Disturbed "Sound of Silence" // Pastors React and Discuss // Lyrical Analysis and Reaction Video

[@roberthoughton7127]

This was a bonus for you guys. It wasn’t supposed to drop till later this week. Hope you enjoy.

[@jomaty76]

Do a review on Worm's Wood by Our Hollow, Our Home

[@tobyappel8966]

This song was nominated for a Grammy when disturbed put it out and I saw them do this live I can't express how powerful it was

[@zacswinney9643]

This is actually my favorite reaction channel, I like watching someone with such a religious view react to dark music and non religious music and connecting the dots. I am not extremely religious but this channel actually have passion behind what he is doing and makes me see more in religion.

[@pigebear]

Only 1 " wow" and " goosebumps" just bustin. Love your channel

[@jitos82]

If you haven't heard it already. You should hear blackbird by alter bridge. Id really enjoy your opinion on this seeing that it's about loosing a loved one.

[@kremlinkoa]

One thing I noticed. Simon and Garfunkle version feels like a surrender to the darkness is speaks of. Disturbed version feels like a call to arms to fight the darkness.

[@Gsolaris]

On point.

[@danaleslie3110]

Perfect description

[@Earnestlie]

Bravo! VERY well said!

[@duanebower3925]

You know these guys are a fake right..??

[@brianmichaelbenjamin7318]

All of their songs is a call to arms 🤣🤣🤣

[@Mechanic.Pete41]

Paul Simin said in an interview "this is disturbed's song now" probably the best praise any singer could receive or give

[@big_sexy123]

Nine inch nails did the same thing to johnny cash

[@jackknight8878]

Is it possible to put the article or source of where you saw that?

[@Mechanic.Pete41]

@@jackknight8878 rolling stone magazine did the interview, also check out the video interview with disturbed as he mentioned it to

[@TheSergio1021]

@@big_sexy123almost exactly. One quote from Trent Reznor about Hurt was "I just lost my girlfriend, because that song isn't mine anymore"

[@louisegraham3204]

In Paul Simon saying that, he conveys how truly profound and humbling I’ve always thought him to be. That comment just proved it.

[@rynkydynk7362]

Honestly, it brings me to tears every single time I hear it. David Draiman (Disturbed lead singer) sent it to Paul Simon for his review prior to release. "When David sent it to Paul, he was very nervous. Paul said 'My version was a warning, your version is the rage because the warning was ignored. It's your song now.' Now that's the highest of compliments."

[@tbusch63]

What an ABSOLUTE Tribute to Disturbed. I saw them in concert about 3 weeks ago for the first time! OMG, What a FANTASTIC show they put on!!!

[@PamelaKilburn-c3w]

Definitely a message....

[@bencollins8054]

If this song doesn’t hit you, if you can’t feel this song in your bones, you’re not human.

[@shandajames5444]

It gives me chills down my body listening to David singing this so I totally agree you!!!

[@carbide1968]

I don't even want people around me if it doesn't hit your soul. those are not people.

[@booklassygarrahan3929]

I have listened to this on a loop, repeatedly, and I also get hit in the emotions.

[@vc6094]

Don't hate the deaf people

[@WitchelliB]

Absolutely

[@charlieparra3103]

Last year, I had the opportunity of seeing Disturbed live in Hershey, PA. At some point they make a stop and David starts talking about depression. The whole venue went silent, just listening. Seeing so many hands raised when asked "do you suffer/have you suffered from depression?" made me feel like I'm not alone. They made a setlist of songs like A reason to fight and of course The Sound of Silence. Picture a bunch of metalheads crying, literally. People that met for the first time hugging each other, enjoying the music, David's amazing voice. Pure respect. That's something I will never forget as long as I live. This song is by far my favorite cover of a classic song.

[@mariusmiller5702]

Had the same experience down here in San Antonio, TX. A solemn crowd of people from all walks and mentalities rasing their hands. I'll remember that concert forever😭🤘🏼

[@osutuba]

I would have loved to seen a concert like that!

[@Yaboi-if8bw]

The original has birthed meme, the remake birthed tears

[@cecile436]

I'm actually not a metal fan, but 'A reason to fight' is the reason why I bought a Disturbed CD. I found the official live video clip here on youtube and I cried in front of my laptop. It was so powerful, exactly the moment you describe, when he asks who suffers or knows someone who suffers from depression or addiction, and like all hands are rising... That message is so important for me that I had to support it somehow, so I bought the CD. As someone dealing with social anxiety, I don't think I'll ever try to go to any of their concerts as it seems to be always so crowded, but I bet it must be a strong experiencee.

[@EdwardsNH]

Thanks for posting this. I'm a long time fan, and that story just made me a bigger fan. Definitely one of the best covers, but I have to add Johnny Cash's cover of Hurt to the candidates

[@VadulTharys]

David Draiman was trained as a Cantor, his education including the years he spent in Israel were all focused on singing the Torah. He said for a long time after his girlfriend killed herself he turned from God, raged against God, and he says it shows in his songs. Today when asked he says "I am a Jew", 10 years ago he stated he had no faith. The messages in his music have changed as well, you can see hope, where before there was rage, anger, and hopelessness. The rage and anger are still there, but directed towards selfishness, greed, and the vices of the world. Their music now is more focused on government corruption, celebrity worship, and other things they see as destroying the beauty in the world.

[@harrynutsackk]

Openly Satanic and yet the lost Sheep can still not see it.

[@jamstheshapeshifter]

@@harrynutsackk Get goin' twat waffle

[@MsCathy42]

@@jamstheshapeshifter David is a practicing Jew and Cantor.

[@moniquefleming3391]

As a messianic jew, I recognize David's message on a huge scale. His voice is God driven... ..

[@WanderingWriter]

Don't forget he also has 3 degrees in political science, philosophy, and business admin as well as being pre-law

[@tempusfugit7127]

As a seventy old grandma I don't understand how l missed "Disturbed " ...it actually made me cry . Words are SO important to me but Classical /Rock / Ballad / Pop ...also moves my Soul , it's too late tonight but tomorrow l shall call my grown up children and ask if they are aware of this incredible man with his amazing range and talent .

[@paranoidrodent]

