Director Reacts - Episode 21 - 'Outro:Tear'

Director Reacts to BTS First Time Listen
Director Reacts - Episode 21 - 'Outro:Tear'



linktr.ee/rogu...
...

Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
#BTS #BTSreaction #BTSarmy

[@sc0ttishlass]

Joonie is the brain, Hobi is the heart and Yoongi is the soul - that is how they write and rap.

[@tatyanach5983]

So true!

[@peachesc.9078]

Couldn’t have said it better!! 😊

[@katja805]

That’s true

[@dzieckoziemi]

Perfectly said!

[@ette681]

Perfect!

[@maddencovers5890]

This was Hobi’s moment. RM and Suga killed it, per usual, but Hobi came in so hard and never let up. This is one of my favorite performances. I’ve never seen Hobi look so good. He’s so underrated as a rapper because he’s lead to 2 of the best the business has ever seen, but people forget that it’s not 2 of the best, it’s 3. He’s every bit as good, all 3 have their own style, and he’s goddamn impressive. Then he smiles and he’s pure sunshine.

[@taratravia9464]

they’re all so incredible in their own way- I always want more of Hobi in almost everything the 7 do. I want more dance and more rap and more of him speaking…and he’s not even my bias!

[@amberpearce710]

Totally agree

[@amberpearce710]

@@taratravia9464 Same here. I would love hear him sing more!

[@aworthingable]

“I’m not going to Google it. This is what family is for.” 💜

[@jerseybultaoreune6107]

Beautifully said, Madden... I think that's why it's somewhat jarring to see Hobi in this space, bc he doesn't go there often... when he does, we feel every piece of it. He leaves it all on the stage. 💜

[@chimchim7121]

joon : analyzes the world suga : criticizes the world hobi : makes his own world

[@taratravia9464]

ooooooo!

[@Pilgrim80.aka.creativseelchen]

❤❤❤

[@jenjin9492]

8:03 notice T.E.A.R. as an acronym, it's Psychologist J.W. Worden's 4 Task of Mourning: T. - To accept Reality of Loss E.- Experience the pain of Loss A.- Adapt to new reality w/o lost person R.- Reinvest in new reality -Suga has great interest in psychology books as well as RM 💜 Actually all of them are, they love to read books.

[@jadedseoul76]

Thanks for this. Was not aware. 💜

[@amberpearce710]

I was thinking about commenting then I saw this!

[@vikaursa]

this is the pearl of knowledge, thx

[@anaastorga6205]

Thank you! I was not aware of this either

[@marinal.]

ty!!!

[@valia3784]

something really important that you should know: "The lyrics have both tear (tir; as in crying) and tear (ter; as in ripping apart), to be rhymed with fear. In EP.6 of Break The Silence, SUGA shared, “The lyrics for Tear were written for the members. When I was writing the melody, at the time, we were deeply contemplating whether we should quit or not. When I played the song for the members, we all cried together." i cry every time i listen to it. i loved your reaction and thank you for becoming my happy and safe space! (i've been here since the beginning, but i rarely comment.) 💜

[@taratravia9464]

I was about to post this and so glad you did - I was going to have to look up how to easily explain the phonetics and you did it perfectly 💜

[@rhondaulm180]

Thank you for giving him the phonetics. It's very important. 💜

[@s.susanmarandi9080]

@@taratravia9464 Same 👍

[@s.susanmarandi9080]

💜👍

[@erume5776]

T.E.A.R means 4 steps of mourning and grief: T'o Accept the Reality of the Loss E'xperience the Pain of Grief A'djust to a World Without the Deceased R'einvest yourself into the world

[@salinasahrom6364]

Amazing !!

[@dzieckoziemi]

I was looking for that comment 😌

[@angelicar2901]

I was going to comment this too. 🤗

[@KaTie-wt1dh]

That one hits hard🤯

[@dzieckoziemi]

"These guys belong on stage" - truer words have never been spoken. BTS's music is impeccable, amazing, moving, superb quality on its own. But to experience it LIVE... you get to see their absolute true love for music, for performance. They LIVE up there on that stage.

[@7toheavan4ever54]

Beautiful words Army 💜🙏

[@Honey-je4pr]

That's exactly it! Their music is great and their personalities are charming, but THIS is what separates them from others. They were born to be on that stage. They were born to be BTS.

[@jerseybultaoreune6107]

I can testify to this... When BTS took the stage at their 12/2 concert, I knew I wasn't ready for their energy live - but did not know how Not Ready I was... 🤯🤯🤯💜

[@catdaragon8028]

I LOVED LOVED LOVED how they showed off their stage when Megan Thee Stallion came to So-Fi. That is their happy place, there in the middle of thousands. It's incredible. 💜💜💜

[@marciasiedschlag3890]

It’s so awful that this pandemic happened just at the peak of their popularity, cancelling so many concerts. It must be so frustrating for them.

[@bt7657]

97% of the time, the rap line each write their own lyrics that they rap. BTS and Big Hit both feel strongly believe that to rap authentically, you need to be writing your verses. RM has said before that the three rappers often (though not always) use their three rap sections in a song (even group songs with all seven members) to set up a thesis + antithesis --> synthesis structure. Where two rap verses set up oppositional forces to each other and the third one merges them. They seem to do this by writing their verses independently, coming together and seeing how their ideas mesh and contradict each other and then working them into a more holistic story. In general, the vocal line's lyrics have been written by RM or another in-house lyricist. THAT BEING SAID, as the band has gotten older, the vocalists have become much more involved in lyric writing, composing and even producing. (We are hoping for mix tapes from each of them!), so in their newer songs (map of the soul 7, BE albums) or singles released on sound cloud, the vocalists were likely very involved in the lyrics/music as well. (that's not to say vocalists never wrote lyrics or composed before those two albums, but if you are looking for a 'general rule of thumb', that's a good one to follow.) After each album is released, RM sits down and gives a live stream where he talks about the production and story behind each song and the roles different members played. That being said, he has said REPEATEDLY that he doesn't like to give the 'meaning' behind songs because "once a song is released, it belongs to the listener". He feels so strongly about the audience owning the music and coming up with their own interpretations that he refused to publish official lyrics to his 2018 mix-tape mono, allowing listeners to even 'hear' different words. Fans will love to give you info about songs precisely because the songs come from BTS's own lives and experiences -- so having the context helps audiences understand the emotions/worries/fears/background behind the words -- but BTS themselves would never want you to use that as some type of 'official' intepretation. I love all your reactions and I love this song!

