David Gilmour - Fat Old Sun (REACTION) with my wife

[@algraham5695]

Please ……do Echoes from this Gilmour show….it’s phenomenal and Ricks last performance before he passed….literally impossible to believe that humans can do such things. Amazing

[@Tbevie50]

I think it’s unfortunately too long a video. I think Andrei & Dominika have a 15 minute limit on video requests. Which is completely understandable. It is an amazing performance though. Perhaps Andrei & Dominika might have time to listen to it on their own time at some point.

[@algraham5695]

Ah, thank you. I think it’s been reacted to in that time? It’s so good they should give it a go, or as you say in their private time…

[@Jeraumina]

sans doute des plus grands chef d'oeuvre de PF, et la version "Gdansk" est absolument géniale !

[@kcrimsoniano]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/in2Zcn2Zn86dqtU I love the studio version, and with thjs videos is perfect

[@SuHo-bp1iy]

@@Tbevie50 They have other clips which go for 20-25 min, so maybe it's possible. Would love to see their reaction. It's a step up from the 70s Pompeii version.

[@geraldherrmann787]

A Gilmour-solo in pure Major key (G ((D, F, C)), no Minor sentiment involved, is an absolute exception. Wonderful.

[@mikewatts867]

Someone else may have already said this, but this is one of the, if not the first, song David ever wrote. On the studio version, he played almost every instrument himself (guitar, bass, drums, vocals). I think it was just Richard on keys. Such a beautiful song for a young man just learning his craft.

[@juanantoniohdezamaro7007]

Ese es el motivo por el cual surgió el egoísmo de water hacia Gilmour....lo veía crecer

[@roballen5718]

the version of Echoes, from this concert, is my favourite PF song. you'd love it. i love what you say about the band, too. they enjoy themselves, so much. they look at each other and smile. it's a joy just to watch them

[@vernonsmith6965]

Bueatiful comments from your heart as you listen to one of the greatest artists of all time

[@kimberlyrineer6822]

70's and 80's had so much great music, across all genres. You're such a great couple. You're like salt and pepper. He's the salt to and she's the pepper. Love from PA, in the corrupt US of A.

[@ChrisEchoes]

Great choice. From the same concert is also an amazing version of the song Echoes. You might have noticed that Rick Wright is also here on keyboards and sadly this was the last time Rick Wright ever played live ... and Gilmour has also said that he will never perform Echoes again. Also the live-set was released a week after Rick Wright had passed away. Pretty sure they didn't plan it that way but it was a very poignant thing nonetheless.

[@richardmodglin3900]

I concur. Most reactors do the original "Echos," and it's great. However, I prefer the version you picked because it's magnificent with the light show and solo's. They had all these years to hone that song to perfection. David's solo is simply incredible and very moving. The whole piece from start to finish = masterpiece.

[@julienmarquet8612]

I wait to see you reacting to the version of "Echoes", of that show, is just MAGIC....Even more, because, it was the last time David Gilmour, and Richard Wright, played it, and, sung it together, before Richard died😢They knew, Richard had a cancer (the fans, journalists, didn't knew), now we know....But, at that moment, it was like if they knew they will play it for the last time😢Listen to the discussion between the guitar, and the keyboards.....I cry all the time.....😢One of the best version, with Pompeii.....✌️Peace from France

[@davidreed1096]

Absolutely beautiful. I have a request. Please do David Gilmour ‘ There’s no way out of here.’ It is such a great song. I love your reactions.

[@antoniogiangregorio7101]

Per me questo assolo è tra i migliori di David . Fantastico.

[@thomasp.3796]

This song is from an album that was released before Dark Side Of The Moon, in the early 1970's. It is still fresh and relevant today. Pink Floyd music is timeless.

[@deanadewall8400]

Yay, my favorite song. Now do "In Any Tongue" live in Pompeii (very emotional). 60k people showed up in Gdansk just to see David, that's not counting the people who couldn't get in.

