DIZI (Chinese Flute) VS BANSURI (Indian Flute) [with Eng Subtitle]

[@LensaAF]

Hi everyone. Just to avoid any confusions. Both of the flutes that i used in this video are modern kind which are not from traditional flute makers. Thus, there are distinct difference in its exterior looks. I am also using a normal tape on the dizi rather than the traditional membrane. What i was discussing in this video are some distinct features of the flutes and its playing style. Hope this clears some negative thoughts. Thank you for watching.

[@chenqings_fan]

The "bansuri" you showed in this video is actually a venu Bansuri originates from the northern part of India, has seven holes (including the blowing hole), and is used in Hindustani music, While venu originates from the southern part of India, has nine holes, and is used in Carnatic Music. I hope you mention this either in the description or the comments to prevent any confusion:)

[@azharzakaria7594]

Pada pandangan saya antara perbezaan seruling dizi dan bansuri adalah jenis saiz diameter buluh (hujung & pangkal yang berlainan) dan juga ketebalan dinding buluh tersebut sebab ianya bergantung pada tanaman semulajadi di setiap tanah negara masing-masing. Begitu juga dengan jenis-jenis buluh seruling melayu dan Indonesia, Buluh Indonesia kebanyakan tebal2 belaka seperti seruling dizi (3mm-5mm). Manakala untuk seruling Bansuri dan Melayu dinding buluh itu tipis2 sahaja (1.8mm-3.5mm) yang saya pernah jumpalah. Untuk buluh lokal Malaysia ada juga yang tebal macam dizi tapi tak banyak. Ok so untuk video diatas tu kenapa saiz lubang jari dan jaraknya berlainan disebabkan bergantung pada spek buluh itu untuk menentukan key apa yang sesuai untuk dibuat, Itupun bergantung pada formula orang yang buat seruling tu. Macam Bansuri tu kenapa lubang jari dia ada yang besar dan ada yang kecil? Sebabnya adalah semasa melakukan proses tuning dan sounds pembuat seruling itu menebuk sehinggalah dapat ketepatan note setiap key tersebut. So jangan terasa peliklah eah. Hahaha, dan begitu juga dengan seruling lain. Ok kalau Bansuri atau Melayu bila kita tiup tu terasa ringan dan senang nak dapatkan bunyi, dan dapat mengeluarkan tone yang terang disebabkan buluh itu tipis. Untuk dizi pula buluhnya agak tebal dan terasa berat sedikit semasa meniup tetapi masih dapat tone yang terang atau jelas juga. Berkemungkinan besar fungsi lubang mokong dimo itu dibuat untuk mendapatkan sounds yang setanding dengan sound seruling yang tipis (agaknyalah). Kalau suling Indonesia pula sound dan tone dia agak gelap dan mendap sedikit sebab buluhnya tebal, tapi sound dia lebih kepada gema dan kenyaringan dia tidak terlalu tinggi dengan buluh yang tipis. So kesimpulannya sebagai flutish tak semestinya seruling yang kita beli itu sesuai dengan kita. Sebab setiap orang mempunyai cara, citarasa dan naluri yang berbeza-beza. So mana yang terbaik itulah untuk anda, Itu baru je saya cerita bab buluh belum lagi bab seruling yang ada lubang angin dengan tak ada lubang angin takut lagi panjang nanti karang. Hehe, maaf kalau agak panjang sebab niat dihati nak berkongsi ilmu sahaja tak ada niat nak tunjuk pandai. Kalau ada yang kurang atau salah tolong tunjukkan saya masih belajar. Salam dari flutemaker Johor, Seruling Buana Suara 🙏🙏🙏

[@anilthapa5631]

Good knowledge. Love from India.

[@wazirzin4481]

Additional note (according to what I've learnt): The special sound character for dizi actually came from the dimo, which is made of onion skin (correct me if I'm wrong). Here's the difference between seruling Melayu, bansuri & dizi by Orkestra Tradisional Malaysia (OTM). Start from 5:36. kzbin.info/www/bejne/j5O6k6ibpNahmtk

[@bernardosanchotena]

Gracias!! Thanks for share! You helped me to decide for a Bansouri..

[@hawk5889]

Sir..where we can buy bansuri ?

[@hakimmmohamad5185]

Assalamualaikum mau tanye sy mau onder buluj sahaje boleh ay ad di area KL pantai dalam

[@nasarquadri]

Thankyou sir! Your video helped me a lot in deciding what kind of flute I should go for. You described so calmly and in detail, that was 👍👍

[@whoops0]

That's not bansuri.... bansuri is hindustani(North Indian)flute style.... the thing you are using is a Venu....a carnatic(south indian) style flute

[@LensaAF]

Thank you for your inputs, and it made me search and found this on the net, "Venu is constructed with 8 playing holes and 1 blowing hole. Of these 8 playing holes, 7 are actually used for playing and the last finger hole is used in tuning. Bansuri uses 6 playing holes and 1 blowing hole." I guess mine is bansuri?

[@whoops0]

@@LensaAF ok brother. Then what about the last 2 holes. The bansuri my self and my teacher has 1 blowing hole and six playing hole and 1 for tuning. My brother who is a venu flute student said that the flute you are using is a venu flute coz it has 1 blowing hole and remaining it has 8 holes. Thank u brother. It was very good music though

[@whoops0]

@@LensaAF kzbin.info/www/bejne/nIKUqItorpx9qpI He is my teacher!

[@krishnanunni6098]

Last two holes are mainly used for ease transition between octaves in bansuri(also called as lower gandhar by some makers). In catnatic flute seventh hole will be used, here they are included only for the betterment of tone.

[@swargosarker]

@@LensaAF you are right

[@malvin946]

english sub titles please

[@LensaAF]

thanks, will try to include the sub.

[@vespasaatmatsuda4546]

Bang key untuk Newbie pilih yang man

[@LensaAF]

bagus untuk mula dengan key C

[@syukiratmojo940]

beli dimana ? berapa harganya

[@DeViLTh0rn]

Tinggikan aperture... mmg bokeh hilang, tapi kalau nak tunjuk benda macam tak sakit sangat..

[@borutoozora1352]

Kalo mau beli dizi dimana bang?

[@mememelayuboleh2618]

Seruling seruling buluh (ruas) yg dijual dekat shopee to seruling bansuri ka bang?

[@LensaAF]

Saya tak berapa pasti. Kalau murah, beli saja.

[@serulingmy9580]

itu dizi tuan. hee

[@srajan5286]

What don't u compare another indian classical flute venu having 8 holes

[@LensaAF]

yup, thinking of doing that. Just got my bansuri set from a friend. The one with 7 holes. Thanks for the suggestion.

[@Terlahir_ganteng.]

Dimana saya bisa membeli bansuri bang?

[@ashutoshsawant7587]

From flip kart or amazon

[@marcos1292]

its not Basuri , but yes its Indian , chill guys , idk what problem you southern guys have ,

[@Sakttii]

Susah bnget nyri suling india

[@dimassuling5643]

Ukuran tidak pengaruh bang

[@LensaAF]

Ini bilang apa nanya?

[@affanhamid7065]

Krakter klo dizi lbh middle

[@seoyaaelouy9389]

lebih enak bansuri

[@devinchan7531]

Bang ajar Boleh 🥳 Boleh bayar bang💁🏼‍♀️