Does the sky exist? (objection.lol)

[@magicalhead]

Imagine actually believing the sky exists, couldn't be me

[@Cristi20071]

...

[@FireyDeath4]

Yep! It's an ontological illusion. We wouldn't live well if we decided there was such a thing as "the sky" and then had to handpick which particles are part of it, which particles are not part of it, and where the boundaries are at different times for when they become a part of the sky or not. We should just accept the fact that there are aerial molecules reasonably close to us at many different distances, and stop bothering about whatever the sky could be.

[@loisebahjin1105]

So ur saying it doesn't exist...?

[@Furbyvvitch4ever]

Objection!! Blasphemy.

[@FireyDeath4]

@@Furbyvvitch4ever Oh, so now skies are part of blasology? Sky

[@Nanachi-n-Mitty]

Phoenix: "who would want to try and prove the sky is fake?" Edgeworth: *phases into existence* "I don't want to but I have to."

[@-General_Bek-]

They force him

[@iamwoke322]

???: *the plot demands*

[@gonwyte8534]

That was the funniest part of the whole video. He just phases in, hunched over, looking like he's about fo burst a blood vessel lol

[@ultimatedanganronpafan869]

"I was paid (insert godly pile of money here) and I still despise this"

[@YuanGaming12]

He ended up switching sides anyways

[@1Korlash]

Honestly, I can see Edgeworth defecting if told to prove garbage conspiracy theories like this. Well played, good sir.

[@adumba3709]

Oh my God I thought you said "defecating"

[@Ilias2]

@@adumba3709 💀

[@Alchemyyyyyy]

@@adumba3709he was just ugh having anxiety abt how things like this exist

[@Shadethewolfy]

I mean, to be fair. In the first game, he actually defects to uncover the truth of what Dee Vasquez did. So it's entirely within character for him.

[@bloodshade1650]

I love how Edgeworth got so fed up with the client, that he decided to switch sides

[@brolytriplethreat]

Not the first time. I mean he didn't switch literal desks, but there was a definite team up

[@Vlumpty_Vonty]

​@@brolytriplethreat he did in bridge to the turnabout

[@Dreamswap]

I would too.

[@Moon-a-Stan-Fan]

Guy did a Romania in ww2 (google it Romania switched sides several times)

[@markob8934]

It’s understandable Alex is straight up moronic (I would of done the same and tell Alex to put a sock in it to shut her up

[@Ultranger]

I’m surprised the prosecution didn’t try to claim that the sun was a giant lightbulb

[@AsmarahKhan]

*_I'm also suprised that they didn't claim the moon as a cheese wheel floating in the sky_*

[@bettycreepersayuri-chan809]

_Is that a OneShot reference?_

[@Dahaka-rd6tw]

HOLD IT! Edgeworth: WHAT SORT OF BRAIN-DEAD TROGLODYTE YOU TAKE ME FOR?!

[@Someonecalledeli]

@@bettycreepersayuri-chan809 Y E S .

[@catmaster8232]

you only have one shot.

[@asoftraiden]

Phoenix and Edgeworth was literally the only ones who shouldn't be accused for using illegal substances.

[@korhol2065]

I don’t know, could be a trick… how do we know you aren’t on illegal substances?

[@prerakgames4668]

@@korhol2065 how do we know YOU aren't on illegal substances

[@BottleOfMilk5252]

Wait a minute... WHAT IF WE'RE ALL USING ILLEGAL SUBSTANCES WITHOUT KNOWING?! LIKE SOMEONE POISONED THE WATER WITH STUFF!

[@theenderdestruction2362]

@@BottleOfMilk5252 someone posted the town well and they did a shit job of it

[@elainegoates9792]

Including the judge

[@luccaconjulusa4218]

Phoenix: questions everything Edgeworth: fades into existence to agree

[@spongefan155]

"We can't really sue the sky" That Is The Best Sentence Ever Created

[@-General_Bek-]

Same

[@Skullhawk13]

Not with that attitude

[@pikadragon2783]

They tried to sue God once, so ther is that.

[@theobamaprism]

COME AT ME ZEUS- *gets zapped*

[@ham_the_spam4423]

@@pikadragon2783and rats. They had to try writing notices and letters that they would understand.