I'm 47 and I can safely say that most fans of metal or hard rock in the 35-50 year old range will tend to be familiar with Disturbed. They're a pretty major band in the genre. I grew up listening to bands like this along with other genres. I've seen them twice in concert over the years and they put on a heck of a show. In concert, the singer tends to let his more melodious singing style through more while their studio recordings have more staccato vocalizations. His range and power are quite impressive (not Mike Patton or Freddie Mercury levels of insane vocal range but still top notch). As a band, Disturbed have quite a bit of talent and range (most good metal bands do - metal originated as a dark moody sub-genre of the blues and it's a very technical genre, unlike say punk rock) but do keep in mind that they are unapologetically a heavy metal band. This cover is not typical of their songs, leaning far more towards melancholy than their usual menu of rage and defiance. Their usual songs have plenty of heavy guitar, bass and drum accompanied by occasionally growled vocals (although Disturbed is known more for singing that transitions into animalistic growls for effect). Like many of the heavy metal bands that gained popularity during the late 1990s and early 2000s, their music addresses a mix of personal trauma and societal ills (actually, these have always been common themes in metal but that era is littered with songs in that vein). Their lyrics can be quite powerful but they often lay bare pain and sorrow. If you do look up their other videos, please be aware that they often use disturbing imagery when it suits the song. For example, "Inside the Fire" and "Asylum" are both excellent but they are about how suicide impacted the singer's life, including years of nightmares and inner torment (and the videos bring those nightmares to life). It's heavy stuff and he taps some deep pain with that same powerful voice. Disturbed do also tend to include one cover song on each album, often being songs that influenced them and/or that they can reinterpret to suit their style. "The Sound of Silence" is arguably their best cover although their cover of Genesis' 1980s classic "Land of Confusion" gives it very strong competition, really exploring the dystopian lyrics of the song of Phil Collins and friends wrote while changing the arrangement of the cheerful tune (needed to make the song palatable during the tail end of the Cold War) to suit the frustration, anger and hope in the lyrics better. The contrast between the videos of each version is extremely dramatic, with the Genesis video being goofball and satirical while the Disturbed video is grim animation that amplifies the song's message about how screwed up and corrupt the world is. Ironically, the Disturbed video has a more hopeful ending (the people rising up against war, oppression and greed) than the original goofball Genesis video (a senile Ronald Reagan accidentally starts a nuclear war - a touch uncanny since it wasn't public knowledge that Reagan had Alzheimer's at the time).

[@rk41gator]

@@paranoidrodent As a 70 year old who loves music (more jazz and Progressive Rock) I stayed away from Heavy Metal. I like their edginess but the music seemed so 'one note' and relentless (yes, that is the point). Since is love, love, love Genesis and their songs/lyrics I was drawn to 'Land of Confusion' and then stumbled upon 'Sound of Silence'. Blown away. Hearing Paul Simon's praise of it only adds a cherry to the sundae. 'Sickness' is way HEAVY. But I like your review and also sense the hope Disturbed conveys in this video. The ark as a Biblical reference for hope is wonderful and appropriate. What a strong, emotion filled rendition of a classic. Kudos to David Draiman's charismatic voice and style. BRAVO.

[@asmrhawaii]

Beware...many of his songs are dark.

[@AceBobcat]

As a 30 year old guy who grew up with Disturbed, I can tell you most of their music isn't as traditionally "beautiful" is this. David Draimer, the lead singer, is trained ans well-versed in the classic vocal techniques, which is how he has such range. Much of which he implicates more subtlety into his music, which is primarily very loud and aggressive. On a surface level, it's not for most people. Much of Disturbed's music is expressive of unbridled rage, and is not very "pleasant" sounding in the traditional sense.

[@kellygustin3392]

I'm 58 and listen to Disturbed

[@evilcowboy]

Simon and Garfunkel vocals were angelic. These vocals are like if God sang the song.

[@shandajames5444]

I love both!!!

[@hickchick112]

Simon and Garfunkel’s version is a quiet warning. Disturbed’s version is an angry outcry that the warning wasn’t heeded.

[@Markeeta_Roberts]

I love both versions.

[@WFly101]

@@hickchick112 yes lol

[@molly1949]

YES!! I thought the same. an angry God

[@jakejager]

Paul Simon said he liked this version better than his original... I agree.

[@mariaeddycesario3067]

Once I read a Simon interview and he said Bridge over troubled water by Elvis was better than his ... I'm a great Simon fan, but ... I AGREE!!

[@caseythompson474]

You know that’s huge when you get a compliment like that! Same thing happened with NIN when Johnny cash did a cover of hurt.

[@wildfire160]

I have always loved the Simon&Garfunkel version ...but imo this is a long way better..

[@RamsFan93]

wait, is this true?

[@dark_faerie]

@Dumb Stupid @Dumb Stupid yes, I cry every time I listen to this song, I cannot stop the tears from coming. Specifically Disturb's version though.

[@briancox5530]

Paul Simon said Disturbed finished the message they were trying to convey.

[@HoopyFroodood]

Really?? I want this to be true, please don't tell me you made this up. Do you have a source?

[@AppleSmasher12]

Hoopy Frood don’t know if it’s completely true, but he has spoken to the singer of disturbed several times and has praised their song. Lots of covers have been made, and Disturbed’s version was the only one that he personally forwarded over his social media

[@dianekinnicutt784]

@@HoopyFroodood There is an interview with David where he describes his conversation with Paul Simon at a party in Hawaii. This is true.

[@bbypookins]

That brings me peace.

[@the_marlin3781]

As is sometimes the case, the writers can almost get there, but then their message grows in the heart of someone else who brings it to full flower.

[@WW-du3kx]

I am pretty sure that he is what angels sound like... the way his voice vibrates through your body. The power. The emotion. I actually played this for a patient to bring her blood pressure down. "How is a band named Disturbed supposed to help my blood pressure down?" "Can you put this on repeat?"

[@tvbnine793]

You deserve a raise.

[@ericarmstrong3435]

When the singer David was asked “do you want the voice of an angel or demon?” His response, “Yes.”

[@dash-x]

David is fantastic. He actually trained for years to be a cantor just as his father and grandfather before him. However he said it still took him nearly 20 years to be able to do the Conan performance. Paul Simon wrote to him after that performance and told him the song is his now. What a compliment!

[@dontsurroundurselfwithurself]

Pastors: There's no hope in the song. Disturbed: The video concludes by literally showing a ship sailing across a chasm to deliver music to the 10,000 people who need it.

[@elizabethposivio8256]

Yes that’s what I was thinking watch the music video while you listen it ends with Hope!

[@joanmaciel416]

I thought it was Noah's ark..

[@obsoleteMAC]

I believe they were focusing on the lyrics and the origin

[@ryandrummond3794]

10 thousand fists in the air ✊

[@pacldawson]

I made this point in my comments... then saw you had made it months before me. :)

[@ryosat]

when asked about disturbed covering this song paul simon said it's not my song anymore. now that is a compliment!

[@dheurung]

It certainly would be a compliment, but he didn't actually say that. He did say he liked this version, though.

[@davidvasquez115]

You’re thinking about Hurt by Cash and Nine Inch Nails

[@702Beck]

That is the ultimate compliment!

[@sarakelly3214]

This is the only song/version that has ever made me cry just because of the beauty and voice.

[@nothing2see315]

@@davidvasquez115 I'm a way bigger NIN fan than a cash fan and I'd rather listen to cash's version

[@TheNeonParadox]

"Guy's got a lot of range." Me: Give it a minute.

[@evenamber]

Same

[@billylaboss5197]

Pretty much lol

[@kellyr7589]

My exact thought too!!

[@thelokiway4478]

Yeah I said that out loud with a chuckle too!

[@freednighthawk]

Soooooo, which multinationally recognized, multi platinum band do you sing for?

[@GryphonArmorer]

I like the original, but I love this version. The best cover of the song, if not the best version ever.

[@vegasrenie]

Gryphon Arms USA - Agreed.

[@toscabella18]

I couldnt agree more!!! 1st time I heard this it made me cry!!

[@sallyewing3185]

Just how I feel ..

[@LassieGal]

I absolutely agree with you. It's perfect.

[@chriswalters4976]

I agree. I cry no matter when I hear this.

[@spunkygmahappy4778]

I am a 70 year old Great Grandmother, I have never been a head banger, hard rocker fan. This band, Disturbed are not of that same group that I am use to. Each and every time I have heard it, and I have heard it a lot, I get the goose bumpe. Just today alone I have listened to it at least 12 times and every time I have goose bumps. I appreciate you taking the time to listen, judgement free, to this amazing rendition.