[@roostercogburn6932]

You spoke about doing a silent reaction, I watched your faces as David executed this beautiful piece, faces smiling days it all

[@maxsinnapah5754]

I love Poland and it's splendour and so much of history. I'd be wishing Poland win when they play football in the world Cup competition. God bless Poland.

[@PhilPastor]

Great reaction, guys! One of my favorite PF songs. David's solo is exquisite... of course, the high notes make you soar, but he is sooo good on the fat, low strings. Keep up the good work :)

[@Ashley4029]

Perfection

[@antmessenger7570]

Hi, I have been watching your reactions for well over a year now, but this the first time as a rather private person, that I have ever made a comment on you tube. My name is Ant (Anthony) I am 63 now, live in Derbyshire, England and been thrilled by pink floyd and latterly David Gilmour since my late teens. Your reactions are so genuine and is clear how much enjoy their unrivalled music, I literally "echo" the last person's comment pleading with you to react to "Echoes" from live in gdansk , it is very long but I know you will really enjoy it. I see the last comment was 6 months ago, so I hope you are still doing reactions, but if not I wish you both all the best and I thoroughly enjoy all your reactions so much that I had to just finally break cover!!

[@sonnymaupin9267]

So refreshing to see someone react to a song that was done BEFORE Dark Side of the Moon. Some of their best work was done in the early days.

[@angelgutierrez2415]

I really like your comments on the music of David Gilmour, I love that there are people who are sensitive enough to recognize in this God of the guitar the same thing that I have been recognizing since I was young when I discovered "The dark side of the moon" and They were forever my favorite band. You have already heard many of their songs, but the work of Pink Floyd is immense and you still have magnificent songs, for example "In Any Tongue (Live At Pompeii)" where David dazzles again with the guitar solo and where the three members of the choir whose work is worth highlighting. "Echoes", "Mother", or songs that you have already heard but that sound very different in other concerts, like "Comfortably Numb" in Pompeii, or the celestial "High Hopes" that in Gdańsk with a great orchestra sounds in a different way. very different from "Pulse" and where Gilmour also gives us a final extension of Spanish guitar that is a pure delight, although different from the one he plays in Remember That Night (Live at the Royal Albert Hall 2006), and the same thing happens with this song from "Fat Old Sun" Good David often likes to give us versions of his own songs and they all sound magnificent, that's why it's so interesting to listen to his concerts, he always surprises you with some variation in his guitar solos. I apologize if you don't understand me well, but I don't speak English, and everything is translated from Google.

[@kimberlyrineer6822]

I wish you could do one PF a day. Going through a rough time and you have NO idea how you uplift me.

[@MerchantOfAlba]

Hello there! We sent you an email! Get in touch please! Thank you for your kind words! 💚

[@Polecat54941]

David just makes people better.

[@strongestfan9823]

Echoes live in Gdańsk from this show will blow you away😢😢

[@jamesbarr2362]

Did you know he sold all his guitars last year for more than 100million dollars and then gave it all to charity what a man

[@jamesbarr2362]

@kevinbrine4223 Then i stand corrected, I know he sold his house in london last year for £3.5 million and gave the money to Crisis another charity, maybe they were talking about Pink floyd as a whole.

[@waynejones1054]

A remarkable version of his half a centuary old song. Great reaction.😊😊

[@danmustarde]

When this song is played on the radio and I'm driving, I automatically pull over and savor the moment. Atom Heart Mother is my favorite Floyd album and Fat Old Sun is one of many great songs on the B side.

[@rexpara3478]

Exactly! It's like magic happening. 😊

[@richardjones4080]

The solo in this beautiful track is so under rated it borders on criminal in my humble opinion WOW

[@BazzSelby]

Amazing! I've only heard the album version, which is much shorter. Bloody love this!

[@g0fvt]

I very much enjoy your reactions, and am rediscovering Pink Floyd myself. As an old man I have a very different perspective on it than I did as a teenager. Watching your videos is like finding Pink Floyd to another level, maybe teenage life was too busy but a lot of it went over my head at the time. Best wishes from the UK.

