Dr ​⁠Yasir Qadhi | Controversies, Critics & Establishing Khilafah | BB #62

In this much anticipated episode of the Blood Brothers Podcast, Dilly Hussain speaks with the prominent American theologian and historian, Dr Yasir Qadhi. #BloodBrothersPodcast #YasirQadhi #Khilafah
Topics of discussion and timestamps:
- Intro & quick fire questions: 00:00:00 - 00:11:25
- Salafi 'Najdi' Dawah & journey to reform: 00:11:26 - 00:53:38
- Quran controversy, online critics & accounting scholars: 00:5 3:40 - 01:25:44
- Establishing Khilafah & Dawah priorities: 01:25:45 - 01:54:23
** SEARCH ‘BLOOD BROTHERS’ ON ALL DIGITAL PLATFORMS **
FOLLOW 5PILLARS ON:
KZbin: / 5pillars
Facebook: / 5pillarsuk
Instagram: / 5pillarsnews
Twitter: / 5pillarsuk
Telegram: t.me/s/news5Pillars
TikTok: / 5pillarsnews
Website: 5pillarsuk.com/

[@5Pillars]

As salaamu alaykum brothers, sisters, friends and foes. Please like, share and comment on this video, as well as subscribing to the 5Pillars KZbin channel! Jazakallah khayran.

[@alishah6591]

Great work again bro Dilly allahumma barik! 0:52 Eloquent intro by Br Dilly Hussain 2:51 ICEBREAKER: 10 Companions for Shaykh YQ to take on a boat trip? 11:45 Shaykh Yasir Qadhi's journey away from Salafi/Najdi Dawah 17:11 Does Shaykh YQ feel 'guilty' for undergoing this journey? 21:38 What YQ taught vs what he now teaches + why? 26:01 Can Islamic inter-sectarian differences ever be contained? 26:59 2005/6 MSA/ISOC Incident 31:19 The dangers of takfeer - matters such as tawassul, istigatha etc 36:53 Are matters of tawassul, istigatha etc [in the ummah today] furoo3i (branches) as opposed to usooli/aqadi (creedal) ? 39:35 Did Shaykh's environment (i.e: living in the West) lead to the shift in viewpoints? 46:00 Has Shaykh's secular encounters (e.g Yale) led to a shaking of his traditional views like Usama Hasan in the UK? 51:56 DISCLAIMER about causing doubts 54:58 Should laymen hold mashaaikh to account (Clips of YQ, Omar Suleiman, Abu Eesa on social media)? 1:04:37 The impact of sectarian differences within Islam on the ground-reality of muslims 1:08:49 Reference to 'Mufti' Abu Layth - the advantage of being indirect with criticism rather than direct 1:11:28 Why 'amr bil ma3roof/nahy anil munkar' is not a valid justification for laymen to criticise ulemaa (inc madkhalis) 1:14:33 Shaykh YQ's conversation with Mufti Taha Karan (RH) about taking non-literal interpretation of hudood which meet the goals of the shariah 1:17:14 Shaykh YQ accepts mistake for wording in ahruf/qiraa3ah MH podcast - NOTHING to do with divine preservation of Qur'an 1:26:29 Does the shaykh see a way forward for a revival for the Muslim Ummah? 1:27:20 Have there been more than one khalifah ruling over the ummah at any one point in time? 1:29:57 Theoretic vs Practical understanding of the khilaafah (Al Mawaradi's Al Ahkaam As Sultaniyyah) 1:32:23 Criticism of YQ based on the utopian notion of having a Muslim state ruled under 1 khalifah 1:35:45 Shaykh YQ's scepticism of the practicality of establishing the khilaafah in today's world (realpolitik) 1:39:41 Obstacles to instituting a Khilafah (New World Order, Nation States etc) 1:41:44 A khilaafah cannot exist independently 1:50:44 The refusal to compromise in legitimate ways in accordance with traditional sunni Islam has led to legitimate reform to be silenced + opened the doors to progressivism 1:51:38 Is there an unequivocal position relating to the impersibbility of khurooj? [Hussain AS + RA, Rebellion of Yazid, Support of Anas Ibn Malik RA against umayyad dynasty, Imaam Abu Hanifah RH] 1:54:28 Wrapping up

[@MBeats27]

Can you get imam suhaib webb on please bro.

[@rumanahmed621]

My brother Dilly inviting people like that on your podcast is a traversty

[@MBeats27]

@@rumanahmed621 are you scared

[@rumanahmed621]

@@MBeats27 Scared of what

[@nahreallybro464]

Can we give credit to Dilly. He's probly the best person to interview all these amazing guests. His questions are so Interesting yet engaging for common people. Also the spectrum of guests is amazing keep it up ♥️

[@Abd-al-Qadr]

5Pillars is tied for #1 for me. Right up there with Muslim Skeptic, simply because of my desire for raw, unadulterated Deen.

[@alishah6591]

Great work again bro Dilly allahumma barik! 0:52 Eloquent intro by Br Dilly Hussain 2:51 ICEBREAKER: 10 Companions for Shaykh YQ to take on a boat trip? 11:45 Shaykh Yasir Qadhi's journey away from Salafi/Najdi Dawah 17:11 Does Shaykh YQ feel 'guilty' for undergoing this journey? 21:38 What YQ taught vs what he now teaches + why? 26:01 Can Islamic inter-sectarian differences ever be contained? 26:59 2005/6 MSA/ISOC Incident 31:19 The dangers of takfeer - matters such as tawassul, istigatha etc 36:53 Are matters of tawassul, istigatha etc [in the ummah today] furoo3i (branches) as opposed to usooli/aqadi (creedal) ? 39:35 Did Shaykh's environment (i.e: living in the West) lead to the shift in viewpoints? 46:00 Has Shaykh's secular encounters (e.g Yale) led to a shaking of his traditional views like Usama Hasan in the UK? 51:56 DISCLAIMER about causing doubts 54:58 Should laymen hold mashaaikh to account (Clips of YQ, Omar Suleiman, Abu Eesa on social media)? 1:04:37 The impact of sectarian differences within Islam on the ground-reality of muslims 1:08:49 Reference to 'Mufti' Abu Layth - the advantage of being indirect with criticism rather than direct 1:11:28 Why 'amr bil ma3roof/nahy anil munkar' is not a valid justification for laymen to criticise ulemaa (inc madkhalis) 1:14:33 Shaykh YQ's conversation with Mufti Taha Karan (RH) about taking non-literal interpretation of hudood which meet the goals of the shariah 1:17:14 Shaykh YQ accepts mistake for wording in ahruf/qiraa3ah MH podcast - NOTHING to do with divine preservation of Qur'an 1:26:29 Does the shaykh see a way forward for a revival for the Muslim Ummah? 1:27:20 Have there been more than one khalifah ruling over the ummah at any one point in time? 1:29:57 Theoretic vs Practical understanding of the khilaafah (Al Mawaradi's Al Ahkaam As Sultaniyyah) 1:32:23 Criticism of YQ based on the utopian notion of having a Muslim state ruled under 1 khalifah 1:35:45 Shaykh YQ's scepticism of the practicality of establishing the khilaafah in today's world (realpolitik) 1:39:41 Obstacles to instituting a Khilafah (New World Order, Nation States etc) 1:41:44 A khilaafah cannot exist independently 1:50:44 The refusal to compromise in legitimate ways in accordance with traditional sunni Islam has led to legitimate reform to be silenced + opened the doors to progressivism 1:51:38 Is there an unequivocal position relating to the impersibbility of khurooj? [Hussain AS + RA, Rebellion of Yazid, Support of Anas Ibn Malik RA against umayyad dynasty, Imaam Abu Hanifah RH] 1:54:28 Wrapping up

[@s.6875]

JazakAllah khair bro

[@taufikahammedmishu6596]

Jazakallah khayr brother

[@farhanshahriar1072]

It was so helpful brother. May Allah reward you.

