Does Israel Target Civilians in Gaza? | Unpacked

[@UNPACKED]

Following the outbreak of the war in Gaza, KZbin updated its community guidelines, and as a result, the previous version of this video was restricted soon after we released it. We decided to edit and upload a less graphic version in the hopes that an unrestricted video will be viewed and shared by the widest possible audience. Please continue to share your comments and thanks for your support!

[@ndadikpa]

I have heard so many views about israel , and yours is the most authentic and fact based. We pray for israel, Jerusalem, the Arabs and jews.

[@notofyourneed5728]

Jews are same way back then when Jesus was alive , they used to lie the way against him

[@chickensalad3535]

@@SerpentdemerWhat? They’re not animated.

[@nicbentulan]

1- Why does Israel have the right but strangely not the obligation to defend itself in that Israel defends Palestinian civilians (eg leaflets, aid, corridors, field hospitals) more than 19yo Jewish conscripts? 2- Why didn't you include the pinned comment in the description or the video? 3- Why are American Jews voting democrat? 4- Why shouldn't I focus on advocating more on feminism or mental health than on Israel if the majority of American Jews won't support republican?

[@nohisocitutampoc2789]

It's very interesting as usual but this chapter is repeated.

[@aarong9327]

Hamas has fired 19,000 rockets since Oct. 7. All aimed at civilian targets in Israel and most fired from civilian areas in Gaza. That's a double war crime for each rocket fired.

[@karinw3917]

In addition, about 10%-15% fell short inside Gaza itself caused casualties of Gazans by their own hands.

[@Aega1107]

@@karinw3917 yep. Remember one of the hospitals that got hit that Israel was blamed for within minutes? There’s clear video footage of it shooting out of a launch site in Palestine into the hospital parking lot 🤔

[@ovidiuabramovici138]

This happened for years and no one ever spoke about a war crime

[@nicholassmidsmid2808]

I was going to point out how wrong you are but there is no point talking to a true believer. Everything they do is in their mind perfect

[@abcdefg2120]

@@nicholassmidsmid2808You were going to point how wrong they were but then you realized they were saying documented and undeniable facts.

[@Lee-kg7ze]

There are over 50 Muslim countries and yet NONE of them will allow Palestinian refugees to enter - not after the last disaster.

[@peterstallo4387]

That's the hypocrisy of muslim.

[@Aega1107]

It’s a mix of Palestinians wreaking havoc in host countries in the past and trying to spread Islam. Look at the 2016 mass migration. A lot of the refugees don’t even want to go home “because they weren’t told it was temporary and were planning to bring their family to live in Europe as well”.

[@israelquintanilla8314]

They consider Palestinian a threat.

[@Lizzied1301]

They dont regard Palestinians as having a country or are a nation. They are basically nomads intermarrying. No one nation of people and have no home. Iran who are Shiat muslims are actually enemies of Sunni Muslims (Palestinians) but they are only using Hamas to achieve their goals. Jordan, Lebanon and Kuwait has had problems with them trying to overthrow their governments and all the other middle eastern countries are aware of this - so that is the reason they dont want Palestinians. Look at Egypt who has put up a higher wall across Gaza than Israel has. The propaganda and lies from Palestinians created lots of mistrust. The West has fallen for their lies and propaganda because they dont know the "real" history.

[@Aega1107]

@@Lee-kg7ze it’s a mix of Palestinians wreaking havoc in host countries in the past and the spread of Islam. Look at the mass migration of 2016. A majority of those “refugees” don’t even want to go back.

[@veekee75]

Israeli civilians are being targeted every day, so why is no one questioning that? Why the double standard?

[@shafsteryellow]

No.

[@juliannahikaru9912]

Because unlike Hamas, our government cares about us as civilians and we have 75 years worth of developments and technology that we developed to protect ourselves when there is war, for instance the iron dome, every house has a safe room, bunkers in every neighborhood etc.

[@shafsteryellow]

@@juliannahikaru9912 yawn the u.s provided that

[@POTATO-025]

​@@shafsteryellowif it makes you feel better 😂

[@user-my3wc7rs9y]

​@@shafsteryellowYour point being Israel doesn't protect its own population? Cough Cough Ĥªmªs does not allow Gªzªns to enter their safe tunnels.

[@Qeewee8500]

The saddest part is Israel has to justify its actions for fighting against pure evil

[@WalterSpilman]

Israel is the purest evil ever my dear.. Try harder. The poor little Jew victim narrative is game over in case you didn't noticed 😂

[@WalterSpilman]

@@MessianicChristianFollowship86 Go back to Poland 🇵🇱 is what you need

[@WalterSpilman]

@@MessianicChristianFollowship86 You need to go back to Poland 🇵🇱

[@RubenWithTheE]

Ah yes the pure evil of a families sheltering inside of schools

[@user-zg3nb1mk5b26]

A guy was caught stealing a bike in front of the owner of the bike, the owner of the bike sees a policeman and tells him, put handcuffs on him, he tried to steal my bike. Then the thief says, "He's lying, it's my bike, he tried to steal it from me. The policeman is confused, but what will the policeman do, he'll take them both to the interrogation with handcuffs and there they'll be interrogated. The parable is that the policeman is the confused world, and that's what the Arabs are doing, they are Hamas and some The residents of Gaza participated in the murder of 1400 Israelis, their plan is to mobilize public opinion so that Israel withdraws from Gaza, so they shout "genocide" and after all they themselves committed genocide in: 7/10, and so that no one will think what they did to the Israelis when they murdered 1400 Israelis A person including women and children, they murdered entire families, raped, cut off limbs and more.....then they shout, "genocide" if Israel wanted, then within 3 days there would not be a single resident living in Gaza. The Israel Defense Forces were fighting inside houses Guerrilla war tunnels, from house to house, just so as not to kill innocents, even though there is no house without weapons, all of them are partners with Hamas, ISIS, the new Nazis.

[@erikp4738]

Finally someone that use facts and not fakes, thank you. Israel has it right to defend themselves!

[@Lynn-i2w]

Israel is in decline.

[@humanfrommars882]

​@@Lynn-i2wno?

[@drdonna4915]

​@@Lynn-i2w Hardly. Israel came together.

[@Lynn-i2w]

@@drdonna4915 continue to BDS Israel.

[@Joel-s1c6d]

Israel isn’t defending itself it is slaughtering innocent. All for a land grab. They are celebrating a r*pist and have been using Palestinians as human shields tying them to the hoods of their cars. Some of the people calling out Israel on its war crimes are themselves Jewish.

[@Bea2u]

How do you destroy 350+ miles of underground tunnels (built by Hamas with money meant to help Gazans)? How do you destroy weapons and command centers in civilian areas? How do you avoid hurting civilians when the fighters fight among them?

[@XLTen-l4s]

What do you want?

[@srbflorin1804]

That is a good topic. Avoiding unnecesary damage. One way would be to not use things such as air support or artilery. To engage hamas only with armored infantry. But you see Israel is under US's fight model. (Dependcy of air support and highest tech since it's infantry drops like flies because it's not so professional as it believes itself to be..)

[@Brimfarm]

@@srbflorin1804That’s just not how modern warfare works mate, if you have the capability of air power you’re going to use it, just how the Arab coalition TRIED to use there’s against Israel last time, and lost miserably, charging a defensive position with hard and soft targets in todays tech is a fast way to lose your army, just look at Russia

[@fatchungus1473]

U do realize that trying to fight hamas with only ground troops will turn into vietnam 2? Its impossible to win against ppl thay built hundreds of tunnels around the whole city​@srbflorin1804

[@tylerjacobson8012]

@@srbflorin1804that would be far more deadly than aerial fighting lol. You fucking idiots don’t understand what war is. How it works. This is brutal tight quarters urban warfare. If a war was fought in any urban environment in the world this happens. People die in war. Innocents. Innocent Germans not aligned with Hitler died in Germany during carpet bombing runs. This is modern warfare. Hell it’s just warfare. Especially when you’re dealing with a terrorist organization that idolizes martyrdom who thinks civilians dying isn’t even a problem. You fucking idiot living in luxury.

[@MFPhoto1]

The correct question is: Does Hamas militarize the schools, hospitals, mosques, and civilian neighborhoods, thus using civilians as human shields? The answer is obviously yes.

[@xaviermontesdeoca2440]

Source: trust me bro

[@ivanj.conway9919]

@@xaviermontesdeoca2440 : Playing the hypocrite card again, as that is exactly, what your side does as well. You believe only one side and you get only, half the picture, ever. Sadly, that seems to be all you want, as well.

[@RedbadvanRijn-ft3vv]

@@xaviermontesdeoca2440 Hello Abdoooooooooooooooooool EU Atheist here. Lesson 1--- never thrust an muslim. Lesson 2--- never thrust an muslim Etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc Islam dies whitout lies

[@xaviermontesdeoca2440]

@@RedbadvanRijn-ft3vv every religion lies, and if you think the issue here is religion, you really aren't paying attention

[@mischamouse1502]

​@@xaviermontesdeoca2440you should lookup memri TV. They have video footage of leaders on arab television calling for martyrdom, palestinian television children's' programmes etc.

[@legoooo09]

Topic should be does Hamas & Hezbollah target Civilians? Ans - they only target civilians

[@YoniBaruch-y3m]

Eh not quite correct, on October 7 they did also attack military bases, and kidnap military personnel.

[@canus2154]

As an Israeli civilian I can confirm this

[@ArielsArtSpace]

@@canus2154 fr🙌

[@smokedgamesfor]

it's not true hamas does has killed more idf troops than civilians, israel has killed more civilians than hamas soldiers!

[@WartHawg8196]

@@canus2154i support you. Good luck

[@JungleJargon]

They attack a country and then complain about the response. Don’t attack the country and there will be no response. It’s not complicated.

[@floydwhatchacallit6823]

So, the US should retaliate for the attack on the USS Liberty.

[@triplex7144]

They've been firing rockets into Israel the last 20yrs I've been following this and literally they fire rockets and get return fire and post ohh the idf attacks us whilst still firing into Israel. I've never seen such a people who are so deceitful in my lifetime.

[@Rogueboss2budgetedition]

Civilians did not attack israel

[@JungleJargon]

@@Rogueboss2budgetedition The said civilians voted in the ones firing the missiles.

