Cricut Maker vs Maker 3 | Which Machine is RIGHT For YOU??

What’s the difference between Cricut Maker 3 and Maker? Wondering which machine is best for you? Find out the answers to this and more in this detailed video review! #cricut #cricutmaker
The Cricut Maker 3 just launched with the ability to cut materials without mats by utilizing Smart Materials. If you were left wondering if you should upgrade to this new machine or stick with the original Maker, this video is for you!
Read the full review here: sweetredpoppy.com/whats-the-d...
SHOP CRICUT MACHINES BELOW:
CRICUT MAKER: prf.hn/l/ZZ9xnnO
CRICUT MAKER 3: prf.hn/l/y8QDQxe
PURCHASE MY CRICUT EBOOK: sweetredpoppy.lpages.co/sweet...
CONNECT WITH KIM AND SWEET RED POPPY:
Subscribe: bit.ly/3dBpaQl | Website: sweetredpoppy.com
Follow Sweet Red Poppy Website: sweetredpoppy.com
Facebook: / sweetredpoppy
Instagram: / sweetredpoppy
Pinterest: / kimberlycoffin
Watch more videos!
CRAFTS: bit.ly/3hArxF5
CRICUT TUTORIALS: bit.ly/2C6Z75q
SEWING TUTORIALS: bit.ly/3e98Vdg
Thanks for shopping through my affiliate links and supporting Sweet Red Poppy!

[@institchesincanada7117]

Thank you so much for this video. I've always believed that if I'm buying something new, it needed to be the latest and greatest. However, now I'm retired, my budget doesn't allow for that. After watching this video several times and giving it endless thought, I decided that the ordinal maker was right for me, especially since it is so much more affordable. You insight was invaluable! Bought the Maker today!

[@TatiTagliari]

You'll gonna love it! I have a Maker and I'm obsessed with it! 💕

[@britt7141]

Probably the most informative video I've watched on the Maker 3 so far. Thanks for going into detail on how it works and what truly makes it different from the original Maker!

[@ashleyeverything588]

Thank you for this video ! I was so stumped as to what their differences are. I think I’m gonna go with the maker 3 because I want the option to go big with my projects

[@jlw102183]

Thank you for this video! I have the original Maker and I have been contemplating upgrading to the 3. This helped me decide that I am ok with staying with my Maker, for a few more months at least.

[@patriceabona1113]

Thank you so much! This helped me make my decision. I received the original Maker for Christmas and I was debating exchanging for the 3, but it’s twice the price! Good to know that since I’ll only be using it for leisurely craft projects, it’s probably not worth it to pay for the upgrade. Thank you for your honesty. I’m also checking out your website- amazing resources! 🌺

[@flipperjw]

This was SUPER helpful! Thank you!!

[@ritabrassfield4296]

Thank you! I was watching other videos and they made the original maker seem like it was not worth the money Thank you for clear differences on both machines.

[@hodlmama6729]

I just bought the Maker. Can’t wait to get started. Ordering your book also.

[@veronicasamms441]

Thank you so much very informative I’m going to buy it now. The maker 3, as I really couldn’t afford the other one. New subscriber here. Your content is so straightforward and to the point.

[@claudiaspees5555]

Thank you for this comparison!

[@yacbdgurrll5566]

Wow thanks you for posting this! As I still have an explore I’m looking to upgrade and use my explore for baking only!! I believe I am convinced maker is the best solution for my crafts!! Thank you again!! 🥰

[@Andra_JD]

this was super helpful! thank you so much!

[@lynnlaverack7334]

Thank you. I couldn’t find any where else to explain the clear difference.

[@janetgasston9888]

Thank you for your video. It has helped me to decide which machine to buy .I have order you book to help me long the way.

[@tinawilliams9163]

Thank you so much for this video! I’ve been going back and forth about this. Although I like the idea of mat-less cutting and being able to cut larger projects I don’t think it would be worth the money (for myself) when the original Maker can do everything that the 3 can do. 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@CarolinaTravis]

Thank you so much i was thinking about purchasing one today but i will get the maker

[@reynaldorobles]

Thanks definitely helped me make my decision. The Maker OG

[@everyDEYNA]

Very informative! Thank you! I have now subscribed to your channel :)

[@Treliyvan]

You're not the only one. I still love your video.

