Dr. Jonathan AC Brown - Hadith and the Development of the Western Historical Critical Method - 2012

Published by Islamic Circles. Check out islamiccourses.org for new courses by leading experts in their fields.
An excellent course sponsored by Islamic Courses / Islamic Circles featuring Dr. Dr. Brown and Shaykh Dr. M Akram Nadwi. The course was given in London on September 29, 2012. The course covered topics such as origins and assumptions of Western study of Hadith, Western criticism of early Islamic History, History of Orientalism and criticism of the Orientalists, Revisionist approach, and finally Q&A that includes the discussion of age of Aisha bint Abī Bakr (RA). The same talk is also available in 4 part series ( • Dr. Jonathan AC Brown ... ) on this channel.
Source: • Jonathan Brown: HADITH...
islamiccourses.org/courses/had...

[@siffatnahar4697]

What a wonderful course! May Allah bless Dr. Brown.

[@4681MM]

I remember hearing this talk a few years ago on another channel. I wish Dr. Akram Nadwi and Dr. Brown co-teach again! And mashallah Dr. Brown always looks the same whether it be 8 years ago or now! The only thing that seems to change is his constant increase in ilm and zuhd. An internally and externally beautiful scholar hafizahulla

[@majeedkhan7515]

Dr. Brown is an impressive scholar.

[@zizou2003sm]

Excellent talk. Complements his book on hadith really well. May Allah bless everyone involved in making this talk available for us.

[@ARmirzaful]

Aameen. A true balanced doctor...Brown the doctor we need but not the one we want. :)

[@aladinndrake110]

Mashallah Amazing. May Allah Bless Dr Brown n his loved ones. I was so impressed to hear someone reaffirm that Allah and His Prophet is the ultimate authority in the life of a Muslim.

[@cdseventy6435]

JazakAllah Dr. Brown. This was great

[@Ronakalin70]

An excellent talk, as always! Thank you dr. Brown.

[@hamza1947]

What an epic talk. I learned so much...

[@retnadewayani6917]

Oh i watched the old youtube version was terrible but still i enjoyed his lecture tho i hd to replay it several times. This much better. Tq

[@nasdzeuropa4627]

MashaAllah may Allah almighty bless you

[@hashmihere6379]

Love 💖

[@ARmirzaful]

I always long for the England affirmation as well, lol. This scholar is really on a different planet, he really understands how orientalists think.

[@lana-ss6lo]

Interesting 🙂

[@bibishah7754]

To everyone searching information on KZbin regarding islamic scriptual sources. Be critical if the KZbin video does not allow comments. Propaganda is when critucal questions or comments are not allowed.

[@NotesofKhan]

Amazing Lecture?

[@ej1068]

1:44:35

[@nabilrady6767]

I am an Egyptian, can someone explain what's wrong with " The muslim brotherhood assassinated el saddat" ?

[@BasedYeeter42]

They weren’t responsible for Sadat’s assassination, it was Gama’a Islamiyya instead

[@antonisorususii4658]

يا عم لك مشايخ في مصر تستطيع أن تسألهم و ربنا أكرمك و جعلك مصري سبحان الله. في ايام مبارك درست في مصر (أم الدنيا) انصحك ان تدرس الاسلام و ان تتعلم دينك

[@ofarah7902]

the fact that it's completely made up nonesense. Clearly the fact you're Egyptian doesn't prevent you from believing false information.

[@Kimeikus]

35:02 - Fantastic point. I was taking a religion class and it was based on the Historical Method and this was one of the major assumptions that we began with. 50:40 Another fantastic exposition. 55:43 Nice

[@ARmirzaful]

He is really solid at presenting non muslims criticisms in an unbiased manner. World Class Scholar.

[@Kimeikus]

@@ARmirzaful I’ve been getting into his content more recently. He’s a fantastic speaker. May Allah increase him.

[@hjj2892]

Assalamualaikum could you summarize his points brother? Im assuming you watched this full

[@AhmedIsa-no6iw]

iam ahmed from egypt i think you are musulm more than me ربنا يثبتك وينفع بيك الإسلام والمسلمين

[@shihab2468]

"Whole bunch of noise with no basis."

[@foxman3374]

Meaning...?

[@katarianshareef8923]

How norani face of his ma sha allah