Dream SMP: Why Is Tommy Immune to The Egg?

[@SkellyViper]

NEW DISCORD SERVER IS OUT! Join to theorize with others about Dream SMP, and chill! It's usually a fun time. The link is in the description.

[@SkellyViper]

@Juice Box That's a whole lot of killing but it's to be expected from Tommy and Dream

[@someone_the1st]

hi

[@SkellyViper]

@@sportsdata3997 :D

[@phantom6360]

I like the theory

[@W1K___]

My theory on why Tommy is immune to the egg is this. Introduction: If you were a fan of the cartoon Adventure Time then you probably watched the mini series that is elements, where the four main elements and elementals (candy, flame, ice and slime) took over the continent of Oo and split it into quarters. How it happened was that , well at least for the candy element, a wave of gum like substance spread on the surface like an infection and turning everyone who had contact into a candy version of themselves. Well most people/creatures, you see those who were 'self absorbed' didn't get infected unless they wanted to or they gave in. The character who saved the day and the connections: The character who saved the day was apparently the 5th elemental, the anti-elemental. The character had the power to make creatures and people normal again. This was because of her not being from Oo and her personality. She was very, very 'self absorbed'. So she was very stubborn and bossy and had the kind of attitude of "People don't tell me what to do, I tell them what to do". Also being immune to elementification was factor of how unwilling you were to give into the element. Now is it just me or does this sound A LOT like Tommy. It sounds so much like Tommy that I probably don't need to do the connections (and I'm lazy). There is not bad theory: I'm not saying I disagree with your theory, I think it could be true, but I'm just saying that the egg sounds a lot like elementification from Adventure Time. Well I hope you enjoyed my theory and remember... That's just a theory... A Dream SMP theory.

[@Hfjhtbhj]

Tommy “I’m the Jesus of church prime” egg:and I took that personally

[@SkellyViper]

Nice one :D

[@ant5894]

Isn’t dream the jesus of church prime

[@Valo_www]

@@ant5894 Not anymore, he's in prison

[@ant5894]

@@Valo_www so who’s the Jesus now

[@Valo_www]

@@ant5894 I have no clue maybe tommy???? ;-;

[@bobitheone1562]

the egg: a yes tecno's mind the voices: you chose the wrong house fool

[@zaazazaxdxdxd3980]

The Voices : EEEEEEEEE

[@tmt3037]

EEEEEEEEEEEEE

[@masterdiamant7840]

TECHNOLATE

[@jakejohnson718]

HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA HUMINA

[@flumin9234]

ONE OF US ONE OF US ONE OF US ONE OF US ONE OF US ONE OF US ONE OF US ONE OF US ONE OF US ONE OF US ONE OF US ONE OF US

[@demonspawn4511]

Tommy has the gift of making anything he pleases into a prime shrine, the path and the log are these said things

[@kkTeaz]

Tommy created church prime as well lmao

[@demonspawn4511]

@@kkTeaz prime is the primal thing keeping him safe

[@kazanothecrackhead346]

Another theory is that the egg can only effect people that have desires they want fulfilled but since Tommy only really wanted the disks now that they have them there’s little to grab at for the egg and tubbo has Tommy to keep them grounded as Tommy is one of the big things tubbo wants to help in their life

[@Place_Holder-cl5hk]

The prime prophecy

[@Otterifcation]

He IS prime

[@bradleyalty163]

The egg doesn’t affect tommy bcuz he has everything he desires, the discs an tubbo, the egg gives u what u truly desire and tommy and maybe tubbo have everything

[@personperson3022]

How does it give you what you desire? What does BBH have to desire? Or Antfrost? And how has anything changed with them other than creepy warshipping

[@blackamongus1740]

@@personperson3022 bbh wants skeppy, idk about ant

[@bradleyalty163]

@@personperson3022 bah wants friends and to help skeppy it looks like to me antfrost wants power he is also in the badlands soooo companionship also before this the badlands was “quiet” and less n known now the eggpire is one of the most memorable on the server the egg literally says to many of them “I will give u wat u want I can give u what u desire”

[@thy-arkham]

So maybe the infected have to kill turbo, and take his disc

[@pocketer_5257]

Then what about the people who hate the egg? There’s not much evidence for that But i disagree with the fact that Tubbo is not infected He’s not exactly “infected” but he has a reaction I think that anyone who has an reaction to the egg is considered not to be immune Whereas Tommy feels nothing at all.