[@TheStationFairy]

My Original Maker is about 6 years old and giving me print and cut issues... I ordered the Maker 3 because I need a new one, love the color and also cut faster 💛 thank you for this!

[@ClaireLouise]

Thank you so much for this video. You've made me feel more confident that I made the right choice in the original maker. You're a gem xo

[@SweetRedPoppy]

Glad I could help! Thanks for taking the time to watch my video!

[@ClaireLouise]

@@SweetRedPoppy I'm so glad I did! Its arriving Thursday. I'll be watching religiously for tips :) xo

[@kayemccartney-regattieri1735]

Great video, I have the Cricut joy and im really enjoying it, ive been looking at the bigger machines and the price of the Maker original is a great price. I am only a beginner and will probably go with the original

[@christamaier66]

sehr informativ…Tausend Dank 😊

[@rodiffinger7998]

Hi, thanks for your comparison. I am going to buy the original Maker as I want to cut paper and light card to make stencils for Pyrography and Dremel woodcarving as well as cutting lightweight leather for inserts for wallets, purses and other leatherwork items. I don’t see myself using Smart vinyls etc and am happy to use mats and wait a little longer for the machine to finish cutting. You have helped me to make this decision 😊❣️

[@TheMysticWildFlower]

You're by far one of yhe best on here. Direct, essential information each time. Amd your voice doesn't annoy me.😅❤

[@ByNicola]

Great video, thank you :)

[@larryii]

Thanks for the 411, and a quick video.I will probably go with the original Maker. Thank you again. The color options do make it a lot easier to make a decision. :)

[@Esha911]

Nice, honest, and unbiased video. Being that I have the Joy since it was released and have never felt or enjoyed the benefits of using smart material, the original Maker is calling my name.

[@Tiger-fv3nl]

I love my joy. So much fun and easy to use

[@mammabear379]

I just got the Maker for $229 at Walmart definitely worth it at this price

[@sylviasid9902]

That was an excellent overview, exactly what I was looking for. Thank you. I may go with the original Maker. I have a Joy and it’s ok for small projects but very wasteful when you use the “smart” materials. I also love the white/champagne color option. Color shouldn’t be a deciding factor lol but hey, I’m a crafter so colors matter. Thank you again.

[@BloomingClayBouquet]

Thank you for the insite on both cricuts I'm definitely going to go with the original Maker 😁

[@LauraOC714]

Not enough upgrades to justify the extra cost. I love my maker and might buy another one! I craft at my friends house and hate lugging it back and forth!

[@debink944]

Thank you I think I going to Order the Maker 3.

[@donnareynolds2089]

I have Cricut Explore Air 2 for 4 years now and it's starting to misfunction, with print and cut I put my image to a size I want and jt always prints bigger then the size I choose, and last night the print and cut feature kept giving me a error message. So I will be purchasing the Maker. Thank you for this video you made my decision easy.

[@Esha911]

So I had to exchange my maker 3 birthday gift today. Only used it 3xs. Today I decided to use it and it had a red power button light that wouldn’t go away. Cricut said it’s defective. Hopefully this exchange I picked up today won’t malfunction!

[@ModelRailroadCardStock]

Great video on comparing Maker/3 features! I'm interested in if the cutting speed of 65 Lb to 110 Lb cover card stock is the same for both machines? (I don't believe white non-adhesive cardstock is available in a Smart Material). Many thanks, Sam

[@CapeFrank57]

Quick question making decals from my boat they are 3 1/2 feet long and 6 inches in height which machine will work best for my needs thank you and what a great video on the comparisons of both machines

[@rebeccakilgore6487]

Nice comparison

[@happyreality244]

I have the maker before the 3 and the only thing I want is the paper holder, with it could work with the prior makers

[@annaguevara6783]

Thank you so much. I have a explorer 2 and have invested a lot of vinyl etc.. materials. Will I be able to use them on the cricut maker3?

