DID IT SUCK? | Doctor Who [CAN YOU HEAR ME REVIEW]

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Don't forget Patrons get exclusive access to my Father's Day review! Sign up today for as little as a $1/month! www.patreon.com/harryshauntedhouse

[@carealoo744]

Hooray! Harry watches these episodes, so we don't have to! :)

[@carealoo744]

Animated Doctor Who Episode? Scream of the Shalka. The Infinite Quest. Dreamland.

[@YourBeingParanoid]

Still making money from Doctor Who while slagging it and saying you're never watching again has become an internet staple these days, in particular, the butt hurt right-wing and their klingon cronies, lost in a world that has passed them by. What's the point of saying you're leaving the show alone only to go straight back to it the moment your viewers abandon you? Surely it's time this (and other clone channels) should stop altogether and just move on with their lives if they hate doing videos about shows and films they hate, instead of continuing to milk the cock of capitalism in their gagging mouths? Or does Trump's cum really taste that good?

[@carealoo744]

@@YourBeingParanoid I don't think you understand how jobs work.

[@YourBeingParanoid]

@@carealoo744 now, if I tell my boss I'm never working there again and storm off every time something I don't like comes along - I wouldn't have a job. Also, this isn't a job - it's a sideline. But Harry has his main source of income from writing scripts for movies and TV shows to keep him from sucking Trump's bellend - oops my bad. Of course he hasn't! Besides, Trump's bellend tastes of success and that's all that counts.

[@sambkingmusic]

Ok but that big monster 100% looked like the thing from Temple Run

[@fungusman9726]

Sam Burton-King Sam Burton-King I think it just looks like a big sloth

[@libertyadams5961]

I was wondering were I'd seen it before

[@BlackMesaEmployee]

Glad I'm not the only one thinking it

[@Vic-en2ok]

I'm convinced now that the Doctor really does not care about her companions. Did she really shrug off Graham when he was opening up to her a fear about his cancer coming back?

[@nightowl8477]

No, she didn't. The episode was about the struggles of opening up, and the Doctor's going through some shit right now. She'll be able to open up to them by the finale, but right now she can't. Graham clearly understood that.

[@madassassin5465]

Didn't she forget all about her companions in the fugitive of the judoon.

[@Temptation666]

@@nightowl8477 He did not look like he understod. He looked like someone doubting wtf he were even there for. Badly disappointed in her ability to connect. I suffer from chronic depression. But even at my worst i have been able to at least listening to those i care about. Especially when it was something serious. Like Grahams really understandable fear of dying from cancer. I really miss the Doctor who cared about their companions

[@blackhawk4042]

Yes she did... This is the worst episode ever. Just for these last minutes but then again the new doctors doesn't really care about Graham.... I hope he just stay one a vacation planet and before he stay, he just give her a talk for being a... "not very nice person"

[@jamesholmes6506]

With that, I wonder how she'd react to, say, beloved former characters passing away. I reckon that if it was the whole Bannerman Road gang who've died (they have never been referenced at all, unlike Torchwood, giving the impression that they never existed), 13 would probably be shrug shoulders, "I don't care, they meant nothing to me".

[@alkrolyd]

No wonder the episode is called "Can You Hear Me?", when the Doctor won't listen to people.

[@nigeltravis4018]

Hey anyone remember the Van Gogh episode? You know the really great one that taught about mental health without being terrible? Yeah I miss those episodes.

[@Tharries]

Series 12: Can you hear me? Everyone: No sorry! We're to socially awkward to listen to you're messages! Series 8: LISTEN! Everyone: Yes Sir.

[@CefoxReload]

uploaded 45second ago your comment is 30min old, Tell us how is the matrix

[@thelasttimelord7550]

Hey its Patron

[@Yvesouler]

ugh i miss peter capaldi’s season

[@ZigZag-mw9ir]

Steven Bailey Capaldi era was the worst one up to this point until Chibnal took over. Yeah there were great episodes but Moffat clearly had run out of ideas and was not really enjoying the show. Kind of demonstrates how bad this has been so far though, with people looking back at that era in pleasure. The fact is you could bank on getting a good episode, and from where I am standing there has yet to be a good episode in season 12.

[@booradley8895]

@@LukasOfTheLight Kill the fucking moon,forest of the earth saving trees,into the cuddly dalek,hell bent(not you Phillip)classics

[@iLeon99]

Nobody: Harry: *FINGERING EVERYTHING IN SIGHT*

[@anawilliams1332]

Harry’s a nonce

[@thelasttimelord7550]

Harry: You are here to watch the new doctor who Me: you know the simple life man. Its almost as you can hear me shouting it to your right ear

[@zechtyler1674]

THE LAST TIMELORD greetings fellow discord friend

[@thelasttimelord7550]

@@zechtyler1674 greetings fellow comrade and discord friend

[@Tiger516funny]

Tenth doctor: "Cancer? I will help you in any way I can." Thirteenth doctor: "Cancer? I'm going to use my personal traits as an excuse to duck out of the conversation."

