Doctor Who What if | What if Rose Stayed with the Doctor (PART ONE)

discord - / discord
#doctorwho #drwho #whatif
thumbnail - ‪@everythingdoctorwho‬
twitter - @nebula1918
discord ID - forcedalek

[@forcedalek]

PLEASE SUBSCRIBE Come back TOMORROW, for part two!

[@Dr_Procrastinator]

that cliff-hanger was not fair man... although i think i know who is with Jackie. wont say just in case I'm right nd spoil it for others

[@forcedalek]

@@Dr_Procrastinator haaaa, who do you think is with her?

[@Dr_Procrastinator]

@@forcedalek Roses Dad.

[@ryanlamb2636]

Nice video mate, can’t wait for part 2 I wonder if she stays for the regeneration into Matt smith, nice video I like your what if videos I can’t wait to see more what if videos mate.

[@Paul-vt6tx]

​@@forcedalekanother Doctor from her own universe. Suggestion possibly Peter Cushing as Doctor Who ?

[@Wanderer2331]

Even though I’m a fan of Clara, I’ve always wondered, What if Amy and Rory stuck around for the entirety of series 7, the 50th anniversary special, and witnessed 11 regenerating into 12?

[@forcedalek]

thats a cool idea, thanks!

[@samlopez5152]

Good video! Suggestion - What If… The Tenth Doctor bi-generated in ‘The Stolen Earth’. Ten forgets to use his hand, so Matt Smith pops out.

[@forcedalek]

This is one I’ll be doing!

[@tjf8567music]

We’ve got to have one part three when she’s with the 11th doctor and Amy Pond that would be a brilliant idea for part three if you ever were just doing part two

[@evangamer5752]

What if rusty the Dalek made his own race of daleks

[@forcedalek]

This would be interesting

[@James_skywalker]

I love your what ifs.

[@forcedalek]

Thanks, who do you think was with Jackie?

[@James_skywalker]

@@forcedalek Pete maybe or rickey and the rebels

[@James_skywalker]

@@forcedalek what time will the next episode come out

[@forcedalek]

@@James_skywalker out now!

[@FrostyScarf]

Suggestion - What if The Master regenerated in the last of the timelords?

[@forcedalek]

epic!!

[@thepandorica1660]

Can't wait to watch this later! Here's a suggestion I've got: What if Missy ended up standing with the Doctor? I know she chose to, but he never knew that since she went to stab himself. This'll be if she stays with the Doctor instead of going with her past self.

[@forcedalek]

love that suggestion!

[@reeceemms1643]

I didn't even get this video in my recommended I literally had to open your channel to see it. Also this one must be long if you had to do two parts.

[@forcedalek]

I felt this one would work better in two parts, as it feels cliff hanger worthy, also because part two will feel like a totally different story, so it made sense, but fear not the story continues tomorrow!

[@reeceemms1643]

@@forcedalek oh right ok

[@vinniequick]

I'ma predict The Valeyard (throwing it out there) The Master/Missy (trying here) Meta Crisis Doctor/Doctor from the future (never know that world's Doctor (Plausible) or one of your What If Doctor's this includes 10 in What If 9 Bigenerated (most likely) 9 in What if 9 Bigenerated (never know may be blipped just before death) 11 or Doctor Rose in What if 10 died in Midnight (unlikely but hey ho) or something completely new

[@forcedalek]

You'll seeeee

[@DarthDread-oh2ne]

Great job with the video. I gotta be honest; I ship the tenth doctor/Martha.

[@cameronjosephvideos5942]

Last of the Time Lords you skipped over a bit quickly. Frankly, I can't see Rose doing what Martha did in Last of the Time Lords. Martha shows far more independence than Rose. I think the only showing from Rose that has her showing that kind of independence is pulling everyone together in the Satan Pit. Rest of the time she's just following the Doctor's lead. Even the Bad Wolf thing seemed to be more out of her control. Martha on the other hand, managed to save her kidnappers car in Gridlock, figured out the location of the Dalekanium, devised a strategy to take out the pig slaves which worked wonders, and really kicked ass in the Family of Blood. Rose, is not going to handle it well at all.