[@rmm5265]

I’m incredibly impressed with this explanation! Well said! Well said! 💜

[@luvBTS7]

Excellent advice on having the freedom to interpret a song however it resonates with the listener! That's the beauty of music, and art in general.

[@marinal.]

looks now now its not mixtapes but albums! 😅

[@goreyfantod5213]

Your comment should have 100x more likes - it was factually accurate, insightful & well-phrased. Bravo!

[@sylviahilinski4378]

This was their “breakup” song. When Yoongi presented the melody to the members;they all cried. Meaning of tear to Namjoon was “crying “. To Suga tear meant to “rip apart “. And Hobi was fear. The fear of “losing his members”. These songs just hit differently once you know there meaning.

[@materidouska286]

Yoongi has written this masterpiece when they were considering disbandment due to emotional and physical burn out. When he presented the finished " product" to other rappers who then written their own parts and played it to the other members they all cried ... This iconic performance of Outro:Tear from Wembley is called among Army "Hobi in black Dior performance" lol.

[@alicet_x]

This is the perfect summary! 🤣

[@ottaviagiano2823]

Tear is a heartbreaking masterpiece, and Hobi ate up the last part, leaving no crumbs. It gives me chills every time.

[@taratravia9464]

my bf always say’s “he chews up all the scenery” when he loves an actor. I feel this way about Hobi

[@ottaviagiano2823]

@@taratravia9464 oh he definetely made sure you looked at nothing but him. I am mesmerized every time I watch this performance.

[@Honey-je4pr]

@@taratravia9464 That's exactly it! You can't look away! Have eyes only for Hobi!

[@Honey-je4pr]

Yes, it always leaves me with chills

[@LoveYoonMin]

This was them potentially disbanding. They cried about it while delivering their speech at the MAMA Awards in Hong Kong(2018). I wish you can react to that video. This song expresses their pain and fear of parting (tear) and of sadness (shedding tears for it) - I think it goes the same for all of us. The first time Suga played this to the members, they all cried.

[@christinaneville2814]

The song Let Go (full members song) goes along w/this song & was going to be like a farewell to ARMY but thankfully they stayed together

[@dariajustdaria2292]

Writing this while you're still watching, please notice the double interpretation of tear - tear as in crying and tear as in tearing stuff apart. And this song is written by Suga for the members when they contemplated disbanding in 2018 due to overwhelming pressure of their fame.

[@aishwaryaahirrao]

Yup.. BTW rapline wrote the lyrics (joon, hobi & yoongi)..yoongi wrote the melody

[@dariajustdaria2292]

@@aishwaryaahirrao true, rapline always write their own verses

[@aishwaryaahirrao]

@@dariajustdaria2292 yup😁

[@jkvlogs9224]

Rm and Hobi also part of writing this song. It's not only suga

[@aishwaryaahirrao]

@@jkvlogs9224 yup.. it's a lil misinformation into Fandom that this song is wrote by Yoongi..as we know rapline write their own verse ofc..so the lyrics are written by rapline..just the melody is wrote by yoongi

[@pichuka24]

I'm not the one that is always leaving comments, I just read and like them, but I swear that tears came to my eyes after reading the thumbnail!! This song is everything!! 😭😍

[@pichuka24]

@@ideagirl 🫂 Borahae 💜

[@amberpearce710]

🫂🫂💜🫂🫂💜🫂🫂

[@myhopeisjhope8315]

Although bts songs can be interpreted in many ways "outro:tear" was originally written for the members when they considered disbanding. i think it's important to mention this, cause when you know it just hits harder. And yeah, rm,suga and j-hope wrote their parts based on their own experience and feelings.

[@rihana533]

THE TRACK THAT SUMMONS THE ENTIRE FAMDOM🙌

[@classical7]

This song is already heartbreaking as it is. So many people can resonate with this song. Everyone goes through the heartbreak of a relationship ending in many different situations. I was already feeling emotional when I first heard it, but after discovering the true meaning behind these lyrics and its intentions, my heart felt even more torn and completely ripped my heart out. The idea of the possibility of them "breaking up/disbanding" as a group just took this song to another level for me. Thank you for staying strong Bangtannies through all the trials and tribulations! ARMYs are forever grateful. 😭💜🎶

[@Wila.NoniKant]

💜

[@imajinallthepurple]

"He was the perfect one to sing this part". Yes, that's exactly what they as a group and as artists prioritize. That's why the line distribution isn't necessarily even in their songs. There've been incidents where fans of a certain member have been dissatified with their fave's lack of lines and acted out. They (now) generally ensure that everybody has a part but the song itself matters to them as well and you can tell that they really care about what they create. The rap line is a little special because they tend to write their own verses but I'm speaking of all of them as a whole group.

[@amberpearce710]

I totally agree with you…BTS will write, compose, produce, distribute part, etc. how they want and how they want the song. We should be thankful instead of criticize their choices. They are professionals they can decide things without us complaining….