[@reggiefokes6677]

I'm almost 76, an old hippie chick die-hard rock and roller. This cover is the absolute best cover that's ever been recorded.

[@sandyaw3057]

@spunkygmahappy4778 I’m a 66 year old great grandma and a hippie chick head banger and this man has the best voice I ever heard. I cry every time I listen to it.

[@spunkygmahappy4778]

I have listened to a lot of their work, while some is not for me songs like this on is. I do hear some great lyrics in their music .

[@WitchelliB]

Another grandma here and ditto 😊

[@kympridham8267]

Simon and garfunkel was a warning disturbed was the anger the warning was ignored

[@katiescarlett2539]

Zathrus Pridham Nailed it!

[@CynDuby]

Perfectly stated!

[@Deeyenen]

YES🙌

[@wolfhawk1999]

I've seen this comment before. It's true though

[@jamierogers5016]

Amen!

[@katyc.1969]

a comment on another reaction was: "the original was a warning. This one is a rage because the warning was not heeded". very apt. thanks guys!

[@paulashay4179]

I saw that reaction and totally agree!

[@nessienessie8798]

I read that. Very apt.

[@chillsoul2613]

And each generation gets warned of new dangers & each generation does not heed. We are hopeless

[@nelmagene2010]

I don't think the song is hopeless, I believe it is song about breaking out of the hopelessness. "Silence like a cancer grows, Hear my words that I might teach you Take my arms that I might reach you".

[@elizabethposivio8256]

Beautiful

[@tammywomack8070]

evidently they don't get the meaning of the song!!! and yes i am a christian!!

[@markponn9622]

Right on! 😘

[@kurtsibrava1684]

There a shining beacon of hope at the very end with the boat sailing across the divide.

[@gabrielefried3853]

100%, look at the end of the video where the boat crosses the separation with water and the shining light appears - if that not symbolize hope I don't know what.

[@ceciliakilgour5744]

If you watch the video closely, you will notice how the musicians are on one side of the water and the people with the music sheets are on the other side. The boat carries the musicians to the people. Bringing them together. The black and white video with all the fog is very post apocalyptic. Deep stuff.

[@BabsisHere]

Nice catch!

[@brittvdr806]

@@BabsisHere You didn't see that?

[@darthvader3550]

It implies that the instruments had to travel to the written music, because the writers were too afraid to break the silence, so the musicians made the first move, so the writers of the songs could finally be shared.

[@paulukjames7799]

@@darthvader3550 I can run with that kind of squares it up of loose ends thanks

[@lirmediatv753]

David Drayman has a degree also in Philosophy hence the depth of both the song and video

[@kimberlystark3944]

Get ready for a religious experience.... Moves me to my very soul! It's a thing of beauty!

[@chaoticoldbore]

Best description of the two versions is that the original was a soft spoken warning whereas the cover is an angry "you didn't listen to the first warning"

[@24elijahR]

Perfect description.

[@MrConstant23.]

That's a great take.

[@deminybs]

I don't get how this version is "angry" the sickness was angry lol

[@johan.ohgren]

@@deminybs compared to the original it is. But it's definately more angry Disturbed songs.

[@Bassist4AW]

Couldn't possibly agree with you more Chaotic. #Truth #Fact #Undeniable #HeedTheWords

[@sarahughes6452]

There is hope in the song. They rescued the instruments, saw the people across the cavern, put the instruments on the boat to the people living in silence. It’s a raw, emotional version that you don’t just listen to, you feel it.

[@thulehuff6402]

Eloquent interpretation!

[@tinydancer36]

It's a message of unity to me. We need to work together, like people and instruments...without each other both are useless. Together, the possibilities are endless. United we stand, divided we fall. Americans need this message more now than ever.

[@murph1822]

Couldn't help but notice they crossed the water in an Ark-looking boat!

[@judyovington7469]

Thank you

[@tamiguion7175]

I couldn't have said it better!!!

[@larrywelchko6136]

It doesn’t matter how many times I hear this version, it brings tears to my eyes, every time

[@rebelnoxford1985]

Every time I hear it, I'm not only left with tears in my eyes, but goosebumps on the back of my neck down to my arms.

[@michaeljacobs8755]

Even Simon an Garfunkel were impressed with this cover

[@RivkahSong]

I've heard it actually brought Simon to tears. :)

[@JacobP81]

@@RivkahSong Wow!

[@saky29]

@The Memo Wow! Imagine your life as a musician being complete like this, making a cover over a Legendary duo's song and getting such compliment. What a wholesome thing!

[@rudycarlson8245]

@@RivkahSong it did?

[@LoubyLou21]

His voice makes my whole body get the shivers. This cover is beautiful. Love Disturbed.

[@Rebel37th]

HEIDI .B. I agree. First time I heard it, I said his voice fit so perfectly with this song.

[@MYxYOUxTUBExUSERNAME]

Honestly

[@debbowen2011]

His voice...those eyes...David Draiman is the complete package!! 😍😍😍

[@LgSutterby]

I agree. I can’t hear the last two verses without getting continuous goosebumps up and down my arms.

[@LgSutterby]

And good music is the only thing that can do that to me

[@sophieleanna9391]

This version is powerful. Maybe the most powerful songs I’ve ever heard.

[@funeralgrey]

Try listening to their new album. It's called Evolution. It's about how people are being brainwashed into the lies that our world has convinced us are true and how he sold his soul and the regret that he gets out of it.

[@heatherr3455]

Sophie yes I agree!

[@coralraeartandthings]

Sophie Leanna listen to yesterday by Roy Clark. Amazing lyrics.

[@gamingwithbrandon6617]

I had my 5 year old daughter listen and she started crying. I said baby whats wrong. She said "hes just so powerful!"

[@Jeff-zs5hd]

I will not die until this song is played at my funeral. This song brings tears for me as I interepate as us folks who deal with depression or PTSD. So moving when you look at this song this way. The darkness and silence being depression and PTSD and how many people die or suffer in silence. Often choosing to end their own misery. It's no joke folks...reach out to someone who may be suffering

[@1492dac]

To me, this song makes me believe we can change our direction. It is not hopeless, we have a choice to make

[@giacomanrocker]

i like it how this guys are the example of what a good christian should be open-minded and not eager to attack non christian things

[@videohound2005]

I totally agree with you, I've run into to many people who claim to follow God, yet judge others, Judgement is reserved for God, not humans

[@videohound2005]

@@chelimix4580 I do agree, however I've run into fellow Christians who when they attack sin, they do so in a way that is wrong. What I mean is, I knew someone who would immediately attack the person, calling them this and that, saying your going to hell and so on. Theres far better ways to help bring people to Christ. But yes attacking sin is something that should be done, not attacking the sinner.

[@midnightmoon8237]

Agreed

[@Loregamorl]

I agree I don’t like people in general that attack me or others in general out of the blue or for very small reasons But I see where some of them come from though

[@cinderellsworth]

@@videohound2005 If a Christian is going to bring up somebody else's sin, they CANNOT "attack" the sinner. The sinner is just being who he NATURALLY is. You really cannot blame the sinner for doing what people who don't have the Holy Spirit to guide them do -- being human.

