Does Oxford Rail Make the Best Wagons?

[@samgarnett9174]

I’m mightily impressed with Oxford rail wagons. Just bought myself a beautifully weathered one which looks incredible and so reasonably priced

[@E350tb]

Whoever wins, Dapol loses. Excellent video!

[@ILikeTransport]

Whoever wins in steam category Dapol loses, whoever loses in modern image category Dapol definitely doesn't loose (please @Sam'sTrains do 2 categories)

[@ioqid8440]

I feel like heljan is worse

[@ILikeTransport]

@@ioqid8440 actually that sounds about right!

[@SamsTrains]

haha you may be right!!! ;D

[@darknekosan2091]

Nah Helljian is a miracle when its good

[@timbervalleyproductions]

I bought an oxford rail wagon today at Warley, and whilst looking around their stand, I was amused to note that they seem to have increased their prices on everyproduct - diecast vans now £7 ish instead of 4-5, and their carflats seemed ludicrously high. They did have some good bargains in the bargain bin, though

[@leroyholm9075]

Wagons: A memorable and very enjoyable series of constructional and very entertaining reviews. Sam is the man to pave and save your endeavour! Excellent

[@SamsTrains]

Many thanks Leroy, that's very kind of you indeed! Thanks for watching, Sam :)

[@ninjapenguin2371]

The little yellow door in your layout you should make it in to a loco turn table and have trains run out from it in to the the layout

[@SamsTrains]

haha that would be a lot of fun! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@hippsthehippo9804]

Im a simple man I see sams trains I click

[@SamsTrains]

haha you're very kind mate! :3 Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@hippsthehippo9804]

@@SamsTrains NP I love model railways in fact im saving up

[@bjoe385]

Hippsthehippo you’ll need to do a lot of that, but it’s worth it.

[@hippsthehippo9804]

@@bjoe385 yeah

[@iceeblueburst03]

I'm gonna give the 3 Oxford Rail mineral wagons an A. This must've been the highest grade that I have given so far! :P I love the details on the wagons and I like how clear the writing is on the sides. I also love the colors on the wagons. And for the price you spent, it's definitely worth it! :)

[@SamsTrains]

Glad to hear that - a very deserving A! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@SqueezeboxOfDelights]

I've got a few of my uncle's old mainline wagons, and they are very nice. They've got very fine detailing and lovely colours, but they are sturdy enough to withstand being dropped/derailed as they don't have as much of the tiny wire details as some top-of-the-range modern ones do. Unfortunately you can only get them second hand now.

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah the Mainline ones are very nice actually - I wonder if Bachmann still produce any of them? Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@CarminesRCTipsandTricks]

THIS would sway this Yank to run a pre-war British Train more than anything I've seen!! The lettering and details are stunning! £30 for three?? That may seem like a lot to you... but here in the Colonies, £30 wouldn't buy you a SINGLE US Boxcar of that quality. Some of those are even approaching $FIFTY!! (abt £41!) Again, for a SINGLE Wagon!! So WHAT ours have 8 wheels instead of 4... It still doesn't warrant the cost for HO Scale Trains HERE!! That notwithstanding, outstanding Review! Carmine ✈🚂🚙

[@SamsTrains]

Blimey - how come you guys get ripped off so badly?! That's crazy stuff! :O Glad you enjoyed it, Sam :)

[@CarminesRCTipsandTricks]

...... I believe sadly, because too many of us Yanks - have more money than BRAINS!! 😖 I'm definitely not one of those. I haven't been able to afford a new ANYTHING in over 6 years. 😞

[@deanwilliams5466]

Hey Sam I'm a Bachmann man where wagons are concerned but however everyone makes differing wagons. The 7 plank is a tipper wagon so one end would of opened on the prototype. Love your vids man

[@SamsTrains]

Sounds fantastic Dean - I'm looking forward to doing the Bachmann ones! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@terencebennison6275]

Hi Sam, I'm fairly new to this hobby and looking at the level of detail on these wagons, well its impressive. I suppose they are made in China and I would love to see them actually being made, I mean there's got to be a fair amount of hand crafting going on with them and for 10 quid I think they are good value for money. Enjoying your videos Sam and liking and commenting on them.