[@adurodetrola]

tommy was in exile, so he wasnt near the egg at all. Everyone else seems to be affected because the've been around it since its shown up.

[@virld0052]

Tubbo was near the egg but still doesn’t show no sign of being affected except only hearing the voices just like everyone else who got infected

[@Aramanela]

@@virld0052 "he wasn't affected but he was showing symptoms of being affected"

[@Dakka-do4cu]

@@virld0052 Tubbo was crying and screaming when he touched it, he obviously hates the egg wtf are you talking about

[@CurrentlyTrippin]

good point

[@itzgalatic]

Badboyhalo has expressed that the people who desire things are the only ones effected. So it doesn't matter if they live far away they can still get infected.

[@nambam5409]

Simple answer: He doesn’t care about the egg.

[@SkellyViper]

Your name and this comment juxtaposes greatly

[@itslexi_]

True lmao

[@Minecartmaster7]

I think thats just everyone besides puffy, the badlands, and fundy.

[@the_egg_]

that makes me sad

[@fitlexyt2600]

@@the_egg_ lol

[@lemoncandies1863]

My theory is that Techno and Philza will use the egg to make omelets and cake >.>

[@jotarokujo2981]

Then Ranboo picks up the cake

[@SkellyViper]

lol

[@aceyy_669]

@@jotarokujo2981 then it’s infinite cake 👏 we did it

[@the_egg_]

please don’t.

[@metaflare1384]

Philza has death script maybe when he eated the egg he will die

[@soratruu5020]

Theory: I just think the egg can only control people that desire stuff

[@SkellyViper]

Well, everyone desires something. Even so, when Dream came into contact with the egg and even broke the blood vines, he wasn't affected. Obviously, Dream desired power, control, the discs, and more back then.

[@jamisoncrawford2265]

@@SkellyViper ya but dream already had power but for an ex bad wants skeptic witch he couldn’t like have unless he was with him

[@pickle4259]

I was thinking that having a key desire would factor into the egg. I feel as though in order for the egg to truly know that you are loyal to it, it asks for your greatest desire so the person would get something out of it. Nothing comes for free.

[@NuggetOG]

i understand how that will fit into bad and skeppy... but how about antfrost. i dont know much about his character but it doesnt seem like he desires anything. BUT, this theory could be very plausible as the egg says its against government, possibly trying to trick techno into joining him. Philza could be promised into what he wants(maybe bringing wilbur back to life, maybe?). Another character that could be influenced would then be Niki, since she wants to kill Tommy and well, the egg is all about that your theory has plenty of potential TBH. it also is proved by Tommy and how he got his desires prior to meeting the egg, being his discs and defeating Dream. the final question if your theory is said to be correct, what will happen if their desires get fullfiled, will they still follow the egg or ignore them from the on.

[@Celwxl]

@@NuggetOG For Ant, I just think that’s he’s staying loyal to Bad-

[@takashinguyen6778]

Plot twist: Tommy just doesn't wanna play along with the lore

[@nou7583]

HDHSHDHD LMAO

[@anvisriva1824]

That’s what I was thinking bc he just joked around and said “I think the egg wants bbh to curse”

[@rainydeestar]

Tommy just stopped roleplaying, L

[@Ratcup]

pft

[@aoifecampbell6715]

Lets be honest he probably just wasn't interested in their lore lm

[@pigzengamer5663]

