Searching For Penny's Father! - Stardew Valley

Today we're searchign for Penny's father! Who was the brave soul that had a child with Pam? Will we eve know for sure? In a game with much depth and detail you could probably actually figure it out if you spend enough time.. Stardew Valley gameplay with my commentary as always!

[@yourcrustyramen]

Maybe Pam is actually her dad. Pam can take all 3 forms. Woman. Man. Beast.

[@sadfacekira]

You forgot form 4: Trashcan.

[@neuba2380]

5: Pale Ale

[@egeoeris]

In order to drink pale ale you must become pale ale

[@Packiechu]

Half man, half woman, half beast.

[@briasandifer210]

6: Beer

[@bizzbell7246]

So I jokingly decided to google this question....and it came up with this: So you know how there is a war going on in stardew valley? And penny seems to be the only one who likes poppy’s?poppys can signify fallen soldiers. I saw a theory that her father sadly passed away when he went off to war. It got dark real quick.

[@Naiadryade]

I've always assumed Penny likes poppies because she's making opium tea from them to escape her miserable life. Your theory is good too though.

[@Ren-wf7nu]

Strange. ConcernedApe is definitely the type of person to do that on purpose, so I wouldn't be surprised if that was correct.

[@Whydidyoudothis]

And maybe Pam started to drink after that?

[@spiritfree5050]

Yup Ken came back from that War and he still have shellshock

[@nathanricketts2415]

Think she just likes muffins lmao

[@MuttonTheDragon]

It was clearly Abraham Lincoln. There's a reason she's named Penny.

[@bertranwalker6524]

ahahah

[@omeleteazulproducoes8196]

HOLY FUUUUUK

[@melonlord4889]

Oh crap he’s right

[@cbass7283]

Thats it, im placing you under arrest.

[@Cheddarfather]

Heh

[@22lrlol36]

Penny said her dad walked out on them and Pam went into a downwards spiral.

[@Lena_M]

Can you elaborate on this? Like, when and how you can get the dialogue?

[@Ben.....]

I remember this being said at some point

[@pikagirl8224]

I've seen her say it while playing the game too. I totally forgot about it.

[@alestiiidaeno_last3075]

+Avery M. No conditions to get that dialogue; she'll just randomly mention it on some days.

[@msia7201]

It's in autumn, I believe. She'll sigh and say fall makes her sad, because it reminds her of when her father left.

[@buddyart-]

Pam ate the father

[@AuraOfANobody]

Sort of like a praying mantis....

[@lukekinder4959]

This is my theory

[@menacing_name]

Garnet or a black widow spider

[@simonixen0762]

Im dying...... BLEH

[@xydonkael9748]

Lmao

[@Girl-Supersonicboy]

*"The brave soul who mounted Pam."* omg that line XD

[@lilminus8144]

I have a theory on how it's elliott. Elliott is the only one with long enough hair besides sebastion, which age-wise wouldn't make sense, to blind themselves during the event

[@maknify4538]

bet someones gonna say " ITS A DAMN THEORY" and "r/wooosh"

[@shoddypeasant8762]

Yummy

[@sasutouzuha6238]

" ITS A DAMN THEORY" and "r/wooosh"

[@justjaein]

“aside from me that one time”

[@nellixir]

penny's father is that one skeleton you see in the intro cutscene

[@Santi-bt7if]

I thought it was Sans

[@sebastianramirezortiz3972]

@@Santi-bt7if Maybe sans is the father, and when he escaped into an alternate timeline he left them both. That's why the picture on Sans shed says there are two people you don't know.

[@veketal]

@@Santi-bt7if Pam had some bad time...

