Designing the TF2 Weapons My Fans Created

Nowadays it seems everyone and their mother has weapon ideas for TF2. But sadly, many of the good concepts seem to get drowned out in the seemingly infinite pool of terrible ones. So let's try to fix that! In this video, I took some custom TF2 weapons my fans created in my Discord channel, tweaked them a bit to make them more balanced, and designed what they might look like if they were added to the game. While definitely not all of them were like this, overall I was impressed with the weapon concepts that made the video. They were pretty interesting mix-ups for the class they were on and would change their gameplay significantly. If you want to submit your own, the Discord link is in the copypasta below.
Join the community!
Patreon: / greatblue
My other channel: / @bluesnest
Steam group: steamcommunity.com/groups/GreatBlueHeron
Discord: discord.gg/TFVcZUR
Twitch: / greatblue
Outro music by liledix4: • 🎵 Graze the Roof ︱ PvZ...
0:00 Intro
0:34 Weapon 1 - Scout baseball launcher
15:48 Weapon 2 - Scout fire throwable
25:46 Weapon 3 - Medic splash healing throwable
36:59 Overview and outro
Also thanks to QCubic, DRAGONFLAIR, and Abunchoftrash for letting me steal their weapons!
Let me know if you like the new format for this type of video (vector illustration instead of drawing, gameplay next to weapons, etc). I wanted to update everything to be closer to my current stuff, but I'm willing to change it back.

[@dropkick9547]

Funnily enough the Scout Molotov indirectly buffs the Volcano Stick, and actually gives it a purpuse

[@darksuperganon]

It could also pair with an Axtinguisher Pyro because ironically Scout's molotov is better at lighting lots of people on fire all at once than the Gas Passer. Scouts throws the molotov and then both him and a friendly Pyro go clean up with melees if that's a thing you really wanted to do.

[@Goat_gamering]

It is sun on a stick but yes

[@IM_WICKXD]

@feketenorbert9421 "uhm actually it's sun on a stick" 🤓

[@hankandianbrown7363]

@@Goat_gamering honestly I like volcano stick better

[@StitchPen]

@@IM_WICKXD Aaaahhhh SHAAADUP.

[@OPGrace2199]

Honestly the Hot! Bottle seemed a lot more like a beaker of Magma than a potion so my mind went to some kind of failed Saxton Hale hot sauce that was literally just lava but eventually recalled. Imagine if it was like a bottle of A1 or Tapatío instead of a Molotov

[@Henrex2000]

A hot sauce bottle used as a Molotov

[@apossiblyhereticalalphaleg3595]

Saxton Hale using lava as hot sauce is quite possibly the most on-brand thing I can imagine as well!

[@AgentTasmania]

MANNbasco. Gotcha!jang Many options for name tags for the user's favourite brands, varieties, and puns thereupon.

[@cetadel6597]

Real Mann's Flaming Sauce

[@thanoid2373]

TBH it should have been a molotov in a soda can, some sort of "spicy" critacola or something

[@scylorn]

The curveball is a perfect name and it is on par with all of the valve names. Nothing wrong with it.

[@AbruptAvalanche]

I feel like it would be kinda weird since the pitching machine doesn't actually throw curveballs though.

[@doctormedic2682]

@@AbruptAvalanche I mean they sorta do. Technically they (can) throw sliders, but in terms of naming; close enough

[@RazzBeri1]

also fits because the curveball is drastically different from all the other primaries, it’s literally throwing a spanner in the works.

[@gabegunderman482]

I also thought the name 'The Perfect Pitch' was a good idea.

[@jc_art_]

​@@gabegunderman482 that actually sounds great, but maybe itd be better suited as a scout cosmetic name. Idk what the cosmetic would be but something to do with being a singer i assume. Idk, tf2 names almost always have double meanings, and the phrase 'perfect pitch' already has 2 meanings, so itd just make sense to be used for something with relevancy to both meanings, rather than just the one.

[@angiovanni7356]

The Molotov could be a scout AND pyro weapon, first because fire, obviously, but as a weapon for the fire of revolution cosmetic set added in the most recent case, as that has a Molotov too

[@Appletank8]

And be a lot less utter garbage than the Gas Passer.

[@tosdy8480]

I think it would fit well on the heavy because it would work well with the huo long heater

[@novaseer]

@@Appletank8 meanwhile mvm

[@Caliburn_]

The Scout Molotov combined with the Sun on a Stick would actually be such a fun combo

[@DRAGONFLAIR2008]

thats why i made it

[@AverageBreastMilkEnjoyer]

Imagine running the medical solution with the crossbow and the quick fix. It would feel like the enemy team is just straight not dying.

[@CrackHeadGaming1029]

If it gets in the game, the poor f@%k to fight a Black-box & Conch soldier WITH that pocket medic should be financially compensated

[@eliasdex1236]

I think giving The Physician's Fix the stat "Removes debuffs from teammates" (similar to shield charges) would be a cool addition!

[@Mai.Calico]

Nice animations.

[@thealmightyidiot9574]

I think that would be a good addition I would also add the part that it would or wouldn’t (I don’t really know which would be better) gain UberCharge to compare it to the Ubersaw

[@epicblue00]

So just a fuck pyro tool

[@RandarTheBarbarian]

I don't think we can add anything to it, I think the idea is super OP as is, but I could be wrong. As a replacement for the secondary it's balanced by the crossbow and mostly fine, but as a replacement for melee it gives you, IMO, too much utility. You've got your short range team heal in the medi gun, your self defense plus additional self heal in the blutsager, and (while yes, on a cooldown) short range AOE team/self heal plus enemy damage.

