Did Woman Abandon Great Dane? | Part 1

Billee claims she didn’t abandon her Great Dane, but Kara’s been taking care of it for two years.
#JudgeJudy
The Original! There’s only ONE Judge Judy. Visit our website for where to watch, weekdays.
Subscribe to Judge Judy on KZbin: / @judgejudy

[@JYBeliever]

I love when the defendants actually stay quiet and say nothing, they just watch the person suing them get ripped a new one. Brings a tear to my eye

[@UnscrupulousAgitator]

Haha me too. My son got sole custody of his 1 year old daughter by using the same method!!! Joy ❣️😊

[@sharonasbury7698]

@@UnscrupulousAgitator Zaza Q rq

[@wendya.presley7316]

Me too! It trips my trigger I luv it 😂

[@WeAreNotAmused]

It's pretty. Choice. JJ know what cooks.

[@Onxy1976]

Defendant knows court etiquette. Don't talk unless spoken to. Don't interrupt, keep answers straight to the point and concise

[@wontsufferfools9332]

I got my dog as the defendant did. I was asked to watch the puppy (6 weeks old) for a week. 3 months later he came and got her. A week later I went to check on the dog. He worked and partied all the time. The poor thing was in an enclosed patio, summer, almost dead. I broke in took the dog to the vet. 3 months later he called to tell me the dog got out that morning. I told him what I did, he said he'd be right there to get the dog. I said "take me to court". That was 15 years ago and she's still going strong ... In my home. Spoiled. Loved. Happy.

[@merihahoule4309]

Thank u for saving that dog. Need more people like u

[@bubbaXzone]

this need more likes!

[@AzarathsFlame]

15 YEARS?? The quality of life you've given that dog by that fact alone is incredible ❤

[@dolcesweet5173]

It just irritates me how people will do things out of ego. He had no intention of taking care of the dog knowing his lifestyle. Thank you for looking out for the dog's best interest.

[@skylarjaxx2399]

@@AzarathsFlame right. That's a feat!

[@JamieM470]

She says "I'm her mother", but she left her with someone else for two years, and only refers to her as "the dog". Does she not know the name of "the dog"? And if she can't have "the dog", she'll be happy with money. I agree with Judge Judy; "You're not her mother."

[@dorishousand3122]

Omg.....her children would have starved!

[@RXbee2]

She's a drunk to boot!

[@BeccasaurousRex270]

Exactly. I rarely refer To my pup as a “dog.” I always refer to her by name or by a pet name (like princess or sweetie)

[@historysyourbestfriend5500]

It’s easier to refer to a dog as a dog in court in order to cause the least amount of confusion

[@Zzz2x]

Imagine how she treats a child

[@sydhsydh1084]

When plaintiff said spaying the dog is unnecessary and want money for it, i knew JJ would be extra pissed 😂

[@BleedingGrafitti]

Understandably so. People only want an unfixed dog for one reason; breeding. And 99% of "breeders" are morons who have no idea what they're doing, and are just causing damage to their animals.

[@tuesdae666]

There are 7164 Judge Judy episodes. I figure if I watch an average of 3 episodes a day, this will last me a good 6 years. I feel somehow very secure in that knowledge.

[@tinamariasteenfathjenskole99]

A very underrated comment!

[@Dhruv_Dogra]

😊😊😊😊

[@Irishjay_94]

where can you watch every season though?

[@tinabrain4646]

2years? She's got some nerves this woman.her boyfriends and dog came first hers came last.

[@user_7239]

Exactly. She really has some nerve.

[@kathymyers7279]

@@user_7239 just one.

[@nnedwards3260]

Wow. English is hard.

[@sophie2084]

Absolutely ridiculous. This woman should be ashamed of herself. She should be grateful that some one took on such a big dog and took good care of her. Yes, she did abandon her and that dog is most certainly no longer hers

[@thejapmobile]

So I had a similar situation like this but when I asked the lady to watch my dog, I told her it would be a month and then I’ll come back once we settled in with the move. I signed a contract and offered her payment. Brought food, his toys and some extra things if he needed it. Went every week to see my dog. It may have been for an hour or 2 but i made sure to see him. Had a slight hiccup with the move and called her if she can watch him for another 2 weeks and that I will provide payment for it. Finally got settled at the new house and went to pick up my dog. It’s not hard. I get that things come up but you got a dog and you have to be responsible for it. If you ask someone to take care of your responsibility then do the right thing.

[@SlicerVorzakh]

"You understand this is an UNSYMPATHETIC face to you. Listen to me. WE'RE DONE."