[@rockh1993]

Thanks

[@mohammedabdirrahmanrubblei9141]

Never a dull moment with sheikh Dr Yasir Qadh's podcasts. May Allah preserve you... also Sheikh Salmaan al-oadah is in our hearts, may Allah preserve him too.

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905]

Salmān Al owda is a flaming Ikhwani.

[@mohammedabdirrahmanrubblei9141]

@@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905 do you believe in Hereafter and fitnat Alqabr? Just do your daily prayers and thikr and hope that Allah forgive your sins. Forget about others just concentrate on your shortcomings.

[@mohammedabdirrahmanrubblei9141]

@@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905 it's Friday sen alot of salutations to the prophet salalahu alayhi waslam,and Qur'an recitation

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905]

@@mohammedabdirrahmanrubblei9141 اللهم صلي وسلم على نبينا محمد وعلى اله وصحبه اجمعين If people listen to Salmān Al ouda, people won't do their daily prayers, dhikr, or istighfar properly, meaning no Jannah.

[@mohammedabdirrahmanrubblei9141]

@@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905 Salam!

[@brothersman524]

Always loved Shaykh Dr Yasir Qadhi - benefitted so much from him

[@salmanjalloh8604]

One can only appreciate a scholar when you have the same or more credentials knowledge like him . The only reason why I like shayik yasir qadhi it's not for the criticism, stands, refutation or move on. It's because he addresses issues that no one talk about and talk about the reality inside which is affecting us outside but no one talk about it . Even if he have some issues which is normal because he is a human you don't expect him to be perfect 100% his knowledge is absolutely amazing we have to appreciate that .

[@mogainz]

He said quran preservation has holes in narrative meaning he doubts it is 100% preserved. Why is this an issue? Because Allah says he will preserve the Quran which if you question you are literally doing kufr with ayat in Quran. Do you understand ?

[@SammyAgon]

May Allah protect and bless Shaykh Yasir Qadhi

[@alperenalperen2458]

lol

[@hkicgh7277]

May Allah guide him and all of us too. Ameen

[@ibnamanot]

@@hkicgh7277 aameen.

[@ibnamanot]

@@alperenalperen2458 for some reason, your comment made me laugh.

[@Gufaaco]

Something amazing is going on in the ummah .. InshaAllah there will be unity. InshaaAllah!

[@joeblow-mf2jx]

no unity amongst cowards

[@manchesteruM]

Dilly is probably the best Muslim podcaster out there. Keep you the great work!

[@CR7Update]

This is why I respect Dilly so much. He keeps his composure during difficult questioning and remains respectful to guests who may be at the face of controversy. Unlike the other so called followers of the salaf who have developed an online cult of character smearing and slandering scholars of today, Dilly has akhlaak and adab of respecting his seniors.

[@Abd-al-Qadr]

Id say Dilly is _skillfully_ the best at what he does. He knows what to say and when to say it. He's almost _surgical_ when he's exposing frauds and liars. Does it in a way where even the liar thinks he got away free 😂😂😂 Daniel Haqiqatjou's style is my favorite if I'm honest. I say this because I can relate to him. I came into Islam thinking some stuff was true that absolutely wasn't true. I originally started out as a follower of the Najdi brand of Islam, because they didn't tell me they were responsible for the beginning of the end of Al Khilafa. Edit: for clarity, I don't say Br. Daniel ever believed in untrue things... The relation I feel is due to his time at a particular institute where he was made to believe certain individuals were on a creed that they really didn't follow. Being decieved is the shared experience here. It's why I prefer the in-your-face, abrupt style of calling out liars. I mean think about it. Anyone who's into combat sports will know, the majority of the audience wants a knockout rather than judges decision. Especially when it's the underdog vs the heavily-backed "crowd favorite". It's only when there are two highly respected fighters that we want to see it go all the way. I think the wisdom behind that is we want to see a full display of skill between the two.

[@RayhanulSumon]

brother Dilly questioning are another level. Such a good deep discussion. May Allah protect all of ummah, Ameen.

[@sisterfleur7523]

It's the intelligence machallah

[@hassanabdaladl]

It's so disappointing that those dawah trolls have made it such that Shaykh Yasir has to always preface his statements, to ensure they're not taken out of context etc

[@paimei26]

@@ibmsulaymani for the first time i agree with you However, according to your ustadh dawah man you shouldnt be here as you are gazing upon ahlul bidah

[@hassanabdaladl]

@@ibmsulaymani lol I'll have a nice reply for you shortly. But are you sure you want the reply? Will you just run away and hide from my comments, like you did on your channel? Or have you unblocked me now? By the way, being sincere means actually considering what other people say, even when it goes against what your ustadhs teach you

[@RRUU198]

@@ibmsulaymani lool bro his got nothing to bring trust me don’t waste your time on him.

[@hassanabdaladl]

@@ibmsulaymani I'm still travelling with the family. My apologies for using the word 'shortly'. I should have said later today. You didn't answer my questions about blocking me on your channel btw, bro. That is a strong indication of how sincere you actually are; when you block opinions that clarify your errors, instead of acknowledging your mistakes and rectifying them.

[@fallenprince2146]

@@ibmsulaymani Dude what's your problem? Yasir Qadhi has clarified all of that literally a thousand times. Ibn Hajr also problematized the hadith about Adam being 60 ft tall, and he even used the word "mushkil". And when did YQ ever say Shariah needs to be modernized? This is outright slander because you are accusing him of the very thing he's against. Calling a moratorium on hudud punishments isn't something that is novel or outside the fold of Sunni methodology.

[@NA-bb3bq]

Extremely beneficial and insightful podcast, may Allah reward you all

[@nasraqaali7050]

This is what I've learnt in tawheed lessons. "When people say but they pray, fast,give charity and do so many other good deeds, they are looking at the right of the servant and not at the right of Allah to be worshipped alone. "

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905]

Mashallah

[@emerald7857]

Well said

[@TheConservativeHippie]

Sheikh Yaser Qadhi is my favorite! I learn so much from him. He speaks with high level of English language and his pronunciation of both English and Arabic is perfect!

[@kaymubarak7331]

Absolutely and thoroughly enjoyed this podcast, beneficial and insightful 👍

[@a.s.4991]

Thank for this podcast/interview. I hope we have more like this. Big fan of your content.

[@tinaali790]

Always relax, and gain a lot listening to sheikh quadi, may Allah bless 🙌 and reward ,assalaam.