[@djzar6188]

Bruh, Edgeworth just fades into existence at 1:20 😂

[@PAWSAREONGRASS]

270 likes and no comments? 😮lemme fix that

[@DinoandGalaxy]

He’s so tired 😭

[@whar3]

von karma’s hand ceases to exist at 6:32

[@collinpersinger4809]

I can only hear the teleport sound from Super Mario 64 when he fades in

[@thefollower2933]

The fact that everybody is in character makes this hysterical

[@Global-yt]

I just started playing the game, and that's what struck me first

[@ralek592]

I thought your profile picture was the kaaba

[@DouglasStewart99]

4:57 Even with my limited knowledge of the Ace Attorney franchise (as of typing this), even I can tell this is probably the biggest lawyer tag team fans have probably wished could happen.

[@AmyElnah]

It honestly started happening pretty early in the franchise in some ways (not like this where he just goes to stand with phoenix). It first happened in the third case in the first game, where he gets so fed up with the bs of his witness (the murderer), that he started questioning her as if on the defence so Wright could win the case. Since in the end, all he caree about was the truth. Spoilers for other games below: In the second game, he's a close ally working together with phoenix in the final case, having to be prosecutor again but working together to stall the trial. In the third game, I think you end up playing as Edgeworth for a section, since he's filling in for Phoenix who's in the hospital.

[@Hina41508]

y e s

[@EnclavegovtofficialUSA]

​@@AmyElnah wait, that reminds me of an episode of perry mason

[@pipootkelter3289]

​@@AmyElnahwhich case do you play as Edgeworth in?

[@jarlboof]

​@pipootkelter3289 the last case of the third game, i believe its called "bridge to the turnabout"

[@fuzzyalba5419]

“Not guilty of not existing” means it exists right? I hate double negatives

[@isaiaholaru5013]

Yes

[@isaiaholaru5013]

Double negative = Positive

[@SuperFm101]

Yep it means it exists i hated those double negatives as well but you get used to it eventually

[@fuzzyalba5419]

@@SuperFm101 English is my first language and I still find them annoying

[@victoralexandervinkenes9193]

Negative two - negative two = zero

[@Worthy_Edge]

If you ask Manfred “who let him bring a gun into the courtroom” he’d just say “me lmao”

[@Dokataa]

Gumshoe would probably ignore it if given candy, also

[@Ostr0]

Ignore it and you can have a mystery flavor candy ball on stick.

[@connormcnulty6377]

He brought a gun to a courtroom? Again?

[@davianwesson7978]

77 + 33 is still 100 btw

[@RinJackson]

​@davianwesson7978 No it's not. Or am I missing a reference?

[@zavie3513]

My favorite part about this case is that Edgeworth has no clue what he's doing there either.

[@-General_Bek-]

They force him to prove "sky is fake"

[@lordscourge9395]

I actually had a hard time breathing through my laughter when Edgeworth just slowly appeared on screen. Nice video

[@-General_Bek-]

1:23

[@WaterFairyAqua]

143 likes and only 1 reply? let me fix that

[@GodOfTheJGCU]

If I’ve ever had a case in ace attorney, and Edgeworth went to Phoenix’s side, my soul would straight up leave my body

[@pavithrasanthosh6073]

i mean... ig something similar happens in turnabout samurai

[@cristiangomezmontt6248]

Von Karma: "Yes for you see, Phoenix, I created the sky in order to watch you and your plans to make you fail in court"

[@Dahaka-rd6tw]

Phoneix: "Sigh" Well IF you did, it seems that you did a poor job with it!

[@solidonseraindogthetenth1679]

@@Dahaka-rd6tw OOOO!

[@-General_Bek-]

​@@solidonseraindogthetenth1679 OOOOOOOOOÒOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

[@iamwoke322]

@@Dahaka-rd6tw Phoenix: “Kenya.” Von Karma: “Kenya what?” Phoenix: “Kenya mind your own business?”

[@GlitchyHunter]

VON KARMA NO-

[@redactedgamer1975]

4:57 Edgeworth literally went to the pause menu and hit CHANGE TEAM.

[@16Vessel]

"that isn't relevant for this case" "But it is relevant for my well-being" *Von karma pulls out a gun That got me good

[@iamwoke322]

“but it’s relevant for my well-being” Von karma: bruh ill tell you wot you fat lil-

[@starboundsingularity]

he really said it's time for dl-6 2

[@yukiyuki2-2]

"THAT'S MORE THAN OKAY WITH ME!"

