Depp v. Heard Trial Day 5 - Morning. Keenan Wyatt, Shawn Bett.

[@TheEmilyDBaker]

🌍 Get exclusive NordVPN deal here - nordvpn.com/emilydbaker It’s risk free with Nord’s 30 day money-back guarantee! ✌

[@jennifercriss1897]

No offense Emily but it’s hard to listen to the sworn in bc your talking tooooooooo much and my adhd finds it frustrating to try to hear you and the sworn in. I’m sorry to complain but it was frustrating. Love ya replay crew

[@Herstyleseduier]

AH lady lawyer lied. If you go back Wyatt testified that “I have never seen” NOT that “I have never heard” he said that he has never seen him physically harm anyone. AH layer kept saying “you testified you have never HEARD” he never said he never heard but that he had never SEEN. he never once mentioned or testified to HEARING anything. Can she get in trouble for this!? Who do I need to tell this information to the judge?! 😂 I don’t like AH lady lawyer.

[@007nadineL]

Great.

[@trailblazer14a]

I’m really confused as to why Amber’s lawyer is so scattered, drones on, mispronounces words and objects to everything. On paper, she looks like a good choice, in reality, it’s like watching my grandma, super cringy, doesn’t really understand what’s going on etc.

[@Songbirdstress]

I think she does it to put the victim their guard and confuse them, then she pounces.

[@dudette2c]

😄😄😄😂😂this made me laugh so much!

[@elzabethmcarthur3154]

I watched that being discussed on another live. Someone speculated that she was bullied at school and very snippy as a result. Don't know if there is truth to it.

[@davemurphy9334]

I genuinely wouldn't be surprised if she was picked because she reminds people of older aunts, grandmothers etc. given that the other lawyers opening felt as if they were trying to create an "us v them" situation; the everyday person of Virginia v. these celebrities.

[@katego370]

Yes, she's speculating about the reality of work in the film industry like a 90-year-old speculating about TikTok. I bet some of the jurors will be annoyed by her.

[@draconis17]

AH's lawyer: "did you see Mr. Depp do something bad?" Keenan Wyatt: "no." AH's lawyer: "but did you see Mr. Depp do something bad?" Keenan Wyatt: "no." AH's lawyer: "but did you see him *not* do something bad when you weren't there?" Keenan Wyatt: "...no?" AH's lawyer: "gotcha!" What.

[@tarampryce1372]

lolololol

[@owynpham1478]

So 👍

[@tyfaknee]

😂😂😂

[@marleeljoka9333]

Not to mention the judge allowing her to continue to ask the identical questions that seriously should’ve been sustained 🤦‍♀️

[@shelbyschnoor9369]

Wow. I just watched the couple’s therapist testimony and as a therapist (not couples), I’m shocked by her assessment of their relationship based on her own statements from her notes. She testifies that there was “mutual abuse” but she also states more than once that every allegation of physical abuse from Johnny was reported by Amber without Johnny present- but she never testifies she asked Johnny about it- also we know if she had he would adamantly deny it. It blew my mind that she just took Amber at her word and would have never discussed it with Johnny. She also says that in a session with the couple, Johnny brings up how Amber punched him in the face and that Amber did not deny it, but she changed the subject and went off on a tangent and Johnny was not going to say anything more than that. I’m sorry what? Is she actually a therapist? Her job would be to redirect the conversation to discuss Johnny’s statement. The therapist said Johnny couldn’t find his voice in the relationship- so she knew it was one of their problems that Amber bulldozed him- and then the therapist enabled it in their session. That’s a very common tactic to avoid taking responsibility is to distract- and I’m really really taken aback the therapist wasn’t able to see this. Amber didn’t want to let him talk bc if he was allowed to share his feelings and experiences then the spotlight would be on her and she didn’t want to take accountability. This would be a nightmare scenario for most therapists- enabling abuse by siding with the abuser. She probably should have seen too that they weren’t going to work, it was unethical for this therapist to continue working with them.

[@jessyjulie5506]

I think she only saw johnny twice by Skype.

[@Metta_with_a_long_e]

It's not every day when a person can say this video right here was the first video to help me function as a human. My mom had passed away in March and by this time I was not handling it very well. I would literally go days without getting out of bed. Not realizing I hadn't had anything to eat for days. Until I was physically ill and it would dawn on me that I hadn't had food for the week yet. This video and the whole trial gave me a schedule. I'd wake up at a certain time, get out of bed and eat lunch when we had breaks. I had similar type of depression when I was younger but I was consumed with a lot of self-harm thoughts and planning. I haven't had self harm thoughts or planning since my very early twenties. So in this way this depression was different because I was just consumed with the grief. I was so depressed I didn't even realize I was depressed. I'm so grateful for lawtube because I really don't know how I would have gotten out of it without them.

[@Indigo565]

Amber told the therapist that it was mutually abusive. That alone makes me feel it wasn't. She was building a story to benefit herself financially. When that didn't work out, it seems like she lashed out via the op-ed

[@marnienaylor8550]

She actually asked the therapist if calling the cops would be Beneficial for her! She was absolutely planning this to get $$. That 7 million, that she didn’t want, that was going to charity. That she NEVER donated! She knew exactly what she was doing.