[@uponsunnah6986]

Thoroughly enjoyed this podcast! Thanks so much Dilly and team! May I suggest sh. Abu Taubah in future episodes? Would be interesting!

[@TheSuperHumza]

Amazing podcast, definitely one of my favs, in the top 3.

[@djamaluddin]

Narrated Hudhaifa bin Al-Yaman: The people used to ask Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) about the good but I used to ask him about the evil lest I should be overtaken by them. So I said, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! We were living in ignorance and in a worst atmosphere, then Allah brought to us this good; will there be any evil after this good?" He said, "Yes." I said, 'Will there be any good after that evil?" He replied, "Yes, but it will be tainted. '' I asked, "What will be its taint?" He replied, "Some people who will guide others not according to my tradition? You will approve of some of their deeds and disapprove of some others." I asked, "Will there be any evil after that good?" He replied, "Yes, some people calling at the gates of the fire, and whoever will respond to their call, will be thrown by them into the fire." I said, "O Allah's Apostle! Will you describe them to us?" He said, "They will be from our own people and will speak our language." I said, "What do you order me to do if such a state should take place in my life?" He said, "Stick to the group of Muslims and their Imam." I said, "If there is neither a group of Muslims nor an Imam?" He said, "Then turn away from all those sects even if you were to bite the roots of a tree till death overtakes you while you are in that state." حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ الْمُثَنَّى، حَدَّثَنَا الْوَلِيدُ بْنُ مُسْلِمٍ، حَدَّثَنَا ابْنُ جَابِرٍ، حَدَّثَنِي بُسْرُ بْنُ عُبَيْدِ اللَّهِ الْحَضْرَمِيُّ، أَنَّهُ سَمِعَ أَبَا إِدْرِيسَ الْخَوْلاَنِيَّ، أَنَّهُ سَمِعَ حُذَيْفَةَ بْنَ الْيَمَانِ، يَقُولُ كَانَ النَّاسُ يَسْأَلُونَ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم عَنِ الْخَيْرِ، وَكُنْتُ أَسْأَلُهُ عَنِ الشَّرِّ، مَخَافَةَ أَنْ يُدْرِكَنِي فَقُلْتُ يَا رَسُولَ اللَّهِ إِنَّا كُنَّا فِي جَاهِلِيَّةٍ وَشَرٍّ فَجَاءَنَا اللَّهُ بِهَذَا الْخَيْرِ، فَهَلْ بَعْدَ هَذَا الْخَيْرِ مِنْ شَرٍّ قَالَ ‏"‏ نَعَمْ ‏"‏‏.‏ قُلْتُ وَهَلْ بَعْدَ ذَلِكَ الشَّرِّ مِنْ خَيْرٍ قَالَ ‏"‏ نَعَمْ، وَفِيهِ دَخَنٌ ‏"‏‏.‏ قُلْتُ وَمَا دَخَنُهُ قَالَ ‏"‏ قَوْمٌ يَهْدُونَ بِغَيْرِ هَدْىٍ، تَعْرِفُ مِنْهُمْ وَتُنْكِرُ ‏"‏‏.‏ قُلْتُ فَهَلْ بَعْدَ ذَلِكَ الْخَيْرِ مِنْ شَرٍّ قَالَ ‏"‏ نَعَمْ، دُعَاةٌ عَلَى أَبْوَابِ جَهَنَّمَ، مَنْ أَجَابَهُمْ إِلَيْهَا قَذَفُوهُ فِيهَا ‏"‏‏.‏ قُلْتُ يَا رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صِفْهُمْ لَنَا‏.‏ قَالَ ‏"‏ هُمْ مِنْ جِلْدَتِنَا، وَيَتَكَلَّمُونَ بِأَلْسِنَتِنَا ‏"‏‏.‏ قُلْتُ فَمَا تَأْمُرُنِي إِنْ أَدْرَكَنِي ذَلِكَ قَالَ ‏"‏ تَلْزَمُ جَمَاعَةَ الْمُسْلِمِينَ وَإِمَامَهُمْ ‏"‏‏.‏ قُلْتُ فَإِنْ لَمْ يَكُنْ لَهُمْ جَمَاعَةٌ وَلاَ إِمَامٌ قَالَ ‏"‏ فَاعْتَزِلْ تِلْكَ الْفِرَقَ كُلَّهَا، وَلَوْ أَنْ تَعَضَّ بِأَصْلِ شَجَرَةٍ، حَتَّى يُدْرِكَكَ الْمَوْتُ، وَأَنْتَ عَلَى ذَلِكَ

[@wanfatinsuryaniewa7007]

Its never the discipline of knowledge to quote one hadith to understand a whole spectrum of knowledge of a different time ,different era and different context

[@djamaluddin]

@@wanfatinsuryaniewa7007 Agreed. I quoted based on the 2 hour lecture and could see a good relevance between our unfortunate parochialism and the hadith.

[@wajahatkhan]

Shaykh yasir and Shaykh asrar would make for a very interesting conversation. Two people I dearly love and respect

[@JannahInProgress]

2 hours and i wasnt bored once! Great work

[@hassanabdaladl]

Good job Dilly. Barakallahu feek. Great episode

[@tinaali790]

Bro sheikh quadi,alhamdo lillah,listening to your talk, saw your video,difficult question to answer, but was prepared my sheikh,mashaah Allah .

[@sarahnovella4971]

jazakallah to both of you :) i really enjoyed this podcast..

[@Gokutalk-yl2lk]

Alhamdulillah. May Allah guide us all to the straight path

[@frankzappa951]

Assalamualaikum Warahmatullahi Wabarakatuh, great work.

[@maxmudxareed1345]

Unity is attained through purification of islam not by compromising islam.

[@ibnamanot]

Brother!!

[@checkmate5338]

Islam is pure. No need to purify what is already pure.

[@ibnamanot]

@@checkmate5338 I think he meant purify it from all the bid’ah and shirk that it has been mixed with. Like bring it back to it’s pure form before people started committing shirk and bid’ah.

[@maxmudxareed1345]

@@ibnamanot yes I mean so.

[@checkmate5338]

@@ibnamanot Islam has no bidah and shirk.

[@a.ssajjad5269]

Pls, do another episode with Ovaimur Anjum on the topic of the Khilafa.

[@essa200911]

Very strong high level series

[@noorkhadim844]

Wallahi I love sheikh Yasir. Incredibly strong man with yaqeen who has had to endure all the labels and accusations under the sun. This comments section is a testament to that. I dont know if theres ever been a scholar who's had to deal with more lay people telling him he's wrong, or even calling him a deviant, than sheikh Yasir. Instrumental to Islam in the west for the last decade and more. May Allah allow us to benefit from our beloved brother and sheikh Dr. Yasir Qadhi for many years to come and may He grant him reward for his efforts and sabr.

[@abdullahassaffah]

Thats he is a gay supporter and accepts evolution both pure kufr followed with his zomby view of yajuj majuj further proves the joker deviant he is

[@emerald7857]

I can’t believe I’m just discovering dilly’s podcast since yesterday. I just finished the one with bro haji then this came up. Very good content Akhi. Glad I have a lot to get through during my busy yet isolated coming few weeks

[@CineRanter]

What mic is being used in these podcasts?