[@barbaraeborgconyers7866]

a heavy metal band the lead singer is a classically trained opera singer

[@geoffgaebe8354]

That's a common misconception, but he was trained as a Cantor... not an opera singer.

[@troyjohns5645]

Killswitch engage minus the singer are all trained musicians with explains how every single song has seamless transitions even during live shows

[@45vixxen]

He made it very emotional!

[@jasondutton2531]

There is a band like that, Nightwish.

[@twhitten828]

...and many metal bsnds learned how to plsy classical INSTRUMENTS 😳!!

[@b1blancer1]

AS I've seen posted elsewhere, Simon and Garfunkel: A warning. Disturbed: Rage because the warning was ignored.

[@Hurricaneintheroom]

Good thinking. Probably true. Simon & Garfunkel tried to tell.

[@cogit8able]

David Tilley certainly the message is more urgent.

[@Blackheartrises]

I love that. You were warned. Now we have to do it , the bad way

[@coraleeowensmiller7288]

We can gleen from anything. To me, God is saying wake up before its to late. Without God there is silence, the absence of God is hell.

[@lilyprice1516]

I disagree with the pastors, this song gives me hope, strength, determination,,,to get through each day!!!

[@alexdavis-mann8513]

yes, it feels like its time to stand up and fight, like a call to arms

[@jessicas6586]

I have seen this so many times, EVERY TIME. CHILLS.

[@highlander200107]

And years later, still gives me the chills, and sometimes to tears!

[@BruceLee-xn3nn]

It brings tears

[@kaitlynraw4899]

Me too 😭

[@cherbrowne1637]

Hi Jessica.. Every time I listen to this song I cry..same place,.sets me off. Just love it.

[@dancinmike2001]

Totally agree. If you are not moved or get chills, your heart is all ready dead.

[@metallicamadmen172]

Paul Simon said this is his favorite cover of the song.

[@godfather7174]

not only that the cover was the bet but in whole he made the song much better gotta take a lot from an artist to say you just took my stuff to a whole new lvl ;) and he sure did his voice is so powerful seen them 2 time live ;O)

[@JPVNG67]

u have a link to that? i only found this : "In case you missed it, Disturbed did a wonderful rendition of "The Sound of Silence" on Conan this week. The S&G cover also appears on Disturbed's latest album, Immortalized."... taken from Paul Simon facebook @@godfather7174

[@allmeatchame6244]

@@godfather7174 Totally agree!

[@blindbrad4719]

Metallica Madmen so did Chuck Norris…

[@SparksDrinker]

Ummmmm, duh.

[@jeremesmith9266]

The man sings like an axe wielding Warrior King after winning a glorious battle

[@rosiebutler2376]

You are a poet ..........🖖🏻♥️

[@boondocks8002]

Perfect

[@kimberly9876]

❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@persadies]

I find hope in this version. They could not change the lyrics so he presented them with anger not hopelessness as the video showed us hope. A call to arms. Picking up the instruments and writing songs. In the end bringing hope to the lost masses. That is how I saw it.

[@sabinesteil4690]

Not just writing songs but actually sing them. Out loud.

[@paranoidrodent]

Their cover of Genesis' Land of Confusion does something similar. It is sung with anger and as a call to arms. Their video is far darker overall too yet it ends with hope for the people fighting back and bringing about change (while the original satirical goofball video ended with a senile Reagan starting a nuclear war).

[@Chief2Moon]

This version is untouchable, period.

[@sirfirfry6761]

Paul Simon doing this at ground zero is pretty powerful also

[@slightlyalteredconcepts5561]

Agreed

[@Snakeyes11123]

Dallas DautermanDallas Bobaflex does a cover of this. It’s decent, think this untouchable

[@attackhelicopter7403]

Hold on, Henk Porth gave one at Beste Zangers, and i might say, it was quiet powerful....

[@MickeyKraut419]

Johnny Cash's cover of Nine Inch Nails - Hurt.... one of the most moving covers I've ever heard.

[@kevintunaley5079]

I still prefer nine inch Nails version but Cash knew his life was ending so he timed it perfectly

[@robertshadbolt3056]

Hits me emotionally like this cover every time. Hurt makes you think back to friends and loved ones that have gone.

[@MoA-Reload...]

Another version you guys might want to check out is 2wei - sequels - hurt right here on YT. Another amazing cover of that song

[@robertsmith3276]

Awesome cover. So much emotion in it

[@buckeyesfan4700]

@Engineer Eagan that comes down to personal choice....... So it's way better...... For you

[@juliannewelch5854]

The power behind this version blows you away. I always get chills.

[@alexiskiri9693]

You, as pastors, might appreciate the lines; "Hear my words that I might teach you Take my arms that I might reach you" How often does the silence win?

[@alexiskiri9693]

@@MySlash2006 ❤👍

[@rogerdavis9607]

Paul simon wrote the song originally, because of a friend of his going bling it has absolutely nothing g to do with religion. And the album did not even do good at first and simon and Garfunkel broke up after the album was released.

[@alexiskiri9693]

@@rogerdavis9607 you are being didactic here. The song is the issue. Sometimes a song writer will write a little ditty, nothing important and the next thing you know it's a number one hit world wide and the writer is going "what the hell just happened?" It is the people who decide what the song means, how the song speaks to them. The people who give life to the song.🎶🎶🎶🎵🎼

[@tomsautocadstudio6446]

it's winning now everyone's afraid of the far left KZbinrs saying sorry for jokes they made and stuff.

[@putgordon]

It is a very moving song. And the words can mean differently to everyone. But now in Sept 2020 ,it seam to really go with what is happening now in America. This country is not the same since TRUMP took office. America will NEVER BE THE SAME.

[@mariacusimano-byram2259]

My mom 80 yrs old believe it or not is crazy about this version also! My husband loves Disturbed but this is done so beautiful it just brings tears to our eyes! Awesome job

[@nancymcnulty4740]

I have watched disturbed do this song a least 100 times. I never get sick of them. I get emotional every time I hear it.

[@michaelcrane4135]

This song and it's presentation by Disturbed is extremely powerful and moving. I too get emotional every time I hear this. I feel that if one is not moved emotionally when listening to this version, one is dead inside.

[@nancymcnulty4740]

Michael Crane for sure Mike!!

[@katerussell6139]

David Draiman’s voice is absolutely incredible! The man can sing anything and make it new and powerful! Thank you for your reaction! I enjoyed your lovely dynamic together! You can tell what kind men you both are, the ministry is lucky to have you both! Have a blessed day ❤️!

[@alethiastafford6061]

I think metal is the most empowering genre out there.

[@1314CK1]

Agreed

[@brianmichaelbenjamin7318]

Be careful with what you put in your head, from an old rocker guy from the 80s. Lots of it was great, lots evil. Read lyrics first and stay away from demonic music, please.

[@celestialcolosseum]

@@brianmichaelbenjamin7318 Listen to some Behemoth my friend

[@Dan-qx5mi]

I'd say rap and metal have that in common. Most other music is meant to appease instead of inspire thought.

[@Edd25164605]

There is a place where race,religion, sex or political bias mean nothing........in the Mosh Pit we are one !

[@lesleakeurvorst3148]

Yes, the lyrics are hopeless, but I think David's genius as a singer comes from that "growl" you speak of. It's anger, and anger is proactive. The anger in his voice becomes a rallying cry. We must join forces and 'rage against the dying of the light', or in this case, the sound. The growl itself, is hope.