[@shadowhenge7118]

The aliEn

[@Goldfish_Brain]

@@sebastianramirezortiz3972 that is an excellent theory...A GAME THEORY!!! Please don’t take down this reply Matt patt or DF

[@CreativeWM_Personal]

Thoery Time Pam started out as a promising young lady and fell for a man she fancied, but this man was in fact an arsehole who ruined her life and trapped her in a loveless marriage. They then had a daughter called Penny who would end up living a horrible life in her early years and would retreat to the local library to get away from her abusive father, Pam obviously got a job driving the bus to get some alone time. Some time later Pam divoriced her husband but the years of abuse made her turn to drinking and the divorice left her almost penniless, hence why there is a an abandoned house in the forest that the mouse takes over. Pam then deciedes to buy a trailer so she and Penny can have somewhere to live, the result of this life made Penny shy and nervous making it hard for her to interact with people. This could explain her love for books and why she decieded to become the local teacher because school was another place where she could escape her father, this would go on to shape her into who she is today. Now then Pams habit of going to the Saloon might have stemed from her needing a place to go where she could feel safe and Gus being a good friend would obviously make sure that she can stay safe at the Saloon. Maybe he barred Pams husband from the Saloon and help her to file out the divorice papers needed to set her free.

[@alexschmitz3414]

Keith Jones that’s definitely an interesting theory. Because it’s rooted in psychology, it seems believable.

[@Julaeable]

"penniless" - teehee... Cool theory! Especially the part with the house! 😲

[@ApexBrachydios]

maybe she is poor because divorce is 50,000g?

[@Plestod]

it has possibilities with just 1 pinhole from Penny as she states in one of her dialogues that her father abandoned them

[@nerdcontrol22]

Her saying she was abandoned could be something Pam told her.

[@aaronamaphone5865]

Jas has purple hair. So is it just me or did the wizard father most of the town? Oh, Penny might be the dwarf's and Sebastian is probably Krobus's.

[@summersurock2171]

And shane has slightly purple hair too lol

[@IndependentOreo]

Her hair is black

[@raiii8506]

My theory is he has ginger hair and dyes it black-ish purple

[@crucify_then_learn3370]

Summer Surock wtaf is your profile picture....

[@crucify_then_learn3370]

OH it’s just pam’s baby picture

[@summersurock2171]

Pam shoplifted Penny from the jojamart obviously

[@Egg-d4mn3d]

"aw c'mon... That was the last Penny left, what am I supposed to do now? Buy a Harvey?!"

[@KiraraLalaYT]

Pam is Penny's father!! We should ask who is Penny's mother?

[@neuba2380]

Kirara Lala Do you make DF’s thumbnails?

[@klouise6918]

Hello thumbnail queen

[@KiraraLalaYT]

Yes i do :P

[@mr.eeggbert1340]

Hi thumbnail boiii

[@neuba2380]

Kirara Lala you do a good job!

[@mcs_drinkwater]

Gunther is obviously the father. You see back in the 80s Gunther had a mullet and some hair got into his eyes. Pam then seduced him, and since he had hair in his eyes he could not see. That was how Penny was born.

[@Spark---]

XD hell yes thats why he never appears at events, he doesn't want to see THE PAM and he makes sure he cant cut his (facial) hair so he can grow back his mullet

[@halomoment7205]

Who's Gunther again?

[@halomoment7205]

Oh wait the museum guy

[@DumbCommentary4You]

This is by far the funniest theory I've ever heard.

[@trumplostlol3007]

@@DumbCommentary4You It isn't funny. That's perhaps why Penny is always in the museum with the kids. She went there to see her own father.

[@vipanoire262]

What about Linus...? Penny says at some point her father went off and left her because he felt 'trapped'. So he escaped into wilderness, exploring his natural self, since the family didn't had any cash. He likes eating trash and is half beast, just like Pam. Also that would explain why he's always aware of keeping distance on events, he doesn't want to run into his ex-wifes hungry claws...

[@javieralejandro2155]

Penny acknowledges Linus' existence though, or else she would've pointed out that the strange man living in the wilderness looks a lot like her father

[@no-mk6vt]

Yeah, but in this dialogue: “When I was a little girl, my father abandoned us because he said he felt 'trapped'. We haven't seen him since. I'm sorry to make things uncomfortable for you... It's just that this time of year makes me think of it for some reason. Anyway... How's the farming life going?” it says they haven't seen her dad since.