[@yawarnadeem]

Masha'Allah what a podcast. Great to hear the great Sheikh Yasir delve into a multitude of topics and past controversies. Credit to Dilly, who was excellent in his approach and questioning, which led to a fascinating discussion.

[@SammyAgon]

Be fearful of slandering shuyookh. What he says may only go against your (lay-man I presume) understanding of the Quran and Sunnah.. For you and me with a probably basic understanding of the religion, the finer nuances of advanced scholarship may at times seem foreign to us because of our lack of depth in the fields. When you go through everything Shaykh YQ said, all of his arguments are made from the framework of the Quran and Sunnah with the correct usool. Therefore his opinions (all of them) are valid even though you or I personally may gravitate towards another opinion from another Shaykh. We need to mature ourselves beyond saying "this Shaykh went against the Quran and sunnah" simply because he expressed a view that is different from your own, and is from your perspective the wrong ruling, but is in the grand scheme of things an opinion that is within the understanding and methodology of the Quran, Sunnah and our 14 centuries of Islamic scholarly tradition. Let me tell you a story to illustrate this point: Once when Ali (radhiallahu 'anhu) was in the brink of a war against the Khawarij (extremists of that time) he said something like: Why are you fighting us, and what is your issue with us? They responded with: You do not judge by the Quran! And then he said: Bring me the Quran! And then they brought him the Quran, and put it between them. And Ali (ra) said while looking at the quran: Oh Quran, judge! And then the Khawarij started laughing and said: How will the Quran answer you back when it's just a book! And Ali said: "Exactly! The Quran is not able to judge by itself so it needs people of knowledge to read it and to pull from it rulings using the islamic methodology." And what happens when people try their best through their knowledge to come to a correct opinion? They differ. You will find some that hold one view, and others that hold the opposite view. And both of them are good. Because both sides attempted their best at finding the true ruling. Now Shaykh YQ tried his best in all of the different cases to come to the truth. I agree with him in many and I disagree with some. But it is all good and khayr. He holds one view (and you will find other scholars that agree with his opinion) and you can follow the opposing opinion. But we need to be mature enough to realize that both views are from the islamic methodology and therefore khayr and good. Shaykh YQ has done nothing wrong, he only may have an opinion you disagree with. But both his opinions and the opinions of the shuyookh that you take from are based on islam therefore both valid. May Allah expats the sins of ulama like imam bukhari who was heavily smeared in his lifetime and many ulama like Shaykh YQ that are also smeared in our times. I ask Allah to increase all of us in wisdom, knowledge and the understanding of the religion. Āmīn. ❤

[@AK-47ak12]

Ameen ❤

[@Chakswari101]

You compare YQ the modernist charlatan to imam bukhari?? 🤣

[@nesarulalam8268]

Excellent brother.Thanks for the naseeha and you also ignore the critics above

[@ma5839]

YQ is a student of knowledge and a "dai', but he is not an alim. YQ dismissed al Mawardi (rh) as a mere theoretician when he was a chief qadi of Baghdad under the Abbasi Khilafah. He was a respected faqih and alim. Should he be dismissed as inconsequential by a mere student, while laymen should elevate the student above the alim and faqih?

[@basnation7769]

@omq Wallahi he does not and wallahi he will take his Haqq from you on the day of judgement for your slander.

[@sisterfleur7523]

I am athari (usually I just say I am sunni muslim, this is just to be more precise 😁). I disagree with him on maany issues, but I agree on many (I mean he is athari too) and I love him for the sake of Allah. May Allah preserve him. Salam

[@elkaramani]

nl bekeerlingen be like

[@justneedlife2001]

Which kind of Athari?

[@sisterfleur7523]

@@justneedlife2001 i am maliki in fiqh, I am athari in terms of the names and attributes of Allah. In aqeedah you could say. It's all still orthodox sunni, so I am just a muslim who follows the Quran and Sunnah with the understanding of the salaf, and I try my best like you and many others! May Allah unite us in jannah, salam

[@n.a3642]

@@sisterfleur7523 No I meant Salafi(like Ibn Taymiyyah) or original Athari (like Ibn Qudamah)

[@sisterfleur7523]

@@n.a3642 I don't call myself salafi anymore bc I don't want to be associated with the modern day salafi movement (najdi, saudi) ! I am completely disgusted by it, seen the ugly ugly part of it, it's toxic ! Of course I still respect (some of) their scholars because they are nothing like the followers, especially Ibn Uthaymeen! I have a special love for Ibn Taymiyyah🥰 and read a lot of his books, but I also looove Ibn Qudamah subhanallah! Ibn Taymiyya has nothing to do with the najdi, a lot of them are closet takfeeri, Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahhab himself made chain takfeer on the entire Ottoman Empire, Ibn Taymiyya NEVER did that in his life and he was super just even with his opponents, he would even praise them and HELP them! Basically I don't follow ibn wahhab, I stick to the early generations and read classical scholars that were ACTUALLY mainstream and ACTUALLY giants in their field ; I don't consider ibn wahhab a giant. So yeah !

[@omara3938]

Great job brother Dilly. I didn't agree with sheikh on certain things related to the khilafah but I respect his akhlaq in stating that he may be wrong and may support those who are working to unite the ummah under khilafah. I do agree that harsh attacks have to stop and the focus needs to be more on the ideas than the personalities. There maybe some exceptions ofcourse.

[@dryusufmgamadiid2246]

Very interesting excercise. Very beneficial.

[@haziqzia5671]

Many things clarified MashaAllah

[@KA-fx8co]

Awesome podcast and some really important points discussed JazakamAllahu khayr to all you brothers

[@tasleem3D]

Jazakallah khair brother ! Now you must invite DH for a podcast brother..

[@ozzyrulz212]

Already done several months ago.

[@sea_clicks]

Excellent talk brother Yasir! As always.my opinion: when our masjid get full fajr time and we shun western media then talk about khilafa!

[@ghazali8881]

You need to get Sheikh Hamza Yusuf Hanson on the podcast, too

[@zccau2316]

He will never come as Dilly will ask about the UAE affiliation

[@xorpe7172]

@@zccau2316 Care to elaborate?

[@MBeats27]

Hamza Yusuf is a celebrity unfortunately doubt he would come on a simple video call with someone unless he knows dilly personally then maybe

[@muhammedthameem3016]

@@xorpe7172 just people making things up. He has explained this several times that he has no such affiliation.

[@xorpe7172]

@@muhammedthameem3016 jazakAllah

[@youtubeowl9544]

1:08:30 Here, Yasir Qadhi talks about Abu Layth.

[@MustaphaBulama]

Masha Allah. Alhamdulillah for this interview.

[@naushad5139]

This is a man who has recently put his hand on his heart during a Khutbah and sincerely apologized for any mistakes or for any past statements that may have been ambivalent or ambiguous on certain critical topics. And yet some of his haters continue to attack him. I think he is sincere in his intentions, and his benefit in boosting the imaan of young Muslims is unquestioned.