[@__-fm5qv]

Ikr, I'm pretty much the definition of introverted, socially awkward and bad with words. But I've never once used it as an excuse to brush off a friends issues, I at least try to say something mildly comforting, or humourous in a dark way depending on who it is. What the doctor did was straight up cold and rude.

[@randomshit308]

The doctor is a huge dickhead a lot of the time, but not like this, never like this. It's just bad

[@AxelaxiB]

I feel like even the Peter Capaldis doctor would’ve been a little more sympathetic.

[@thetimeshadow6769]

@@AxelaxiB I feel like they would've used it as an opportunity to make another stupid "joke" about Clara giving him cards to read from.

[@minislim5]

The scene with Graham confiding in the Doctor about his fears really angured me. Gaham has been supportive too several characters and companions in the last 2 series and the one time he needs reasurance the Doctor just shrugs. As River explained The Doctor "Doctor the word for healer and wise man known throughout the galaxy. We get that word from yoiu". Not anymore shes too "socially awkward" too help support one of her companions

[@oliversmith5919]

It’s so frustrating that they finally had a great antagonist and then got rid of them in sch a lame and abrupt way. Chibnall and others need to learn that we are patient and want longer and more meaningful story arcs. It’s not that hard to save doctor who. Look at the judoon episode and you’ll realise that this show can be good again.

[@DokkaChapman]

You are aware that they were a metaphor for depression, right?

[@DokkaChapman]

@Rob C For me that was an editing & pacing issue, not a writing one.

[@Here_is_Waldo]

I feel like an episode about mental health could have had a different ending aside from trapping two people in a tiny box with a monster of fear and misery from which they can never escape.

[@DokkaChapman]

@@Here_is_Waldo As I said, they are a metaphor for depression. You don't defeat depression.

[@MichaelJohnson-kq7qg]

But 'we're aren't patient. Personally, I love watching stuff pay out over years (like Rose's bootstrap paradox storyline not resolving until John Hurt), but most people have no attention span. I saw someone complaining the other day that the show STILL hasn't resolved the Ruth storyline. For some people, 3 weeks is apparently just too much.

[@johninglis2622]

viewers: we want more benni Harry: not today

[@LPTV84]

The fact this series fails at The Doctor talking to themself while on their own ... It says a lot about where we came from.

[@libertyadams5961]

Fuck that bit was so annoying. The fact that she 'forgot' she was alone about 4 times was cri gey and not smart. Compare this to Matt Smith's 'mad/sad man with a box' segments

[@meris8486]

Takes me back to Heaven Sent where the Doctor is alone in the castle for the whole runtime and it's _riveting_

[@libertyadams5961]

@@meris8486 It least that posed more narrative purpose than 'imma be deep'. I think he pulled that off pretty well considering it was basically a 45min reflective piece. Chibnal's best doesn't hold a candle to moffat's worst, and that's saying something lol

[@karkatvantas9557]

@@libertyadams5961 You realise they weren't being sarcastic, right? Heaven Sent is genuinely riveting, and nowhere near one of Moffat's worst. It's one of his best.

[@libertyadams5961]

@@karkatvantas9557 Fair enough, didn't catch that, however I wasn't claiming heaven sent to be moffat's worst; it's one of my favourite episodes. What I mean is that in general, despite the fact that we were getting sick and tired of some of moffat's convoluted/weird plots, even his worst stories can't compare to chibnal's 'best'.

[@f_woody3824]

How you not gonna mention when the Doctor did the most absurd flick of her hip to make the sonic go straight to her hand

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Magnetic clamps bro

[@avrahamishshalom1799]

@@HarrysMovingMedia You just blew my mind! That fixes the most cringe moment of this episode for me, thanks!

[@Geznoo]

@@HarrysMovingMedia shit you right

[@SuperMandibleclaw]

@@HarrysMovingMedia if it was magnetic, it would go to the clamps not straight up to the doctors palms

[@penguins7360]

SuperMandibleclaw she catches it *facepalm*

[@billylardner]

I was really excited when I saw this episodes teaser, the floating fingers looked creepy and awesome. I thought we’d have something similar to that SJA story where the man from people’s nightmares is trying to escape into the real world, but instead we got ear fingering to keep a demigod sane until she can be freed so they can do... more ear fingering?

[@keyanstoney1742]

Also what did the doctor do that the immortal guy couldn’t. The guy didn’t even believe the doctor was that smart so...