[@torgerthorkildson725]

It would also just be an upgrade to the amputater

[@sgtpepper861]

I’d say an interesting mechanic for the “All-Star’s cannon” could be that successive hits decrease charge time (maxing out at say 5 and a 5-10% increase per hit)

[@Goat_gamering]

I think it would be a bit too dragon's fury with that

[@jamesmorrison6204]

I thought an interesting mechanic would be the reversed damage falloff like the Crossbow.

[@qcubic]

One idea that I had was to gain your shot back if you get a hit, which I think would be a better replacement for the faster firing speed Blue implemented on my weapon

[@Epic-ft2bg]

The fact he found the baseball launcher image from a tf2 clone of all things is insane Edit: holy crap this blew up overnight

[@RealErdenman]

"Yeah!" -Scout

[@Mai.Calico]

Funny how that those developers had the same idea as great blue

[@odl3144]

Typical colors 2

[@theflyingfish66]

He also didn't recognize the weapon in the "All-Star Cannon" image the user posted, he thought it was a modern suppressed submachine gun when it's clearly a Can Cannon upper on an AR15 (a big tube you can put on an AR15 that fires soda cans and tennis balls using 5.56 blanks)

[@smolbrendan5978]

the "baseball launcher" is actually just the default Snowball Cannon gear from 2009. they did not make that design

[@rexanderson4585]

I'm pretty sure that so-called suppressed carbine was actually a picture of a can Cannon which is basically a gun that fires cans out of it by you loading blanks into the magazine and a can into the enlarged barrel

[@manitoba-op4jx]

yeah that was an AR with a can cannon upper lol

[@sorararah]

I can now imagine a second variation of the weapon except, instead of shooting baseballs, it shoots cans of BONK! so it's a real weapon type

[@epicassassin8502]

@@sorararah charge it up to launch cans of crit o cola

[@lukelofquist3734]

You are correct. But I'm pretty sure the can cannon was invented in the 2000's. Tf2 canonically takes place at around the ww2/cold war era.

[@epicassassin8502]

@@lukelofquist3734 china lake loaded with cans

[@NuclearNecro]

i'm still shocked that we never had a molotov item for the scout, despite his personality and him having offensive throwables with the guillotine i actually had an idea similar to the one in the video for the molotov weapon in a dream, except it was named "The Extra-spicy Shake" and it had a 10 second recharge instead

[@mrsentrybuster]

Also the sun on a stick might actually not rely on other people to be almost-not-useless

[@gabrielbarron7667]

@@mrsentrybuster i didnt even think about the combos with the sun on a stick. with that you could oneshot any class thats not a heavy or a soldier and leave the soldier at something like 20 health after all the afterburn.

[@aibadenshi]

It's basically a AoE Guillotine that assist friendly Pyro with Free Crit and make the sun on the stick OP due to it being the Bushwacka combo for scout.

[@mrsentrybuster]

See, this gives the sun on a stick attention

[@robuxyyyyyyyyyy4708]

Anarchist scout

[@lukizard9625]

Scout with the power to light enemies on fire would give the sun on a stick an actual use

[@meeedicthethird6423]

That basicly what jarate bushwacka combo is, but now insted of a slow sniper that you could outrun, you have a scout that always does crits. Maybe the sun stick from hell would need a nerf

[@pacifistminigun3987]

@@meeedicthethird6423 i personally think the "molotov" Simply shouldn't deal splash damage, but just set on fire. That way, the Stick can no longer one shot weak classes

[@bitcidic]

⁠@@meeedicthethird6423 the reason that combo is stupid on sniper is because sniper is intended to be weak in close range combat, wherease with scout it fits a lot better. For example, the axtinguisher works with pyro because he’s intended to be close range. Although I still agree with you that the sun on a stick even with the molotov is poorly designed. One weapon that basically relies you have one other specific weapon equipped to work is pretty bad design. Scout running at you with his melee is a lot easier to deal with than you’d think, and the crits have to be worth it over scattergun meatshots which is not easy to do without it being broken

[@adversarry]

Designing weapons in TF2 have always seemed like a strange case to me

[@darker8484]

I hate you, have my like and LEAVE.

[@cheesepop7175]

Top comments have always seemed like a strange case to me

[@cheesepop7175]

Replies have always seemed like a strange case to me

[@3st3ban70]

this joke won't stop being funny

[@muffinman9018]

@@3st3ban70 These jokes have always seemed like a strange case to me

[@hoofly1323]

Another way the Peaceful Protest (The Molotov) could be styled is as a Bonk! soda bottle, and it could be called "The Fanboy's Firebomb". I do really enjoy the look of the ale bottle but I just think it'd be another interesting styling

[@smallangrycrab]

Scout being given a way to ignite enemies unironically provides more of a genuine use to the sun on a stick.

[@DRAGONFLAIR2008]

yes yes it does thats why i made it

[@eloquence_4143]

I think the All-Star’s Cannon was originally intended to be a T-Shirt Cannon, since the flavor text reads that it was “repurposed for the distribution of your favorite sports merchandise”, though baseballs would also make some sense in this context.