[@sonshinesunflower]

This is exactly what I needed to know! Thank you very much! I was actually upset when Cricut launched the Maker 3! I thought the original Maker was the LAST machine that would be updated by software & different blades! I enjoy my Maker, but I now want to add the Maker 3! Lol 🤦‍♀️🤣

[@Nina-2311]

Would you plz plz plz make a video about all the cricut maker 3 tools and blades? I'm about to get it but I am still clueless about all those tools! Thanks! 😃

[@christinahines2542]

Thanks so much, this video was very informative and exactly what I was looking for! My barely 3 year old Maker's grey rollers are constantly moving out of place. It's not under warranty so I am deciding between buying another Maker or getting the Maker 3. I have lots of regular vinyl I'd be using before I bought any Smart Vinyl (if I went with the M3). My biggest question is does the M3 improve the grey rollers life or are they at just as much risk of constantly moving out of place as the original Maker?

[@simplisticthings]

The maker is fabulous. I don't think the maker 3 has any extra appeal. It just seems more expensive.

[@marikiemarie7622]

Yup

[@crystalina369]

thank you so much

[@juliedoolin9042]

I already have the original, the smart matless cutting is so cool. But I’m satisfied with my maker and what it does.

[@dougsobel2571]

Is there any reason to get a maker 3 if I am cutting leather and fabric? the leather is fairly thin and ive been able to cut it on my Explorer Air

[@reapermontanta3280]

Amazing video:)

[@doaft1560]

How about the Cricut most useful for working with leather? What is the max. thickness the machine can handle, cut and or pass through? Have you ever used the debossing/embossing tip on dampened leather?

[@gerilynne1955]

So much to learn! Do many decisions. After listening to many videos. I decided to go with the Maker. Especially since I found a nice sale at Joanne's right now. I love the idea of faster. But I have to be realistic and say I can deal with more time. I'm not a business after all. I'm just using it for my own needs and gift giving. After investing in the Joy and seeing how much easier it was to understand the program. I decided to get the cricut Maker. I currently own a Silhouette. I rarely use it. I feel I'll use this cricut Maker much more. Thank you for explaining the differences. The video made it much easier to choose.

[@MsDstarr]

Why don't you use the silhouette?

[@gerilynne1955]

@@MsDstarr Long story short. Major Paper jam. Pull out. Now cuts 4 inches lower then its suppose. I've tried everything suggested to readjust it. No luck.

[@MsDstarr]

@@gerilynne1955 aww I'm sorry that happened to you im going to stick with the maker. Especially since I'm totally new to the cutting machine world. I hope you can find a resolution with your silhouette. 😔

[@gerilynne1955]

@@MsDstarr thanks

[@-kohakuma-]

Thanks for this video! It seems that for now, there's no real advantage to a maker 3 other than saving time with helpful shortcuts. As of now, maker 3 doesn't have any new features that really entice me to buy and replace my maker.

[@SweetRedPoppy]

Yep, it definitely won't appeal to everyone! I think if you aren't into matless cutting sticking with the Maker is a great idea. :)

[@Ines_InesLOVE]

Thanks for all reviews, I was trying to make my mind about which to buy and this was super helpful

[@CrescentMoon566]

If we r buying for the first time ?? Should I get maker 3 or 1 is enough ..

[@EdCardinal-MindThump]

Thanks! My child stole my original Maker when they moved out, and they're creating some amazing art works with it. I had considered getting a Maker 3 (and possibly swapping with them so they have the latest machine), but neither of us sees a lot of advantages in the upgrade for what we want to do. As I reflected on it, I don't cut much thicker materials like wood or leather and while I liked them I really don't need the other special tools (score, perforate, etc.). Now I'm pretty convinced I will be getting the Joy Xtra instead. Thanks for the review!

[@micheletanis9973]

I’m still not sure. Excellent video but fabric can I just set it in a maker 3 or must it still be on a mat for cutting out 2 1/2” strips or even triangles and etc.?

[@mamom3]

i saw a few reviews of comments stating the maker 3 was cutting poorly for card stock. Does it not do card stock?

[@rackleykids125]

Does the roll holder come with the machine? If not where can you get it?