[@dfa3366]

There was a similar case I think on People’s Court where a woman took her dog to a kennel and never picked it up. The kennel owner found a home for it months later and I think a year later the previous owner came to pick the dog up. She land up suing the kennel but she lost. She abandoned the dog.

[@Zola_6]

Judge Judy has done many cases, we’re people abandon their animals , then sue for the pet back .. cat /dog etc

[@harper.la.vegano]

There's something really scary about people who refer to animals as "it".

[@izzybella6888]

Do I remember what the title of the episode was?

[@theclamhammer4447]

“You understand this is an unsympathetic face to you?”🤣🤣🤣

[@feralhomunculus]

That woman called it "the dog" 🙄 She loves "the dog" so much she doesn't even call it by it's name. I've never once referred to any of my dogs as "the dog"

[@harper.la.vegano]

Referring to animals as "it"? Straight up hypocrisy.

[@alieddy3846]

@@harper.la.vegano it's really not that deep

[@michellevanlonkhuyzen3701]

I've called me dogs an a$$hole but he is my a$$hole

[@exoressdelivers70]

JJ must be a frustrated defense attorney. She is excellent at cross examining the litigants like a sharp attorney.

[@bl7817]

She was a family court judge, where you see dirtbags as awful as some animal owners.

[@blossomx1804]

The way she said "everyday" was legendary. And soo true, that's why i don't understand when parents can stay away from their kids.

[@DD-d6d3]

She legit said "the dog knows that I 'm her mother." 😂🤡

[@guttermouseTV]

Dogs shouldn’t be available to just anyone. At the very least you should have to take an IQ test before bringing one home.

[@bethp3320]

Agreed. Breeding and sale of animals should be more regulated.

[@elemental7207]

True, but consider that so many actual humans are brought into this world without an IQ test ( let alone a drivers license) but yet it happens. Kind of a moot statement, dontcha think?

[@uggyboots]

Kids too lol

[@ddfamf88]

Same could be said about “babies” or “kids”👍🏼

[@Lenasevilla-yb4ei]

It’s not that deep 🙄

[@itsjustmaddisen]

I’ve been binging these and it’s amazing. Absolutely love Judge Judy. Also the plaintiff has absolutely *nothing* going on upstairs. The cogs are not turning.

[@maryrodger5130]

The boyfriend was more important than the puppy.

[@miriamkivlehan3498]

A 110lb dog is the weight equivalent of 2 eight-year old kids or a 4'10" teen! As a 'mother' the plaintiff abandoned her 'baby' in favour of the boyfriend whose dog wanted to eat the baby; and now wants to sue the 'foster mother' for the return of the fully grown teen. It's clear she has no concept of how morally and legally wrong she is, but luckily her 'baby' found a lovely home

[@michaeljbasla5335]

Hello Miriam

[@michaeljbasla5335]

How are you doing over there today?

[@SnowWhiteTheU2]

I can’t go a day without my dogs, nevermind 2 years

[@tors14]

The number of times I check in with my pets while working from home is ridiculous. I agree, two years would be torture.

[@chiquitagreen5287]

I wouldn't be able to sleep with my dog.

[@aangeltx444]

It was so lonely without my dog when I went on vacation. I told my husband I'm taking her with me the next trip. I don't know who was crying more when we were reunited.

[@chilledart1269]

so true❤

[@leodoubleooseven8836]

Exactly. I don’t travel unless my babies can go

[@invalidusername883]

That lady who dumped her dog seems like she’s slurring her words.

[@t_aintbut1me416]

Something is wrong with her,,,,,definitely..

[@keeper6458]

Agreed!

[@pattilemonhouse7911]

Yep

[@Zenobiadream]

Jj is awesome “you’re not her mother”

[@nulse55]

If theres one thing its that when animal cases come to JJ's court Judge Judy understands the well-being of the animal.

[@FFProGamer2009]

Anybody sees this comment may god bless you everyday ♥️♥️♥️❤️❤️

[@FallenAngel53]

And you my love xxxx

[@AG-fs9xe]

You too!

[@brendakabanda2181]

And you too.

[@pugzlipigeon5906]

You too 🥰

[@gemrock]

You to❤

[@claybyrd4943]

Girl that ain't your dog : you chose the boyfriend over the dog now go away

[@kellymarietarotfamilypets9598]

Dogs have feelings, and to mess there routine up is not good! My pooches won’t even eat for A week when I go on holiday because they miss me to much! So to go take the dog bk will probably upset it, now that it’s settled leave the dog to be happy! It’s not about the money it’s about the animals feelings!!!

