Ditching Aluminum - Native vs Duke Cannon Natural Deodorant Review

[@MrJ3]

Keeping armpit hair to a minimum has been the single greatest personal change I've made in terms of deodorant effectiveness.

[@UGA.D]

Agreed. Kavalier at 2:20 looks like he has a wookie in a headlock. (Just playin')

[@patrickmcmullin9522]

Mr. J I am curious why keep armpit hair down to a minimum?(A male doesn't shave his armpits!I know that females do shave their armpits!)

[@StanfordChiou]

@@patrickmcmullin9522 Keeping armpit hair to a minimum reduces surface area on which bacteria can grow.

[@Billybillybillyrocking]

This is true. So the hair follicle carries the sweat and odor out. Keeping it trimmed down reduces this, I trim it short not bald. Where the deodorant can cover the follicles but also the skin. It's made a big difference. Arm and hammer essentials is the best so far for me so far. Trim your hair, it's not hard and makes a difference.

[@SeanShimamoto]

Patrick McMullin At least you’re not disingenuous in your comment and actually showed your sexist views. If a dude wants to not have Chewbacca under his arms, WTF cares?!? But to answer your question, it reduces the area that breeds the odorous bacteria...it’s pretty common sense.

[@DamonCrawley]

I’ve found native works well, and I don’t have the staining issue. But what I noticed is that Native says that you only need 2-3 application swipes (1 down and up counts as 2) and it looked like you went a little heavier. But also, as someone noticed, trimming the underarms up will also help the application issues.

[@KParks]

I like Duke cannon and I prefer how they run their business. A great company

[@michaelmcgowan7099]

First, I enjoy your channel and think you do a consistently good job in your reviewed. That said, I find the use of the word "natural" as a guarantee of health and safety too often to be a marketing con. It doesn't take much research to learn that all the concerns about aluminum in deodorants have wildly exaggerated and consistently debunked. First, some early studies thought it might be connected to breast cancer, but that was disproven. Then there was a theory that aluminum is a cause of alzheimer's, but that also was proven meritless. I know that the internet is full of references to thinly supported and poorly done studies, but I hate when people's ignorance of science is used to sell consumer goods. I have nothing against "natural" antiperspirants, if they work for you, but it is unlikely that they are helping to safeguard your health. If they keep you dry and smelling fresh, then fantastic.

[@armandol1826]

Native isn’t an antiperspirant. That’s why you end up sweating naturally (as one should)

[@lupuscorvus841]

I used to use nothing but Old Spice, then went to Every Man Jack because old spice became way too gimicky and it reflected in their scents. Until recently I had to find a new deodorant because Every Man Jack was giving me a horrible rash under my arm pits out of nowhere. After years of using it, out of nowhere they would itch and burn like crazy and leave a red rash everywhere. Finally stumbled upon Duke Cannon deodorant at a random gas station in South Carolina during a road trip to Florida one day. I had been using their soaps for a while so I was curious. Never looked back since.

[@zacharymccarty3774]

Hey man, just wanted to say thanks for posting this. I have been using the Duke Cannon you recommended for about 3 months now and it has been awesome! I was also using Native before and had the worst BO and was getting the worst stains. Duke Cannon is great, no stains and does a good job at tackling BO. Thanks!

[@walkermorales337]

Another good one to try is Schmidt, they can be found at target Edit: although the texture can vary from one stick to the next, and I’d recommend for holding it in your armpit for about 1 minute the first time you use it, and as for price it’s $5 dollars here, so only a dollar more than old spice and a couple dollars less than native, I use the magnesium and charcoal scented one

[@brandoh98]

For $12 or $13 I expect greatness so if native doesn't work or ruins clothes it's a no. I got Dr squatch Birchwood breeze deodorant and that was amazing, smelled great most of the day and even next day no fragrance but no odor either.

[@tigergreg8]

WOW, This has been a personal thing with me for quite some time. I've been trying to find a brand of Deodorant that I could trust to wick away moisture and still have a great smell to it. I've tried several with success, but the way you speak of this charcoal Cannon Deodorant, I'm buying it off Amazon to be shipped here by Sunday. My brother is a fan of Cannon, and I do like the scent called Victory. Great products with a great aroma. Thanks for the information.