[@qcubic]

As the creator of it, it was actually meant to fire soda cans like some rifle accessories have. Just look up "soda can launcher" and you'll get a general idea whay I was going for

[@yourfriendlyneighborhoodsc1447]

for the 2 medic weapons, I think one neat mechanic would be combining them both. what if you had the jar, then you can press right click to shake it or something and swap between the effects.

[@rafouk6867]

and like you have a 3 seconds countdown to swap it back

[@afasdfasafd314]

damn, i like that, but both would have to be nerfed bad to be balanced

[@thepixelartists5756]

@@afasdfasafd314 the thing is, I don't think they need to be nerfed, *it would compete with the übersaw for the melee slot*

[@qcubic]

Hey Blue, thanks for the mention for my weapon concept! I'll be sure to take the advice you've given for future weapon concepts!

[@DRAGONFLAIR2008]

hello fellow concepter

[@qcubic]

@DRAGONFLAIR2008 Oh hey man!

[@DRAGONFLAIR2008]

@@qcubic howdy

[@ChaseVaccaro-ge3gk]

I think you could do some good shit. Maybe try a Soldier primary? They're easy to balance, and it seems perfect considering your idea was a projectile.

[@lambsauce5312]

He ruined ur weapon imo, not being able to 2 tap a medic (SCOUT'S BREAD AND BUTTER) is very stupid It should do like 70-120 damage, with huntsmanesque velocity and charge time, and maybe like a shot every second?

[@cook_it]

Imagine if he had made a molo-bonk instead of a molotov, that would fit scout way more and also explains the "explosion damage" with metal frags flying around (the can doesn't break afterall when thrown).

[@Oxygen1004]

"Bonk! Nuclear Blast"

[@badideagenerator2315]

There's a tf2 inspired roblox game where the scout class has a throwable soda can that causes the target's head hitbox to expand

[@jackhe760]

@@badideagenerator2315flappy men

[@diamond_assasion8291]

Other people have said the first weapon is a soda can cannon but if we want to keep the sports motif of scout then mannco modified t-shirt cannon “Designed for even the largest of stadiums” “do not point at face”

[@FIVEBASKET]

This will be a great series

[@alphabattack]

Scout's weapon SHOULD be a T shirt cannon so it doesn't overlap with the sandman

[@aduckwalkeduptoalemonadestand]

Source could break in Medieval mode if you replace the bone saw

[@budcat64xd88]

Then make the replacement not allowed in medieval mode.

[@Brokendog-wt4ul]

How.

[@aduckwalkeduptoalemonadestand]

@@Brokendog-wt4ul You can't not have a weapon in the Source engine

[@purplehaze2358]

If there's any class that should get a molotov, it'd probably be demo. Seriously, they're literally weaponized alcohol that explodes, it'd fit perfectly for him.

[@dovahkat9635]

Counterpoint: Demo would never waste perfectly good alcohol by burning it. If he's burning it, that means he's not drinking it!

[@badideagenerator2315]

@Dovahkat963 make it a lunchbox item that gives him incendiary grenades/stickies in exchange for being 50% more vulnerable to fire damage when he drinks it.

[@nuherbleath461]

You should name the Molotov “dads wine”

[@kwableguy9795]

For the first weapon, I think a better idea for increasing firing speed would be to take an idea from the Dragon's Fury and have the firing speed dramatically increase after you successfully hit someone, and keep the base firing speed slower like on the original concept. (Maybe there could be an additional stipulation, for example you only get the boosted firing speed if you hit a charged shot)

[@qcubic]

One of my first reworks to my idea was to gain your shot back on a successful hit, and I think that would've been the best approach since it's pretty simple

[@I_am_ENSanity]

I love how the picture for the first idea wasn't a suppressed AR15 but an actual can cannon. They are a blast to shoot!

[@qcubic]

Thanks man!

[@keyboardspam1458]

For the medic weapon I tried to give a name that played off both of the submitted designs. Considering they are similar weapons I wanted to give them similar names that reflect their purpose, either supportive for the healing, or offensive with the crits. With that I mind I submit the twin names of The Therapist's Tonic for the healing, and The Tormentor's Tincture for the crits.

[@oygemprime3864]

The pneumatic rifle would probably hide a lot of its stats the way the Shortstop does, we think that's a remnant of Valve at some point intending to add more 'pepperbox' class weapons instead of 'scattergun' class weapons but that's based on pretty much nothing

[@Zander2212]

I think the intention for the launcher was to be like a Tshirt cannon (like you see at sports events), but I like the idea of launching Baseballs. Maybe one of those would have made for a more interesting base for the visual design?

[@totallynottoaster1114]

The user’s intention was a can cannon, it’s an AR-15 with an enlarged barrel that you load cans into the barrel allowing you to take a magazine of blank firing 5.56 ammo to launch the cans, user likely wanted the projectile to be a Bonk! can.

[@Zander2212]

@TotallyNotToaster I figured Tshirt cannon based off of the description before the rebalance, which mentions it was used by Mannco to launch merchandise.