[@JohnnyCoolBreeze]

Absolutely. This song, to me, is a 'trumpet' from heaven call to overcome the 'silence' and take authority over the passivity and the 'falling away' which Christianity of this nation has partaken of. :)

[@politereminder6284]

Yes

[@paquefeal2385]

Lesley, well said. I would have made the same comment, but you already did. 👍🏽🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@tomasg920]

@@JohnnyCoolBreeze good! Seperation of church and state is in the constitution

[@wafflehousewitch]

Anger is an energy-John Lydon

[@colesimoneaux2375]

This is what people should do when they cover songs! Instead of copying it completely they should put their own spin on it to emphasize a meaning or an ideal.

[@nicholascarroll1225]

I agree. Gary Jules' remake of Tears For Fears' "Mad World" was similar: an improvement upon the original. Unique and different sound.

[@JacobP81]

Absolutely! Great comment.

[@LJ-ne1bd]

I agree, I also think the Jonny Cash version of 'Hurt' is brilliant. Even Trent Reznor himself said it was Jonny's now.

[@UncomfortableShoes]

Agreed. Probably one of the best examples is “All along the watchtower” by Hendrix. Made it his own.

[@eyesonheaven4765]

The Conan version shows the orchestra and shows how important they are to the song too. Outstanding cannot get enough!

[@scottmcelhiney323]

Unfortunately David was sick with the flu when they did Conan... and some idiot at the show decided to autotune his live performance. When he found out, he declared he'll never do that show again.

[@digitaIgorilla]

I honestly feel this is the best cover of any song I've ever heard.

[@movietimeateds69]

I think Whitney's cover of "i will always love you" is better.

[@daviddow8150]

Bad Wolves cover of Zombie is good too

[@molealto]

It's great, but I'd put Johnny Cash's cover of Hurt up there too.

[@tehnemox]

This and Johnny Cash's "Hurt" are tied as my two favorite covers of all time.

[@robertmills2900]

The Disturbed "growling" song that was first referred to is called Down with the Sickness. It's about the cycle of child abuse passed from one generation to the next. Awesome song!

[@numberletter1312]

oh ah ah ah ah lololol

[@Jim87_36]

Tis "the Sickness" after all.

[@solosam9]

@@numberletter1312 I don't get the joke? Maybe child abuse is funny?

[@deonnahepler5152]

And the iconic scream was a primal reaction to the music that stuck and got the band stuck in your head and soul. Success. Mic drop.rock on

[@debbowen2011]

Yes!! Disturbed does not get enough credit for the value of their lyrics & music!! They have messages that are powerful & meaningful. Their newest album is so important to what we are seeing & living daily.

[@terristevens1778]

Someone mentioned that he was accepted into quite a few Ivy League law schools which is true but the reason he did not go into it was because he said he could not live with himself if he had to defend someone he knew to be guilty. He said his morals just wouldn't allow it. First rate guy

[@wearelegion1163]

Same reason I decided against law school. I wanted to be an attorney for years, until I worked for several of them.

[@ThekiBoran]

@@wearelegion1163 If a lawyer, an IRS agent and a politician were all drowning and you could only save one, would you go to lunch or read the paper?

[@yournumberonepal]

@@ThekiBoran Record it with my phone?

[@boondocks8002]

Wow. My son wouldn't complete law school after saying the same thing. And he likes this band. I will have to tell him that. Blessings

[@indeed2207]

Same here, one of my dream job until a grew up, started studying, and discovered the terrible truth, I have standards, and I wouldn't be able to do this job. I would never be able to look at myself in the mirror or even stay calm and not burst in rage when I protect someone who's clearly isn't innocent, he don't deserve it.

[@pamlong2409]

I was born in 1962, known this song my whole life, felt years ago it was prophetic, I believe it shows as believers we want to reach people, the words " hear my words that I might teach you, take my hand that I might reach you "

[@drummingninja1065]

David kills the song. I've been a fan of Disturbed for years. And when this song came out, it was such a difference from their norm. It almost gives me the chills as he delivers his vocals throughout.

[@gunthersquirrel5685]

I remember when he almost killed his voice. The scream was wrong and too much. He took time off, and came back better than he ever was before!

[@kayarnold3151]

This song live was one of the most beautiful experiences I have had. He nailed it and the energy through that venue was incredible.

[@rachaeld111]

@@gunthersquirrel5685 he also had surgery on his throat. Unfortunately the thing they repaired is shot again. But, you're absolutely right. He came back much stronger.

[@boojoe1989]

Same on all accounts, I stopped listening to them for quite a while honestly, then this cover came out and brought me right back in

[@RushinTruckin]

Gives me chills every time I hear it!

[@discoverisrael9742]

This is why I like watching your reviews: 1. Christians are stereotyped as closed-minded 2. As Christians you are smashing that stereotype 3. All without seeming too preachy. Great stuff, guys. Keep expanding your musical horizon!

[@TheModernSnipez]

I mean by definition you believe in god you are close-minded.

[@discoverisrael9742]

@@TheModernSnipez The assertion God is real is equally as presumptuous as the claim he is not. Disagreements on faith shouldn't separate us.

[@loomick]

@@discoverisrael9742 thats why Atheists are the most open minded.

[@ericroberts8808]

Well said, my dude. Good vs God = o difference ;)

[@MrAndypree]

Jacob Goldberg it’s really not the same. Is presuming pink unicorns don’t exist as presumptuous as saying they do? One an opinion asserted without any evidence, the other is an opinion because there is no evidence. That’s completely an intellectually different. On every level.

[@Taiyou536]

If you get goosebumps from music you have a special brain :) I have it , too ♥

[@Vroomerz]

This one makes me cry.

[@whitneyschuebel3100]

This is actually true about getting goosebumps

[@1organdonor3]

Every time I hear it....goosebumps!

[@dmjr437]

Everytime I hear it!

[@numberletter1312]

I get goosebumps from music now I need to consult google to see if I'm special I swear if you're lying-

[@heatherhalleck8836]

this is amazing. but the live versions, especially one on Conan are truly soul touching. goosebumps and yes brings tears to eyes. I could listen to this song over and over and each time will be touched deep inside my soul. He voice is so amazing and to this date have never heard anyone who could do this song so perfectly

[@botheringthewildlife9641]

*obligatory Disturbed fan and non-Christian comment* Thanks for giving this song a chance. I'll go ahead and recommend that you also check out "Prayer" and "Liberate." I'm genuinely curious to see what you think.

[@jamesdjl4359]

Prayer is absolutely fantastic. Also, love liberate.

[@douglasfitzgerald8898]

Prayer is a favorite.

[@amberelliott-hassell3343]

Bothering The Wildlife prayer!!! YES!!! My favorite after this one!!

[@weirdstpodcast1750]

Prayer was a central part of my life growing up. That song spoke to me in a way few songs can.

[@EverLearningDragon]

Prayer is one of the ones I came to suggest but also Inside The Fire as it’s about the idea that his girlfriend, who committed suicide, is now burning in Hell and the Devil is trying to goad him into joining her. Both would be songs I would be interested in hearing a pastor’s perspective on.

