Defining the Philippine policy on Sabah

[@mommymoonishi5540]

Who’s watching now February 2022,I loved this kind of conversation and professor Carlos is really bright

[@daniloordonez2213]

999999oo9 999⁹99⁹9999⁹⁹9⁹9⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹99999⁹9999⁹99999

[@daniloordonez2213]

9⁹99⁹⁹⁹this 9999999⁹⁹9⁹⁹9999⁹⁹9⁹9⁹⁹9⁹99999999⁹9

[@brianmayabella5992]

Agreed

[@brianmayabella5992]

@Hope Lope how u know all about this?

[@brianmayabella5992]

@Hope Lope tis true, tis true. History is what every official would read. So that their present would be guided. In the end, this is a matter of strength (military might). Indian - Chinese border really displayed the stand off. Other than that, bigger nation slowly creeping out to smaller nation.

[@lynmarpambid608]

Very well said Dr. Clarita Carlos. Ang Bansa natin Pilipinas ay kailangan Ng magaling na katulad mo. Sana may puesto ka sa Isa sa mataas na puesta sa Pilipinas or maybe consultant and advisers .❤️🙏👍

[@tesslecheluxuriesandtravels]

Now ur wish granted .nayional security adviser

[@ReynaldoDeGuzmanhagibis]

Please pay the lease agreement while our Muslim brothers are waiting for peaceful resolution

[@nanettecuauhtli5866]

NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER. WOW DR. CLARITA CARLOS WILL DO A LOT OF GREAT THINGS FOR THE NEW ADMINISTRATION PRESIDENT BBM.

[@brucelim5155]

wow! bright tlga c prof carlos.... keep it up.... stay healthy po

[@orlandocastromayor9641]

P09u

[@alexyabut1851]

Dr, Carlos , I am your #1 Fan !! I wish all the best madam, I will be following you, id like to witness your success..

[@roniearenga482]

akoy' Lahing Pilipino tubong Mindanao,may karapatan kaming ang aming claim sa Sabah dahil sa aming salinlahi kanila yan.tunay na pinakinabangan nyo nang ilang siglo kaya nararapat na ibalik naman sa aming Pilipino ang sa amin.may hangganan ang lahat nang bagay.pls.lang Malasia sauli nyo na Sabah!!!... ang sa amin ay amin.mabuhay ang Pilipinas

[@susanbugayong946]

True that's is ours pilipino land. God bless our new elect president bong bong marcos.

[@eelchiong6709]

@@susanbugayong946 Are the two of you Tausugs? Remember that Sabah was the personal property of the Sultan of Sulu, given to him by the Sultan of Brunai in payment for services rendered. Even if by a miracle Malaysia returned it to us. It would still be the private property of the sultan, and by extention, of the muslim Tausug tribe. Philippine land it might be, but private property.

[@shakinajoyvrich1286]

Well Said! Bakit ba inangkin nang Malaysia ang Sabah...na hinde nman pala sa kanila yan? It means they are grabbing and stealing the island....! Both Philippines and Malaysia have to show their proof of title the land of Island PERIOD!! Something fishy in the middle.....

[@eelchiong6709]

@@shakinajoyvrich1286 Bakit? Simple lang. Pinili ng mamamayan ng Sabah maging bahagi ng Malaysia. Grasya na yan kaya di tinanggi ng Malaysia. Di mo rin masisi ang mga taga-Sabah dahil muslim sila at ayaw nila mapasa-ilalim ng mga kristiyanong pinoy gaya ng kapalaran ng mga kamag-anak nilang Tausug ng Jolo at Sulu.

[@carlosuyat1839]

@@eelchiong6709 di lang po kristiano ang namumuno sa pinas kasama po dyan ang muslim basta pilipino pwede mamuno

[@jacobrason3708]

DR.CLARITA CARLOS IS THE EPITOME OF CLASSICAL KNOWLEDGE OF PHILIPPINE GOVERNMENT HISTORY

[@jamillansangan260]

Tsiduhd ate estroiord. In Islam thatd jihad... dont Malik they claiming is helping to them just give assistance tllhese people.

[@dextersings3944]

Well doesn’t matter if it wasn’t clear before but now we are more unified and the message is clear...both parties will have to submit to a more modern political negotiations.

[@josephgador238]

Agreement that was done in 1878 between sultanate of SULU/British north Borneo Company must be respected and it simply shows SABAH is ours basing on historical facts

[@mayaasan3605]

Dr Carlos, claiming sabah will weaken your government claim on spratly. like kiram, china also claims based on first sighting. What Malaysia did that is effective presence and governance is far more valid, and native sabahans chose to join Malaysia officially in 1962.

[@fidelsosa2335]

Maraming salamat Prof. Carlos, you are always reasonable. Lets continue to protect Filipino interests! North Borneo is part of the Sulu and Sulu is part of the Philippines!

[@brianmayabella5992]

Diplomacy is by means of Strength. If hindi ma enforce yung claim, malimutan yan. Ang deciding factor, what is the stand of Sulu. Are they pro Malysia or Philippines. Mahintulad yan sa Taiwan or Hongkong. Kung gusto mag solo yung Sultan of Sulu, goodluck. Kainin sila sa pressure of Malaysia and/or Philippines.