[@qcubic]

​@@Zander2212 Nah, the dude's right. It was a can cannon

[@Herr_T]

@@totallynottoaster1114 Just from how Blue was talking it doesn't seem like he's familiar with firearms. But that didn't stop me from yelling at my screen for that whole section

[@0ne678]

I feel like the Medic throwable would be incredibly helpful regarding uber pushes, as usually when you use stock uber or kritzkrieg you won’t have the chance to heal another teammates. What this does is allow Medic to essentially give his entire team constant healing before pushing in with an ubercharge, and not have to worry about any of them dying.

[@lunchtime_mmmmmmm]

For the scout cannon maybe in order to avoid 3 uncharged shots being fired really quickly you could add a firing speed increase after every fully charged shot, or an increase just dependent on the charge

[@Samael3110]

Weapon Concepts in TF2 have always seemed like a strange case to me. On one hand there are a lot of great ideas floating around the community. But on the other hand, Valve never pays the game any attention, so these never have a chance of making it into the game.

[@robuxyyyyyyyyyy4708]

Tf2 is a victim of valve's poor corporate structure

[@phoonwax]

but tf2 classic exists and people are crazy enough to add custom weapons to that though most of the servers i see are pretty ridiculous

[@meadnex331]

crossbow, quick fix, and surgical solution/physicians fix. absolutely perfect loadout. if they let this weapon get in the game this will be my medic loadout

[@SkywayFishers]

I think in addition to the Curveball there should be a function that discourages charging and holding a full powered shot like how the Demoman's fully charged sticky bomb fires automatically. That function may have been implied, seeing as how you drew parallels between it and the sticky bomb launcher often, but I feel like I should explicitly say it just in case.

[@jaredparks4713]

There's a medic melee on the workshop that's a beaker full of liquid complete with a shattered model like Demo's bottle. You could potentially take the Surgical Solution and make it a support melee akin to the Disciplinary Action, with splash healing as a "one-and-done" effect like the Ullapool Caber (probably with a recharge).

[@MrDrpoptart]

For the first concept I think it would've been a cool idea if it was a shirt cannon like you see in big league games. Yes it was invented in the 90s, but they used slingshot versions before that (didn't have enough range originally) which could also be a downside too

[@zeehaye]

The medic jar seems op, specifically in a competitive environment. Medic is pretty vulnerable to being bombed in competitive settings and he rarely has the opportunity to use his melee anyway. The self heal would really help him survive being jumped and the bleed would be really annoying for spies to deal with. Especially on payload defense, where most spies sit and wait for an opportunity to stab the medic, him being able to randomly throw a bleed around whenever he wants seems a bit much.

[@badideagenerator2315]

Who cares about comp though

[@Buglin_Burger7878]

@@badideagenerator2315 These situations they list aren't exclusive to comp though.

[@Drunken_Hamster]

Bro really channeled his inner 2020/2021 with that molotov name. Also, the launcher image wasn't a suppressed rifle, it was something called a "can cannon" which uses blanks to launch FILLED soda cans 100+ yards.

[@naughtymelon6712]

Heres a funky little idea I had for a weapon called the Blast Nozzle: Upsides: +10% air blast push force +100% ammo capacity Unique Mechanic: Air blast deals push force to the pyro wielding it when fired on solid ground Downsides: Air blast becomes primary fire, as the weapon can ONLY use air blasts My idea for this weapon is that it would act as a purely supportive tool. It allows the pyro to essentially rocket jump (although it is a much weaker version of a real rocket jump) and the increased ammo capacity plus increased push force opens up the doorway for you to extinguish more teammates and push more enemy players away. However, with it being a PURELY supportive tool, it also comes with the downside of taking away the pyros entire gimmick. The weapon literally ONLY has airblasts.

[@dexterity494]

For the all-star's cannon, it feels like it's supposed to be based on the scattergun's 10x6 base damage. This is a little strange, because it doesn't mention a pellet reduction, which means technically it's supposed to be 10x5.4, but given it's based on a t-shirt launcher, I'm going to assume it's a single pellet projectile. So on the base stats, it's missing -90% pellets, +900% damage. edit: just realized the opening blurb about the projectile says "fires projectile... instead of pellets" so yeah, it's one projectile dealing 60-10% instead of 10x6-10%

[@qcubic]

Yep, all stats were based off of the scattergun

[@itscznben8728]

this needs a sequel.

[@carrotsandcats]

I love that you put some much time and efforts in this video, even recreating custom icons for the weapons. Good job !

[@Gensolink]

i really love the physician fix concept, would be interesting to give medic more stuff he can do differently, like you would have the reliable but close ranged medigun, the long ranged crossbow and the jar that could be lobed around ledges and stuff. That's 2 different kind of projectile you have to train yourself to use and it could also mean that running crossbow might not be just as a default pick as now, I still think medic should have more interesting stuff on needle gun slots tho

[@GGgentlemen]

I think a silenced shotgun for heavy would be epic. Like the one Anton Chigurh uses. No idea what the stats would be but it would be named something like The One Right Tool.

[@Themanwhoatethecorndogs]

For the “silent” part I say either a pretty quiet firing sound, or no hit indicator.

[@Uprank]

Would love for you to hire a source mod/vscript developer to actually visualize and make these useable!