[@johannamartinez9191]

Bro brang out his 600k volt stun gun dayum

[@Elaniden]

@@starboundsingularity DL-7

[@CharBot580]

*cocks gun*"let me prove that the sky is real,as you can see,normal loaded cartrige"*goes outside and fires the gun into the air*"wheres the broken screen?"

[@pickitha]

This is the most American way of proving the sky real.

[@dragon_user1609]

If it works it works

[@denizhaspolat1239]

@@dragon_user1609Couldn’t agree more

[@jasevr9533]

I’m now confused how the tv screen would be so big it could wrap around the earth.

[@samuelst-martin7472]

Hell why dont we see the base of the monitor. It cant be the endless black void of space because it goes way beyond the "tv screen"

[@evanm1337]

And even so, it would all have to be powered, as well as the creators having to have a model for the sky in the first place, as well as keeping this sky perfectly consistent with human actions such as fireworks or space launches.

[@Le_Confuzzlement]

Conspiracy theories aren't known for being well thought out

[@LorvinWolf]

Don't Tell him about The lasgegas sphere

[@nateghast6456]

Have yall heard of a Dison Sphere? (I'm misspelling it.) Theoretically a superstructure that could support its own weight could be built around a celestial body. Its parts would be held equidistantly from the center of mass if its structure was strong enough, keeping it from crashing into Earth. This was proposed originally to put around the Sun, with solar panels inside to capture energy, turning the Sun into humanity's personal battery with close to 100% efficiency. Yes, this is outlandish, but perhaps possible in a few hundred or thousand years if humanity leveraged a ridiculous amount of resources from space.

[@Nihitplayz]

i wish there was a actual court case in which edgeworth and phoenix defend together, like a spinoff which is not canon

[@anjugupta8367]

Well in the final case of JFA they both prosecute together

[@Cofivsz]

phoenix defends edgeworth in turnabout goodbyes

[@jacobnewell7845]

The sad thing is that there are people who genuinely believe this

[@Ethan13371]

Eh, I deem it better to leave them be. The solar system and all it contains will function whether people believe in it or not. You really need to be worrying about people who are misinformed in ways that change behavior tangibly. Anti-vaccination movements for example (though there are certainly cases to avoid under-tested vaccines, for instance).

[@morse2511]

Like the guy above said. Natural selection

[@plaidhatter1674]

​@@Ethan13371The key word being under tested. I can understand people being apprehensive during the hight of a pandemic, but people STILL refuse to get well tested and safe vaccines to this day. We knew a pharmacist who quit her job because of an anti vaccination mentality. Believe me, I am just as confused as you are.

[@BuddemsMorgan]

For once, Edgeworth and Phoenix actually agree on something

[@lylevillanueva8624]

Bro. They are lawyers. Not an idiot fools 😂

[@Fixon_cam]

This literally explained my whole entire science class discussion 💀

[@pickitha]

That's actually hilarious

[@NathanRibeirodeFrancaYegrosFer]

Ok, how's that one gone? Kind of curious now

[@EggsBenedictsStuff]

Legends say Nathan still awaits to this day to know how Kamii's experience was.

[@CyberTheFurry]

honestly I had more fun watching this than most youtube videos ive seen im my entire life. Thank you for the entertainment.

[@Hugo_Ma]

Same here

[@quickmations8086]

same

[@gp-1542]

I like it took phoenix a hot minute to understand the situation and immediately went bonkers

[@ladyjuno2456]

You actually could sue the sky as you can sue inanimate objects, its called in rem jurisdiction. Hugbees made a video on it, some examples are: The United States v. 422 Casks of Wine Nebraska v. One 1970 2-Door Sedan Rambler United States v. Article Consisting of 50,000 Cardboard Boxes More or Less, Each Containing One Pair of Clacker Balls And South Dakota v. Fifteen Impounded Cats

[@theguywhoseinsideyourwalls9153]

This reminds me of the time someone sued God... And won

[@ladyjuno2456]

@@theguywhoseinsideyourwalls9153 you just made me look this up and I need to add, according to Wikipedia this has actually happened 4 times and only 1 person won

[@Jump-Shack]

@@theguywhoseinsideyourwalls9153 wtf

[@elisabethsun7059]

@@theguywhoseinsideyourwalls9153What-

[@apricot8246]

@@ladyjuno2456 h u h?