[@scruffsnugg736]

Linus was actually a rich man but he felt the need to go back to nature so he donated everything he had and went to homeless mode

[@sigure.inspiration]

Linus once mentioned that heis from a rich family.

[@_something64_59]

YES she likes digging in the dirt and he’s the only one desperate enough

[@lisalegend9528]

Who is the only man that is a ginger in stardew Valley he has his own stop.... His wife cheated on him with the wizard. Pierre went to the bar once he found that out got drunk and ended up going home with Pam and that's how Penny came along.

[@emp6591]

...😶

[@aidancolan9748]

That is sort of my theory, but I have more evidence. And my story is a little different.

[@oliviaeatsoranges9386]

Elliot is also a ginger

[@ratinapillowfort]

Or it can be the other way around

[@mjolnirsoul9214]

but pierre doesn't know that Abigail isn't his child

[@rubyliciousOG]

I mean,Mumps did marry Pam at one point didnt he? Oh god..

[@thechickenmaster6543]

in my head this is cannon now

[@fletchhead938]

Head Exploded :P

[@amykluck7523]

He also had kids with her. . .

[@caitlinobrien273]

Mumps, too, is a beast

[@JamesLandry8]

Uh oh

[@jczbas]

Theory: Pam named her daughter Penny because after she pays her bar tab that's how much she has left to her name ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@zacharyestel9582]

lol

[@bariodoesrandomstuff4845]

lmao

[@jczbas]

Wow thanks for all the likes lol

[@boo8822]

Lmao

[@Saraa-go6bc]

So it always seemed weird to me that literally everyone in town either dislikes or downright hates poppies, yet it's one of Penny's favorite things. Why? Poppies are a symbol of fallen soldiers (At least in the UK and the US? Maybe elsewhere?), so maybe Penny lost someone in the war. Penny's father isn't in the story, only her alcoholic mother Pam. I mean wouldn't the loss of a husband be the kind of thing to drive a woman to alcoholism? And we know that there's a war going on, since Kent just got back. (My alternate theory is that Penny loves Poppies since she's a secret heroin addict, since addiction runs in the family.

[@no-mk6vt]

There's this dialogue, which takes away the death part, but that's still a hella solid guess. “When I was a little girl, my father abandoned us because he said he felt 'trapped'. We haven't seen him since. I'm sorry to make things uncomfortable for you... It's just that this time of year makes me think of it for some reason. Anyway... How's the farming life going?”

[@gitap7869]

Also Australia

[@elgamer_1785]

It’s kinda weird considering that the story contains info on alexs’ parents

[@Egg-d4mn3d]

@@no-mk6vt Pam could've lied to spare Penny the thought of her dad dying.

[@explosify5035]

Gus is not penny's father, its more that he treats the people who give him 50% of his profits well, If you want to know who the other 50% is its shane

[@Your-Least-Favorite-Stranger]

Linus offers non-monetary services in exchange for zucchini fritters. _I smell a connection between those greasy little squash balls_

[@wheeljack2279]

“Pam is quicker than she looks for a gorilla” “Excuse me sir, are you going to pay for those things?” These Pam jokes are cracking me up 😂😂

[@1AndOnlyMr187]

I dont think Pam is even the mother, most likely she just stole a baby from a hospital!

[@tallahriehl8220]

It was supposed to be lunch, but then everyone started congratulating her on the new baby. Not even the mighty Pam can eat that many witnesses.

[@hachi8284]

she shoplifted an infant from Joja mart

[@shibob4084]

Thats accurate

[@randomcanadianguy9740]

Im so done. Awesome

[@jedidiahcox5272]

@@tallahriehl8220 this is comedy gold lmfao

[@madmanchriss]

She drives the bus to the desert is it some one in the casino? Or maybe a monster in the caves? ( probably the monsters)

[@ophigreen2096]

Cannot be a monster, Penny is pretty human, so her other parent must be SUPER human to make up for the Pam factor.

