DID IT SUCK? - Doctor Who [TOOTH AND CLAW REVIEW]

NEW POLL: www.strawpoll.m...
THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER THE PARTY ISN'T OVER YET
SUBSCRIBE: www.youtube.co...
Donations:
► Paypal: www.paypal.com...
► Patreon: www.patreon.co...
Social media:
Discord Server: / discord
► Twitch: / hmc_twitch
► Facebook: / harrysmovingcastle
► Twitter: / hmc_tweets
► Instagram: / hmc_instant

[@mattrobert5]

damn that was harsh. the banter between the doctor and rose as on point in this episode and really shows there relationship of well.

[@samuelbarber4154]

This episode didn't even introduce TORCHWOOD, it was referenced in "The Christmas Invasion" when Harriet Jones says something like "Bring up TORCHWOOD." Or something like that.

[@TheSheepWielder]

And Bad Wolf during the Weakest Link game

[@HarryThomasPictures]

Tooth and Claw is a little underrated, it's one of the best frightening stories of Series 2. Nice review though.

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Thanks!

[@hollywark2885]

This is the story that gave me nightmares

[@uniquelegend391]

during the time when this episode came out bbc had an ad before every program where monks would jump around and a catchy tune would play and then a women would introduce the next program i always assumed the monks where from that bbc ad.

[@liamwilliams6651]

I still really enjoy this episode it's one of my favourites

[@fourthdimension9940]

I like how you used a picture of the Girl Who Died for "awful" episodes, thought I was the only one!

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Check out my review of it, honestly I think it's the worst episode of Who Revival.

[@TGM_Productions]

Well it's a shame I grew up with that episode

[@lukewalker5717]

@@TGM_Productions unlucky

[@datdragonboy3000]

Can't say I agree with the review though. This has to be one of my favourite episodes because of its simplicity and things seem to actually tie together quite well. Its as though this folk law-esque tale is like a destiny for Victoria planned by the local monastery that just never came into being. Its all very conspiracy theoryish and I think the CGI has aged really well making this very rewatchable. Also, that scene with Victoria and the gun is just pure epic and just gives it 5 stars for me immediately haha. I do respect a lot of your points though :)

[@mrmrsgamer6938]

the orange suits always reminded me of the title scene for the BBC when they announced a show, i suspect its the same group

[@martinmaguire-music6692]

Yeah I loved this episode but that fight scene at the start was one of the worst things in Doctor Who history. Luckily it doesn't last too long. [EDIT] Also, Queen Victoria wasn't disgusted by them saving the world, but for doing it in such a happy-go-lucky kind of way.

[@WithADashOfPazazz]

The episode was good for the establishment of Torchwood and highlighting that the Doctor and Rose were enjoyingly themselves a little too much, good foreshadowing for the finale

[@dvader518]

Jenna Coleman plays Queen Victoria in Victoria. Now imagine the Whoniverse version as an older splinter of Clara.

[@obiwankenobi687]

My god nothing satisfies you 🤦🏻‍♂️, the knighting scene is brilliant because she tells the Doctor and Rose how wretched their life is. There’s literally nothing wrong here and everything she says makes perfect sense,

[@TheTravelerww]

The monks from the opening have clearly slipped through a crack in the void from the DnD universe

[@Joey-mm5nu]

The character the actress playing queen victoria played in the Faceless ones was originally going be a companion but she declined.

[@moonraven6145]

Looking back at these reviews have revealed how Goofy Doctor Who really is looking back, it's kinda adorable in some way.

[@badger_shorts7708]

Me, after hearing Harry say Moffatt basically ruined Doctor Who, in a time when Chibnall wasn't showrunner: "Boy, just you wait"

[@TAP555]

Before season 2 began airing I remember binging on Eccelstons episodes after watching it's Christmas special. I loved how season 2 had this fresh look on the Doctor and made me appreciate the earlier episodes even more. I was so excited about this episode with it's shift in tone. The trailer looked incredible. I don't think I'll ever get this, queasy-excited feeling like I did watching the next-time trailer as a kid, any time in my life again

[@samsentertainment8290]

Have just spent several minutes humming and whistling along to the background music before finally going, monkey see monkey D’oh?