[@baudolino2727]

Yes, yes, agree. That kind of fights because "my fav has three words less than others" are stupid and unnecessary. They know what they're doing, just let them do it. And enjoy 😉

[@ot7raplinebiased573]

Thank you Roscoe. That song is my number one. I listened to it after I had gone through my divorce and simply couldn’t understand how these kids who are half my age could write about this pain that I was going through… how could they know?? It was many months later that I found out what the song was written for. Doesn’t diminish the pain and emotion but also healing I go through when I listen to it. I love this song with every broken shard of me they pieced back together💜

[@mindytaylor4950]

Much love to you.

[@s.susanmarandi9080]

Hope you're thriving now.💜 I'm also constantly amazed by the depth of their thoughts at such a young age.

[@rhondaulm180]

💜💜💜

[@namastan5580]

Same my favorite part is Suga's "This is the real me and this is the real you"

[@mammak990]

ah, the very first note ~ you will never forget it and will recognise the song for eternity by that note. It'll 11pm for me, I'M STAYING UP ROSCOE!!, Can someone scoot over a smidge and hand me the blanket cause I'm tired, wake me in an hour💜

[@tracydowd4013]

@Mamma K - Here is the BTS Love Yourself Blanket. I hope it keeps you warm 💜

[@katera465]

That first note 🤌🏽

[@christinaneville2814]

@MammaK plz take my spot it's time for to pull a Yoongi & stretch out on my side on the floor 🤗

[@christinaneville2814]

@@katera465 ARMY's unofficial battle cry

[@mammak990]

@@tracydowd4013 Thank you for the comfy blanket, I felt it wrapped around me!💜

[@E_L_]

I always thought when SUGA says "a thing like tear is a luxury" basically means 'I can't afford to cry, I can't dwell in the pain of parting or I can't even get myself to cry...' As someone that has a hard time processing emotions, crying doesn't come easy to me. So maybe the line hits me differently. SUGA's lyrics always hits me at my core.

[@taratravia9464]

this line always kills me. I’m a psychologist and this song is a goldmine

[@amberpearce710]

Oh I didn’t think about it this way…I thought about maybe it meant because he is a celebrity and every action is being watched and criticized. So sometimes he has to hold back.

[@s.susanmarandi9080]

@@taratravia9464 It is, isn't it?

[@vikaursa]

"a thing like a tear is a luxury" !! I now have days when I want to cry because I know that if I'm sad, I can be happy at other times. But it doesn't work yet, so far I have the feeling locked in myself for fear of hurting myself. maybe ...

[@E_L_]

@@vikaursa I've lived with those feelings, and felt I was self sabotaging my own life for quite some time. I found a good therapist, and it helped me greatly. I don't live stuck in a world where I am my own worst enemy. I hope you can find inner peace and learn to love yourself. In the words of Kim Namjoon. Remember you are "limited edition" You are uniquely special, and you're worth loving.

[@XxrazorxmintxX]

Just a small note about the line “our end came in two characters” In Korean he says 글자 which can be translated at “letters [of the alphabet]” but Korean is written in syllables kind looking like a Chinese character (as in it’s a combo of letters that form one sound). So in this context he’s talking about the 2 syllables that make the word “이별” which is both “breakup” but also “parting”.

[@carolwebster9215]

Thanks for this, I was wondering about this line and what it means, hoping someone would talk about it in the comments 💜

[@marissa1341]

Hobis part in this always hype me up. I still get goosebumps listening to it. I also love how he gets into the headspace behind Suga. This is top tier. House of Cards by the Vocal line will do the same...well so does truth Untold.....ok a lot of songs still give me goosebumps.

[@rhondaulm180]

House of Cards is one of my favorites as well. You can literaly see and feel their emotions in their live performance.

[@Hotshortie]

Marissa; you and I have same taste. Tear, House of Cards, Truth Untold, my favorite BTS songs.

[@vaishalipatil-re5he]

Me too 👍 for house of cards

[@jaden6312]

Yes and underrated Butterfly (Prologue Mix) is what you hear as you walk through heaven....

[@ayy_yo6619]

Hobi killing it even though he has the shortest part. This man who had very little experience in rapping before joining BTS has mastered the game.

[@aishisikdar7243]

Probably my favourite rapline song 😍.This was written at a time when they were deeply considering disbandment , so it was written for the members and they cried together when they listened to this. Havent started watching yet but I know you will love it. 😇

[@KaTie-wt1dh]

Same😎

[@TeddeyZzzz]

BTS are really forthcoming about writing lyrics from their experience. It's never just a concept. When you look at the overall story many songs tell you can paint a pretty vivid picture. By the way Roscoe you were spot on each member wrote their own verse. And there's three different stories being told by each individual connected by one theme.

[@cieradivens3934]

Exactly! Many of their songs are also connected with references (lines, music, etc) from other songs (or even speeches) or continuations of themes. That’s why it’s always good to (at some point) listen to albums in order so you can get a fuller picture of what they are trying to say. It’s also helpful to read notes on Doolset because she points out the references between songs or even cultural references that you would notice if you were Korean.

[@TeddeyZzzz]

@@cieradivens3934 💯

[@Honey-je4pr]

@@cieradivens3934 Exactly! Love Doolset for doing that extra little bit!

[@significant_other]

When this song came out, ARMY assumed it was about romantic relationships. Over a year later Suga shared that he wrote this song when members were considering to disband 😢 When ARMY heard that, the whole internet was flooded with tears 😭 No ARMY ever interpret this song was for members (you know how ARMY love to decode BTS songs 😅). They suffered so much to get where they are now. I'm thankful their bond is so strong 🥰

[@charnight181]

My heart! About a year into becoming Army this overtook all my other favourites to become my #1. Remarkable really for someone who hated rap before. I am really looking forward to this

[@amberpearce710]

Same here. Almost a year for me and I didn’t like rap that much until them.