Simple, anyone who already has voices in their head is immune. Tommy and Tubbo: Wilbur. Ranboo: Dream. Techno: Orphans. Etc

[@Goodereste]

@Blob Whahahah

[@otherfluke8309]

OOP-

[@izthistle6196]

“There can be only one voice in their head”

[@otherfluke8309]

@@izthistle6196 no it’s fake Ranboo stream he almost got influenced by it

[@Anestheticcritera]

Damm you really called us orphans-

[@miragailecruz2491]

My theory is: The egg can’t affect idiots

[@utkuayranc3210]

*this guy doesnt have a mind for me to control* -the egg upon seeing tommy

[@mvshroom6875]

@@utkuayranc3210 Lol

[@abel0692]

Lmao

[@vivala3999]

@@Random_Iceberg ranboo probably protec tecno with his powers

[@thatgamingenderman1843]

@@vivala3999 OH NO HES A MAIN CHARACTER - Technoblade

[@reyn_xd3622]

Plot twist: The egg knows he’s a minor so it doesn’t effect him.

[@turtlesarecool]

Mhhmm it’s learned from dreams mistakes and doesn't manipulate minors.

[@catchthesepaws.]

egg just doesn’t want to get cancelled on Twitter

[@idk123]

No it is because he is lesbian

[@catchthesepaws.]

@@idk123 egg doesn’t want to be called out on Twitter for homophobia

[@yamaguchitadshi1283]

That would explain why tubbo didn’t get infected by the egg two and ranboo and purpled they were all exposed to it and didn’t get infected.😱

[@theredeemer524]

I think the fact that tommy survived so much pressure and torture from dream makes him immune

[@mitsunitaiko1742]

That's interesting! That would definitely be believable

[@mitsunitaiko1742]

@help me reach 1 million without a video the point was not that Tommy suffered, it's that he has been through so much manipulation that he became resistant to it

[@mitsunitaiko1742]

@help me reach 1 million without a video Don't worry, it happens to tge best of us

[@Mvtrixx]

Dream aint do nothin tommy did much worse smh

[@mitsunitaiko1742]

@@Mvtrixx Ha ha ha ha I love jokes

[@no-ln3tf]

wow, i never knew tommy was the "chosen one". That could very well be why he is immune, I mean it wouldn't be the first time a bit has become canon.

[@EarnedAcrobat]

Calling it now: Tommy and Tubbo are Immune to it because they have nothing of value needed from the Egg.Bad Mentioned in one of his streams with Quackity he chose the Egg so he can Have Skeppy back. This means maybe Skeppy Originally wanted Bad, and Ant wants to be Loyal to Bad. Edit 1: I think Tommy and Tubbo hear it because they don't know if they Want Wilbur back or not. The Discs were what was Valuable and Even though Wilbur was a Valuable friend to them they don't know how to feel since he blew up Manburg/L'manburg.

[@SkellyViper]

That's interesting! Solid theory

[@kellykramer2599]

i agree with you i think that they are immune to it because the egg has nothing to offer it bad said that they egg can give you everything you want tommy and tubbo have everything they want but they can hear it because they are unsure if they want wilbur bad.

[@NuggetOG]

I dont think that Tubbo is immune but tommy definetly is. there seems to be 3 types of people so far: immune: tommy resistant: punz, awsamedude normal: badboyhalo,skeppy Rn from this info, i feel that Tubbo currently is resistent but has shown signs that the egg does affect him(he cried when he touched the egg, seems to definetly have some sort of influence on him, but it seems to be a different type)

[@Celwxl]

@@NuggetOG The egg made Tubbo cry because it (yes I’m calling the egg ‘it’) showed Tubbo some sad (I think, I don’t really remember) images of some families (I think-)

[@NuggetOG]

@@Celwxl That shows its still is influencing him in some way. It makes Tommy feel absolutely nothing

[@CandyThePuppy]