[@Oliwolf78]

It'd be awesome if you could update us on how the Cannon deodorant worked for you. Did it do you justice?

[@elitaylor5826]

@@Oliwolf78 i can’t speak for them but i personally really like the sandalwood and amber duke cannon trench warfare. an amazing smell you never get tired of that keeps you smelling great all day.

[@ransomkirk9676]

Just went to Duke Cannon's website to order some deodorant and they were all sold out. I guess your video convinced a fair amount of people to look into them! Ill have to settle for trying out their soap in the meantime.

[@peterjohnston477]

The key to using non-aluminum deodorant is to detox your armpits beforehand using apple cider vinegar. It takes away any smell for the whole day. Look up videos on bentonite clay and apple cider vinegar masks to detox your armpits. Also Lume is the best brand of natural deodorant. It’s a little pricier but it works.

[@jmgerraughty]

I'm only finding this video now after months of using Native. I thought I was taking crazy pills because I was getting pit stains with an aluminum-free deodorant! Glad to see I wasn't the only one.

[@CaptaenRon]

I've always been an Old Spice guy. I have found the soft-solid works the best for me; long-lasting and no residue in the shirts. Thanks for the video, I might give the Duke stuff a try. Side note: My wife tried going natural (non-aluminum) with Tom's and it was so ineffective she quit. What is your wife switching to?

[@orlandourenanyc]

Thanks for this awesome video brother! I tried & wore Gillette, Secret, Dove, & Old Spice. They were all great but I hated that my armpits on all my shirts would stain so fast!! Switched over to Native and never looked back. I find that it works fine with my body type for daily use. Perfect for fall, winter, and spring. During summer Native didn't wear as long ( NYC summers are harsh & humidity is off the charts lol ) so I would carry a small travel size Native in my everyday carry bag just in case I had to apply a second time. I would deff check out Duke Cannon and give them a try! Thank Again!!

[@wardrice4778]

Big fan of Jungleman. But you are correct. You need to use the one that works for you, and it is not one size fits all. 4 ingredients in Jungleman: Ingredients: Organic Zea Mays (Corn) Starch, Sustainable Elaeis Guineensis (Palm) Oil From Non-Peatlands, Sodium Bicarbonate (Baking Soda), Melaleuca Alternifolia (Tea Tree) Leaf Oil.

[@chirich572]

Not sure if it fits the parameters of natural deodorant, but I like the sandalwood deodorant from Every Man Jack. It's free of aluminum and parabene and uses essential oil as fragrance. And it is of the gel type that you prefer.

[@Oliwolf78]

I've used Every Man Jack's natural deoderants and they don't do shit. After a few hours of going about my day my armpits smell like the dumpster of a Chinese restaurant at 9pm when using that stuff. Meanwhile, old spice antiperspirant keeps me smelling perfectly fine many hours later. I'll give Duke cannon a try, but Every Man Jack sure as hell doesn't work for every man.

[@michaelgraci2925]

I tried Native back in '17 for a couple of months & had similar results. I seemed to sweat more & had similar issues with my shirts. My 1st & only attempt at a natural product. I went back to Dove Men+Care Comfort. My have to check out Duke-Cannon. Thanks

[@FLTlvl]

I had a huge problem with underarm sweat, to a point, where I was not comfortable wearing certain shirts (with and undershirt of course) as I knew how long it would take for me to not have a visible stains, once they get wet. Certain Dry, applied every two or three nights is a game changer. Then the best other trick I found out was Ejis or other brand's (I think your well liked Mack Weldon makes them too) undershirt with extra padding under arms that are guaranteed to not show anything. Lastly, for a physical separation, I did hear but have not tried underarm stickers, and some herbs / supplements claim to reduce sweating. All I have :) Cheers

[@anthonycbrown1952]

Next Episode: 'Manscaping In Three Easy Steps". Full applauds to your channel as you are not 'body shy' and help us understand how these products work. Has your work changed? In the past it appeared your were traveling much more internationally.

[@WhatShallEyeDo4U]

Interesting, Kavalier... Native works for me... 🤔 I will try the other Duke Cannon, soon.