[@deelovesbts571]

Uh oh. Roscoe is going to explode from this one. I get chills every single time I hear it and tear up at Hobi's ending

[@natalierodreguez]

Ahhh yesss me tooo get the tissues ready!

[@Honey-je4pr]

Same! I always, always tear up at Hobi's verse. He raps with absolute raw emotion right there.

[@Maraaha55]

From Doolset - Written by DOCSKIM, Shin Myung-soo, SUGA, RM, j-hope Note: The lyrics have both tear (tir; as in crying) and tear (ter; as in ripping apart), to be rhymed with fear. In EP.6 of Break The Silence, SUGA shared, “The lyrics for Tear were written for the members. When I was writing the melody, at the time, we were deeply contemplating whether we should quit or not. When I played the song for the members, we all cried together.” I think that goes some way to explain the real pain that underlies this song and each performance. Thank you for your reaction to this! I agree that this song is customised to each voice so precisely that the verses feel like they are coming directly from each performer. They have been living together for ten years now - some of the members for slightly less, but these three it is now fully ten years. They know each other so well that, at times, it looks like they are limbs of the same body. Like you, I like to look deeper, even if I am not very good at finding explanations, because even without a clear explanation, the substance of what they are talking about is real and true. Most KPop does little for me - the artists are very obviously very skilled, but it is rare for idols to be allowed much artistic freedom so the songs often seem very superficial and repeating moments from the same subject themes. BTS dives. I have not been able to actually show BTS to any of my small number of friends - and frankly, I don't know if I could bear to see that kind of polite, bland reaction. Several times I have asked them to explore for themselves, but, while one of them said she had listened to some stuff, I really DO NOT know if I believe that she really listened. Maybe played it in the background perhaps. I want them to make even the smallest effort to understand! It makes me sad. I can't help thinking that one friend in particular might need BTS (ish) - has been buffeted with awful working relationships and escaping from one narcissistic supervisor and then found herself in a new job with a new company, and another narcissist!

[@MariaChavez-ey5sr]

Oh you just described my concern about showing friends BTS, a “polite bland reaction”. Because if you dig the tiniest bit and pay attention it’s so deep and wonderful but they won’t trust me. Now my BFF does tease me and bought me a Love Myself shirt for xmas so she won’t listen (yet) but I’m hoping.

[@anaastorga6205]

I feel your comment about sharing BTS and having a polite, bland reaction. My BFF would so benefit emotionally from BTS's music but I fear she'll dismiss it and not really listen because of the 'boyband' label and the language barrier. So many people miss out! They really are healing and empowering.

[@TaylorCanada8]

I understand what you mean about wanting to share BTS with friends, but struggling with trying to help people understand the power of BTS. Unless someone is invested in discovering them on their own, it's impossible for them to understand. I too have friends that I know would be helped by BTS (struggling with self-love etc), the response is usually "that kind of music isn't my thing" which is laughable because they do so many genres. I feel sorry for people who haven't (and may never) understand the depth of BTS....it's usually impossible to explain.

[@JenAvaShei]

This was the song that made me realize that I actually like rap. Not every kind of rap but until I heard this one I thought I didn't like rap at all. Now I know how powerful it can be. And so so deep...

[@carolynmatthews1545]

I hear you, I have always hated rap until I found BTS, I'm giving more rap a chance since then but nothing can compare to them.

[@gaylerichardson5649]

When you read these comments and learn the meaning of this song, I promise you, you'll go back and give it another listen with fresh ears. It's just so heart wrenching and raw. Thank you so much for your recent rapline reactions. I know you're "rapping" this up soon (rapping? wrapping? see what I did there? lol), but when you have a chance, please please please give Cyphers 1, 2, 3, and 4 some of your time (reaction or not). You will absolutely be blown away. Much love to you and Annie! Much love to the #couchcrew 💜💜💜

[@sakuralovesanimation]

Yoongis part is my fav his line " the dream has finally become just a dream" hits me so hard 😭 this song is just heart-wrenching. I hate when people who don't know bts say they're not deep or just have happy-go-lucky songs, I always tell them hell nah read tears lyrics then say that to me.

[@sakuralovesanimation]

I agree Yoongi(Suga) is very upfront, honest, blunt, or genuine, whichever way you wanna say it, with his songs that's what draws me to him again and again, I love how he never holds back.

[@slee7925]

ooh mate outro tear is A Spectacle for the eyes, A Stab to the heart once you read the lyrics. Dior made these outfits specially for BTS for their Love Yourself concerts and dare I say it made the guys feel ELEVATED 🔥

[@imajinallthepurple]

Yes, Dior's designer Kim Jones really loves them. I can't say I blame him... 💜

[@MariaChavez-ey5sr]

The Dior outfits are just a cherry on the very emotional performance but the perfect cherry. My favorite rapline fits, the boots to the fit of the pants and how each looked was perfect.

[@amandaweiler6371]

Suga had a solo song "Burn It" it is played daily in our house. Often during homeschool math lessons 🤣 when you have time add it to what I'm sure it a very long list you have of things to listen too! Lol

[@adenahill8798]

You said "these guys, all 7 belong here on stage" The sad part is, at that time, they weren't sure they could continue. Everything was happening so fast they weren't sure they could handle it. But the thought of giving up, disbanding and loosing each other was to much for them to handle. That's why when they were writing this song, they all cried.When you know this, this performance really hits you hard, They were contenplating giving up on their dream. It makes me cry every time, They decided they had to at least try. And we "Army" are thankful that they did.

[@debsuk8249]

Tear live at Wembley Stadium! This is one of my favourite performances ever....by anyone! Thank heavens they didn't disband ❤

[@BTSeomma1977]

As I mentioned before, Suga started this song when BTS was contemplating disbanding. I read somewhere that disbanding to Joonie meant shedding tears; to Suga it meant tearing out his heart; to Hobi it meant his biggest fear. I was so hoping you’d end the week with this. God I love this song 💜

[@geniancatarinaferro5564]

Yes!!!! I hope you did the Live one from London, because their emotions were palpable on Live version. Love the recorded, but incomparable to Live performance.