[@celestinovelarde9601]

@@brianmayabella5992 Ang malinaw diyan ay itinaturnover ni súltan Kiram ; ito ay ipinapaubaya na Sà Philippines Ang claims, ayusin Problema! Para sà people of mus lim sulu, Mindanao ,regalo ito sà Kay sultan,

[@brianmayabella5992]

@@celestinovelarde9601 pag ganun. Enforcement nlng kulang pala. Next , sa election nlng. If u know what i mean.

[@andrewlim9345]

As a former Malaysian, it was interesting to hear the Filipino perspective. Not many Malaysians have been exposed to the Filipino and Sulu perspectives. The trouble boils down to conflicting translations of the 1878 deed agreement between the Sultanate of Sulu and the British North Borneo Company. Need for dialogue between both sides. Perhaps international mediation and a referendum. Rights of Filipino migrants in Sabah also need to be respected. Perhaps a pathway to residency and citizenship?

[@antondelacruz9362]

Its been years since i read about this issue but iirc: As explained by prof carlos, the documents favor the philippine claim, which is why Malaysia has no interest in confronting the issue in an international court. It makes no sense that malaysia still continues to pay money to the heirs of the original filipino owners, unless it is actually rent money rather than a purchase. Sabah was given to malaysia when the colonizers left, even though they technically had no authority to do so. The philippines is the country which wanted dialogue while malaysia never did. The predecessor of asean never got off the ground because malaysia refused to join the body if it included the philippines. Iirc, forming asean included the caveat of the philippines not bringing up the sabah issue. Hence there are multiple reasons that the philippines claim is stronger, and why malaysia will never discuss the legitimacy of its claim in any significant depth.

[@leonelgamboa7365]

Deceitful is the word for stealing!

[@dong_ilconte9504]

The Spanish arbiter has finally ruled that the 1878 deed of agreement is void and that Sabah belongs to the Sulu Sultanate, and by extension to the Philippines.

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

​​@@dong_ilconte9504, you meant "Gonzalo Stampa"? His appointment as Arbitrator had been annulled by Spanish judicial authority. And his arbitration which was filed in Paris Court had been annulled. Latest news in 2023: 1. June 6th. - Paris Court of Appeal had set aside and annulled the previous Paris Court (lower court) ruling awarding the heirs of the defunct Sulu Sultanate. 2. June 27yh. - Dutch Court of Appeal had dismissed a bid by eight descendants of former Sultan of Sulu to enforce the arbitration award by Paris Court (lower court) ruling and dismissed an attempt to seize Malaysian assets following the Paris Court of Appeal decision. Mean while in Luxembourg, a second attempt to seize Malaysian Petronas assets had been filed by Sulus after the first attempt had been stayed. This too will likely be dismissed following the Paris Court of Appeal decision.

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

​@@dong_ilconte9504, (continue) 3. Paris Court of Appeal also imposed €100,000.00 (Euro currency) on Sulu to be paid to Malaysia as legal cost.

[@felixanabo6468]

Thank you Professor Carlos for pressing the issue and giving us clarity to it.

[@achillesmeltar]

Now that arbitaration recognized the claims of the heirs. I'm expecting that Dr. Clarita will advise the president to pursue the claims on Sabah as part of the philippine territory and sovereignty over the land

[@carolinabarobalmaceda]

God bless Teodoro Locsin who has the courage, guts, the balls to declare and to claim Sabah openly as belonging to the Philippines, not Malaysia which repatriated a large number of Muslims even during this covid-19 pandemic. They were all taken care of and nourished back to health by Zamboanga City before returning to Basilan, Sulu, and Tawi-Tawi. It's really best If Malaysia contends with our Nation as a whole and not just with a small number of claimants. That country has not respected the Sultanate, and has only used our people for their own benefit. God bless the Philippines!

[@celestinovelarde9601]

No respect to pilipínó Sultan kiram! And people of ! pH ,

[@celestinovelarde9601]

Malaysia has denied sultan kiram's Property! Which had donated to Philippines Government, they have No respect!

[@eelchiong6709]

Might makes Right. Remember that. All Locsin did was talk. Anyone can talk. What really takes guts is to fight for your right. Are we filipinos ready to fight and die? You know the answer to that. Do you expect the UN and America to fight and die for us? Were they able to make Israel give up Palestine? Or China to give up Tibet? Nope. So what makes you think they can force Malaysia? Only we can do it. But will we?

[@celestinovelarde9601]

@Hope Lope what I had have was Based only to what I read ; sorry, po! Hit it to authority! Not me ,

[@jamillansangan260]

Why this gov. Nonoy swuimo just let s lot of sultanate soldier ler him die battle with Malaysian gov . Coz he is if it. Sabah had minerals has.. a coward pres. Aquino He font know nothing.. help kitam dultsmaye of sulu. My wife family they both on Sabah till their last breath is there . Gov. Male buildings dapat to put the diplomats. Embassy.. too. Pit a person that you can trust..

[@felixrivera3249]

Walang makaki at mabigat n problema s mamayang nagkakaisa. Magtulungan po tayong lahat s pag bawi ng Sabah.