[@chrisalvarez7068]

The last 2 Duke cannon antiperspirants caved in on itself while I applied. I lost maybe half of it because there is a giant hole in the middle. It worked fine the first week. I hope they fix it because other than that it’s great 👍🏻

[@bphangamer]

I’ve been using Every Man Jack deodorant. It’s also marketing itself as a naturally derived aluminum free company. Was wondering if you’d tried it before and what you thoughts were? I still sweat a lot after I apply it

[@gamesvideo9818]

I tried theirs and my armpits started burning and left a rash I still have, I wouldn't recommend it, I don't have sensitive skin either.

[@kristendietz2022]

I have been using natural deodorants exclusively for months now but I have issues with Native and Schmidts. They both make my pits itchy and I can't wear them more than twice in a row. And the schmidts one is supposed to be for sensitive skin

[@rodz7910]

Best application regardless of the type of deodorant would be to shave your arm pits. Just use clippers not blade.

[@parthavmody4875]

The dermatologist Dr. Dray on KZbin has talked about applying antiperspirant on at night on clean skin. The antiperspirant has to essentially permeate the sweat glands and stop the production of sweat and it takes time. If you apply in the morning the sweat that you experience, however minimal, essentially removes the antiperspirant before it can do it's job.

[@drizzypuffs523]

Its weird because I used to love Native but it does leave residue on my clothes that do wash out. But the Cucumber and Mint scent gave me a bad rash and then I saw this video and tried Duke Cannon. Honestly Duke Cannon is immediately my go to deodorant. Works great. I work in a muggy hot car wash in the midwest and it can power through the days no problem. Of course you'll still "smell" but not as much if you wore no Deodorant. But also I don't sweat profusely naturally so consider that.

[@stephenb6491]

Native left the worst grease stains in my shirts. I kept thinking my shirt looked wet but I was dry and it was grease from the deodorant. I tried several naturally deodorants and all the same gave me darkened armpits and didn’t work. I’ll try the new one you recommend that I haven’t tried.

[@barretthooper9207]

Thanks Kavalier, I always enjoy your videos and suggesting. I'll use your code and try it.

[@technolotree5690]

It's cool to see the topics you choose, because I'm probably 8 to 10 years older than you, and these are things I contemplated in my 20's as a bachelor who subscribed to GQ and Details. Most of the non-aluminum deodorants I looked into were fine, but in the end, you still stink at the end of the day. There's a reason they use aluminum. In the end, I went back to my Old Spice. (I use both the Deodorant AND the Anti-Perspirant). Recently though, a skincare company that I've been a big fan of (Baxter of California) started making their own anit-aluminum deodorant. It's good. Really good. I swear by most of their products, actually. Get into them, Jon. Baxter is a great company for men's products. I can't really speak to their hair products though, because I am bald.

[@gregstarr2954]

Very honest review!!! Give a good thumb’s up!!! Job well done

[@juliet5280]

Hi There- What deodorant is your life switching to? I have been using Native and I love it 85%...but I am interested in trying something else.

[@nico_jerome]

Really wanted to try this Duke Cannon deodorant, but it seems like it has been discontinued. Have you moved on to something new?

[@walkermorales337]

Another deodorant to try is called sodawax, it goes on nicer than Schmidt, and it’s about as effective. It kept me from smelling when I was doing roofing this summer

[@bessieroman2704]

Hi! Thank you for sharing! I went to buy this for my husband and he loved it! He was really disliking Native. Can you please share what your wife switch to? I would love to try it, Native is not doing the work for me. Ty!!

[@matthewklein6283]

Video very well put together. Thanks for info. 👍

[@Kilbu]

Loved the video! thank you, gonna check them out! just bought 3 of them

[@wesleycoats]

this channel is punching above its weight

[@blaketeague8682]

Malin and Goetz has a great natural deodorant! Highly recommend

[@wesleycoats]

Lifetime old spice user here. I’ve been trying to switch to a natural deo for several months. I tried native, malin and goetz, oar and alps. All 3 of them irritated my underarms to the point of pain and extreme redness. I thought the issue was was propylene glycol. 2 weeks ago I started the bergamot/black pepper duke cannon. It works, and there’s no irritation! I suspect it has something to do with the gel application that my pits like for some reason.