[@eli_berdugo04]

@@keyanstoney1742 I think the point was that the immortal not realizing how smart the Doctor is is the reason he defeated, lots of times when you have characters like him their downfall is their ego

[@keyanstoney1742]

Eli Berdugo I get that I’m more wondering why the guy used the doctor since it seems like he could’ve done that himself

[@eli_berdugo04]

@@keyanstoney1742 "I needed someone from this realm to break a lock from this realm" it's said in the episode

[@keyanstoney1742]

Eli Berdugo oh alright sorry about that then.

[@chloeellis1246]

Did I slip into an alternate dimension or was this channel once called Harrys Moving Castle?

[@sumilal5108]

It was it was

[@thekillbot500]

@@sumilal5108 when did it change?

[@nightowl8477]

@@thekillbot500 - Halloween.

[@xeptian]

Mandela effect

[@Notanothercrayon]

@@xeptian lol, definitely not mandela effect. Anyone know why he changed it though?

[@disgruntledwelsh3817]

Better than praxeus.

[@SuperPokekami]

The shit I'm taking right now is more intriguing than that shite

[@HUDSON7]

@@SuperPokekami same bro

[@Ren-zg7nu]

An unfortunately low bar

[@Problembeing]

The treatment of Graham was jaw-dropping in its treatment. This alone has cemented my position that I now refuse to watch it again until this vile Common Purpose controlled group of cretins are gone.

[@fadikhoory5350]

Nice to see you again.

[@RobTFilms]

Ryan and Yaz had that convo outside the Master's TARDIS with Yaz crying about thinking she was dead

[@Diamond_Squid]

Classic Chibnal ending - Making a huge story and hyping up just for the doctor to press a button and the doctor wins...yAy....

[@andrewwright848]

Agreed. These so called "immortals", hugely powerful beings are just defeated by the wavey wave of Dr Planks sonic? For all I hated Capaldis first series, Chibbers and the Woodentops have really screwed up DW for me...

[@aaabatteries5576]

Weren't people also complaining about this same issue with Moffat?

[@Diamond_Squid]

any 01 idk, I liked moffat (well mainly 11) Most writers are hated during there run but then praised after it but I can’t really say so Even if he did his stories were much better than these and will always be

[@aaabatteries5576]

@@Diamond_Squid I like Chibnall

[@Diamond_Squid]

any 01 he was okay for Torchwood but he’s killing doctor who - Evryone has their own opinion but views went down for s11 SpyFall and fugitive of the judoon were great (and a women who fell to Earth aswell) but all the others were shit - and especially this episode which was pretty good(if it was just zenith and some all mighty beast that would be better) until the classic chibnal ending

[@marineboy1964]

I love the way the doctor uses The sonic screwdriver about a thousand times A episode, its heart warming

[@jacobnivert582]

Nice poem

[@charliewarner787]

We leave earth's orbit for the first time this series. Gallifrey: am I a joke to you

[@SamDavs]

His name is Alllah 😭😂😂 lost itttt

[@TheJaviferrol]

1st Doctor reassures Susan about staying with David 2nd Doctor reassures Victoria about missing her dad 6th Doctor reassures Peri about Ravalox turning out to be Earth 11th Doctor reassures Amy after knowing Van Gogh didnt have a happy ending 13: Im socially awkward The worst part is that the Beeb actually were arsed to put up a statement explaining why that behavior is normal and that people who dislike it are wrong

[@CineScarborough]

Cancer is completely different to any of those scenarios.

[@SirMeowsAlot89]

5th Doctor.. Adric dies, the start of the next episode that takes place immediately after his death... come now Nyssa and Tegan, Adric wouldn’t want us to mourn unnecessarily.. Yeah but I’m sure he would want you to mourn more than 45 seconds!!! A bit socially awkward to me.

[@TheJaviferrol]

@@SirMeowsAlot89 You should know the 5th Doctors last words were for Adric and anyway, the classic series was more story driven than emotion driven

[@SirMeowsAlot89]

TheJaviferrol thanks for telling me what you think I “should know”. 😸 FYI I did “know” it was during the Classic Doctor regeneration trope, where the Doctor who is regenerating, sees all their companions swirling around in their mind. (See I did know). No, but being serious now. I get what your trying to say. The Doctors last word being “Adric” shows us he did still mourn and thinks about Adric. But I think you also get my original comments point. Your original comment were classic Doctors reassuring/heartwarming companion moments. So I pointed out a socially awkward Classic Doctor moment.. which there are more. (Cough)-6th Doctor strangling Peri 😙 👍😎😸 but we really shouldn’t fight. Judging by your picture, I believe both our favorite companions are Ace!! And we love 7 more than most fans! I haven’t seen the bbc statement about it. I’m gonna look for it now, I am interested from your original comment.