[@micheledelia3107]

Thank you for this video which was very informative. Can you still use the Smart materials on a mat as you would non Smart materials ? I don’t see how the machine would know the difference. 🤔🤔🤔

[@heidicastain9552]

This was super helpful. I feel like I might have bought the wrong unit. I bought the Cricut Air 2. I haven't used it yet, after watching this I feel like before I jump in and start using it I should exchange to the Maker... Any suggestions from everyone what to do? I am a beginner and haven't used it before but the things important to me would be quick, being able to make labels, and iron on's for t-shirts/sweatshirts for the next couple years.

[@julieraesullivanhymas6763]

Fabric, what is, if any, the difference between the maker and maker 3 when cutting fabric?

[@susanschwartz2669]

I have both machines boxed sitting here. Can you use the smart material on a mat on the maker?

[@elenita1961]

Thank you, since it is my first one I decided on the original maker. I don't think I will use very much.

[@adamali3295]

thanks informative the maker is okay for me.

[@jillabigaelsmith]

Could someone explain the balsa wood use with the Maker 3 please 😃

[@JackieZCreation]

Which of these two cuts fabric faster or the same speed and thickness?

[@ronayles9050]

can the 3 cut the same material as the maker? or does it have to just the smart brand? can the 3 use a matt if choose to?

[@shanny889]

Question: I'm new to all cricut machines and I want one specifically to cut out designs with cardstock, for cardmaking and scrapbooking. What do you suggest?

[@brendatisdale9152]

Is the maker 3 quitter? Plus will it still cut faster when your cutting on a matt? Also does the maker still have rubber holders around the metal rod? Mine keep moving.

[@Jimzgirl0514]

Do you have to use cricut materials in the maker 3?

[@mrswray]

Can the maker engrave metal and cut leather? Can I use it with my iPad?

[@user-vk3hx3ur4h]

Thanks for this video appreciate it. I’m new to this world. I was wondering can you still use the mat and non smart vinyl on the maker 3.

[@SweetRedPoppy]

Yes, absolutely you can use a mat with the Cricut Maker 3.

[@lindaketner2142]

I already have the Maker and I haven’t even mastered it so I think I will stay with it lol

[@nazmulbappi7511]

I need to know. sizes different between both machine Thank you

[@sutharvj66]

Is it possible to use design space if I have no subscription to use smart materials features? Also can I use my own designs from my computer?

[@karlee3000]

There is currently only $70 in price difference in New Zealand between the maker and maker 3. Would I better off with the 3 or original maker. I am looking to do iron on transfers on clothing at first and decals for glasses and mugs etc

[@AD-ox8bv]

Hi, Will the Maker 3 cut shapes from a sheet of A2 cardboard?

[@user-ne8so4eg9h]

I'm trying to figure out what machine to get for what I want to make. I make designs in Adobe Illastrator, that i want to print out and make custom cutouts as decals. What would you suggest?

[@micheletanis9973]

Please explain the difference between smart and I guess the original material. I have not used a cricut before.

[@emmajohnson3775]

Do you have to use smart vinyl with Maker 3?

[@priklstudio]

I can see this machine does more than I need but hmmm possibilities. I would like to cut wool fabric width of fabric 8” and length 10” to 54”. But strips if 1/8 - 1/4”. Would this be able to accomplish.

[@MissMolly3377]

Very helpful video. Thank you. I think the original maker will be fine for me, unless they have a great black Friday sale. 😂

[@karinachu2036]

The Maker 3 bundle is currently $99 and Maker bundle is $86 on their website right now! Discount ends in 8 hours

[@Mimi-jg7vf]

How do you cut fabric on cricut maker 3? Can you still use a mat?

[@allieg.1656]

I would actually prefer the rotary blade with housing and the mats to come with the maker 3. I now had to buy that separately and I was really annoyed of that. I don‘t just want to use smart Materials since they don‘t sell them in store where I live you just get it online

[@SweetRedPoppy]

Why not just purchase the original Maker? You'll get it at a pretty good discount!

[@beautyfashiongoals7912]

Good to know, I'm trying to decide and this comment was awesome, thank you!!