[@ericgranberg8893]

I love watching Judge Judy. Watching a professional jerk is always enlightening.

[@biff5856]

So why do you watch? Keep in mind this professional jerk is very successful and well liked to say the least... and you are?

[@ericgranberg8893]

@@biff5856 What part of "I love watching Judge Judy," is confusing to you?

[@bettyspaghetti4803]

Great Danes don’t live an extremely long life. That amount of time is a huge hunk of their lives.

[@eph2vv89only1way]

If she cared about the dog she wouldn’t demand her back after 2 years. She had the puppy for a few months so she wouldn’t be strongly bonded to her yet. Then the defendant had her for 2 years. That dog would be bonded to the defendant and tearing the dog away from her would be emotionally harmful to the poor dog. If she cared she would let the dog stay with the person she was bonded with

[@d.c.9012]

Imagine being a loyal dog on your last legs and your owner brings home a brand new Great Dane to replace you . 😭

[@wintercame]

Very sad. Hastening the dogs death.

[@anonymoushuman8443]

“I am her mother.” “You’re not her mother” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@mojave7604]

I love when Judge Judy says "whatever" to people.

[@maddiesmith4498]

Judge Judy knows exactly she didn't have to say anything LoL 😂 so it's so ridiculous that she would think that she could do that. Go JJ ❤️ 💯

[@reallifewithray2707]

In my opinion NO ONE who puts a value on their animal and says you can either give me my dog or the value of my dog does not deserve the animal because clearly they are willing to give it to someone else for a price! There is no price for my cats! If anyone came into my home and offered me money any amount I would not give either of them away and let me tell you I'm not rich LOL but I love my babies and they will be with me until they leave this earth or I do. And they are well taken care of, loved beyond measure and I understand people get into hard situations.... when I had to move from my friend's apartment back home to my parents I left my cat for one night I was going to leave him for two nights just so I could get moved back in but she said and I believe her because my cat and I were so close that he laid in the middle of my bedroom curled up crying for me so I went and got him the next day immediately. She could have said here's a million dollars for your cat and I would have said kiss my ass LOL

[@eloahnon4952]

THIS! I was looking for this statement! Who in their right fcukin mind, puts a monetary value on their furbaby? This woman is a piece of work.

[@reallifewithray2707]

@@eloahnon4952 I didn't realize it was the woman who had the dog for the longest time or longer than the other woman who wanted the money but at the end of the day she seemed to care about the dog and the dog is happy in her care and was only with the other owner for 6 weeks so I guess the ruling was correct it just makes me sad that anybody would say if you give me five grand I'll give you the dog

[@Lenasevilla-yb4ei]

It’s not that deep 🙄

[@alieddy3846]

@@Lenasevilla-yb4ei I said the same thing 😂😂😂

[@DesiAyala17]

Plaintiff: My dad passed away Judy: Oh whatever Me: Damn the savageness

[@ichemawisu]

Right like damn 😭 JJ shows 0 sympathy 😭😭

[@Pudding_Pupp]

“I bought it with cash I do not have the receipts for that”- Payment method does not change you keeping a receipt 😂

[@pegasoltaeclair0611]

Oh, so this is the infamous case... " - You are suing the defendant for the return of your Great Dane _or the dog_ - Yes. - You understand that this is an unsympathetic face to you! You understand that! - Yes, I've been trying to get the... - Listen to me: *WE'RE DONE!* " (case ends) LOL

[@jayycash212]

If I asked for a couple of M&M's I would expect maybe 5. SoS EminemenimEminemenimE

[@domjones_who3849]

MANNNNNN...THAT DAMN DOG DON'T EVEN KNOW HER ANYMORE AFTER 2 YEARS

[@TiaJacksonTheRealOneAndOnly]

I’m a dog lover I loss my dog 3 years ago and omg up to this day I’m still hurt 😔 I miss my dog so much

[@UTBBT]

Hold your head up mama, that baby is looking over you 💜💜

[@TiaJacksonTheRealOneAndOnly]

@@UTBBT 🙏🏾

[@gingercake0907]

Judge Judy “ I am just laying out the case. This is an unsympathetic face you are looking at, you do realize that?”