[@SamsTrains]

Hey Terry, glad you liked these - yes they're made in China, and i'd love to watch them being made too - fascinating stuff! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@thepope1332]

Hi Sam! I personally think Oxford make the best rolling stock by far. In fact, I ordered 4 plank wagons and a cattle van from them yesterday (coincidence?) and I also own their railgun! They really are great quality and are cheeper that hornby and baccmann rolling stock of equal to inferior quality! Your recent review of hornby's lswr brake van also helped me to make the decision to buy it, so thanks! Anyway, great vid as always! Rowan

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah I have a feeling that may be my conclusion too - do love their products! Glad to hear the vids were some help :3 Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@shiny2dope]

Hey Sam, thanks for the vid as always. You might already know this, but when you get to looking at Bachmann wagons note that the newer tooled ones (item numbers starting with 37 or 38) are more detailed than the older ones (numbers starting with 33 or 34). Have a look at photos in the preowned section of Hattons for examples. Thanks mate!

[@SamsTrains]

My pleasure - duly noted - are the older ones cheaper than these then?? Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@farric1]

I recently bought a couple of 3 pack 7 plank end door wagons weathered in BR grey. They run very well indeed. Take a magnifying glass to the fine detail and you will be awestruck. I bought a couple of bachmann versions and they are also good but lack the detail inside the wagon and cost more. BTW I have a short clip of a crosti 9f pulling a long train of all the aforementioned as well as some DAPOL EGG VANS in the rake. They all run fine together. I'll send you the clip if you like.

[@SamsTrains]

Glad to hear that Craig - were those Oxford ones?? Yeah I'd love to see that! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@Thoroughly_Wet]

That bit of white lining on the wheels really does it for me. Small details like that really help

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah me too - I loved that!! :D

[@LNERA3PRODUCTIONS]

if the wagons or any roling stock looks good and runs well im happy

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah! Ultimately I agree with you! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@theeveningstar9235]

I own a Coppice wagon and it’s absolutely amazing. Please can you review some model steam traction engines or steam rollers. Thanks

[@SamsTrains]

Great to hear that mate - they are excellent aren't they?! Great suggestion - I may do that! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@DalekBuilder]

Those Oxford wagons really are quite nice for the money. Be interesting to see how the other manufacturers compare to them. I haven't really paid much attention to wagons but realise things have moved on from the Hornby and mainline waggons I used to own. Another really nice review Sam. You are 100% guilty of resparking my interest in model railways.

[@SamsTrains]

They certainly are Paul - I'm looking forward to doing the rest - I haven't paid much attention to them either thus far! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@therealvbw]

I must say, never had and issues with D-WORD, the only issue was the moving couplings were sometimes hard to join

[@SamsTrains]

haha glad to hear that mate - you're a more patient man than I am! ;D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@TheGodsrighthandman]

Tilmanstone was one of the last 3 Pits on the Kent Coalfield along with Snowdon & Betteshangar. Being relatively near to the coast they all needed pumping out 24/7, I believe, but the pumps were shut down when Arthur Scargill threw his rattle out of the pram trying to hit Mrs. T.. After the Miners went back it was too late to save the mines due to nigh irreversible flooding so they were forced to close anyway. Kent felt emptier, somehow, when the mines had gone :/

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks for the info on that, I'd never heard of those before - cheers! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@KameronCousin]

Great job Sam! The Oxford Rail wagons look amazing! :D

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks Kameron - glad you liked them! :D Cheers, Sam :)

[@joshualoynes7408]

Picked a bunch of oxford plank wagons for £2.45 each, picked up 5 and have a nice small rake of them. Brilliant detail, well built, and for me a great bargain 😂

[@SamsTrains]

Blimey that's crazy - how did you get them so cheap?! :O These were 3 for £30, I mis-spoke at the start ;) Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@joshualoynes7408]

@@SamsTrains There is a small shop that has been in business for about 100 years, they've always sold model trains and at the end of each they perform a series of sales, on the last day the offer is half the price of the last sale price, so for the last 3 years I've picked up some mega bargains from there, for example the Bachmann Ambulance train set for £83, the shop is Langely. Deffo worth a look into

[@stevemanklow5128]

Tilmanstone was a colliery in the East Kent coal-field (yes, we had one!), pause the video at 6:37

[@SamsTrains]

Duly noted Steve, thanks for the info! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@danprice7973]

Perfect idea for a video! I’ve just bought the pack of 3 wagons from Oxford Rail. My first wagons, and they’re great

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks very much Dan - really glad you like yours! :D Cheers, Sam :)

[@raymondanthony127]