[@hagridmary]

God, this episode was awful. And that moment where the sonic screwdriver flew out of the Doctor’s pocket into the Doctor’s hand has got to be one of the cringiest things the Chibnall era has spewed out thus far (and that’s saying something)!

[@penguins7360]

Someone explained this basically cuz the Sheffield metal is magnetic it magnetised onto the handcuffs and the doctor catches it

[@hagridmary]

Thelonely penguin If that’s true I don’t think it changes the fact that it was bloody cringe.

[@libertyadams5961]

Thank you, I really wish Harry had mentioned that BS. Not only was it bullshit that it reached her hand in the first place, but the way it was depicted made me want to cry

[@penguins7360]

Liberty Adams he didn’t mention it because there was a legit reason for it happening...

[@penguins7360]

Tom Monty ye it’s true,I think I would of like it more if it was sort of explained or it took the doctor more time to get out it just happens in a flash

[@Diamond_Squid]

The doctors “nightmare” looked like boashane penisula or whatever - Capt.ya Jacks planet

[@meris8486]

I hope it's the same planet, there's a chance since Chris was showrunnner on Torchwood but it's probably coincidental.

[@onyxowl70]

I think the episode would of been a lot better if they dropped the whole Syria bs and the random side character, then there would of been more focus on the companions and they could of conquered their fears, but no, we have a random one-off side character yet again getting more development. On a more joking note, I bursted out laughing when the doctor was sonnicing the finger and making it move, all I thought was the doctor saying "wingardium leviosa"

[@XDspacemanJD]

Ian Gelder was also in Torchwood Children of Earth.........................(sighs) good times.

[@AzurePhoenix636]

As was Peter Capaldi

[@Roxy_Rox]

Can you hear me? Unfortunately

[@davey1577]

Every 13th's episode has had a part which makes me groan in disappointment; the screwdriver flying from her hip to the hand was that moment. The two antagonists in the story were likeable, but once again the time and space element was used so badly and eventually sidelined entirely to turn this into a mental health thingy.

[@penguins7360]

Davey magnetic clamps

[@eli_r_q]

I AM SO EXCITED TO SEE YOUR FILM REVIEWS! The outcome of "Parasite" winning best pictures at the Oscars was unbelievably incredible!

[@AniViRus]

I was so freaking sad whem Gram told his problem to the Doctor. Not because of the drama, but becausevit is the whole lost opportunity for character development. The Doctor could show that she at least cares about them. I do not know if the next thing ill say is good enough, but maybe it was the whole thing about Gram. He was no one to understand him, everyone are focusing on his wife death and cancer, so he tries to find the one who will. But screw this! That scene was just to finish the nightmares topic of the episode... Maybe if there would be only one companion or if the Doctor would support Gram after she is fighting her social awcwardness, or if Chinball was a good writer the situation would have turned into a good direction

[@bananasaregood8655]

ok not as harsh a review as I expected haha surprised you didn't mention the weird sonic screwdriver flying up to the doctor's hand in a very bad choppy edit hahaha

[@Larry]

6:50 I think the Doctor not listening was Chibnall trying to shoehorn in that The Doctor has Aspergers.

[@desperatemohammedantheworl5833]

Often thought about the Doctor being autistic spectrum with 6, 11 and 12 (certainly in series 8) strongly giving that impression. However while all the Doctors have show autistic traits (though I'm leaving 8th and War Doctors out as we haven't seen enough of them on TV) something about the moment came across as "off" and out of character. There was no attempt at sympathy in her reaction which felt wrong. Even though the Doctor at his least personable (1 or 6) or most manic (4 or 11) may have with out warning struggled with what to say they would have found a way to express empathy, 13 just came across as unpleasant. Maybe it was meant to work as clumsy foreshadowing of Graham's departure? Who knows?

[@ciminod]

Larry Bundy Jr Hello You

[@nyassaisleaving990]

Ooooooo saying the Doctor has aspergers is going to be flattering to half the Doctor Who fan base😂💗💗 Although people keep telling me you're not allowed to say aspergers anymore cos he was a part of the nazi party. Nonetheless I say it anyway.😁

[@desperatemohammedantheworl5833]

​@@nyassaisleaving990 In Asperger's Syndrome for Dummies in the "fun" final chapter the Doctor is on the Ten Famous People (Some Fictional) Who May Have Had Asperger's list, though IMO the only two definites were Ian Curtis of Joy Division and Mr.Grewgious from Charles Dickens' The Mystery of Edwin Drood (who isn't actually famous, LOL)

[@nyassaisleaving990]

@@desperatemohammedantheworl5833 If anybody ever does like "confirm" the Doctor being autistic then a lot of whovians will find that very flattering cos a lot of whovians are autistic

[@blueplanet9917]

Who's ever going to re-watch these to get a Doctor Who fix? I don't want to even think about them again. Ever.