[@SuperTANMAN007]

38:00 this is a game changer. The whole ummah can unite under that!! And we should all work towards that

[@ibnamanot]

Check out Farid's channel for this latest playlist of short videos.

[@TheESMAT07]

Hi brother! I know it's been two years. One quick question: What is Allah's rights that we should do?

[@SherazH1]

Amazing interview!

[@jaed123]

It is always a pleasure to listen to Sheikh Yasir Qadhi

[@kami3434]

I noticed, you made the subscribe button appear when he said the word subscribe. Clever!

[@zahrashafwah794]

I think the issue of OS pagan ritual is eye opener for me on how much the idea of tolerance and interfaith can make person who do tahajjud regularly and memorize Qur'an like OS attending this kind of ritual.

[@cissejr7695]

Really you think he knew beforehand what was happening there?

[@MrBobDug]

@@cissejr7695 He was in the front front speaking and shouting fam

[@zahrashafwah794]

@@cissejr7695 well, when you're going to attend anything, don't u check what is the event about? Who will be attending? What's going to happen in the event?

[@littlecouchpotato]

Just came across this, what a great discussion!

[@abdullahijama447]

I love Yasir Qadhi for the sake of Allah.

[@alib7489]

Shaykh the majority of us love and benefit from you. Please ignore your detractors and carry on. Jazakallah

[@ma5839]

As the Deen is nasiha, and I want for you what I want for myself, the phrase is "jazakullah khayr" - may Allah reward you with good. Peace

[@Itz_HFA]

Smashed it Dilly !!!!

[@amazizi7783]

I am not sure about others who critisized Sheikh Yasir Qadhi, but Wallahi brother Daniel Haqiqatjou did a good job. He alerted the muslims on what is going on with some muslims in the US. Specially shedding light on people who support LGBTQ and also very "bizar" modernist views. There is a plan to change islam just like Christianity, the european leaders admit it themselves. They say "we have to modernize islam". Some scholars fit very well within these plans.

[@aboutthat1440]

DH has his own issues. He is far from perfect like us all. While some of what he said is true. He also has his own issues. Many dealing with the right wing. Who are indeed racist and he even uses their vile landealing with race. He has his own destructive issues to deal with. Unfortunately many won't hold him accountable. Due to his coming out (rightfully so) against certain actions. However that doesn't absolve him of his vile comments.

[@amazizi7783]

@@aboutthat1440 Can you share a link? I have watched and listened to many videos of his, but did not get that view of him. I think if you search thouroughly anyone one of us has soms issues.

[@DebunkSensibly]

Jazak Allahu khyran brother ♡🤲

[@MuhammadAli-hr1bj]

A very constructive discussion... Keep up the good work. Ameen ya rabbi.

[@peacenow6618]

This was very good clarifications

[@djamelchaib8598]

wallahi good job dilly, djazzaka lahou khayran, this types of interaction will bring the ummah more tpgether

[@shifeq9770]

I am a common muslim, I would love to discuss and hear about aqeedah, asma sifat, tawassul, istighasa respectfully.

[@qawwalifan786]

Get Hamza Yusuf on, he would be great.

[@muhammedthameem3016]

❤️

[@jahangirnawab1534]

Yea dilly akhi please get him on and press him on many of the straight absurd and controversial he has made

[@MBeats27]

Doubt it he is a celebrity unless he knows dilly can he get in contact with him

[@arkaazizul6673]

@@jahangirnawab1534 What controversy and absurd? Explain

[@mrmsali7689]

Almost all Westerns educated Dr Hamza Yusuf, Dr Ally Dr Sheikh + Yasir Qhadi and Dr Omar Suleiman they are from the same Western secular influenced type of educated persons. A LOTS of Muslims will get confused and some will be able to take good and leave strange/contradictory views of Westerns educated individual such as above. May Allah help with correct understanding of deen. Ameen

[@azizkhan9154]

mashaAllah.

[@GokuBlack-sn5dr]

watching this before it gets taken down

[@frankzappa951]

Hahahaha

[@liamfred9011]

Hasn't been taken down

[@muhammadhasan2582]

There is much good Shaykh Yasir has stated and there also things I disagree (even strongly) with him on. His view on what way the Ulama/Tulab al-Ilm should criticise others was excellent in my view - definitely the method employed by him to criticise a certain Mu'tazilite from the UK was very effective and balanced. Of course I also agree with his criticisms of the Najdiyyah as well. However the last section on Khilafah and also his views on reform I find myself disagreeing with. Khillafah is Fard al-Kifayah - it doesn't matter whether someone believes it can be established or not, it is communally an obligation on us to establish it, and reward is in striving not results. His view on this actually harms those working towards Khilafah as the way he put it "they are doing something useless", which makes me think he does not believe it is Fard al-Kifayah (he mentioned at one point that he is not commenting on that - and I want to know why he doesn't want to open on what his view of the Khilafah is). Yes Khilafah is not this all-perfect utopia some imagine it to be. The historical Islamic states had their ups and downs. That honestly doesn't matter though - it is an unremovable part of Islam. We cannot just ignore it. Also his mention of the prophecy of the three sons of the Khalifah - he really wasn't thinking on this point. He misquoted the Hadith at one point and suggested that these are three Khulafah themselves trying to use it to invalidate the Hadith of only one Khalifah. This is really bizarre. Why is attacking this so much such that he makes mistakes with his points? This does not seem like something he has thought through prior to the discussion. (As a side-note: I agree with his view that the Quraysh are preferred in the issue of rulership (per Imam Ibn Hajar etc.) but that Qurayshi lineage is not necessary, but I felt he did not elaborate to much on this point - he could have quoted some more evidences on this, from the rule of Imam Umar Radiyallahu Anhu and his wanting to appoint Mu'adh bin Jabal Radiyallahu Anhu, Hadith on obeying the ruler even if he is an Ethiopian, prophecy of it leaving the Quraysh, compared it to making the Mu'adhin an Abysinnian etc. But this was just a fiqhi point and he was just providing his views.) On his views of reform - I appreciate he recognises how it sounds to talk about this. There is a difference between temporary suspension of something in implementation of the Sharia (which is part of Siyasa) e.g. the Khulafah ar-Rashidah suspending executions during a drought, and suspension of something "due to the necessities of the Nation State". I have no idea what he is talking about here - why is there a need to suspend the Hudood for the sake of the nation state? Can someone spell this out to me - I don't get it. What is the actual problem here? Or is he saying that it is needed in order to implement the Sharia gradually - ok that I can understand and it has precedence in the Seerah - but it does not seem that he is saying this(?) So what is the reason? I always notice that my differences with many of these scholars are primarilly in the political realm and that is true with Shaykh Yasir, aside from some theological differences. I really do not get this - why are we having such a growth in the Modernist position of seeking some reform of the Sharia? I feel there must be a good reason for this but I can never see it. There is something - I feel - that these Ulama are not telling us or are failing to convey coherently. Perhaps Shaykh Yasir should make a video clearly outlining why he feels the Sharia must be reformed. Not to give justification for why some suspension is acceptable - but to speak of the present reality and explain the need for such reform as the reform he is calling for. If there is not a Shar'i reason for temporary suspension of the provisions of the Sharia (as in the case of the Khulafah ar-Rashidah) - then there must be no suspension - to admit such reform is blameworthy Bid'ah. I really want to know what the whole issue is.