[@FrankyFrankAlot]

Emily calling Elane Bredehoft "BirdHoft" before getting to know her is so funny. 😊

[@judgejudyrocks1]

I giggled too!!!

[@devonsimone2891]

Why is this lawyer so mad?? It feels like she never lets anyone she questions finish a sentence or even answer the initial questions she’s asking. Her abrasive attitude is... 🙄I just cannot. She’s like “You’re not answering my questions exactly how I’d like you too! So, I’m just going to continue to cut you off mid sentence and talk over you at every opportunity.” Unbelievable and childish behavior.

[@hoshi-15]

The female attorney being aggressive really did distract me. I was so focused on how aggressive she was and her trying to get gotcha moments I didn't notice the possible impeachment. The string of her counter arguments were also bouncing around so much that I got lost where her point was so it also made the possible impeachment harder to notice. Thank you for the clear explanation Emily! It was really insightful

[@filuska]

"If the jury is also hating the lawyer and the witness claps back, it can be a very light and funny moment" - yeah, we saw THAT :)

[@TourettesMajestic]

Keenan Wyatt finding out Depp cared about him enough to put his work in his own contracts. Wonderful.

[@kerrivandenberg7469]

The thing that strikes me is the level of professionalism that comes from Johnny Depps team. The fact that in comparison to those who are backing Amber, they seem to be very straightforward, professional, honest, even a little dull (I’m not going to lie, I was expecting a few more sketchy individuals, it’s made me see a whole other side to Johnny). Where as, the vibe I get from Ambers backers is not wholey honest.

[@juliat9211]

The fact that we get 6 weeks of this every day… poor jury.

[@AndreaVazquezOMG]

yes omg, that woman is annoying

[@saraandmoeandbaby]

Saw them questioning Larry, Johnny’s friend. The questions they asked about Amber wearing makeup were so weird. They seemed to be hinting that she covered her bruise so perfectly with tint and makeup for days after Johnny apprently hit her. And then the day tmz took photos of her bruised face; she Apparently didn’t want to cover it that day? I call bullshit

[@MelaineT]

If she did then she needs to share the tips my dog got excited seeing me one time and hit my lip and it bruised, I would love to see how amber a girl with hardly any makeup skills her self would cover, puffy fresh bruises with literally tinted sun screen and blush

[@luiza.limaneves]

@@MelaineT and without ruining the makeup simultaneously as, with a fresh and awful wound, it would probably hurt a lot to put even light pressure on it - especially prolonged pressure with makeup utensils

[@jofip9199]

bruises are not only colour but also are bumpy so even if she magically, with the tiniest amount of make up, covered it perfectly she still would have noticiable swelling imo

[@kendallneason3645]

Don’t forget the “Amica” cream Lol. What she means is Arnica cream which is a balm for muscle soreness and doesn’t cover bruises either. What Amber should have said is she used theatre makeup which is thick pancake makeup but people would have noticed it up close.

[@tyfaknee]

@@jofip9199She is a medical anomaly. She claimed to have gotten blasted in the face “so many times she lost count” by a man with “big, chunky rings on every finger” but for her the injuries “weren’t what you would think” & for her, it “wasn’t that bad”. She claimed to have covered bruises, cuts/scratches, black eyes & a self-diagnosed broken nose with simply tinted moisturizer & was able to bring down the swelling that such a beating would cause with a few ice cubes. I have seen black-eye injuries where the whites of the eye turn completely red from blood vessels bursting, but not her. 🤔 For someone to claim to have suffered such horrific beatings with multiple injuries to her face, but everything is healed to perfection nearly overnight….. she should be studied & analyzed. She is a damn medical miracle!

[@JMay-]

I was jury foreperson in a tobacco trial. The plaintiff's attorney was so obnoxious, yelling and ranting, mostly directly at me... it turned the jury off completely. The plaintiff' did not have a viable claim anyway because she started smoking in 1992!. After the verdict the attorneys asked to meet with us to discuss the verdict and only two jurors met with them. The rest of us were so sick of plaintiff's attorney we refused. I feel the same way about Elaine... she is making it easier for jury to rule against her client.

[@yolandawilson9852]

Their therapist said Amber told her about the abuse not Johnny. She also said that Johnny wouldn't speak unless Amber wasn't there because Amber was always speaking over him. She also said Amber told her that she hits him and said he hits her Johnny never told her that, Amber did. Her therapist just confirmed that Amber was planning alot sooner than we know. Therapist said Amber came to her and asked if she reported abuse first would she have the upper hand for divorce, something to that extent.

[@BlueSkyes17]

"Did he have wings?!?!" Made me laugh so hard. Thank you for your snark and wit and knowledge, Emily! Re-watching during the week gap.

[@Ray-a-Sun]

I'm watching this over a year later and i still can't believe Heard's lawyers. Where did they learn trial behaviour? Its appalling how disrespectful they are to witnesses.