[@onixtheone]

alot of the natural deos recommend you not use the deodorant on broken or cracked skin or else you will get that irritation

[@maxloyd9682]

What do you think of arm and hammer essentials? It’s aluminum, paraben And phthalates free. It’s cheap . What do the deodorants that you mention have that something like arm and hammer doesn’t ?

[@Fedgery007]

I use prescription Drysol. It was a god send.

[@HernanHH95]

Jeffrey B I’ll try that

[@thestarseeker8196]

I’ve ended up switching almost my entire hygienic arsenal to Duke Cannon, save for the shampoo, but that’s not because their shampoo isn’t awesome, I just have a really finicky scalp and needed something even more finicky than the Tea Tree shampoo I was using from DC.

[@mikeanaya117]

I really miss this duke cannon trench warfare deodorant, it was the best deodorant ever!

[@acetvr6]

Just ordered the Duke Cannon Natural Charcoal Deodorant Bergamot & Black Pepper after watching your review, looking forward to something that won't stain my shirts, so it being aluminium free should help, I hope

[@mountainstatematt271]

I switched from antiperspirant to aluminum free deodorant a couple years ago and the only thing that I have found that keeps me from smelling like a manimal is old spice. I'm going to have to try the duke cannon and see how it works out.

[@misterbobby8913]

How'd it go? Is it good? Or is old spice aluminum free the best one out there?

[@mountainstatematt271]

@@misterbobby8913 I have tried all 3 now and they all work well. I would rank them old spice first, native, then duke cannon. Body chemistry is different for everyone, however, so you might have a different experience.

[@misterbobby8913]

@@mountainstatematt271 Thank you very much Good sir

[@smithanimal]

Have you ever heard of the service Hawthorne? I tried out the cologne and deodorant lately and actually really like them. It's an interesting idea for a business the way they work but I managed to have success with the service. Not sure what your thoughts were?

[@oadefisayo]

I still swear by Old Spice deodorant. I stay away from the anti perspirant though and just stick with the classic Old Spice

[@scottd.3382]

@thekavalier which scent of the natural Duke do you like? I'm finding two different ones: bergamot and sandalwood.

[@turoe03]

Did you detox your arms before using the natural deodorant?

[@michaelhilbe2991]

I would really love to hear an attempt at an explanation that tries to explain how Aluminum isn't natural.

[@jhavenhyde4178]

Some people are allergic, and the aluminum works by blocking pores on the skin and it aborbs into the body. There have been concerns about potential negative effects of aluminum buildup which has led so a movement against it.

[@joepalonis9237]

I'm a big fan of Native, but was having the same problem with my polo shirts. It's the coconut oil that creates that issue. Solution = before washing, apply "Dawn Platinum" directly on the soiled \ stained areas, let it sit for 15 minutes, wash as usual, problem solved. Duke Cannon uses propylene glycol instead of coconut oil. Here's a quick google search on propylene glycol: "Propylene glycol (also known as 1,2 propanediol) is a relatively small molecule with two alcohol (hydroxyl) groups (-OH). It is a colorless, odorless liquid that is completely water-soluble. PG is a synthetic product obtained from the hydration of propylene oxide, which is derived from petroleum products." So really not all that "natural." I also find that keeping the armpits slightly trimmed \ manscaped allows the native to go easier and helps reduce odor.

[@danielkitts4903]

This. The Propylene Glycol really irritated my skin, like a severe rash that looked and felt like a horrible sunburn. Native is one of the only brands I have found that doesn't use that ingredient.

[@tjbaggett]

I swapped to Schmidt's Charcoal and Magnesium after getting it in my GQ box and haven't looked back. I too always thought it was the aluminum to stay away from never researched it myself. Grabbed my stick after watching at the Schmidt's is a "natural" deo but it still contains parabens.

[@flyguy22190]

What's the problem with aluminum aside from turning the armpits yellow?

[@JoeT-re5ro]

Nothing. for years it was rumors to cause cancer but that was debunked over 25 years ago . I found nothing works as good as Mitchum unscented gel 25% aluminum

[@victorgarcia592]

I think that you were sweating a lot because I heard that when you switch to natural deodorants your armpits start to sweat more to release all of the waste that was there from the other deodorants that u were previously using.

[@ljp388]

Look into Sam's Natural! Not only does it work with odor but works best for sweat! A friend uses Bravo Sierra which he swears by. Would love for you to do a line up for natural deodorants. I'll check out the brand you mentioned! Also, best to trim your arm pit hair down low for most effective.