[@vicsagala7896]

Takot sa gera ang bawat namuno ng pilipinas ksi magastos ang gera ksi kung papasok sa gera ang pilipinas walana makurakot ang mga mandorugas sa governo yan ang totoo

[@user-jj1br3co8z]

☝*SABAH is for SULU & MINDANAO and must be always included in the Phililppines territory and jurisduction...* Malaysia may peacefully rent the territory that belongs to the Philippines but still the Filipinos Government must take a strong stand & rule on this renting issue of Malaysia...

[@dannyboy6847]

it is 2020 now, 5 years since 2015, sabah is still in malaysia. You keep on following your trash sulu ancestors in claiming sabah, how long untill you realise you have no more shame. carry on people of sabah dont even want to be filipinos. lmao

[@Justin00704]

One of the problem is that the Philippine government does not spread the historical evidences...

[@maharlika7049]

The government is literally slappin it to Malaysia and there just like "talk to the hand". The fact that there still paying the sultanate of sulu is the reminder that they don't own Sabah and the real owners are the ones that the SOL has given the piece of land to

[@itskalboofficial1217]

Thanks SMNI. Nakilala ko Dr.Carlos

[@maymella7821]

A brilliant professor... Prof. Clarita Carlos... 🇵🇭👍🏼

[@dioscorocencil6536]

Dr. Carlos... I really like your brilliance. Your wisdom is unfathomable.

[@adongdeveyra4857]

The malaysian government surely will not just drop their claim on sabah whatever arbitration decision is rendered. What is then the govt stand on the sabah?

[@donoragonvlog641]

Now that you are in the best position in the Government Dr. Carlos its time to reclaim North Borneo.

[@arcee11]

It's good to look back and watch these videos while now in 2022, the french arbitrartion court ordered Malaysian government to pay the heirs of Sulu Sultanate.

[@Prototaloy]

IMO the UN referendum supersedes all historical claims by the Sultanate of Sulu. This situation reminds me of Saddam Hussein, who invades Kuwait on the basis of an ancient document showing it as a province of Iraq. However, the vast majority of Kuwaitis oppose the annexation of their tiny nation to Iraq. And with US military help, Hussein’s forces get kicked out of Kuwait. To permanently resolve the Sabah issue, I suppose another referendum can be held, which I believe will yield the same result

[@sanorsandayjul4898]

this matter..samething it happening in between.. if in case..that Malaysia want to Claim back Singapore Island based on Historical..is that make sane..let us analsis the latest 3 time Agreement after 1987 that made by sultan of Solo..an authorish that North Borneo is Hand over to the Governor Bristish of North Borneo..and Why Sultan of Solo did not made an Negosiation with Presiden republik of Philipine in time of Bristish Colonial withdrawal..like the time of Bristish withdrawal and Hand Over Hongkong..in 1997

[@loidanellas9257]

Probably.

[@robertgabuna355]

Amina Rasul and Dr Claire and Dr Baja should join hands to do devoted studies over Sabah funded by gov't and find ways how to resolve the lingering issue.

[@zhadrockrodriguez9659]

sa pilipinas ang sabah paalisin na ang mga malaysian dyan idaan sa tamang proseso kng hindi kaya sa tamang proseso _ _ _ nlng hehe ubusan ng lahi ! volunteer ako hahawak ako machine gun parehas lng tayo maliit na bansa kaya walang angasan hindi mag papatalo ang pilipinas kng sa malaysia lng naman malaysian ang nagpapasasa sa yaman ng sabah tayo ano ? nganga..

[@giovannivicente7462]

Ako taga hawak ng bala ng machine gun. Hahaha

[@pagtalunanlouiepana.8105]

Mga Pilipino yun, nag change lang ng nationality kase mahirap yung sultanato at mayaman yung Malaysia. #Traydor

[@arnolddrdc]

Sabah is not for Philippines nor Malaysia! Kiram grandfathers is just a ruler fooled by the British with Brilliant mind and Character! If I am the UN I will give this to Sabahans only!

[@MarkRamirezNepa]

British is in Europe not in Asia okay

[@kaypeebreeze1550]

i just love what she says" it was LEGAL indeed... MHASHALLAH

[@honoriopascual8351]

Dr.Clarita Carlos is right to what the Philippine Goverment do based on the UP scholars and other Researchers.

[@LUMADSAMATI]

I like this intellectual discussion! As per Dr. Clarita Carlos of the UP: I laughed at 16:40-17:10 If you have a sinister mind, alam mo na ang sagot dyan. I love it....

[@marcelinobarcial5951]

Fight to claims sabah this belongs to the Philippines.

[@myou41]

you go to hill. sabah are our sabahan own. stupid pinoy

[@giovannivicente7462]

@@myou41 we go to war!!!

[@rondoponce770]

I will raise my hat and vow my head to you Mam ...you give the enlightenment to all Filipinos who know nothing about the Sabah issue...

[@SilverHawkFightClub]

Actually all old agreements are void automatically after a referendum was conducted in Sabah in 1963 and the result of the Cobbold Commission was accepted by the UN. The voice of Sabahans must be respected by all parties. Do u know China is using 500-year old map during the Ming Dynasty to claim that Spratly Islands are theirs? Do you accept 400 or 500 years old archives are relevant to today's world? The Sulu Sultan is pestering on an old story to make claim on Sabah is ridiculous and unsound.