[@a.a5589]

i think they've gotta be subtle when talking about implementation of sharia; quite frankly i don't believe it at all possible - i mean fully sharia, where we have the necessary jurists implementing on all fields, bc we don't want to end up like saudi arabia which implements some part and leaves out others, so the whole system is very unbalanced and draws a lot of criticism there - the problem largely is that the world seems very United in somehow believing democracy to be the only viable form of government and anything else being an "abuse of human rights." you might ask why we should care for their opinion but the truth is they have all the necessary capital and military power to lend them credibility and with the way they plunder from resource-rich africa and refuse for her to benefit from the riches if her own land how are we to beleive they are to let us take a form of government of our own completely divorced from theirs, which as we know, would be a complete rejection of not only their values which they have somehow deemed to be the height of human enlightenment but also a severing of all the cultural impact (which works to have them believe we are culturally inferior and so controls the common man) and affects their monetary dealings with us (keeping the country down nationally). i don't see a way out of this. the most vital element to an islamic society was the ethical and moral guidelines that people were already living in tandem with unquestionably and sought to solve problems in their community with the understanding that their problems were ones of their own creation, divorced from islam. it was the ethos which kept everyone grounded, not the constant threat of a police force; violence of the sorts a modern society thrives upon and is central to it's continuity bc of the need for a greater centralising force. overall, the modern state and all it stands for is completely divorced from any standard of governing bodies we have ever had and so problems arise from trying to build an authentically muslim civilisation from that. example: the modern state desires a codification of the law for which muslims have functioned without and kept large and stable societies despite the lack of such a viable thing because the nature of our law lies in fiqh - the human attempt to derive sacred law - which is itself plurivocal and the reason we have 4 schools of law whose principals are equally sound but may have very different rulings on a wide range of issues. can you imagine the nation state without singularity of law or without codification of law? where one would appeal to moral values and to admonish others and actually have that have a sizeable societal effect? because while things were definitely not perfect, all these inlaid assumptions formed the bedrock of societies in the past. I'd recommend you read 'The Impossible State: Islam, Politics, and Modernity's Moral Predicament' by Wael Hallaq to further expound on this

[@a.a5589]

i want to mention that i say all this not because i don't beleive that khilafah is not fardh kifaya, or that i don't believe that islamic form of government is a bad sytem if government but because our modern predicament is so vastly different from the pre-colonial one that the structures within those societies that lent them their strength and continuity are no longer available. it saddens me really, but i think the best thing we could do us to have democratic states based on islamic principles because getting rid of/ minimising the impact of capitalism and ribaa on society as much as possible is something we can work towards and have an impact on far more strongly imo, maybe an islamic finance system would work, i would love that ( i know this sounds contrary to what i said above in that we shouldn't implement some part of the sharia and neglect others, but if we are to make a genuine attempt at khalifa then the economic system i think is far greater than what the structure of the political system is, china is probably a good example). most of all, though, building up our cultural capital is of the most importance because our youth are increasingly seeing their cultures in a negative light, if we can build up their pride in their cultural and religious values that would be a good starting point. beyond that even we need to revitalise islamic education because the masses are extremely misinformed as our religious discourse is profoundly affected by the western orientalism and increasing secularisation, building cultural capital would hinder that effect, and having more institutions if vigorous islamic learning - how sad is it as an ummah of over a billion persons it is perhaps only al azhar that adheres to the highest standards of academic vigour which has in fact weakened over the past century? we need to decolonise our minds and learn and engage with our intellectual transition and change gear to making the central objective of learning to be for the sake of Allah. isn't that the reason why the muslim world flourished with polymaths and made great advancements in religious learning but also in science and other fields? i think further we need to empower our women and provide oppurtunities for them to be part of revitalising our islamic education especially. it's a sad fact that most of us are completely unable to mention even one of the many accomplished female scholars that existed past the female companions of the the prophet, peace be upon him. and the seeming lack of women in religious education is at time used to discourage them from learning and becoming accomplished at it, and even when a certain level of accomplishment is reached, there is a lack of oppurtunities for our sisters to address a large audience (even though there were less problems raised with publicly speaking as in teaching in front of a mixed audiencd for a great deal of islamic history so long as the islamic requirements were met - this was not all women ofc but the need our sisters have to see sisters who are learned and can encourage other sisters to learn and give female-oriented advice during lectures and talks like this cannot be understated). all in all, i too desire the best for our ummah at large and these are the things that have come to mind thinking of things, feel free to disagree tho

[@mahmudakhanom6101]

Vice Co founder/journalist Suroosh Alvi as a guest on the podcast would be really interesting

[@The-oy6yd]

Clever guys

[@farheenrasool1280]

Yasir Qadhi is one of the few sheikhs and academics who actually applies common sense to his knowledge also. Highly respectable.

[@RRUU198]

Quran and sunnah > anything - respectable to think the Quran is not preserved or to question it? You need to reevaluate your stance on respectability with all due respect.

[@ma5839]

So you think calling a fard kifayah "mythical" and "utopic" is common sense?

[@RRUU198]

@Aadil Vadva did you even watch the podcast with him and hijab? If he didn’t why did Ustadh ARh make a video on the preservation of the Quran and why did adnan rashid also do the same? Wake up honestly and smell the damn coffee. Not just preservation, there’s so many other things.

[@fallenprince2146]

@@RRUU198 Are you aware of the role of ARH behind the email leaks?

[@ibmsulaymani]

@@fallenprince2146 Prove it

[@MohammedAli-nz6lm]

Alhamdulillāh excellent interview with the Sheikh We need Ulemā like this who understand traditional Islam, history and the modern world May ALLĀH (Swt) preserve the Sheikh, reward 5 pillars and all those that are working for the Deen. Āmīn

[@digitalnomad3180]

Nice video. Good work by the host in wearing the NZ cricket team t-shirt during the WTC final between NZ & India. Cannot hide the inherent biases; can you Dilly?

[@okayyeah8699]

Assalamu alaykum, I was listening while cooking dinner and then watched the video and seen the All Blacks shirt haha big up all the way from Australia, I’m New Zealand Maori and support the All Black.

[@mirzaamuhammadmaaazbinshaahid]

Mughals always declared themselves to be Khalifah. Khalifat ul Muta'aali was their first title. I think Akbar started it.

[@danraf1562]

Akbar was not even a muslim. Yet the others gave baia to the ottomans. And even of they did not, they still regarded khilafa as an important hukm.

[@tanveer5655]

@@danraf1562 Akbar was a muslim. He started deen e ilahi, however stopped that as he realized he was wrong. He might be a little more to the secular side, however to call him a non-muslim is literally extremism.

