Do Tibetans want Independence from CHINA? 藏族人想要独立吗？

A Han Chinese traveler met this Tibetan grandpa on her way to Lhasa, Tibet. She asked him some fairly sensitive questions regarding the Chinese government and Tibetan activists who support Tibetan independence. What would he say? Does he want Independence from China?
================================
Your support keeps this channel alive:
🌟 Patreon: / xinjiangalex
❤️ Wechat: prnt.sc/1aonadz
🔒 PayPal: www.paypal.com...
🌟 Buy me a coffee: www.buymeacoff...
================================
#china #tibet #tibetan

[@alexfromxinjiang]

Your support keeps this channel alive: 🌟 Patreon: www.patreon.com/xinjiangalex ❤ Wechat: prnt.sc/1aonadz 🔒 PayPal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/xinjiangalex 🌟 Buy me a coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/xinjiangalex

[@littlestone1541]

This guy grew up during the early years just after the Revolution. The incredible amount of change and positive progress he has seen in his life must be unimaginable to many people. Respect to him, old comrade!

[@wagonwheel6657]

based posadism pfp

[@harutosunaa3881]

Based comrade anarchist 💪 🚩

[@zappurple8201]

Ignorant old man.. probably fed my Chinese CCP

[@Tube4mj]

Thank you for sharing Alex, great video. Cheers from Australia.

[@Nk66222]

I didn't know a lot of this! Thanks for teaching!

[@aminitum]

Great video! Thanks for sharing!

[@jmjt3709]

Beautiful, insightful, honest, down-to-Earth man speaking the truth and from his heart.

[@palmpalm5131]

Alex, you are amazing. Thank you for another great video.

[@greenscenery1974]

Love China from Indian occupied Nagaland. Chinese are our ancient brothers 🇨🇳❤️

[@Shaiii444]

😹😹😹 very untrue

[@greenscenery1974]

@@Shaiii444 I am genetically east Asians. Nothing to do with Indian Invaders who try to dilute our genes. It's untrue for refugees like u who knows nothing about outside world.

[@asahiglass]

@@Shaiii444 ok slave owner

[@wise003090]

Nagaland independence

[@PEACEFUL502]

Seriously!? People Like you are nothing but traitors!

[@AnneliedeWet]

Thank you, excellent info as always!

[@姜依彼]

谢谢你做的这些发声视频！论证清晰，有理有据，当是吾辈楷模！请继续加油💪我们一直支持你，为中国正声，为人民抒情

[@premchopra6521]

your bloody china is a guest in tibet for some time one day the entire Chinese people will have to return from tibet. because Tibet is not for Chinese people at all, Tibet has never been part of bloody china but china was part of Tibet once this is the truth real 2:41

[@Psalm118.26]

Great video Alex. thanks for sharing.

[@alexfromxinjiang]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@maxdc988]

Tibetan activists want to rule over other Tibetans and their resources, and not wanting a better life for their fellow beings. In other words, power and money hungry drove their agenda.

[@loKaisa-og8yx]

Those "Tibetan activists" are just puppet, there are leashes on their neck and CIA controls the leash.

[@tenzinlhadon1884]

Wait what? Where did you get that information from? Ahhh of course China, so people started believing China now

[@Vladimir_Putin_2021]

The Han Chinese dominated CCP also have the hunger of Money and Power that's why they capture Tibet to get the control of large amount of frash water reserve and resources of Tibet to fullfill their Dream of becoming Superpower In Manufacturing....The Fresh Water is required to produce the SEMICONDUCTOR chips which are mostly produced china .....

[@saddamhussein_legend8343]

​@@tenzinlhadon1884bbc lying of gaza citizen death what will you say?

[@inesruirui5247]

sb@@tenzinlhadon1884

[@danieltam3923]

Should broadcast this video on the Western media channels !

[@theresaleung823]

It will never happen, doesn't fit the narrative!

[@BeanOnTheFlipside]

This is propaganda, china has been persecuting Tibetans for decades now.

[@danieltam3923]

@@BeanOnTheFlipside U have been lying and thieving for decades. Pls stop fabricating lies out of your *ss, it's not pleasing.

[@xwqi]

It doesn't conform to some western political values. You can see the author's other videos. This video is obviously restricted by Google. Its playback volume has been significantly reduced

[@theludvigmaxis1]

@@xwqi not it has low views because 99% of the population of the world have no interest in Tibet. It’s a tiny country, the average westerner has no opinion on Tibet or the CCP there.

[@kl9518]

Keep up the good work Alex. I have been to Lhasa and have seen new temples, shrines and Tibetan villages. The Chinese government has really looked after their culture.

[@dhasalha]

😢😢😢

[@miguellines5907]

@@dhasalha 🍌🐒🤭

[@letsexplore9633]

So Tibetans should be happy with new temples and shrines when photo of Dalai Lama is banned?

[@saddamhussein_legend8343]

​@@letsexplore9633why you dont say about the america indiana? You got blind by bbc?

[@hosz5499]

The guy is lucky, because he is a nobody. If he were born a serf master, he might be cursing like hell for the land lost.

[@CapSoo999]

There should be no serf system as well.

[@Simba47242]

I was born in Tibet and now me and lots of Tibetans exile in India 🇮🇳 other countries because in Tibet no religious freedom no human rights. we have no values in our own country because of China 🇨🇳

[@nepalirecaps]

i can verify that he's speaking from his heart. I've been to tibet as a migrant worker (in 2018) and because I am also a tibetan (nepalese tibetan), some kind tibetans allowed me to live in their homes. Even though our nationalities is different, there is a strong tibetan bond between us. I went here and there, met a few tibetans. I told them that I studied under a school run by the exiled tibetan government because i trusted them. They said they are happy living under the chinese, and that tibet is a part of china. They said only the richer households are still seeking independence. But they all wish the Dalai Lama to be in tibet. Also, not even the rich tibetans who want freedom recognize the exiled government (which wants to be indpendent from religion).

[@bryanping1329]

Thank you 👍❤️

[@MrKikiLV]

Great video. Not sure about the authentication of the man. However, I believed the development of Tibet under CCP era since 1949. People's life is getting way much better.