[@BalticNixe1234]

The elected government of the Gazans has declared war on Israel, so the Gazans as a population bear responsibility as in any other war. The civilian population is responsible for their elected government, if they do not agree with their government, they would try to overthrow it, something what we don't see. It can therefore be assumed that they approve of the behavior of their government.

[@MinasMelas]

The fact that islamic countries call out Israel for “crimes against humanity” is pretty hilarious.

[@roeital5504]

Those countries are full of men that see a 12 year old girl and see bride material, they have 0 human rights to talk

[@YoussefEissa-b2e]

not only them buddy you missed the rest of the world.

[@MinasMelas]

@@YoussefEissa-b2e You mean the countries with leftist governments that are being funded by Arab oil money? Yeah sure.

[@IntegrationChaos]

Finally someone who speaks against those terrorists , I am Ukrainian and I am so sick of comparison between us and Palestine , We are not the same.Hamas invaded Israel , russia invaded our country. Period.

[@tomer2144]

You are right. Russia commits horrible war crimes against the Ukrainian people and people around the world stay silent. These people follow trends and don't even try to learn what's happening worldwide. They support terror organizations that oppress citizens, kill gays and rape women and children while ignoring the atrocities committed by Russia, Iran, China, and those various terror organizations in Asia and the middle east.

[@YoussefEissa-b2e]

go read history books.

[@scificyber]

And the European Jewish Zionists have invaded Palestine, they continued to build illegal settlements in Palestine If u want to talk abt recently, how abt when the IDF started the Gaza war in late October 2012 killing 105 civilians and wounded 971?

[@thecowboy2541]

@@YoussefEissa-b2e what he said is true

[@genetbelay9929]

Thank you unpacked... Israel has the right to defend itself

[@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781]

But no right to commit atrocities

[@Joe-pc3hs]

​@@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781 But hamas does?

[@tallspicy]

Disproportional response and huge amounts civilian casualties are absolutely within the sphere of righteous criticism. Both are terrible.

[@Joe-pc3hs]

@@tallspicy So is pointing to inflated death tolls that even the UN had to admit to. But perhaps you can explain how hamas differentiates a civilian vs combatant or innocent vs culpable? Because the initial footage of the attack that precipitated this war showed hundreds of civilians following hamas to loot the homes of recently killed Israelis, in addition to taking live hostages on motor bikes. Apart from Al Jazeera journos being intrinsically linked to hamas figure heads, and aiding in the retention of hostages, where does the line for combatant end?

[@RedbadvanRijn-ft3vv]

@@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781 Islam did made themselve 6.5 billion enemies. The real question is now,,wil Islam survive all that anger???? I think not.

[@PoyongViana]

The IDF did not intentionally target civilians, but Hamas deliberately tied civilians around their waists and shared the consequences when Hamas was punished.

[@RandomFrenchmain]

Yes they said “go there it’s safe” Than they bombed there

[@tortoisewarrior4855]

Yeah sure bud, when they opened a refugee route to the South and fired missiles on civilians, or when they fired upon Palestinians demanding aid outside a UN truck. Were those Hamas Terrorists? I’m actually shocked how many of you are defending an ICC given arrest warrant for someone who is obviously a war criminal, Netanyahu.

[@YoussefEissa-b2e]

where did you get that from .

[@vikingwind25]

Simple question. Why doesn't Egypt accept Palestinians, their Muslim Brothern, into their country? Egypt has a huge wall to keep Palestinians out. I don't understand this situation...

[@Marcus-nn6js]

I think it's because they would risk Hamas entering Egypt if they let Gazans in.

[@ЯшаСагалович]

Because Egypt sees the threat of Hamas

[@updatemysettings5095]

Why dont they accept the israelis and get them out of palestine.

[@jollyroger7624]

I would guess that much of the Arab Islamic population of "Palestine" was ex Egypt, workers who went to Israel as Israelis built the country from virtually nothing. Most of the rest of the so called "Palestinians" would be terrorists from North Africa, Iran etc.

[@Roddyisntreal3437]

Same with (almost?) every other Muslim country they see Hamas as a threat

[@patriotsforisrael3610]

*The population of Jews, along with those murdered during the Holocaust:* Lithuania 150,000 murdered: 135,000 Estonia 5,000 murdered: 4,500 Latvia 95,000 murdered: 85,000 Poland 3,500,000 murdered: 3,000,000 Czechoslovakia 355,000 murdered: 300,000 Germany 210,000 murdered: 170,000 Greece 75,000 murdered: 60,000 Holland 150,000 murdered: 105,000 Yugoslavia 80,000 murdered: 55,000 Soviet Union 2,100,000 murdered: 1,400,000 (the territories occupied by the Nazis) Austria 60,000 murdered: 40,000 Romania 850,000 murdered :425,000 Hungary 404,000 murdered: 204,000 Belgium 90,000 murdered: 40,000 France 210,000 murdered: 90,000 Italy 57,000 murdered: 15,000 Bulgaria 50,000 murdered: 7,000 *Pre-war total about 8,546,000 Jews of which about 6,140,500 were murdered* Now, that’s a genocide!

[@grahamt5924]

That is horrible

[@Avihai_Levi]

not to mention the ethnical cleansing that happened to the jews who lived in the middle east and north africa. my grandparents are survivors of the Farhud, a pogrom that occured in Iraq in 1941. all the jews from these countries were robbed from their wealth ,property, and their dignity for no reason at all.

[@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla]

Add also beta isreal in Ethiopia

[@aneliyageorgieva5352]

You have a mistake. During the Second World War in Bulgaria no Jewish person with a Bulgarian citizenship was killed.

[@naelpontes8444]

Can you tell me your sources?

[@harmacist6623]

Everybody's dunking on Israel committing genocide when their enemies uses civilians as meat shields. Yet rarely, if anybody, ever talks about HOW can Israeli military destroy the enemy WITHOUT inflicting civilian casualties when their enemies are using civilians as meat shields.

[@muzicsplash]

When October 7th happened, I was naive to think that at least now the world will see what Israel is dealing with because Hamas were the ones who published videos of themselves. Yet, I underestimated the hatred and double standard people have and their stupidity. I am blown away by it

[@RobotNinja28]

people in the west will look at videos of Hamas literally butchering innocent people and say: "damn, this is fire" it's pure antisemitism

[@thedumbaviator5536]

Me too. People seem to ferget it happend? Whenever im in an argument, and i bring it up, it is igonered.

[@jessicarichter6436]

Same! Im English we grow up learning the horrors of the Holocaust genocide inflicted on the Jews in school. I never thought in my lifetime I’d see ignorant people calling for them to be killed & removed from their homeland again! It’s like they’ve learned nothing from history. But I know these evil terrorists will be defeated just like the Nazis were I just hope the remaining hostages are freed soon 🙏

[@RandomFrenchmain]

Not true Israel also killed some of their own some testimonies of troops participating said that they were instructed that if there were hostiles and civilians but was having some crossfire to eliminate all and also 1948 does that ring a bell ? Or how Israel was saying they were going to invade ?

[@alemarte5447]

Ain’t stupidity when is a War that’s going on for decades and started BECAUSE OF ISAREL (which repeat after me is a state colony implanted against the will of Palestinian arabs)

[@patriotsforisrael3610]

Over 1.2 billion pounds of food have been transferred to Gaza since the war began. - 791,521 tons - 41,897 trucks - Food: - 611,320 tons - 28,626 trucks - Water: - 44,975 tons - 2,245 trucks - Mixed: - 33,400 tons - 2,306 trucks - Shelter equipment: - 70,230 tons - 5,109 trucks - Medical supplies: - 25,571 tons - 2,464 trucks - Fuel: - 423 tanks - Cooking Gas: - 724 tanks - Jlots: - 433 trucks *The Palestinian Arabs are the only people on earth that start a war with a heinous massacre and then get more aid than all war zone afflicted people combined!*

[@rinskedevries3272]

Right!!!❤

[@djraleshio3278]

Slight correction for shelter equipment. Israel has purchased 100 tons of tents from China so your numbers are too low

[@5pAcEiNvAaDeR]

People who supported the n@z!s in the 40's also behaved like you now 🤮

[@lupen_rein]

To be fair though, the absolute numbers don't really tell a useful story, the only question is how many goods and how many calories reached the Gaza Strip per day and per person, so that Palestinian civilians were able to eat enough. In the first months, the absolute numbers were not enough, but since March, the provision of goods has risen enough to prevent a famine, and even if the rupture of the Rafah border by Egypt (not by Israel, by Egypt!!!) has slowed down this positive improvement, things are still very tough for civilians there. Now the biggest threat there is the spread of diseases because of the total breakdown of the sanitation and health systems there. I'm glad that Israel has been working with humanitarian organisations to improve the situation to avert these crises.

[@libistur]

​@@lupen_reinwhy should the world feed the terrorists? They kill and murder but the world has to feed them? How crazy is that logic? 🤔

[@pichkes]

It is important to note that electricity is produced in Israel and it is not Gaza's power plants that Israel stopped. Israel, until October 7, have supplied and sent water and electricity to Gaza without Hamas paying all the bills, what kind of country that wants to destroy someone would do such a thing?

[@leth5540]

This deserves more likes, simple, logical, verifyable and kinda obvious as though it may be.

[@mr.d682]

Correct, Israel did supply electricity and water to the (illegally) occupied territories. You know why? Because palestinians arent allowed to build and operate power plants in those territories. Israel also controls the water supply. They are not allowed to access the Jordan River for a fresh water, dig their own wells or deepen existing ones which results in less than 4% of the available water being drinkable, all while also not being allowed facilities to treat the polluted water nor cisterns to collect rain water. Oh and the hilarious part for all you Apartheid apologists is.... not only is this just the tip of the iceberg, but all of it happened before October 7th.....

[@pichkes]

@@mr.d682 One, you are talking nonsense, we are talking about Gaza, what does it have to do with the Jordan River and there is no such thing as legally occupied territory, it is garbage that the conquer Europe powers Think about and anti-Semitism thought, Where did you see such a thing that there is a law that allows you to occupy? Israel occupied these territories in the war and also in 1988 Jordan said it had nothing to do with this territory so what illegal territory are you talking about, Do you even listen to your own bullshit?. And why did she say it, it is clear that Palestinians have no right to do whatever they want, outside the territories under The Palestinian Authority control, it is Israel that created the Palestinian Authority and divided the territory of Israel into the territory of the Authority. Why in your country can you go and build something wherever you want without permits or agreements from the state?