[@arsonistnpc]

fun silly goofy advice for making good molotov cocktails (in minecraft) that isn't illegal to know but is illegal to put into practice in the usa (in minecraft) so definitely dont: -if using alcohol, use the highest proof you can get your hands on (ideally 100%) ~gasoline isn't the best on its own cuz it burns well but doesnt last long- you'll get an initial explosion but not much else. mix with roofing tar or motor oil(?) for it to last longer (and get bonus points, cuz it'll stick to the target!) ~kerosene/paraffin works well, as you can guess cuz its a lamp oil ~you don't need to fill the bottle all the way. 3/4 should be enough -most wine bottles are designed to not break when dropped, so they aren't the best to use. beer bottles are better, or even mason jars! (you can always score a bottle first to make it weaker, though do be careful because you're cutting glass and if you go too far you might cause leaking or just break the bottle altogether) -the wick used (whatever rag you're lighting before throwing; avoid synthetic materials) should only be two or so inches long outside of the bottle, with most of it being inside soaking up the liquid. you just need the fire to last long enough to ignite the fuel when the bottle breaks! Make sure to pack the wick tightly in the mouth of the bottle so nothing spills -right before lighting and throwing the molotov, quickly turn (and then un-turn) the bottle upside-down to soak the wick a little. light it and then throw it IMMEDIATELY! ~when throwing, make sure to aim at hard surfaces instead of soft ones. Sure, a bush would be a good target for starting a fire, but the bottle is much more likely to break when it hits the ground beneath it instead of the thin branches. also, remember this is only for minecraft pvp so never do this in real life, but the pavement beneath a person's feet is a much better target than the person themself. ~throw overhand, like a throwing axe! you'll get more force compared to underhand. but remember this is all stuff that's only for minecraft and not real life and possession of a molotov cocktail is totally illegal so like never make one. but its totally cool to write this information down! (in minecraft, of course) edit: stupid youtube putting strikethroughs

[@0Cocoron0]

Just found your channel and this was my favorite video so far, I love watching you design the weapons in illustrator as well! More like this would ve great

[@LimeonCandy]

The curveball's final design kinda seems something like a scout's huntsman

[@qcubic]

I didn't realize that in the making of it until now

[@livsbian]

I think the molotov would make for a good alternative for the mad milk in mvm for a more damage focused scout

[@Cow-Moth-With-A-CRT-Head]

My first thought when I saw the first weapon was "front loading t-shirt cannon" based on the provided flavor text, but the baseball launcher you ended up with looks amazing! I can easily imagine the reload animation being Scout using the thing under the barrel like a pump action, and the gun shakes a bit when it's ready to fire again.

[@yoshifan33]

I definitely saw it as a T-shirt cannon too.

[@jadynandchara640]

a pretty fun idea for the scout molotov I had was a throwable with 60 extra switch speed (in general like the old degrease), sets enemies on fire and deals 20 damage in the radius of a rocket or the jarate. It recharges every 20 seconds and damage dealt decreases the timer (50:1, a full meatshot would decrease the timer by around 12.50 seconds) and the main idea is to run in and out of battle dousing enemies in the molotov and running back in to pick them off with your scatter. This would be a good alternative playstyle for scouts wanting to have some effect on a whole group of enemies rather than being a 1v1 master. It would also pair really well with the soda popper and soas, since melee covers the soda popper's low sustainability and the molotov validates the stick's schdict. It's trade off is worse 1v1 duels since 20 damage isn't all that much considering the reason you've switched to your secondary is because you beefed your scatter shots. It would also work worse in competitive formats since people will generally be more spread out to reduce splash damage, and most comp lobbies are 6v6 or 7v7 anyway. It would lose the mid to long range harrassment capabilities of stock, but it could work around this by being spammed mid-1v1 if you can manage to aim the splash away from the person you're fighting, meatshot the guy, then throw it again.

[@itscznben8728]

you should continue your random weapon generator drawing series.

[@bigmangeorgie7952]

I had this idea for a new snapper for spy Similar to the red tape recorder, the sapper does not kill the sentry, but instead after maybe 15 seconds swaps its team colour and becomes a new entity (as in the engineer cant destroy or buff it since it belongs to the other team). And then after maybe 30 seconds after it switches it would self destruct. And to make it more balanced, the sapper only works on sentries and removes the spies disguise or something. Sounds too op though They could figure out a way to balance it

[@JarthenGreenmeadow]

I think it would be cool but I think a slight delay to its firing speed would be in order and slower holster speed too. That way you're having to aim/choose more carefully which building you sap and cant just spam into the engie nest like a regular sapper and then easily switch to a knife to stab and steal the sentry. Basically make it require slightly more skill and be easier to punish but have the new utility of team switching. Also make it so friendly engies can heal it but not upgrade it or move it, so if its a level 2 sentry thats all you get. I dont think it should last only 30 seconds because sentries without an engie to heal them are weak anyway.

[@awppackwheedle]

Good job designing these. Keep going man, it’s looking good.

[@kirbythewizard101]

I would LOVE to see more of these videos, this was great!

[@minekraftminer-5252]

9:03 As a typical colors player, seeing the game make any kind of cameo in a video, makes me really happy for some reason.

[@leodaoust8035]

im just wondering how the fuck he landed there

[@RedFragmentation]

Custom weapons are always such an interesting thing to explore, I just wish Valve handed over the games updates to the community but part of me knows it's too good to be true.

[@aibadenshi]

Good idea. But it will be somewhat horrible on practice.