[@rongwu-sj9ws]

As a Chinese, this video brought me to tears watching it. Western media always preach hatred and say that the Uyghurs and Tibetans in China are bullied, but it's not true at all! We have always used our blood and sweat to help the people in the border areas. One of my elders worked as an obstetrician and gynecologist in Tibet in 1950 and saved countless mothers and children. Before liberation, the maternal mortality rate in Tibetan areas was 5,000/100,000 deaths!This old pastor made a good point that hearts are all connected and sincerity touches everyone.

[@mdl12321]

As a eastern european who saw several Tibetian made forbidden movies, read Dalailama's biography and I am aware of Tibetian buddhism and its meaning, I must agree, that China modernized the region a lot. Moved millions of Chinese people there, burned millions of Dalailama's photoes and arrested million's of those who do not see Chinese takeover as blessing. Some were shot, some were told not to go to their work again, some were beaten, some bullied. Those are facts. And now my opinion: I love chinese teas and tea culture. I love chinese cousine, I admire their hard work, but Tibet wise, I would much prefer to see well kept original look of the city of Lhasa and other Tibetian cities, without destroying and rebuilding it by its standard stuff. Why they did not build another city right next to original one? Because chinese did not want to just modernize, they wanted to eat it and chew it and keep it as attraction. Remember Mao's saying that religion is poison? He neutralised it. From this point of view it is a tragedy. But I need to give China a credit for allowing the religion to go on. But I do not applaude chinese government for denying leaders of these religions. It was a hostile takeover, not just wish for enhancement. Yes, Tibetian lives enhanced, but at what cost? In my opinion chinese want them to function (in a harmless and controlled way) but without any power. Also, new Tibetian generation is completely disattached from old ways, so basically what Chinese did to Tibet is killing its history. That is my point of view. In few years, there will be modern cities in Tibet with sightseeings made for chinese tourists that are dead from cultural, religious and historical point of view. My opinion is that China and chinese people deserve true variety. They deserve to go to places where culture is different within China. Tibetians are not the only subjects of cultural genocide. If you normalize everything, you will end up with modern and prosperous uniformity. I would have done it better. If I was Mao, I would made Tibet crown jewel on Chinese crown. He was too hasty.

[@TeterPiago123]

@@mdl12321 west after the decolonization period and after the whole political correction trend of cultural protection and representation started became really keen on the idea that all culture is best when they are kept clean and away from the profanity of the larger so called modern society. I think that great, the effort to keep the world diverse after realizing how we raped the whole world with colonialism. But looking at cultures now doesn't all traditional cultures more or less becomes a spectacle any way with exposure to the internet. Also you have to look at the top priority of their country at the time, it was to strengthen the country because the whole 100 years of being bullied by basically everyone, so stability the most important thing. And I would think the fedalism wasn't very good for that, and would be very nice for most people if you had girls raised to be made into human-skin drums would it? Compare the minority culture to the main stream han culture, the han culture would be the one to suffer more losses, like traditional medicines. If you visit the place you definitely won't say they are culturally dead.

[@user-pz3to6ck1o]

@@mdl12321 Tibetans have the right to choose their own life and live a modern life. Rather than preserving the so-called "traditional life" for display like animals in a zoo for some explorers with a colonial mentality.

[@draekalloy3673]

​@@mdl12321Did you watch the video?

[@mdl12321]

@@draekalloy3673Of course I did watch the video. I am not expert in the topic. I may exagarate a bit, but I do that only in a name of some kind if respect for those I secretly love and admire. I would give the tibetian youngsters that later grew to wise and silent older men a credit. I would give them opportunity to save what can be saved. Is it a fools hope? Maybe. People are not always wise and soon you discover that money is all that matters for having good life. I am a romantic soul that needs to live practical life. Some good intentions also may turn into pointless and bloody revolutions and where is is justice in that? I would start with demolitions in old Lhasa city. Demolitions of shops and residences. I would say: look brothers, rhis is yours. We are truly sorry we took it from you. Here you go. Here you have money but only for stones and water, not for plastic and televisions. The longer you wait, the less people will understand what to do with it. It is enough to wait for one whole generation and no Tibetian will even understand what to rebuild and how it should work. That happenned already. So all you can do now is back off from directing them, do the demolitions and give give to them everything while you can, if you do not want dead Tibet. Time is ticking. Tick tock.

[@gabrielcaian2394]

Greetings from Brazil, comrade! 🇧🇷🤝🇨🇳

[@eprohoda]

hello,Alex! this is great vlog.

[@alexfromxinjiang]

Hey, thanks!

[@GuyWhoLikesTheSnarkies1435]

@@alexfromxinjiang Didn't mean to be too braggy about it, but did you notice some of our replies are getting hidden, that they're only become visible if you sort the comment section by "latest" instead of "top"?

[@alexfromxinjiang]

@@GuyWhoLikesTheSnarkies1435 It happens to my channel all the time

[@welcome1891]

Yes we need freedom

[@mauriciolizarbe4835]

And Xinjiang too

[@hongqingxiang3374]

Thank you🙏👍🙏

[@allenwong2219]

Exile Tibetans are regretting they left their birth place and all the benefits provided by CPC. Why don't western media interview these exiles and show us what their lives are like? Too embarrassed and against their narrative I guess.

[@pbworld7858]

I bet a lot of them are living in dire poverty in India. Also, just look at those BNO passport holders who fled HK to say, UK? I wonder what sort of jobs they have now?

[@xwqi]

那些流亡英国的香港人，听说要被遣返出去了。工作？英国人自己都在抗议

[@cadhlaohanlon4443]

The elites had to run since the serfdom was broken, and the slaves were give the rights to run Tibet.

[@letsexplore9633]

@@pbworld7858 Tibetans kids inside Tibet under CCP are begging on the streets.They are supposed to be at school.

[@ivanzhang7314]

@@jakejake8189 They are slave owners. In any culture, there is no class of slave owners would treat slaves well. In Tibetan Buddhism, had many barbaric and bloody rituals full of killing. Then I think you should understand.

[@truthteller6182]

Just like British consolidated many princely states and created modern India. Tibet was the part of China since yuan dynasty.