[@catherineeckstein2705]

Great Dane life expectancy is only 7-8 years …dog ain’t hers…

[@blackgarmentbag7482]

Judge said, “Whatever” thereby cutting off a potentially irrelevant story🤣🤣🤣

[@TaylorMMontgomery]

"Have you ever had a boyfriend before?" "yes." "what kind." "i hada staffordshire terrier" ytp :)

[@Rombizio]

Hahhahahshhshshhahahha. Here...keep my dog for 2 years. If you touch it, I will sue you.

[@darthcrowley5561]

The defendant should start a pod, love her voice

[@r.r911]

"when did you get your house?" Lol the whisper 🤣🤣

[@AminaBeans205]

I wanna know why she had to move out of her old house in order to get a settlement from her dad’s estate. She should have stayed in her original home.

[@princeofdatny]

“Whatever you moved in with your boyfriend and his pitbull“ - Judge Judy Hahahah that cut off and calling the dog what it is. Staffordshire Terrier…means Pitbull

[@bulldawg7232]

Only referred to as Staffordshire Terriers when in court 😆

[@stevecox7075]

The plaintiff looks like Hank from Breaking Bad.

[@jazzyj6640]

Dogs cost $1200? Damn, I adopted all of my animals so I didn’t even know this. 😳 Spaying a dog is considered “unnecessary?”

[@mariepret3903]

Yes, my dog is worth 3800

[@jazzyj6640]

@mariepret3903 I've always gone to the shelter. That's crazy!

[@lorirogers9304]

Adoption fees where I live are around $450.00. It has become a lucrative business to some.

[@ninosimone]

“ she couldn’t have a 200 pound grand Dame in heat around the house “😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@meganb5710]

50 seconds in....this isn't ending well for the plaintiff

[@hermanjoi]

ADOPT DON'T BUY 🙏❤️

[@jessicagauche3712]

The lady had two years to get her sh*t straight. I can't imagine doing that to my dogs.

[@joecrawford172]

When the plaintiff said, "The dog knows I am the mother." I can't believe Judge Judy didn't interrupt with "don't tell me what the dog knows."

[@kareneley-ix6lu]

Love when defendants don’t have to speak

[@gangisspawn1]

$1200 for a dog? How are kill shelters so common...

[@1ivanesku]

4:46 the best 'villain' EVERY DAY.. lol... Gary Oldman would be proud!

[@templar19]

Does the plaintiff know what spaying actually is and why it's important?? If not the defendant, the plaintiff would have ended up spaying a much older dog and consequently make the procedure much more complicated.

[@Kirby4life620]

i’m gonna start saying that. “i have a question, there’s a question out there.”😂

[@peterburman5193]

Really outrageous to sue the lady who took care of "your" dog for two years! Ungrateful and delusional

[@TMS-pj7fp]

I went to Germany for a month with my husband to visit his family and I took my labrador with me his ticket, vet visit, chip, etc cost more than our tickets, apiece, but I took him. I planned to take my 2nd pup but she was 2 anxious 4 plane ride so I left her with my mom at my house and my mom stayed with her at my home. I left my 2nd 1 with someone I trusted in home she knows because I felt like taking her would not be in her best interest due to her anxiety. I have 2 now that I leave with my mom only due to family emergencies, funeral, etc out of town. I myself couldn't go 2 days without seeing my pups because I couldn't handle it much less them not being able to handle it.

[@raintree3383]

Suing for the return of the Great Dane OR it;s value..........wow that says everything right there

[@DMO-om8md]

Defendant standing quietly FTW

[@AnarchistPoop]

For someone who never had a great dane, it speaks so well of the defendant. Those dogs are MASSIVE. They eat a huge lot and their poops are just....pstd inducing, my folk. Such huge dogs take a lot of thought before getting one, and only someone who loves and wants the breed would get it. She still kept them and loved them.

[@elliefunt755]

The plaintiff wears such heavy eyeliner!! It ages her, makes her look like she’s glaring at everyone.

[@jamessatterfield5705]

2:14 I’ll bet money she didn’t know where she was going 😜

[@Aceofwolves]

Anyone who thinks getting a dog fixed is , "an unneeded medical procedure." Should NOT have a dog

[@oovdap5909]

JJ: had you ever had a great day before? Ms Hirsch: No, I had not. Me: 😭😭 ... it took me a while to figure out she had said great Dane and not great day lmao.

[@josephphelps5696]

Oh. Boy. Some people shouldn’t have children or dogs, Period!!!

[@TristianoLonaldo]

It's so weird to hear someone equate a dog to children.....

[@saskia315]

I raised my children, now I have my little doggie, she is my baby, because I care for her as much as I cared for my kids when they were little. It’s the care that brings up the mother like feelings.