[@lynnmarch7071]

Me too and totally agree

[@christinenelson5017]

Yes! I have been rewatching too and I don’t understand how they were all so bad.

[@fenderr]

Emily, you've become my comfort zone on KZbin, i come here everytime i need to see people get what's coming to them. Thank you for creating this community.

[@sianmilne4879]

The witness looks SO CONFUSED when Heard's lawyer is cross examining him 😅 definitely not a good sign when the witness has no idea what your accusatory questions are about

[@JessRodr]

I thought that the marriage therapist said “Amber told me that it was a mutually abusive relationship”. NOT that Johnny admitted it, but that Amber claimed that. Let me know if I’m wrong!

[@Heyxamber]

The therapist testimony is that they were mutually abusive and that Amber would instigate the fights due to her insecurities.

[@truecrimenwine489]

I took it as: this relationship is mutually abusive. Physical and emotional. Amber seems to physically abuse Depp but even if Depp never hit Amber, the relationship is still mutually abusive. More emotional from Depp it seems

[@MsSilverTulip]

The therapist can't testify whether abuse occurred on both sides as she was not there. Therapists are also not police and cannot comment on whether crimes have occurred. They can only comment on what they have witnessed in person or what clients have *reported* to them. Eg. If both parties accused the other of abuse, the therapist may have operated on the assumption that the abuse was mutual, or she may have been biased against men (assuming women cannot be the primary aggressor).

[@zidapplip]

@@MsSilverTulip I watched the whole testimony. According to the therapist, Amber told her that she was physically abusive and JD was physically abusive. There was no testimony about whether JD claimed/confessed abuse, so I'm assuming he didnt. If someone says they were themselve abusive, I'm going to believe them. My impression is that both sides are psychologically pretty toxic, but it doesn't seem like JD was physically abusive.

[@R.M.3.14]

@@truecrimenwine489 there’s no such thing as mutual abuse. If AH abused JD and he lashed out-he is either reacting or defending himself. If it were a man hitting a woman and the woman hit him back-would that be abuse? No, we would say that is a victim fighting back in self defense. A man hitting back at his abuser shouldn’t be considered abuse.

[@Conformist138]

I loved the laugh when Wyatt was asked if his lodging was "comparable" to Depp's while filming. What an absurd question!

[@lexijanovec9751]

Holy shitshow Batman! Amber Heards lawyer makes my butt itch. Emily, you're incredible! Part of the replay crew here, and you always leave me wanting more! 🤓

[@dijonwhitmore171]

😂 That made me laugh so hard!! Try putting amica cream on it😄

[@lexijanovec9751]

@@dijonwhitmore171 Baha! I might just have to after all this sh*t. 😉 Pun intended.

[@likesunflowers]

this comment wins the Internet today 🤣🤣😂

[@alexkaen1701]

After the whole of the trial, I can't help but wonder what was Bredehoff's deal. From beginning to end she struck me as completely unprofessional, arguing court procedure, defying orders to avoid certain topics, misconstruing anything from evidence to legal facts such as the nature of the UK trial, etc. Even after the trial she went out to describe evidence which did not exist and lay accusations against the judge, jury and JD's lawyers. How is this woman allowed to work when she can't even respect the rules of her profession?

[@elenamartinez7301]

I feel like Amber Heard's attorneys are violating the rule of not asking a question you don't know the answer to. Like they THINK they know and are surprised to be getting a different response than they expected.

[@jettnatchez4776]

AH’s lawyer are like nails on a chalkboard. I hate them and I actually just don’t care much. I believe JD bc I’ve been around narcissist and know how they operate, but I’m willing to listen to both sides of story. Her lawyers however have turned me off so bad I’m can’t even take them serious now.

[@sjworrier0613]

I was around an abusive narcissist for years who abused me. I guess we have different perspectives. Everything about Johnny reads as a narcissist to me but I’m also not a licensed psychologist so I can’t make that call, his weird stuff in the stand was truly baffling, he goes from Euro to Southern Fried boy to Midlife Crisis within minutes… I can only imagine living with that, but I can also see borderline personality qualities in Amber. Neither of these people seem pleasant or likable at all, but Johnny is very charming and entertaining… which is a red flag to someone like me. I believe the abuse was mutual until Johnny took it too far and Amber started to genuinely fear for her life and wanted to end the marriage, Johnny had her sign an NDA and she signed it…. and then she wrote that op-Ed…. and here we are. I don’t think it’s a black and white situation, most cases involving abuse never are.

[@genevievexx]

@@sjworrier0613 there are recordings of Amber admitting she had been physical towards JD and saying that he's the bigger person and that it's admirable (but she was saying it with irony just to delegitimize what he was saying... There's a KZbin video that has the recordings : Johnny Depp and Amber Heard: the story . I have to say, I don't know if he has ever been physically abusive. I'm willing to hear both sides. It seemed to be a very toxic and emotionally abusive relationship in general.

[@jaybee4118]

@@genevievexx how do you know she was saying it with irony?