[@natalierodreguez]

Yea the live one is soooooo powerful it’s just soooo good!!

[@TheHoneyee]

That was great. I never been apart of something like this before. Even if I missed most of it.. have a good weekend and stay safe couch crew.. thank you Roscoe

[@ThisRoscoe]

Thanks for coming!

[@Saraard_]

Thank you for this!!! You asked about Suga’s verse when he spelled T.E.A.R. This refers to the tasks of grief: T = To accept the reality of loss E = Experience the pain of the loss A = Adjust the new environment without the lost person R = Reinvest in the new reality Tear is a piece of their heart. Its heart wrenching for us too.

[@mdc1746]

Many have explained what this song means, so for me this is a reminder of how blessed we are that they didn’t disband and that they continue to share their art, passion and love with us!💜Thank you Roscoe, excited for the next comfy couch gathering,

[@mariaalkassouf8207]

Dude, preparing myself now for when you drop the MMA 2019 reaction video. It is 40sh minutes by itself plus “a day” of Roscoe reacting to it🤣 Oh dear I better up my popcorn game on that one!🤩

[@mindytaylor4950]

I can’t wait lol! But Roscoe watch the older MMAs first please!!!

[@mariaalkassouf8207]

@@mindytaylor4950 oh yeah agree… the older ones are also as good (in my opinion)… if watch in order you can see their progress in a way… can’t find the right words… as Roscoe says “vocabulary”🙈

[@annanamoose9943]

MMA 2019 was so amazing .I couldn't believe they were really that good live, and that was an award show!?!?!?, When the concert in LA came up last year I had to go see for myself. BTS did not disappoint. I've been to good concert before but BTS, and the BTS army, live is an experience. I LOVED IT!!!!!

[@danielakoff6321]

I actually prefer the MMA 2018 performance, but it’s a personal taste thing. I’m not a fan of the 2019 aesthetics. To my personal taste, the 2019 had great moments, but overall was a bit tacky, the 2018 was so much more elegant, with the colors, the Korean traditional dances and clothes. To my taste it was way better. But I know people adore the 2019. Truth is there’s no bad BTS performance.

[@houseofalex]

Pls watch in order MAMA 2016 - Boy Meets Evil, Lie, BST, Fire MAMA 2017 - Cypher, Mic Drop MMA 2018 - Fake Love, Airplane pt2, Idol Then MMA19 Both MMA 2020 and MAMA 2020 - Black Swan, ON, Dynamite

[@suhani2748]

My most fav rapline song. The emotions in this song is just so overwhelming 😭

[@clarechen1081]

SO excited for this. Outro Tear is in my top 5 BTS songs. I'm commenting now because whenever your videos are uploaded its 1am here in New Zealand and by the time I watch it, it's many hours later and I'm always late 😆

[@butterbuttersbetter3689]

NZ here too! but I’m always up at 1am😏

[@clarechen1081]

@@butterbuttersbetter3689 hey kiwi army!!

[@irinatache1107]

" these guys belong on stage!" 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 When i discovered TEAR i listened 4 hours without break, it teard me...and i did not know it was about them disband

[@silviamunoz6863]

T.E.A.R. is related to psychology. It's about the tasks of grief: T = to accept the reality of the loss. E= experience the pain of the loss. A= adjust to the new environment without the person lost. R= reinvest in the new reality. You said "they were made to it (stage)" and that's why we have them til now. It was the reason they decided not to disband in 2018. Their way to put every problem on the table and discuss it to solve it it's awesome, I would like to be this way...

[@melgaye0]

As someone who is in the midst of going thru a divorce this song hits extremely hard. Lyrics are genius and their performance is beyond amazing. Edit: I'm gonna take that drive and sit in this song. I haven't done it yet but will. 💜💜💜

[@MariaChavez-ey5sr]

I hope you get through your divorce ok and take that drive. Borahae.

[@anaastorga6205]

Wishing you the best in your next chapter, take the drive blasting this! Much love and strength to you 💜

[@melgaye0]

@@anaastorga6205 Thanks ARMY friend! 😘😘💜💜

[@melgaye0]

@@MariaChavez-ey5sr Thanks Dear ARMY friend 💜💜💜

[@luvBTS7]

The way I got instantly excited but also my stomach dropped when I saw this thumbnail pop-up. Tear is just THAT song. I knew you'd love it, and I knew I'd love watching you love it, but damn it's always a punch to the gut. This is my #1 rap line song.

[@anggianggraeni1120]

Yes,actually Suga wrote this song...it was the song that he wrote when they struggled with disbanding thing that time....all the members were cryng when their first heard this song

[@aishwaryaahirrao]

Lil correction ☺️: rapline wrote the lyrics, yoongi wrote the melody..

[@michmoe85]

I’m thankful I got to see this performed live. I wish I could upload my fancam of the audience, during the chorus of this song, here. It’s so loud, we probably echoed for miles. I became Army when this album came out and this is still one of my fav BTS songs. It gives me chills every time. Joon and Yoongi set us up to be knocked out by Hobi. Love this song!

[@anaastorga6205]

You're so lucky! I can just imagine the excitement and amazing energy from the crowd.

[@ashleybriggs750]

The day we learned that this song was about the members when they were on the verge of disbanding was intense for army. That reveal made it so much more powerful and meaningful. What a relief they are (still) 7.