[@jey5806]

Custom weapons in the tf2 community has always been a strange case to me

[@RedFragmentation]

​@@aibadenshi Depends how it's done y'know? I would love to see more community made maps brought into the rotation. Custom weapons may just be too much for the base game though

[@RedFragmentation]

@@jey5806 You'll need a 5$ key to unlock it, sorry

[@aibadenshi]

@@RedFragmentation Yes. But the community it's own worst enemy on how thing should be done. So I don't have high hope for them to work.

[@KeepCalmSoldierOn]

It's worth noting for weapon one that's a firearm called the "can cannon", it's a blank firing adapter for ARs that allows you to shoot cans

[@maxschumacher9446]

Your vector art is looking great! Really works well with the TF2 style, reminds me of the flat, colour-blocked shading you see on old posters .

[@m3rcules580]

The AR thing is called a can cannon and it came before the nerf tennis ball launcher

[@MrSlizzard]

The names are great. Great job on this vid.

[@Oooze3424]

I've thought of several spy secondaries that would be like... ya'know like how solider has his banners 'n' boots, demo has shields, scout has throwable, but spy has only one secondary and it's just the normal sapper but worse at everything except frontier justice engi's so here are some that would shake things up a little: -The Daily Doctor Deterrent, a throwable apple that reduces medic uber if you can hit them or their patient. -The Deadly Dosage. a vial of poison that can be used to poison medkits, making anyone who picks them up marked for death for 8 seconds. the poisoned medkits have their blue replaced with red and their red cross replaced with the marked for death symbol so that you can tell them apart. -and The Fake Friend, a deployable that would create one of the wooden class cutouts that for the enemy appears as a rival teammate of your choosing standing still with their primary out. if it's a heavy, its revving and if it's a sniper, it's scoped.

[@ItsEvanHere]

Honestly I think BiNC would have been a really cool weapon concept of it got tweaked a bit. Not only would it completely Scout’s Soda trilogy, but it would add a unique effect that would be well utilized. Here are my tweaked BiNC stats: + Dealing damage increases BiNC meter + + On Full BiNC Bar: Drink to gain +15% movement speed and +50% damage resistance vs sentrys for 10 seconds + + Dealing damage under BiNC effects will give recharge to all meters + - Dealing damage under BiNC effects increases damage vulnerability vs players, capping at 50% - - -50% BiNC recharge when Dealing damage with BiNC - • BiNC recharges based on damage output, taking less damage to recharge depending on damage output with last BiNC effects •

[@CentipedeChan]

The design stuff is my favorite tbh. There's lots of things I never thought about with my own ideas for weapons and how they'd affect the rest of the game and the class

[@Kool65Dude]

I just realised with the medic bottle. TF2 might be in violation of the geneva convention

[@lunarpitch]

i was looking for this comment

[@MayoTF2]

"and other types of books that have words in them" ah yes, my favourite reading book, pictures.

[@tigerlover2853]

Yo! This is really cool! Amazing job!

[@moritamikamikara3879]

The All-star's cannon appears to be a can-cannon. It's an AR-15 modification with a cup on the front end. You stick a soda can or beer can in the end and load a blank into the chamber, the gasses from the blank yeet the soda can through the air. So not quite a pneumatic gun, it's still gunpowder, but it's cool as shit, and yes, it can fire baseballs.

[@Biddybud]

Dang, it's been a while since I watched this type of content. I do hope you continue with this type of content, it's very entertaining

[@charlesmieth2467]

Missed opportunity to call it the Teutonic Tonic

[@gmanplaysgames256]

you could call the molotov "Like Father, Like Sun" in reference to Spy and his fancy wine

[@urielsantiago8395]

When you talked about the baseball launcher I immediately started to think of the pitching machine weapon from let it die, like a wrist mounted pitching machine that kinda needs to rev up like a mini gun but the longer you fired it the faster the projectiles shoot out

[@M_orcan]

Great video! I feel like that scout primary could also be a t-shirt cannon

[@OMEGARunner-C.AMI.EXE_ORCA]

I feel like The Surgical Solution seems like the kind of thing you would throw out of panic while a screaming trolldier just commits an air raid on you lol (I feel like The Ludwig Solution [Just like Benedict's Solution] could be a good rename for it)

[@girlie_p0p]

Recommending the name The Fifth Humor for the Medic throwable, as a reference to the four humors of older humoral theory, in a fun twist, they’re actually real and Medic discovered a new one!

[@iliakatster]

All-star cannon seems like the perfect name, its baseball themed and describes what it does pretty well

[@qcubic]

Thanks man!

[@PantheraLeo04]

I really love these weapon design/rebalance videos.

[@MFlari]

Some words on the jars: I think that, if you do a second episode, should totally remix the minicrit medic jar, as I think it could be an interesting challenge to differentiate it from the prescription. Another idea of mine was having the medic throwable able to replace either the secondary or melee. This move would pair well with my previous idea: perhaps the blue jar would give minicrits to the medic, who would then ubersaw a nearby demo to death or smth. The throwables for medic in general just open up so many doors.