[@andrewwright848]

No JW episode will get a rewatch, unless the last couple of episodes blow me away....

[@blueplanet9917]

@@andrewwright848 Genuinley, do you think that's likely?

[@MCLooyverse]

When we first saw the nightmare creatures claws, I also thought "waymenet...is that a Slitheen?".

[@somanypedals]

When I saw the shot of the creatures mouth, I immediately thought ‘Oh, are we bringing back the krillitanes for an episode?’ Before it was shattered when I saw the creature in full

[@helloitsme7553]

Tbh I thought all those character developments were actually good

[@jameskegley4006]

For the last 3 episodes my first thoughts were "What the hell did I just watch?"

[@alexlove4374]

UNBELIEVABLE the Doctor was so f*cking callous and rude and chose to skirt away from Graham's disclosure that he's scared about the cancer coming back. She goes all atomic on social justice and environmental issues....and yet she's closed up and c*nty about her own "Fam" I was so f*cking insulted...and that takes some doing.

[@jaydenyugi9034]

One of Graham’s friends actually appeared in the first episode of Series 11. I don’t blame you for not noticing though. I didn’t realise this either until I saw Blind Wave’s reaction to the first episode. The character appeared very briefly in The Woman Who Fell to Earth episode. I’m a bit split on this episode. It gets better on a rewatch but it falls apart with the rushed resolution and the antagonists aren’t used to their potential. I like that we finally got backstory on Yaz but it feels like it came too late. I do think the mental health focus is good but it felt too detached from the main story.

[@TheNerdestOfOne]

Also that beach ball looks like the crystal from freaking spearhead in space

[@TheWhoEditor]

Not going to lie I would love to see a new animated Doctor Who story (not including the Troughton dvd re-releases)

[@qayyuma9622]

Am i only the one who doesn’t even watch doctor who anymore but still watches Harry’s videos

[@mjm3091]

It shows me which episodes I should watch. After checking ranking and some comments - I either open my VPN to watch the real shiet, or just stay and watch Harry. Unfortunately I didnt watch anything since Fugitive.

[@Maths4Morons]

For this and the last season I find that the next time trailers are miles better than the poxy episode

[@GhostLightPhilosophy]

Tosin in this episode was so cringy. My god.

[@detectivebaghead5567]

I hate his acting in every episode. so stale imo

[@GhostLightPhilosophy]

Detective Baghead I think he got better towards the end of series 11 but I dont know whether he forgot how to act but In series 12 he has been so stale and cringy. Its like stage school level of acting

[@philipthegreat4126]

TheResurrectionOfMars Whoever’s in charge of casting on BBC’s Doctor Who at the moment is in the wrong profession.

[@TheJaviferrol]

@@detectivebaghead5567 Hes monotone as hell aint he?

[@adamoconnor8964]

He's terrible in all of them

[@GameBreaker1055]

The worst part about the ending for me was that the Doctor literally had to remind us verbally about her quirk being socially awkward! It was established in the first episode of series 11, but it really never came back up again until she literally told us in this scene! And even then, her not giving an answer at all was out of character! Giving a stupid answer that is not reassuring at all would have been the move.

[@cybermatt941]

Harry I'd recommend that you watch The Sarah Jane Adventures episode The Nightmare Man if you haven't already. This episode stole a fair chunk of it's plot, including the resolution, from that....but SJA actually did it better even though it's a kids show....

[@MoneyGist]

"...two people BBC found on the street." 😭😂😆

[@h.rtheater8321]

Honestly through out this episode I thought that Ryan would stop traveling with the Doctor and stay on Earth. We see that he's afraid of losing time with his friends and family, mainly his best mate who seems to be afraid of going outside/interacting with people. Having confronted that nightmare in this episode, I thought that it would lead him to see that he wants to spend more time and be with his friends and family and stay on Earth. The best part is that it would totally be in line with his character arch. When we first see him, he's abrasive and doesn't like spending time with people, mainly Graham, but he's wanting to do more. The he meets the Doctor, goes on a couple of space adventures and comes back to this episode where he sees that he missed a bunch of messages from his friend and couldn't be there in his time of need, he then confronts his fear, stays with his friend and helps him out, this learning how to appreciate spending time with the ones you care about. BUT NO, they didn't do that and he keeps traveling with the group leading to this episode being pointless. Damn it!

[@DokkaChapman]

Sometimes I wonder why I put myself through this hyperbolic wank... must but a masochist.

[@carealoo744]

Animated Doctor Who Episode? Scream of the Shalka. The Infinite Quest. Dreamland.