[@scottd.3382]

No. Leave your armpit hair as it is 😉.

[@Jebro439]

Great Video have you tried other items from Duke Cannon? Can you do a video on the other products they have?

[@dgthomas11]

Soda Wax natural deodorant is one to check out. All Natural, made of ingredients you can literally eat and the smells are great. Made in USA!

[@michaelrutledge3750]

I’m allergic to most deodorants and all antiperspirants. I haven’t found anything that works well, yet. I’ll have to check into the DC brand. Lemon juice and setting the shirts in the sun with the treated pit stains exposed removes the pit stains from deodorants/APs on white shirts.

[@donovansantana9977]

How are you 6’4 and wear a size small shirt? I wear XL and they’re still not long enough.???

[@Oliwolf78]

I'm guessing he wears a small tall or something

[@JoeT-re5ro]

Small med. large .extra large are all the same length each size Is just wider . I”m 6”4 and have to get a large tall . A large tall is about 3 inches longer than a regular large

[@JM12044]

Menscience is the best natural deodorant out there in my opinion.

[@friendlygoz]

I swear by Arm and Hammer. Works really well, it’s natural, and the baking soda kills all odor.

[@rickm.l.8229]

AOS (Art of Sports) has worked nicely for me. Its “Rise” scent is the one I like. I must add that the transition to this type of deodorants takes a bit of adjustment. Like many, I was using a 24 hours protection one. The very first day I tried AOS I was funky by 4pm. Then a coworker told me that during the transition I had to apply it more often than usual until my body got used to it. So, I applied it every 4 hours (during the day) for a week; now I apply it only twice a day, right after a shower (I take two every day). Best thing of this change was that the yellow stains on my white T-shirts and shirts are gone!!!

[@MayonnaiseOreo]

AOS has aluminum in it though, despite claiming not to.

[@gearup9503]

Does the sent last throughout a 12Hr day?

[@siratulmustakim3076]

To me the best natural deodorant ever is the Lavilin cream deodorant, a tiny little pinch keeps your pits odor free for 7+ days continuously. Works even after showering 🚿 or excessive sweating 😓 goes away only if you scrub your pits but 🧼 soap is totally fine.

[@MrDmitry4ever]

Hi! what about parabens in duke? does it have them?

[@carbofation]

Have you Hawthorne? They make fragrances, deodrants, etc; their deodrants come in different forms, without AL as well. I've had good results with it.

[@fire4christ34]

I have a question my son has the worse and I mean worse bo no matter what he uses! He tried lume and it worked for about 6 hours then the stink came back every man jack works pretty good but I'm looking for something better for him he doesn't even have to sweat to have bo he showers regularly he isn't nasty he just can't seem to find a good deodorant does anyone know if this works good enough for someone who hasa hard time with bo

[@Daniel_Page]

My friend, cut that underarm wool, you will naturally get cooler.

[@Sam.Buchanan]

Thanks have been wanting to move on from low end DEO for some time. Fortunately Amazon shipped to New Zealand. Kia Ora Bro!

[@ryanfoote7558]

I’m the person that makes them i work for the company that makes native and we get worked to death and we’re not even aloud to leave the building on breaks or any thing can even be outside our breaks are ten minutes its expensive cuz it’s man labor included with it

[@RegularGuyism]

Every Man Jack is all you need frfr

[@joeq6683]

Usually aluminum causes those stains. Native probably has another metal that acts as an antiperspirant that is causing those stains.

[@jhavenhyde4178]

Thats so crazy to hear because Native is the only brand thats worked for me. My deodorant would turn into glue in the shower and it was so painful I tried every brand I could get a hold of. I tracked the issue down to antiperspirant so I tried to find deodorants that didnt have the antiperspirant and so many natural brands just suck. Native covers the smell, and you dont need so much? I never see residue and if I feel like there is a lot on I wipe off the excess. I've never had a single stain, and I wear my button up shirts a couple times between washes, but never anything with my day to day activities. Even with hard sweats Ive never had a smell other than the scent. I'm sold on it! Although now Ill also try duke cannon

[@scoopx88]

I have the same experience, Native is good stuff

[@Valandreas]

I agree with the antiperspirant deodorant application, it's a little rough. I also ordered the Sandalwood Natural One, hoping it works for me. :-) Great review!