[@mr.d682]

@@pichkes riiight, so lets start at the bottom. In my country, you are in fact allowed to build smal things, like cisterns to collect rain water, wells or water filters without a permit and we are allowed to own and use chemicals to purify water. None of which palestinians are allowed. You are right though, for bigger stuff, we would need a permit, something palestinians cannot legally get in Israel. So the state of Israel both refuses to supply clean water and electricity AND at the same time makes it illegal for palestinians to provide it themselves. So tell me, why would a country do that? Now the Jordan River applies to the West Bank, cause it flows through it. Thats why I said occupied territories instead of specifically Gaza. So I am really curious how youre going to justify Israel denying palestinians access to a water supply (again.. a human right), that is in their territory. Now to the occupation. For one there is a distinction between legally and illegally occupied land. What makes this occupation even worse is the Israeli blockade of those territories, which btw is desgintated as another human rights violation.

[@eladmilnitzki7595]

@@mr.d682 Have you seen the video? The EU spent billions with Israel to provide water supply in and to Gaza. It did not take 1 week until Hamas DIGGED UP the water pipelines and rebuilding them to rocket launchers.... you cannot help somebody that DOES NOT want the help. Hamas is the disease. Can't put the blame on Israel

[@jimjames4348]

No they do not, the inverse is actually true. Israel takes more measures to prevent civilian casualties than any other country on earth.

[@yamiyugi2894]

Sure buddy

[@WhiteWidowXX]

​​@@yamiyugi2894 yeah he is sure... because they have... and for sure are doing the most... always have actually... even gave them Gaza when everyone knows they deserved nothing of the sort... case and point Here we are there they are using human shields taking and executing hostages... War continues... untill Hamas is erased... and all they had to do is surrender..

[@ivanj.conway9919]

@@yamiyugi2894 : You only believe one side you only, ever, get half the picture. Sadly, that seems to be all most of you want.

[@turalmirzaliev1232]

​@@yamiyugi2894grow a brain

[@erikthered1719]

@@ivanj.conway9919this is Islam. No facts, many lies, lots of victims and lots of hate

[@xevicxavier9802]

Hamas should really be ashamed of their actions, and also people (including Jews) protesting against Israel.

[@tallspicy]

False, it is reasonable to question if what they are doing is effective towards long term peace. It is not. Netanyahu must go, as does Hamas.

[@FreeSpeechThought]

@@tallspicy your imbalance matches your confusion and false equivalence. Any izz Raily leader wherever they sit in the Overton Window would be ex termin Nate Ting scumus. Most would be far more decisive

[@user-id5yg9fc9k]

Netanyahu cares more about his political survival than returning back the hostages.

[@notofyourneed5728]

Jewish propoganda

[@Ggifhfh]

@@notofyourneed5728did you even watched the video

[@talbn880]

The very simple thing people seem to miss is that *if* Israel would have not care about the Palestinian civilians, *if* Israel would have not considered civilians casualties when attacking, *if* Israel didn’t care about Palestinians civilians getting killed, this war would have ended in 3-4 days and Gaza would have turned into a parking lot

[@the.worst.stories]

And if Americans wouldn't have been saving your asses, there won't be single jew living in the israel.

[@YoussefEissa-b2e]

Oh so just because they did not yet kill 2,1 million civilians and only estimated if not more than 40,000 civilians they care. How caring of the IDF,"The most moral army in the world".

[@talbn880]

@ In short to answer your question, Yes, exactly. And I will explain: Wars are bad. Civilians will always die in war. Look at the history, and don’t even go that far. You can check any conflict in modern history and see for yourself. As Hamas openly stated that massacres like October 7th will continue on and on as long as they exist, they left Israel no option other then ending the existence of Hamas. I’m willing to bet my life that any country in the world would do the same. The question left is, who can stop the killing? Who can protect the innocent civilians? Theoretically, Israel can stop the killing, but as we just concluded, Israel (or any other country in its place) should not and would not do so, as this war has a righteous goal. They do try and do their best to minimize casualties. That is a fact supported by numbers and many acts, for example, notify everyone (including Hamas) where they are going to bomb. This leaves Hamas, the authority that publicly seeks to be responsible for the fate of the Palestinian people, with the responsibility to protect their civilians from a war they started. But they won’t do it. They refuse to release the hostages they took, the main condition Israel set for a ceasefire. They won’t hide their civilians in the vast network of underground tunnels they built. They didn’t build bomb shelters from all the money and resources they got from Israel and Qatar. They don’t care one bit for the Palestinian people. It’s good for Hamas that they die, because they can play victim in front of the foolish people of the International community, people like you who don’t have a clue about what’s happening in this conflict. They use them as human shields. They even said that themselves. If you don’t believe me, go check their spokesman Sami Sbu Zuhri’s opinion on the subject. Go search Google for the stories of brave Palestinians about Hamas threatening them to stay and listen to the IDF warnings, and hide their weapons and missiles in their civilians homes, that’s a fact I encourage you to check as well. Wars are bad. Civilians always die in war. But this war has a good side and a bad sideside. In this war, there is only one side who fights for both sides: Israel. The best thing that can happen to the Palestinians is that Israel will end Hamas, and they do so with minimal casualties as possible. Historically,urban warfare results in a casualty ratio of 9 dead civilians per 1 enemy fighter. As in the war in Gaza, the casualty ratio is 2 dead civilians per 1 Hamas terrorist, which is awful, but wars are an awful thing. So to answer your sarcastic question, yes, exactly because of this. And yes, yes, the IDF is the most moral army in the world that is supported by facts my fellow human.

[@YoussefEissa-b2e]

@@talbn880 Thanks for telling me your thoughts about the matter. dude, you are comparing a terrorist group with supposedly the only democratic state in the Middle East. Also, I hope you do not get this the wrong way, and I do not wish any harm on you, I am not being sarcastic, but honestly, this sounds like what a certain Austrian with a certain mustache would say to justify a certain horrible thing that happened to the Jews.

[@YoussefEissa-b2e]

@@talbn880 What fact man literally all the human rights organizations have stated that Gaza has become unlivable, and everyone is in danger of starving. Also, what about the journalists who are shot in the head, what about the babies that are shot in the head. what about the apartment buildings being blown up with people inside them. Oh, what about Hind Rajab. What about all the ambulances that were destroyed by the IDF. what about the infrastructure. What about bombing the hospitals with their patients inside them. what about killing the Hamas terrorists not regarding that it may harm the hostages. Actually, the hostages that died were killed by IDF bombs. What about UN workers. You are taking your morals from countries like the USA, which launched an invasion of Iraq for oil and funded and supported the creation of the Taliban, AL Qaeda, and ISIS and wiped out a whole race. Or maybe you are taking your morals from England, which at a certain time occupied most of the known world and launched the Crusades (look how many it killed). Or maybe you are taking your morals from France which is literally still exploiting African countries for its resources and cheap labor. There is no such thing that says to kill a terrorist it is justified to shoot a baby in its head shoot a journalist for doing his job or starve 2.1 million people. Also, where did you get your last ration from, I bet it is some source from Israel, I would suggest you do not take it for granted because Israel has already lied on many occasions in this ongoing war.

[@user-kp3qk9gx6q]

VIVAAAAAA ISRAELLLLL

[@Serpentdemer]

Yarc jamais de la vie

[@ellev11]

THIS! Always

[@chenrhrh]

Thank you! ❤

[@derka346]

​@c109henrhrh

[@toddl3328]

🇮🇱

[@christianporter3638]

This is a video, sadly, 99% of pro Palestinians would categorically reject. Facts don't care. Also, the civilian to combatant k/d ratio is one of if not the lowest in modern history FAVORING the IDF.

[@Brimfarm]

Precisely, anyone saying “genocide” haven’t read a book in their life

[@BostonSQ]

The reason they won’t except is because they will try to prove with HAMAS’s death reports, where every single death is on civilians list and none in combatant)

[@onTheWork-z6t]

@@Brimfarm they simply do not understand the meaning of the word. it's a known problem with people who live too protected life. they see guns as a game. bombs as an exciting thing. war is a computer game where you get to kill soldiers (no wonder they don't care about IDF's soldiers killed in so many pointless wars). so genocide is something you can shout at people, instead of a real horror you should be reluctant to name.

[@owaissheraz]

Un called it and ic has feclared natanyahu as warcriminal​@@Brimfarm

[@Brimfarm]

@@owaissheraz Both of which are public disgraces and proven untrustworthy to do their job LOL

[@happyokay345]

Excellent video! Like you said Israel is not committing genocide; they are defending their country. It's a war not genocide. May peace come soon. 🙏

[@YoniBaruch-y3m]

It’s a hostage recovery operation.

[@matheusdesouzasilva9320]

yeah and palestinian went up from 700000 to almost 7 million, which is the opposite for the jews in muslim countries.... but no! of course its israel who is doing genocide, bunch of clowns ....

[@TojiFushiguro5123]

Yeah, killing 40,000 people while injuring 50,000 more, and even killing americas and you still think its "self defense"?!?!!?!?! HOLY, ITS NEVER WAS SELF DEFENSE, WAKE UP

[@AMBallProduction]

I don’t like extreme Palestine supports they think all jews are bad

[@RandomFrenchmain]

It’s not. Israel has shot hostages and they have technically 7k hostages of which 50% are minors

[@uggmonster8795]

crazy how people can see Israel as the bad guy when hamas is literally killing their own civilians in order to win this war.

[@alemarte5447]

You can’t be that dumb? Hamas is a problem as well as Netanyahu. You know what’s “funny”? Netanyahu himself gave 15+ millions to Hamas back in 2018

[@unnameduser5647]

Yes Hamas is a bad guy in this war. A very bad guy. But in my pov Israel is not the good guy simply because they fight a bad guy. Israels war will hardly reduce the numbre of terrorists in the world. It will only fuel the hatred against 'the west' that it is part of. So I struggle to see their actions as nessessary and therefore they are not a good guy either

[@roeital5504]

​@@unnameduser5647damn you got room temperature IQ

[@roeko10]

100% right. And for the people who don't believe Hamas can be so evil, check what they did to their opponents, Fatah, in 2006-7 and check what regime they put on Gaza.