[@loisebahjin1105]

Technically, the sky is the atmosphere so yes, it does exist.

[@-General_Bek-]

Facts

[@through-faith-alone]

the sky is an emergent facet of the atmosphere

[@cakes.]

this is the first time I’ve seen phoenix be smart, and i love it. PLUS an edgeworth + phoenix team-up? this is one of my favorite cases. ugh I love them being smart together 💀 it’s so satisfying favorite timestamps: 6:32 7:22

[@-General_Bek-]

You just *love* when Manfred beating himself, huh?

[@amazingnoo9935]

MAJOR table abuse, von Karma is literally vandalising the courtroom

[@cakes.]

@@amazingnoo9935lmao

[@Phoenixjkl]

1:23 Edgeworth fading in with the pose caught me off-guard so hard i almost spilled my water.

[@bozomaster69420]

hey i finally found someone that knows how to use "Take That" button correctly

[@ryanepic45]

6:17 apparently i thought he said "thats because it cuts off at Ecuador" lol

[@therealelement75]

technically it does only if it doesn't cut off somewhere else

[@firenzarfrenzy4985]

I haven;'t watched an ace attourney shitpost in a while but this had me rolling. The fact the 'villain' switched sides to tackle the real problem.

[@-General_Bek-]

The *villain* is not Edgeworth

[@iamwoke322]

yes, the villain is stupidity

[@guyjohnson6442]

'How are you not in prison right now?' 'That isn't relevant for the case.' 'But it's very relevant for my wellbeing!' This interaction is gold. This video is the gift that keeps on giving.

[@Khornes_knight]

i watched this right after watching "Miles is a Robot" and now I cannot stop hearing voices.

[@magicalhead]

That video is truly legendary

[@Chaosflower]

That series legit helped me fall asleep because I like the voices they use also LACTATION Z SAYS

[@RandomDude1487]

Phoenix: why is this my life Edgeworth: idk

[@ameame32]

I love how Edgeworth and Phoenix were like: why tf are we doing this anyways?

[@-General_Bek-]

The girl in orange made it

[@-General_Bek-]

And I don't understand why they agreed to make the trial🤔

[@Foxking437]

Von Karma really brought a goddamn gun to a courtroom and no one said anything

[@metalclawsteelheart]

4:37 PLUS! THE DOME PART ONLY COMES IN AS THE ARENA!

[@TheInfiniteLegend]

2:52 bro Edgeworth's statement got me rollin

[@BlizzardOfTheArctics]

When the case is so absurb that the defense turns into the offense team

[@karmatical5837]

At first i was thinking the video would make a deal about the sky being "unexistent" because it is composed of gases and not something really solid, but then they bring that tons of conspiracy and i love it.

[@cloaker57]

6:31 losing a game for one point be like

[@BLP_Memes]

The fact that was perfectly timed 💀

[@marshallmadrid1471]

Edgeworth suddenly apearing killed me

[@Mary_Studios]

"Who let him bring a gun into the court room?" Phoenix they let Franzsika bring a whip into court and use it. They don't seem to care about court safety.

[@mastermewtwo5503]

Suing the sky for not existing... Well, yeah it's not even a physical item so you can't do anything even if it does exist. If she's right though and the sky she's suing doesn't exist... What happens then? You can't exactly gain any prizes from something that doesn't even properly exist. [Also fun fact, I remember in the Simpsons Movie, part of the main plot was the town was trapped in a dome. They'd be living in an actual glass dome though as opposed to a magic firmament thing like Flat Earth suggests.]

[@StylichSketches17]

I get that this isn't supposed to be a wrightworth thing, but seeing the two of them work together as defence attorneys was actually really cute and fun. I would love a game where Edgeworth was Wright's assistant instead of Maya, I think they would work really well together.

[@jeffbenton6183]

Or if Wright was Edgeworth's assistant

[@willimberg7795]

People have actually sued inanimate objects, oddly enoughs

[@Yayofangamer16]

The sky were the friends we made along the way.