_He's just screaming swear words in his head so much, the egg doesn't want to have anything to do with that mind!_ XD OoO What if the egg doesn't like swearing, which is why its first victim was BadBoyHalo! XD It all has to do with who swears more and who doesn't! XDD

[@as-pl2kj]

That's is hilarious, what if that was the actual reason? XD

[@avaisapopularnamebutitsmin4979]

But tubbo stop swearing much on his streams

[@eeeyt08]

Sounds pog! I htink this makes loads of sense! Tommy said he might be going to see the egg again if he streams tonight, so that could give more information, so we can compare that to your theory. Your theory's seem to be right most of the time, or at least make sense, unlike mine XD My one for tommy being immune was because he got so many primes he was immune XD also, Tommy kinda is spreading primes because whereever he lives he has something to do with primes, like the prime log and prime path.

[@SkellyViper]

p o g

[@Kokichus]

Tommy : Do I look like a guy that gets infected by the egg?

[@the_egg_]

ye.

[@Sph34l]

Yes

[@mvshroom6875]

Don't listen to them Tommy they just want the Eggpire to rule. Turn it into a Omelet. (This is just a joke, please do not take this seriously lol)

[@W1K___]

My theory on why Tommy is immune to the egg is this. Introduction: If you were a fan of the cartoon Adventure Time then you probably watched the mini series that is elements, where the four main elements and elementals (candy, flame, ice and slime) took over the continent of Oo and split it into quarters. How it happened was that , well at least for the candy element, a wave of gum like substance spread on the surface like an infection and turning everyone who had contact into a candy version of themselves. Well most people/creatures, you see those who were 'self absorbed' didn't get infected unless they wanted to or they gave in. The character who saved the day and the connections: The character who saved the day was apparently the 5th elemental, the anti-elemental. The character had the power to make creatures and people normal again. This was because of her not being from Oo and her personality. She was very, very 'self absorbed'. So she was very stubborn and bossy and had the kind of attitude of "People don't tell me what to do, I tell them what to do". Also being immune to elementification was factor of how unwilling you were to give into the element. Now is it just me or does this sound A LOT like Tommy. It sounds so much like Tommy that I probably don't need to do the connections (and I'm lazy). There is not bad theory: I'm not saying I disagree with your theory, I think it could be true, but I'm just saying that the egg sounds a lot like elementification from Adventure Time. Well I hope you enjoyed my theory and remember... That's just a theory... A Dream SMP theory.

[@silas-arlo]

W1K - 12 Its a good theory but i dont think so, Dream basically told him what to do in exile?

[@nextwenxd4777]

Nope

[@JordynNexus]

It’s a really cool theory but the fact that they were joking when it happened makes me believe that they don’t even remember that all of that happened,

[@lizwilliams8472]

Ghoustbur gave Tommy blue whenever he was exiled and the sign is that red vs blue, So that is why Tommy is immune to the egg

[@makenzieleigh1365]

I had a separate theory and I thought I’d share it because why not haha! So the people who stand to be pretty much unaffected are (if I’m correct): Tommy, Tubbo, Techno, Dream, Ranboo (who spoke to the egg but wasn’t affected but I believe he was capable to speak to the egg because it spoke backwards just like enderman do), and I’m pretty sure Phil but idk that for sure. So Techno will most likely have no issues because he already deals with voices in his head and such, so another voice (being the egg’s) wouldn’t matter. Now originally, I thought maybe minors were safe, but Purpled was later affected from what I saw on Instagram. So I believe it could come from stability. Characters that were tormented/traumatized (by dream specifically) do include Tommy, (who is the least affected and got the most torment) Ranboo, and Tubbo. This also supports Techno not being affected because he’s also an unstable character. It could possible be that manipulation and PTSD have sort of protected them from trusting something that seemed risky, but for most other characters, they are seemingly very stable and are therefore affected by the egg. It could all be connected to Dream using the egg (as stated in the video that he could’ve used it) and therefore the three characters used the most by Dream don’t feel it’s effects because of past PTSD that follow Dream. Idrk just throwing it out there :D Edit: which is also why Dream wasn’t affected, although I do think this theory alone is really good and I hadn’t really thought about it this way. Edit again because of course I would: I swore when watching the vod and everything that when Tommy said he heard the egg, he just ended up making a meme out of it. Every single time he’s “heard” it that I’ve seen he would say things like, “It wants us to swear BBH” and stuff like that