[@jonandra678]

Maybe don't buy a dog if you don't have a house or plan to move in with someone that can't have that dog. Crappy owner. Also, pretty sure her Xanax has kicked in lol

[@elemental7207]

Ultra tan with bottle dyed ' red hair'. Why do all the crazies with big aggressive dogs end up on here? Doberman, hmmmmmm? Sounds like they are fighting over a lover.

[@natalier6201]

My dogs are my entire world. I can’t go a day let alone 2 years.

[@jernigan007]

buying a bag of dog food is NOT the same, as homing an animal.

[@justinenicole3926]

If you'd settle for the value of the dog then you definitely abandoned the poor thing.

[@CeltycSparrow]

So this woman had this Great Dane for a couple of weeks as a puppy. She gave this dog to her friend, who then kept the dog for TWO YEARS because the original owner's boyfriend had a dog and the two dogs didn't get along. During that time, she has providing NOTHING in the way of financial support for this dog. As far as the dog is concerned, the defendant is her owner. She's the one that the dog has bonded to and she has taken care of this dog since she got her. I absolutely agree with Judge Judy's ruling. If the plaintiff had wanted her dog that badly, she would have gotten the dog back when they moved in 2016. The defendant even SAID "take your dog back."

[@frigid4real]

This case makes me laugh no matter how many times I see it!

[@otisfreeman5146]

The way she said “everyday” lol

[@mariafelix4745]

I have had a Great Dane in heat before, be prepared to either clean blood everywhere or have training pants in these beautiful creatures!

[@TboneSteak1992]

Love this channel

[@judywilson3953]

Irresponsible dog owner! She shouldn't be allowed to have another dog! Boyfriend vs dog? Dog always!

[@trunkzl740]

“do you know where i’m going” - JJ “yes!” - Plantiff we all know when JJ asks anyone that they have no idea where she’s going 😂😂

[@AliKhan-yx1dy]

How can u leave your dog for two years I can never do that

[@dharmallars]

What a great way to make sure your dog has adequate care and attention in her dying days-getting a new puppy! What an idiot. So eager to replace the dog she couldn’t even wait until it was dead.

[@JESUSLOVESYOU219]

Something funny about hearing JJ say “boyfriend and girlfriend” 😂 it’s as silly as it sounds tbh lol

[@owendarkhome86]

“A HARLEQUIN Great Dane.” God. The way she said that was so obnoxious. 🙄

[@adrienecrego]

She abandoned that baby..thank goodness the defendant took care of it!

[@tkilecalistyle2610]

You can’t take the dog back my god. That’s her home. Get a grip lady.

[@MrReaperHand]

The defendant should sue her stylist...hot damn.

[@violagentsch]

My God, her old dog wasn't even dead yet, so she went out getting a replacement. Wtf is wrong with ppl?

[@wolfiebunnyshopofficial3923]

even when I had to leave my old dog at a housing for a week for a family death out of state, I still texted the kennel owner daily to get pictures and updates. I couldn't go two whole weeks without knowing what's going on with my dog

[@mrich9654]

Omg. Stop buying dogs! Rescue, adopt!

[@kaygee5115]

Spaying your dog is medically necessary unless you believe in increasing the chance of pyometra and mammary cancer. Glad this dog was with someone who actually cared for its well-being.

[@marilyncornell2194]

That plaintiff doesn't deserve the dog!.

[@harrisonhanson2998]

🤣🤣🤣 “I visited the dog she came up to me & kissed me”. Dogs don’t kiss on people the way people kiss on people, I’m not a vet or a scientist but even I know that!

[@Sidious6460]

Honestly the fact she's suing either for money or the dog, makes me think she doesn't care that much about the dog. I sometimes don't know who to believe though, was she constantly visiting and paying for all the dogs food and told she would have dog returned. Giving up dog that long when you only had her for short time seems like a thing I would try to avoid at all costs though also. Not paying for every single expense to me is a sign she didn't still view it as her responsibility. I don't even know how much the dog is viewed as hers at this point when she had it a couple weeks total and been 2 years with other woman.

[@Lledrith]

Man, Bayonetta hasn't aged well.

[@tilethio]

Abandoning and asking back pets is a ridiculous claim. I will not give back a dog which I own for 6 months let alone 2 years.

[@BrooksDunn]

3:36 … that’s weird, I swear stores still provided receipts when you pay cash for stuff. Maybe I’m just needy when I take my receipt after paying cash.