[@biancaugolini6596]

Can normal Vinyl be used on these Machines or do you have to use the Vinyl it comes with as that will become pricey

[@kisshab4beautyfull2]

Can you crafters help me decide? I plan to make tshirts and eventually other things for my boutique, I am a beginner not sure which to choose

[@kentharris7427]

I have a Creality Falcon 2 40 Watt laser engraver and cutter. The one thing your not allowed to cut on a laser is Vinyl. It produces Chlorine gas which is very toxic. That is where the Cricut comes in. Since the Cricut does not produce heat while cutting.

[@floydc65]

I'm mostly interested in cutting leather or template plastic for leather patterns. Not sure what one would be best for me.

[@ashleysoandso861]

Original will be perfect for you.

[@Esha911]

So I opened my birthday gift on my birthday- September 11 and to my surprise my husband and 13 year old son bought me a Cricut Maker 3. So I guess I won’t be buying myself the original Cricut Maker it would make no sense, since I got a new Maker 3 for free.

[@diplayball]

Congratulations! I have the joy too and I will most likely get the Maker . Don't get me wrong if my husband got me the 3 I wouldn't complain at all 😊

[@aracelis_gonzalez]

With the regular maker can u use smart material? Regular vinyl and iron on? Can u cut faux leather?

[@ashleysoandso861]

You can use smart material but the cost isn’t worth it since it’s 3x the price as the other vinyl. But yes, yes, yes, yes and balsa wood as well.

[@melaniedevuono1671]

This is an excellent review. I wished I watched it before I purchased the Maker 3 . I'm not much of a fan of the smart materials, but I did want to upgrade from my Explore 2. In my mind it made more sense to go for the Maker3 than Explore 3. Oh well...I'm sure I'll love it anyway!

[@rig2037]

well what do you think now?

[@melaniedevuono1671]

@@rig2037 I have no issues with it. I like it a lot. It's not any faster. I haven't tried the smart materials in it. I got it for $200 so I can't complain.

[@tropicallytwisted2825]

Where did you find it for $200 please? Was that during a sale?

[@jenniferbradshaw9474]

Just curious what “smart material” is and whether the original has Bluetooth capabilities?

[@ashleysoandso861]

Smart is just that it doesn’t need a mat and the rolls are huge but 3x the cost. Original has Bluetooth.

[@opfla]

Are the mats reusable? Is it not just a protective surface so the blade can cut completely through the material?. I am new at crafting and Cricut and I am interested in making gifts like personalized coffee mugs or wood items so I think the basic maker is good enough for me to begin with.

[@ultimateyaoifangirl]

Yes they are definitely reusable!

[@ericajones3390]

Hi! I just purchased my maker. My question is if you want to do larger vinyl projects, are you able to do those on the maker, or are you limited to what fits on the size of the mat? Thanks!

[@laurentillery4957]

I would also like to know the answer to Erica Jones question from last month. I don't see a reply.

[@JazzyJae88]

I have made larger items with my original Maker. But the max with is still 12” but you can go up to 24” in length. So I just rotate my image and cut that way.

[@troyvo8069]

i still can’t decide because they’re both the same price right now on the website for $350ish. the only difference is the bundle package!

[@supatim1]

Maker 3 (I am owner) does not cut any faster when using mat, as far as I can tell cannot cut any thicker material than maker (please correct me if you know differently). I am very impressed with the print/cut feature which scans the print to confirm alignment before cut (I do not know if this is the same function for the maker). With the greatest respect please clarify 'amazing upgrades' other than a picture on the start button and a raised bit of plastic on the guide. The maker 3 can cut upto 12ft length I think that is about it.

[@marilockette]

I am looking into what machine to buy as a first time buyer but I'm not very impressed with the Maker 3. They lost me at not including some of the tools that come with the Maker. I'm disappointed the roll holder isn't compatible with the Maker but I've heard you can only use the Cricut Smart materials for matless cutting anyway. I don't like being forced to purchase only their brand, especially since I've heard their products are overpriced and not as good quality as some other brands. I'm tempted to go with the Silhouette Cameo 4 for some of the feature it has that the Maker lacks and sadly fall flat on the Maker 3. I've also heard the Silhouette software is better. My only reservation is how loud the Silhouette is. Wish there was a clearer answer. Weighing the pros and cons is driving me crazy.

