

She was Lori's protector and enabler just like Alex and Melani her neice

[@j4kgang921]

Yup

[@michelejordan4115]

It seems like she is saddest that Lori is in jail and can’t have the life she wanted; to be with Chad. To have nice things and look pretty/nice. This whole thing is crazy!

[@tracievendetta1908]

I don't know...her facial expressions looked like she was happy she's in prison I think she had a thing for Chad and the Lori came along

[@rbisme113]

I think those were left-handed comments. Melanie G. was available, but Lori V. was married and Chad chose to pursue Lori V. I think Melanie G. had a little jealousy and resentment towards both of them.

[@wordsleuth992]

Renee B I didn’t get that feeling, but I could be wrong

[@jenniferkluck1681]

I totally agree. This lady is either extremely naive or hiding something. So creepy

[@pennythpmas5787]

@@jenniferkluck1681 The kids!

[@barbarahenninger6642]

It keeps striking me how much compassion and love she has for Chad and Lori, but she doesn't mention the children who were murdered. It's weird.

[@alexperkins8433]

well she DID say jj was a handful.....🙄

[@haileymakethatbread9926]

yeah that didn't go over very well.

[@waypay1]

@@alexperkins8433 No, she said Lori said JJ was a handful.

[@waypay1]

It's an interview. He wasn't asking questions about the children. 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@AshJae]

She never even mentioned that they were murdered. She keeps saying they “passed away” all of them. She won’t admit they were all MURDERED

[@Jeanne90275]

"I'm gullible!" she says. No kidding! Try delusional.

[@mashellepardue1989]

I'm not buying into this interview. She knows more than what she is saying. She's not gullible, she is hiding something.

[@ticketyboo6435]

She’s as crazy as a box of frogs.

[@waywardangel6356]

@@mashellepardue1989 I agree! She knew, as when she talks about the welfare check, how does she know they did what??? "That" being dead! I'm sure of it!! Even after knowing all the talk about the partners are going to die so they can be together & then all the Zombie talk! Absolutely she knew!

[@TheSassleburger]

I do not mean to offend anyone, but all the studying and learning crap makes no sense to me. You’re studying made up crap. Ur learning nothing.

[@genabargay4391]

@@ticketyboo6435 don't insult frog's

[@LadyLsound]

Great important interview Nate.... Especially looking at this today (25th April 24), with all the court cases !!