DEAR RAZOR - PLEASE CONSIDER THIS

[@SoCalDreaming87]

Well articulated, Mark! I am a Bok fan, but this is what our rivalry with the amazing ABs is all about. Nail-biting, epic tests! I was at the game yesterday, and the atmosphere was so intense. Jozi was buzzing all week. I look forward to Cape Town. Let's hope it is as intense as yesterday. Much love and respect, mate.

[@misternatural1338]

No, controversy surrounds it. The bokka are coming to realize a cruel reality and that is they are not evolving. Lost every part of the game and played soccer all night until we lost a prop and only then, did the bokka make any moves(in the forwards)

[@mybadgaming6786]

I agree with you but the New Zealand public is very hard on the All Blacks when they loose and I think Razor is to scared to make bold changes because the standard of the All Blacks to win every game is too high. Rassie wants to win everything but do not mind loosing games as long as we build squad depth for the next RWC. And the best way to do it is against the best teams in the world like the AB's.

[@wernerkruger9709]

As a Springbok supporter there's two things that matter to us...1st to win the World Cup the 2nd to beat the All Blacks the rest is just a bonus ...think about it and I think coming back to your point Mark dont worry about winning every game build get the depth going.. the AB's will always be the bench mark for the Boks and the Boks supporter we have too much respect for you.

[@frasermilne7801]

Correct Mark, The Abs are afraid of losing, as jobs will will be on the line. That's unfair on the coaching team Depth matter, forfeit some games to get there. Who knows what you will find. Rassie has found it all. World Rugby needs a strong AB side.

[@MrMarkdaub]

My biggest take on what Rassie has done with the Boks over last few years, apart from the technical stuff, is he's built a family. A trust and belief in one another. Sure we are blessed with depth in talent, but these guys will die for eachother. It's not a squad of individuals. Blood brothers.

[@MarkWilliams-ce2gd]

The defining moment of Saturdays game was the crazy options Rassie allowed the Springboks the freedom to make mistakes while playing enterprising rugby.

[@robertmariu6783]

Stop getting on the wrong side of the referee .Don't rate Ofa. Need a running , kicking half back . Ardie is too small for 8 .

[@99waylon]

@@robertmariu6783 Everyone knows Ardie is too small, except the All Blacks selectors

[@zwet4269]

@@robertmariu6783 I think it was deliberate for TJ to not run, TJ usually does run with the ball

[@MichaelShaw-n4c]

The defining moment was the propensity for the ABs subs to give away dumb penalties. Boks bench superior, closed it out.

[@99waylon]

@@MichaelShaw-n4c 14-5 penalty count, says it all. That is the only thing contributing to the loss.

[@South_Affy]

To be fair Rassie said Sasha has been followed from U15, U17 U19. SA Schools and Baby Boks… and then put into games with tier 2 teams and then tier 1. Definitely there has been a gradual gradient.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@CC-om8ze absolutely right. Thank you for the comment

[@boeksieb749]

@CC-om8ze agreed but Rassie has set-up this development programme and it's been going for about 15 years and that's the way it needs to be done. You need to develop from early on and we are fortunate with our schools system and the development plan that Rassie has set-up.👌🏻🇿🇦🇿🇦

[@randomlyfactual1943]

You're talking about performance tracking. Yep, it's really cool. So imagine being able to go into a room and find out what the Bok team would look like in five years. Or even ten. So now you see oops, my number 7 is going to be old in two years time, who can I start so long? Boom, already a guy in the system, right there waiting. Ireland basically started this system and they arguably have the most efficient one (it's easy to be efficient when you have less names) but the Boks have a very good system in their own right.

[@kirtap2601]

Hi Mark, I have been following Springbok -All Black test series since 1949. South Africa dominated in the amateur era and NZ have dominated thus far in the professional era. The Springboks are now much more competitive. I enjoy and respect your views. Thank you.

[@JamesBarnard-et2fd]

As an Bokke Fan in S.A....Because of YOU....I am having more and more RESPECT for N.Z. Fans...So nice to hear your views of this GREAT GAME....THANK YOU.

[@influential_leadership]

@@JamesBarnard-et2fd it is 'a Bokke fan' ...

[@nzfreeski]

Honestly, we're usually so chill and humble, ignore the trolls. I think you'd agree Mark Keohane/Moiney man can also put NZers off your folks too , unfairly:-). Great win, congrats!

[@vicetsebeth2187]

​@@influential_leadership English is not his first language....

[@Won_By_One]

I think Rassie has successfully pioneered a Bomb Squad where players coming off the bench actually feel their role is crucial to winning the game. In most Test Nations the bench players feel they're not good enough. Rassie has turned that on its head. The Boks bench guys are proud to come on and finish the game.

[@kappiekapp3294]

You got it spot on. You are one of a kind. Be safe

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thank you. We are all one of a kind.

[@shaneelbachoo2480]

Mark, you are one of the most unbiased, respectful and knowledgeable pundits in the business. Thank you for making a positive contribution to the game and the rugby fraternity. Shaneel Bachoo from SA. 😊

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@shaneelbachoo2480 and you sir are one of the nicest supporters who has been following me for a while, so respect right back to you. Thank you so much for your contribution, this helps me move forward more with this channel and my goal of bringing rugby to more.

[@andrewlowry2142]

Can we please stop with the Springbok brutality comments. Did you see Sia's face, and who dunnit.