[@TheNerdestOfOne]

Just a couple more weeks then the cyberman 2 parter

[@komati7046]

Thats the one thing keeping me on board

[@joeduffy4547]

I liked this review quite a bit. While I liked the episode, I'm open to the negative points being... well, pointed out! And the comedy put into those points was funny. I'm also glad you didn't skim over the positives either and gave them their merits. Good job.

[@lorddrayvon1426]

My favourite part of Doctor Who is the episodic set-up. Point and case, the Dream Lord or the Keblam! man delivering a package into the TARDIS.

[@DSM_Cosplay]

I hate how everything I thought during this episode was brought up in this KZbin video i’ve became too cynical😂😂

[@marshallhuffer4713]

Here's how the BBC responded to the controversial scene: “We never set out to upset our viewers with what we show and this episode tackled some sensitive themes. The episode used dreams and nightmares to explore the inner lives of the companions. Thanks to Zellin’s nightmare powers, Ryan, Yaz, and Graham were forced to confront their worst fears, many of which relate to the way traveling with the Doctor has changed their lives. “When Graham opened up to the Doctor about his fear of his cancer returning her response was never meant to be dismissive. The Doctor’s friend was scared, and we see her struggling to deal with the severity of the situation. The intention of the scene was to acknowledge how hard it can be to deal with conversations on this subject matter. When faced with these situations, people don’t always have the right words to say at the right time, and this can often lead to feelings of guilt. By showing the Doctor struggling to find the right words, the intention was to sympathise with all those who may have found themselves in a similar position. “We hope this has helped to address your concerns, but please be assured your feedback has been raised with the programme’s Executive Producer.” That is a sorry excuse for an "apology." What's even more asinine are the Jodie-Bots who tried to justify the scene by saying things like "The Doctor is an alien, she doesn't have the same emotions like humans do." Other Doctors have dealt with expressing emotions and being harsh to their companions, but they always understood grief, trauma and humanity. Jodie just comes off as an unlikeable c-word.

[@timothygeorge5806]

0:12 Sums it up well!

[@malfattio2894]

I'd like to see a story arc where the doctor straight up dies and captain Jack tries to go back in time and stop if from hapening Engame style

[@oneplushydude]

Felt like the episode had some great stuff in it. All characters had good development (except the doctor). Learning that yaz has left her family before adds to her leaving again with maybe some guilt. Ryan also feeling guilt and missing home will affect later decisions and Graham learning that The Doctor doesn't know how to respond to heavy life problems. However these will doubtfully pass into other episodes because why would a series continue problems from one episode to the next. That would be silly

[@davidbray5982]

4/10 is generous in my opinion, this episode was shockingly bad. What happened to the rage of 9? The steaks of 10? The insanity of 11? The sorrow of 12? Those doctors felt like they MATTERED. 13 just feels unimportant. 11 saved all of time and reality from the end of the universe. 13 helped Yaz get over her insecurities as a police officer in Sheffield. Rose looked into the heart of the Tardis to obliterate the Daleks, and save Earth from a slave-like existence. Ryan recommended therapy to his friend. Do you understand what I'm trying to convey? The steaks are so low with 13, I just can't bring myself to care about each episode. Mundane. For me, this episode would hardly crack a 2/10. I wish I hadn't bothered watching it.

[@azuregriffin1116]

Can you hear me? *Major Tom?

[@smore7190]

Can you hear me major Tom!?

[@azuregriffin1116]

@@smore7190 can you- Heeeeeeere I am floating 'round my tin can...

[@TheSmart-CasualGamer]

Planet Earth is blue, and there's nothing left to do.

[@azuregriffin1116]

@@TheSmart-CasualGamer he's a little confused but he's got the spirit.

[@carealoo744]

Hooray! Harry watches these episodes, so we don't have to! :)

[@fittinginisforjigsawpieces3141]

Aleppo, more like alepPOINTLESS PLAY ME OFF STEVEN

[@alextheanimator2395]

joke wouldn't be too bad if you didnt do the god awful cliche of saying "i'll see myself out" "i'll just leave" "i'll just um-- bye" "yeaahhhh,,,,, see you later" please stop it

[@tiobridge841]

I thought the slitheen too when I saw that arm at the start

[@crusadier1134]

Not gonna lie, all the points you made in this video were exactly what I was thinking when watching!

[@justdenks]

I legit thought this episode was gonna be a krillitane episode and I almost freaked

[@LordDoom10]

There was a good villain in this episode. And them conquering their fears to turn the immortal's creations against them was a good idea, but they just rushed the resolution. And it was rushed to speed run character development for the three companions, because they probably can't or don't want to give them episodes to properly develop.