[@truecrimenwine489]

I don't understand this take...I don't really think narcissism is a determining factor here... A narcissist could very possibly keep their cool and walk away knowing that it triggers their partner to physically abuse the m so they get sympathy and the law on their side... this isn't about personality traits it's to determine if ABs story of physical abuse was true or not and therefore defamatory or not.

[@SaltyD3plorable]

@@jaybee4118 because you can hear the sarcasm in her voice. It's obvious in the clip

[@alysaneblackwood]

It's like war of the Roses meets war of the worlds...crazy, confusing, sometimes shocking. I feel like the sound tech, artist and bodyguard could double of character witnesses for Johnny. Each of them were likable, giving off truthful vibes and non of them had a bad word about Johnny no matter how much Amber's bear poked them. So grateful for your commentary, hair looks amazing,

[@selfesteem3447]

Nah, just a Malignant Narcissist and her target who grew up in Narcissism and became her victim. Please See Professor of Psychology Sam Vaknin's teachings on Narcissism. Vaknin was discovered to have the IQ of Albert Einstein when he was in grade school and then invited to attend a prestigious College. He's hits all 9 points on being a Narcissist himself and is also a Psychopath. Who better to learn from.

[@ellismorten]

the earpiece thing! I remember hearing once that Johnny was showing up to set drunk and he never had his lines memorized, so they used the earpiece to feed him his lines. probably something his team wanted to debunk since that weakens Amber's team's depiction of him/his character? I'm less than an hour in so maybe that gets established later

[@ellismorten]

follow up I love being a genius

[@chitrakshirawat]

@@ellismorten haha, you indeed are a genius.

[@Creature_of_Knight]

I didn't know about this trial until the second half so I'm coming back to watch more of the first half. It's very interesting to see some of this knowing how much of a fiasco this all becomes later. Like it's interesting how Emily is saying the sound technician should be looking at the jury, when we all know how that goes for Amber later 🤔

[@ShaCaro]

There's a very distinct difference between looking at the people you're supposed to address and staring them down.

[@laurab1057]

thats the first thing i thought as I am rewatching this here. yikes...amer do not take this advice!! noooo scambur no!!!

[@tyfaknee]

I think she was trying to intimidate & to burn their faces in her memory so she can “find” them later if (when) she loses. IMHO

[@jacobknopik1413]

I can’t believe everybody doesn’t know who Monty Python is?! I feel sorry for people who don’t. I got my parents DVD set and probably spent a week watching that. even though I watched it when I was growing up too, but it’s different when you’re a grown-up.

[@bitemad]

Love monty python

[@RaenbowBlight]

What is up with these parents raising such uncultured swine...? 😒

[@nancychisholm5399]

LOL my family`s Easter tradition....time zones coordinated and Life of Brian goes in the DVD players!

[@jacobknopik1413]

@@nancychisholm5399 We used to have a holy grail Christmas tradition.

[@nancychisholm5399]

@@jacobknopik1413 our Christmas Eve is The Meaning of Life

[@kirielbranson4843]

I understand why your viewership went up so much during this trial. I have watched a few of the other channels and none of them provided the immediate legal context, would know when and why objections were done, etc. most of the time when you spoke it was to explain things which was sorely missing on some of the other channels. I felt like you have been holding my hand and teaching me all through this trial. Thanks so much for all your work. FYI, the reason I started watching some of the other channels is that you missed a few days in the beginning and I wanted to see those days.

[@spak3950]

Emily can you please do a breakdown of the Kentucky man who won 450K because his work threw him a birthday party against his wishes and he had a panic attack? Please? The court documents are out now!

[@demi4632]

God, that’s unbelievably pathetic.

[@007nadineL]

Ugggg

[@ellah6188]

@@demi4632 I believe he also was fired due to the panic attack, the lawsuit was really about wrongful termination

[@likesunflowers]

@@demi4632 are you saying having a panic attack is pathetic??

[@tyfaknee]

⁠@@demi4632 Clarification is needed. I’m hoping that is not what you meant.

[@Herstyleseduier]

Maybe I misunderstood if I did forgive me BUT AH lady lawyer lied. If you go back Wyatt testified that “I have never seen” NOT that “I have never heard” he said that he has never seen him physically harm anyone. AH layer kept saying “you testified you have never HEARD” he never said he never heard but that he had never SEEN. he never once mentioned or testified to HEARING anything. Can she get in trouble for this!? Who do I need to tell this information to the judge?! 😂 I don’t like AH lady lawyer.

[@H3arme3r0ar]

Now that I've watched the whole trial I find it funny that umbridge is objecting to everything under the sun but when amber was on stand she had so many leading questions and hearsay . What a joke

[@darkinside2213]

Coming back after watching to the closing statements all I can say is, if their only real case here is that everyone is getting paid by Depp or wanting their 15 min of fame, I can't believe anyone outside that courtroom could actually believe anything coming from Heard's team. Also after watching the 6 weeks I have come to the conclusion that Elaine was on the brink of retirement and just as she was stepping out the door she got the call that she needed to do this trial. She is very bitter and angry about and it has taken it out on every single person she can who isn't paying her right now.