[@Rdotmop]

I actually also had an idea for a throwable Medic primary recently, although mine involved having a bread monster inside like the Self Aware Beauty Mark and the Mutated Milk. It would deal damage over time via the bread monster biting them, but like the cosmetic bread monsters on the reskins it would only be on a direct hit, and otherwise the enemies would only get like some sort of debuff. You could also have it recharge based on healing instead of over time, but it wouldn't really change much. This mostly stemmed from me wanting the Medic to have a bread monster item since he was actually experimenting with it in Expiration Date

[@aidengray3998]

A class that specialises in hit and run massive burst damage. Medium health, melee exclusive, a schmoovment mechanic akin to a shield charge, and a tagger which, after waiting some number of seconds, allows you and only you to run back in and instantly crush your opponent like a beer can, no matter the health, blockable only by uber. You must give the tag time to mature, and if you swing early the tag is erased and must be reapplied.

[@benthebamboozler4104]

I think the all-star cannon was supposed to be a T-Shirt cannon, the kind you see mascots using

[@cheetoman4690]

24:03 “books that have words in them” - Great Blue, 2023

[@VincentRoyceMorgan]

Man, designing weapons for TF2 is a fun hobby. Having to make sure everything is taken into account makes for a good mental challenge. You know, talking things like competitive and MvM. Giving scout more fire-based weapons is also a curious addition but for some reason those two classes always had this vague connection to each other. The Physicians Fix doing damage and bleed the in an area makes it a spy-checking tool, unless disguised spies are allowed to heal from it instead. More so, if it also extinguishes fire, imagine putting out an enemy spy as well as heal them. It being a projectile also means enemy pyros can deflect it back at you or themselves.

[@keeganconnolly7708]

Please do more of this kind of content., I personally love it, but all of your content is fantastic. Also for the Surgical Solution I think the original name works very well.

[@jobot0114]

I think the Physician's Fix was a better name for the third weapon than the Surgical Solution, but if I had to come up with one, I would go with the Terrible Tonic

[@SowhyEnot]

I really like the surgical solution, honestly I’d love to see it in the game, as you said with it being similar to the ana nade, I’ve played overwatch and having a tool like that with medic would be really interesting! Also it means if you have the kritzkrieg and crossbow with it you can do a ana cosplay which would be funny

[@mwahjahoocha]

Weapon Reskins in TF2 have always seemed like a strange case to me. On one hand if you like how a weapon works but hate how it looks it's nice to have another option to choose from. But on the other hand, reskins usually look like they would function differently from their counterpart. And I've always thought it would be neat if cool looking weapons like the maul had more of an identity than "Its the Homewrecker but for rich people" So I took a large number of weapon reskins currently available in the game and gave them their own set of stats ranging from "Slightly modified sidegrade to the original" to "Completely new weapon idea that's not balanced at all but a ton of fun." For this video at least I'm only going to be modifying weapons that are relatively cheap and easily obtainable so it can keep the pay 2 win to a minimum. Basically if its under a key in backpack.tf (tm) or it's directly craftable then its gonna be fair game. I'm also not going to be touching the Original, either of the pyroland weapons, or the Holy Mackerel since even though they're technically reskins, they have enough unique functions that make them notably different from their counterparts. All right lets go. The Three-Rune blade is a really cool looking weapon that just doesn't do it for me. Like sure if you hit somebody with a sword in real life they're probably gonna bleed. But if you made a sword that's so poorly weighted that you're guaranteed to hit yourself if you miss your target then you'd probably be better off not even forging the sword in the first place and just hurling chunks of iron at people. So hear me out, we've already got Demoknight but we don't have Scoutknight. I've always thought it would be really cool if the Three-rune made scout functioned kinda like Demoknight. You have a lot more health, better damage and range, and a slight movement speed buff in exchange for scout taking his medieval roleplay very seriously and refusing to use any non-medieval weapons. Scoutknight would effectively be a sidegrade to Demoknight by trading off health and shield resistances for better movement and secondary utility. I'm actually surprised we don't have a second melee subclass in TF2 already with how much time went into Demoknight. And the Three-rune seems like the most obvious weapon change to make to make that a reality. The Holy Mackerel is notably different enough from stock because the killfeed tracking hits function. However, the Unarmed Combat does basically the same thing as the Holy Mackerel so it does count as a reskin. The Unarmed Combat's basically a meme weapon so I'm not too concerned about making it competitively viable or anything, but I do wanna make it fulfill its role as a funny weapon by giving it funny stats. Since you're slapping people around, why not give it a knockback effect. The knockback wouldn't be much, but you'd be able to get kills with this pretty well just by juggling people around. It would be kinda annoying to fight against but the idea of slapping people off a cliff is funny to me, so I personally like the changes regardless of how effective they may be. The Nostromo Napalmer is technically not a reskin from stock because if you have the entire item set equipped you do more damage against scouts who are wearing the entire alien set, but only like 5 people have ever gotten use out of that specific stat so I'm willing to make an exception. Most of the flamethrowers right now reward you for being as close to your target as possible. So I thought it would be interesting to make a flamethrower that's the opposite, where it has increased flame distance but reverse falloff so you have to keep your target at the maximum possible distance to get the most damage. The increased flame speed would also give the flames more range since their calculation is based on time in the air instead of distance, so essentially its not as much of an ambush tool as much as it is a spacing tool. I have no idea how good or bad this would end up being because its such an "out there" concept, but I think this would be more of a high skill ceiling flamethrower to add to the game, and it would also work well in the Nostromo due to how the original version works in Alien. The Postal Pummeler has such a random design for an Axtinguisher reskin. Like sure, a mailbox as a melee is cool and all, but why make it a reskin to the Axtinguisher of all things. So if not an Axtinguisher reskin, what would a mailbox do? Mail has to travel to reach its destination and a lot of mail travels by air and yeah this is a pyro market gardener. There's not much explanation with this one, the only thing in note is that I added a deploy speed bonus to both negate the jetpack's long holster animation and to give you more time to hit targets with the detonator's smaller jumps. Other than that, I feel like pyro could use a market gardener and these are stats that would be a lot of fun in TF2. And it would make it doubly function by making the mailbox theme make more sense. The Maul is another really cool looking weapon that ends up being boring because of its stats. Because of how futuristic this thing looks, I'd expect it to do something more high-tech than just being a building smasher. So what if we inverted the homewrecker's damage against enemy buildings to provide buffs to friendly buildings instead? What I'm thinking for the Maul is that you'd be able to whack friendly buildings to make them operate a little bit faster. That means sentries would fire faster, dispensers would regenrate ammo and heal faster, and teleporters would take a little bit less time to recharge. This is of course a significant buff to Engineers, so just to make it a bit harder to keep buildings overclocked, the firing speed penalty would probably be necessary. Pybro's currently a great niche that's limited to a single weapon type, and since teamwork based playstyles should be widely encouraged in a game called "Team Fortress 2", getting pyros more option to help out friendly engineers would be a super great addition.