[@nellrose4699]

i think part of teh problem with jodie's doctor is that it comes off like she's performing for children all the time, it's the same voice i hear from actors who only do 'theatre in education' for school groups

[@grxviton-surge8908]

i actually liked the ending of this ep tbh. I felt like i related to ryan mate in terms of the concept of lonliness and that yaz and the police officer is an important figure in her life (tho the implication of suicide was weak af) but the bit w the doctor was just flat out TONE DEAF. i love having a message about mental illness and fear where the final message given is "dont talk to your friends because theyre socially awkward and will pretend to not listen."

[@desperatemohammedantheworl5833]

4:33 - Stepdad if we're been honest. EDIT: Sorry, creepy stepdad.

[@TnT_F0X]

Am I the only one who thought... "Hey these might be some good Villain... oh wait they've been plot twisted away"?

[@kgregory6210]

I think zelin should have been the dreamlord, that would be a great story as we found out when we first saw the dreamlord that the dreamlord was the doctor, it would be cool that he regenerated into zelin, that would make the episode just a little bit better

[@william2496]

Those monsters looked like that monster in Temple Run

[@GuineaPigEveryday]

I wish it was Slitheen. Especially if they hid the monster, only showing the claws, building up tension and keeping it scary. Until suddenly revealing it to be Slitheen. Would’ve been interesting to see them as a serious horror threat perhaps.!

[@JR98GAMING]

I’ve been watching a lot of series 4 this past week and one thing I’d love next series is if the current crop of companions get replaced by someone who can actually speak up to the doctor. In Planet of the Ood the doctor makes a remark about how clothes are made in a similar fashion to the slavery of the ood and Donna basically yells at him for taking cheap shots at humanity yet this series we have full on lectures about climate change and plastic waste, plus the doctors reaction to Graham, and they don’t say a word.

[@stevejones7181]

The whole plot just reminded me of nightmare man from SJA

[@NotSoRadical_]

The first episode of dr who I actually didn’t watch when it first premiered. I’ve lost hope in Dr Who and now cba.

[@mikeboosh8776]

You've got more stamina than me. I've been watching since 1978 and just couldn't last past the midway point of season 11. Briefly watched a couple of episodes this season to see if it got better... nope.

[@NotSoRadical_]

mike boosh I always hoped that it could get better again, it hasn’t which is quite sad tbh

[@jacobgorman3145]

Honestly I don’t watch doctor who anymore

[@CineScarborough]

You should. Despite Harry's annoying ramblings, Series 12 has been an absolutely amazing series and Can You Hear Me was an absolute classic of a Doctor Who episode.

[@pdawg4114]

@@CineScarborough Tell me you're joking

[@jacobgorman3145]

The Yorkshire Time Lord honestly can tell it’s isn’t good because I watched most of series 11 and it was terrible. It was so bad I actually felt stupid watching it so I stopped so I don’t understand what you think is good because it hasn’t changed at all it may have got worse. And he does ramble he telling us when it’s good and when it’s bad in his opinion. Furthermore if it’s just because it supports your agenda now doesn’t mean it’s good a program isn’t good because it has a message you like. Also rather then just attacking give me some points why it’s good.

[@jaydendixon7300]

@@jacobgorman3145 I've tried to keep up with the series, but I've ended up skipping through each episode apart from Spyfall which was pretty decent but due to the terrible story writing and political agendas I think I might join you in shunning DW.

[@CineScarborough]

@@pdawg4114 Nope. Perfectly serious.

[@celine1295]

Also, I think Ryan’s friend was at group therapy?

[@RoboNuggie]

Ian Gelder would be a great choice to play the lead role in Nosferatu the vampyre.

[@amelialikesfrogs5778]

I thought the doctor's response to Graham was totally in character for her doctor

[@philipthegreat4126]

Might’ve been in character for her Doctor but it’s not in character for THE Doctor.

[@TheDriverEarist]

And also if they wanted this episode to do with mental health they shouldn't really added that part and actually have the doctor listen.

[@aceywacey9871]

philip the great Yeah I have to agree, any main character who is meant to be liked should NOT be written to just write off a serious heart to hearts, if she had said something along the lines of there's others that can help you I probably wouldn't mind it but she just leaves Graham, one of the greatest companions we've had, with no pieces of advice or wisdom, not even a friendly word which every Doctor has had... I think it's more of I really can't see her in line with any other Doctor, she's way too different to even seem like the same character we've known since 2005, and some since the 1960's

[@jamesslater9098]

This was just write for a speach every doctor so far has had a defining speach and jodie has had none. Think of the end of time, the rings of akahten and especially the zygon invasion.

[@libertyadams5961]

I was honestly waiting for her to say something at the end, I thought it was just a bait and switch, but the episode just ended 😬

[@xenon8117]

Not a patch on the SJA Nightmare Man story. These new stories just have nothing on the 2005-2012 era for doctor who content.