[@lindseyjulian8219]

You guys should look up David Draimans background. He grew up being in the choir in a synagogue and his voice is absolutely beautiful. I've been a Disturbed fan for many years and this is my absolute favorite song

[@dash-x]

He trained to be a cantor. We dont really have a choir in the way people think of a choir at Christian church. People train for years, with most starting in Hebrew school (primary school,) in hopes of becoming one. The really neat part is he also comes from a long line of as well. His father and grandfather were both cantors .

[@IForgetWorlds]

Simon and Garfunkle's version of this song always felt like a warning when you grew up in this era. With this version of the song you see the warning has played out and this is the rage that the warning was ignored.

[@CartmanMorisato]

Very insightful. You hit the nail right on the head.

[@thulehuff6402]

Wow! Insightful Erina!

[@Frodo113711]

As a agnostic person who is not religious I appreciate what you are doin on this channel I think it's a great service. Music can be enjoyed by all despite religion or belief...keep up the videos you earned a subscriber with me. Great job

[@hoggle9415]

@Big Bosseseses Colossians 3:10-11

[@hoggle9415]

@Big Bosseseses John 13:34. Just because someone else lives in sin doesnt mean you get to harass them and constantly insult them. We all sin and you are not fit to be the judge

[@sanuloatheist6336]

@Big Bosseseses look how ignorant this person is, just till me where's that hell located anyway .

[@hoggle9415]

@Big Bosseseses i never said that it contained the additional comments. Thats why they aren't in quotations.

[@hoggle9415]

@Big Bosseseses do you know how to read English? I never said that I put quotations.

[@Doublespeaklol]

"Starting out kind of slow though" It took you guys 5 minutes to get to the actual content.....

[@deannelson9565]

Touche LOL

[@redbarn6160]

Lol

[@prismsage3957]

Preach

[@xas4723]

Preach to the preachers lol

[@MORNINGSGLORI]

that WAS part of the message, like a durge... a durge is ominous and not actually to be enjoyed

[@natkatmac]

Fun Fact: Disturbed has been wanting to cover this song for YEARS but didn't try to until they knew they could do it justice.

[@jenniferballinger4350]

BEST COVER EVER. A deep song that the sixties couldn't express. We are now in the sound of silence. Seperate from ourselves and blinded by the screens light

[@RaulDuke2123]

I'm a 40 yr old atheist and got here by watching a bunch of different videos. I'm glad you guys did this video and can be open minded. Keep up the good work and remember all people are different and the same.

[@Bstonz85]

Atheist are like vegans, you sont even need to ask, they will tell you within the first 5 minutes what they are.

[@kookyjoeb5524]

Atheists replace God with government.

[@TheMsmeme123]

At the end of the video the boat coming to the people each person carried a musical instrument and the people on shore had the lyrics they wrote...they come together. To say it was a hopeless and helpless song is subjective...I believe each generation has something to teach each other...we just need to listen...

[@lizv3634]

And the sun is just coming out as the boat comes to shore!

[@DianaEmilia911]

I’m an atheist. Your reaction to this makes me rethink the way religion looks, and what/who it includes. Thank you

[@nooneatnowhere]

I so appreciate your comments. As a Christian, I am personally guilty of avoiding meaningful conversation about my faith, and how and why it may be relevant. Thank you for listening to this video and taking the time to comment.

[@killuminatepeacefulness3948]

I believe in god . But follow no religion. But I'd rather be around Christian's then muslims tbh.

[@maandpasattic6254]

It's all about believing on Jesus, his sacrifice was for everyone and he loves everyone. If you ever want to talk feel free to reach out.

[@embyquinn]

Being a Christian isn't about a religion. Religion is ritual. Christianity is a belief system. You can go to church every time the doors open and know the Bible by rote and still not believe. Christianity isn't lip service or public piety. It's between you and God.

[@knowledgetracker]

Yeah, "religiosity" can give a bad name to Christianity. Christ spoke out against religion.

[@Dave1507]

I've watched tons of reactions to this song, and only one guy was like "makes sense that it starts with silence." and he was absolutely right.

[@charmmh4054]

but also the background of the lead singer. He was actually a 'cantor' when younger (a Jewish Singer who led all prayers etc. in synagogues). Plus some family members came from the horrific sadness and evils of WWII>the attempted genocide of the Jewish People, so he has a history. His music is based a lot on antisemitism etc. He is not a cantor anymore but i can understand his 'passion' he brings out through his music. I agree with the reaction to this video, because his voice is BreathTaking and i also, am not one for this type music except a 'piece' such as this song because it shows his voice, range and passion.

[@cerealbobkiller]

First time I watch your channel but the 100th time I listen to this song. Honestly when I read "Pastors React" I wasn't sure I should watch since I'm an atheist but you guys did a good job of reacting and discussing this interpretation by Disturbed of a masterpiece without overpreaching faith. It was interesting to hear your point of view since it's very different to what I'm used to and although I won't become a believer because of it, it makes me realize dialogue is possible between people. It's surprising how your religious background and my political science background see culture in a very similar way, aka a message, a vehicule of value, a sermon, etc. Good jobs. Keep doing it

[@82jrounder]

being a atheist is illogical no one knows the truth agnostic is the only logical choice although the Bible could easily be 100% true.

[@cerealbobkiller]

@@82jrounder What is illogical about atheism? What's the difference between believing something does or does not exist?

[@Formulabruce]

@@cerealbobkiller In Humanity there is Good, and there is Evil. Nearly every song, every movie is about Contrasting Good and Evil. So, where does one find that Good and Evil come from? Our "WILL" to choose doesn't Define it, But shows that there are indeed two paths, Believe it or not.

[@cerealbobkiller]

@@Formulabruce That made no sense whatsoever. Good and Evil are Man made and dont preexist our understanding of it. Morality differs considerably depending on many conditions and factors. Believing something exists or doesn't isn't different. It's a choice. Nothing more. Honestly I don't mind people believing in whatever they feel like believing. It's none of my business. As long as it makes them happy I'm all good with it. I chose to believe in something else that is not diety related. That's all

[@82jrounder]

because believing something does or does not exist is illogical most humans have to because it makes them feel better in some way but the truth is our existence makes no sense our knowledge of the truth is almost nothing 0000000000000000000000000000.1% the probablity we are in a matrix, created by God, or nothing is easily all the same. it scares people to understand this so most ppl don't think about it . atheism is illogical because your believing against something for no reason whhen in truth no one has any idea wtf is going on. Humans need grounded reality that makes sense .. imagine if everything you see in movies / horror movies / anything you can amagine could be real? people would lose their minds. so being a atheist is simple and not scary big bang.. evolution thats it. simple easy.. although in truth those are as much fairy tale as anything else you can imagine ; )

[@jonnamarie3841]

While I absolutely LOVE this version, my introduction to Disturbed was David Draiman singing it acapella and I sat with tears running down my face.

[@crystals5962]

Jonna Dittemore I would like to hear that version where did you find it?

[@jeremycarpenter2731]

I seen them in concert and the put on a great show. If you ever get the chance to see them in concert go.

[@lisadgingersnaps9843]

I heard David first in the movie "Queen of the Damned". Didn't know the singer, but that voice! Fast forward a billion years and my hubs plays this song. I scream "I know that voice!". And I found in in my brain and there he was. Amazing vocalist!