[@yesnaja]

It could be mister Qi. I mean Penny certainly dosn't got her smartness from Pam :D

[@alexis-re4rl]

The monsters obviously fear pam

[@Kryptnyt]

@@yesnaja Just because Pam nuked all her brain cells doesn't mean she wasn't smart before she became old enough to drink illegally

[@Someone-ish]

She married a mysterious psychopath called Mr. Qi

[@A12683]

"Who the brave soul was, that mounted Pam?" Dunno, but that question really had me laughing.

[@PsychOsmosis]

Pierre's the father. His hair color is the one that looks the most like Penny's. When he learnt Caroline was cheating on him with the Wizard, he drowned his sorrows at Gus' saloon. Pam was (obviously) there, one thing led to another and Penny was conceived! Then he admitted to Caroline he had also cheated on her (without disclosing with whom) and they both agreed to pretend nothing ever happened and to never speak of both affairs ever again.

[@analien3831]

actually pierre cheated on his wife first then she did it with the wizard but then they got back together And Abigail pierre's daughter ended up being the wizard's without him noticing but who did pierre cheat with my be pam

[@idkJoey0]

Mabye Pam wasnt ugly back then. Also, she never goes to Pierres store, mabye she cant bear to see him, or she got banned for being so ugly.

[@no-mk6vt]

Nah, it says in this dialogue that they haven't seen the father since, so it can't be him. “When I was a little girl, my father abandoned us because he said he felt 'trapped'. We haven't seen him since. I'm sorry to make things uncomfortable for you... It's just that this time of year makes me think of it for some reason. Anyway... How's the farming life going?”

[@shyamsundarrajan2469]

I think Caroline is actually the witch in disguise after she and the wizard split she stole Pierre from Pam and hoodwinked everyone. The shrine of yuba is actually the witches altar

[@xxyoutubexx117]

@@no-mk6vt well maybe it's kent

[@BeyondEcho95]

"...Until the light makes her blood warm enough to move again." Omfg

[@dfhdfsagtgatwtywfhshrrsdfh29]

"I'm sorry you had to see this, kid" "I'm sorry i had to see you, ogre" *clap clap clap*

[@Lulabellexd]

When Penny said "You can dig in the dirt and find interesting things". DF: Ahh our first clue - Pam murdered Penny's father and buried him under the ground made me laugh so much😂

[@nataliateta]

Hey DF!! I commented this a few vids ago but idk if you saw it so I might as well say it again lol. Anyways i've seen people talk about this weird thing Demetrius does on I believe summer the 20th where he hides behind one of the bushes near the playground. When you see him there's just a "..." or "?" dialogue bubble above his head and I think it would be interesting if you looked into this for one of your vids!! anyways yea bye

[@wrenthdavis5174]

Very interesting. I hope this gets a better look at.

[@KuraiCross]

its just a pathing issue that occurs during summer

[@pickledspud6285]

Matt Hartt it could be but I don’t think it is. When ever someone shouldn’t be talked to they would say “Hi.” If he said “...” they probably did that on purpose. Just a thought , no hate!

[@thelegendofhuman]

Natalia Teta yeah that sounds intresting

[@Helgacabbage]

He's just studying the plant. The ? is him thinking about it.

[@jaderxby]

Linus could be Penny's dad. he met Pam when he looked through the bins and they had a child after.

[@iiSmexyMattX]

They probably fought over food first

[@addywright6429]

Pam- I wish I had a hobby. Other than hanging out at that saloon every night. Any ideas? Df- VOLCANO SPLUNKING

[@Dennis-hq8qv]

You should've searched for Penny's mother, we know who her dad is lmao.

[@klouise6918]

Too true master of DF helping mods

[@hypnoticia]

Who is it?