[@varanchio]

hey, I got lil bit confused, do you know if Emily has the first part of this day on her channel or not? can’t find it.. I mean, stuff between opening statements and this vid As for Elaine, I think she did very little (if any) trials..and maybe it’s not a good idea to do more🙈

[@loriburnip]

I might have agreed with you if she had gone Into Obscurity after this trial, but she's not she's doing the rounds on morning shows and stuff. Seems like she's the one who wants 15 minutes of fame.

[@Saitaina]

1. Everyone knew Pirates 5 was delayed, we can read. 2. Depp has been a well known functioning alcoholic. He is one if the Brat Pack that didn't clean up, but made it work. He MAY be more sober today then he was before, but I don't think he's been sober. That doesn't mean he's not a brilliant man who works hard. 3. Depp doesn't have a history of abuse unless it's REALLY well hidden, this relationship brought that out and unfortunately, created a horribly toxic place for both. Did she start it? Can't say, wasn't there, but I've known of Depp since the 80's and vaugly followed him that long - this isn't his "typical" behavior, so if he DID start it, it's extremely out of character and more evidence it's THIS relationship. I mean, not even Ms. Rider has a bad thing to say and their relationship was in theore tremulous days.

[@Lollipop_Lexi]

Gotta disagree with your point about following Depp for so long. We know nothing of these people-only what the miedia, their publicists and the studios want us to know. You never know what happens behind closed doors, often even with the people close to you in real life, let alone a person you’ve never met.

[@april-tui3524]

You didn’t read about Kate Moss and that hotel room situation? Just because someone hasn’t always been abusive doesn’t mean they can’t be. ‘I’ve never hit anyone else’ isn’t a great defence, especially as a crew member from Pirates sued him over a punch on set.

[@louiseplatiel5431]

Your final point there is think is very true. While abuse is often well-hidden, there is a distinct behavioral pattern that others notice. At least that was my experience, anyway.

[@april-tui3524]

@@louiseplatiel5431 unless drugs or alcohol are involved.

[@myroselle6987]

@@april-tui3524 But it isn’t a great argument to say that just because someone hasn’t always been abusive doesn’t mean they can’t be. By that logic anyone could be accused and have no chance to prove their innocence because, well, they could be guilty. A person should, obviously, have to be proven guilty rather than have to prove their innocence but the point is the same.

[@katego370]

If I was a juror watching Amica Lady do what she does, I'd be so annoyed by her. I think I'd probably just stop listening to her cross-examination and just take his testimony as the whole truth. My ADHD would definitely take over and I'd just start doodling on my notepad and zone out. Seriously, why is the judge just allowing her to ask these ridiculous questions? She's speculating about work in the film industry like a 90-year-old granny speculating about TikTok.

[@laurenlancaster5807]

Is this ear piece in the ear foundation related to the hearsay that JD "couldn't remember his lines, due to his drug and alcohol use?"

[@TheEmilyDBaker]

I think that is why they are bringing this in.

[@gratuitousumlaut1944]

It is so fascinating having come back to listen to these after the document unsealing and seeing just how much sniping happened between the lawyers prior. I feel like Elaine was taking her anger at Chew out on the witnesses.

[@sharroon7574]

So lawyers basically repeatedly ask you if you know what happened when you weren't there? Why can't they just make sure the jury understands that their witness only extends to when they were present. Honestly the fact that this needs to be said in the first place....

[@Sonicsis]

ANSWER THE QUESTION: DID YOU GROW WINGS?!

[@GeegeeBuggin]

That so called win for Umbridge was ABSOLUTELY lost on me. All I remember him saying was that he never witnessed Johnny ever being physical with anyone. I didn’t even make that distinction. In fact I found her so GRATING I started completely tuning her out. She is just so nasty for no reason it is disturbing.

[@kevv95]

man I was really hoping you did cover Shawn Bett's direct testimony

[@cunderw12]

Oh my word, why is Elaine talking to this man like that? He’s so relaxed and chill in his answers and she’s yelling at him like he’s been raising his voice, or talking back to her. lol almost like he’s in trouble. lmao 😂

[@constancebraun2251]

I love your commentary. You explain things so well.

[@kittie479]

Yes. But not every commentary is required. Like Emily went on and on abt the witness looking at the jury. Cuz we also wanna listen to what the witness has to say

[@kittie479]

And the but abt the wings

[@TheEmilyDBaker]

Thank you! 😊

[@constancebraun2251]

@@kittie479 so maybe there is another channel without commentary. I like and appreciate Emily's commentary.

[@kittie479]

@@constancebraun2251 not requiring some comments (eg 2 min on the hair) is not the same as not needing any commentaries at all. don't be so defensive

[@melissazabower339]

JD uses music in an earpiece -- as a novelist, I choose a "soundtrack" for the historical novel I'm working on. A novel with a host of Scottish immigrants, I listened to the Celtic Album from the City of Prague Philharmonic. For a novel set n the early 1900s coal country, it is waltz music, because that's when waltzing came into vogue I find it interesting that actors do the same.