Have you tried or considered trying out building a Parkside Models wagon kits? I recently finished building a brake van and it came out pretty good. Not perfect, but definitely good for a first time. Next time I build a Parkside kit, it should come out better now that I have experience. I will get another brake van soon and have a boxvan kit on the way. Not too long ago, I took a chance on a D---- GWR boxvan and had a somewhat similar experience to yours. I swapped out the wheels for Hornby 3-hole Disc wheels and there was significant improvement. No more derailing. Now to try and figure out how to retro fit Bachmann couplings. One can never have too many wagons. Of course I prefer to call them trucks. -Cheers

[@SamsTrains]

That sounds great - I'd love to give that a try, thanks a lot for the recommendation! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@bentullett6068]

I have a two of the larger wagon related items from Oxford rail which are the rail gun and a war well with a oxford diecast steam roller load. Obviously you inspired me to get the rail gun but the war well was brought as I liked the load and I must say its well detailed for its price along with the steam roller on top. It's worth getting a war well as they do a choice of one with the steam roller load or one with a Sherman tank load.

[@SamsTrains]

Glad to hear that Ben - glad you like the warwell - I'm thinking of getting one! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@bentullett6068]

@@SamsTrains best warwells to buy are the ones with the loads added like the WW2 Sherman tank or the War Department steam roller (one I have).

[@simontheplantsman]

Nostalgia draws me to Hornby but I’ve noticed the attention to detail particularly with Oxford...I’m trying to restock 2nd 🤚🏼 and notice Oxford have silly prices on the 2nd 🤚🏼 market such as EBAY...recommendations for restocking quickly goods wagons etc..bought my favourite recently, a flat bed blue wagon by Hornby with the Llanf.....unpronounceable welsh name. Love it and runs like a dream Excellent review topic

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah I'm with you there Simon - looking forward to seeing the result! Ooh yes I know the one - they look awesome! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@woodenrailway123]

Another Brill video, really enjoyed this idea of comparing wagons and seeing who's is best definatley changed my mind about Oxford rail wagons I've seen a few but never really took any notice but now I'm definatley gunna have to keep my eye for them and pick them up, great video as always... Tom

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks very much mate - I'm hoping it will be great fun! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@Shauniboy1984]

Great set of reviews Sam - Id say my shoddiest modern wagon is a Dapol. De-rails all the time, brake decoration fell off and stupidly lite. If it wasn't a company local to me Id have returned it I think

[@andycromwell8229]

can you also include how the kadee work/ are compatible with the rolling stock. It is useful to know if the no 18 just fits in or if the manufacture has the height wrong!

[@TheRiverLeW]

0:19 When you really gotta get a cow across town, but there are no cattle wagons.

[@SamsTrains]

haha!! ;D

[@Lennon6412]

For all the faults with their Dean Goods, their wagons are brilliant. Great detail, I hope they expand the range!

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah they certainly are - I can't fault these! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@karabiner002]

If you count preowned wagons then mainline ones would be the best in my opinion. You can pick them up for same price as oxford ones (or slightly cheaper) and there's a bit more variation in liveries and wagon designs (again, in my opinion).

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah Mainline wagons were great - I could look at those one day too! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@thequietestengine]

10:47 aaah the Dean Goods again, very lovely model and perfect for this kind of train ^^

[@SamsTrains]

Thank you! Yes I do love that engine! :D Cheers, Sam :)

[@Steamjammer]

I grew up in Cannock, so I'm a bit geographically biased towards towards the Coppice Colliery wagon. Though, even accounting for that, it's still the best of the three!

[@SamsTrains]

Ahh good to hear that - yes a very lovely wagon that one! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@hsgunderson3152]

I'm glad you like the Coppice as I purchased that one myself back in December.

[@SamsTrains]

I very much do - really happy with that one! Glad you got one too! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@michaeldavies9600]

I purchased the Janus shunter pack from Hattons and it came with 3 ICI wagons, they do run lovely.A good interesting video Sam :)

[@SamsTrains]

That's great to hear Michael - a real bargain that! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@Ste1952]

Have you reviewed any Accurascale wagons as yet?

[@SamsTrains]

Never! Are they any good?? :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@toy1606]

+1 on accurascale. Really highly detailed models and great customer service as well

[@OmegaInfinityAlpha]

I just checked Oxford's site. Each of the individual cars are only 10 pounds (about $13 american). Even factoring in the shipping to get from UK to US, Oxford really can't be beat in terms of price if you just want to fill out your rolling stock.

[@SamsTrains]

Blimey, that's definitely good isn't it?! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@matthorn9209]

I would love you to run the tilman stone wagon with your green oxford adams radial because I just found out that the small font under colliery says "empty to east kent light railway".