[@j.d2084]

U laugh at ur own joke smh

[@foxthebox5113]

@@hypnoticia Pam of course, hehe

[@hypnoticia]

@@foxthebox5113 or maybe the trash cause she trash *dab*

[@Sianistic]

Considered exploring their improved house for additional clues?

[@cymbient2972]

^^^^ this... genius

[@briankenney9528]

There is barely anything in the improved house

[@jameeblack5310]

I know this video was made a long time ago but fun fact: Penny's dad left. They don't say who he is but only in the fall season will Penny mention her dad if you're close enough to her. She says she gets emotional in the fall because that's when he dad left her and Pam. So he just realized Pam was a beast and booked it.

[@fishstix8025]

Happy Thanksgiving all you Canadians! Also I had some dialogue with penny who said her father left her and Pam saying he felt 'trapped'.

[@nathanricketts2415]

Me too, i think its on the wiki?

[@wolfplay4317]

...Thanksgiving is an American thing.

[@bib4eto656]

@@wolfplay4317 Nope, pretty sure Canadians have it as well, but on another date.

[@wolfplay4317]

@@hspt4l well than when is it?

[@wolfplay4317]

@@hspt4l well, we have one as well, so it's not really my fault...

[@connordarvall8482]

I noticed that when angered, Penny's eye colour changes. You should probably erase her memory when you divorce her, a half-Pam is still something you shouldn't trifle with.

[@Your-Least-Favorite-Stranger]

Woody Farmer and the Half-Pam Ex.

[@shutinread]

It's probably marlin since he likes to conquer beasts

[@Kamui07]

There he lost His right eye...

[@juicebox8458]

Marlon not marlin

[@2Yeonnnn]

Df as a parent: Child: dad my leg hurts.. Df: we should amputate it :) Child: * visibly scared *

[@ThisguySL]

Pam: "Don't mind that ol' dog next to the house." DF: "I'm more worried about the one inside." I'm effing dead.

[@malgai]

Pam: You got any ideas? DF: Volcano Splunking *leaves room silently*

[@ianalex9062]

Pam's motto is "If you don't shoot for the stars, you won't miss."

[@CookieMasterRBLX]

Get married on the 21st of Spring so you would be married on the day of the Flower Dance. Remember the path above the Flower Dance location behind the Wizard. Maybe you will be married there. Far fetched but it’s worth a try.

[@strongside4565]

There is actually dialogue you can get that I got recently at around 6 hearts in Fall after having seen the heart event where Penny says "my dad left because he said he felt trapped" which means he isn't one of the townsfolk and thus the theory that Penny's dad is indeed the talking bear is very solid.

[@syddyzz]

She once said to me, something like, “My dad left me and my mom, and then she started drinking more... “ It was along the lines of that!

[@danielobrien4944]

"Ah, my head." "Yeah, you should probably amputate it."

[@carlyhamilton7167]

I think Penny is probably just a kid that Pam snatched at some point to live in her trailer and do chores.

[@SasukeUchiha723]

havent started the video yet, but It obviously the bear

[@omeleteazulproducoes8196]

0:27 She doesn't *spend time* with them, she *teaches* them.

[@hexinthelilypond4213]

I have a long theory. I think her father is a demon. Since we know that Stardew Valley has religion and a god, it would make sense that there is knowledge of them. It would explain how Penny isn't a beast like Pam, because demons can shapeshift. Penny's eyes also go red in her angry portrait, and as far as I know, the only other character with red eyes when they're angry is Abigail, who is the daughter of the wizard. Penny was also born in fall, which is the month when the veil in thinnest. Her demon father came from the demon world on the first day of fall, mounted The Pam, and Penny, being demon spawn, was born the day after. Pam was too drunk to notice, naturally. Penny, strangely, has red hair, despite her mother being a brunette, probably. You could even say her hair's... fiery red. Pam probably drew the demon to herself by being the unholiest thing in town, and because she was jealous of the non alcoholics, which makes Penny a creature born of envy, thus explaining why her eyes are green. Penny also has a dialogue about finding interesting things in the dirt if you dig. You know what else in under the ground? THE UNDERWORLD. Or potatoes. She could also just be Irish or smth