[@frostburn2982]

15:17 a neat upgrade for it would be being able to launch your other projectile weapons (cleaver, ornament, and mad milk) out of the launcher since it's a tube gun

[@miticjack7658]

the medic throwable breaks geneva's conventions

[@erochicken]

This was a great video I liked it more than the old weapon idea videos where a robot came up with them is awesome that real humans came up with the ideas

[@silenc3068]

I’d change one thing about the Solution, essentially as a hidden stat, if you throw it into a crowd, the damage gets spread out between everyone, because 40 damage to in-theory an entire team feels to offensive a tool for medic to have from a possibly pretty large range

[@mcintoshpc]

Glad to see another one of these types of videos

[@idarkstarx6939]

“Spook’s Schooler” On backstab kill, opponent killed will gain a damage buff against you on respawn, and will be able to see the marked for death symbol above your head. The person you’re disguised as is also marked with a “marked for death” symbol, and can be damaged by the person you killed. Backstabbing the original opponent while disguised kills your disguise target as well. Backstabbing someone else clears the effect. Looks like a No5 pencil

[@logangould9918]

I think a funny idea for the Medic one is after you throw while it's on cool down just to make sure the player isn't COMPLETELEY defenseless giving him a little spoon would be great great. It does horrific damage but it would be hilarious to die to a literal spoon. How you die to a spoon I have no idea, we'll have him scoop your brain out through your eye saying something Medic-y like "Ah a fine specimen to add to my collection!" or "Hmmph, I thought there would be more haha!"

[@dakotasan8719]

Basically a stock knife reskin for the Spy and it’s literally just his middle finger. Because him running around with his middle finger out is absolutely hilarious

[@ryguy9876]

If this is going to become a regular series, then I would like to add my own two cents with my own weapon idea, and yes, this is an attempt to fix the gas passer: The Postal Pyre It would be a Pyro weapon that replaces the melee slot with an area denial/trap tool. Instead, the Pyro is given a jerry can full of gasoline that allows him to pour gas on the map. The jerry can would have enough gas in it to cover roughly 200 HU, however the pyro can refuel the jerry can with ammo pickups and potentially place more fuel then that, but only up to 400 HU. This gas can be ignited using either the pyro's flamethrower or at range with one of his flare guns, but both allies and enemies can ignite the gas prematurely with explosives. Once ignited, the gas burns for 6 seconds, and any enemy that gets caught in it is immediately set on fire with full afterburn ramp up, and any enemy that chooses to linger inside the fire as it's burning takes double afterburn damage. Unignited fuel trails would despawn upon the Pyro's death. This would be far less an offensive tool and more a utility that helps Pyros who want to either ambush or trap enemies. It could be used to stall the enemy team or deny them an escape. The obvious downside is now Pyro no longer has a melee backup in case they run out of ammo or if someone gets in their face.

[@alexandermain5102]

Gorbachev's Gatorade: a molotov cocktail that fills the space of the gas passer, it spreads fire in a cloud the size of the gas passer that lasts 2 seconds and inflicts afterburn on hit targets . It recharges only on fire damage and takes 850 points to fill, on direct hit it deals 80 damage and the target takes mini crit damage . While equiped if lit on fire or hit with melee it will explode in your hand and put its effects on you . The weapon would give pyro a way to better fight heavys and engis .direct damage and mini crits for heavy & you can use it to flush engineers out of their nest plus do a large amount of damage to buildings with the direct damage.

[@gmg9010]

Take a drink every time Great Blue says Ideally

[@I0NE007]

I feel like the "Peaceful Protest" could also be "Violent Pro-Taste" and the tape would be to help hold the rag into place. I would still really like to have the lingering area denial since that would have Scout block of escape routes to help pick targets along with hinder anyone from chasing after him; basically, what the Gaspasser was likely meant to achieve. As for the Medic, while it wouldn't work as an official name, a perfect Nametag title would be "KOTH syrup."