[@SamsTrains]

Ooh that'd be awesome - feel free to request it during the next live stream if you like! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@davidmolin8944]

I may not be a HO or OO modeler but I still know a good wagon or engine when I see one and my favorite producer of wagon is KATO a Japanese model railroad company who specializes in N scale but have some HO's as well

[@SamsTrains]

I've heard great things about KATO too, I'll have to check them out! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@davidmolin8944]

@@SamsTrains your welcome and if you ever get a HO scale Kato engine or wagon you can be sure that it will be top notch quality

[@thegremlin1999]

I have the Coppice Collieries wagon because it’s local to where my Dad grew up. The modern wagons are lovely and I really like the Oxford ones. The D**** ones are often too light for my liking though. Damn, I need more private owner wagons now!

[@SamsTrains]

Sounds great Phil! Yes the Dapol ones do tend to be pretty light too! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@johnrobson4230]

Excellent detailing, really look good those are going to take some beating!

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks a lot John - I think so too! ;D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@chielvanderkolk4830]

Hello Sam, I think I heard you saying that you'd buy one of Hornby's new Princess Coronations when at a reasonable price. TheModelCentre has R3642 6 46232 Duchess of Montrose for £133, and I think it's a great price for such a beautiful model.

[@SamsTrains]

Blimey, that is a very good price! :O Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@ausfoodgarden]

I'm a bit like you and buy a lot of crusty old wagons but the Oxford rail one's are nice and not too expensive. I have a few of them. I do hope you look at the recently retooled Hornby 3 plank wagons as they are excellent too. Cheers

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks a lot Gerry - yes they make a nice change don't they? Sure, I can take a look at those! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@trmn311]

Beautiful wagons! The detail and decoration is first rate!

[@SamsTrains]

Cheers mate, I agree with that! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@AMOGLES99]

My understanding is that in the Big Four days, virtually all privately owned wagons were for coal. The reason being that customers would use the wagons for storing and stockpiling coal and hence owners would wait a long time to have them returned. The Big Four companies thus starting charging rent on a per day basis and basically forced customers to switch to wagons of their own. In some cases the situation got so extreme that they outright refused to allow their own wagons to be be shunted onto private sidings where they would lose control over how long they stayed. Coal wagons with Big Four markings were thus typically reserved for locomotive coal or for private customers who would unload at company sidings. All other types of coal went in wagons owned either by the customer or by the colliery. Other types of freight such as perishables and other high value goods would see a quick turnover and wagons would be returned quickly meaning the Big Four companies didn't have to resort to nasty tricks and were quite happy continuing to provide their own wagons for this type of goods. Most box vans and such with private markings from that period have no basis in history.

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks very much for the fascinating information there - duly noted and appreciated! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@ukhawkeye]

just a point of interest on your review of the coppice coal wagon for people who like historical accuracy the Coppice wagon would proberly been based at thje coppice colliery which was at Heath Hayes near Cannock (for those with a historical intrest the colliery opened in 1983 and closed in 1964) keep up the excellent work Sam

[@SamsTrains]

Duly noted mate, thanks a lot for the info! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@peterjennings6072]

Imo my fave wagons are oxford rails fulton weathered wagons theyre stunning

[@SamsTrains]

Great to hear that - yes the Oxford wagons are always excellent! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@delaray7]

Coppice my favourite, too. Good choice, buddy. Thanks for this interesting review

[@SamsTrains]

Good one Ray, very nice that one! Thanks for watching, Sam :)

[@Jakefrc]

Hey sam, I’m glad you covered the coupling in the video. I have mostly Bachman wagons which couple nicely and behave reasonably well on decoupling ramps, however one of my Hornby wagons does not like the decoupling ramp at all. The little coupling hook locks up when it’s pushed up. Otherwise it operates smoothly. Have you had any issues like this before?

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks Jacob - that doesn't sound good, I'll look out for that when I do the Hornby ones! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@bobfuller]

If you are able, a helpful addition to your wagon reviews would be whether they are compatible with Kadee couplings. Is there room to fit Kadee couplings and do the attachment points meet the standard height criteria needed for Kadees.

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks Bob - but all wagons should be kadee compatible, if they're NEM, they should be at a standard height! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@bobfuller]

@@SamsTrains not according to Charlie's video kzbin.info/www/bejne/nJjVgWZudpaaoZI. Go to 15 mins into the video. There are a lot of height variations, apparently.