[@UNPACKED]

Yep - kzbin.info/www/bejne/pWjHiWmgbZJgrKM

[@aliciafletcher9739]

The rules of law are non-reciprocal, meaning that they apply irrespective of what the other side has done. Ihl only addresses the means employed/conduct, not the justification used for an attack. The world holds H@mas more responsible for it's war crimes. Isr@el had acted with impunity since it's inception. Violations - such as deliberately targeting civilians or imposing collective punishment - can never be justified by claiming that another party has committed violations. H@mas or any other party's violations are irrelevant to whether they r committing war crimes; it's basically an admission of doing so, while arguing they shouldn't be held accountable for it.

[@UNPACKED]

Can you bring any proof of Israel deliberately targeting civilians or collective punishment that wasn't tied to a military objective?

[@RubenWithTheE]

⁠@@UNPACKEDI mean when they bombed the camp in Rafah. Or when you say “military objective” you just mean the idf said hamas was there with no proof. 😐

[@UNPACKED]

It’s literally been proved countless times that Hamas has fired rockets from civilian areas. Is there something stopping from you seeing that reality?

[@jankaufmann4305]

The discussion in this war is absurd. First. Israel acted selflessly to live in peace with the Palestinians in Gaza. It was more than a decade ago when Israel itself relocated thousands of individuals living in Gaza with lethal force from their homes to follow the agreement, which obligated the Palestinians in return to stop any kind of aggression towards Israel. The Palestinians had the chance to build a safe, functional, and prosperous livelihood. But the first thing the Palestinians did in return was to elect a government that enshrined the goal of destroying Israel in their constitution. The elected government followed through with its promise. Since its founding, thousands of rockets have flown into Israel. Dozens of civilians died in terrorist attacks. Millions of aid funds - intended for civilian purpose - were misused to build rockets, tunnels, and other nonsense. The crimes committed on October 7th like raping women, killing children, or kidnapping a baby, was Humus has been doing for years. Secondly. Israel behaved more humanely in this conflict than any other conceivable party in any imaginable conflict. It allowed Palestinians to work in Israel, receive medical care or even migrate into their country. During war, they warn civilians where their military is operating. They admit collateral damage and apologize for it. They saved Sinwar’s life giving him a lethal brain surgery. They treated the daughter of Haniyyas daughter for her complex disease in Israel. While Humus was building rockets and tunnels with all the foreign aid, Israel supplied their civilians with free water and electricity. The situation is clear. In no other conflict the responsibility for the suffering has been so one sided and clear - in no other conflict have the perpetrators been held accountable so weakly. The same goes for any related conflict: Hezbollah, Houthis, etc…the more peacefully you try to live with them, the more visible their genocidal intents becomes. People with voice and power who claim to reject war have the duty to unequivocally name the culprit of this war and do everything in their power to eliminate them. Everything else is responsibility for the resulting suffering and will extend it.

[@mochithepooh5368]

Palestinians literally only have 1 year to "build a safe, functional, and prosperous livelihood" before the blockade start. Tell me a single country that managed to pull this off.

[@RandomFrenchmain]

Palestinians were shot if they came back to get family Israel are the ones that started it

[@lironbz1]

AHH yes, the Egyptian blockade is horrible. ​@@mochithepooh5368

[@Alireza-h7r]

You have literally taken a land from a people and you believe that you are the symbols of peace?

[@jankaufmann4305]

I don't know what you mean by that. The land belongs to the jews as they were the first people ever settled to this territority?

[@lukaskamin755]

Thank you for stating that all with such clearness ❤ am Israel chai 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@thegamer3049]

עם ישראל חיי🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱❤❤❤🇮🇱❤🇮🇱❤🇮🇱❤🇮🇱❤🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@Bunnyhopper1234]

עם ישראל חיי

[@oritheshambalooloo]

עם ישראל חיי!!!🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@YeshuaIsrael722]

No Israel has not commited genocide

[@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781]

Yes it has

[@Joe-pc3hs]

​@@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781 Genocide is what happened to the Khurds. More recently the Armenians in Artsakh and now Hindus in Bangladesh. Genocide isn't any conflict were Jews fight back against those who call for genocide against them

[@haugtussa8989]

@@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781 Only one side tried to commit genocide, and its the Iranian terror alliance

[@user-ut5wv]

@@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781 it was your namesake pdfile who commited crimes...

[@rinskedevries3272]

​@@user-ut5wvIndeed.

[@waisinglee1509]

How come we don't hear about the Palestinians calling for the genocide of Jews?

[@UncleTazTaszung]

Exactly, the bias is crazy

[@TheOneThatKnocks333]

It's very alive among the Palestinians and the surrounding Arab Nations. Don't be naive. I can say easily it's there on both sides.

[@Aega1107]

@@waisinglee1509 they have. You just don’t hear about it in the media.

[@erikp4738]

Those who cover their ears, won't hear even if shouting. Just make a simple Google search man.

[@jimjames4348]

​@@TheOneThatKnocks333 No you cannot. You might find one or two crazies but not 75-85% of the population.

[@Bayerbach9541]

35,000-75,000 civillians died in Mariupol according to an study conducted by the Associated Press (87,000+ by Ukrainian Govt.) and no one is calling that a genocide

[@tomer2144]

You are right. Russia commits horrible war crimes against the Ukrainian people and people around the world stay silent. These people follow trends and don't even try to learn what's happening worldwide. They support terror organizations that oppress citizens, kill gays and rape women and children while ignoring the atrocities committed by Russia, Iran, China, and those various terror organizations in Asia and the middle east.

[@anders4160]

I know right wtf, and no one talking about fact russia supporting hamas. And still people dont understand who the bad ones.

[@tashikoweinstein435]

Since I started embracing my Jewish ✡️ Heritage in 2011, I have been told time and time again that Israel has committed war crimes. But, growing up, my dad would always tell me stories about visiting Israel 🇮🇱 especially during the 6-days wars, and in his stories there was a sense of pride. Every time, Israel 🇮🇱 was in the news, I always ask my dad do you, a secular and culture Jew support Israel 🇮🇱 his answer would be always be yes! Followed by how many times times he has visited Israel and having it stamped in his Passport. When you have someone in your family who wants nothing to do with Judiasm, whether that be the religious or cultural aspect, tell you he supports Israel 🇮🇱 and give it nothing but praise all your life especially during a war. Then you know, Israel is good. My dad wanted nothing to with his Jewish Identity growing up, but when it came to Israel all sudden he was a proud Jew. If Israel 🇮🇱 can make a Jew like my dad proud of his Jewish Identity ✡️ Then I know Israel is a good, and that no matter what, I should believe in Israel and her people. Because only a place like Israel 🇮🇱 can make a Jew like my dad, a proud Jew! I won't give up on Israel, because was only thing I had to connect me to my Jewish Heritage growing up, so don't you give up on Israel either! AM YISRAEL CHAI 🇮🇱

[@enigma1000]

You need to think for yourself. Just because someone told you something doesn’t mean it is true. I was brought up to think Israelis were the good guys, protecting themselves from decades of oppression. That seems now to be one big fat lie.

[@Lynn-i2w]

Over 40,000 people (babies too) bombed and starved by Israel. BDS Israel, an apartheid, racist, right wing government committing genocide. Israelism is not Judaism.

[@anthonypalo8191]

Its not israel that commits war crimes, it's Islam that commits war crimes throughout history.

[@ivanj.conway9919]

Also Darling, while I understand Jews largely, reject him, and I actually, partly, understand why; this nation and people were the ones who produced the Prince of Peace, as well. Arguably, the one Jew to changed more of the face of humanity than any other, for the good. A nation and culture who can produce someone like that, surely, cannot be so very bad. Proudly supporting to the end. AM ISREAL CHAI FOREVER.

[@User-laiejwo5381]

@@ivanj.conway9919 The ICJ confirmed that Israel systematically oppressed Palestinians. They also said Israel violated over 28 international laws.

[@nrodry76]

First of all, Israel didn’t start this conflict, Hamas was. And secondly, Israel’s target IS NOT civilians. What they want is to eliminate the threat that is Hamas, not only for Israel, but to the entire world.

[@updatemysettings5095]

Lets all just agree that Israel is done now and that everyone has seen how evil Israelis are.

[@theobserver3753]

Meanwhile Hamas specifically used civilians to get an upper hand

[@PinkMushroomPie]

Show this to the radical left. I say this as being on the left. I stand for Ukaine, for human rights and public safety, Hamas is everything but that, and those who support them are an insult to humanity in my eyes. Being evil is a thing, supporting evil while pretanding to be a good person it's messed up

[@144Donn]

"Their accusations are their confessions!"

[@Serpentdemer]

Sounds like israel

[@R2d2..]

@@SerpentdemerFakestine*

[@Serpentdemer]

​@@R2d2..* isnotreal

[@SokKaka-qq8qn]

​​@@Serpentdemerfakist💩

[@144Donn]

@@Serpentdemer I did not think I would have to explain this: EVEY claim the Pa*les* make against Israel baby killers, land grabbers etc is PRECISELY what they do and have done for centuries!

[@neriamoye6729]

NO NO NO AND NO- Israel does NOT COMMIT war crimes. Full stop. It's high time to stop the blaming and accusing and truly stick to the facts. YES Israel does assist with medical and ground aid all over the world. YES YES YES AND YES.

[@enigma1000]

The evidence that Israel has committed war crimes is compelling. Read the ICJ submissions and the ICJ response.

[@elliotlevy8610]

​@@enigma1000the ICJ has not issued any binding resolutions or opinions, nor would it have the needed information to do so in all likelihood.

[@chenrhrh]

Exactly! I wish people would be as critical of Hamas instead of blaming Israel for everything, especially when Hamas is a literal terrorist organization that commits war crimes all the time- not only against the Israelis but also against the Gazans (the saddest part is that Hamas also has huge support among the Palestinians). But with the overwhelming criticism of Israel and little to no criticism of what Hamas does, it seems like people don’t really care about war crimes- they only do when they think Israel is involved. The hypocrisy is real.

[@neriamoye6729]

@@chenrhrh AMEN🙏

[@mochithepooh5368]

Meanwhile you literally have american doctors saying they treated children in double sniper wound. Then you have the World Kitchen strike which was clearly targeted as Israel hit them 3 times. And you have America airdropping aid and building piers because Israel is blocking the aid in.