[@DrissZyani-bu5mo]

1 Time vs how many times by boks ( speciality) !

[@theroogie]

@@DrissZyani-bu5mothat should have been another Sam Cane red card

[@Keepitsimple183]

Ask the TMO.. play on..😅

[@janevanreenen8768]

True

[@misternatural1338]

No impact for bokka they were back to being subs. Every bokka that went off was because he was beat up. The boys smashed that brutality nonsense.

[@davidoliver9886]

Mark thank you for your balanced and insightful commentary of what is happening in the rugby world. Stay blessed.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thank you for the kind words

[@johnharris4474]

Hi Mark , The All Blacks rose to the occasion , played good football........be good to see Richie Mounga orchestrating the backline best wishes John

[@insiderugbywithmark]

They did John and they weren't far away. Richie would make a difference wouldn't he.

[@SampoLapilill]

Frankly, Mark, there isn't anything in your advice that I could disagree with. Of course, Razor Robertson has to prioritize rebuilding the All Blacks for the next World Cup but he also has to put out a team that can win matches in the here and now. That unbeatable aura that has become the very persona of the ABs cannot be lost. Razor now has to decide which positions need changing as a priority for the next match in Cape Town. He cannot afford to lose both matches in this championship. That's my two pennies worth!

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@SampoLapilill my friend, thank you for your thoughtful comment as always. If I may, I feel the ABs have already lost their unbeatable aura, some time ago in fact. And on the point about winning here and now, I bet if he told the chiefs at NZR , look lads, we might lose a few games now but we will win the world cup I know what they might choose.

[@adalderson6269]

Thanks for the great video Mark. In my opinion Beauden Barrett is NZ's best number 10, that's where he started his career and I believe that's his best position. Kwagga grew up on a farm, he can probably put a fence with his bare hands. From a power to weight ratio perspective he is probably the strongest player on the park 😁. The difference between the boks from the past and this particular squad is belief. The Boks now belief they can win every match and not hope they would that has been the case previously. Continue making this great content!!

[@anthonyturner5319]

@@adalderson6269 best off the bench last 20, he was pretty avg the whole game extremely school boy mistakes with kicking 2 out on full, one into touch just before half time hooter that the springboks got a line out then penalty with. Then 2 chip kicks to no one in the last 2 mins, did the same against Argentina when at 10,

[@bokudesu3280]

Beauden had an ordinary kicking game which is fundamental to being a top tier 10. No thanks.

[@TW-mc9wk]

I think Razor is between a rock and a hard place. He wants to please the unforgiving NZ public by showing he has a winning team, yet by doing so he’s compromising the development of the squad. Your analysis is 100% correct. Let’s swallow our pride and elevate our strategy to the World Cup. Other nations are !

[@davidfife-nm7uy]

Razor doesn’t want to please the public. As the great Jack Gibson said” if you listen to the fans, you’ll soon be sitting in the stands with them”. Razor is way smarter than you people give him credit for

[@bokudesu3280]

​@davidfife-nm7uy he hasn't shown he is very smart so far, more likely he has looked a bit out of his depth.

[@marcovanrooyen9530]

Hi Mark, you're spot on with your view. I agree to take out Rieko Ioane and Jodie Barrett. Similarly, Ardie Savea to flank and Sotutu to number eight. Why the All Blacks keep on playing guys out of specialist positions, puzzles me. I understand the notion that the coach wants guys to play two positions but here's my take on it. Frank Bunce and Walter Little then came to Ma A Nonu and Conrad Smith, SB Williams with Ryan Crotty. These guys were specialists in their positions. Razor didn't play Will Jordan at fullback at the Crusaders. McKenzie is not the option at first five eight and I agree with you that Perenara should play from the bench. Too many mistakes, and slow distribution. Jordie Barrett started at Full Back, then shifted to wing, and now he is at centre. Reiko Ioane had got plenty of time on centre now it's time to give ALB with Billy Proctor a chance.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@marcovanrooyen9530 Hola, thanks so much for your sharing. I get boths sides of the discussion. Stick with loyalty hoping that these guys evolve, or switch out and try new options. I am a ¨try new thing¨kinda guy.

[@frankvsnschalkwyk6030]

I agree, may we need a total revamp, we use to focus on spesific position Cullen was 15 mostly, going to center destroid him. ARDIE 7 BRING IN SOTUTU, KEEP SITITI, TRY GET N LAUMAPE BACK

[@seanpinkey8798]

Spot on Mark! I agree- the ABs need to experiment with different combinations & yes,TJ is past his best as a scrumhalf! Razor needs to be bold & try different options in the backline.The bigger picture is RWC 27 & the ABs will build towards that.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@seanpinkey8798 thank you for sharing.

[@barneyboy2008]

We have roigard coming back from injury.

[@garyprobert8579]

Fully agree with You .Mark with regards to players starting for the All Black's.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thank you kindly for the comment

[@SeanLarkan]

Elephant in the room for ABs & Wallabies is (lower?) standard now of the Super rugby vs URC & Champions/Challenge cup.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Appears to be so, yes. Thank you for the comment

[@maakstemdik007]

Looking at it as a South African, I think the AB coach is still busy finding his feet. I think he is an awesome coach and proved himself at the Crusaders, he now needs to up his game at a national level. The AB's have always been dangerous and any game against the AB's is a challenge that sets the bar very high, the AB's are always a force to be reckoned with and can never be taken lightly.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@maakstemdik007 thanks for the great comment. Absolutely agree, that Razor needs time, and by the end of the 2024 Rugby Championship we should see the impact, and also his philosophy when it comes to selection etc.