[@terminatorplayz4614]

Here’s a what if I’ve wanted to see- what if the doctor faced the 456 from torchwood? I’ve always thought it would reveal such a dark part of the doctor, being faced with such a disgusting alien

[@Bobcat_guy]

I need morrreeeee. DAMNNNNNN CLIFFHANGERSSSS 😂 but good part 1 mate

[@forcedalek]

Tomorrowwwwww

[@MeidasWhovianAdvocate]

Suggestion: what if Captain Jack Harkness never met the doctor and Rose?

[@Jxbrenna225]

What if Captain Jack stayed with The Doctor and never Joined Torchwood?

[@MeidasWhovianAdvocate]

@@Jxbrenna225 interesting I wonder how different things would be

[@Jxbrenna225]

@@MeidasWhovianAdvocate id love to see a What if on this, as The Tenth Doctor Said, he deliberately left Jack behind as he somehow knew Jack was now Immortal and was essentially running away from Jack, with even the TARDIS trying shaking off Jack in Utopia.

[@forcedalek]

This is such a cool idea, and one I will make sure to bring forward on my plans@@Jxbrenna225

[@reeceemms1643]

@@forcedalek where do get your What if ideas? I know some come from us but what about the others. Also do you make a list of all these ideas?

[@cameronbaker97]

what if the 10th Doctor had actually Regenerated in The Stolen Earth/Journey's End? what if Missy had joined the 12th Doctor after stabbing her younger self in The Doctor Falls? what if Amy and Rory were not taken by the Weeping Angel at the end of Angels Take Manhattan?

[@forcedalek]

thanks!

[@mayanksingh9621]

Yeah finally a more than 1 part what if

[@forcedalek]

Who do you think is with Jackie?

[@Legendary3Dgamer]

1:07 ha copyright 😂

[@orent6143]

What if Mickey had joined the TARDIS in Series 1? What if Rose never joined the TARDIS after the events of Rose? What if Jack travelled with Martha during the Year That Never Was? What if The Master accepted the Doctor's offer to stay in the TARDIS with him at the end of Last of the Time Lords?

[@forcedalek]

Thank you for your suggestions!

[@vanimapermai]

I want to see this alternative version of the show so badly

[@forcedalek]

would be amazing!

[@dwf12gamez58]

4:50 rose is racist 😂

[@forcedalek]

Classic Rose Behavior

[@Ollie_1022.]

What if? The Doctor never lost his hand in the Christmas invasion

[@forcedalek]

ooh good one!

[@Commanderpioneer]

And then I was back with you with some anger the rest of the way

[@nani4249]

What if jack looked in the heart of the tardis (after his immortality)

[@forcedalek]

oooh cool idea!

[@nani4249]

@forcedalek it could have happened before the metacrisi doctor appeared, I mean they were in the tardis and the scenario they were in was so life and death that why not get the powers of the tardis, its only logical to do so.

[@Commanderpioneer]

I was with you until new earth

[@Commanderpioneer]

If he doesn’t see face of boe death then he would not have met the master

[@forcedalek]

he would@@Commanderpioneer

[@Dr_Procrastinator]

@@forcedalek yeah I agree the race if boe just prophesied the Doctor's death. So the doctor hasn't had the foreshadowing doesn't mean he won't meet the master.

[@thepandorica1660]

​@@Dr_Procrastinatorthat's true. I wonder what people will make of the name 'Yana' in this alternate timeline 😅

[@Dr_Procrastinator]

@@thepandorica1660 "yana who the what now"? Is what I imagine. Or just 10 say his signature "what" over and over again

[@mayanksingh9621]

When will you make what if the 11th doctor bi generated into 12th

[@forcedalek]

Don't have a specific date yet but I can confirm its in the works!

[@casparthomas4775]

My god this are amazing

[@forcedalek]

Thanks!