[@Sion67Productions]

Would have voted Fear Her but my phone just freaks out trying to redirect to a random pop up page and then it just gives up.

[@markpostgate2551]

Beginning of video: "I have no interest in reviewing average episodes" End of video: "4 out of 10". What? This must have been a bummer for you! It's a real shame that those monks get unexplored as an idea. Why do they know martial arts like they're Taoist monks when they're apparently Christian monks in Scotland? It seems everything Davies knows about monks he learned from the AD&D Players Handbook! The convenient plot resolution is slightly improved compared to RTD's convenient plot resolutions of the previous season because Davies sets up the telescope and the gem early on the episode. This was a tip he picked up from Moffat. He actually asked Moffat why during season one all the fans were complaining about "deus ex machina" endings, and Moffat explained that the resolution to a story needs to be set up fairly on hidden in plain sight so the audience don't feel you've cheated. This was Davies' first attempt at applying that advice. It's still not that great, mind, because it relies on the tools for the resolution being deliberately left behind by characters that we don't see and we don't know why or how they would know that it would work. One-parters frequently sucked back then, because they tried to fit traditional Doctor Who story ideas into the time frame usually given to a Star Trek story idea.

[@161genius]

"Act of 'LUNACY", damn that cracked me up

[@JJsims5504]

These reviews are like reflecting on my early teens and I love it

[@archive9796]

I think -for being one of the most "famous" series in the show in the publics eyes- Take it or Leave it really sums up series 2

[@johnconstantine171]

Hey Harry I don't know if you'll read this or not but I created the subtitles for you, think of it as a thank you for all of your hard work (P.S. I'll try to do some of your other videos as well)

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

I read all my comments mate I'm not THAT popular yet. ;) No but seriously thank you so much, I can't believe somebody would put all that effort in for nothing... which is pretty much what I did for the first 18 months on here. If only somebody were to handle my social media and annotation for me for free...

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Urgh, people contributing to MY work and it's youtube who gets to choose if it's correct or not. Booooo

[@johnconstantine171]

"HEY YOU DID SOMETHING NICE TO A PERSON YOU TURN TO FOR ENTERTAINMENT? WELL WE HAVE TO 'REVIEW' IT SO FUUUUUCK YOU- KZbin

[@johnconstantine171]

Im sorry i'm easily triggered

[@worsethanyouthink]

Wasn't Torchwood introduced in the Christmas special before this episode?

[@nightowl8477]

5:59 It's not timey wimey. It makes sense. Remember that speech in WestWorld season 2 episode 3 about elephants and stakes? Hopefully cos I can't be arsed explaining it lol

[@jennawood8149]

Wasn't Pryat Pree bearing up Ser Rodrik Cassel?

[@nightowl8477]

1:16 It's just a phrase, Harry. Albeit not a common one. I think you took this whole scene a little too literally. Though it *is* awful.

[@reviewnueb7521]

and what does the 4 score mein is it a bad rating or OK rating

[@nozoto]

I have absolutely no recollection of this episode. The premise looks like an unused Tom Baker Gothic era script rewritten by RTD, after plenty of drinks: "Yeah, and there will be shaolin monks doing sommersaults, audience will crack open the ceiling * looks at a promo poster of Jet Li in Fearless, on movie theaters around 2006 * And... * looks at old tat having imagery of Prince Charles and Lady Di * Queen Victoria making the Doctor and Rose sir and lady for giggles and British tradition quota! I have the best ideas, hehe"

[@ScreamingmadJoe]

This episode feels like a fever dream

[@nifralo2752]

Why cant we have more episodes like this? A raw adventure with a monster. You nearly get those these days

[@JohnnyLCob]

*No, it did not fking suck. This is one of the best episodes of Doctor Who ever.*

[@JH-jl7cq]

Cool review dude, as always. Make sure to make more! Also, what do you think about 'Power of the Daleks' coming out soon?

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

What's the "Power of the Daleks"? ;)

[@tabularasa0606]

Animated version of a lost Troughton episode.