[@annmariegrant4037]

@melissa zabower I do the same thing! Especially if I'm working on an intense scene that I really want to nail down, I play music that I feel matches the mood. Kenny's testament not only refuted the claims that Johnny was too drunk to work effectively, but reinforced how dedicted he was to his craft despite the turmoil in his personal life: a consummate professional.

[@VeroRochaEscorcio]

Has anybody else noticed johnny is starting to look younger and healthier now that he has escaped from the narcissistic abuse

[@Kiterpuss]

That witness has so much more composure than I ever will. If this waspy lass started making such vulgar statements to my face I'm not sure if I would laugh or be too shocked to answer.

[@HouseofStaci]

One other thing: I have come to learn that trials are games of strategy not about who is telling the truth (although that’s what we WANT to believe…that truth reigns in a trial and often it DOES). The whole game is performance in front of the judge and jury who don’t do any work on finding out facts-they await the attorneys to scurry around to tell the best story. And sometimes the story is just a story…but player one (trial attorney) was a better game player than player two (the other trial attorney). And that’s it. Whomever plays the game better is who wins regardless of ultimate truth. It’s about who played the better game. Is this fucked up thinking? It certainly has reduced my OUTRAGE at the judge and jury for not seeing through bullshit because they have to follow the rules of the game.

[@jettnatchez4776]

So true! It also revolves around money and whoever has more money has a great advantage. The lawyers will literally try to run you out of money so you can’t keep going. It’s a dirty dirty game of lies and money. Its not abt the truth or right

[@HouseofStaci]

@@jettnatchez4776 You are exactly right. I forgot to mention that. This also happens to be the reason that jails (private business that MUST have inmates to generate PROFIT) are NOT FILLED with RICH PEOPLE. The more money you make, the less likely you will go to jail. See also: The Financial Collapse at the hands of the leaders (?) in the industry who bilked BILLIONS from people and NONE OF THEM went to jail. Yet the dude who robbed a 7-11 of $150 to buy diapers and milk goes to jail FOR 7 YEARS. See also: Jeffrey Epstein

[@ErinJeanette]

If one has a great defense, but they're obviously guilty, I think that this wouldn't apply but otherwise true

[@chachachazki]

Elaine clearly hasn't worked on a production. Food and accommodation are the very basic anyone in the core crew gets when shooting on location. If she knew the length of the days and the amount of time you spend away from your family and friends and your hobbies, she would not be portraying that as luxury.

[@njlms]

Emily! Where is your reaction to Isaac Baruch’s testimony?

[@haute03]

She didn't go live that day, unfortunately. I would have loved to hear her thoughts on his testimony!

[@raffila]

I am glad I did live only for JD, because AH lawyer's cross of Wyatt (on replay) provoked terrible headache. Dunno how a jury could endure listening to that woman.

[@ShannonMcgowan-l5o]

The way Emily calls her birdhoff and umbridge is what I’m living for. 😂

[@sonjavandam1306]

Who is Umbridge.

[@StellaKnights]

JD can drink as much as he likes in the car , he doesnt drive himself :-)

[@msaaka8552]

What happens when the replay crew shows up early and finally catches a live stream... Emily, sign out already so I can catch up before you come back! 😉😁

[@sharlisify]

Yea same, I just waited till it finished

[@panda5122]

I'm surprised how many objections the judge is overruling when the questions have no foundation.

[@bce4au]

Oh my GOSH!!!! Attorney Miss Frizzle ROYALLY pisses me off. She is so abrasive & so condescending.

[@louiseplatiel5431]

Don't do the real Miss Frizzle dirty like that 😆

[@bce4au]

@@louiseplatiel5431 you’re right. Apologies to Miss Frizzle…she didn’t deserve that. 😂

[@overit6969]

That woman attorney is very very aggressive with the witness. Why aren't JD attorneys bringing that up?

[@TheEmilyDBaker]

They don't need to comment on it, the jury sees it in real time.

[@edenferriss768]

Yeah she is a real beeeyatch!

[@catscats664]

Which means that it is beneficial to JDs case, they want her to keep on doing what she doing because it makes her look bad. Likability is so important.

[@sallycinnamon5370]

@@catscats664 I agree. I particularly think it’s important in terms of optics when the root of the issue is if the aggressive lawyers client is an abuser. If the lawyer seems aggressive to the point of being abusive of the witnesses I feel like it would be natural to project a little bit of the character shown by the lawyer onto the client, since they are their mouthpiece …whether or not that is fair…seem natural to me

[@Jazzv13]

Commenting for the algorithm. Emily changed my life. Because of her I realized I had adhd and everything started changing from there. ❤❤❤❤thank you Queen Emily. Queen of the lawnerds

[@TheEmilyDBaker]

I’m so happy to hear it!! Understanding can bring so much change! 💜💜

[@barbaralondon8143]

Emily thanks for your response and clarification .I will try to be more patient while I listen to your analysis. While the Lawyers and Judge are having a Sidebat is a great time for you to give your critique . Thanks for your hard work! BL

[@BabyKangaroo279]

Lol. I'm watching days of the trial that I didn't watch with Emily's commentary. It's much more entertaining and tolerable. The mutual incredulity on cross-exam makes me feel less insane. And rewatching it makes me feel slimy whenever her lawyers come up. They really are trying to slip "evidence" and testify whenever they cross. It's super icky.