[@markmatthews7202]

The thing is, I don't want to be given a message about anything in Doctor Who, and in saying that some of the best ways to put me back on track is watching a Tennant, Smith (Series 5) or Eccleston episode, I just want it to be entertaining and not preachy and retconny.

[@jamesa.fitzpatrick1566]

BBC be getting some complaints over Graham's cancer confession scene this week!

[@TheNerdestOfOne]

Funnily enough when I asked people did they get the celestial toymaker reference everyone got it but he only got 1 episode and 3 episodes are missing

[@eli_berdugo04]

When a character is good enough they'll be memorable no matter how much screentime they got

[@TheNerdestOfOne]

Eli Berdugo that’s true now chibnal we’re the celestial toymaker episode

[@carealoo744]

The Celestial Toymaker is my favorite Hartnell story! Hey, if anyone's interested, I'm reviewing all the Doctor Who stories on my channel, with me just having uploaded my review of: 'Death To The Daleks (1974)!' No pressure, of-course; It just might be worth checking out! :)

[@someguy4405]

harry please do a review of 2011’s the dinosaur project

[@someguy4405]

i thought slitheen, by the way

[@TommyLednorMusic]

The Power of the Doctor’s Beach Ball, Jodie’s final episode as the Doctor

[@WGDN05]

I kind of liked the idea but thought it was just an awful remake of the Sarah Jane adventures the nightmare man and completely hated the way the doctor just ignored the way graham was speaking to her about his well being.

[@lewimillionzYT]

This is the first time in doctor who where I actually want them to kill off the companions. Except Graham

[@jamestiller6156]

Hey Chibnall can you hear me and all my angry comments ? 👊🏻

[@lynndeju]

The worst part of that episode was just the incredibly short "win" from the doctor. They meet zelin and the other immorta in aleppol and boom now they're both in the prison-orb.

[@sohankalirai8769]

Harry, when’s the inside no.9 analysis coming out?

[@MrMadshepherd]

The finger separating thing was an ok idea. But did they have to make it look so amateur and janky? It looks like something even I could do

[@MCLooyverse]

Woah. You can make your fingers come off and fly? /s I thought it was kinda neat, if a bit arbitrary (why fingers? Why not already detatched drones?), but one thing I didn't get is why he detatched all five fingers every time he wanted to get one person. I only saw one hole get used, although the first time he did it, I was expecting more.

[@maxsnelling3335]

Thought I was the only one who thought slitheen when I saw the claws

[@franticranter]

i actually enjoyed this episode. ive generally been rather critical of this series, but apart from the resolution to the immortals part (which was pretty naff) i thought it was pretty good. second best in the series, behind the judoon episode.

[@desperatemohammedantheworl5833]

1:49 And Torchwood Children of Earth! Call yourself a Whovian? I think not ;-)

[@FlamingoSundew]

I loved mr Dekker but he doesnt have to call out everything he has done also torchwood is kinda stand alone they never say the word tardis and they dance around the word doctor and no consequences on the main show

[@desperatemohammedantheworl5833]

@@FlamingoSundew Game of Thrones however is 100% DW universe canon LOL. Whatever.

[@FlamingoSundew]

@@desperatemohammedantheworl5833 I'm not saying it's not cannon I know it is I worded it badly but basically it's not dependent on doctor who and you could probably take docotr who out of it and it would still be fine

[@desperatemohammedantheworl5833]

@@FlamingoSundew Yeah, I was being a dick. Sorry. Don't take the comment personally. I understood perfectly what you meant.

[@SimonLeicester]

Has she regenerated yet? Oh well. I’ll come back and check next week

[@megashark1013]

The episode had some things that weren't bad, but the overall plot and pacing was just an absolute mess. The way the villains were suddenly beaten felt ridiculously rushed. I mean, we didn't even see Tahira actually conquer her fear (which was supposed to be a key plot detail), and we didn't even see what happened to her afterwards. I still have some small hope for this show, as the new Master is pretty good, Captain Jack's making his return, and the setup for future episodes has interested me. But for now, Doctor Who is pretty damn weak. I am excited for those Oscar movie reviews, though.

[@eli_berdugo04]

We didn't see Sonya's fears, those were meant to be Yaz's

[@megashark1013]

@@eli_berdugo04 No, I meant the big wolf dog monster. We didn't actually see her confront it and learn to control it.

[@eli_berdugo04]

@@megashark1013 That was Tahira. Sonya is Yaz's sister

[@megashark1013]

@@eli_berdugo04 Oh shit, you're right. Sorry, I meant Tahira. I'll fix it.

[@emmabendelow9393]

I hope the episode of the 23rd is good because if it bad it will probably ruin my birthday, but saying that it probably will be bad.