[@all_time_elevated]

You lack knowledge, it is very important to increase your knowledge

[@nathan9523]

What is the Yuan dynasty? It's Mongolian empire not China, Tibet was never a part of China

[@YuyingPeng-g4r]

你根本不懂蒙古帝国，蒙古帝国有很多势力和部落，元朝是其中的一个分支，他全民改学汉语，继承了中国的国号和皇帝​@@nathan9523

[@frankh.5378]

They speak to han ppl in Tibet not Tibetan.

[@chengsweelim2765]

Thanks for sharing the truth

[@gabrielruiz512]

0:35 "I know how was life under kuomintang" Bro, This is a clearly obvious lie, with the revolution of 1911 Tibet together with Mongolia obtained their Independence from the Qing Dynasty, the Republic of China never ruled Tibet, it was only annexed to China in 1950 by the forces of Mao Zedong. So how this old man can talk about what it was like to administer a political party to a country where he did not even live?

[@alexfromxinjiang]

Do you know there are Tibetans who live in west part of Sichuan province which used to be the Xikang province of Republic of China? He is coincidentally one of them. You are going to come across Tibetan people not only in Tibet but also in Sichuan, Yunnan, Gansu and Qinghai provinces.

[@DucaTech]

@@alexfromxinjiang These idiots are narrow minded and think Tibetans only live in Tibet, as if Mexicans only live in Mexico and don't go across border into the US.

[@爸爸-g2q6t]

哈哈哈，你就像一个小丑，不懂就要多学，解放前的西藏，和国民党统治时期的西藏疆域是不同的

[@davepsk7334]

But the naysayers say this is propaganda!! And you work for the CPC! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Oh! Sorry they don't say CPC they say CCP! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@alexfromxinjiang]

🤣

[@货拉拉不拉布拉多]

还有新疆，我经常去新疆滑雪，大部分新疆人都是很喜欢ccp的，和西方媒体宣传的根本不一样。 也是这样的亲身经历让我明白了西方媒体的虚伪，一切东西沾了政治就变得丑陋不堪

[@Ru-yl1cv]

一些新疆人家里甚至会挂毛主席的画像，还有习主席还有之前一些领导人的，我刚刚在其他外国人去新疆西藏旅行vlog 里面看到的😂

[@货拉拉不拉布拉多]

很多藏民和维族人是真心拥护ccp的，特别是了解以前西藏农奴制度的老人@@Ru-yl1cv

[@saddamhussein_legend8343]

西方媒体只会报道以色列的状况

[@johhw_6432]

人民为什么要憎恨一个这样的政府，哪怕翻山越岭也要为一小部分人建设桥梁和铁路，让那里的人们有更多选择。

[@manizare7068]

Alex you are amazing keep up the hard work. Don't pay attention to some ignorant fools hating you and calling you wumao or whatever. Your channel is great. Your videos are great. You and china are great 👍. Support from I.R.I 🇮🇷🇨🇳

[@beingastudents]

If you put a bird into a cage and give it all kind of facilities it doesn't mean that it's free. Organise a referendum on Freedom of Tibet. The truth will come out that what Tibetans want.

[@CHENGQILIU-zt9zh]

我可以明确的告诉你，如果进行公投，西藏独立也不会通过。人们会投反对票。

[@白天月亮]

请你想象一下子这个笼子有多大，960平方公里和14亿人口。所以这还是一个笼子吗？更何况从来没有人阻止他们出国。或者你的意思是生活在地球的我们都只是笼中鸟。😂

[@c雨颖]

Tibetans' lives are all about voting

[@faithfulshadow]

True. As Tibetan. We want Freedom. And also feel pity to Chinese too. They too need freedom from their government. If every word you say can be used against you. Only rainbow will come out “praise”.

[@faithfulshadow]

⁠​⁠@@白天月亮 people has to risk life to escape from Tibet. Are you living in bubble? If you are not Tibetan. It’s easy to comment like no one has stop them from leaving abroad.

[@leiuwu3965]

so laowhy86 mentioned you in his latest video, just letting u know

[@littlestone1541]

Laowhy86, that anticommunist counter-revolutionary CIA op! I sometimes flag his vids for racism and/or disinformation. I know I'm probably not making much difference on my own, and anyway he's obviously protected by powerful right-wing interests on KZbin. But hey, it feels good. So I'm not going to stop doing it. 👹

[@zack2804]

Ah yes, the same dude who keeps posting a video saying China will “collapse” tomorrow (for the past 5 years) just for extra clicks & views 😂

[@DucaTech]

Loser86 has no skills, except for lying. He should be labelled Liar86.

[@jayarajmaduturi3514]

​@@zack2804atleast we know the truth behind china

[@zack2804]

@@jayarajmaduturi3514 The truth? Let me tell you the truth. Laowhy86 once dug up a body on the beach in Taiwan and recorded it for views, while yelling at his wife to be quiet. When his daughter was born, he stated that she looked “too Asian”. You would need an IQ of 5 to believe anything he says.

[@maniaouri2146]

Thanks Alex , we need more videos like this with ordinary people who tell the truth, because the western media lies never stop

[@troenkelha6854]

He talked like that because he was afraid of chinese government.. hahahhaha..

[@saddamhussein_legend8343]

​@troenkelha6854 you talked that because you scared of america government haha

[@maniaouri2146]

@@troenkelha6854 most people who talk such garbage, don't even know how to find China in a map

[@faithfulshadow]

If every word can be used against you… only praise will come out. 😅

[@clinttroy6066]

funny how ccp propaganda works 😂 even elementary would not believe it hahaha

[@rodrigoh1025]

West npc

[@clinttroy6066]

@@rodrigoh1025 lol actual ccp bot

[@RedBird7]

Wow a weatrn npc

[@m.45]

Funny how American propaganda works 😂 they can brainwash people around the world into hating China.

[@indexruning]

You are loser, and loser is not right to talk about dominance😂😂. Now, China is stronger than India😂

[@ericchinier8722]

非常好的视频，充满了真实和尊重

[@Tenzin-jj]

Seems like granpa social credit score over the cloud.