[@CampervanJon]

Great finish you can read all the writing and detail is fantastic

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah absolutely - wonderful wagons for sure! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@CampervanJon]

Got a couple saved for purchase soon, thanks for the review would not even have considered them

[@cooljoeyski5190]

I enjoy your videos Sam. You always do a great job with the reviews. I also like the selection of wagons. Thank you.

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks very much Joey, that's very kind of you! :3 Cheers, Sam :)

[@Chadington_Steve]

I'm all about collecting trucks, coached and different types of rolling stock

[@SamsTrains]

Glad to hear that Liam - I love them too! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@DangerAngelous]

Can you have a look at reviewing a few different brands of airfix-style kit wagons? I bought one second hand because I was fascinated by actual 3-link couplings on it, then I looked up that they're cheaper by a (Australian Standard Measurement AS069) f***tonne too!

[@SamsTrains]

That sounds great - I'd like to try that, but I'm a bit useless with kits ;) Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@naven2802]

Loving that Coppice wagon. I’d get some myself but I’m saving up for the new Hornby Class 255 sliding door MK3s. Probably something to look into after I get me castle set sorted.

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks a lot mate - that's fair enough, those definitely aren't cheap! ;D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@mrdreaded8865]

That is some fantastic looking wagons ! Looks great behind the Dean Goods loco !

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks mate, glad you liked seeing that! :D Cheers, Sam :)

[@MoleculeMind7]

Wondering if you reviewed the black label A4’s from dapol

[@SamsTrains]

I never have - they were a bit too pricey for me :( Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@mattclass9176]

Clearly you make the best wagon. I’d pay a lot for the cow wagon! 😂

[@jackhromadka6842]

You mean Bullman? I don’t think Sam can part with Bullman just yet!

[@mattclass9176]

Jack Hromadka yep that’s the one! I agree it’s too special for him to part with it!

[@ILikeTransport]

You could ask if he can make a slightly different one to sell you

[@jackhromadka6842]

I like Transport or, you can make your own with a well flatbed and a OO gauge bull

[@jackhromadka6842]

Also some glue

[@Emma-tv9nm]

Lovely wagons. Thanks for the amazing video Sam.

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks Emma, that's my pleasure! :D

[@PHsRailwayVideos]

I have the Oxford 7-plank wagon in the Stoke-on-Trent 'Bass Brewery' livery, and the painting livery is excellent. Can you do the Dapol 8-plank wagon? It's actually kind of decent, no derailing issues this time.

[@SamsTrains]

Oh very nice - glad to hear yours is good too! I'll take a look into that - good suggestion! :D Cheers, Sam :)

[@miniroll32]

I made the great mistake of purchasing a load of Dapol wagons as they were reduced. They looks fantastic, but my god I reckon 1 out of every 3 had wobbly wheels.

[@iceeblueburst03]

My favorite Oxford Rail mineral wagon in this video might have to be the Coppice wagon since I like the red and black.

[@SamsTrains]

Glad you liked that one too mate - lovely aren't they?? :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@Timwellsphotos]

I do enjoy watching this type of video from you Sam, Although I model in N gauge my son has 00 so I check out what you have to say when it comes to this gauge and it does help me choose for my 8 year old boy and his trains. Thanks and keep it up

[@SamsTrains]

Great to hear that mate, thanks very much! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@tubs1725]

Despite your experience with the egg vans, dapol used to make some nice wagons around the early-mid 2000s. I had one from my old model shop, but the box was absolutely battered, so I had to chuck it, which means the wagon eventually got lost

[@bentullett6068]

I have some of these Dapol wagons that were made in the early mid 2000's and your right they looked good and had sensible couplings, not like the new ones.

[@SamsTrains]

I agree that they're nice - just not very reliable :( Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@evanswoodcentral315]

Great video and excellent review Sam of three awesome wagons. I have the Coppice wagon in my fleet and i agree it is stunning, one of the best wagons of its type i've ever seen. By the way Hornby own a decent percentage of Oxford Rail. Keep safe, regards Gary.

[@SamsTrains]

Cheers Gary - glad you liked them, they are really stunning aren't they? They do indeed - let's hope they don't interfere too much with them! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@bjoe385]

I quite like Hornby Railways wagons/tank wagons.

[@SamsTrains]

Awesome! I'm looking forward to trying some new ones! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@donsharpe5786]

The Oxford Rail wagons are excellent value. For my use, I would need to dull down the decoration because they are as new, which I don't want. The important part is do they run well and are they good value.