[@inprif2165]

Theory- Tommy is immune because he’s a child

[@lemsavage9473]

In a more meta analysis, I think Tommy tried to pick the option he thought would keep him out of the plot and poeple went "immune!" And he just rolled with it. TLDR: Ex-protag still has plot armor

[@mvshroom6875]

And he ended up being dragged into the middle of the plot xD

[@aoifecampbell6715]

My exact thoughts i was like bruh maybe he just wants to do funny bits with people

[@evanl_9217]

theyre immune because they focus on making the egg into an egg sandwich, so they cant do anything else

[@roven_5530]

Reason: He's a main character.

[@Shaea_Q]

That’s really good theory. Maybe even Dream is somehow under control of the egg and that’s why is he evil and don’t actually care for anything.

[@kevener3349]

It's easy, since he's been in exile, he doesn't know this is lore Im kinda breaking the 4th wall but eh whatever

[@sheepysnowtato824]

I love how at this point, literally anyone could do just the dumbest shiz ever on the server and fans would find a way to fit it into the lore. And I'm all for it XD

[@justsomeguywithoutahairlin272]

FINALLY, SOMEONE TALKS ABOUT TOMMY BEING THE CHOSEN ONE thank you

[@iregretnothing9916]

answer: because he naturally has primes 👍

[@polcumaku6622]

Him: why is he immune Me: he's the main character

[@tdc3477]

Nah thats Ranboo XD

[@mvshroom6875]

@@tdc3477 Just gonna explain this in my opinion :) Just because player one exists doesn't mean Player two cannot :)

[@digital_leo96]

@@mvshroom6875 ikr

[@4lexn0t4ce]

why tommy is immune to the egg: *he’s a child*

[@NicoNeeks_]

tommy other than being "the one" also suffered a lot and now he has all he ever wanted, tubbo and the disks so it's pretty normal that he is immune (and even if tubbo is too tommy is more immune)

[@probablyfuturevods]

Yo, I love the theories being made, the smp members are probably like "Oh, No Tommy is just too bad at roleplaying to fake being corrupted." when people like this are just *Intense lore essays*

[@sonikyuu7970]

I think Tubbo isn't immune, here's why: - after their visit when they passed the vines, he started to cry again - he doesn't have any infection effects because he bathed in Church Prime's water, so he washed off the effects He didn't go there more than once so i don't have any more proof :/ Tommy tho, he is immune but to all voices not only to egg's manipulation Every time he said "oh, egg told me something" was in a joke matter and i think he just wanted to do some funnies So he doesn't actually hear what the egg said Anyways, you've got a nice theory about Tommy just being the chosen one lol I like it a lot and it makes sense

[@arithblue]

eh... it was just a joke bit tho,my theory that tommy has already went through more sadness and darkness that the egg can could do to gain control over him,and got him stronger,i mean tommy is not the only one in the server with so called powers,Karl can time travel,and Ranboo has endermen powers

[@magnificentcheeseburger6996]

He loves women so much he don't got enough room in his brain to love the egg

[@cbld3012]

I thought that children can't get infected like how tommy and Tubbo are still just kids and stuff

[@haileydied3741]

My theory is people who have trauma are unaffected (Basically all the children on the smp aside from purpled)

[@rflamez]

The writers of the Dream smp: Noted-

[@rlv1gaming16]

Tommy is an egg and eggs don't betray their team😂

[@hydrastuff8029]

So we're aren't gonna talk about Techno? Or how he ended up betraying Tubbo to work with Techno? Or how he's betrayed a lot of people as of late?

