Doubts about the Sources of Islam

[@MoonLight-id9kk]

Shabir Ally continues to show courage debating non Muslims and even getting today’s Muslims to think in modern times ! Very reasonable individual and love listening to him !!

[@JaneyImaaniEmotionalAwareness]

Aisha, Alhamdulilah I have to say you are a very good interviewer! Thank you very much for being a great host! This is the first time I heard that Khadijah couldn't have been 40 because she had six children which seems very unlikely. But it makes sense! Those are some very good questions, thank you for answering them so well Dr. Shabir Ally

[@luccaaldo3847]

i guess im asking the wrong place but does anyone know a trick to get back into an instagram account?? I was dumb forgot the account password. I appreciate any assistance you can give me.

[@emiliokasen4553]

@Lucca Aldo instablaster =)

[@luccaaldo3847]

@Emilio Kasen I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and I'm waiting for the hacking stuff atm. Seems to take a while so I will reply here later with my results.

[@fiammettamaccario122]

@@luccaaldo3847 did it work?

[@brucesims3228]

For myself, any doubts I have about my Faith comes not from the Prophet but from things that happened in the 100 years After the Prophet (pbuh). Dr Shabir Ally's explanation might also be a good starting point for referencing earlier prophets such as Jesus, Moses, etc. Not to be disrespectful, but I would really like to listen to Dr Shabir Ally's view on the influence of developments of that first hundred years of Islam. FWIW. BTW A quick compliment to Aisha who has become increasingly poised in her on-camera presence. Nicely done!

[@Flower-qq7je]

Her Hijab is always beautiful ❤️Today's hijab is so cute!

[@mumairsaad]

Salam alaikum, I have submitted the same question twice to your channel and received no response. I want to ask Dr. Shabir for his perspective on the claims of new religious movements which emerged out of Islam, such as the Ahmadiyya and the Baha'i Faith. The emphasis is on the claims of the Baha'i Faith. Thank you.

[@fatimayoutube8108]

Thank you so much you two people, you have been so helpful that you have answered the questions so well and aisha thank you for asking such amazing questions that even i didn,t know the answer too, i mean some i did know the answer too but some i didn't! God bless you two for actually not wasting your time doing some other jobs, but working/talking on a subject that will be very helpful to most people! MASHALLAH!!!!!!! may allah(swt) make your dreams come true and make your families always happy and make their dreams come true aswell. IF YOU AGREE, THEN GIVE THIS COMMENT A LIKE!🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗

[@syedali4097]

About the controversy regarding Aisha (ra)'s early marriage we can say that it is FALLACY OF PRESENTISM which means judging the past basing on present day laws, customs, mentality etc.. Fallacy of Presentism is something which is usually disapproved universally. For many different reasons people felt safe to marry off their daughters very early in yesteryears. Since it was a custom of the past, it would be inappropriate to judge it with our present day custom, law, etc.... Thanks Dr. Shabir Ally for your eloquent replies. Thanks Aisha madam for your lucid presentation.

[@Tenzek]

_Presentism_ is a fallacy if you're allowed to update and improve your beliefs as time goes on. If you're referring to a perfect god with morals that are absolute, then there is no room for that, and the time of the event is irrelevant. Therefore, the fallacy can't apply here. 1) The moral choices then must either be equally valid now, or they must have been incorrect and in need of improvement. 2) Since it was specifically allowed by god, then by definition, it cannot be incorrect. 3) That leaves that the moral choices must be equally valid now. Since they clearly are not equally valid now, there is a contradiction.

[@anonymousanonymous-iq3fz]

@@Tenzek alot of Muslims disagree with the whole Aisha being 9 at marriage thing many Muslims scholars and historical evidences has proven that Aisha was actually 19 .

[@Tenzek]

@@anonymousanonymous-iq3fzI understand and appreciate that some people have altered their beliefs to be more socially acceptable today, but I was not responding to people who have done that. The comment I responded to was defending that she was 9.