[@Ibrahim-xf6jo]

People are changing the narrative that only salafis are angry at YQ etc. The recent anger on YQ was the doubts he created on Quran, Yajooj and Majooj. His weird stance on liberalism per Haqiqatjo videos. No one has ever touched upon the 'najdi dawah' and YQ is humbly tryna change the narrative. The online refutation was on the DOUBTs YOU CREATED. not on najdi dawah

[@SammyAgon]

1. He didn't create doubts, he himself said multiple times the Qur'an is preserved, what else do people want? What he was talking about was a minor issue of the Ahruf and Qira'aat - that's all. 2. Haqiqatjou is a massive misrepresenter, this is well known. 3. Ya'juj and Ma'juj are his personal opinion. You may disagree with his view, but it is an Islamically acceptable view to hold and therefore you should learn to respect the opinion of other shuyookh that you may not agree with. He isn't the only scholar in our history to have an alternative view with regards to Ya'juj and Ma'juj. This religion is vast, and 'ulama have differing views on issues, if you don't realize that, then you have a bigger problem. Conclusion: he hasn't created doubts, he has been misrepresented and slandered. Big difference. May Allah bless you and me, and increase us in wisdom and knowledge. And may He bring the hearts of the believers together. ❤

[@AbuMoosaa]

It's an Aqeedah issue, how is a personal opinion? There's no room for opinion on Aqeedah

[@Ibrahim-xf6jo]

@@SammyAgon He did create doubts and allowed the missionaries to grab on to the whole holes in the narrative and he says he regrets it. Haqiqatjo hasnt misrepresented anything. Everything he says he shows the vids so you could make the conclusions. YQ is known to speak in riddles so to speak. He is open to islamic reform is what he tells progressives but then tells conservatives that his definition of reform is different and this type of reform is normal and needed in the west. He jumps left write and center trying to appease everyone. Not everyone can be pleased. Regardless he is trying to "reform" islamic fiqh

[@tanveer5655]

I don't agree with his views on yajooj/majooj, but they made million times more sense than the orthodox view.

[@ibrahimn.606]

Ma sha Allah

[@wajahatkhan]

New Zealand fern ♥️🙂 Much love and duas from Née Zealand dilly

[@nasraqaali7050]

How are Muslims going to unite when Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him told us that the ummah will divide into 73 sects and all except one will enter hell fire?

[@hamzafayyaz6965]

Great balanced discussion 👍

[@NomanNoman-vu6cm]

How can you save your emaan while living under taghut(kufria system)?

[@snowstreams7503]

Wake up for fajr salaah..

[@swalihmm]

60% of muslims live in muslim minority areas. What do you want to do with them? The muslim lands also dont take them.

[@ma5839]

@@swalihmm all those circumstances were shaped by human powers who calculated strategized acted to undermine Islam and weaken and divide Muslims. To treat this as if it is unquestionable "fate" and Muslims should learn to live under these circumstances, aka "be pragmatic" and "realistic" is defeated, sick thought that misleads to worse self-inflicted circumstances. It is also a lack of sincere iman

[@moealshaheri5438]

Brother yasir disappointing when it came to the Khalifa. Belittling the concept of Khalifa saying it can't solve this and that and is not practical. That's why I don't understand how someone can say go back to the ulama go back scholars and on such a vital subject Khalifa he say my personal opinion. Just overall blown away by what he thinks about Khalifa in general.

[@mkhan9227]

YQ is saying the truth when it comes to this.

[@danraf1562]

@@mkhan9227 no he is not. He is not consistent and his arguments are self contradicting.

[@mkhan9227]

He's just being polite. The khilafah that people are imagening is not possible.

[@danraf1562]

@@mkhan9227 he is neither polite nor respectfull in every single situation. Khilafah is a hukm, not an imagination. Plus he is highly self-contradictory. Just a few examples: Only Ulema have the right to criticise other Ulema. Yet he himself as a talib is criticizing Ulema. It is from the wisdom not to speak about secondary topics in front of the awam like sifat etc. Yet he himself does not uphold his own rule and speaks about hole in the narrative of ahruf for example. He criticizes some Ulema for being puppets of the government. Yet he himself listens and follows them on such topics like fiqh aqaliyaat and reform.

[@mkhan9227]

@@danraf1562 i didn't say the khilafat is a imagination. It's happened ask isis but the ideas of the people who want khilafah will never work.

[@fowadhamza]

Quick Fire Questions and Answers Who would you accompany from one of two people in the list on a 7 day journey on a boat from the below historical figures? 1) Ahmad ibn Hanbal / Al-Shafi'i YQ Choice: Ahmad ibn Hanbal 2) Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz / Harun al-Rashid YQ Choice: Ahmad ibn Hanbal 3) Salah ad-Din / Alp Arslan YQ Choice: Alp Arslan 4) Al-Ghazali / Ibn Taymiyyah YQ Choice: Ibn Taymiyyah 5) Fatih Sultan Mehmed / Sultan Aurangzeb YQ Choice: Aurangzeb 6) Omar al-Mukhtar / Imam Shamil YQ Choice: Omar al-Mukhtar 7) Jamal al-Din al-Afghani / Muhammad Abduh YQ Choice: Muhammad Abduh 8) Rasheed Rida / Abul A'la Maududi YQ Choice: Rasheed Rida 9) Abdullah Azzam / Mullah Omar YQ Choice: Abdullah Azzam 10)Omar Suleiman / Abu Eesa Abu Eesa Niamatullah YQ Choice: No Comments 11) Muhammad Taqi Usmani / Yusuf al-Qaradawi YQ Choice: Yusuf al-Qaradawi

[@umarp5325]

Salam, who are they talking about

[@abumeethakyemen2639]

Very surprised by the sheiks views on Khalifa and that's its a dream and won't happen. Even claiming that a certain group calling for Khalifa has done nothing for the ummah. Brother dilly this subject should be a podcast by itself about the issue of Khalifa with brother Yasir.

[@mkhan9227]

Absolutely right he is

[@abumeethakyemen2639]

@@mkhan9227 ? I don't understand ur statement

[@symbiotezilla12345]

@@mswimboo Great points by bro snm sm. In short: we need a STRONG, unifying, polarizing leader that can unite the ummah. Currently there is no one we know ready for this task, neither any way of knowing. We need to look at the hard reality and realize the logistics we would need to overcome in order to have a "khilafa" given how entrenched modern Muslims are in secular nation states.

[@abumeethakyemen2639]

So you guys believe Khalifa in the time we live today in our reality can never be established and is not practical. Just curious when you say the powers to be won't let it happen. And are you guys suggesting that Muslims shouldn't work for it even thoughts it's a obligation in Islam. I'm confused, general statement no matter how sound they seem doesn't mean it's true. What do you mean by logistics makes it unpractical. We need to explain when we say stuff like this

[@symbiotezilla12345]

@@abumeethakyemen2639 Well if it was possible then yes. But we’re saying it won’t be until the mahdi arrives since muslims will actually unite under him. (Yes it is a very pessimistic approach). When you say muslims should work towards it, then we should ask how? You would have to convince every nation state govt (secularistic establishments) to merge all their countries, the average muslim would have to abandon their nation state identity, and that’s not even mentioning the economical and logistical nightmare of incorporating rich muslim countries with extremely poor ones. On top of that we would obviously be inviting war from the west which we would have to be prepared for. Furthermore we are to expect every muslim majority nation state to agree on one central leader. These are just some of the issues but they are well beyond the efforts of the average muslim. We’re not saying khilafa shouldn’t be established, but we are saying it’d be extremely difficult if not impossible for us today given how entrenched we are in the modern systems. One would have to overthrow these systems by FORCE. All of this is easier for the mahdi since at that point we would have explicit evidence as per the hadiths of a righteous leader worth uniting under, as well as the baraka of doing so.