[@ricardoaquinocarrasco1534]

Professor Carlos Iam one of your fans here in USA. Doc Rick

[@SilverHawkFightClub]

The Sulu Sultan was making claim that Sabah is their territory based on an agreement signed between the Sulu Sultan and Baron de Overbeck. Making claim without direct control on the land is like u claim the moon is yours. Also, there was no written document to prove the Brunei Sultan ceded Sabah to Sulu Sultan. Its high time for both goverment to form a high level commitee consisting of international historians to study the new evidences from the Brunei Sultanate and other archives. (continue)

[@randymontenegro3269]

You are kidding, right? There are documents of such that even Malaysia admits it. The big question is: who gave the British the right give away someone’s territory/property to one of their slaves.

[@cyrocruz3088]

Kulang ka sa kaalaman nung mga panahon nato

[@Justin00704]

Where can I find the that book of Doy Laurel telling what really happened to the 1963 referendum?

[@rommelrotulo1295]

It is very clear that we win in arbitrary ruling in International Court.,.

[@christopherkalaw439]

DR. CLARITA CARLOS I REALLY ADMIRES YOU YOUR VERY INTELLIGENT U. EXPLAINS VERY CLEAR WHAT WE WANT TO KNOW ABOUT OUR CLAIMS TO SABAH BRAVO!....

[@leobarrios2532]

The new administration is very fortunate to have Dr. Carlos. She knows what she is talking about. Please don't ask a question to test her logic. It's just a waste of time. Ask questions that you need an answer for the people watching.

[@bohcap418]

Tamaaaaaaa Sec Prof Claire🇵🇭

[@gil523600]

Kung may panahon kukunin ang sabah ay ito ay ngayon

[@reagansiddaguio5089]

Just curious, how ANC would conduct an interview nowadays with Dr. Carlos.

[@lewiscromoglycate561]

does PH government recognise these southern PH groups eg MORO,mnlf, milf etc? 1.how come they can have their own army? 2. what will happen if sulu gets sabah? does sabah becomes PH or sulu state?

[@jongjong2x]

#2. On 12 September 1962, during President Diosdado Macapagal's administration, the Philippine government claimed the territory of North Borneo, and the full sovereignty, title and dominion over it were "ceded" by the heirs of Sultan of Sulu, Muhammad Esmail E. Kiram I, to the Philippines.

[@beachberm]

well said Dr. Carlos. I agree with you 100%. In the order of priority, the Filipinos interest should be protected. Second of all, i also agree that the govt should shift gears and not waste anymore time investigating on this matter before agreeing to talk with the Kirams when there are scholarly people who has already investigated the claim to Sabah.

[@lucreciahidalgo7409]

Eeee44

[@eelchiong6709]

Just one problem. Might makes right. Malaysia is willing to fight for Sabah, are we willing too? You think the UN or any other international body can force Malaysia? Nope. They can't force Israel to give up Palestine or China to give up Tibet. So do you still think they can force Malaysia? Do you think the US will help us? US just sit and watch while China takes over the Spratleys. The only way is to do it ourselves. But can we? You know the answer to that. All we do is talk. Its what we're good at.

[@IgorotDancer]

@@eelchiong6709 and the Sultanate is willing to sacrifice their lives for Sabah. They have already proven it in 2013. Now, the Philippine government is going to back up the sultanate of Sulu, otherwise, the Filipino people will lose confidence in their own government. Do you think the Sultanate, which is much much older than the Federation of Malaysia, and after decades of fighting for their ancestral land, will back down now? I don't think so... and yes, I agree that might is right in Realpolitik. In terms of legalities, the Sultanate already won. This win is recognized by the international community. Now, if you are talking about an armed conflict between the Philippines and Malaysia, do you think Malaysia will win? What makes you think so? 🤔 Personally, I don't care about Sabah being part of the Philippine Republic. BUT, if the Sultanate of Sulu, if the Tausug people think that Sabah is their rightful territory, I will support them. This is because, despite the Philippine government being unsupportive of the Sabah claim (because they're afraid to ruffle Malaysia's feathers) the Sultanate continued to fight for generations, spending their own resources, appealing to international bodies for assistance, and these efforts, I say, are very commendable and heroic. This is the only reason I am one with the Tausug people.

[@eelchiong6709]

@@IgorotDancer Armed conflict? Yes. Malaysia will win hands down. We have 200+ aircraft of which only 12 (FA-50 South Korean made light fighter) matters. Malaysia 30(18 Russian SU-30, 8 American F/A-18, & 12 British BAE HAWK Light fighters). As for our Navy, we have 2 Frigates & 1 Corvette, we won't count small gunboats, only Major ships. Malaysia, 2 Submarines, 4 Frigates, & 6 Corvettes. Now I will admit our soldiers are 100% better, more experienced, & highly trained. Not to mention our army outnumber them 3-4 is to 1. But WE HAVE TO BRING THEM TO SABAH 1st. Do you honestly think our Navy & Air force can protect our soldiers being ferried over to Sabah? All they have to do is sink our troop carriers and its all over. Lastly, the people of Sabah, will they help us? When the Sultan of Sulu's men tried, the only help they got were from filipino OFWs there. The Sabah people supported the Malaysian Army.