[@963460]

After this one comes High Hopes and Echoes. Got to do both 😊

[@jasonparsonage9122]

I got to say i just watched the albert hall remember that night thought that was good but tjis made brought tears to my eyes what a solo

[@Godard92]

Bardzo dobry, always a pleasure watching and enjoying your reactions to David Gilmour. His canon of works over the decades has the complexities and nuances of a wildflower meadow, put more simply - life enhancing. Andrei you need to purchase the DVD/Blu-Ray of this magical Gdansk concert for Dominika.

[@ShaneMccormick-d8d]

My favorite song so deep

[@kcrimsoniano]

You need to check the old floyd, you can find a lot of gems. I recommend you Mudmen, Burning Bridges, Cirrus Minor, Green is the colour, Astronomy Domine, Remember a day, A saucerful of secrets (live at pompeii), A pillow of winds... and a long etcetera I love PF, they are so unique

[@KrazyKatLadyx2]

Just never ever gets old ❤😊❤

[@robm9999]

Gilmour is magical, I totally agree! He is a master of feel, and plays so emotionally that you don’t even realize how drawn in to the moment that you almost miss just how perfect he plays. 50 years of listening to The Floyd and Gilmour still touches me very very deeply! So happy to see how you both have been so deeply affected through your Pink Floyd journey!! P.s. I often get choked up listening to Pink Floyd so you are in very very good company!

[@FadyHelou-ft2tp]

Extraordinary person full stop

[@Tbevie50]

Another beautiful reaction. Don’t worry about not always being able to find the words, your expressions and emotions say everything. I believe this was one of the first songs David wrote himself. Apparently the other members of Pink Floyd locked him in the studio and told him he couldn’t come out until he’d written something. And this was the result. He wrote and composed the entire thing, playing all the guitar parts, the bass and even the drums himself. Only getting help from Richard Wright for the keyboard parts.

[@deanadewall8400]

They didn't lock him in lol. David had already composed and written the song, but Nick and Roger weren't available on the recording date. David plays bass on more than half the albums, so that was no big deal, plus he's also good on drums too.

[@Tbevie50]

@@deanadewall8400I didn’t mean it literally lol. I can’t remember what book I read the story in. I believe it was a quote from Richard, who said the other members had to persuade David to go in the studio and try write something. I think he was lacking a bit of confidence.

[@deanadewall8400]

@@Tbevie50 I can't remember the names of PF books I've read either. Except the latest one "Comfortably Numb" in which it says PF was notorious for wasting time in the studio, but instead would go home with an idea and create it there, then come back and work on it in studio with the others. David did lack confidence in the early yrs. mainly for taking over his friend Syd's job and not knowing where the band is heading, since he was mainly into rock, blues and folk music. Lot's of interviews with David on here, where u learn more than just reading the books.

[@KNOPFLERSGOD]

Your right, you don't always need lyrics, especially if you have the talent of David Gilmour, you should listen to Mike Oldfield for an example of not needing lyrics.

[@robm9999]

BTW, his fellow PF bandmate Rick Wright joined him on this performance, so you had half of The Floyd were present on this PF song! Loved your reaction and love this song very very much!! One of my fav PF songs!

[@kennethkeith7336]

This is the greatest guitar solo of all time

[@jchost331]

Boujour, je suis d'accord avec la dame moi aussi a une époque, je n'ai pas su apprécier leur talent. Je pense ne pas avoir eu une maturité suffisante quand j'étais jeune. Mais maintenant j'adore et hélas je ne pourrai pas les voir en concert. Cordialement

[@ripleyenmordor828]

Hello.. you have already reacted to some of the most popular Pink Floyd songs. Here I leave you some suggestion. "One of these days", brilliant madness (Pulse version). "Then i close my eyes" (version Remember that night), exquisite sensitivity. And "Echoes" (Live in Gdansk version), all impressive, with a few last minutes Wright/Gilmour of absolute perfection. Thank you, and greetings from Spain.

[@ericsandi6619]

You guys rock! ❤

[@markferrett700]

Please,please try to do a reaction to David Gilmore live in Gdansk (The Blue)....it will leave you mesmerised......a song about the ocean that makes feel literally like your floating through the sea.......the most amazing controlled sustain on guitar I have ever heard........amazing stuff.