[@freeyourmind7538]

so grave worshipping is not shirk? We cant say to another 'muslim' that you're committing shirk? between 30-35mins

[@v-latifi4134]

Salaamu alaykum wa rahmatullah No because, it's not 'worshipping', its about the belief and intention. Listen to the lecture he mentioned dear brother. He talks very explicit about this in a library lecture.

[@MBeats27]

No Muslim thinks a grave is Allah so it's not "grave worship" its asking for something that you believe Allah has given to the person in the grave and Allah gives it to you through them

[@anonymousnoticer]

no yasir qadhi is a jahil whose been completed refuted it is shirk don't listen to such an ignoramus

[@musicanolaevery-ting7986]

If someone is grave worshipping, it's shirk but do you have proof that he's doing that? Ask them? What if they are praying to Allah at the grave of a pious one who was possibly closer to Allah than the said person due to his peity and acts. Stop assuming, start asking, listening, learning then judging.

[@zahrashafwah794]

Awwam do have right to question people of knowledge. Use the example of the women who question Umar ibn Khathab views on dowry.

[@cissejr7695]

With knowledge and adap

[@TajulIslamtajul39]

Dr Yasir Qadhi is one my favourite, when allegations came, i felt really bad. But now with this podcast, his innocence has been cleared up. May Allah gives him more wisdoms and longevity as if we can enlightened by his work.

[@ma5839]

He cleared up his views on the Quran but raised new concerns, such as mocking the Khilafah and abrogating hudud. He is a student of knowledge, but not an "alim" scholar, nor a faqih. Bara bin Azib reported the Prophet (saws) saw a Jew with his face blackened so he asked is that punishment for adultery in your Book. The Jews said yes. And then he (saws) asked a rabbi in front of the people "in the name of Allah" is this from your book? He said no, the people changed it to suit their sentiments (they offered explanations and excuses). The Prophet (saws)said : Allahumma, I will be the first to revive Thy command after they made it dead. Then he stoned the man to death. [sahih Muslim] YQ as a mere student advocates abandoning the hudud, apparently being misled by deviant ulama

[@DigitalResistanceGroup]

He’s calling a caliphate a daydream. Wow. Such ignorance and arrogance.

[@kidkool27]

From a pragmatic perspective, we probably won’t see one anytime soon

[@johnwickr678]

What mistake 10 sec did hamza yusuf make..send me link bro?

[@ma5839]

Jazakum Allah khayran for producing this offering time stamps to navigate the podcast. Insha Allah I subscribed and look forward to interesting Islamic discourse. Qadhi's interpretation of some topics are weak and deficient which positions his trajectory and vision of seeking unity unsound. But he seems to care. Will he listen to criticism? May Allah help him.

[@ismohd87]

True, he's strongest when he's taking down Ibn Abdul Wahhab and his deviant views.

[@healghana]

Racism, selfish nationalism, the world order as it is currently stand wouldn’t make one Islamic government possible. We should work now helping distressed and miserable women and children now!

[@guledmohamed3600]

Excellent podcast❤

[@rabiahakhan]

The political state of many Muslim countries is very British. There is always a need to separate between "state and church" and I got the same vibe from sh YQ. That's why he seems very skeptical on the establishment of khilafah in current times because in his opinion, practicing Muslims cannot lead and they cannot be burdened with the responsibility. He also talked about politicians and how when people come in power they get corrupted. This ideology is not from an Islamic perspective and is a very colonial perspective. Khilafah is not to rule over people. Khilafah is for all that is on land and to establish justice and mercy among all that live on land: humans, animals, cattles, crops, properties, etc. When everything is restored to its natural purpose and role, people with clean hearts will accept it. May Allaah give sh YQ tawfeeq to continue doing da'wah from His Fadl.

[@riam5429]

Which side are you on Dilly? Brother Daniel or sheikh Qadhi?

[@shifeq9770]

Wonderful job, dilly, I didnt get sheikh position on establishing khilafah, did he mean khliafah won’t be established before imam mahdi, there is no point in striving for it.

[@JannahInProgress]

He Said it might be but he dont know. He says he dont think a khilafa like the original one Can exits in the modern world. But of course Allah knows best

[@youssouftzaydani8250]

In the last part, I think there's no problem saying that the Ottoman were not to be called a khilafa. They did a good job of ruling the Muslim world at times, but that doesn't make them legitimate khalifas.We should definitely affirm the Hadith of the prophet (saws) that the khilafa should be lead by a Qureshi.

[@MBeats27]

Fair enough but If there is not someone who would be able to do it then a non arab would have to do it

[@youssouftzaydani8250]

@@MBeats27 there are always people to do it but the problem is when some people are too greedy to let go of power to those who deserve it. I believe there is wisdom in this Hadith and that the prophet should be obeyed.

[@MBeats27]

@@youssouftzaydani8250 if there are only two options then it is better to have a Khalifa who is non arab rather then not have one at all

[@marziaball5089]

I do not agree with that this sentiment divid the umma and this is the argument that Britain 🇬🇧 used to dethroned Abdul Ameid khalifa , we lost Palestine 🇪🇭 and the Arab countries didvided, and lost khala for for ever

[@youssouftzaydani8250]

@@marziaball5089 the khilafa is not gone forever inshaAllah it will come back earlier than you think. What happened doesn't change the fact that this argument is true

[@homtanks7259]

Why Yasir Qadhi, he is lost may Allah guide him to the truth

[@inspirationalguy81]

It maybe that the one who calls others "lost" is far more lost.

[@homtanks7259]

Muslims know the controversy surrounding Yasir, many controversial statements such as the Koran has not been preserved. Tell me which Muslim says that the Koran has not been preserved? its madness to follow a reformist

[@ismohd87]

Ok, Tom Hanks. We take you very seriously, lol.

[@homtanks7259]

@@ismohd87 some do, but you must be a follower of this reformist

[@inspirationalguy81]

@@homtanks7259 that's clearly not what he said. His issue was nothing to do with the preservation of the Qur'an. It was to do with "Ahruf" and it was an academic discussion and not one for discussion in public especially not for lay people. Even though he has clarified himself so many times but unfortunately many are blinded by arrogance and hatred until their hearts are sealed so even if you show them the proof or clarification to their faces, they will still not believe. Allah mentions the examples of such people numerous times in the Qur'an.

[@peacenow6618]

Jazakallahu Khayran Ahsanul Jaza

[@headphonesyt2300]

12:26

[@lenwilkinson672]

One never sees The Church of England having so many speakers as the prolific number of Muslims.Arent we a Christian country..When do Bhudists Sihks,Hindus,and all other religions advertise like the Muslims.or are they considered more important on you tube.

[@hassankhwaja]

Amazing podcast mA! Sh. YQ is an amazing person may Allah swt preserve him.