[@sandeepghale5895]

♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳

[@hardikgupta5730]

Fake narrative 😂😂

[@TRST-h5u]

Dalai want to be the Pope of eastern Asia, with the regime of Tibet as his Papal States.

[@aray1312]

It shows how little you respect Tibetans

[@TRST-h5u]

@@aray1312 How much do you know about the history of Tibet I wonder. The Tibetan Buddhism used to have a position just like the state religion of Mongol Empire, and Dalai is the head of which, they always want to keep that superiority. When it comes to the Qing Dynasty, although the emperor still want to use the Tibetan Buddhism as a tool of ruling, he can`t quite tolerate their arrogant opinion that the Dalai should at least have equal status with the emperor, if not over him. Dalai refused to kneel in front of the emperor and hint that the emperor should salute to him instead. Half century ago Dalai visited Mongolia, at the beginning he is very welcomed, but as the Mongolian religious leaders found him more prestigious than themselves, they snubbed him and drove him away, since then Dalai determined to let tibet stand alone. Watching the speeches of Dalai you`ll easily find out his sense of superiority base on a childish pre-modern opinion he tried to conceal.

[@aray1312]

@user-tr2uj9sy6v If Tibetans have any religious disputes, it is their personal problem. They can solve their problems. But I know the history of how China occupied Tibet. China is so greedy that they try to take over even a tiny non-threatening country like Bhutan. Such a shame

[@aray1312]

@@TRST-h5u If Tibetans have any religious disputes, it is their personal problem. They can solve their problems. But I know the history of how China occupied Tibet. China is so greedy that they try to take over even a small non-threatening country like Bhutan

[@CapSoo999]

@@TRST-h5utrue…Dalai Lama is a very ignorant person who always wants to be the emperor of Tibet.

[@ChihHaoChung]

🎉🎉🎉🎉，藏人是懂得 感恩的。

[@Itamaru]

Wow so many tibet wanabe and i can also probably identified as tibetan and shit on china because 'trust me bro'

[@samchen271]

多求得很😂😂😂，成都一天打来回😊😊😊！耿直大爷😂😂😂

[@letsexplore9633]

CCP propaganda.

[@exo-l4742]

it’s sad that you label everything you disagree with as propaganda. if you do this, it will make you much more close minded. much of what he is saying is true. china’s government has worked hard in recent years to reduce poverty. we should listen to this man who knows more than most people do about this topic.

[@letsexplore9633]

@@exo-l4742 I am Tibetan.I know it well. I know what my parents and fellow Tibetans have been through.Freedom is imp not infrastructure.. Tibetan never died without food.

[@cloudwithwind574]

@@letsexplore9633 bullshit

[@herrwolf5184]

@@letsexplore9633 Free China from Tibet!

[@jinpawangmo1694]

@@cloudwithwind574 get educated

[@cabasadefogo9533]

Wise man!

[@guajiraguantanamera]

好! 没有共产党就没有新中国 我爷爷奶奶都80多了，从小就听他们说，那时候没有吃的也没有希望，直到共产党和新中国才有希望，才有吃的 60年代的饥荒是有，但那是最后一次的饥荒啊，以前在中国每2-3年都有饥荒的

[@Khftg]

麻雀是害鸟 👏👏👏

[@gratefuldeadly7899]

Tibet is better off being part of India. UK tried to annex it into India failed. India would spread democracy protect their religion and teach them Hindi language ❤❤

[@YJ-s7o]

是谁创造了印度这个国家，是上帝嘛

[@berryyang3610]

他敢说吗???

[@wise003090]

Thank you 👍 make more videos. Most videos regarding Tibet are from Indian side. Let the Indian Tibetans compare which side is better.

[@alexfromxinjiang]

Will do!

[@Redmi-xu1yo]

Indian are famous in pariah everywhere 😁 even Indian Tibet and Chinese at northeast were discrimination happened suffering

[@harekrishna3394]

Only one king story use all time and man who has internal peace dont want han in Lhasa

[@AdilAdil-vf5iq]

Tibet is a part of china now and some tibetan are happy but some of them are left Tibet at the time of war they want tibet should free china gov should take them back in Tibet

[@mauriciolizarbe4835]

Until Tibetans has enough and protests for demand independence from china

[@c雨颖]

They abandoned China, it was their own choice, and now they have no right to choose

[@faithfulshadow]

Government should Give land back to Tibetan. Mamma didn’t taught manners? Don’t take things that is not yours.

[@miguellines5907]

Not only lives has changed to much better but now they have football club and other sports club in Tibet. Many Chinese football fans even said the Chinese football association should call more tibetans because of their stamina which used to living in high altitude soil. And i also heard that the Chinese government is also planning to build a football stadium in there as well so next time when any visiting team playing any qualifier against China and played in tibet, it will be affect badly on away team physicality. "Reminded by Bolivia as the much scared places for world cup qualification in latin america".

[@edwinsiu5205]

Not only Bolivia. Peru and Ecuador live that kind of atitude.

[@miguellines5907]

@@edwinsiu5205 But Bolivia is much higher and less oxigen for athletes who are not used to as similar in most Tibet. 3000 meter is the limit altitude for athletes and most of Bolivia were morethan 3500 meter while most of Tibet were morethan 3000 meter.

[@jinpawangmo1694]

We don’t need football Stadium in Tibet, we want our freedom.

[@miguellines5907]

@@jinpawangmo1694 They already have their freedom and you don't need to be jealous because of living in underdevelop village. Wait a minute, just now i saw a Tibetan guy riding a Landrover car passing in front of me. Wow.. what a great lives those Tibetan is currently having.. can't said the same happening with the underdevelop villager.

[@jinpawangmo1694]

@@miguellines5907 🤣😂 must be a duplicate one. You guys are good at that 😝. But I am actually happy for my Tibetan brother. And sorry to break your bubbles, but freedom means to have the right to practice one’s own religion and have human rights. They are not even allowed to keep His Holiness the Dalaï Lama’s portrait . And here you are talking about freedom. Is this what a freedom looks like to you???

[@利贺田-z4t]

加油❤

[@cesarn5784]

Looks like something has been clipped from the end of this video?