[@melodyjoy_v6793]

The wizard is Penny's father. Magic is the only thing that could've handled Pam's stink cave

[@namelessqueen2949]

"I'm sorry you had to see this, kid." "I'm sorry I had to see YOU...Ogre." That one just killed me xD

[@MartialArtsCat101]

"Don't mind the dog outside" "I'm more worried about the one inside"

[@GothicTherapy]

Pam: “Have any ideas?” DF: “Volcano spelunking” Me: 😂

[@thetherrannative]

I've got the flu and I swear to Yoba if you make me cough-laugh any more at how savagely you keep trash talking Pam I might actually die.

[@nicolaim4275]

Patient zero found in the comments.

[@crabulonbestgirl9130]

Pam & Gus stand together at dance of the moonlight jellies... i ship it

[@stampedebuffalozz2024]

Omg yes gam could be the ship of the century

[@thonex8787]

too sad you missed some dialog DF in the library at 7 hearts i got Penny to say "My father left us Years ago and we have never seen him since" (not a direct quote im writing this of off memory) and i read a comment here that actually sounds kinda possible, the war that happned in stardew valley years ago and the meaning of the poppy in the victorian flower language hinting to a fallen solider. Still the poppy could just be associalted with penny becoming successfull by getting married to you :D

[@iriswing6520]

Penny actually has a line where she says that her father "felt trapped" and basically abandoned Pam and Penny. I have a feeling her father probably isn't sticking around in Pelican Town.

[@stubz6077]

Gus could be a reliable lead, he said that he “hears too much sometimes”... exiting since Pam lives in the saloon most of the time she’s bound to have spilled the beans on the father

[@joelifts6046]

Penny: I don’t want you destroying yourself! DF: I kinda do. She’s probably the only one who could defeat herself.

[@murasakirin8998]

8:28 😂I totally missed that for a second, it took a moment to finally hit me!

[@longtailenderwolf3068]

Pam is pennys father Pam just has long hair

[@neuba2380]

Longtail Enderwolf Yes

[@klouise6918]

WTF? THE REPLY IS 8 MINS AGO YET THE COMMENT IS 5!?!?! ILLUMINATI CONFIRMED!

[@plutoisaplanet1020]

And boobs

[@funduedsadventuers9174]

then who is the mother

[@stampedebuffalozz2024]

Pam is a girl

[@Rob_Thorsman]

What happens if you get Penny's 4 heart event after building Pam a house? Does that change it?

[@hollyweston602]

The wiki says that heart events in the trailer dont occur if the house is built

[@markobijuklic6007]

"urgh...my head...", " yeah, you should amputate it" Lmao

[@ChillyBupper]

Its like that south park episode where cartman tried to find his dad, except cartman is penny and his mom is pam

[@Xwarman343X]

what do you think about this: Penny was abandoned outside or in Stardew Valley at a young age and Pam adopted her; since Penny did say she lived in Stardew Valley all her life and has never left. during the heart event Pam had said putting a roof over her and clothed her. also has Pam ever referred to Penny as her daughter?

[@tdintm85]

This is like cartmans dad all over again

[@craddenali]

Yeah but it ended up being that Cartman's mom changed swapped the paper work to make it look she was the father. Spoilers It was a Denver Bronco and Scott Tennerman's father whom knocked up Ms.Cartman

[@Goldfish_Brain]

“Once you enter the realm of Pam you don’t really have any more choices with her.” I AM DYING

[@OggiLive]

Penny's father is Mr Dime. or Mr Quarter? Sorry, i'll leave.

[@MissMusicQueen101]

Tbh its Nickleback

[@asternightingale4020]

Fool, his name was Nicholas.

[@lucasezequiel6892]

Mr clean

[@WolfiEnyo]

Lol honestly df you’re great at making entertaining content out of not a lot of game. Absolutely loving it. Your sense of humor is hilarious.