[@JordanWahl]

So for your contacts I watch overly sarcastic productions and my first thoughts were decapispheres

[@that_Dominic_guy]

“Edgeworth? What are you doing here?” “Believe me I’m just as confused as you are”

[@kinokomuffin]

1:49 rewatched this on my new main The mood change of edgeword never dails to kill me

[@ChrisHinners008]

I N H A L E “The prosecution is ready, your honor.”

[@Snyarhedir]

This is literally my first exposure to Ace Attorney (beyond articles and advertisements in Nintendo Power magazine). This was just in the recommended video list. I am already intrigued.

[@TARINunit9]

The webcomic Erfworld once decided to test this for themselves, since it took place in a fantasy RTS/TBS hybrid game. A group of dragon-riders decided to figure out where the line between "sky" and "ground" was -- the answer turned out to be "the ground"

[@CopperWalker]

8:00 it is now canon that the sky is not guilty

[@jayrry]

i have gained like 3 brain cells watching this video, thanks!

[@axoltheartist]

YOU STOLE EDGEWORTH’s BRAINCELLS?!?!1???1!1!?1

[@dontknow9042]

@@loisebahjin1105 , they meant stole.

[@jayrry]

​@@axoltheartist 😁

[@masonthekyogre]

Whoever made this edit deserves a great life! This was beautiful!

[@Amikas117]

You know it's really bad when Edgesworth *jumps to the opposite stand in the middle of trial.*

[@alphabetlorenoises8154]

if the sky is just a tv screen then how do people manage to go to space, its not like they magically open the tv, plus who affords a tv that big??

[@I-Eat-Pencilz]

Edgeworth I feel you- I lost many valuable brain cells from the argument

[@DarskideDraws]

as soon as phoenix said “you decided to pull that government conspiracy out of your-“ it cut off and an ad played LMAO

[@pickitha]

Ain't no wayyyyy xD

[@TailicaiCorporation]

I never get old of these videos

[@Ferrari255GTO]

You know you did some stupid shit when your own lawyer is busting your ass in court

[@Fighting.Flower]

Strangely informative for a video debating if the sky exists and attempting to sue said sky for potentially not existing.

[@buglium]

5:48 THE WAY HE HOLDS THE GUN IS KILLING ME😭

[@donxx1206]

i think its an edit of his finger waging pose croping over the finger with the gun to make it quite funny

[@rmf99fr]

3:53, OBJECTION! if there is a massive tv watching us? then where's the cameras at? as far as we know, TVs don't have cameras, and even if it were some SOTA technology, then wouldn't we see it? and if you would suggest they use clouds, then that's impossible since clouds are not transparent and they wouldn't be able to watch us from the TVs screen as for the same reason.

[@Cron024]

Birds bro, birds are robots created by the government to watch us

[@SomeDudeCauseYes]

​@@Cron024what??

[@Souls7283]

I'm with Phoenix on 3:54. "Huh?"

[@dominoj8263]

This has to be one of the funniest videos i have seen for a long while, i'll be sure to check out more of them ❤

[@SoupMarley64]

I can't believe the sky was Furio Tigre the whole time.

[@robertlupa8273]

Mr. Blue Sky, please tell us why you had to hide away for so long? 2:38 also while I won't _hate_ you for it, the fact that you used Pursuit for Cross Examination feels kinda wrong

[@idiotbrit9951]

I actually learned stuff watching this

[@standardrobloxian7212]

miss Alex: the sky is a tv screen Government: she's onto us

[@buffkirbo598]

5:38 VON KARMA NOOO

[@Souls7283]

I know karma is a bad thing, but seriously? Jail?😂

[@starfighter1884]

Wright and Edgeworth, I wanna see them in a discord call THAT SHIT WOULD BE LIT

[@eon1014]

Wow. The case was so stupid that it made Miles switch sides to work with Phoenix.

[@Lucas-kw9mi]

The sole reason I love ace attorney is how every prosecutor appears out of thin air in the courtroom and nobody questions it.

[@bellahu5331]

I’m sorry but Phoenix’s expression when Edgeworth just switched to his side is gold. For some reason I love seeing Edgeworth siding with him

[@frostwolf8994]

Edgeworth: It’s very relevant for my well being. Von Karma: *I’m about to do what’s called a pro gamer move.*

[@Souls7283]

5:05 the moment that gavel smacked, I got hit with a dragon ball super Saiyan Goku first transformation ad. 😂

[@pickitha]

Me when the Dragon Z got his Balls: (I never watched Dragon Ball Z)

[@Souls7283]

@@pickitha aww thanks for the heart! ☺️

[@why_you_peaking]

I got hit with a YELP ad

[@ARegularPersom]

Now i am just as confused as they are, how did this even go through in retrospect?