[@tenzinlhadon1884]

But do we have the right to study our own language? No. Do we have the right to chant our precious Dalai Lama’s name? No. Do we have the right to learn about our own Tibetan history? No. Do we have the right to call our families living outside of Tibet? No. Do we have the freedom of speech? No. Do we have the right to travel around freely? No. Do we have the right to keep our country flag? No. Do we have the right to talk about politics? No. Do we the right to just keep a picture of Dalai Lama or a freedom fighter? No. Do we have the access to the outside world’s news? No. Do we have the right to learn about our culture? No. We might have cars, but can never travel without there permission, we might have TV but we only watch what they want us to see, in Tibet bars and clubs are free of cause and can drink all night, they want us, young Tibetans to think less about our freedom and our rights, when you visit Tibet, you can see only few speaks in Tibetan, most of them speaks Chinese, cause they force little kids to speak in Chinese, my little nephew, he speaks in Tibetan with all of us until he went to school and his Chinese teacher force him to speak in Chinese, I didn’t realise how we were suppressed under Chinese until I escaped to India, I learned how to read, wright in Tibetan, I learned about our history, culture and i can proudly carry Tibetan flag, and I get access to the news around the world, no one forcing me to learn Chinese, I can speak about how I feel. That’s freedom! If I were in Tibet now, I surely would be arrested after writing this comment, my grandma once visit India I remember that very clearly and when she came back, around 11pm Chinese officers were outside our door, they claim that they saw our grandma lining up in a temple in bhodgaya which is in India, so they took her, it was in January, they didn’t even let her wear her coat, she was in prison for 6 months! I would rather have freedom and peace then cars and access to those facilities

[@user-pz3to6ck1o]

Even the largest city, Lhasa, is predominantly Tibetan-speaking. You can see from other KZbins that Tibetan signs are everywhere on the streets. I saw many specialized temples, Buddhist schools, and Tibetan language schools in Tibet. The students there do not study Chinese, mathematics, or physics, but only Buddhist scriptures. Not only is Tibet not oppressed, it even enjoys privileges because of its status as a minority. I have seen Tibetans collecting tolls arbitrarily but the police would not stop them, and some rapists had their punishment reduced because Tibetans have different views on sex.

[@tenzinlhadon1884]

@@user-pz3to6ck1o I’m a Tibetan, I was born in Tibet, I’ve seen the brutal act against us, it’s really hard for us to show the proves of what they are doing to us as everything is in there control, what you see is just a show, if we don’t act like we are happy and living our best lives in Tibet, we are done!! If you ever get a chance to travel to Tibet as a tourist, you won’t get to roam wherever you want to, only the places you are allowed to, and also wherever you go they will keep track of you and you might not notice it but they will know everything you are doing, I haven’t seen my mom for so many years, she is in Tibet now, and I won’t get the permission or the visa to visit there, my own land. Thousands of Tibetan children were sent to China last year, separated from there family, just so to give those young souls the mentality of the dictatorship, they were taught Chinese, and the discrimination they face in the schools in China are really heart breaking, just a few weeks ago, a young college girl in Lhasa was arrested by the Chinese officers, they tortured her and now she is no more, the family can not do anything, they asked for the body, but they refused to give them that, and the only reason was she taught Tibetan language to the young children, every time it breaks my heart that Tibetans in Tibet are suffering, but can not show how wounded they are, and it is very hard for the Tibetan in exile to show the world what we have and are going through

[@MaxBerry-j6d]

@@tenzinlhadon1884 ..Stop lying. You are another C1A sh!ll. I have been to T!bet and did NOT see any suffering, but only saw pe0ple enjoying safe and happy lives. Your wes.ter.n pr0ppaagganndaa is getting old and tiresome.

[@nepalirecaps]

I am from a tibetan village in Nepal, close to the chinese border. My mother tongue is Tibetan. Do we have the right to study my own language (tibetan)? Yes Do we have the right to lean about tibetan history? Yes Do we have the right to call our families no matter where they are? Yes Do we have the right to travel around freely? Yes Do we have the right to keep a picture of the Dalai Lama? Yes Do we have access to the world news? Yes Do we have the right to preserve our culture? Yes Purang, a tibetan city close by, is under the chinese occupation. I would readily give up all of these rights if my people can live as prosperously as the tibetans in purang. It's very patriotic of you to say you would have freedom and peace than cars and roads. Go live in the mountains and raise a bunch of yaks. You'll forget your religion if a man with cars living in America wants to marry you

[@MaxBerry-j6d]

@@tenzinlhadon1884

[@premchopra6521]

tibetan always want to free Tibet not only u-tsang tibetan but also kham and amdo tibetan too because Tibet has never been part of bloody china but china was part of Tibet once you can check the history 1:08

[@nepalirecaps]

I recommend u read Hasao Kimura's book. Just before the chinese took over, U-tsang tibetans were killing and r*ping people of Kham. When the chinese came, Kham people did nothing. In fact, they were happy to finally rid themsevels from U-tsang tibetans. When tibet was not under China, tibet was a part of poverty, filth, injustice, famine, and religious riots. All tibetans respect the Dalai Lama, including myself. But a Chinese tibet is a strong tibet that can challenge india. The chinese tibet is a prosperous tibet. There are some rich tibetan households in tibet who want independence, and they send their kids to india to receive tibetan education and unify the exiled and chinese tibetans. That number is decreasing. In tibet, there is a slow stigma going on. It's not good to support for tibetan independence. Most poor tibetans want to live under the chinese rule.

[@premchopra6521]

@@nepalirecaps Abey jantha chikne kyun jhut bolte ho tum ? tujhe pata hai na pehle tere nepal ka koi maujud nahi tha phir bhi nepali khud ko Bahadur mante hai

[@nepalirecaps]

@@premchopra6521 actually, i'm a tibetan. you don't meet tibetans like me who are supportive of the one china policy because your theocracy threatens us. Whatever may be the case, I will not live under a theocratic government that still uses state oracles to decide national policies and refers to buddhist scriptures to decide foreign policies. Grow up tibetans. The world is 21st century.

[@MarttiSuomivuori]

Alex, you are great.