[@cmeblu75]

I don’t understand all the Paul Bettany “drug buddy” references by Elaine & AH. Paul Bettany is a family man who’s been married over 20+ yrs and is a very respected actor in his own right. AH lawyer is so incredibly annoying, but I notice that Ben Chew tends to argue objections similar to Elaine, but it’s hilarious Elaine “it’s not to offer the truth of the matter,” Ben “then what is it offered for?” 😂😂😂

[@fruktsodaadorable]

Haha, I've only ever seen American court scenes in films, and it's so weird seeing how it actually is, all the uh and ehm and the stammering 😅

[@klwflorida5438]

I cannot believe they pooped in his bed. If you did that to my bed you would be sueing me for assault! That is crazy! Sounds to me like he met his match this time. These Hollyhood people are out of control. Gascon has a select few ready to tattoo his name on their face!

[@SophYeff]

is there a time stamp? Im just wondering what this is referencing to, am i in for a horrible surprise whattt haha

[@Dozav7]

Love how The first witness mentions how the security footage could have miscalibrated times. Happens where I work all the time.

[@Kitaliae]

I don't fully care about this case but it lead me to you Emily, and I adore getting to see your perspective and have access to your amazing wealth of knowledge with a live trial. Thanks for shedding light on trials and our legal system! I never wanted to be a lawyer but I love learning about our legal system

[@trusttheuniverse9589]

How is it okay for them to bring up Depp past relationships, and his assault charge ( which I've heard was him defending someone). But they so far have been unable to bring up Ambers past DV charge?

[@T.Rex33]

Did you see how they snuck it in?

[@juliat9211]

I feel like the judge is a little biased here? Allowing things on behalf of Amber she shouldn’t?

[@crystalfarmer4074]

Trying to catch up now that the trial isn't live for a week. Didn't she say JD had put in all of his contracts that Mr. Wyatt be his sound guy? If so, then why did she ask if he knew about projects he didn't work on with JD? You can't say it's in JD contract that Mr. Wyatt be his sound guy & then point out projects he didn't work on with him. Like which is it Elaine?

[@Megumi646]

OH NO!!! NOT THE RED BULLS you got to be kidding me

[@cremepuffle]

oof i'm so glad you're professionally breaking this down. especially from an unbiased pov because it gives me a clearer view of where i stand. i very much want Johnnys story to get out. i'm not saying he is all the way a victim but i've seen what an abusive woman can do from experience of having brothers, so this case is important to me in that aspect. This will absolutely break down many walls for feminists to talk about some well overdue topics.

[@hazelangus]

Poor Mr Wyatt, he's a sound tech! How is he supposed to know about high-level production and budgeting questions? And asking how Disney was impacted??! Right, like Disney's going to tell all their private financial business to random low-level film crew. But thanks for establishing that nothing written in what you say are Johnny Depp's contracts are things that can be taken as having happened, Elaine. Like the transportation and accommodation items that never actually came into play on the contract you say is for a film that was shot locally. So, the entire paperwork you're using to make your arguments is irrelevant. Well done. 🤣

[@LadyBama]

It’s December 11, 2021, and I still find this entertaining while crocheting Christmas ornaments…I still believe that someone got their law degree out of a box of cereal.

[@alwayswondering127]

It’s a shame 3 days of the trail are no longer available to watch 😕

[@viviankroger]

Why is that? I've been trying to find Emily's lives on those days.

[@alwayswondering127]

@@viviankrogerI know this is late but I forgot she actually didn’t cover multiple days due to prior engagements.

[@lolabroadhead3972]

Quote of the Day, " Look at them, they will like you, you've got Good Hair "

[@percyackerman8313]

Johnny is an incredible actor. As an actor myself, listening to music (particularly one with lyrics) while acting is not easy. I can def get into character, but acting while listening to music?? amazing.

[@D-AMJ-C]

I worked with one of my abusers (yeah, I've had more than one, it's pretty sad) & he became mad @ me & was going about our building telling nearly everyone he could get to listen all sorts of terrible things about me (s*xual deviancy & that I was su*cidal & stuff). Maybe 4 different people came over to tell me what he'd told them (& how uncomfortable it made them) so I told the director of operations -- in charge of the entire building -- & do you know what he told me? "Well, I can't tell someone what they can & can't say, besides, he's one of our best workers, it's weird that he'd do that." This man had been harassing me for a long time, physically & verbally. I had to catch him on video before I was taken seriously, & then I was told I wasn't allowed to do that (which isn't true, in AZ you can record a conversation as long as one participant knows: me. Plus there was no company policy against it... however, not long after that, the company actually wrote it into policy that you couldn't record people @ work). And not long after a camera was installed & caught the guy harassing me & he had to be fired, I was fired too. So, yeah. That's my don't rock the boat story.