[@SamsTrains]

I agree Don - hey that'd make for a fantastic little project?! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@donsharpe5786]

@@SamsTrains I have bought a range of acrylic weathered wood paints to experiment on a number of wagons.

[@twonkfieldrailways4110]

personally I think Parkside kits are the best first theres the fun of building it, then the level of detail is brilliant, then you can have what ever livery you choose, I've painted one of mine with a custom company name on the side inaccurate but quite cool. tough in terms of rtf I think you've started with the best. Oxford is the best of both worlds; Hornbys price and Bachmanns quality.

[@SamsTrains]

Sounds great mate, I'll have to look into those! Maybe I did start with the best, uh oh! ;D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@ModelRailwaysUnlimited]

Hi Sam, Oxford rail will get my vote to be honest, they make really nice quality affordable stuff. The wagons are all pre ww2 based on a railway clearing house specification, hence the under frames being the same. All unfitted as well. Can the makers plates on the sole bar be read?

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks Mike - that may well be the outcome for me too - just love their stuff! :D Yes they were all legible I believe! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@OlivierGabin]

About your comment on Oxford Rail wagons, you just let me wanting to buy three dozen of them ! Perfectly agreed on your test. About other brands, my subjective point of view, based on the models I have recently bought, makes me say that with Hornby and Bachmann, you generally have good vehicles, but with some lemons from time to time. E. g. the “car bumpers-like couplers” series of Hornby, and some Bachmann's below today's expectation (e. g. ref. 37-706A, cattle van NE brown, a little coarse with the details). With D****, yes, they show their age as 1970's old Airfix series, and with outdated quality paintings and lettering. Half the price they are sold, why not, but at the same price as other manufacturers, there is no reason to buy them. Well, let's wait for the next episode, this would be very interesting I guess. Have a nice day !

[@SamsTrains]

Oops sorry about that Oliver! Yeah I'd agree with that - though I didn't mind the age of the Dapol stuff, just the constant derailments and rubbish couplings ;) Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@OlivierGabin]

@@SamsTrains Thanks for the precisions, it is something to take care of. I have seen your video on the egg vans before buying one of them (what I did not do, thanks for the information !) and I am seeing what to buy instead. For some types of wagons, there is not a lot of choice... Bachmann can be a good substitute for vans, I have seen, and bought, some 20 tonners coke hoppers at Hornby's (their ref. R6831 is pretty decent for instance) and I expect somebody to make the grain wagons Dapol have on their catalogue. If the CEO of Oxford rail read this one, he's got a customer, and many more, if his society sells this kind of wagon ! So, I would certainly be nice with the age of Dapol's molds if their wagon can stay on the tracks when you haul them, and also shunt them ! About the crappy couplers, I'm expecting Chadwick Model Railways next video on Kadees to build my opinion on this point. Some modelers use them happily for their increased reliability in operations, but there is a potential issue with NEM versions. I'm not sure of it, and highly dubious about it (it comes from french modellers, which I do not trust, except for doing costly nonsenses and silly elitism, that's one of the reasons why I'm doing UK trains !). So I need a second opinion, and if this issue is not something big, trying to use Kadees on Dapols might be a solution. I will tell you about it when I've get more informations on it.

[@willpullen3053]

Having bought wagons from each of the major manufacturers, I have to say I like Oxford Rail's offerings the most. The level of detail and overall quality feel are fantastic given the price point, which seems to be consistently lower than Bachmann and Hornby for wagons of comparable quality. Bachmann, to me, are middle of the road. I'm happy to pick up Bachmann wagons second hand but I seldom buy any new given (to my mind) the superior quality of Oxford Rail. I've never been much of a fan of Hornby's wagons, though I did recently purchase a couple of the SR cattle wagons which are superb. Where do I start with Dapol 😂

[@SamsTrains]

Glad to hear that Will - I may come to the same conclusion! I agree on the price - Oxford do seem to be much better! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@theretrocrowe9389]

When you do the bachmann video of this series, you should get the 31-081tl pack. Probably the best wagons in my collection.

[@SamsTrains]

Great idea - I'll definitely look into those! :D Cheers, Sam :)

[@jamieevans4475]

Accurascale wagons have set the bar for detail please please review Sam

[@SamsTrains]

Ooh sounds good Jamie - I'll have to try some! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@raykiii]

This is a great idea, Sam. Can't wait to see how the others stack up. In your country you have some really detailed and fun modelers. When I was running HO Scale here in the U.S. I had to build the models to get the details and you had to really look at the paint work in the shops before you bought them. Athearn had the best castings but sometimes the painting was fussy, or not clear to read. I'm running N Scale now and I like the Atlas brand the most. Sam, if this is well received, could you do the same with coaches?