[@IgorotDancer]

@@eelchiong6709 all talk, remains to be seen. Just numbers. Don't underestimate what you know nothing about. See what you've done for years? You made the Sabah issue a non-issue. What now? You lost.

[@iconideas05]

Now that its proven that the Sabah is owned by the Sultanate of Sulu, and that Descendants of Sultanate of Sulu, give full authority to the government of the Philippines, and now you are the Head NSA, what should your first move to re-claim Sabah?

[@abunamli9001]

Wow Dean Clarita Carlos, mabuhay po kayo, you talked SENSE, Patriotism, Rescuer of your bros who are being killed by other nation, n our gov't to help or abandon our own fighting people being murdered by another foriegn forces. Does it has something to do wt ALLEGIANCE to Malaysia or to Philippines, by our Pres Nonoy Aquino, as a result of his father late Benigno Aquino was found to be a "Malaysian citizen wt a Malaysian passport" on his death? ANC n anchor men of this program, thanks too for bringing out this issue before our great masses for their info n understanding. Mabuhay din po kayo!

[@yammipurple4820]

Go to the brunei times and under the search box type sabah and the sulu claims

[@jacobrason3708]

THAT IS WHY WE NEED TO REINSTITUTE THE 1973 PHILIPPINE CONSTITUTION

[@nanettecuauhtli5866]

WE COULD HAVE GOTTEN BACK THE SABAH IF NOT SOMEONE DID SOMETHING OR STABBED THE GOV'T BEHIND.

[@SilverHawkFightClub]

The colonial powers dutch, english and spanish had consolidated and shaped what Philippines, Indonesia and Malaysia as what we know today. If you recognize your country as what were handed down, then yo should recognize malaysia as it is. Japanese disregarded any agreements, all South East Asia was under their control before the surrendered to allied. The world was in new order after WW2, those got more power won more. This is the reality some people refused to accept. PEACE. No War.

[@wilfredgile7311]

the unbiased and very intelligent woman DR.CLARITA CARLOS

[@alexraymond3834]

what do you want is already given claim back what is yours period. simple as that any improvement stays. sultan of sulu naman ang makikinabang sa panahong ito and that is his right.kc sa daming meron at greedy mga panggulo naantala ang hustisya. ngayong meron social media iba na pananaw ng henerasyon tausug.

[@ox5599]

Dr Clarita doesn't want to talk about the 1963 Cobbold Commision becos it will go against the Philipines claim. I dare her to talk about that again. The second time this issue crops up she ask them to read a book. PATHETIC.

[@robertgabuna355]

ox5599 That was a manipulated referendum

[@bernieprecones]

What commission are you talking about.. It was one sided.. IN THE GUISE of the right for self determination....

[@Cloud-er6yg]

Now the Arbitral Court in France asked the Malaysian Government to pay the Sultanate of Sulu’s heir $14.92 B

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

Sulu finally lost in various courts of appeal. Sulu lost in Paris Court of Appeal, which annulled and set aside the Paris Court ruling and failed to get the US$14.92B compensation. Instead, Sulu has to pay Malaysia €100,000 as legal cost imposed by the Paris Court of Appeal. Sulu also lost in courts in The Haque, Netherlands in their bid to enforce the Paris Court ruling and failed in their attempt to seize Malaysian assets, following the Paris Court of Appeal decision. Sulu's claim case in Luxembourg would face the same fate following the Paris Court of Appeal decision.

[@annette_138]

I am watching it now and I see sec Carlos is very professional.

[@reyfulgencio457]

I ask that, what is the true title of the Saba island, it is true that the Original Certificate of Title has a 01-4?

[@chocofield]

9 years ago. Still still fighting at present. Prof. Clarita is right. Phil's should take this seriously.

[@helioszxc3794]