[@Bonbon_Bangtan]

I loved being in the premiere.. the chat with the couch crew was awesome.. but ya'll finished the sprite before giving me some 😂😂.. anyways.. this song is a masterpiece.. SPOILER ALERT Mr. Roscoe.. don't read the rest of this comment if you don't want to know the reason behind this song.. While song actually ties into the whole theme of Love Yourself: Tear album and it's the perfect outro to the album.. it describes in beautiful poetry how parting in a relationship means.. and how you imagine seeing the true meaning of love when you go through such times.. however Suga has said that they wrote this song in a time when they considered disbandment.. they were all going through a tough time in the time between 2015-2017.. they were receiving much hate for no reason.. and ARMY had always supported them through these tough times.. and it was also the time when they started getting famous internationally and it felt very overwhelming for them.. but in the end they pulled themselves together and helped each other to stay strong.. and here we are.. still on this journey in 2022.. Suga said he played this song when they were all gathered together and they all cried after hearing it.. which explains how deep and emotional this song is.. and how much it means to them.. which you can see in their eyes during performing it.. it's a powerful song.. and like you said.. you can be going through something like a breakup or any kind of parting and play this song and let it all out.. again BTS songs can relate to everyone.. Thank you Mr. Roscoe for hanging out.. it was a pleasure.. see you next time.. purple you 💜💜💜💜💜

[@amberpearce710]

Love your comment. However he already saw it.

[@Bonbon_Bangtan]

@@amberpearce710 yea, I saw the community post a while ago.. can't wait to watch together.. thank you Amper💜💜

[@ette681]

So glad you did live. The energy, interplay of RM, Suga and J Hope live, the best! That Suga wrote it about them talking about disbanding and how they cried hearing it. The intensity shows the deep feelings this brings to them. Still can relate to anyone in a break up situation.

[@shannonborahae]

Roscoe I have been trying to tell you. They all have pluralities about them. All 7 of them. If you ever get around to Hobi’s Boy Meets Evil, you will see his dark side. And of course the dancing and cinematography is insane. Suga’s Shadow is the same and deals with mental health and loneliness. When you start getting into the run BTS etc you will see how funny and loving they are. The millisecond they step on stage, they turn into absolute beasts. Whether it be dancing, singing, rapping or whatever. You hit it on the head, they are all meant to do this. Consummate professionals and total beasts!!

[@Krystara]

Sobbing into my coffee.. This song is so powerful. If they had stopped back when this was written I would never have found them and that.. scares me.

[@s.susanmarandi9080]

That's deep. 💜

[@victoryred5362]

This song hits me in, perhaps, a strange way. I was 8 years old when I began to actively hate my body. (Unfortunately all too common for dancers and gymnasts.) This song speaks to me about trying to hang on to a healthy relationship with myself. Torn between self-loathing and desperately wanting to love myself. Something I've struggled with for over 30 years. And that's the fantastic thing about art-and BTS in particular-the connection the music makes with our own personal stories and feelings.

[@Thaology]

O M G ROSCOE!!! Besides Mono, I have been quietly waiting for you to react to any song from the LY Tear album! On the ibighit site, the description says "LOVE YOURSELF 轉 ‘TEAR’ album embodies the pain of boys faced with parting." Many of my favourite tracks are on this album as the lyrics really hit me hard, like a good upper cut. Outro Tear is my favourite BTS track.. Feels like my past troubles around loss are perfectly compacted in a song. All the questions from the confusion, to the T.E.A.R model of grief, to the fear from all the emotional flashbacks that repeats. Then years later learning what it was really about.. 🤯 It is like a leet rogue's finishing move or a super combo strike before ko.. this song is a masterpiece!! You are awesome Roscoe! Never change!!💜💜💜 Edit after watching: This is my most played song and for the very reason you mentioned! It reminds me to accept and embrace my truths as it's so easy to forget the 'other' perspective . What I love about this, is we get 3 sides of the story in one song and it feels complete. Same like you.. I liked the song the first time but i'm obsessed with it now. Every time I did watch it, it layered up and now has become my most go to song!! I think initially I wasn't ready to face some truths perhaps but when you are ready.. it becomes everything and more. Magic Shop is another song that didnt impact me much at first but is everything to me now. lol I love BTS!!! xo

[@natalierodreguez]

Ahhhh yessss! Can’t wait for this one! I’ll be there with bells on! I mean tissues… I mean… Gosh this one was actually a very emotional one for me back when I found out what it was actually written about 💜 it’s so powerful can’t wait to se your reaction!

[@pie8999]

Hehe found ya

[@monekos1094]

Yay!!!! This is my favorite BTS song, especially when I learned the meaning behind it! 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@ThisRoscoe]

Reaction to my discovery of the origin coming today.

[@monekos1094]

@@ThisRoscoe Yay!!!! You spoil us too much!!!! Also, you always have the best quotes for me to steal! 'Where my Hobi wants to Hobi out of my Hobi'! Are you kidding me?! I'm mad because I didn't think of it first, especially since Hobi is my Ult Ult bias! 😡😤😂😂😂🥰🥰🥰

[@fae-armyxbangtan613]

@@ThisRoscoe omg can’t wait Roscoe!!

[@ThisRoscoe]

@@monekos1094 that’s one of my favorites too now haha

[@racheljerusha]

All art is subjective. So it moves people in different ways and we find the meaning in relation to what it causes us to feel. The one who creates, of course, fashions their art in relation to their experience. So draw from their music what you will. This song was written during a difficult and pivotal time with BTS. Finding out how this song was born was both heartbreaking and beautiful for me. You don't like spoilers so you won't ever hear it from me. The meaning of this song is explained in their docuseries, Break the Silence. 💜

[@raevan2125]

Suga's vocals and lyrics ARE raw. That is a perfect way to describe him. This is why I am so drawn to his work...he brings his entire soul into everything that he does. This song makes me cry but at the same time it is so beautiful that they were able to express themselves in this way and work through their emotions. And its so relatable because everyone of us has been through this process.