[@longtailenderwolf3068]

"We need pam fixed" BF 2018

[@Wolf-E-Romeo]

Wheels was the one who first villager in stardew along with his wife, they lived a full life until they found the key to immortality. and since everyone is a snoop in this game, each person followed them to learn about this immortal life as it was suspicious they hadn't died yet. around that same time, the community center was no longer important and got forgotten over the many years. When your grandfather had learned about this secret, he refused to do it and wanted to die a natural life (or did he?). Since they are forever frozen in their age, their health can't get worse, but it can't get better, thus wheels and his wife started to look into getting electronic organs to live more comfortably, which would explain why they don't need sleep.

[@Kenfusi0n]

maybe Elliot was the father, penny has similar hair to Elliot and Elliot is a writer and penny loves reading books maybe penny knew her father was a writer and thats why she loves reading books maybe you should try interrogating Elliot don't tell me that its not suspicious that there is a writer and a library in the town and penny goes to the library to read the books

[@marsamor2039]

I remember talking to Pam in the fall season of my 1st year. She said that the fall time always makes her sad and later on she said that her father left her and her mom around that time because he felt "tied down".

[@druid_the_lizard_wizard]

I love how much shade is being thrown in this video.

[@Finalhazrd]

Penny definitely says at some point that her father left when she was still a child because he didn't want to be tied down to his family anymore. It's one of the reasons she wants to help Jas and Vincent and is so family-oriented herself, and it's why she gets upset if, during her 8-heart event in the forest, you tell her you don't want a big family tying you down either. Of course, now that I go looking for it, I can't find where or under what circumstances exactly she says this. So there's that.

[@cheetodust8051]

The way everyone in the stardew community treats Pam as some alien/creature makes it so much better

[@cora1334]

"Sorry you had to see that." "Sorry I had to see *you* " "What a nice young man."

[@CarbonKnights]

I'm from a very small town and from what I've seen in my years of heading to the local bars... Penny's father could literally be anyone drunk and desperate enough to take home the local barfly.

[@misssimmer4546]

Orange shirt on the floor… Always at the saloon… Free birthday gifts… Gus you brave brave boy

[@TheCyborgLord]

I think it's Gus because he has brown hair and blond hair makes ginger hair. OR MAYBE IT WAS MUMPS!!!

[@zacharyestel9582]

oh hell no he may date everyone but there are some lines he doesn't cross

[@cullenlatham2366]

well, you do take note of the possibility of Gus due to the related dialogue, but penny does mention the mountain, which could hint to someone from the adventurer's guild. they deal with monsters daily; if anyone can deal with pam it would be them.

[@that1guy307]

Penny is easily my favorite npc honestly

[@roscoe4943]

He’s so good at being rude while still sounding nice it’s a whole profession

[@sillygachayt]

In fall penny says it’s a tough time for her

[@kael6720]

Volcano Spelunking!! 😂😂😂 I died! Omg!

[@pyromaniac000000]

Iridium quality melons? Damn, you are one lucky guy! ;)

[@kimilini4814]

....best jab ever from DF...."can't we just....tow your home to the dump?" XDD

[@catsonbrooms]

Ok, so, merging all of the comments below, here is my theory: Pam had a child with a man, and they were married. He had to go off to war, and he died- possibly working on a ship, as Pam hates squid for some reason. However, Penny says this line that directly states what happened: "When I was a little girl, my father abandoned us because he said he felt 'trapped'. We haven't seen him since. I'm sorry to make things uncomfortable for you... It's just that this time of year makes me think of it for some reason. Anyway... How's the farming life going?"

[@iSelkiei]

I always thought penny was just sandys daughter and pam took her in since sandy didnt want her

[@neuba2380]

The bear? I guess it’s one of the deadly Pams’ species...