First cousins from the Royal House of Bolkiah BEFORE THE BOLKIAHs RULED BRUNEI, IT WAS REGENT SULTAN JAMASALI A.K.A PENGIRAN RAJAH MUDA TENGAH BOLKIAH BIN SULTAN JALILUL HASHIM BOLKIAH AQIMUDDIN FIRST RULED BRUNEI AND SULU TAWI-TAWI AND NORTH BORNEO FROM 1888 TO 1905 AS ACTING SULTAN (CALLED REGENT WHILE HIS FATHER SULTAN JALILUL HASHIM BOLKIAH AQIMUDDIN WAS ALREADY OLD) AND AFTER THE DEATH OF PENGIRAN RAJAH MUDA DATU JAMASALI HIS YOUNGER BROTHER RAJA BONGSU A.K.A SULTAN JAMALUL ALAM II APPOINTED TO SUCCEED PENGIRAN RAJAH MUDAH DATU JAMASALI BOLKIAH. (SULTAN JAMALUL ALAM II WAS THE FATHER OF SULTAN OMAR ALI SAIFUDDIEN III AND GRANDFATHER OF SULTAN HASSANAL BOLKIAH). THIS IS WHY THE LATE SULTAN OF BRUNEI SULTAN SIR OMAR ALI SAIFUDDIEN III BUILT A MUSEUM SECTION IN THE BRUNEI MUSEUM HONORING THE LATE HER ROYAL HIGHNESS PENGIRAN PRINCESS NORMA DAYANG DAYANG PIANDAO JAMASALI BOLKIAH AS HIS FIRST COUSIN AND THE SOLE HEIRESS/ONLY CHILD OF HRH REGENT SULTAN JAMASALI PENGIRAN RAJAH MUDA TENGAH BOLKIAH OF BRUNEI AND SULU/NORTH BORNEO OWNED/RULED FROM 1888 TO 1905 (Before American Occupation in Sulu the JAMASALI AND BOLKIAH Royal families ruled Sulu Archipelago from 1450 to 1908).. THANKS BE TO ALLAH THE ALMIGHTY ONE THE LATE SULTAN JAMASALI PRODUCED ONE CHILD/DAUGHTER BORN IN JOLO, SULU DURING HIS TIME AS SULTAN OF SULU AND BRUNEI AND THUS ACKNOWLEDGE BY THE SULTAN OF BRUNEI. THE PRINCESS NORMA DAYANG DAYANG PIANDAO JAMASALI BOLKIAH MUSEUM IN THE BRUNEI MUSEUM ITSELF IS A TESTAMENT AND EVIDENCE OF THE VERY CLOSE BLOOD RELATIONS OF HRH PRINCESS NORMA DAYANG DAYANG PIANDAO JAMASALI AND ALMARHUM SIR SULTAN OMAR ALI SAIFUDDIEN III (THEY ARE FIRST COUSINS) THE FATHER OF HIS MAJESTY SULTAN HASSANAL BOLKIAH MU'ZZAIDIN WADDAULLAH. THE LATE HRH PENGIRAN PRINCESS NORMA DAYANG DAYANG PIANDAO JAMASALI BOLKIAH WAS A MEMBER OF THE POWERFUL BOLKIAH ROYAL FAMILY OF BRUNEI. THE BOLKIAHS OF BRUNEI AND PRINCESS NORMA PIANDAO JAMASALI BOLKIAH OF SULU ARE CO-OWNERS AND CO-HEIRS OF SABAH. PLEASE SAY AL-FATIHA AND MAY ALLAH BLESS THEIR SOULS AND RAISE THEM TO THE HIGHEST RANK IN AL-FIRDAUS.

[@nonoydiaz4191]

Pinas wag tutulog tulog dapat tulongan na si princes jacel.

[@precept66]

Sorry to say Carlos, it's a bit to late. Damage has been done extensively by Kirams pirates to the international views. Kiram III are all alone on this....as they will never get international recognition.

[@bebesoto9345]

And who has the last laugh? Its Kiram descendants.

[@melaniussumadic1759]

ALMIGHTY LORD BLESS THE PHILIPPINES.OH LORD OF LORDS BLESS FILIPINOS.PLS. COVER THEM UNDER YOUR WINGS.

[@handle869]

Im curious or want to ask Prof Carlo's talks about Sabah claim.For me it is untimely it is for the meantime. Would it not better if we look at the nearer enemy China. Who's citizens are with us friends but if the bad comes to worse will they be lour friends that they will fight with us side by side against the Chinese or will go home to China to fight against us.

[@VIEWEDBOX]

An educational discussion... I learned something new about Sabah. Thanks a lot Dr. Clarita Carlos. I appreciate your thoughtfulness in our country the Philippines. ;)

[@ray8]

Whats happening in Ukraine reminds me of our Sabah claim in Pnoys term. The difference was Pres. Putin exerted force while Presm Pnoy decided to ignore what the Sultanate of Sulu is trying to achieve.

[@mariastenger5179]

Correct ,Professor Clarita Carlos ideas.

[@amarahnapoles9273]

mabuhay po kayo Prof Carlos. itong Sabah ang dapat pagtuunan natin ng masidhing pagsusumikap para mabawi kaysa makipagiyera tayo sa china sa WPS. patuloy tayong makipag usap sa china about WPS pero huwag tayong makipag away. pero bigyan natin ng mas malaking budget, time, at energy ang pagbawi sa sabah...

[@dromasoc]

present situation, that sabah won the intl arbitration against sabah... dr.carlos havent speak a word as NSC... what now doc.carlos??

[@maryannetteuy7744]

I remember the time when the Sabah claim was taken by Malaysia. I still believe that this must be returned back to our country. The geographical situation says it. The accessibility is close to Philippines and not Malaysia. Thank Prof Clarita bring out the brilliance, I love you.

[@vicenteafinidad7928]

A

[@leovigildosuarez4142]

P

[@fredtacang3624]

Blame UK (and perhaps US), sila nag-recognize na north borneo (where sabah is) 'belonged' to malaysia

[@brianmayabella5992]

@@fredtacang3624 parang pong nangungupahan ibinenta sa new tenant kahit hindi sayu.