[@bokudesu3280]

Hi Mark, Great post here mate. Too much loyalty for average performance atm. 💯 agree with Ratima, Plummer, ALB & Proctor. Also cannot understand why Razor doesn't use Ardie at 7, Sititti 8 and Blackadder 6. Would be a pretty dynamic loose forward trio. Keep up the good work 👏

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thanks for the comment and the kindness. Great to have you on board.

[@dariankrieger4813]

I agree with you I would like to see Billy in a t 12 a bit more.Cortez should also start more.But I believe there is 2 sides to this story.Yes we will be experimenting and building players but think of the pressure this team and Razor would be under if they should lose games more often.

[@jameslovering9158]

I think they progressed and are moving in the right direction, so close and thats good enough at this stage. I wouldn't like to see any changes TBH, let them have another run, possibly only the bench and move to a 6-2.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Ok great comment thanks for sharing your view.

[@allblacks9100]

I agree with you Mrark , some of the selections made by Razor has baffled me. The ABs are predicable , the likes of TJ perena and mckenzie should not be starting .... we need Ratima,Darry ,Wallace siti, Billy Proctor and ruben love in the starting line up , ....start to blending in the young talent . I'm worried about thea autumn series and to be honest i can't see this ABs team beating the likes of Ireland ,France and England . I've seen very little progress under razor . Let's not forget Peter Lakai ..i like to see him get a chance in autumn.

[@EbrahimLarney-u2u]

Hi Mark, firstly congrats on your content & more importantly, the tone of your blog. As a Bok supporter from Cape Town & more generally, a supporter of this fantastic game of rugby, I cannot agree with you more. Rugby needs individual teams to constantly evolve without necessarily compromising respective identities & playing styles. Rugby needs tier 1, 2 & 3 nations to adept & evolve & if this means international coaches to take a leaf or 2 from other innovative coaching teams, then so it should be. With Sincere Respect Ebrahim Cape Town

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Ebrahim thank you so much for your generous comment. It's brilliant to have people like you supporting the channel. That's why I do this. The global rugby community is awesome.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Ebrahim thank you so much for your generous comment. It's brilliant to have people like you supporting the channel. That's why I do this. The global rugby community is awesome.

[@ianshotter1508]

I definitely agree with your analysis and suggestions. Still want to see a win next week though.

[@emmanuelnyahwa5869]

Great insights!

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thank you

[@kekemamoe3106]

Well said Mark, love the channel. Keep em coming!

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@kekemamoe3106 thank you kindly, will do.

[@ferdielekay8401]

Great insight! Agree, the bigger picture is crucial... Springboks won despite numerous errors at critical times of the match! Imagine if the execution of the Bok plan was better... Scary thought!

[@JL-vo9oi]

Correct, but not only that, imagine the Springboks have zero injuries!

[@DavidSmith-yi8ou]

True, however the ABs could make a similar argument. Improve discipline by 50% and that goes a long way of removing much of the pressure applied yesterday.

[@PieterGildenhuys]

@@JL-vo9oi unrealistic yes?

[@antongreyling3386]

You have got an incredible rugby brain, Sir. As a South African, I can only hope that Razor ignores you.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@antongreyling3386 thank you kind sir, and rest assured, Razor wont know a thing about me.

[@sbok9481]

@@antongreyling3386 🤣🤣🤣 Great comments.

[@ungarr]

As an AB’s fan so do I

[@duaneheath757]

Hi Mark, great channel. What is of interest to me as an historian is that there is now, as there was in the distant past, the situation/dynamic where you had young All Blacks players playing in South Africa for the first time in their lives - and at Ellis Park, to boot. A true baptism of fire which didn’t occur in the Super Rugby era when all players facing the Boks would have played in the Republic on countless occasions. It certainly provides Razor with the opportunity to see just who has it at this level, although the learning curve for some players may be high. Such intrigue and so many subplots created by SA’s move north and their regular action against the best northern club sides. NZ is a victim of time zones as much as anything: they understandably cannot select overseas-based players because their domestic game would collapse. Bringing the stars back isn’t as easy as just money, as young players go overseas for myriad reasons and have always done so. Rugby at the top end has never been so intriguing in the 40+ years I have been following the game, and that is wonderful to see. Bring on Cape Town - scene of so many historic SA-NZ clashes over the past 100 years. We as fans are truly blessed to be able to live through this golden era.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Loved this comment. Thank you for taking the time to write it. I wholeheartedly agree with your sentiments.

[@mata2nz]

Very sensible Mark.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Some think so , others not. 😊 Thanks for the comment

[@truthfinder7064]

Mark, my personal opinion is that the NZ bench should have more of an impact. SA's bench not only makes a physical difference, but mentally as well. To bring in 5 massive solid new forwards just after half time, certainly gives you an advantage.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@truthfinder7064 thanks so much for sharing your view. I stated in the video that the bench needs to be decisive and make an impact, you dont always need size to do that, its skills, creativity, and execution.

[@truthfinder7064]

@@insiderugbywithmark Agree, like Kwagga Smith

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@truthfinder7064 100% yes.

[@FinelliDybeen-tk7dt]

Agree with your comments. If you are not prepared to risk and allow new players to grow in the game and positions you will never grow your game.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thanks for the comment

[@taorostrickland8759]

Hi Mark, I love your passion for rugby and your rugby talk. Keep up the awesome work. Take care. Adios for now :-) P.s. personally I can't wait for when these players will play against the Boks in the future, Wallace Satiti, Hoskins Sotutu, Peter Lakai, Cortez Ratima, Billy Proctor, Ruben Love. Peace out

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thanks so much for your support. Yes I can't wait either I think they should be given a go now. Anyways, let's see. Keep enjoying the game

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thanks so much for your support. Yes I can't wait either I think they should be given a go now. Anyways, let's see. Keep enjoying the game

[@peterthompson2124]

I agree well said

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thank you

[@myshepspud1]

Thanks for the post Mark. :). 🇿🇦

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@myshepspud1 thank you

[@ContendformyFaith]

@@insiderugbywithmark I agree 👍.