[@dragons4me393]

This performance, this song..are just it! And our Sunshine came for everyone that day💜

[@fefa812]

I'm Army since 2016...and this song, is one of my all time favorite of them. Luckily I saw this performance 2x times live. It's really raw and captivating!!! Greetings from Germany 💜💜💜

[@FarhanaK]

General rule fo thumb, Rapline almost always 95% of the time, write their own verses. Sometimes other rappers might write the rap for the other but generally they all write their own rap verses and they also write for the vocal line. Vocal line have written songs for themselves as well but when it comes to BTS group related solos, sometimes its vocal line writing their own with others or its the rapline and other big hit regulars helping write. But Rapline usually write their own. But this song my god. It was sad enough but when Yoongi revealed what this song is really about we cried. And we only found out the truth in their documentary that dropped in 2020. As for Outro Tear, the boys wrote their own verses but they also helped each other out and had other writers in as well.

[@Southurnsassy]

😃Roscoe! Great reaction! Outro: Tear is a Suga song. He wrote the base of this song when the boys were thinking of disbanding. Tear is a song about BTS breaking up. You are correct that the guys wrote their lyrics, it hits different when you know they wrote them about the band breaking apart.😳 RM says tear as in cry, Suga says tear as in rip and Jhope says fear of course. Mind(Joonie), body(Hobi heart) and soul(Yoongi). Journey on... 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@rosemeadows6920]

Hi Roscoe. This is why I love BTS.....they wear their hearts on their sleeves. Their rap is so honest and real unlike other rappers whose rap should be spelt with a c in front of it. Everything BTS does has meaning. They are awesome. 😘

[@endang2870]

Aaah, that last part from Hobi... Gave me chills every single time!! He truly put out all of his emotions here. And, gotta mention his Dior outfit... Perfection 👌💜.

[@pj_002]

This performance was everything... So emotionally powerful. I still get goosebumps listening to it. You can see how RM, Suga and hobi were feeling and expresing the lyrics clearly thu the way they were performing. Anger, frustration, sadness, guilt, longing..... And what's more interesting is when u know the meaning and the reason they wrote this. It becomes even more special. Hats off to them. At the end, I always cry seeing jhope teary.

[@docineng]

So much respect for their art and lyricism.. you’re right to use the word “substantial”. Their songs have significance and always relatable.💜

[@amaliedigby1231]

This song gives me goosebumps. Definitely my top 5!! Rap line supremacy 💜

[@Bostonvibes1940]

I think I mentioned this performance on every video since you first said you were doing the rap line. I couldn't wait. I remember sitting in a theater with my husband watching a BTS movie and a clip of this song came on. I leaned close to him and pointed at Suga and said, his verse is so brutal. A few months later he asked me for a divorce right before our 25th anniversary. Then I felt Suga's, burn it so there is nothing left. (And you killed me with go for a drive, listen to this song and let it out, because I have and now I am again. Not driving, just crying.) Whether this song is about the band breaking up or a relationship ending, I think the feelings can be the same. My 25 year marriage to someone I felt I knew and shared the same dreams/path with can feel the same as 7 members finding out maybe they weren't walking the same path on the same dream. Another personal story for the family. I hope there are tissues and someone with a comfy shoulder on that couch. 💜

[@KittieMom56]

Whew! This live of Tear gets me every time! RM & Suga kill it but J-Hope’s passionate performance makes me hold my breath. 😩 I’m loving how you watch it first for feel and then go back and look at the lyrics. I appreciate you 💜

[@dulseokbangtan]

This performance is my fave because of Hobis passion in the end

[@Grassisgreenbean]

That smile when Hobi comes on 🙈🙈 bias wrecker?? Joonie look out

[@charlottepark8855]

Learning to find the meaning in BTS songs is a gateway to searching for meaning in life. BTS is teaching their ARMY to think and feel on a deeper level. They know what they are doing.

[@hadrianpeverell3073]

What you spoke on about at the end is exactly the frustration is with them. No one in my life will give the time to break down then lyrics and understand any of their songs. They don’t understand why I watch and learn so much about their music. They just say I am looking for validation that I like what I like. But I’ve never experienced music or an artist before that has made me want to go out and learn more about psychology or read several books (Dante’s Inferno, Omelas short story, etc.) to understand. And I feel like that is half the fun and it’s what makes music resonate and never get old. With generic songs, you play them enough and get bored, I’ve found with BTS I never do. Each time it plays I’m either bopping to the beat, recalling lyrics , or being distracted by vocals.

[@kayzeegurl]

I so,so love this song ... Beautifully written, passionately recorded/performed...It give me chills everytime...

[@inuyashalovergyal]

I've been angry all day because of the protesting situation in Toronto and it was affecting my place of work but I still had to go and do my job but it was all worth it to just come home and relax with you. All my worries and anger just disappears and I'm just vibing with you as you get blown away by the rapline ^^

[@katja805]

This song and their speech at the MAMA Awards 2018 is so heartbreaking 💔 when you know the background.

[@tuppe99]

Despite the heartbreaking reason that led to writing this song I will never get tired to admire their intelligence, the consideration they put in every word. T = To accept the reality of loss E = Experience the pain of the loss A = Adjust to the new environment without the lost person R = Reinvest in the new reality I mean how do you even come up with that? I will never get over it.

[@jazmin72009]

Excelente reacción! Ah La condición Humana tan maravillosa como aterradora!. A estos chicos les tocó crecer juntos en todo aspecto y además con ventana al mundo! Qué maravillosa experiencia y la comparten con el mundo, nos regalan su arte y nos juntan en torno a nuestras propias vivencias! Junto a ti acá también. Gracias por el espacio. (Quise hablar en mi lengua el español, porque siento que me expreso mejor)

[@ThisRoscoe]

¡Gracias por tus pensamientos! ¡SÍ! Siéntase libre de escribir en su idioma nativo, yo (y cualquier otra persona) podemos usar la magia de la tecnología para traducir en cualquier momento. Borahae!