[@BruceWayne-mb4hk]

What’s your opinion on Dr. Squatch? I just bought all the soaps and a few scents of deodorant. Their marketing campaign found its way on all my social media platforms.

[@The_Kavalier]

meh so far.

[@pattgsm]

Deodorant + AP has been a crap shoot for most guys because as teens we are trusting when parents gave us grocery/pharmacy (GP), store brands that we never outgrow, misplaced brand loyalty, or because of ad campaigns like Axe Body Spray used when they launched. - If you get rash or burns from deodorant stop using and switch to an AP. After understanding the difference btwn deodorant and AP, I wonder why anyone would use deodorant. Look up what we stink after sweating (it ain't all about what you eat). Finding a deodorant or AP that is both not harmful and actually works...the search continues

[@jedwardtong243]

You have to try Aesop deodorant! The scent lingers throughout the day and you can skip wearing fragrances.

[@alexbia5689]

You should try Schmidt’s sensitive skin formula they smell amazing all day long and no Bo in 24 hours warm it to your pits for few seconds and swipe 2 times thats all you need they work and i have tried manny different natural deodorants Schmidt’s works and smells the best.

[@tjs5770]

Have you tried Oars & Alps or Ursa Major?

[@steverocksyo]

One thing I notice, cheap laundry detergent exacerbates yellow pits. I swear by tide.

[@The_Kavalier]

That’s good to know! I use Method but that’s definitely a good investment

[@CalculatedMistakes]

I've used Duke Cannon soap and liked it. I've been using deodorant from Dollar Shave Club (Grounds keeper) and I like it. I'll give Dukes a try.

[@Sirbarry12]

What do think about right guard and (aos) art of sports deodorants

[@wavygoods877]

Have you tried cologne scented deodorants?

[@EvasionX2]

Arm and Hammer essentials is my go to

[@samuelbadillo86]

Degree is my go to for over 5 years

[@ryanborzouei4879]

Try arm & hammer essentials. No aluminum or parabens and works great.

[@vidster7]

I agree! The natural scent works for me i tried the others like old spice ,Dove ,rexona and more but i like my arm and hammer

[@flyguy22190]

Succintly, what's the problem with parabens and aluminum in deodorant?

[@jetlaggedchef6806]

Parabens are carcinogens, they cause cancer. Medical studies have shown that alzheimer's may be related to long term exposure to aluminum because Alzheimer's patience have extremely high levels of aluminum in the brain. Here's a link to a legit medical journal that talks about this: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21157018

[@steverocksyo]

What scents have you tried/liked?

[@davidlanders5369]

You think you could do a review on cuts clothing? Alpham keeps sponsoring them but I'd trust a review from you more.

[@chubbydawme]

Lume and Native work for me. Native has yogurt and it smells milky (not noticeable unless you actually put your nose right to your armpit)

[@taylorberryman5722]

Old Spice is paraben free. Most online sites rate it equally natural, healthy, and safe as Native or Duke Cannon.

[@brandonmoini7009]

The key to reduce sweat and odor is trim your armpit hair. Major Key!

[@kirkus6309]

So it begins

[@antuanmetz4759]

Switching from aluminum to all natural deo u will sweat and be smelly for a couple days im a bravo sierra user but the transition wasn't that bad

[@timshull59]

You get 6 months out of 1 deodorant? I get maybe 3 weeks

[@evankass548]

I’ve had my native for almost 8 months now with daily wear. I apply 5 swipes in the morning and might.

[@ascott2168]

Well, since everyone is at home these days, this a good time to see what deodorant works best when it’s time to get back to being around 1,001 ppl everyday !

[@saltedllama2759]

If the politicians have their way, we will never get back to life "as normal". The lockdowns are too good for their brand because it creates a dependency state, while they radically shift the education programs to teach children that America is bad and this is how life is supposed to be.

[@davethebarber62920]

Jack Black Pit Boss works well for me, but it is expensive.

[@williammack5274]

This is so helpful!

[@bryman31]

whats the purpose of aluminum in the deodorant?

[@TraumaER]

bryman31 deodorize.