[@adenauerheesen2137]

Many Indians hope that Tibet will split from China and become a part of India, just like Sikkim

[@cocaineminor4420]

Lol most tibetian don't wanna be part of India 😂

[@rodrigoh1025]

@@cocaineminor4420Imagine become part of sh1t h0le india

[@yinyangdashi-in1kb]

This is a nightmare for Tibetans😂

[@aray1312]

India does not want Tibet to be a part of India. After India's independence in 1947, India considered Tibet as an independent country

[@c雨颖]

Indians live in dreams

[@berryyang3610]

哈哈， 他怕你告状所以跟你面前赞赞党，口是心非，他说的只有物资方面但他们追求的物质吗?

[@南歌i]

是是是，你都对，心理阴暗看什么都是阴暗

[@Philosofia54]

还好你润了！你开心就好

[@daniel-zx6sx]

小人嘴脸

[@nepalirecaps]

Well, that might be the case. I'm a Nepelase citizen but gentically and culturally a tibetan. I went there as a migrant worker, and people told me the same thing. I am certain they were being honest because I told them that I studied in a school run by the exiled government.

[@Tony63716]

An honest answer from Tibet on CCP GOVERNING SYSTEM.

[@aaronsutton9924]

The place must be nyinchi

[@yoyozent]

Arunachal people don’t want to join CCP! They love India! Arunachal is forever part of India!

[@silentwatcher1455]

Tibet doesn't want to become impoverished like India. They dont want to be part of India.

[@adenauerheesen2137]

Arunachal is a part of Tibet

[@RajeshSoni-k7d]

​​@@adenauerheesen2137read Mac Mohan Line Yuan Shikai Admit it go to India 😊😊😊

[@CapSoo999]

Tibet was part of China long long time ago, even Dalai Lama admits it. If you learn history, you will know there is not a country of Tibet at anytime in the history. Most people out there were serfs.

[@faithfulshadow]

What kind of weed you are taking? If you know. There is also written peace treaty between two nations in 821. the translation of the 'friendship' pillar: "Tibetans shall be happy in the land of Tibet, and Chinese in the land of China”. It’s written in both languages. History is something you need to learn. Half of world is part of Mongolia. So can you say most out tr are serfs or tribe. Every country is part of Mongolia. Your logic is not logging

[@CapSoo999]

@@faithfulshadow Nah. Is Tibet in the UN? Which countries have diplomatic relation with Tibet? Tibet is a region not country! They once had emperors but those emperors were under China’s emperors, so called sub-country. It’s like California and the US. They can self-govern themself but still under ancient china’s control.

[@CapSoo999]

@@faithfulshadow if you learn history you will know ancient china sent princesses to Tibet and Tibet had to accept the marriages. If Tibet was an independent country how can they not refuse the marriage? Their princes are ‘forced’ to marry china’s princesses. That shows Tibet was not an independent country but more of a state.

[@RajeshSoni-k7d]

It was Vassal State of Qing Dynasty Ut had its Own Autonomy and Own Rules China Control its Foreign Policy Army and Collected Tax Thatsit but PRC brutally Invaded it And Killed millions of Tibetans and Destroyed Monastery

[@tombahma]

i don't blame grandpa... the CCP is a special breed of evil and will not leave this man in peace if he said anything different.

[@YiGo-zn8ld]

If u know history of Tibet，u can say CCP is good😂except u are a crime

[@tombahma]

@@YiGo-zn8ld I KNOW THE HISTORY OF TIBET!!! What is the history of CCP.

[@m.45]

@@tombahmaTibet had always been with China! They only left when China was during chaos.

[@bullymaguire2074]

Just because alex loves chicken that doesn't mean every chinese people love chicken. Similarly just because this grandpa likes something that doesnt mean all grandpas agree to what he says. Nobody in this world is perfect. Trust me nobody. No matter how hard they try. Similarly cpc also makes mistakes. It's upto them whether they want to admit it( which they never do) or they wanna silence and defend it (always)

[@姜依彼]

but think... you can never make people have the same opinions . Everyone's value and experience are different.The same as the People in a country. And ofc one person may not represents all, but when it is picked randomly enough , or the scale of investigation large enough, let's make it a conclusion

[@PEACEFUL502]

Tibet is not China!

[@mottscottison6943]

It's not a matter of like or hate. The difference he is spitting facts.

[@bullymaguire2074]

@@mottscottison6943 what kind of facts? You want facts.. Mao Zedong murdered over 40 million chinese men in his regime. The censored propaganda of the cpc are facts right? Yes china is developed i admit because i am not like china who dont admit their negative sides but the problem is tibet issue is a sensitive topic in china. Honest people will be silenced. Why dont you post free tibet post on weibo? Do you have the guts to do it? Then post a screenshot. Get ready to be censored just like the urumqi fire in Xinjiang which alex from Xinjiang didn't cover. He is busy deleting comments

[@Tony63716]

No governing system is perfect. China learns in its progress and makes changes to suit its system. It does not need to be totally democratic. Do the people have freedom, yes they do.

[@ploykickshaw9842]

Why does Tibetan accent mandarin sounds like from Sichuan lol

[@aaronzhao1052]

藏族不仅仅在西藏，请了解一下川藏地区，还有青海等地区

[@nirajkafle9147]

Yes ..Big thank You To Xi & C.C.P

[@kaushalking3521]

Money/technology can do anything but that doesn't mean Conquer/attack other countries and interfere in their practice.. India don't share boundaries with china.. India shares boundaries with tibet and tibet is not a part of China.. Still CPC is claiming that even some of indian sides belongs to them.. China is the only country who have boundary issue with every surrounding countries just because they thinks everything belongs them

[@aaronzhao1052]

yes, 西藏不属于中国的一部分，就像新德里不属于印度

[@anzackhoo6765]

Those of you who only watch Western media and your country's random changes to Tibetan history have no idea of ​​the current situation in Tibet. Tibetans don’t think Tibet is an independent country. You are just making random guesses and being self-righteous.

[@anzackhoo6765]

Tibet wanted independence before because some people wanted to take advantage of the civil strife between the Kuomintang and the Communist Party to become independent, but the Tibetan people were not willing.