[@lydiasaperson1244]

I seen someone’s comment that said the egg only effects people who desire stuff and i think that was such a great idea since i can add to this, everyone desires something except tommy he has all his discs and has just got out of exile so he is great full for what he has, dream knows this about the egg so thats why he gave all the discs to tommy so tommy didnt desire the discs, dream still desires stuff so he loked himself in the prison so he couldn’t be effected

[@lydiasaperson1244]

@@TheDuckLover12Lover when

[@xkosmic2014]

I think your theory is really smart but it doesn’t make sense when it comes to certain people. First, Tommy isn’t the only one immune to the egg. Ranboo, Techno, and Phil are all also immune (shown in their streams). This begs the question; what is the one thing that ties together each of these characters? The fact that they all have “voices”. It’s a well known fact that Techno’s chat is like several voices in his head, but recently it has been discovered that it is the same with Ranboo, Phil, and Tommy. This is even more proven so when it is found out that the egg takes over as a voice. Is it possible that they aren’t affected because the egg’s voice is overpowered by the voices already in Ranboo, Techno, Tommy, and Phil’s head? By logic, this simply means if you have something that can overpower the egg’s influence, you are immune.

[@silas-arlo]

What voices do tommy and phil hear?

[@xkosmic2014]

LilyWasSlain shrug I just know they hear voices idk the specific streams but they mentioned it. Tommy mentioned his voices screaming “run from niki” and phil,, idk the specifics just that he hears them

[@saphire7979]

hes pro gamer making him immune

[@virld0052]

Tommy is one of the builders of church prime (dream and tubbo are also) probably meaning that their immune since church prime blocks affects of the egg so meaning that they are probably still technically affected because he can hear the egg but doesn’t take over him

[@rimurutempest736]

Nah Tommy is immune to everything radiation, the egg, ect

[@slimebind]

why is everyone is thinking too much about this, all they did is say no to the egg, thats it

[@sankuttusk268]

Because the egg only feeds on poor people

[@channelgoingthroughdevelop1668]

Its simple, he doesn't have the brain cells needed so that the egg can control him.

[@robrop1526]

I think that since tommy was not near the egg when it first spawned in ( he was in exile) he is immune to it that would mean that others who weren’t near the egg when it spawned in (techno, Wilbur, Jshlatt, etc.) willl also be immune and tommy would have to team up with them to stop the egg.

[@sadiemorgan4389]

I have a theory as to why Tommy is Immune, however I am not including Tubbo since he was in a way affected, I believe the affect was Tubbo "hates" the egg due to you either "loving" or "hating" it. Okay here we go: As shown recently the egg keeps making people promises based on their desires such as: -Bad: Skeppy to become normal -Quackity: Power and control As shown in the stream, and as bad said, the egg can "give" you what you want most, however I highly doubt that. But the egg seems to use peoples desires and deepest wants to manipulate and gain their obedience/control them. As we know right now Tommy has everything he wants Tubbo, The discs, and his biggest enemy is gone. The egg has nothing it can "offer" Tommy to manipulate him. Seeing this the egg decided that it should get rid of Tommy as seen in recent clips when playing the egg sound backwards. I feel like because Tommy no longer wants anything THAT is why the egg can't corrupt him. But we shall see :)

[@Magnogen]

Tommy's way to young. It's like that how to train your dragon thing

[@spottedfiregaming2248]

I think the egg is just a kind of enhancer of emotions already present. Some people like Bad love a lot, and therefore love the egg a lot when in its presence. As for Tubbo_, he’s lived a very sad SMP life, so he gets real sad. And TommyInnit is pretty apathetic to anything important, or perhaps it’s canonically interpreted as Tommy having too many conflicting emotions all the time for him to have any one magnified. Idk, just my hypothesis/head canon.