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Oh, I don't really care much haha

[@JH-jl7cq]

Fair enough, I'm not sure how it'll turn out myself XD

[@edward4840]

+James Hubbuck a media teacher at my school worked on Power Of The Daleks, and I saw a clip, it looks good so far

[@kbg12ila]

I actually really enjoyed this episode. It reminds me of some classic who more than the others. It was also well paced and was just a load of fun.

[@spengu4627]

Great review as always have you considered reviewing the 10th doctor mars episodes

[@thatpeskyrat]

I enjoy your reviews and you have some good points! Sometimes I just plain disagree though, I think the humour in this episode is really fun. Ten and Rose banter is so childish but it really shows to serve how they treat their adventures like a silly romp when bigger things are at stake. Looking forward to watching more of your reviews!

[@tommyzoom9976]

This is the only David Tennant episode I haven't seen

[@TGM_Productions]

Isn't iron which kill Werewolves?

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

The Grassy Man Productions Nah you're thinking of silver

[@TGM_Productions]

Oh okay, you responded to me... instantly has more respect

[@Bijo69]

The Torchwood episode where Jack is in the Victorian era is a reference to this isn’t it?

[@aramc123456]

Anyone else wondering where the monks went like halfway through the episode...?

[@robthetindog8218]

I only found these reviews recently, so please excuse my lateness. But I just want to point out that the monk’s plans would go for naught; Victoria refers to her husband in the past tense, so no more kids ( certainly none who would inherit the throne anyway) I like this episode; as I do most of tens run.

[@Joey-mm5nu]

You should review them all.

[@hrgrhrhhr]

2:45 Moffat bad? No, Moffat good 😡

[@MetalMercutio]

Miles better than Chibnall

[@liftlash98]

Best thing about this episode in my opinion is change around a few of the characters and you literally have an elder scrolls quest, and I love myself some elder scrolls.

[@Stryker_-qd4nq]

So the captain of Queen victorias guard had been killed by both a werewolf and jaime lannister. That's all I got for thus episode

[@jabojr5171]

I can't believe you faulted the one maid not being in the huddle, hell, if I was one of them, I'd hind in the back too. At least I'd be the last eaten.

[@datdragonboy3000]

First I hear SMG music at the start of your Vincent and the Doctor review and now there's Simpsons Hit and Run music at the start of the review of Tooth and Claw, one of my favourite episodes! I love this channel so much because of this.

[@arrow-flash2730]

Do you know how to get classic who

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Sadly I don't know how to "get" it.

[@fourthdimension9940]

But it or dailymotion.

[@Joey-mm5nu]

Arrow -Flash watch in daily motion or Buy the DVDs. I have all the DVDs :) the black and white era is the best!

[@noahcox7762]

Think you were very harsh here. The nakedness isn’t a crude joke, it’s era appropriate. The monks want the queen to become a werewolf because they have control over the wolf and would therefore have the throne. I don’t see anything wrong with the POV shots from the wolf (you’d want to kill and eat everything you saw too if that’s how you see thing). I don’t think it’s the shows fault for not being able to show men being literally torn apart because of age demographics. The doctors explanation of the wolf and mistletoe isn’t wibbly wobbly timey wimey, it makes a lot of sense and is a legitimate tactic used in training animals. Robert doesn’t have the information on the creature, they read the books so they can find out about the meteorite crashing and the Doctor works out FROM THAT, that the wolf must be alien. Girls in the kitchen throwing mistletoe is not convenience as we were shown them working out the solution and preparing it, it was a well established element of the story by this point. I imagine Roberts father and Prince Albert weren’t planning on being dead when the wolf came and had planned to carry it out themselves, leaving only the Doctor to be able to work out the real use of the telescope. I’m regards to the queen being cut, camera angles and cuts are a thing, it is possible we didn’t see the scratch which is exactly what makes the ending ambiguous and I don’t think the doctor and rose toying with the idea is cringey because it ties in real world facts (the royal disease) to the story which is a nice detail. Plus the monks didn’t win because they dead. I meannn... she’s playing the queen. She’s allowed to add gravitas. Doesn’t make it cringey. And setting up Torchwood isn’t a villain move, she’s just seen first hand that aliens exist and so of course it’s necessary to setup an organisation that fights back, she just counts the Doctor with this because as soon as he arrived, everything went horrifying and he was quite clearly lying through his teeth and deals with this stuff often, so whenever he appears, chances are some bad shits gonna happen.