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks a lot Ray - I'm looking forward to that also, should be very interesting! Good idea with the coaches - I may look into that! :D Cheers, Sam :)

[@raykiii]

@@SamsTrains Here's an update. I went to a train show last weekend and pickup two buildings (kind of). One is a hot dog stand made out of a caravan and the other is an ice cream stand made out of a caravan. I've been looking at these models online and found them at the same price at the show but no shipping charge. I get them home and flip them over and they are Oxford models. So we do get some good stuff here that are made by you guys. LOL

[@sweed6487]

Stuff you could do with kits can be as good or even better, but I understand ready-to-run stuff

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah that's true - though I'm useless at kits ;) Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@LNER985]

Personally, I think Bachmann makes the best wagons, I know they are not cheap new but you can pick up them for good prices at exhibitions and I have two Oxford wagons. That has one of their couplings pockets not probably in place as sometimes fall off the wagon and the Oxford range doesn't yet enough variety of wagon types yet to consider as the best range of wagons.

[@SamsTrains]

Interesting John - I'm looking forward to doing the Bachmann one - it all depends on whether the extra detail outweighs the increase in price! You are right about the selection available though. Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@rydermike33]

Top notch rolling stock. They'll certainly take some beating. Great stuff, many thanks Sam.

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks a lot Mike - I think they'll take some beating too! ;D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@jameschorley1711]

I do enjoy watching your video Sam ,keep up the good work

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks James, really appreciate it mate! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@therealvbw]

Quite possibly! Got an oxford wagon from an assorted pile at Hornby Visitor Center Margate, £7.50. Very nice detail and even factory weathering, for a great price. (that sounded like an advert) By the way, can you post the background music from demonstrating items (0:12) in the description of each video? Thanks :)

[@SamsTrains]

Blimey that's fantastic - glad you got a good deal there! I can look at doing that, I don't know the names of lots of them xD Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@RobA500]

Hornby models in Swindon does the same, that’s how I got most of my oxford rail wagons

[@JohnPW22]

Great wagons reviews - just watched in almost reverse order - stopped to come back now going forward again! Anyhoo, lovely as the Oxford are Sam, your affiliate link unfortunately takes me to a selection of wagons on Hattons that firstly lists some wagons starting Da... with a branding of Oxford. Thought you'd like to know.... Keep em coming! Really enjoyed these!

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks a lot John - ahh I wasn't aware of this, I'll investigate! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@davidstrains4910]

Great video Sam

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks a lot David! :D

[@upwellonwards7373]

though Oxford mainly do mineral wagons but i love the quality and detail level oxford do my go to wagons as their cheaper than both hornby or bachmann in nz

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah so do I - let's hope they expand their range! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@Mason58654]

Britain’s rolling stock, whether locos, coaches or trucks were and are all outstandingly gorgeous!

[@SamsTrains]

haha I know - I agree with you! Thanks for watching, Sam :)

[@joelightrailway2362]

Excellent review of these amazing Oxford Rail Wagons Sam 👍 I think £30 is not bad for a pack of three wagons as that fair to have for anyone who starting into the hobby. One good fact of the Best House Coals wagon is the name of the town of Cannock and it not far of a colliery heritage line called the Chasewater Railway as well another fact of the Tilmanstone wagon is also from a colliery in Kent.

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks very much Joe! :D

[@Mike-no6fv]

Imo: Hornby for coaches Bachmann and Oxford both for freight stock

[@jackhromadka6842]

Immediately noticed the Bullman shirt at the start of the video

[@SamsTrains]

haha! Moo! ;D

[@xenon53827]

But did you see Bullman at 0:20 ?

[@jackhromadka6842]

xenon53827 yes I did! Bullman is awesome

[@kyldeking]

I love the Oxford Rail wagons because I use a chain link system and they are a good price also I love the video.