[@catzify]

have you heard what the sounds like? and in reverse it kinda translate i would honestly cry too 😭

[@nicnicninc7685]

Guess before watching the video - he built the church prime and church prime items have like special things against the egg

[@aoibhe146]

Someone called tommy lapis lazuli from su which I found really funny. If you haven’t watched su, basically lapis has gone through so much trauma that when Blue Diamond uses he powers on her and the rest of the group (her powers would basically make you cry) she stood up, and even though was affected, stood up to Blue

[@mutantdogcat4966]

This really interests me because Tommy is the streamer I mainly watch and he also got me into the SMP. Also in a clip where bad is talking to Quackity he says “maybe it’s not the person but the type of person” (or something like that) eluding to the theory that there may be more than one immune person and that there’s some kind of quality that makes you immune. At first I was thinking that maybe because he’s younger he isn’t affected but then Tubbo was affected pretty badly so I have no clue.. and I haven’t really worked out details of my theory yet so there may be some holes but yeah... Edit: I do think that Tubbo was affected but if he wasn’t then my theory could still hold true.. Edit 2: I really like this theory good job..

[@altmb3707]

I like these kind of videos, keep it up!

[@SkellyViper]

Thanks, will do!

[@annaz8672]

I think Tubbo isn't immune because he was actually said on steram that he was the cursed one (as a joke since he didn't make his pearl throw on the church prime stream). But I do agree that Tommy is immune because he is the "chosen one'.

[@Timeper]

My theory is that the egg only works if the person have a desire they still haven't obtain , and for tommy his desire was his disk and dream's downfall which he already have done and acquired, so even though he can "hear" the egg it still can't influence/control him.

[@alperenk1237]

I think it could be because the egg is a dreamon and because dream wants him alive egg does too.and because dream wanted tubbo dead or doesnt like him egg haves bad effect on him

[@undyingspy5245]

The egg Said to bbh kill Tommyinnit

[@multi0s126]

at one point dream had a dreamon part of him but tubbo and fundy took it out of him and dream is basically god in the smp could the egg be dreams dreamon , it does manipulate people similarly to dream and wants control of everyone in the dream smp, maybe the egg is trying to form a new body or merge back with dream since there was a part of dream at one point though I could be wrong and completely separate from dream I don't know this is just my theory on this.

[@kayetoledo7915]

All the people so far who are known to be immune are Tommy, Tubbo, Ranboo and Phil. I've also seen in the wiki that Ponk has been corrupted before, but after losing its influence, he also became immune

[@D-Trial]

For me because tubbo and Tommy are the people that only hear ghostbur with Wilbur's spirit they're immune

[@nou7583]

Everyone sees ghostbur

[@rodaguj5718]

egg: tries to hijack tommy's mind egg screen: Wait in the queue, your position: 1329, estimates time, 32767 years

[@hydrastuff8029]

My theory: Can't turn someone evil if they weren't good to begin with

[@aoifecampbell6715]

So really people who aren't good aren't gonna be affected aka Tommy, Techno, Dream etc. Etc.

[@YourMostAverageGuy]

Tommy Is A Crazy Child To The Point Even The Egg Doesn't Want him

[@VoidFrankenstein]

Yo thanks for always putting out pog content

[@moomoomackandcheese3405]

Ya know in a weird way I kinda wish that Tubbo was effected by the egg so that Tommy being immune was really unique to him (and like maybe Dream or Ranboo). That way you had like the world descending into chaos around him and for once he isn’t the cause. And so even though there are people who hate the egg they’d probably be so consumed in their hatred at that point that they would be more focused on hating each other and so when war breaks out between the two sides the only ones who can stop it is like Tommy and Ranboo or something cause like main character team up. I have no idea why Ranboo would be immune, but I think it would be cool to see like Tommy and Ranboo have to bust Dream outta prison because he’s also immune or something and even though they hate him they have like no other choice and it’s the only way. But that’s just my take on what would be cool or what I’d like to see.