[@SaintKastro]

I think Rieko is the best option at 13. Once he moved to wing , springboks started to open them up in the midfield. Riekos is able to leave a big gap between him and the wingers when playing centre , because his speed can close gaps quickly. He has probably the worse attack outve all our centres , but I’d pick defense over attack if I’m picking a 13 for ABS

[@Haddaminb]

I agree that Billy Proctor should be playing. Jordy Barrett is so rock solid however in the carry and defence, coupled with the fact he is Vice captain, means he will never be moved. Like your idea of Plummer instead of Dmac at 1st five. Would be deflating to Dmac to go back to the bench as it would Beaudy Barrett too. Tosi would be a good bench player to add impact. So too Xavier Numia who is not in the squad. Yet.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

If you want to be the best team on the world then you need to select the best players in the right positions. There feelings should never come into it. Thanks so much for your comment

[@eyeofrage7025]

I agree about Razor picking players that won't be around next year. I'm afraid I have to disagree with your selections I think Will Jordan needs to be starting with FB with BB fighting Ruben Love for off-the-bench impact, I believe Tosi needs to replace Newell on the bench. Procter outside Barret is a good combination that already has time together. We need to stop playing three 7's, Ardie is the 7 with next in line off the bench, Dogroll (Scott Barrett) is 6 , and give Sotutu a crack. Cam Roigard is the best number 9 in New Zealand. Thanks for the Vid Bro

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Love the disagreement. Well done, I like what you shared. Don't agree with all, but like it. Rubén Love at 10

[@dhirshg]

All we have heard since last year, from fans mostly, was how Razor is the ultimate savior and will go unbeaten in his first year lol. Anyway, great channel.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@dhirshg first off, thanks so much for being a subscriber to my channel for one year, truly appreciate it. Some fans said that, definitely not me. A huge step up to the big boys game from Super Rugby and we will see how it goes, early days still.

[@Icosindaba]

I agree, fear of failure can be debilitating. As in law and in life generally failure is far more instructive than success. That seems to be why Rassie is so good. Not because he loses. He doesnt. But he learns from success, instead of resting on his laurels. Cant wait for the next match to see how much Razor and Rassie have learned respectively, from the last match. Just hope the officiating doesnt become the main talking point again.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Good comment well said. On the last point I don't get into ref stuff on the channel for obvious reasons.

[@claudenewbury1347]

Dear Mark, thank you for your insights and your invariably fair commentary on the games and players that you speak about. This is in welcome and stark contrast to the predominant hubris and even shameful bias of some prominent NZ commentators - some of whom are ex-All Backs themselves - who resolutely maintain 6/6 vision in criticising refereeing decisions that happen to go against the All Blacks, but who maintain averted gazes from occasions of studied infringements and dangerous play inflicted by the All Blacks on their opponents. In this, they do great disservice to the superlative NZ rugby players and teams of the past as well as to many of the present players and teams. There is a Scottish saying attributed to Robbie Burns that goes, "O that the Lord the gift would gee us, to see ourselves as others see us". These few well-intentioned thoughts are from a South African who, as a teenager was privileged to see the many truly great All Black players and gentlemen in Fred Allen's magnificent team in South Africa in 1949, and who now notes the increasing tendency of some South African commentators to speak and behave in this regrettable manner, sometimes using uncouth and even obscene language in doing so! Ever in my mind's eye, as if it happened yesterday, I see the superlative tackling, positional and kicking play of the incomparable Bob Scott, the All Black full-back at Ellis Park in 1949. Renowned Springbok No. 8 Hennie Muller described Bob, (RIP), as "Altogether, the greatest footballer I’ve ever played against in any position". For a man now 89 years old, who still loves rugby, the contrast between the behaviour and words of so many contemporary players and commentators compared with those of the past is bitterly disappointing. "Let not the winning be your only aim, it also matters how you play the game".

[@insiderugbywithmark]

All I can say to this is , fantastic thank you so much for sharing. My Grandad used to love Fred Allen and spoke of him all of the time. I hope I am doing as well as you at your age. Keep enjoying your rugby, it is still a great game, different on and off the field yes, but still great.

[@EugeneHuman-kl1vc]

Enjoying the Weekly chat, much appreciated. When i first looked at the try from Bongi Mbonambi i also thought it was lost, but the ref was right there and seen the Infringement from Jordy and awarded the try. You can rewatch it in slowmotion afterwards. IRB Law 11.5b. section 5. The ball is not knocked-on, and play continues. A. a player knocks the ball forward immediately after an opponent has kicked (like chargedown). B. a player rips or knocks the ball from an opponent and the ball goes forward from the opponents hand or arm. Jordy definitely has a hand in there causing the rip or dislodge. So try stands due to that rule. Was a hard old game. Can't wait for the Capetown game.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@EugeneHuman-kl1vc thank you for the comment

[@didintlekodisang1836]

Although I agree with you on most parts, especially about the inside centre situation which has been an issue since smith and nonu retired. I also agree with you about TJ, just doesn’t seem like it makes sense to have him there especially starting. I also think it’s easier for Rassie to experiment and do the things he’s doing, the Springboks have won back to back world cups and his job isn’t even close to being in danger, he will basically leave when he wants so the pressure is a bit different. I actually think for me where they went wrong yesterday was basics, receiving kicks after kick off, after scoring points, they still can’t get exit properly from their own half. I don’t know why Jordie with the big boot isn’t kicking more as well. Then 3rd, too much aimless kicking, with no one competing. If they can work on those then I think they could be a bit better

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@didintlekodisang1836 thank you for the comment. You actually raise a really good point. Maybe Scott R should had told NZ Rugby during his interview time that this is the way I am going to do it, build and grow depth, we might have some loses, do you want me or not. Rather than the traditional Kiwi philosophy, we must win every game,. Doesnt work any more, world rugby is different IMHO. You have to have two teams of equal ability.