[@mabellopez5127]

To me it’s obvious, they are not targeting civilians. Just because, Israel could do more damage by just not being careful. I’ve never seen an army being so careful towards citizens who hate them anyways.

[@LeviHashem]

Israel is innocent in all this. 100% justified.

[@THE.tribrid.69]

You’re nuts.

[@THE.tribrid.69]

@@HarryBolsak then you’re both very naive I suppose.

[@otteottema6839]

​@@THE.tribrid.69 You are nuts

[@viktor_vaughn]

It is absurd for a war not to have civilian victims. It's sad, it's tragic, but it's literally inevitable. If not, please tell me which arm conflict in human history hasn't.

[@macnosmutano4849]

I love this channel. It offers well-balanced analysis which is incredibly hard to these days.

[@YourFired-md8tq]

I'm not sure why people think Israel is the bad guy here they were attacked and if you try to tell people the truth now and days all they will do is just cry and label you as a biggot or a racist it's disgusting

[@oboealto]

Thank you, Unpacked.

[@tsotnebetchvaia2342]

Hypocrisy of the modern world. Where you have to justify and explain your war agains the terrorism, just so some clown living in the developed country, absolutely safe in their home, can be sure that they don't hear too many "sad" news today, which would hurt their mood before going to their favorite Starbucks in front of their highly paying workplace.

[@IUSEJITTER2]

❤

[@K1ngGr33n]

Will be saving this video for when someone starts talking nonsense

[@kareemhamdan8189]

While I agree with some of the points you've made, and acknowledge that this war is incredibly complex, I find it difficult to believe that the IDF is fighting entirely ethically or is truly "the most moral army," as claimed. Just as you've highlighted accusations of war crimes, there are undeniable incidents, such as the killing of journalist Samer Abu Daqqa in a drone strike at a UN refugee agency. Or what seemed like a targeted attack on an Al Jazeera crew, killing 20 Gazans and injuring the bureau chief of Al Jazeera in Gaza. These are war crimes, and you can't simply justify them by saying, "Hamas terrorists were there," as though you were present yourself. Just as you're skeptical of the Ministry of Health's numbers, I could easily doubt the IDF's claims. For instance, the BBC reported the killing of 15 civilians in their apartment, which, without question, is a war crime-this type of summary execution cannot be justified. The mass evacuation of 1.1 million people in the first week of the war is also considered a war crime under the Geneva Convention, and the list goes on. Proving that the IDF did not commit the three war crimes you mentioned in your video doesn't mean they are following all the rules or acting without fault. If the IDF isn't breaking any laws, why are arrest warrants awaiting Gallant and Netanyahu? And let's not forget what happened two days ago: Shaaban was burned alive along with his family in his tent after an airstrike on a hospital (another war crime). No one should endure this kind of suffering without holding the ones who did that accoutable, and the reasons behind these tragedies must be addressed. You repeatedly use words like "butchered" and "massacre" to describe what happened to Israelis on October 7th, and you're right-it was brutal. But don't diminish the suffering on the Palestinian side by merely saying they were "killed" or "died." They were also butchered, massacred, tortured, and burned alive. Please, stop justifying everything Israel does while solely blaming Hamas. It's time to hold Israel accountable when they cross the line.

[@UNPACKED]

Thanks for your acknowledgements. And yes, war is terrible and the death of any innocent civilians is tragic. Where did we claim Israel is "the most moral army"? (we actually have a video all about that: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nYi4l3xjg9p-obc) How do you know that the drone strike that killed Samer Abu Daqqa or Al Jazeera staff wasn't targeting militants? It's actually been proven that multiple Al Jazeera staff were in fact Hamas militants - including Ismail al-Ghoul. Which 15 civilians in an apartment are you talking about? Couldn't find anything about it on BBC "mass evacuation of 1.1 million people in the first week of the war" -- wait, are you saying Israel should have let them stay in active war zones where they were being used as human shields among Hamas fighters? That's a strange argument to make. And did you know that if Hamas embeds itself and fights from a hospital, it loses its protected status under international law? Like you said, this war is incredibly complex, but there are still rules of war.

[@kareemhamdan8189]

@@UNPACKED The claim that Ismail was affiliated with Hamas was refuted after it was revealed that he had been arrested and released in March following the raid on Al Shifa Hospital. Even an IDF spokesman admitted there was nothing further to add on the subject. Yet, the justification for killing journalists based on the suspicion that "they might be connected with Hamas" persists, despite there being no solid proof. And what about their families? What about Wael's family-his 7-year-old daughter, his wife, and both of his sons? Are they connected to Hamas too? Let me correct myself: it was Al Jazeera that reported the incident of the 15 unarmed men being killed. The OHCHR also received reports of 11 unarmed men being summarily executed in December. In October, the IDF even posted a video showing the shooting of four surrendering, unarmed Palestinians-one of whom was waving a white flag. Doctors have stated that children were sniped. Is that something we should consider normal? The so-called "mass evacuation" of civilians should more accurately be described as "forcible displacement," as hundreds of thousands are fleeing for their lives. This isn't an evacuation. According to the leaflets dropped in northern Gaza, anyone staying in their home is automatically considered a terrorist. Rafah was also ordered to evacuate after Gaza was reduced to rubble, and many officials have classified this forced displacement as a war crime. The notion of forcing citizens to leave their homes so their houses can be bombed is unjustifiable, even if labeled as an effort to "prevent civilian casualties." In the meantime, reports of looting by IDF soldiers have surfaced, with videos circulating online showing them taking belongings, which itself is a war crime. Not to mention their strange obsession with female nightwear, which is also disturbingly evident in these videos. As for the hospitals, many have been declared damaged, destroyed, or out of service due to a lack of fuel, with the blame again placed on Hamas for supposedly misusing them. The footage presented by the IDF in the early days of the war to substantiate these claims was inconclusive. Hospitals can lose their "special protection" if proven to be misused, but Israel has yet to provide conclusive evidence to justify their actions. I'm not a military expert, and I don't claim to know exactly how Israel should conduct this war. But this isn't the way to go about it.

[@UNPACKED]

If you're not a military expert, why are you making determinations and judgements about complex military situations? Do you have suggestions how Israel can destroy all of the terrorists on Israel's border who seek its annihilation, free their hostages, while not killing any civilians? But really, don't worry - Israel has a whole team of legal experts and military experts who oversee their work. And every independent international military expert who's inspected has said that Israel is conducting this war with a greater concern for civilians and for laws of war than any other urban war they've seen. And every example you're bringing here can be explained with just a little bit of googling. No one is being targeted for being a journalist or because "they might be connected to Hamas" - Israel literally shared documentation from Hamas listing Ismail al-Ghoul as an operative static.timesofisrael.com/www/uploads/2024/08/1f46214a-8bb2-4071-a49a-181612193dda.jpg You claim that Israel shot 4 unarmed Palestinians - so why were they photographed, before and after being shot, with weapons? What were they doing entering Israel? In terms of "forcible displacement" - sure, you can call it that -- but are you still saying Israel should have let them stay in active war zones where they were being used as human shields among Hamas fighters? That's still a strange argument to make. In every war ever fought civilians flee as refugees into neighboring countries. It is too bad Egypt didn't let them in, and too bad that Hamas tried to force civilians to stay. Honestly I don't envy the Gazan people, they have terrible leaders.

[@NitaJain]

@@UNPACKED One does not need to be a military expert to realize that the bombing of hospitals, refugee tents, and safe zones and the blocking of humanitarian aid are immoral actions.

[@UNPACKED]

Oh look - more Al Jazeera 'journalists' found to be terrorists! videoidf.azureedge.net/e8e85dc1-518d-4e08-b8a5-77576b4dea42 (www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/idf-claims-uncovered-documents-prove-6-al-jazeera-journalists-are-hamas-pij-operatives/)

[@eltal69]

Thanks!

[@UNPACKED]

Thank you 🙏

[@2slaza250]

Finally someone approaching this topic in a nuanced and balanced way. Well done on a great video.

[@bnthern]

as a war veteran - war is terrible - to see children learn horror, abuse, hunger, and see destrution does not make for a good lesson - it leaves scars hidden and sore festering within!

[@Kenbark42]

Pretty sure Gaza children knew of horror, abuse, hunger, and witnessed destruction long before this war started. I am sure you know how Hamas rules.

[@OnePlusOneEqualsOnePlusOne]

It doesn't. Children of Hamas hate the part of being alive instead of dying and sacrificing for their Allah Yahya Sinwar.

[@summerohara554]

Taught to hate & seek revenge

[@onTheWork-z6t]

if anyone cared about Gazan children, they would have called for Israel to go into Gaza and take down Hamas long ago, because Arab children in Israel know perfectly well what normal modern life is. never knew anything else. no one called for that. so unlike you, they do not care for the children. I appreciate you for caring.

[@khrawbryan]

People chanting free Palestine don't understand who's the one caging them.

[@ivanj.conway9919]

Because of all the insane, levels of deliberate, lies and misinformation targeted toward Israel and the Jewish People, and because I passionately, support Israel, it becomes extremely, difficult for me to be sympathetic to what is happening to Gazans currently. Because the other side absolutely, refuses to be the least bit fair or balanced at all, any concessions you make to side with them, causes them to take things to greater extremes, still. It also, does not help when this website chooses to silence me insanely, every time I passionately and aggressively, speak up for this nation and people.

[@alphadog3384]

Please stay safe, your in my prayers.