[@anzackhoo6765]

You people who are controlled by the West just want China to be divided. You just like to see China getting worse and worse. In fact, you guys say free Tibet free east turkestan online all day long just to make you feel good about yourself. But in reality it’s exactly the opposite of what you think

[@gaga-fp9hn]

What really funny is u can film any view which in favor of china govt but not the other view . 😂

[@user-pz3to6ck1o]

Welcome to Tibet and see the real facts.

[@翻墙者翻墙者]

What is really pitiful is you, you never believe in reality, because it is different from what you think in your heart. In fact, the real Tibet is that the Communist Party is good, and life is getting better every day! But it is different from what you think. It is you who cannot tolerate the truth told by the Tibetans. It is you who are pitiful but think you are free. Only when you have the opportunity to come to China will you realize how ridiculous your so-called democracy and freedom are. China's freedom Is it different from what you think in your heart, rather than imagining it every day?

[@equilibrum999]

Zhongguo, ye may have Zangguo under yr treshold, but dont let culture and language die.

[@explorenepal..whatyougoing3157]

I think they want freedom from pathetic so-called tibetan goverment in exile......!

[@mauriciolizarbe4835]

Long live Tibet and Xinjiang

[@jonnyboy8143]

Carefully, though her tibtan history of independence.😂

[@Timy639]

Tibetans are rich

[@2024-l9n]

没错。汉藏同源，基因验证了的

[@huanglinyang6751]

这靠近四川那边哦，哈哈

[@siouxiez1282]

Very good godly

[@letsexplore9633]

They will not dare to talk openly against CCP else they will be great trouble.

[@翻墙者翻墙者]

What is really pitiful is you, you never believe in reality, because it is different from what you think in your heart. In fact, the real Tibet is that the Communist Party is good, and life is getting better every day! But it is different from what you think. It is you who cannot tolerate the truth told by the Tibetans. It is you who are pitiful but think you are free. Only when you have the opportunity to come to China will you realize how ridiculous your so-called democracy and freedom are. China's freedom Is it different from what you think in your heart, rather than imagining it every day?

[@troenkelha6854]

The old man tells how power full tibet was. the chinese king gave his daughters becoz he was afraid of king Songtsen (Tibet) .. He gave princess to avoid the war between Tibet and China.. so Tibet was not part of chinese and will never be a part of china.. even u took our land .. u cant take our heart.. free Tibet.

[@nepalirecaps]

Well, check your facts. Both tibetan and chinese sources agree that Wencheng wasn't a daughter of the emperor. Also, china was racist at that time. They did not desire having tibet, but it was nice if tibetans didn't attack them, thus the arrangement.

[@onkycui]

西藏 内蒙 新疆 甘肃 ，物流还不是很通，我经常去的一个网购站，这四个地方基本都不发货。疫情以前，要发往新疆和西藏，还要另外收费。

[@mrstang2511]

但我最近才經淘寶買了新疆的杏乾等等。看著物流從比烏魯木齊更遠的地方發貨，經烏魯木齊到西安，然後發到廣東，再集運到香港。雖然千里迢迢，都到了我手中上。😁

[@onkycui]

@@mrstang2511 可能淘宝和快递公司签订的合同更高一级吧，我去那家网购站，在疫情期间，几乎就不送了

[@elinorhampton4780]

那是必然要加钱的，一个新疆的面积能顶七八个沿海省份的面积了，成本都受不了，新疆的商家都是跑内地建仓库发货的。

[@nepalirecaps]

Yeah, the roads in the mountains were built and maintained by Gods, so you don't have to pay anything extra.

[@ploykickshaw9842]

他71岁应该没过过KMT统治下的生活吧，那时候才几岁...应该是他爸妈过过

[@randomguy-rm1wf]

Omg so sad how you fool people

[@erdcr3101]

How much are you pad by ccp

[@DucaTech]

@@Neaktivni99999 You can see so many videos of foreigners visiting Xinjiang in the past 10 years - Germans, British, Americans, Dutch, and even Brazilians. I guess they're getting paid too, according to you.

[@mauriciolizarbe4835]

Free Tibet and free Xinjiang

[@Morrneyo]

Free Tibet!

[@Krios12]

I’m a Tibetan American born and raised in nyc ngl I would love Tibet to be free so I can finally see all my relatives(CCP never gave my family visas to visit)

[@HappyDiary123]

签证是目的国给的。。。

[@Krios12]

@@HappyDiary123 exactly china never gave me or my family visas to visit Tibet

[@HappyDiary123]

@@Krios12 去西藏不需要签证啊。😳

[@norincofan1949]

This is complete nonsense. You only need visa for China. Have you ever actually applied? Unless your family is banned from China for some reason, it's easy to get a visa. I have Tibetan friends that go back all the time.

[@sagitarrius7054]

@@Krios12 are u kidding? there are so many tourist in lhasa. or are u just some indian anti CCP at here?

[@뿅쓰-z7d]

Uy(high)gur means go(high)guryo고구려 which is component of korean history. Tibet have somthing with Japan as DNA

[@xinyiquan666]

STOP BS, GURYO is chinese name HIGH beatiful is name OF Gagouli , it has nothing to do with korean, korean are sanham , also tibetan has same DNA as chinese, korean has some japan DNA because renna japan prefecture, japan ruled south korea in AD300-AD500

[@뿅쓰-z7d]

@@xinyiquan666 not ruled, but same country as DNA, language before AD 700

[@xinyiquan666]

@@뿅쓰-z7d NO, corea was colny of japan , also there is no such thing as korean has same dna as japan, corean has 45% O3, which is chinese DNA

[@뿅쓰-z7d]

@@xinyiquan666 Japan encouraged korean to get married with japanese and give same benefits as japanese, this is not colonial but united

[@뿅쓰-z7d]

@@xinyiquan666 chinese's is more than 50 different tribes. I think O3 is small and original Han and Jin chinese immigrants ancestors's 2000 years ago Ok I will check it Have nice day

[@shepardosborne6394]

Whhhhhat? Ugggg…serious nonsense

[@pointkr734]

Fake Tibetan uncle

[@rodrigoh1025]

This uncle live better than you poor

[@nepalirecaps]

shut up tibetan-refugee bot.