[@chrismontedoro4497]

Jonna Dittemore I've been a Disturbed fan from their beginning, but this song made my weep the first time I saw it as well. All of their songs have powerful messages. Another video to watch is Wrong Side of Heaven by Five Finger Death Punch. It's about the plight of our veterans. As a vet myself, I cried throughout the entire song.

[@brandycarter558]

...and my introduction to David Draiman, Disturbed; was because of this song. I've always liked the song a lot, but now I L❤VE the song and this incredibly talented group. Everytime I hear David sing this song, I become a wonderful emotional mess, with tears falling from my face.

[@NextStopJesus]

"Silence like a cancer grows" Goosebumps indeed!

[@McScott76]

Some of your comments got me thinking about why we as Christians treat music so differently than any other form of human enterprise or art. When we know a Christian carpenter, we don't expect to drive by a house he built and see Bible verses written on the walls or a giant cross on the roof. Or if we know a painter, we don't expect every still life image to have a Bible inexplicably shoved into it just to make sure everyone knows the artist is a believer. So why is it that we expect musicians to constantly produce didactic, trite "art" that is the musical equivalent of a 3-minute "Our Daily Bread" devotional? Why is it not ok for a Christian to produce a piece of music that does nothing more than take an honest look at the hopelessness of poverty, or the joys of parenthood, or the sadness of a widower? Why does every song need to have a hook that can be clapped along to in a Church service for us to consider it "Christian" enough? Isn't Christianity, above all else, supposed to be an authentic expression of humanity's relationship with its Creator and Savior? So if you can authentically have a point in your life when you feel alone or afraid or sad, or joyful, why is it "wrong" to express that in song without making it into some kind of Sunday School lesson? Something to ponder.

[@Razzaq585]

You make a good point.

[@danielschneider8098]

Holy shit this was so well put together i just stared at it for a minute. Props to you sir this was amazing.

[@BS-dq1kz]

McScott76 Great comment. Wonderful insight and fantastic question!

[@MoMoMyPup10]

The artists simply don't have to, nor do all of them. Amy Grant was one who made it big in secular music after getting started in CCM. Some bands make secular songs that are 'quasi Christian' in a broad sense. NeedToBreathe is like that. The problem I think is that CCM should be inspired works of 'art', as you say, and most of it isn't. And it seems like they're just trying to make a catchy tune that is played on the radio, or that can make the Sunday's and Wednesday's playlist. And in today's world, somehow it sells. It sells a lot. But it usually stinks from a technical standpoint. And they sign contracts and in the contracts they're told they need to produce a certain number of 'Christian' songs and albums in a certain time frame. So to me I think they force it, instead of it coming to them organically, and inspired by life events. The results aren't good.

[@achterkirchj]

May i suggest some Christain Metal to show you that not all christain music is churchy???

[@AliceI7764]

I really like the CS Lewis quote you mentioned. I saw a quote from a TV show of all places that had as much of an impact. The character was a devout Christian but lost her faith when another character was murdered. When she found her way back to her faith at the end of the season she said, "I don't think it's God's job to stop the bad. I actually think he's there to give us the strength to get through it."

[@GailColeman]

I love this version! So powerful! His voice is amazing! My favorite line is about the "neon God they made"-isn't THAT the truth?!

[@shandajames5444]

Disturbed did an AMAZING job with this song!!!❤

[@devsox1]

As a Christian myself, I love hearing two pastors react to/discuss one of my all time favorite covers!

[@rebeccafieldsofdreams8428]

Same here!!!

[@sonofasinner86]

this band has been my fav for years but this song hits home bc i battle depression eveyday

[@rebeccafieldsofdreams8428]

@@sonofasinner86 i know that shit sux!! Depression is real!! I know its easy to lay down but try to get out and get endorphins pumping..and some sun..it actually helps..sending prayers man!!🙏💞💓💞🙏

[@thehampster9618]

JT LUCAS my prayers are with you. Keep fighting it warrior! And God bless you and keep you my man.

[@kittyvaughn76]

Comparing this to the original, I actually believe this version is more powerful. When I first heard and saw this, it literally gave me chills! I really like this. It spoke to me.

[@caroldelaney4987]

I was in tears and breathless.

[@UltimateBargains]

Beyond ridiculously good. Beyond ludicrously great. It's gone to plaid.

[@soggy5854]

Lol SPACEBALLS!

[@Shiny_Sean]

"They've gone to plaid!" -Barf the Mog (half man, half dog, his own best friend)

[@josephchastain5410]

Nice mel brooks reference

[@shelleyfoster4077]

I think that this song is relevant today with social media and cancel culture. "Silence like a cancer grows" to me it means that more and more people are afraid to talk. I think that this version is waking people up and saying,"Fight!".

[@karenwillis4026]

Everytime I hear this song I stop what I’m doing and just listen, such a powerful performance.

[@cub316]

As someone who doesn't really have a "faith", I came across your channel via youtube's recommended viewing (mostly because I am a fan of Disturbed). I have to say i really enjoyed your view and discussion on the song. I've now subscribed and will watch more of your work.. Thanks and keep up the work!

[@liblikake]

i discovered the video through the same reason that youtube recommended this. thats just amazing.

[@DOPELEFIRE]

I am the same as Cub316, I came by the channel by recommendation as i'm a fan of Disturbed and react channels! I would like to see the Pastors do a reatcions to 10000 fists by disturbed (cover of genesis). Keep up the good work Pastor! I may not share your views on faith but i can appreciate opening your mind to songs/bands that you may have thought to be "corrupting"(probably not the right word i'm really looking for, sorry). So thanks for keeping an open mind!

[@NorokVokun]

@@DOPELEFIRE Couldnt have saied it better. Thank you.

[@bdarne0024]

"this guy has some range" David Draiman: hold my beer

[@HocusPocusFocus69]

Communion juice.

[@DareDRiver96]

"Well more for me" (glug glug glugglugglug)

[@mikesale100]

LMAO YEP

[@BillKrayer12thMan]

Well played,sir.

[@molsen42074]

He is opera trained

[@conniecorwin1327]

This version is so reflective of what is going on in the world today. It’s a warning of what is here now and how we can overcome the darkness if we want to do it. This is the most amazing and hauntingly beautiful song…..and now after listening to this version of the song, I understand the message better. Disturbed and David did a phenomenal job communicating the future and how we can do better. I love it.

[@donnablansett9593]

Another person posted this on another reaction. And this is what he/she said....This song is dedicated to you. It's dedicated to me. It's a dedication to EVERYONE. That's why it's so powerful. When we do not come together as a people, to share our thoughts, our feelings, our overall humanity with one another... we are left with silence. And as he says, silence like cancer grows. Unless we set aside whatever it is that keeps us "silent", we will never create "music" together. We will never live in harmony. The neon god is the media, technology, consumer market, etc. basically anything that SEEMS like a way to bring people together. But think about how many times you log into Facebook and see posts portraying negativity amongst us, think about how many times you'd rather be glued to your phone or computer rather than conversing face to face with someone... and the consumer market PUSHES for these things because they don't care if it brings people together or tears them apart- they care about one thing... and that is that you BUY BUY BUY so they become rich. Someone else in the comments wrote that Simon and Garfunkel originally wrote this song as a warning and Disturbed brought it back in their rendition as a statement to tell us it was ignored. I agree. And I think most people deep down agree- and that's why it moves us so much. The phrase "come together" sometimes sounds cliche but it's EXTREMELY important. We are all brothers and sisters. We are all human. And we all matter!