[@j-manmarkus7591]

Israel forever, paliestine never! 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@frankcortes6852]

😂

[@nicbentulan]

​@@frankcortes6852Dear terrorist, we can't know 101% a priori Earth revolves around the Sun like with 2+2=4, but it's beneficial to assume this is true and harmful to assume this is false. A good rule of thumb to determine if something is theoretically true is to see if it's practically true. Like 2 state solution, we've tried it, but the solution keeps failing. The world is ABSOLUTELY better off if each Muslim converts to something else. So that's how I know what's true Vs false. It's not evil to hate communism fascism socialism dictatorships. I don't see ☪️ as different. It seems like ☪️'s inherently evil and will/should die just like communism/socialism, dictatorships, etc Vs ✝️☦️🔯✡️, capitalism, democracy. Maybe ☪️'s an evil political ideology disguised as a religion. Evil genius concept which gets the 'Islamophobia' shield because 'technically we're a religion'. (H6kWrI0V0LQ & C22NFtwBogk) To ☪️: 0- How do you know Gasai about corruption in ✝️☦️Gospel or 🔯✡️Torah given there's no such verse outright explicitly in the Quran as David Wood & Apostate Prophet PBUH say? (4of-PbRvdqo) 1 As of 2022: - The only 2 anti-Zionist democracies are the 2 most democratic Muslim countries 🇮🇩🇲🇾. - The 2 most dictatorial Christian countries 🇨🇫🇨🇩 are Zionist. - There are only 3 anti-Zionist non-Muslim countries, namely 🇨🇺🇻🇪🇰🇵. While 2 are unfortunately ☦️✝️, they're both dictatorships. Why? 2 Am I hypocrite if I side w/ ☪️ countries eg 🇸🇦🇮🇷🇸🇾🇳🇴🇦🇫🇪🇬🇯🇴🇱🇧🇧🇭🇳🇴🇦🇪🇮🇶🇹🇷🇶🇦🇵🇰🇳🇴🇩🇿🇾🇪🇴🇲'🇵🇸'🇳🇴 but prefer to live in ✡️🔯☸️☦️✝️🕉️ countries eg 🇯🇵🇨🇦🇮🇳🇮🇱🇺🇸🇺🇦🇬🇧🇳🇱🇵🇭🇭🇰🇨🇭🇦🇺🇳🇿🇮🇹🇸🇬🇩🇪🇵🇱🇧🇪🇵🇹🇩🇰🇸🇪🇰🇷🇮🇸🇫🇮🇸🇮🇸🇰🇦🇹? 3 Which of the 2 sets of countries/regions do you side w/? 4 Which set'd you choose/prefer to live in, regardless of where you actually live? (And it's gonna be a random element of the set you choose.) 5 Why are ☦️✝️✡️🔯🕉️ countries generally viewed as more democratic & better to live in than ☪️ countries? 6 Which non-Muslim does NOT think the world is better off if each Muslim converted to 🔯✡️, ☦️✝️ or 🕉️? Or at least which non-Muslim thinks such a world is better as compared to if all ☦️✝️ converted to ☪️? 7 Why's most religious terrorism today from ☪️? 8 There are stories of abused ex-☪️ women saved by ✝️☦️/✡️🔯. Where are the stories of abused ex-✝️☦️/ex-🔯✡️ women saved by ☪️? LOL. 9 Chess: Why do 🔯✡️🕉️☸️☦️✝️ players do better than gentile ☪️ players? 10 🇮🇩 is the top in ☪️ population and is luckily democractic because 🇮🇩 is also the top in ex-☪️ who convert to ✝️☦️✡️🔯. So without apostasy laws and stuff and with more democracy, ☪️ will convert to ✝️☦️✡️🔯? LOL. 11 The Serpent told Eve that God's revelation was corrupted. How's this different from Islam? Jesus & Paul never said previous revelation was corrupted. 12 Most importantly why don't you use your real name and face? --- Bonus : Mohammed was poisoned by the Jewish prophetess Zaynab bint Al-Harith (PBUHer) w/ a lamb, fulfilling Galatians 1:8, Psalm 83:6, Matthew 26:52, Deuteronomy 18:20 & John 1:29 (again LOL). This represents 3 enemies of ☪️/Jihadism/Arab world: A. Lamb - ✝️☦️/democracy/🇺🇲, the Judeo-Christian nation aka great 👿, the top in ✝️☦️ population & the top 2 in ✡️🔯 population (or top 1, depending on your definition of ✡️🔯) B. Jewish - ✡️🔯/Zionism/🇮🇱, the Jewish state aka little 😈 C. Woman - Feminism Meanwhile, Jesus saved a Jewish woman from stoning. This represents 2 allies of ☦️✝️/democracy/🇺🇲: A. Jewish - 🔯✡️/Zionism/🇮🇱 B. Woman - Feminism And 1 enemy: C. Stoning - ☪️/Jihadism/Arab world Also: After Jews & Romans killed Jesus, Christians got Paul & Constantine. After Jews, Christians & women, via Zaynab PBUHer, killed Mohammed, Muslims got no one. Lol. (Well, unless you follow 'Kosher Jesus' by Rabbi Shmuley Boteach, Jesus never really considered Jews or Romans as enemies.) Finally there's - Genesis 16:12 - Ishmael hostility - Quran 5:51 - 🔯✡️ & ✝️☦️ are allies - Psalm 83:6 - Ishmaelites, including Mohammed, can't be prophets. Lol. - Deuteronomy 18 - Romans 11 - Matthew 7:15 - Quran 22:45-46 - Ironically, ☪️ countries are in ruin plainly for the eyes to see, but ☪️ hearts are blind. LOL. cf Isaiah 6:9 as quoted in the Parable of the Sower. Coincidence? Prophecy? --- More info : - Ha6uVGB-Mtw

[@Baconstraps]

​@@frankcortes6852*Pedostine

[@drdonna4915]

Yes!!!! Oh wait. There are already 14 Palestines in the world today,13 of which are in the US and on in Haiti. None of these real Palestines have four generations of terrorists and cry babies. We don't need another Muslim terror state.

[@laevum5601]

That isn’t it

[@axol_the_goat]

כל הכבוד לך מרגש❤

[@kellyw5512]

Finally someone who is educated about this war. 🇺🇸🤝🇮🇱

[@playerx3546]

Wasn't Britain Responsible For The Endless Conflict SEPTEMBER 24, 2024

[@venjaminschuster2797]

Am Israel Chai!

[@goddessstarla]

This makes a lot of sense! Thank you for this educational video! Also, subscribed!

[@garyschneider6644]

Most Gazans supported Oct 7. I don’t see those people as “innocent civilians”. Rather, they are complicit.

[@jaisupremea9809]

They didnt really have a choice, Just as most russians "support" putins invasion and Chisese will "suppourt"' Taiwan's "liberation"

[@jaisupremea9809]

at the same time many of them have been radicalized because it was that or persecution which is why no country wants to take these people in.

[@Rogueboss2budgetedition]

Generalising is racism. Youre being racist. Just because most support hamas does not justify civilian deaths, learn that.

[@marlonsky6113]

Based of your logic, 7.10 didnt target any civillians, as there are people in Israel (radikal settlers, etc...) who kill palestinian civillians in their territory

[@russianbear318]

@@Rogueboss2budgetedition not really racist, but prejudice, sure, but, racism is not the same as generalizing, though generalizing by skin color is racism

[@TestHandlePleaseIgnore]

Am Yisrael Chai

[@Serpentdemer]

Never b

[@SokKaka-qq8qn]

​@@Serpentdemer🇮🇱🤫

[@electricdazz]

Heil Netanyahu!

[@operation1968]

As an Israeli, I got one thing to say: Thank you 🙏🏻

[@updatemysettings5095]

Nah, most americans are tired of Israel, you will be third world in 5 years.

[@karikoo3105]

So many hamas bots in the comment section

[@AMBallProduction]

People don’t like Israel and in extreme all Jews together

[@Israel_estine_EDU]

Absolutely genius ❤ Unf, the world is already too biased. IRAN won the internet war way ahead. BUT KEEP IT COMING! The arguments are just stronger!

[@soosooaryan]

It truly pains me when i see people demonize Israel for defending itself. i'm from Iran so i can feel what Gazan people truly feel. i know that, they like Iranian people, do not endorse Hamas's atrocities, but after all, it does not bother Hamas to do its business without hesitation and taking heed to its peoples cries. and again, i have nothing but scorn for those people that expect Israel to wait and be killed by its enemies, shame on all of them.

[@matter_of_fact_]

Very well said. Thank you for this. And as for those Aussies calling for Israel to stop fighting (and the other things they have said), they do not speak for all Aussies. We are shamed of them and the vast majority of Aussies support Israel's right to defend itself. You guys go down, we all go down.

[@patriotsforisrael3610]

Gaza pop: 1967 - 340K people 2005 - 1.3M people 2024 - 2.1M people This is the official number of people in the Gaza Strip by years. odd, When they committed genocide against the Jews, our numerical amount decreased and did not increase.

[@lupen_rein]

I reject the argument that Israel commits a genocide, but the argument you are making is not a good one. The Jewish population today is about the same as it was just before the Holocaust, but that clearly doesn't prove that there was no Holocaust either. Also, a genocide doesn't have to mean that very many people are dying, in Srebrenica, the only legally recognized part of the Yugoslav wars to have been an act of genocide, 6000 people were murdered, while millions of Bosniaks did not endure this fate. So the total number of killed alone is not the reason for calling something a genocide, the INTENT to do so matters, which has always been exceptionally hard to prove. In fact, Antizionists have been misunderstanding this issue as well, as their argument has not been to say that Israel has a clear policy to kill Palestinians, but their arguments were "many civilians die, so that's a genocide", so they themselves are only invoking numbers instead of actually looking at the actual policy given.

[@GR-wf5gi]

​@@lupen_reinI would argue the original point has merit. While I agree that it is hard to prove intent, I think you have to factor in capability. The Nazis had intent and capability, hence the results. Hamas have nowhere near that capability (thankfully), but I would say their intent is quite clear. And it would be a difficult argument to say the IDF doesn't have the capabilities to be far more destructive I am not saying the IDF is 100% ethical, as the video points out every decision to endanger and possibly kill civilians in order to kill military targets is morally difficult. But there are many points that show, in general, the IDF has no intent of targeting civilians

[@laevum5601]

@@lupen_rein but the fact of the matter is, it took nearly 100 years and we’re still not really there while the growth is occurring at the same exact time as the alleged genocide for Palestinians.

[@kevindutton3676]

I guess in our modern and civilized world attacking your opponent and then complaining about losing the war earns you victim credits

[@AdanSolas]

Short answer: No. Long answer: No, but they don't let that get in the way of achieving their objectives. You can't make an omelette without breaking a few eggs.

[@هايالقناةفقطتجربة]

how brainwashed are you?

[@AdanSolas]

More complex answer: That depends on who you ask. There's a blurred line between the designations of "civilian" and "legitimate target" and, in this case, they're often one and the same, if only for a moment.

[@womsky4537]

@@هايالقناةفقطتجربة "only test channel" Suuuuuuure Arabian buddy.

[@AdanSolas]

@@هايالقناةفقطتجربة How brainwashed are *you* ? Combat against such enemies and in such environments is not cut and dry.