[@jazmin72009]

@@ThisRoscoe Muchas gracias!!! Estoy muy agradecida de verdad por este espacio que has creado.

[@tammarabg8174]

What I love about BTS is all the layers. The outer layer is just feeling the vibe of the song. Next we start the looking at the visuals. Then we move on to the lyrics, the details, the story. With some of the songs/albums, I am reading books that are referenced in the lyrics (Kafka on the Shore in the song Butterfly, Omelas for Spring Day, Damien for the whole Wings album and related MVs and short films...) SUGA shared, “The lyrics for Tear were written for the members. When I was writing the melody, at the time, we were deeply contemplating whether we should quit or not. When I played the song for the members, we all cried together.” Two letters are 이별, meaning parting Yes, the members write their own parts after given the melody/beat and concept, and then collaborate and refine.

[@lyndaal5792]

The emotions on Hobi's face always gets me 😭 and once you learn about the background of the song (which am sure you know by now with the hundreds of comments) you'll see the song in another light 😌 I don't listen to this song breaking down, I use it to remember the importance of people around me. I try to cherish everyone who cherishes me, so that I won't regret if one day something happens, cause I was honest with them and gave it all. Lol Roscoe I'll answer your question that you don't want us to answer, "it didn't happen to me yet". Even if a song is not my style, once I learn about the message they try to portray through it, the song has a place in my playlist already 😅. Namjoon is obsessed with Converse btw, so much that he wrote a song about it lol. Being "forced" to be part of the song along with the other members, Suga wrote his part "beautifully" . You may want to check it out 😉☺️ My comment is getting long and I don't know how many mistakes I made while writing 😅💜💜💜🇩🇿

[@ashleyder9164]

Suga *is* the most raw of the three ... your perception is correct, heh. I think it is one of the things that makes us really cherish him.

[@sarahmilesgaerlan31]

Woooow... I really love this song so emotional.. there are only few rap that can make my heart ache.. specially Suga's rap

[@armystacinator6732]

This is how it is to love BTS and ARMY. We love each other so much and love our boys. And we love taking in new fans and guiding them through the BTS journey and turning them into ARMY with us 💜💜💜

[@jenniferjohnson5064]

They did all write their own verses for this song. Beautiful performance

[@asianiewie9142]

I love this reaction! I'm glad you watched this wonderful live show right away and said your own interpretation! #protectthecouch

[@7toheavan4ever54]

I was so blessed to witness this epic legendary performance of "outro: tear" live in wembley!! My heart almost exploded! It gave me goosebumps....It was like in a dream.......it was absolutely breaking! Legendary BTS RAPLINE performed with so much heart, soul and emotions !! Hobis ending made Mr cry like a baby ! I have no words to describe it.....

[@suzannahmontreal1051]

You were very lucky to be there 🌟💜🌟

[@MariaChavez-ey5sr]

Just gotta shout out Suga’s genius in writing/composing the initial melody as his feelings about breaking up the group and making everyone cry and being a big part of keeping them together. Then Namjoon and Hobi writing/performing such amazing parts with so much raw passion. Nothing like the sheer passion of the rapline. And they just had to add custom Dior outfits to really put a nail in Army nailing us down.

[@erume5776]

​i love seeing how joy that comes with music overflows in you roscoe, same

[@taezmanian3020]

This is my top 5 from the rapline..it so much emotional and powerful rap.can't wait to see this.

[@oli_5243]

After discovering BTS and learning about their creativity and effort to send a message through their music, I became more interested in finding the meaning of their lyrics. This eventually transferred into making connections with my personal experiences and now it has become part of my life. Totally change my perspective on how I respond to certain situations. In the process having the opportunity to meet so many ARMY with similar struggles that offer emotional support to each other has been life changing. So when people ask me why do you like BTS...because they taught me to Love myself...it is a work in progress, but definitely helped me become a better version of me. This song will always have a special place in ARMY's heart.

[@marinal.]

"These guys belong on stage!"-Roscoe 2022 ...Yeah 🥰

[@jean3A]

They do really belong on stage. And so many layers to their music and performance.

[@auragriman132]

Hey Roscoe, fist of all I have to say that I loveeeeee hanging out with you and ARMY, I'm in the point where I wait for my daily video of BTS & Roscoe lol Well, I have to say one thing, as an artist myself I know that we are overwhelming by emotions most of the time and the only way we have to let them go is through our art (music, painting, writing, etc.) and those emotions never are the same, what I mean is that one minute you can be full of happiness and everything you do is bright and colorful but at the next moment you can feel all in darkness and everything you do is depressing or fill of anger. I know that every human being in general is capable to feel so many emotions through their life but I think artist can feel them like 1000% more intense and it's hard to deal with them. And I think what difference BTS from other musicians is that their music and their lyrics feel authentic, feel honest, you can feel the emotions they had in the moment their created those songs, it's like if you can see through their hearts and souls and for me, that what makes them real artists. P.S.: I hope that when you do the vocal line week, you can heard epiphany by Jin (that song always makes me feel better, It has an amazing message) and Lie by Jimin (I know that everybody loves 'serendipity' and I do too but 'Lie' for me is something unique, not only was writing by Jimin himself but he talks about their depression and it's a very intense song).

[@tatyanach5983]

Thank you so much for fixing the sound on your videos, Roscoe!💜 especially for Outro: Tear🙏💜

[@timothywest1183]

Sounded great, didn’t it?

[@ZariDV]

The power this live holds. They really had their feet on our necks the whole time.

[@ThisRoscoe]

100%

[@user-iq6mi5ti5d]

The lyricism here blows my mind !! ✨✨💜