[@SuperAmazingScott]

I met pyat pree months ago at some event and he's such a nice guy lol

[@SweatyCam]

3:44 please do a “did it suck?” on New Earth!

[@torgeirl]

1:02 anyone else that thinks this is creepy

[@liamdienemann8937]

The books were relevant because the dad compiled them in order to study the origins of the werewolf

[@ElmoElmoSWAZILAND]

Rip Pyrat Pree😓

[@heresyosmoothie695]

Have you seen this DWPoop?

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

I will be making my way through them at some point in my life

[@archive9796]

I think this is quite a good story but Rose and 10 kill it I feel it would be a very good 6 and Peri episode and the dalek audio where they are in Scotland is fantastic actually

[@TheInsid3]

When is Half Blood Prince review coming ?

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

October

[@MOVIESINGENERAL]

and released it in February.

[@probablynot8154]

I hate to double comment but can you do some Sherlock reviews. Your tear downs of these stories are hilarious!

[@MRNAZIZOMBIE11]

He's done the abominable bride but I'm not sure if he'll do the previous 3 series's

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

If I get bored of Who, maybe... one can dream of having enough spare time to review all the amazing TV on offer

[@probablynot8154]

What do you even do in life? A q&a please! And maybe all of sherlock overly analysed. And maybe do some archer (that animated show) and maybe rick and morty. You know, all the //decent shows

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

I did a qna a few months ago dude! I may have to do another when I pass 2000...

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Archer I won't do because it's just entertainment for me. Rick and morty though... very tempting...

[@gbsheard]

Brill review man!

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Thanks bruv

[@gbsheard]

No Problem Fam

[@vampiresquid2635]

my parents wouldn't let me watch this because it was too "scary" they let me watch the Empy Child two-parter though sooooo

[@yussepig6629]

I thought the constant joking from Rose about Queen Victoria was tiresome and disrespectful and unbelievable. Rose was slowly becoming a really dislikeable companion by this point. And Tennant’s constant gurning and forced wonder put me right off. CGI was basic too. Still, a solid 5/10

[@uniquelegend391]

i vote impossible planet has its one of my fav episodes/story its also the only good one on the list imo

[@edward4840]

Have you watched the classic show? Because when you said 'It's something a lot darker and contained' I thought of most of the episodes of the classic show. Episodes like 'Curse Of Peladon' show this well as they appear on a random planet and something just so happens to be afoot. But whatever. The new show shits on the classic show anyway so I can't blame you for this opinion.

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Nah sorry I've not seen that many episodes of the original series. Not much of a fan either, I was referring to the revival.

[@edward4840]

***** oh I'm a die hard fan of the originals, but still, great video

[@archive9796]

Think of your fav eps of new who and then times it by 10 that's classic who for you

[@archive9796]

They have a whole era of the show called The Gothic Horror Era One of the main reasons DW became huge is cous they basically took class hammer horror elements and make a DW spin on it Like Franknesting -The Brain of Morbuis The Mummy -Pyramids of Mars The Talons of Weng Chiang -Phantom of The Opera The Ark in Space -Alien And they even mix it up The Seeds of Doom is the Thing meets Day of the Triffids

[@edward4840]

79.03.13 The Seeds Of Doom to me was The Thing, The Thing From Another World and the 1978 version of Invasion Of The Body Snatchers

[@GodsMistaek]

How do books help kill a werewolf? Someone's never seen Supernatural before. Sam is having an aneurysm while holding all his monster lore books

[@SkywalkerReviews]

Great review!

[@JeMoederGamesJMG]

This episode has some nice moments, but it seemed more like one of those 'Oh god how do we write in the story-arc for this series?' episodes. I just keep forgetting it even exists, this review was a good reminder of how awful it is. Anyways love your reviews :D

[@SmoothRacing99]

Great review once again, love how bad the opening of this episode is and how bad queen Vic is in places.

[@apricoticpeaches]

I think theres a reason why I dont remember this episode

[@TommyLednorMusic]

Wow that Idiots Lantern comment didn’t age well ;)

[@PathsUnwritten]

These stupid monster of the week episodes where the aliens are just Earth animals are really dumb ideas. How do they get past the brainstorming phase?