[@brianmayabella5992]

@Hope Lope i always thought ying East india trading company yung nag lease, tpos ibinenta or pinapa lease rin nila sa Malaysia. After world war II, dami nanag claim and since America yung supreme victor sa World War II, they recognized that the British is the sole owner of Sabah. After Workd War II, is the best time to claim territory and recognize sovereignity tpos paperworks lng kulang. Also may partly mali yung sultanate of Sulu, Since kinilala sila part sa Pinas, nag pay tribute lng sana sa govt. In the end, uts like gangwar. I do hope that, hindi mag defect yung Sulu sa Malaysia with the help of BANGsamoro law

[@yammipurple4820]

To be on the safe side, since Sabah was also claimed by the Sultan of Sulu, Baron Overbeck negotiated a treaty with the Sultan of Sulu. He signed an agreement with the Sultan of Sulu and agreed to pay him $5,000 annually. The Sultan appointed him as Dato Bendahara and Raja of Sandakan in 1878.

[@andresflancia1090]

Mm mom k KLM m km he JCPenney

[@jamillansangan260]

All sultanate ask for restoration the gov. In Sabah. From the political issues should.they get back the words term theukyvusevid renting.

[@jamillansangan260]

They pursue that's belongs to out country. They have honor po.. they claim mga. Ds kamila yan... ikram sultanate . Of sulu they font have a dupportvkasi ...alot of tausug living there the others they died in that place and native there . tsususugs.

[@jamillansangan260]

If gov.. read these people and not abandoned.

[@jamillansangan260]

You always saying Malik....they ate going home not going in mindanao...

[@lonamakabuhay7457]

Face analysis of Prof Carlos???

[@mosesmalik3637]

Ang mga mananakop na putì pinag away away ang mga Asians. Ginawan tayo nang gulo . We stand for truth , rights and honor Sabah belongs to Philippines. Honor the Tausugs historical rights to the land .

[@39pabssoquirata30]

By history, Sabah or North Borneo was never been part of the Philippines. It was given to the Sultanate of Sulu as a sort of gratitude for helping the rebellion crushed that happened in the early years there. Not in any given time that Sabah was part of the Philippine Jurisdiction or Philippine Map. What was given to the Sultanate of Sulu, is not automatically the property of the Philippine government. Who is receiving the the money as they said as "RENTAL"? the Sultanate of Sulu/heirs or the Philippine government? Not a SINGLE PESO in any given time that the Philippine government received from the said "RENTAL" if it was indeed owned by the Philippine government. The existence of Sabah or North Borneo was even ahead than that the existence of the Philippine government.

[@marikitliwayway6703]

Here's a word for you and please,... please,... try to understand its meaning so that the next time you open your mouth no stupidity will come out of it. "transference"

[@jerrydalimot4653]

PROF CARLOS YOU ARE SO SMART !!!!

[@Dennis-fg5sd]

She’s right! She’s the only one that has balls!!!

[@deocyasol9406]

It would have been unthinkable for the King of Borneo to have another Kingdom ruled by another King/Sultan in his Kingdom even if that King/Sultan is his friend. The King of Borneo simply gave his friend, the Sultan of Sulu, a piece of property not a territory.

[@danielgutierrez1937]

I'm confident that our current President being a Mindanaoan and has a Tausug descent himself will not lax concerning this issue ,also the fact that the people involved if we still consider them as not only our Muslim brother's but also our fellow Filipino who cares for our own countrymen!?!?😍😇😷😎

[@eelchiong6709]

Now our president is about to step down. Did he do anything about Sabah? Face it, unless we are willing to fight and die, we will never get back Sabah. Do you expect Americans or the UN to fight and die for us?

[@bernardbulan6467]

I couldn't have a proper connection of imo apps what to do about it pls kindly lit me know how

[@dannymission8547]

The Philippines government should assert and support the Sabah claim of Sultanate of Zulu since original documents are existing which prove that Sabah was lease by Malaysia from the Sultanate of Zulu.

[@eelchiong6709]

Zulu is an african warrior tribe living in the nation of South Africa. You mean Sultan of Sulu.

[@rothcarlos891]

Divide the area of Sabah. Doesn't this idea support both parties?

[@garry5oh]

The people living in Sabah have two options to choose from: 1. They can relocate to Sarawak or return to peninsular Malaysia and retain their Malaysian citizenship, 2. They can remain in Sabah and be affiliated with the Sultanate of Sulo and choose Philippine citizenship.

[@bernadettecultura1888]

The tausog,yakan tiduray, sangil, maguidanawan, maranaw, buayan will eat you raw

[@alphaoms8963]

Sarawak is also Indonesia

[@IEMONTeacher14]

​@@alphaoms8963Indon khayal jugk 😂

[@robertgabuna355]

Dr C Carlos is a walking encyclopedia

[@RomeoSolis-k1g]

What happen to the video why cannot play what is the problem

[@lourdesladiao6881]

Another history learned from Dr.Clarita Carlos dapat talaga Kumilos na talaga ang Philippines Government regarding Sabah issue / or former north Borneo.

[@nanettecuauhtli5866]

I BELIEVE THIS WILL BE TALKED ABOUT WITH THE MARCOS JR ADMINISTRATION AND NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER DR. CLARITA CARLOS.

[@kenzacker1476]

it is a Philippine Territory, but it is an Autonomous region to be Administered by the Sultanate of Sulu and its rightful owners. To be honest Sabah could have been a Malaysian - Sulu partnership. However, the Natives of Sulu has always been a brother and a part of the Philippines. the claim over the territory has been clearly for the Philippines but the Philippines only acts like a father figure for the Sultanate. and recently, the issue is now clear and the Philippines will not turn a blind eye for the cry of its people and the natives of Sabah.