[@SamsTrains]

Yeah me too Kyle - do they take the chain links okay?? Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@kyldeking]

@@SamsTrains they take the chains great (and it is not Kyle but Kylian but you're easily forgiven)

[@greghale9972]

Hello Sam, Being quite light I am wondering how well they would go attached immediately behind a loco then followed by say six [6] wagons of approx. 45 grams which seems to be the recommended weight for small freight wagons. Would they derail on your layout on the sharpest curve...............Cheers Greg

[@SamsTrains]

I'd say that should be absolutely fine Greg - I've had many more than 6 wagons running behind these before, no problems! Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@TreniFS_]

It's weird to hear your comments about the price: here in Italy, H0 wagons and engines usually cost 3 times the price of similar 00 rolling stock in the UK. Usually. Sometimes they make super-detailed models and the prices go crazy. Anyway, nice video and see you in the next one :-)

[@SamsTrains]

Blimey is that so? I think £10 is more than enough - and Oxford prove that it can be done! :O Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@TreniFS_]

@@SamsTrains I don't know if it is a matter of economy of scale or whatever, and I'm not sure it would always be possible to sell for those prices, but I'd be so happy to be wrong! Thanks for your answer :-)

[@davidtucker8724]

I do like Oxford rail wagons, great value for money! Sam have you tried the Oxford rail mk3s? Also very good and highly detailed.

[@SamsTrains]

Me too David - fantastic! I haven't tried their MK3s, I might do! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@robmasterman]

Interesting review Sam, in the beginning you said you had a bargain of three wagons for 'Ten quid' then shortly afterwards they became 'Ten quid each'...still a great review though...Bob

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks a lot Bob - no it was three wagons at £10 each, 3 for £30 - I mis-spoke at the start of the video! ;D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@the4tierbridge]

Sam, I’ve noticed that besides Bachman, you tend to stay from other American model trains. Have you ever tried MTH, Caboose Industries, or Lionel, all of which make HO scale trains. It would be nice, as an American, for you to review those to. I bring this because I recently went to the “ Worlds Greatest Hobby on Tour” train-show at the Dulles expo center. It was great, and it got me thinking about the subject of this comment. Great video! P.S I think Hornby will win your completion of the rolling stock.

[@SamsTrains]

I haven't tried those - I do tend to keep things British - but I might expand one day! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@lewishughes8541]

Hi Sam oxford certainly do they look the part and the detail is on point

[@SamsTrains]

They really do Lewis, glad you agree! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@jamesdunloptrains]

Loved the video today Sam you can’t go wrong with Oxford rail rolling stock

[@SamsTrains]

Cheers James, yes I agree with that! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@russellbenton2987]

Oxford look good . Great printing on them. If you think these are expensive at £10 a shot , have a look at Bachmann . Outrageous prices for old tooling .

[@LNER985]

£10 a wagon isn't that bad.

[@SamsTrains]

haha yes I've been doing some shopping, and I'm getting a flavour of that for sure ;) Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@russellbenton2987]

John trainfan101 how about £31 for a 4 wheel grain hopper that dates from Trix times

[@russellbenton2987]

Sam'sTrains always entertaining and informative Sam, particularly the Garrett video

[@LNER985]

@@russellbenton2987 I wouldn't pay that much for a wagon from the 80s or 90s.

[@jasonpike1724]

Hello Sam, have ever made a video about how to wire a large DC layout?

[@SamsTrains]

I never have Jason, but I may do! :D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@tfukyfguygiughiughiughiugh6275]

Sweet & quality looking wagons - you should have them filled with stuff like sand/grain/etc for better realism. When I was a kid playing my toy railway sets, I was making sure the train carry something to somewhere where it's needed. xD

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks a lot mate, yes that'd be a great idea - good suggestion! haha I used to love that too! ;D Thanks for watching - Sam :)

[@alancarpenter2070]

Hi Sam, good video. It's not surprising that all of the underframes are the same. In full size they tended to use standard chassis as they were easier and cheaper to build and maintain. Likewise the bodies. The lettering is beautifully crisp and clear but, in full size they wouldn't stay that way for very long, in fact, they often became quite illegible. As far as weight and couplings etc. are concerned, in America, the "NMRA" have a whole list of requirements that all manufacturers are required to adhere to. These cover wheel standards, coupling height, weight for each type of wagon (Car), and many more, to maintain very high standards of running etc. It would be useful if we in the UK had such a set of standards. As far as price is concerned, some of our wagon kits can cost considerably more and then, you have to build, paint and decorate them yourself and, some of the transfers leave a lot to be desired. Rant over. Regards, Alan.

[@SamsTrains]

Thanks a lot Alan - yeah I didn't mind that at all - still fantastic for the money! I agree it would be useful - too many couplings sit at the wrong height these days! :O Thanks for watching - Sam :)