[@هايالقناةفقطتجربة]

@@AdanSolas bro yes 100% israel is targeting civilians in gaza how can you see israel brutally murder 50000 civilians in gaza and say the idf isn't targeting civilians in gaza yes the idf is 100% committing unspeakable war crimes in gaza it's so obvious idf terrorists are literally committing war crimes and posting it on social media how can it get more obvious than that?

[@Liatofek670]

Recently the UN said that around 640 palestinian civillians have been killed during the war. That means for 11 months straight only 640 civillians have been killed while hamas is using human shields and is taking hospitals as bases. On the other hand on the first day on october 7th over 2500 innocent civillians have been slaughtered by hamas. In one single day they have slaughtered over 3 times the amount of civillans israel striked over 11 months. So if you wanted another fact about israel not targeting civillians here you go. Great video by the way thank you so very much for uploading a video like this especially in these hard times. Always spread the truth. The numbers of plaestinian civillians are from the west bank only due to the fact that there arent any correct numbers about gaza.

[@winterstime1138]

Could you give me a sorce? I cant find it on UNs site

[@Liatofek670]

@@winterstime1138 sorry not in gaza in the west bank. The numbers according to the UN in gaza are based on hamas but hamas has been known to lie so there isnt any official source. Though I would say its probably lower than we think.

[@winterstime1138]

@@Liatofek670 I agree that the numbers are most likely much lower than they say they are. Still, people will think you mean in Gaza, and that is just not right, so please dont just say that without spesifying

[@Liatofek670]

@@winterstime1138 yeah thats on me this time.

[@JeanBod1111]

You Awesome man

[@mzimhlemosiwe5047]

Why is it only israel being made to conform to international law, but hamas can bomb israel indiscriminately? Even after THEY (hamas) started the war? This makes no sense.

[@Hasanbas-rv3vm]

Israel b.. about being a democracy

[@UNPACKED]

You should learn more about that: kzbin.info/www/bejne/p6THl5moZcufqK8

[@tungteo1190]

Thanks

[@CVBv-j4p]

🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱🙏👍👍👍

[@Bournetobefree-j6m]

GOD BLESS THE CHINBET & THE GLORIOUS IDF, love you all , defend your country i pray that our lord keeps all that are defending isrealis safe amen 🙏 ❤️

[@flaviocalichmansp-brasil6958]

This video is an absolutely must see for anyone and everyone interested in what's been happening in Gaza since Oct 7th. Kudos for all, kol hakavod to all Unpacked crew. Yirmiahu, you and and the chevre are best.

[@45eno]

When claims are made you must start with what you already know about who is making such claims. I’m sorry but if the people with such claims have in their books to hate and not take for friends the same people they are accusing then I have a very hard time taking them seriously. Then add in all the factual events they do on a regular basis and I can then form my opinion that these hateful people are not to be trusted, not a word. Long live Israel.

[@sararichman6612]

Dont be a criminal and you wont be in prison

[@qlintenFX]

This is the best video about this conflict I've ever seen. Well documented.

[@yvonnehutchcraft4884]

We Hear What You're Saying but the World Doesn't What To Listen

[@Alireza-h7r]

The ratio of death toll in gaza is 100 Palestinian for 3 hamas troops . How dare you call that cladral damage? . By the way the intention of IDF (Israel troops) are exactly the Palestinian people not hamas

[@slowcuber7193]

did you hear that from them or some random guy who told you?

[@Cyberstan_Broadcast_Center]

let me guess, the 100 civilians per 3 Hamas troops was told to you by Hamas

[@jamesonthemap1768]

@@Cyberstan_Broadcast_Center According to the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights in August 2024 we are around 40k death in Gaza, how many of them were civilians?

[@Cyberstan_Broadcast_Center]

@@jamesonthemap1768 The UN is an anti Israel, pro-Hamas organization. Anything they say is easily disproven when you look at and expect the actual facts

[@Cyberstan_Broadcast_Center]

@@jamesonthemap1768 The UN is anti Israeli. Anything from them is most certainly a lie

[@Pearloryx]

It’s depressing to see people accusing 🇮🇱 for “war crimes” even tho it’s the opposite for the most part. Also China is killing the Uyghurs but no one, even the Muslims themselves, are talking about it.

[@WSY01]

Idk, but if you're gonna call Russia genocidal with civilian casualty numbers that are way less in like 3 times the time span, then you should definitely call Israel genocidal as well, or you'll sound like a complete hypocrite.

[@af2828]

Like he mentioned about a hundred times here. It’s about intention…

[@tomersnir-o7n]

Am israel Hai 🇮🇱 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@TobiasRieper-jx9lq]

Thank you for this, no sugarcoating or polarisation just stating the facts at a time where it’s rare.

[@itaysror6591]

gj on delivering these takes, not ez

[@AdanSolas]

@@itaysror6591 You’re joking, right?

[@Kenbark42]

This is as easy as it gets. Anyone thinking these are not easy obvious takes might have a little Nazi in em

[@itaysror6591]

@@AdanSolas no

[@AlbertKamut]

I watched the whole video and I remain skeptical of over simplified explanations. I understand that a video can only be so long and use so many sources. I also see that the goal of the video is to address its main question. I appreciated that focus. I also appreciated the comment about supporters of Palestine being focused on the humanitarian loss as their reason for protesting Israel. I’d say I fall into that category when it comes to the question justified level of force. Substantive loss of human life is heart wrenching. Although I have not protested Israel and have no plans to do so in the future. This video also helped confirm some of my suspicions about the ministry of health in Gaza. When I saw that symbol earlier in the conflict I wondered to myself if the government processes and institutions there were more fleshed out than I had previously realized. I just can’t get behind the idea that Israel (not the Jewish people or the faith) is doing what they can to keep civilians safe. I follow the UN’s news reporting, I’ve seen the storming of encampments and the like. Does that mean genocide? No. But it doesn’t mean the Israel is clean in this conflict in the ways this video painted (inadvertently or not). We are all too aware of the Hamas’ disgusting treatment of Israel and its people alike. However, I think it’s dangerous to say that either side is fully following the ethics of conflict and war. I guess what I’m saying is- as an outsider, a Canadian, I know there is so much more than can be shared with me via the news. To completely admonish one side of the conflict is wrong. My hope is that videos like this offer people like me key information that we need for continued support of the humans who are suffering. The Jewish community does not deserve anti semitic and hateful rhetoric from outsiders. A conflict is not the whole of a faith or its people. Nor is it a responsible way to support the bridge to peace.

[@jillk368]

Very well said. Thanks for sharing these thoughts.

[@krystalfaith]

Thoughtful. I would like to say something regarding your point on the I D F not being careful enough when it comes to killing civilians. If we are talking about boots on the ground, then we should all keep in mind that it must be incredibly stressful and difficult for them. They are fighting an enemy that has no problem with disguising themselves as civilians. An enemy where many (not all) civilians are aiding these mltnts. Where they cannot truly tell civilian and mltnts apart because the enemy does not wear a uniform when fighting. The I D F are putting their lives on the line fighting these guys. They may not be careful simply because it's very difficult to tell exactly who is the real enemy. This enemy even puts weapons in the hands of their children. I have seen countless videos like this. They will purposely send their children to point weapons at the soldiers and jeer at the soldiers telling them to shoot the children.

[@miller486a]

I will throw this into the mix to possibly add to your confusion. There has been no real war in which civilians were not affected. Killed or otherwise. None. Let us take out the fact that "Palestinians " have in there charter to kill the Jewish people. 1. Palestinians purposely targeted, attacked, and killed isrealy civilians. 2. In no war that I know of, nor studied, has any military given up strategic military advantage, just to warn of an upcoming assault to save civilians like isreal. Something to think about.

[@Kenbark42]

Right. So, what should Israel have done in response to Oct 7? What should they do now? Should they... die off? Should they have pretended that Oct 7 never happened? What about the fact that Hamas has literally been attacking Israel for decades? Israel (with the help of the US and allies and the Iron Dome) has simply turned a blind eye to the near constant rocket attacks, and aggression from a terrorist state that has declared their only goal in power is to murder, and massacre every Israeli alive. And they have shown they have every intention of doing so for decades. Its not just Hamas in Gaza either. Do some more homework, and you will find that this is Iran and the nations of Islam looking to finish Hitlers mission. Hell, perhaps you should do a little research into where the SS went after the fall of Germany. Or perhaps who in the middle east were actively allied with the Nazis during WW2. This has been a literal continuation of the Nazi mission in the Middle East since the day the war "ended" and the Nazi's "lost". So please, why don't you share your opinions of what Israel and the Jews should do. Because, when I read this I get the sense you feel they should just die, and make room for the nations of Islam to dance on their dead bodies.

[@jankaufmann4305]

The discussion in this war is absurd. First. Israel acted selflessly to live in peace with the Palestinians in Gaza. It was more than a decade ago when Israel itself relocated thousands of individuals living in Gaza with lethal force from their homes to follow the agreement, which obligated the Palestinians in return to stop any kind of aggression towards Israel. The Palestinians had the chance to build a safe, functional, and prosperous livelihood. But the first thing the Palestinians did in return was to elect a government that enshrined the goal of destroying Israel in their constitution. The elected government followed through with its promise. Since its founding, thousands of rockets have flown into Israel. Dozens of civilians died in terrorist attacks. Millions of aid funds - intended for civilian purpose - were misused to build rockets, tunnels, and other nonsense. The crimes committed on October 7th like raping women, killing children, or kidnapping a baby, was Humus has been doing for years. Secondly. Israel behaved more humanely in this conflict than any other conceivable party in any imaginable conflict. It allowed Palestinians to work in Israel, receive medical care or even migrate into their country. During war, they warn civilians where their military is operating. They admit collateral damage and apologize for it. They saved Sinwar’s life giving him a lethal brain surgery. They treated the daughter of Haniyyas daughter for her complex disease in Israel. While Humus was building rockets and tunnels with all the foreign aid, Israel supplied their civilians with free water and electricity. The situation is clear. In no other conflict the responsibility for the suffering has been so one sided and clear - in no other conflict have the perpetrators been held accountable so weakly. The same goes for any related conflict: Hezbollah, Houthis, etc…the more peacefully you try to live with them, the more visible their genocidal intents becomes. People with voice and power who claim to reject war have the duty to unequivocally name the culprit of this war and do everything in their power to eliminate them. Everything else is responsibility for the resulting suffering and will extend it.