[@kaypeebreeze1550]

kayo na po ang taong nagsasalita nang may alam.believe po ako sa inyo.mabuhay po kayo.at tama po marami po tayong scholar na kakaalam.

[@marioalviar1]

The two announcers or interviewer seems doesn't know what they are talking about in favor of the Philippines and the technicality side of it. Luckily we have a brilliant Professor who knows the fundamental basic laws with regard to Sabah and our rights as a claimant. As she said leave it to the scholars to make the final decision. Sabah now is ours therefore we need not to compromise.

[@mahalkoortiz3304]

Good job mam for claiming Sabah

[@westerntrend]

IDLE LANDS SA PILIPINAS (sa mga Probinsya) Marami ng lupa sa Pilipinas ang nabili na ng mga chinese-filipino businessman na hindi dinevelop. Naging 'idle' na at hindi na productive. Hindi rin magalaw ng mga ordinarying Pilipino dahil privately owned na. Dapat magkaroon ng batas na patawan ng Double or Tripple ang Tax ng mga 'idle-lands' para mapilitan silang idevelop para maging productive ang lupa.

[@eligiobrosas825]

Yes madam Clair know well historical rights on Sabah claim. We r positive God guide !& bless Phils & Filipinos

[@BryanWong]

does the sabah people have any say at all as to their destiny and statehood? SUltans , this goverment and that claim as if the sabah people have no say in their own state , respect the sabahans and their selected wish as to what statehood they wish to belong to.

[@danilopioquinto8068]

What happen if president bbm will not conform what maam clarita carlos conveyed to this media?

[@denzilkb]

The Malaysian govt doesn't even give anything (rights, recognition as aliens) to Filipino migrants who lived there all their lives. Better to really look into getting back Sabah or to at least continue the lease and provide basic services to (Sabahan) Filipinos over there.

[@eltonyong23]

Big time dreamer .Wake-up is 2013 now

[@yammipurple4820]

In 1877, Baron von Overbeck visited Brunei to negotiate a new lease with Sultan Abdul Momin. The latter agreed and a treaty was signed that same year. Sultan Abdul Momin appointed Baron von Overbeck as the Maharaja of Sabah and Raja of Gaya and Sandakan and in return, the Baron shall pay $12,000 per year and additional $3,000 to the Temenggong.

[@Morphasella]

Well, in Malaysia version history. The sultan sulu have given sabah to the cobbold for FOREVER. Cobbold then give it to Malaysia BECAUSE THAT IS WHAT THE PEOPLE OF SABAH WANTS TO. Now, forget about the lease. No lease is for FOREVER. Does not make sense. Easy, ask the people of Sabah, in which country they want to be in? If the people does not acknowledge you as sultan, you are not a worthy sultan after all. They are not their sultan in sabahan people heart ok.

[@Bast_Ailuros179]

Morphasella you are an idiot! you’re saying its ok to just grab or steal any land as long as you like, its the rule of thieves or lawlessness you want to follow. without justice there can be no righteousness and people will be barbaric. you should start reading the Bible, God pulverized Sodom and Gomorrah for they are lawless and without justice. look what Islam has done to your mentality, it made you unruly and lost your morality, what a shameful people.

[@edgardoandres7067]

the way i see prof. carlos is reaally bright and really qualified to be in the position as one of the cabinet member of PBBM government .

[@hisagony8094]

The referendum has nothing to do with their self determination of willingness to belong to Malaysia. Rent or lease will n must prevail.

[@JohnDoe-lc2tr]

I am thinking if Sabah Crisis was created by the West? Dr. Carlos: "I hope this thing will not lead to more tragedies". Today, Sulu heirs seized 2 billion $ worth of asset....

[@danielgutierrez1937]

TO OUR ;Malaysian government friend ,Pls. be kind to our fellow Muslim brother's don't force and push them back to where they don't want to work and live freely ,don't try to bully them out in a violent manner, cause the outcome will be worse !?!?😷😎😕😢😧😞

[@comatoast911]

How can this woman and supposedly a professor in UP not know much about this issue she can't even string the past presidents in chronological order. She is the prime example why not too many Filipinos knew about this issue. I am from the North Luzon and our teacher taught us about this issue yet PNoy in his speech was news to him. The truth was that Ninoy's supporter to come back to Pinas was Malaysia along with Japan. So the Liberal Party have to ignore this issue when in Power.

[@dondieperillo1289]

let's admit that we couldn't afford to fight by force against malaysia then, and under any previous administration. but president duterte's administration is very different, he has the will with intelligence and power to do it.

[@chitodscorpion]

When BBM & Sara will be the pres & vice-pres of the Phil for sure this issue will be reopened to solve it once and for all who the real claimant of Sabah and hopefilly it will be the Phili since the sultan has documents to prove it and since Malaysia is paying the sultan of Sulu annualy until they stop in 2010.

[@lydiacristinamartinez3058]

I agree with you Hon. Madam.

[@franciscoreyes4339]

My idol clarita clear carlos napaka bright mo madam