[@faylienfromspace]

Theory: It's Pierre. We know that Caroline cheated on Pierre and had Abigail. But why did she do that? It was because Pierre cheated on her first. She found out and wanted revenge. And who did Pierre cheat on her with? Pam of course. They're neighbours and they probably we're drunk and hooked up, and that's why Pierre doesn't really go to the saloon anymore. Pierre is also the only ginger (kind of atleast) male in Stardew Valley. Theory 2: Pam drives the bus. Maybe she had Penny with someone in Calico Desert. Like maybe someone at the casino or somewhere else.

[@TaliEpshtein]

Now that you're married to Penny you can be her 'daddy' ;)

[@coconutjam6013]

NANI!?!?!

[@alkaios_lykos]

ahahahhahha

[@emilynightray]

It was Krobus. There was one extra dark night when Pam stumbled and fell into the sewers.

[@PorkyChop-Vincee]

I Think its Gunther and I got some Proff 1.Penny is a nerd Just like Gunther :D 2.penny know there some cool stuff on the ground , maybe Gunther once told penny that there cool stuff on the ground 3.penny is somewhat a shy persona and if u dont know u cant socialor talk with him , everyone u can see in the relationship bar / menu but u cnat find Gunther , that mean u never meet him (also im using Game Logic ) 4.Gunther is not that rich and i think that one of the reason that Pam leave Gunther or pam is some what stealing Gunther Money, maybe pam just sold the gold artfiact or all of the artifact to buy beer , and the second reason might be pam driking problem but the second reason is not that strong cause maybe pam is depresed when Gunther left and then pam start to drink. 5.penny dont know who is her dad or penny just forget,cause all of penny dialog never said anything about her dad , so penny probly was a baby when Gunther left , cause there is no way that penny was still in pam belly cause if she did , she probbly have died cause of the beer that pam drinking. 6.if someone said hey gunther dont have red hair , well there is a chace that gunther relativ or pam relatic have red hair cause Red hair can skip a genaration. example , a person have red hair but there parent dont , but the granparent use to have red hair , that mean the red ahir Dna or something skip the parent generation . ( also im just assuming that penny have a red hair cause the wiki didnt tell penny hair color) 7.gunther probably teaching penny , becuse we all know pam didnt teach penny cause you know its pam Well that my theory , if u think u have nore proff comment below :D

[@lukeily8359]

I stopped playing stardew occasionally like 2 months ago but I still will watch all your intresting conspiracies and random videos

[@theresarayner5726]

So according to the thumbnail, the father is either Willy, a damn bear or Pam What about Mayor Lewis

[@thegamingmushroom1052]

DF literally predicted the 1.5 update by saying "Volcano spelunking" 8:28

[@eatskatefastass]

*chanting*Jerry! Jerry! Jerry! Jerry! Jerry! Jerry!

[@phr0ggz]

There's a Penny dialog you missed that said something like "my father said he felt trapped and left, i never seen him since then."

[@maddiemueller6363]

can you beat journey of the prairie king during Abigail's heart event just to see what she says?

[@kingwo9992]

Maddie Mueller it’s impossible the heart event finishes after level 1. Trust me I’ve tried!!!

[@maddiemueller6363]

Oh. I just suck at the game XD

[@plasmaflippy9376]

u cant beat the whole game, just the first lvl

[@snowleopard6016]

I did and nothing really happeneds

[@wynter_pisces1857]

Some dialogue I got from Penny before was "When I was a little girl, my father abandoned us because he said he felt 'trapped'. We haven't seen him since. I'm sorry to make things uncomfortable for you... It's just this time of year that makes me think of it for some reason" (You get this dialogue in the fall)

[@rogueywougey7545]

People who's father's we still dont know: 1. Penny 2. Eric Cartman 3. Tyrone

[@Amanda-hh6kg]

Wait, we now know that Eric Cartman's dad was also a ginger (Scott Tenerman's father). I now have reason to believe that Penny and Eric Cartman are siblings and are the Yin and Yang of the world.

[@Rakeshkumar-ly6gm]

Man has a great sense of humour, no wonder why his channel's name is dangerously FUNNY .