[@DainKeith]

1:35 tf2 reference

[@LadWithTheHat]

THE MOMENT EDGEWORTH SUDDENLY SWITCHED I DIED

[@NeruWeek]

8:04 goodbye braincells

[@Copter200]

7:22 Basically the conflict with Christianity vs Atheists+Science/j (Before you say anything this is a joke, I'm sorry if this offends you).

[@ChaoticEvo]

No, that's basically it

[@SomeDudeCauseYes]

the afterlife myth, that can't be proves correct or wrong. vs a thing that git researched, tested, etc. for a better human understanding.

[@water_sponsored]

Even Saul Goodman couldn't save this client

[@randomizerofficial17]

They could have just asked how planes could reach so high, why you lose oxygen when you get high enough and how astronauts and rockets even exist

[@Firemarioflower]

I like seeing Phoenix and Edgeworth work together

[@Abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz1024]

2:32 There are an excessive amount of coincidences in the world but there's also only so many concepts, you'll be hard pressed to find more than 1,000,000 unique concepts although defining a unique concept outside of time space real energy material and paradox, is nearly impossible To be fair with how authors treat fiction, and religions are all based on fiction and half of people are religious, thinking fictional worlds are real isn't that strange especially for a non-adult, it's authors and religions that create a veil of confusion "Why does half of humanity believe in contradictory gods if fiction isn't real?" Not supporting the sky person btw just pointing out that even logical people can be tricked into believing in fiction due to humanity's absurdity

[@gat0anonimo]

Phoenix and Edgeworth being on the same side is unstoppable bro 🔥💯 (I've never played any Ace Attorney games)

[@christhelegend889]

Karma Rapidly beating himself up and slamming his hand makes be cry laughing

[@Nightslayer337]

Edgeworth just leaving and joining phoenix, even being literally together on the same stand is so cool lol

[@dragonballlover2880]

5:28 How did you manage to put Phoenix and Edgeworth next to each other

[@magicalhead]

When making an objection go to tge three lines, then go to "pairs" then "add new pair." From there you can put whatever duo you'd like together

[@thisisasupersayin376]

"Go to your house and point a camera at a lightbulb, you'll get the same results as the sun." Von Karma getting ready to reveal that the floor of his house is flat:

[@prayingmantis2412]

When two lawyers just want to argue over something

[@Morfes-sw5un]

Out of all the names she could have gotten… why Alex? WHY!?!?

[@pickitha]

Lol, because the person she was based on name was "Alex-serves-Tea" or Smth like that

[@Morfes-sw5un]

@@pickitha well I’m ashamed to share a name with that person

[@LordSiravant]

Plot twist: Alex is secret a reality warping god who forced this scenario on everybody purely for her own amusement and is just fucking with them.

[@drdca8263]

Ah, I thought this was going to be about a semantic argument over whether “the sky” can be said to refer to an existing thing, or whether it just refers to an apparent thing which “doesn’t exist”. Like, people say that there is “nothing where a rainbow seems”, meaning that our perception of a rainbow is kind of an illusion, and that while there appears to be a thing at a particular location, this location depends on where we are, not on there being something which “is a rainbow” at that location, Similarly, one might argue that “the sky” refers to the *apparent* dome that it looks as if there is, and that, while the atmosphere exists, “the sky” does not, and is instead like a rainbow. (Though personally, I think I would take the position that both the rainbow and the sky “exist” in some sense, the sky more-so than the rainbow.)

[@t_cheating8239]

This is hilarious, I’m surprised it doesn’t have more views.

[@derekarredondo5563]

I hate how I could make arguments for either side. “It’s real, cause how would we show the sky on televisions if we have records of the sky before tvs?” “The idea of medicine has been around for hundreds, maybe thousands of years, and there’s no way someone didn’t make a memory wipe drug and gave it to everybody who saw what’s behind, then they installed the tvs”

[@SonicFanBoy729]

Just like a normal Ace Attorney Trial