[@rugby_stat]

As Bok man who admires NZ rugby I expect to see Plummer and Sititi back in. Finau and ALB were a waste of space this test.

[@jaxuys]

Echoing sentiments; great feedback.

[@greatshark9625]

No Mark, we as the Boks don’t mind NZ carrying on as they are and only looking forward to the next game. We don’t want a well prepared and rounded NZ squad in what will in essence be a RWC in their backyard. We are happy with there being a huge gap between their best and next best player.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@greatshark9625 ha ha, no ones going to listen to me, so you are safe. Thanks for the comment

[@jamesveltman9533]

Hi Mark. Good thoughts. Totallyy agree with Proctor at centre and Plumber at 1st 5.Why? Simply because they are both naturals in their positions and that is what Ibelieve we need to focas on. Example would be MoUnga is a natural 1st 5, BB and McKenzie are not. Play people in their natural positions!

[@insiderugbywithmark]

I hear you, thanks so much for the comment

[@stephengjgreen-mlloy2229]

Hi Mark, totally agree with you. Really enjoy your channel. I am a Kiwi living in the UK and now see the domestic game up here as superior. Is it inevitable that we will have to select players from up here, I mean to be the best surely you have to play the best.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@stephengjgreen-mlloy2229 Hola Kiwi in the UK, I hope is all well over there. Great point you raise and the mentality of to be the best you have to play the best, and you also need to select the best.

[@jameshartzenberg5763]

Thanx for rugby insight. I would like to to some new players in certain positions as you said. For exsposure and dept building towards the bigger goal yes. 6:2 spit going forward. I don't agree with benching a player thats playing well during a game. Upcoming bench players doesn't necessarily deliver with regards to what needs to be done. The bomb squad impacted the game yes but the game was lost ... kick of blunders , breakdown turnovers , last 20 minutes game discipline and game management.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Here here, thank you for the comment

[@valescodevries1]

Thaaaank you finally someone agree with having plummer 😀

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Absolutely why not try him out.

[@hartley9958]

Well analyzed the problem we have is that Razor has a lot of talking heads in the coaching team that have a lot of differing thoughts and theres already been conflicts, and thats how solutions go astray, i'm a big Dmac supporter but hes not a game director i myself would sooner have Harry Plummer there also hes more of a Grant Fox type with a bit more X factor...

[@thudeshreenaidoo3330]

Wow, interesting comments Mark. Definitely food for thought! 😮 I agree with most comments but for 1. The AB can’t win if they play like demons for first 40 minutes and then get defensive in the following. Herein lies the problem. They honestly need to find the right balance of power play and tactical play and defensive play and concentration. They tend to lose focus towards the end of a game. They get bored/fall asleep/lose intensity. Thank you for a great video 👏🏽 From a die- hard Springbok fan 🇿🇦🌈😍 But love the AB too! And love rugby most!!! ❤️

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@thudeshreenaidoo3330 awesome comment thank you for making it. I apologize if my opinion was not so clear. If you watch the All Blacks game strategy against the Boks last year at Mt Smart Stadium in the Rugby Championships you will see clearly what I mean. They put the game beyond the boks by half time, negating to some extent the impact of the Bomb Squad. Protecting a lead can be done in several ways, its not about closing shop and going to sleep, its about playing smart, keep playing rugby but the risk reward decisions can be lower. Hope that helps to clarify what I was trying to say.

[@Haddaminb]

The fact they have already had Hoskings Sotutu in the ABs already to have a look at, then not having him make the squad again is telling maybe?

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thanks so much for the comment. Perhaps yes. We will see how things change as ai suspect they will thru the Rugby Championship. After next weekend's game I suspect Razor and crew will assess things before the Aussie games

[@KowieCoetzee]

Nice listen to u on your channel..u always give positive and true feedback I’m from SA and I’m respect the all blacks sins my early years..if u don’t play the all blacks u never no ur strength and abilities great program the all blacks never ever send not a strong team..!!💪🏻💪🏻 thanks

[@paddyshanahan3950]

Hi mark, hope you are doing well! definitely get what you’re saying. And agree with some players needing to change, especially the no. 13 Jersey. Personally I think that when it comes to no. 9, I don’t think Cortez has played well at all in the last few test matches. Making crucial eras time and time again (there were definitely a few in this last test.) the momentum has also changed when Cortez comes on, and not in a good way. And because we really need to stop thinking of just the starting 15 and instead the whole 23 man squad, if Cortez isn’t fulling his role and changing the game for the better upping the tempo and helping swinging direction to abs favour attack wise not making those mistakes) then I would personally feel uncomfortable putting him at 9. If he wants razor to put him at 9, he needs to first be the best 21 he can be. I totally think razor would do that and have a change in 9 if Roigard was fit. As all blacks fans I think we need to be patient and wait for Roigard to come back and start lighting up the attack, we saw last year how lethal Mckensey and Roigard are together. So for me Tj is good for now (and did you see how much quicker his service was this week?) until Roigard comes back. And hot take, let’s get Hotham and Love on the bench. As there are 2 route you can take I believe on the bench, Experience, or youthful energy (or both). I don’t think we currently have either. So if we’re missing experience let’s get some energy!