[@Genarii]

Sadly, intention doesn't matter to the people who need to understand this the most. Those causing long-term damage to Gaza and the region by protesting in the streets about a genocide that isn't a genocide by any definition but their own. And yes, it is because people are dying, and because many of those people are children. But a huge part of it is also because the people dying are brown, and therefore seen as the oppressed victims of white colonizers of European origin. The fact that Israel is successful both economically and in regional wars historically is also not helpful in this sense. Even the fact that Jews are successful minorities outside of Israel is harmful to Israel being seen as anything but the privileged oppressor.

[@trevors2063]

KZbin Natasha Hausdorff, expert international lawyer. Israel has not broken any intl laws.

[@AwedaHammed]

Israel propaganda .😅

[@GeoTime2]

This video should be seen everywhere, on the new and in every pro Palestinian protest and every classroom. It’s perfect, and you’re using pure facts to give the ENTIRE picture. I have a ton of respect towards you for doing this. You are truly amazing. Keep up❤

[@rachelsharabi8470]

IDF is the most ethical army in the world.

[@vickygraham2444]

Arabic people should leave Gaza, the west bank and Israel to the the Jewish people. There are seven member states of the Arab League in the region: Bahrain, Kuwait, Iraq, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates. A huge area of the middle east is Arabic. Leave the tiny state of Israel and Gaza to the Jews!

[@WalterSpilman]

Jews should leave Palestine. Poland and Germany are very nice countries to live in. And that is offcourse where they came from. US and UK also very nice.

[@harrynutzach307]

@@WalterSpilman And how did they get to Poland and Germany? Oh that's right.... they were driven out of their HOMELAND. Well, they're back.

[@Ruach7777]

@@WalterSpilmanthere is no P a l e s t i n e, it never existed as a sovereign nation.

[@WalterSpilman]

@@harrynutzach307 HOMELAND ? You must be joking. Well ,read and educate yourself genius ahaha Ha'aretz , ARCHAEOLOGISTS UNDERMINE FOUNDATIONS OF PEOPLE OF ISRAEL !! After seventy years of intensive digging, most Israeli archaeologists have come to startling conclusions: the Israelites were not slaves in Egypt, they did not wander through the desert and they did not conquer the land (Israel). There was also no mighty empire of David and Solomon. And the Jews discovered their one god only late, and not at Mount Sinai. Well-known 'facts' in the world of archaeologists, but politics and society in Israel prefer not to know about them. Ze'ev Herzog Ha'aretz Daily Newspaper Ltd. Most scholars of biblical studies agree that the historical events concerning the origins of the Jewish people differ fundamentally from what the biblical story tells. This archaeological revolution has not yet filtered into the public consciousness, but it cannot be ignored. Palestine archaeology developed as a science only at a relatively late stage, in the 19th and 20th centuries. The civilizations of Egypt, Mesopotamia, Greece and Rome were the first target of researchers, usually employed by the major museums in London, Paris and Berlin, who were looking for impressive finds from the past. That first phase in fact ignored the small size of Palestine and its geographical diversity. The circumstances there were not inviting for the development of an extensive kingdom. Spectacular works such as the Egyptian tombs or the palaces of Mesopotamia were certainly not to be found here. The impetus to do archaeological research in Palestine was religious: the connection between the land and the holy scriptures. The first excavators in Jericho and Shechem were biblical researchers, searching for the remains of biblical cities. Archaeology revived with the arrival of William Foxwell Albright, who had specialized in the archaeology, history and linguistics of the Near East. Albright, an American, began his excavations in Palestine in the 1920s. His starting point was that archaeology in particular could refute criticism of the historical truth of the Bible. Critical biblical researchers in Germany in the second half of the previous century questioned the biblical stories and said that biblical historiography had only been formulated and even largely invented at the time of the Babylonian exile. The history of the people of Israel as a continuum - from the days of Abraham and Isaac, through the descent to Egypt, slavery, the Exodus, to the conquest of the land and the twelve tribes - was only a later reconstruction with a theological purpose. Albright believed in the Bible as a historical document, edited more than once, but nevertheless reflecting ancient reality. He was convinced that once the ancient remains of Palestine were uncovered, they would provide indisputable evidence of the historical accuracy of the history of the Jewish people and their land. Biblical archaeology led to extensive excavations of such biblical sites as Megiddo, Lachish, Gezer, Shechem, Jericho, Jerusalem, Ai, Givon, Beth She'an, Taanach and others. The method was simple and direct: each find would contribute to a harmonious picture of the past - the period of the patriarchs, the cities of Canaan destroyed by the Israelites, the borders of the twelve tribes, the gates and stables of Solomon, his mines at Timnah.There are still archaeologists hard at work who believe they have found Mount Sinai or Joshua's altar. Cracks slowly began to appear in the picture. Paradoxically, many discoveries began to undermine the historical truth of the biblical stories instead of confirming them. The theory could no longer explain the contradictions. The explanations became complicated and inelegant. The image of the puzzle became vaguer. Below are some examples. The patriarchs: the researchers did not agree on the correct period of the patriarchs. When did Abraham, Isaac and Jacob live? When did Abraham buy the cave in Hebron?

[@WalterSpilman]

@@harrynutzach307 They're back ? From where actually ? They never left Poland Einstein. Well read and educate yourself some more dear. DNA changes Jewish history ! It seemed clear. The Romans expelled the Jews from Palestine, after which the diaspora began. But according to historical research, modern Jews are mainly descended from converts. Microbiologist Jits van Straten also draws this conclusion in his own way. Eildert Mulder February 1, 2010, 00:00 Why does a microbiologist delve into the origins of the Jews? Jits van Straten became interested in the subject when he lived in Israel in the 1960s. He later moved to the US, and has long since returned to the Netherlands, but the interest remained. In Israel he came across a group of Indians. Tourists, he thought. Remarkable, because at that time relations between India and Israel were bad. They were not Indians but Jews from India who had settled in Israel. But how could they look so Indian? At that time Van Straten was still assuming the usual historical scenario, in which the Jewish population of Palestine was forced into exile after a revolt against the Romans in the year 70. They lived in the diaspora for almost two thousand years, after which they returned to Palestine, where they founded the state of Israel in 1948. He also thought that the Jews had mixed very little with their environment. How could those Indian Jews look so Indian and not so much Middle Eastern? Why are there so many blond Ashkenazi, Eastern European Jews? And why do Moroccan Jews look so Moroccan and Chinese Jews so Chinese? How can people, whose ancestors formed one people two thousand years ago, be so different? Van Straten eventually wrote a book on the subject, or at least part of it: 'The origin of the Ashkenazi Jews: the controversy resolved'. In it he uses historical-demographic, genetic, archaeological and linguistic research. The question of the origin of the Jews can provoke strong reactions, because it touches on the national myth of the state of Israel: that of expulsion, diaspora and return. The discussion is more than a century old and flares up regularly. It revolves around the question: are the large Jewish communities in the world descended from the ancient people of Israel or from converts? Shlomo Sand, professor of history at the University of Tel-Aviv, opts for the latter

[@itayamit123]

I really admire your stance in regard to this compliacted situation. It's awful that we have to shed some light in the first place. Having the courage to speak up and bring up literal laws of war is what everybody who speaks online need to do before they make accusations.

[@dapengu777]

Thank you for the Video!

[@elcalich33sehead]

There's no tangible way to determine if the IDF is targeting civilians intentionally. That's why the people who want it to be true just say it.

[@num8309]

It is pretty evident that Israel is not targeting civilians in Gaza because if they were then we would be talking about hundreds of thousands to millions of civilian deaths.

[@TheNotehead]

There will inevitably be some instances where protocols are not followed or mistakes are made. This is a war, people are terrified and enraged; there is no such thing as a clean, let alone perfect, rendition of war. But the IDF has ALWAYS emphasized the importance of minimizing civilian casualties, which is what any of the thousands and thousands of former soldiers of all ages will tell you, regardless of their stance on the current government or the situation in Gaza. How many other fighting forces in the world literally drop leaflets and make phone calls to tell civilians that they are attacking and implore them to leave? How is Hamas doing on that score? They have lobbed tens of thousands of rockets at civilians. Killing as many non-combatants is exactly what their intention is. They wish to do October 7th attacks over and over again, as brutally as possible, until all Jews in the entire world are dead. So pardon me if I don’t take Israel to task for being extremely thorough in their efforts to eradicate Hamas. Military experts have pointed out that the civilian to combatant casualty ratio is probably the lowest ever seen in this sort of dense urban ratio. There’s a whole lot more than “trust me, bro” to this, and your flippancy is really unbecoming.

[@renegade1520]

Good video. Well written. It is tragic that civilians suffer so much due to war but you can’t blame it all on Jews defending themselves. Praying for Israel and for peace.

[@doctordl7757]

Why do I feel like Im watching a propaganda video

[@zik2000]

Because you are brainwashed into thinking that everything that supports Israel is automatically wrong

[@UNPACKED]

Because it challenges the narrative you've been fed for so long by showing empathy and showing another side of reality?

[@doctordl7757]

@@UNPACKED Isreal is not innocent buddy no matter how much you try to rewrite current events. Isreal blew up a hospital with civilians inside Palestine is not your land !

[@UNPACKED]

Did Israel steal Palestine? kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZnPEpIuXnq2cn6s And you do know that if a hospital is also serving as a military base, it becomes a legally justified target in war, right…?

[@doctordl7757]

@@UNPACKED So you admit that they leveled a hospital, where's that empathy you were preaching about?

[@ToriHalfon]

All this, yes!

[@UdiKoomran]

Regarding the nature of Israel’s conduct in this war and its casualties Here are some facts and insights by John Spencer a retired United States Army officer, researcher of urban warfare, serves as the chair of urban warfare studies at at West Point. His expertise is on military operations in high dense populated urban areas and subterranean warfare. Never in the history of mankind Has a regime used its own civilians as human shields not even the nazis This is a urban warfare that is unprecedented in history Please understand there are 400 miles of tunnels dug under Gaza that the hamas built with western aid funding and zero bomb shelters for the population in Gaza Yet unlike London underground in World War 2 Hamas forbids any civilians to take shelter in these tunnels