[@craigbourbonevans]

they already have

[@markferrett700]

@@craigbourbonevans thanks......I'm new to the channel... Should have done my research👍👍

[@craigbourbonevans]

@@markferrett700 great song..i prefer the royal Albert hall version with Crosby and nash on backing vocals ..both excellent but with solos a little different

[@dalemcmillan7231]

Love it ❤

[@rarebond8102]

The Nile song... Very early very Heavy!

[@marcosodin464]

Show👏👏👏

[@Jeraumina]

je me demandais quand quelqu'un allait vous conseiller ce petit bijou, écrit en 1970 pour le très original album "atom heart mother" ,; encore un album chef d'oeuvre

[@glenmorris6539]

As usual a great in depth spot on reaction !! Please please react to the mother of all guitar solo’s ! Comfortably numb in Pompeii.!!!!🙏

[@berndwolfram451]

I need this on vinyl ....very very expensive........

[@vernonsmith6965]

List to the track murder live at Hammersmith

[@miniwobil7652]

please check the album more. the album, which is finally a movie soundtrack, also features fat old sun. there are beautiful songs like summer 68, cimbaline, green is the color etc. very sensitive pieces, i love them

[@mikewatts867]

I think you may be confusing More (which was a sountrack) and Atom Heart Mother (which was not) but they did come out just a few months apart.

[@jim5247]

This is Syd Barret song that Dave plays as a tribute. a lot asking for "Echoes" Gdansk" being to long. Play the first part ( 13 minutes) which is a 2 part song > First is about the anti- empathy in the human race. Part 2 start with a passage of time where man has empathy for one another. The end is Dave and Rick talking to each. Almost a goodbye as this was their last concert with Rick passing. Maybe able do it in 2 parts.

[@deanadewall8400]

This song has nothing to do with Syd.

[@davehagi9883]

The Floyd as a group, and individually, will always take you to places in your soul you never knew you had, it does´nt matter when you discovered them, the Beauty is, that you have, I will happily buy you both a coffee....Peace.

[@sonnymaupin9267]

Here's an older one you might enjoy. Gilmore nails his part and I love the work Wright does toward the end kzbin.info/www/bejne/oJbGemquodelo8k

[@ianfortier6796]

Great song! Great version of an OLD Floyd classic. As much as I love this version, the version from Remember That Night is the best due to the solo, IMO. Gdansk = 9/10, RTN = 15/10. Hopefully you give that a listen on your own time, if not in a reaction video.

[@davegilbertson4907]

Has never received the attention it should have. Controversial statement but I think it's my favorite Floyd/Gilmore song

[@miniwobil7652]

you are both very cool and i love your reaction. they are full of human feelings, it is very beautiful. with pink floyd, it is important to note that pink floyd is not david gilmour. Most of the tracks, and this is the case with Fat Old Sun, are the result of collaborations between David, Roger and Rick. it is often forgotten that the lyrics were written by roger from the late 60s until he left the band. he is a brilliant songwriter. and many melodies were refined through the influence of rick. Pink floyd thrived on the creative tension between these three extraordinary people. but of course David is simply the best guitarist forever, no question about 😊

[@deanadewall8400]

David wrote this song and the lyrics.

[@sonnymaupin9267]

@@deanadewall8400 More than that, he played the bass and the drums, only getting help from Wright. This guy is flat out wrong tryng to minimize Gilmore's influence. It was David who refined the melodies specially on the songs he sang. Gilmore said in an interview that Waters was a great lyricist, but wasnt very musical. Gilmore was a major influene on Floyd's sound and he and Wright worked together the most when it came to the musical side of PF

[@deanadewall8400]

@@sonnymaupin9267 I completely agree.

[@antoniogiangregorio7101]

Dave la tua chitarra parla

[@podcuts_0]

2016 is better

[@roydagger]

The song should be called Boring Old Sun. I'm so glad Pink Floyd moved away from this hippie, pastoral, sleepy style of music. Roger's direction and anger were much needed.