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thanks for sharing an alternative view. It was nice to read your thoughts. Thank you for taking the time to make the comment

[@leonderecha]

Wow. I just found this channel. Really insightful comments. Thanks from a Springboks supporter!

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@leonderecha welcome, I hope you stick around and I hope I can earn the right to your subscription.

[@leonderecha]

@@insiderugbywithmark you got it!

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@leonderecha awesome thank you

[@sbok9481]

Spot on, Mark. But remember, Dr Rassie knows that success is built on more than 1 pillar. Yes, selecting specialists in their positions but also have a few players that can cover multiple positions. Next pillar is to have the right coaching staff. Get experience. Get the best. Get members that buys into your vision as head-coach. Dr Rassie got Tony Brown. Tony knows Rassie's work ethics. Tony knows SA because he played in SA Curry Cup. Another pillar is mutual trust between coaches and players. Select 4 flyhalfs and give them equal play-time to test them on biggest stage. With pressure off players, they perform at their best. Great discussion.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@sbok9481 excellent comment, thank you for making it. May I add. The two coaches are at opposite ends of the spectrum when it comes to their careers with their national sides. Razor is starting from zero essentially, he lost Mo´unga, Smith, Whitelock and Retallick to start with. Incredible stars to be replace. Rassie is building off an incredible foundation. Re-leaving Leon Mac Donald of his duties was Razor saying to all, its my way or the highway.

[@myshepspud1]

He got Brown now, but though they now a winning coaching staff don't think Deon Davids was the best. Stick had zero coaching experience but atleast knows the ethos as a blitzbok.

[@deanharmse5126]

For quite some time, I thought the AB's had the Boks' number. The AB's were brilliant. It was evident that they did their homework and targeted the weaknesses in the Springbok game plan, which can be predictable. The Bok comeback was brilliant, but if they are going to let the AB's run in 4 tries again next week, I don't think they'll get away with it again.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thanks for the comment let's see what happens. 6 tries would be better right 😮

[@lionelannandale8153]

You are so spot on.. I am a Bok supporter in SA but have Family in Christchurch and love AB rugby and very updated with your game have friend working for Cantabery rugby(Gaza) AB need to use the oversee based players to bolster the bench and need to use younger players Like SA are doing That said,Rasor is new in his role..give hime time

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@lionelannandale8153 great comment, thank you. One thing, yes, give Razor time, this is not a vote against him, its a discussion on a KZbin channel to see what everyones opinion is because we love rugby.

[@DavidSmith-yi8ou]

You hit the nail on the head mate. NZs selection policy is hamstringing them.

[@barneyboy2008]

​@@DavidSmith-yi8ou we would lose all our players if we open up to overseas based selections. We don't have the option of playing in Europe.

[@DavidSmith-yi8ou]

@@barneyboy2008 I don’t think we’d lose all of them. Perhaps something like the what Aussies do. 60+ tests and you can play overseas while remaining eligible for the ABs. Just something that’s different to the status quo because what we have now is not fit for purpose. Unless you want to prioritise Super Rugby over International rugby results that is.

[@gihanilangakoon]

Mark, this is an informative and objective analysis. Why not do another to Rassie? Tell him what more he should do 😊

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@gihanilangakoon thanks for your comment. My opinion is rather than copy Rassie, learn from how Ireland and SA have evolved and take learnings from there, but do it the Kiwi way, if that makes sense.

[@andradelucio2125]

I think we should play to our own strengths. The AB coaching staff should be able to review clips of the game to find pragmatic solutions. Mark you have valid suggestions too.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@andradelucio2125 thanks so much for the comment. I am sure that the de briefs are very detailed after each game.

[@MarcWithersea]

Interesting to hear your thoughts from that side of the fence, thanks Mark. Long-time watcher from SA. Cheers mate.

[@rekoawa5732]

Totally agree with everything you said Mark. Can't fault a thing. Give Razor a call mate.!!!

[@InezFrancis-l7c]

Mark Razor needs to address the lack of discipline when defending in the red zone,referees are onto Nz tricks in this area.

[@janevanreenen8768]

They are… at last!

[@glennharris6352]

Nz gives penaltys in their red zone. Not right. 3 points vs 7 points. The refs havd to check it. 😢😢

[@alandavis5295]

Hi every one I just want to say that I think both NZ and South Africa fans are crazy about their teams and don't like them loosing. Mark thanks for your bringing us inside rugby. You I believe have nailed it on what changes should be made.

[@antslim168]

Great insights into NZ rugby from Joburg

[@jacquesbrits5822]

NZ need to bleed in new players, and fast....in Razor I believe you have the right man for the job....I've been thinking that this AB side dont have the players to topple the world right now...as a Bok fan, I'm a little disappointed in our overall performance on Saturday....