[@wardjunior1450]

Too low Give it a six at the bare minimum.

[@MOVIESINGENERAL]

2:03 PAAAAAAARTY.

[@raiedahmednishat8883]

I just watched this episode an hour ago. how the fuck does youtube know?

[@captaincrumpet5558]

It's a bland episode that has good ideas.

[@JeithKarrett]

Argh.. Why does every fella I'm subscribed to upload just when I'm about to go to sleep.. I bland them timezones...

[@JeithKarrett]

blame* thanks autocorrect...

[@lynnpomfret931]

amazing video!

[@tennumb]

I'd say this episode is average.

[@joycec5646]

impossible planet/ Satan's pit

[@odiedodieuk]

Lunacy..... really? ;)

[@GbrosReviews]

Great review but in all honesty, i really hate this episode and dont get any of its appeal

[@reviewnueb7521]

do you like any Matt smith episodes

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

Yes

[@osiancoleman8447]

Russel T Davies is the worst fight coriogrefer ever. Literally watch any of his fight scenes 😂.

[@rorystockley5969]

At least the choreography isn't as bad as your spelling.

[@PwnZombie]

First episode I ever watched.

[@Nicori-hibi]

Wheres my idiots lantern gang

[@YourBeingParanoid]

Worst Doctor Who episode ever is Fear Her - it has every middle class, pan ethnic, BBC viewer cliché all rolled into one. By trying to be everything to everybody, it just becomes a nothing for nobody bore-fest. Even thinking about it makes my teeth grind! Gotta stop now or I'll put my blood pressure up too high and I'm really looking forward to a morphine induced sleep tonight without interruption lol. On another note - I managed to survive another 9/11 without the Americans taking us into yet another illegal war, so at least I'm not too stressed at the moment. Hope all is well with you and your clan ✌

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

What other 9/11? And yeah things are good, Robot wars is the next challenge

[@YourBeingParanoid]

9/11 was yesterday's date - lots of American invasions and dodgy deals are done on 9/11 - it seems to be their favourite day for evil doing. Just ask Henry Kissenger

[@JeMoederGamesJMG]

I actually enjoy Fear Her, it's cliche as fuck but I wouldn't consider it the worst episode ever and I don't mind rewatching it.

[@HarrysMovingMedia]

JMG Network Tread lightly

[@YourBeingParanoid]

JMG Network it's an insult to the intelligence of the viewer and purely there to promote the Olympics - I'm sure the BBC has better things they could spend their (our) money on - especially considering that you go to jail if you refuse to fund them.

[@rollercoaster9023]

Worst from series 2 and nothing will change that for me.

[@Joey-mm5nu]

Roller Coaster really? Its one of the best alongside The Impossible Planet/Satan Pit

[@rollercoaster9023]

Opinions have changed since then.

[@Joey-mm5nu]

Roller Coaster so much for Nothing can change it :P personally I used to not like the episode purely because I prefered Futuristic stories XD Luckily over time I grew to appreciate ones set in the past and even now I prefer the older doctor who serials over the modern era. The Aztecs will always be on the the best stories set in history and that is definatly followed by This one

[@rollercoaster9023]

At least we can agree Classic is better. I enjoy the historical stories from Hartnell's era including The Reign of Terror, The Romans, The Gunfighters, The Smugglers and the Troughton story, The Highlanders.

[@Joey-mm5nu]

Roller Coaster Yeah I started to appreiate historical stories when I got into classic who xD The Gunfighters doesnt deserve the hate it gets.

[@Peoples_Republic_of_Devonshire]

It was fucking brilliant

[@probablynot8154]

WHOOOOOO!

[@djsweatshirtx]

Fear her and love and monsters two shitest episode ever

[@thedragonskull1065]

staves you mean staffs lol

[@thedragonskull1065]

also why is the background music for this review one of the stage music from The Simpsons hit and run game (from the stages like collecting monkeys as bart or collecting buzz cola's as marge for example) it doesn't really fit the video very well you could've used some doctor who music instead that fit it perfectly this music does not go well with doctor who at all