[@thulehuff6402]

Donna, loved your interpretation!

[@kimrasmussen7188]

its a sad song, but i still feel that it gives a sliver of hope...note, that he is speaking in past tense he has seen the stupidity of man, but he survived, and can now tell the story as warning this version is MUCH more powerful , than the original. it didnt make me cry at all..i just got something in my eye

[@thehoogard]

the wole song is a vision (he dreamt it). A vision implies you can change it.

[@drops2cents260]

@kim rasmussen > it didnt make me cry at all..i just got something in my eye Might be those sneaky ninjas which are always lurking in the shadows of my flat and sometimes launch surprise attacks by furiously chopping onions. They probably have opened a new chapter near you. Bastards.

[@irrevenant3]

It feels like a progression. Simon and Garfunkel were despair. Disturbed were anger. Next comes action.

[@Manni_Z]

That is a cool way to think about this songtext. At the first time I listened to it I started to cry at the middle of the song..and sometimes, mood does matter, too.

[@travisgraham2592]

You guys do good work. You listen well and analyze the songs with a Christian filter/outlook while still being fair to the person or people who have worked hard to show how they feel in their songs. i agree that we should be able to listen to most music as long as we hold to our morals and see the song for what it is while not allowing if it is negative to have any affect on how we act or believe afterwords. I really like when you have Danny on he is a very intelligent person who seems to get the songs you guys listen to. I really like the enthusiasm and feeling that you show Robert, you also seem like a really down to earth person and it is very refreshing. Please keep them coming!

[@boogerwelder]

"More connected through technology, yet more disconnected socially " Hit the proverbial nail directly on the head right there.

[@krisk3988]

Not sure if you guys will wind up seeing this but one of the most accurate comparisons I've heard for this song and the original is that the original was sung as a warning and this version encases the anger of the warning not being headed. One of the duo even said that the song was no longer theirs after listening to this cover.

[@overkast6841]

Simon and Garfunkel's version was a warning. Disturbed's version is rage because the warning was ignored.

[@scorpio4992]

U copied someone

[@overkast6841]

Was an amazing statement

[@scorpio4992]

@@overkast6841 that's true

[@alanarreola9082]

true

[@DracosRose]

And Pentatonixs' cover is the rally call. 😉❤😁

[@RenzitoARG]

You 2 really break the Christian Stereotype. As an atheist, let me tell you: You're performing the "preach by example" flawlessly; that, sires, is a compliment.

[@wufongtanwufong5579]

Who cares what you think.

[@kerrex86]

More people than who care what you think

[@raymanspy95]

@@wufongtanwufong5579 Wow dude. would you have cared if he didn't say he was an atheist? Just curious, cause I have known people who treat others like the plague once they find out somebody is an atheist even if they have known them for years. It's not like being an atheist makes his opinion any less valid than yours, or anybody else.

[@cinderellsworth]

@@raymanspy95 Yeah, we Christians really need to clean up our act if we truly want to win souls for the Kingdom. Love is kind, patient, long-suffering, and I can't remember the rest of the list. But you get my point. The only two commandments given to Christians by Jesus Christ were to love the Lord our God, and LOVE OUR NEIGHBOR as much as we love ourselves. *smh* We've got a long way to go, folks... God bless.

[@wedniephiloxy3389]

The people who don't live by preaching by example they're not real questions honey.

[@passtheparcel2007]

When the voice gets angry an firm, its like God himself is speaking to us! Its not a hopeless song, but one of hope an release. Its a clear warning for us to turn back an repent, before its too late!

[@TexasSnyper]

Simon and Garfunkle version is more of a helpless song. Disturbed version is more of a call to action. The fact that it continuously grows to the crescendo at the end emphasizes that, even if the lyrics are the same. It's a gathering of strength behind it.

[@tabbiestelljes3437]

This is my favorite cover of this song his vocal range he uses in this song is amazing!

[@debbowen2011]

David Draiman's voice is spectacular! Powerful and penetrating. ❤

[@nancypater5225]

Hi

[@scottwilcoxson2439]

"people writing songs that voices never share". How sad. Truer today than ever before.

[@SirALXNo1]

I'd never heard of Dr. Purvis. Now I am impressed and I dare say, a fan! I thank both of you Gentlemen! God bless!

[@evilgenius4213]

I invite you to listen and compare Johnny Cash's cover of "Hurt" with Nine Inch Nails original as further proof that sometimes another artist brings a different set of experiences to a song and makes it better.

[@jimthecactus7425]

I don't really consider Cash's version of hurt and NIN's version the same song (also prefer the original). They have different meanings.

[@ringingsteel8729]

JimTheCactus it’s interesting that two songs can have the exact same words, and mean entirely different things and convey completely different emotions.

[@TheNightOwl11683]

@@ringingsteel8729 Perfect example is John Lennon's "Imagine" & A Perfect Circle's cover of it. John Lennon's version was about hope for unity & the potential for world peace. A Perfect Circle's version was about how that hope is long gone & world peace is now just a fantasy, especially with the imagery in the video.

[@ringingsteel8729]

Vlad the Inhaler I’m aware of the single word change between the two versions of the song. I’m fairly certain “crown of shit,” is a reference to Jesus in the original as well, but it’s a reference Cash and his audience wouldn’t have received well, and is probably the reason behind the change.

[@elizabethsantersero9597]

His version was very moving to me, in a way the original wasn't for me

[@egidioruffolo8490]

I never tire of Reaction videos to this SOS version.His vocals are a gift

[@caseythompson474]

Egidio Ruffolo I’ve only encountered one person that wasn’t completely stunned by this version. He decided within the first 5 words that he didn’t like it which really sucks for him.

[@corrinnegarfield2460]

Also, CHRIS STAPLETON, Tennessee Whiskey, I love all the reactions!

[@lindagravier3641]

I am 70 years of age and I unmistakably think Disturbed is FANTASTIC...I grew up with the original and I can't listen to it anymore.

[@valhallastiger2960]

Huh just realised that the initials spell S.O.S wonder if that was deliberate

[@sysain6114]

This is exactly the kind of content you need to get me interested into learning more about christianity and the project you guys are doing, good job :D

[@azaleataylor8031]

When people are lost in darkness you don't know up from down. I discovered Jesus's love through the darkness. I discovered the darker genre of music didn't make me commit immoral acts just helped me not feel alone. I've never fit in and it's finding your way alone because everyone you trust either abandons or you betrays you that makes you feel lost. Also dealt with darkness from loved ones dieing I was upset with our creator for several years because of the loss of the loved ones. Music that understands that darkness can be a blessing. Metal goes into the depth of darkness instead putting everything in God's hands without looking for the signs to find solutions. I've watched people become doormats or very judgmental because of their faith which made me struggle with the bible. I've actually found a church that respects my struggle and is helping me. That's how our creator works and darkness is there to show us Jesus's light. I'm trying to find light in the bible so if you've got any inspirational verses would like to know because that helps me with the bible. I think darkness is there to show us the light and the deeper we go the deeper in your subconscious thoughts you can go clear out sins you didn't realize were there. I knew that's what happened because I can't listen to the sadistic music and watch violent movies anymore. I don't have that rage anymore it's healed that's what I learned through decades of darkness. That working through pain you can find salvation with our holy creator and Jesus.