[@supatim1]

@@marilockette I find the Cricut software frustrating, it tends to 'lead you by the hand' and is a bit over simplistic (Silhouette software is more flexible). I agree Circut material is overpriced, I mostly use a mat and other material. I would say the Cricut maker 3 machine is very good quality. To sum up I don't regret getting the maker 3. It is however expensive and tries to make you use Cricut materials, you can use other materials with a mat. Also the maker 3 only includes a basic blade out of the box (likely is you will have to buy the 'knife' and/or 'disk cutter' about £50 each) and a set of mats (£20) if its your first machine. It possibly depends what kind of projects you are planning to do and material you want to cut.

[@Esha911]

@@marilockette me too

[@shanditv]

@@marilockette they're driving me crazy to! I came to the comments for help but they aren't that helpful. Did you ever make a decision?

[@Grinch2002]

@@marilockette my MIL has a sillouette and she is considering a cricut now that i have one. I enjoy the simplicity of the cricut maker studio but i know some prefer the sillouette for its versatility, though that versatility comes with a bit more of a learning curve which tends to be very frustrating. Her sillouette is also VERY temperamental and decides when it does and doesn’t want to work. There’s been so many projects that went from 30 minutes to an hour worth of work. For what I wanted it for, the cricut maker is simple enough for what I need.

[@jodiemsick905]

I am asking for a circut for Christmas, a beginner at all this, and I am leaning towards the Explore Air2 or the Maker...any suggestions?

[@fionadelaney9251]

When I was researching which cricut to get I chose the maker as it cuts so much more than the air2 and I knew eventually I would want to upgrade to a maker eventually.

[@fionadelaney9251]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/pHWbmWqunMlgbMk. This video compares maker to explore.

[@SD-fn5iv]

What is mat and matless cutting? Im looking to purchase my first cricut. Can i do both mat and matless cutting with the maker 3?

[@ldwm]

Yes you can, but only with the 3

[@SharonsStuff1]

If I invest in a Maker (not 3) right now, am I likely to find the supplies and mats being discontinued in the future?

[@Pinkkermit17]

That is exactly my thought , I have a feeling that the 3 will go under faster then the original , which will make it difficult to find those supplies. I don’t think the 3 is as popular as they hoped.

[@ladys702]

I was thinking of getting the maker 3 but did cricut update the software to design bigger as well since you can print bigger on the maker3?

[@Oh_Cecilia]

Can you use cricut mat on new maker 3? I'm considering the new machine but would still like to use up all the non-smart vinyl I've purchased. Also can you use cardstock without the mat in the new machine? Hope those questions make sense. Thanks for the video!

[@SweetRedPoppy]

Yes, of course! You can still use your mats and all of the original materials. You can use smart cardstock in the new machine without the mat.

[@fairycrafter1549]

Hi. Great comparison on both machines, I am a complete beginner on Circuit, a bit concerned that it might be too complex for me though😕 from what I can make out from your video The Circuit 3 sounds like the better machine, as it has many features. I wonder if you could please tell me, dose it cut Greyboard? Also I have a few decoupage sheets, if I put them through the maker 3 will it cut out the images? (Rather then using a Craft Knife I don’t do so well with a Craft Knife.

[@jgon12]

It does cut more and precise than that maker 1 one so if you want a better cutting experience then maker 3 is better.

[@sirennoir258]

Just get the maker 3 and you will be good for the next 5 years.

[@gracieteduarte7888]

The cricut joy cuts the same kind of materials or only the "smart ones"?

[@fionadelaney9251]

The joys cuts both.. smart materials without a mat, and everything else with a mat.

[@tunaroll3957]

Awesome review thanks a lot! I’d assume Maker 3 can cut also cut thicker materials with the ability to apply much more pressure.. Maybe those materials will be gradually announced?

[@arleneaugustahair8393]

It really makes no difference.