[@99waylon]

Well said Mark. We have 2 far better-attacking halfbacks, that should start over TJ. My backline; 15 Jordan 14 Telea 13 ALB 12 J Barett 11 Clarke 10 B Barret 9 Ratama. Loose forward 8 Sotutu 7 Savea 6 Finau. We could look at injecting really big men from the bench when all are available, like Williams, Pasilio Tosi, Sititi and Taukei'aho. Razor selections this year are really puzzling. We have a disadvantage compared to the other countries in the world and that is that we can't pick our top players as some are overseas. If we could pick all players, we would have Aaron Smith, Brodie Retallick, Shannon Frizell, Richie Mo'unga etc etc. Also, Peter Lakai should be in the squad or even coming off the bench. He is a superstar in the making

[@peterbritz620]

I agree with you. Well analyzed. Thanks

[@burn6580]

Well said!👏👏

[@maori_brotha]

We are in the beginning of a RWC cycle. There is no mystery to the ABs attack. We like width and the edges. We need our forwards to carry hard, pass quick and tackle harder. We need to train our kickers to be deadly accurate. Razor and team are doing fine with a bunch of newbies, not the biggest pack in the world, a developing first five, a skillful but elderly fullback, and firepower on the edges. The Bok reserves had more than 450 caps between them. We did well against a huge pack, and a blind ref! Noone gave us a chance at Ellis. The Boks will take the win but know they were lucky. This is a 14 game season. If we can win 11 games, it's brilliant. But my prediction is still 10 wins. The top 5 teams can all beat each other on their day! We are on track to build the top team. But it won't be easy!

[@KBkbkbkbxyz]

For the past 5 years the AB'S have had the the best 10 in the world, in Bauden Barret, but have rarely used him there.

[@mthunziphakathi4215]

@@KBkbkbkbxyz Richie M is a better 10, BB is great as an impact player. He is also good at 10 but not better than Richie.

[@troymomma]

Bauden played 10 in second half against pumas, what a disaster

[@markreilly105]

@@mthunziphakathi4215 We don't have Richie and what happens if he is injured in Japan? We need backup 10's.

[@davidr5597]

Totally agree with ya. Bigger picture and more growth of new players is critical. Right now, the ABs have a solid 12 - 13 players. They need to build out the quality of the whole 30+ man squad. I totally agree with your statements around the backline and particularly 9, 10, 12 & 13. Tactical kicking also needs to improve drastically. Blind hoofing down the field straight to the opposition back 3 just doesn't work anymore.

[@pierrejoubert7195]

Fortune favours the bold and that was proven Saturday.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Nicely put. Thank you for the comment

[@Andrewpc2023]

Wise words Mark. The mighty All Blacks are coming and Razor would be very foolish to take his eye off the bigger picture.

[@jimmyjames1807]

not so mighty with a 2 losses outa 5 games, fozzy had a better win/loss ratio , remember razor is supposed to to the saviour for nz rugby, to busy moaning about the ref's

[@Bergz01]

Sure the Bomb squad is effective but i believe that Quagga Smith is the outstanding weapon... unrivalled on the playing field.

[@EyesuponJesusministries]

As a bok fan thanks Mark for the even handed analysis

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@the.place.of.refuge Hola Bok fan, thank you

[@christiandemarino8895]

What a fantastic game, lived up to the hype for sure. I think if the AB would have kicked for 3, it might have changed the outcome.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@christiandemarino8895 first up, thanks so much for recently subscribing to the channel. Appreciate it.

[@WonsonBotha]

Hi Mark your annalizes of the game are excellent it is well documented. #rugby wins

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@user-lm7sf6of6r first off, thanks so much for subscribing recently. And yes, rugby wins

[@TheBuildKingR]

Hello Mark, as always I agree with your observations, now, as well as the game yesterday. As you know, like you, I'm not a fan of TJ and McKenzie, however I do think that Tele'a is one of the best wings and they should make place for him. That said, it seems to me Razor is scared to take big chances, he persists with players that should not be there, he could've easily played a 6-2 bence and have an extra fresh forward to help with that onslaught late in the game, but no. This coming weekend, he'll probably play the same guys, or 80/90% of them and will probably win. Rassie already said he'll make some changes when he was on the park after the game and come world cup time, all those players will have 30+ caps and these pressure game experiences with a plug and play scenario. The weekend, Razor brought on his bench when it was too late and to put inexperienced players in a situation where there's that amount of pressure was crazy. A lot of people had good things to say about the ABs the weekend even though they lost, however I'm finding it hard to do so. They've lost the 2 games against SA and I think they were desperate to not make it 3. Yes, everyone said that was not a try of Bongi, and I agree but I don't think it would've changed the outcome. Barrett for example could've easily received a red card for that upright tackle on Kolisi as it made head contact and he will probably be out for a bit, the ref missed that too. If NZ win or lose the weekend, Razor should consider making big changes with current starters on the bench against Australia for both games. He has a difficult tour in November and I'm sure Ireland and England will want to prove a point. Ireland especially given the world cup.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@TheBuildKingR great comment, thanks for the share. The loss was great for New Zealand has long as they learn from it. IMHO. Cape Town and beyond,

[@Leon-lp9fl]

Who forced the change in the Super series, taking us out? THE WORST THING EVER. Seems you are paying fore it. Which it get fixed. You an the Aussies need proper exposure before enrolled.... To fix your bewilderment in tests when things turn against you. How do you ID your youngsters without exposing your youngsters against ZA teams as well. You are 100% correct. Thanks.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@Leon-lp9fl thank you for the comment, appreciate it.

[@GeraldMoses-tl3jz]

Hey Mark, I have to say as Springboks South African. You make great points on your suggestions big up 👍

[@kirinnahna1284]

Cheers mate. Love your channel and your thoughts 😊

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Thank you so so much for the support, really appreciate it

[@andradelucio2125]

Does it help training with reffing staff who can call out any issues with discipline within the squad?