[@anonymousanonymous-iq3fz]

@@Tenzek oh

[@fahadusmani2184]

Excellent

[@qudsiatabassum2394]

Excellent 👍

[@mehfil-e-ghazal786]

How u ask questions u r good philosopher

[@mullimulli6259]

The Sun God Ra is the one true God. All other God's are false. Blessed be thy shiny yellow thing in the sky. Peace be upon Ra 🌞

[@farisibnjamal6175]

Ok who is ra your sun god when the Moon shines?

[@WithoutFameGames]

How about 1 Fatwaa or even 1 words what’s happening inside entire land of Shaam. See how much you all cares about Ummat an Al Islam...

[@uptownbayarea6068]

Good one

[@rasmuszaurins7233]

Sorry, this video does not answer any scientific questions. What about: Why had Mekka not been founded befor mid 8th century? Because there is no archelogical proof of Mekka before this age, that is a question every muslim has to answer.

[@AdamAdamHDL]

These number games can be played with any text of significant size. It's not an equation, it's determination to find numerical patterns. There is a distinct difference between the two.

[@tamijahmed3413]

if you think that this numeric miracle can be done with any book. ..then put ur bible 1st in this test ....and make the same vedio like sabbir.....

[@AdamAdamHDL]

@@tamijahmed3413 It's not my bible. And people did it about 15 years ago and called it the bible code. It was even published by Christian apologists. And then debunked by everyone with half a brain (including some Christians). This nonesense is the same and actually it cheapens the quran. "why do you believe the quran is real?" Dr Shabir ally "because a bunch of words can be counted and where number patterns can be found we call it a miracle and where there are no patterns we ignore it". Not very convincing... How about answer honestly and say the text is beautiful and gives you meaning and moral guidance or something like that.. This video does a disservice to islam. I like Dr Shabir ally but this is.. Rubbish.. I

[@bartversteege6270]

you can do the same with a kookbook and find some paterns

[@AdamAdamHDL]

@@bartversteege6270 A cook book! Easy... It's got lots of numbers anyway. But that's too easy. Something a little less methodical.

[@bartversteege6270]

@@AdamAdamHDL every long text has paterns

[@bittertruths4719]

The true and irrefutable source of Islam is the Cave of Hira. If you study this location archaeologically, you will get sufficient evidences to prove that this is the opening of the bottomless pit. The pit extends from the cave into more than one directions. One leads to Bermuda Triangle and another to Dragon Triangle. The center points of these three are within 20-25 deg. N parallel (latitude) around the globe and I believe it is equally distanced too. Neither Bermuda nor the Dragon are triangles. But these two are two corners of a globe wide triangle with its third point falls on Jabel Al Noor. The top part of Jabel Al Noor looks like a cap and that is the cap of the bottomless pit. The other ends are opening into deep seas. So it is literally bottomless pit.

[@bartversteege6270]

the koran now in use was compieled in 1954, the first full koran was written 200 years after mohamed died , after thad many alternativ korans were written (about 50)

[@AbdulLatif-ob5ju]

1954? You sound well informed...

[@bartversteege6270]

@@AbdulLatif-ob5ju yip...its the offisial saudi.arab koran

[@fidelcatsro6948]

Are you related to Bart Simpson amigo? I think you were born in 1954...

[@AdamAdamHDL]

Not 1918? I thought we were all reading the Cairo standard edition 1918

[@bartversteege6270]

@@AdamAdamHDL no it is the saudi

[@albusai]

Numbers are no signs of being from God , fulfillment of prophecies is

[@adnanshafi1297]

albusai They are there too. But the number of mathematical miracles in there are baffling. They only make sense to us nowadays because education has come so far

[@albusai]

Small incomplete book full violence and no fulfilled prophecies

[@derekosgood3230]

What book do you suggest then?

[@alporkhari4072]

You just keep kidding yourself, mate. You can try all you like, but you cannot make the untrue true.

[@sarahs8976]

Jealous Christian😁😁

[@sarahs8976]

@@alporkhari4072 don't afraid brother... I'm like you...

[@lickerishstick]

At 6.05 you can see the red face glitch

[@Faiz9163]

Yes it seems it was the face of satan

[@lickerishstick]

Anyone else notice the artifact over her face when she talks about the Prophet

[@saygee5006]

Yes that kinda scared me