[@Della624]

I think the impeachment would have got lost in her abrasiveness because it was like she kept clubbing the witness over the head until he said, "alright alright, I give up what is it you want me to say?" Well, that's the impression Elaine gave off to me.

[@jlebo001]

Unbelievable. That CROSS!!! 1:33;48 - how is that not the lawyer testifying???!!! 🤐

[@weaverbee2808]

I don’t know why I am putting myself through this again, but I only caught your feed on the last few weeks of trial and wanted to see all your reactions! Worth it for time stamp 1:02:00! If the lawyer is unliked and the witness snaps back?😂😂😂😂 Oh little did we know!!! I honestly laughed out loud!!

[@madisonimogen6509]

I’ve started to come back to this case as I didn’t watch the first couple of weeks. I work in film and TV, watching her ask him about pay, benefits, and per diems is so frustrating 😅 any crew that isn’t local to an area is put up in accomodation, per diems are given plus food is provided via catering on set/location during filming days. Travel is also usually paid for, organised for crew or crew is reimbursed (depending on contract type). This is normal and expected practice.

[@amandahaught4625]

I have to say, I just found you and I absolutely love your commentary!

[@JeanMarie561]

Combo of live and replay… I live for the commentary!

[@hallythejester1234]

as to the impeachment: I don’t think it was fair. What I saw was Keenan being asked if he was aware of anyone accusing Johnny of violence, then (keenan) him saying no, then the lawyer telling him about that suit, then asserting that Keenan lied. Lady, what I gathered was that the only reason Keenan knew about that suit was because *you told him* AFTER he expressed that he had not heard of anyone else accusing Johnny of this (no pun intended). How is that fair

[@sharlisify]

The mental game amber is playing with copying depps outfits is disturbing

[@stellairis1782]

Hi 😊 Emily D. Baker...my favourite channel here...!!!! So informative and real ! Thank you ❤...and love the snark 😂 and the cursey words🎉 you are my hero 🎉

[@7beauties161]

Emily your commentating is killing me., cant stopped laughing. Also, thank you for streaming this!

[@impastomusic]

Replay crew here! I didn’t realize you were streaming all day so I watched Legal Bytes’ coverage. But now I’m rewatching for your commentary

[@cmay7429]

I write, and I totally have soundtracks for my characters. I also like to play exciting music while I'm editing action scenes. :D

[@lalala3566]

34:12 - “was mr depps lateness a problem for the crew?” “Objection hearsay” 1:25:40- “how many of the crew memebers were impacted by Johnny not being able to be there after the finger was cut off?” Is that not the same thing ???

[@RebeccaSpillane]

"Problem" could imply their thoughts on the matter, like I have a problem with you and I don't like how you are behaving. "How many" is asking for a number and "impacted" is more about actions that happened because of, not individual person's thoughts on the matter.

[@Cdwny]

I'm going through some of your older videos and you comments on this one are killing me :)

[@amyames1979]

Watching the replay… AH attorney to witness, “Did you hear JD say….wet pussy?” Emily D Baker, “y’all remember to do the KZbiny things.” 😂😂😂 I’M DEAD!

[@IHQAE]

By the way Emily she (Amber) refused to actually file one, she didn’t even really want to talk to the second pair of officers.

[@rainingtacos3135]

I love how Emily talks I know she wouldn't talk like this in court but I love to think of her swearing and sassy in court

[@veronica978]

How the heck could he pass out and kick her... if he was that messed up he wouldn’t have the coordination to kick someone even more so in the back

[@kirielbranson4843]

It was a 14 hour flight plenty of time to do a lot of things including getting a full nights sleep, watch a few movies, get into a fist fight. But I don’t know if half of the stuff said happened on that flight was ever testified on enough for me to believe some of that happened.

[@veronica978]

@@kirielbranson4843 I honestly don't see a flight with an ex cop and marine would stand by and watch a man beat up a woman. And then she said he threw her into a glass table the same time Jerry "saw" her nose bleeding.

[@rose-rs5ul]

Emily the girl sho said she was watching they later found out she was watching old information from the other trial. That is when they discovered the girl looking on her phone and giving the information out. They say the judge was furious about the girl with the phone.

[@tarampryce1372]

I binged you because you get so happy when it happens. thar and because I really like how you walk us through it all

[@Anjeecm]

This case is my favorite go to when I can't find anything else on youtube! LOL quick question though I wonder why Amber's DV arrest was not allowed in? Camille mentioned it at some point but the actual paperwork was never allowed in and I wonder why that is

[@smortalz6371]

Replay crew here, thanks for your coverage!

[@oppsyikesreally]

Emily, You are new to me. I’ve recently watched a few of your videos and I have to tell you I love how authentic you are! I love to hear your explanations but when you are sharing screen and there is dialogue on the screen and you are speaking at the same time, it’s difficult to hear both you and the shared screen. Can we turn that share screen volume just a tad?