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@andradelucio2125 dont fact check me on this, but I believe this is done on some occasions. Thanks for the great comment

[@CraigAlderson-h1j]

Hi Mark as a kiwi fan in Malaysia been enjoying your posts. I agree with your sentiments in part. Would love to see Savea at 7, Proctor at 13 (Jordie had a good game) and Jordan at 15 (although is he in form?). Totally agree with Kwagga impact. Does NZ need a real fetcher too for the last 20-30? Someone like a Billy Harmon would make a great impact player. Bench really needs to be uplifted and i would go for Tamati, Amua, Newell, Vaai and Sititi off the bench with Perenera, Beudean and Reiko in the backs. Maybe last 20 have Barrett at 6 Savea 7 and Sititi 8 unless Blackadder can do 80

[@Orion3741]

Taking into account that rugby union is a contact sport, each player should wear a scrum cap ( head guard ). No player should experience a head injury, which could be fatal.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Awareness around this issue is really important. Thanks so much for sharing your view.

[@Orion3741]

@@insiderugbywithmark : it is with great concern and alarm to read of the death of 7 minors, due to brain trauma. All 7 died within a single month ( August 2024 ), while playing tackle football ( aka gridiron or American football ). There have been renewed calls from the public to improve safety in that sport discipline. Condolences to the families affected.

[@Keepitsimple183]

Absolutely I reckon we need to change it up and now is the time for the ABs to rise above it they need to understand and so do the AB's supporter base that we need to not fear change accept that while we could loose games... start bringing in players like Proctor outside Jordie or Jordie outside Proctor... Also give Tosi a crack from this point on coming of the bench... fussi is a liability late in the game... I thought Razor reckoned with Ryan it was love at first sight a forward coach's Dream when they selected Tosi....They need to find a way to start scoring points Late in the game like a drop goal expert just pot them over to keep the scoreboard ticking over or even through out the game ... yeah Boi no more stupid yellow card's and giving the opposition an opportunity to get back in... Having said that full credit to the World Champion Springbok can't wait for game 2 in South Africa... Ten points was never going to be enough to hold em out...

[@jaspermalan3640]

I feel Scott is a intelligent coach, he is building this AB team.you never ever write off the boys in black, it is not easy building a team, and people should support the coach and not breaking him down, it is still early days.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@jaspermalan3640 , thanks so much for the comment. No one (here) is breaking Scott down. As has been the case for over 100 years of rugby, the arm chair coaches all have an opinion, and in this safe and respectful place we can share it. Its all in love of the game.

[@bokudesu3280]

Razor is elegant? Maybe at breakdancing.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Chuckle

[@jaspermalan3640]

@insiderugbywithmark I feel give Razor 6 months more and everybody upset and laughing now is gonna cry when the All Blacks run out, his team selection for the second test was spot on, and pushing the boks so close in South Africa is already so positive

[@Cruzader80]

Id quite like to see selectors put more emphasis on the ability for long exit kicks. James Lowe would have been an asset to the ABs for his long range boot. Granted he might not be as dangerous as some other NZ outside backs. I think Zarn Sullivan looks promising in this respect.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Good point thanks for making it.

[@kirinnahna1284]

Also, love your work mate. Cheers. Kirin

[@markreilly105]

Hi Mark, I agree with what you say. Before the 1st England Squad was picked, I chose a 23 which I got a bit of flack for. Especially as I chose Reiko, but I can see how him and Jordie are limiting our backline. This is the team I would chose. Currently I am looking at a 6/2 bench 1 De Groot 2 Taylor 3 Lomax 4 Tuipoloto 5 Darry 6 Blackadder 7 Lakai 8 Sotutu - (current squad I would chose Sititi) 9 Ratima 10 Plummer 11 Clarke 12 ALB 13 Procter (I had Reiko) 14 Jordan 15 Perofetta if he doesn't work then Love 16 Aumua 17 Williams 18 Tosi 19 Barrett 20 Savea 21 Papali'i 22 Hotham (had Perenara but he's off to Japan) 23 Barrett

[@EddieDeTe]

In line with your thinking, my view is that the game outcome has more to do with what the AB’s did, and not so much the bomb squad. AB was really good for 60 min, then faded?

[@insiderugbywithmark]

@EddieDeTe A number of factors, I am not saying it was one thing, poor kicking decisions, poor game management at time, discipline and the bomb squad all had an impact I believe.

[@barneyboy2008]

Razor said sotutu doesn't work well on both sides of the ball.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Ok then I hope it's something he is working on.

[@ShanePleasance]

Yeah, I realised I am one of those that expects us to win every game. Every game! Would I sacrifice that for losing the World Cup again? No. I know what I want, and it's more games such as this, but where we win. Am I asking for too much? You bet.

[@insiderugbywithmark]

Ha ha great comment. They say the first step in changing is realizing where you currently are at, so you know sir.

[@presterjohn4123]

New Zealand lack intimidating centres. Think past combinations. Conrad Smith and Ma'a Nonu (who in their right mind would want to face Nonu at centre), Bunce and Little, Aaron Mauger/Tana Umaga, all formidable and dangerous combinations. Barrett and Ioana are great players but I have a feeling the Boks look at just ‘managing’ them rather than ‘fearing’ them. Of course, with the All Black forwards not, at the moment, dominating opposition packs maybe I’m being a bit unfair to the two incumbent centres. Ioana is powerful but Barrett, to me is not a centre. Great player as full back.

[@jerryb6323]

Mark I could not agree more I was surprised that the All blacks team is actually older than the Boks they are not bringing any new young talent.....This Boks team will get better next week....win or loose...there seems to be too much fear of failure in the Abs which can be a weakness....