[@翻墙者翻墙者]

Poor thing, life in Tibet is much better than you, but you think you are democratic and free. All this is fake. To comfort yourself, if you have the opportunity to come to China, you will feel that your speech is because of your ignorance and blind confidence. How ridiculous

[@rubiskim6311]

四川藏区吧？

[@alexfromxinjiang]

对

[@lusanmao6255]

他说在理塘县，可以一天来回成都。（其实做不到，哈哈。）

[@alexfromxinjiang]

@@lusanmao6255 他在康定

[@lusanmao6255]

@@alexfromxinjiang 原来如此，康定全程有高速。一天来回轻松加愉快。

[@sliver1903]

tibet is country Free tibet

[@好想发癫]

应该是四川那边的藏族

[@alexfromxinjiang]

是的

[@BeanOnTheFlipside]

Propaganda.

[@ctynwbraygalm]

Lol he is trolling hard!!😂

[@vidhansahu]

How many western propaganda channel does CCP has? I see so many these days, that's the advantage of CCP no need to worry about propaganda but spread propaganda everywhere and people believe this is real i pity on them

[@beproudasian8279]

Indian media is the one spewing anti China propaganda everyday. Also all the Western media. Just because you don't like the truth doesn't mean it's propaganda. There's an Indian couple KZbinr channel name "2.5 Travellers" so by your bias standard this is also a CPC propaganda channel then. So the average Chinese can't be allowed to show the real China? You're just another China hater with deep-seated prejudice.

[@ctynwbraygalm]

One YT channel that does not trash China and some people get triggered 😂

[@jzeng2022]

There's nothing wrong with propaganda, as long as it's telling the truth, isn't it? Go to Tibet and have a look. Those beautiful roads and neat villages, blue sky and white clouds and beautiful lakes will make you give up a lot of hatred and see if it is as advertised.

[@truenorthstrongandfree3699]

There are 60 million children of migrant workers in China living either on their own or with the sibling taking care of their younger brothers and sisters or they are with aged grandparents who no longer have the energy it takes to guide a young child. These children only get to see their parents seven days a year as they went to the big cities throughout China to try to EEK out a living. These children are poorly dressed for inclement weather, they do not maintain their cleanliness, they don’t brush their teeth, they don’t get nutritious food. To put this in perspective, the entire population of Canada is 37 million. If so much is one child is seen walking the streets dressed like any of these children or as dirty as these children, and they are automatically picked up and taken care of by child services right across Canada. With 60 million children in such poor conditions, China is raising a lost generation. Thanks to those people who are seen in these videos who give of themselves to these children. The mental anguish that these children suffer is apparent when you look into their eyes and listen to their voices. 有 6000 万农民工子女要么独自生活，大哥照顾弟弟妹妹，要么与年迈的祖父母住在一起，他们已经没有精力去抚养年幼的孩子了。 这些孩子一年只能见父母 7 天，因为他们去中国各地的大城市谋生。 这些孩子在恶劣的天气里穿着很差，他们不保持清洁，他们不刷牙，他们没有得到有营养的食物。 从这个角度来看，加拿大的总人口为 3700 万。 如果看到一个孩子穿得像这些孩子中 的任何一个或像这些孩子一样脏兮兮的走在街上，那么他们会自动被加拿大各地的儿童服务机构接走和照顾。 6000万儿童处于如此恶劣的条件下，中国正在抚养失去的一代。 感谢在这些视频中看到的那些为这些孩子献出自己的人。 当您注视他们的眼睛并聆听他们的声音时，这些孩子遭受的精神痛苦就显而易见了。 kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXicinuDmLF-aLOc

[@jzeng2022]

I don't rule out your statement, but it's not 60 million. It's hard to explain this data. Every country has its own problems, doesn't it?

[@midcent73b]

Evil CCP propaganda machine.

[@范晓勇]

yes i also to think

[@PEACEFUL502]

To be honest we want an Independent Tibet plus Tibet is not China it has never been China We have our Unique Culture and Traditions but unfortunately you guys are trying to destroy all that, Isn't it true that China is an Expansionist Nation!? Ask yourself and use your brain!

[@apotato3483]

Dalai Lama disagrees with you.

[@greenscenery1974]

By that logic, Nagaland Manipur Mizoram Kashmir all should be independent too. They are totally different from India. What to do expect from a refugee who is brainwashed and knows nothing about China but a puppet. Han, Tibetans, all Sino Tibetans and homogeneous. Unlike India. Level of HYPOCRISY

[@greenscenery1974]

Ua are nothing but a traitor to ua own people. HYPOCRITES

[@JS-ih7lu]

Tibetan culture isn’t unique to Tibet. Large populations of Tibetans have always lived in neighboring provinces of China, and other ethnic minorities have always co-existed in Tibet. Bet you didn’t even know that the grandpa from the video lives in neighboring Sichuan province. China has preserved the cultures of its ethnic minorities better than the same ethnic groups who have their own countries, just ask the Mongols, Uzbeks, Kazakhs and Tajiks (they now speak Russian while their relatives in China speak their original language). You also forgot to mention that before the CPC, your “unique culture and traditions” included slavery for 95% of Tibetans. Many Tibetans were forced to sleep outside with the animals they herded. You want Tibet to go back to a feudal theocracy and its people back to slavery? 🙄

[@cloudwithwind574]

bullshit

[@miliba]

CCP propaganda

[@Noah-od4my]

Rofl. You brainwashed Dumb ass frog in a well

[@leiuwu3965]

whats wrong with pro china content when theres wayy more anti china content

[@HKChineseCanadian]

It is called telling the truth. The west calls it propaganda because it can’t handle the truth.

[@littlestone1541]

You watch pro-capitalist and pro US propaganda everyday and don't even bat an eye. But one positive story about China or a single individual expressing a positive opinion about the CPC and you jump up and down pointing accusatory fingers like some kind of monkey with a bee up it's arse. lol. Sad.

[@BeanOnTheFlipside]

@@leiuwu3965 china is a brutal dictatorship I suggest you see independent journalists report on these situations