[@eeelaina5588]

His internal monologue or thoughts are so loud that it nullifies the egg

[@qxarts3896]

After watching Technoblade’s lore stream, we can make a hypothesis that anyone who already had a voice invaded in their head is immune to the egg’s influence. When Ranboo falls into Bad’s trap, he starts blurting out things like “I didn’t do it” etc. Using this information, and the information we have on Ranboo and Dream’s conversation, we can assume that it was Dream talking to Ranboo, not the egg. Technoblade outright admitted that he hears many voices in his head, that another one added doesn’t effect him. The voices in his head are repelling the egg’s influence, allowing Techno to effectively counter the influence with his own arguments.

[@SkellyViper]

Interesting theory! Though I still stand by the hypothesis I made in this video (About Tommy's immunity, not Techno's)

[@eleanorv3754]

There's something I've noticed that I'm no sure everyone has. People will either like or hate the egg with varying levels of intensity at first, but if anyone spend enough time close to the egg, they will slowly begin to like the egg more. It's sort of like a scale where one end is pure hatred and the other complete infatuation. Where people start at various points but move closer to the 'love' side the more they are exposed to the egg. An example of this is Awesamdude who started off hating the egg but when he was trapped with it for a while he started to think it was okay. Tommy however is completely unaffected by the egg and so is not on any part of this scale.

[@ctggames320]

My prediction of why Tommy is immune is because he’s a minor

[@trashy8343]

that is very intresting. i forgot about that, but thought it was something about tommy and primes >:)

[@FallenRosestorm]

it'll be so cool to see what will happen to the dream smp if tommy got infected and if he could get everyone to join the egg, he got people who didn't like him to help him and tubbo fight dream, so it'll clear that he can get a lot of people to join...

[@thatgamingenderman1843]

I believe possibly Tommy might possibly be the only one who can destroy the egg

[@alansfreimanis253]

ok this might sound stupid but culd it be that its the age thats the reason since tubbo and tommy are kinda not full adults but the others are meaning they culd get infected by the age diffrence. as i said this sounds stupid but might be good to think about. btw love the vids man. keep it up!

[@devotedicytea]

On the topic of the egg, I’m pretty sure slime who literally just joined the server, is already enemies with the eggpire considering he defiled their signs, and he seems to possibly want to break dream out of prison

[@PillowWantsSleep]

I say it’s because he still doesn’t listen to anyone except tubbo and wilbur, and even then sometimes he doesn’t listen to those 2, so if he doesn’t listen to the 2 people who he trusts most then why would he listen to the egg?

[@rutinha-lg5gr]

thats just one of the many main character perks

[@trenrir8519]

I have a theory, but I need to see how Ranboo responds first

[@aliraza-uw5vt]

Other peoples : watching and listening the video carefully Me: oooooooh the modern white house looks cool in the video

[@brh7157]

i believe its because of his mental state rn like, the attemp to do suicide while in exile in stuff made Tommy immune

[@dreamsgrandma3584]

techno and Philza will just take lightly of the egg and turn it into a decoration for the table 👍

[@lemonix5893]

I think that Tubbo falls under the people who hate the egg, as he suggested to destroy it many times and although it was probably a bit, Tubbo claiming the egg is mean would prove the presence of the voice in his mind. Although, Tommy has also heard the voice of the egg and has said such. So....There isn’t any way to be sure about whether or not Tubbo is infected.

[@kudretyldrm1383]

i think tubbo is immune cuz he is a dreamon hunter that means fundy to i think ?

[@Celwxl]

So I saw a few comments saying that they think that the egg only affects people that desire something, I honestly think so too, buuuuuut, let’s see Skeppy wanted Bad, Bad wanted to be with Skeppy, Ant’s just staying loyal to Bad, Punz wants money and the same with Ponk. (Oh and this is not about the theory above but Ponk used to have BLACK eyes, and now they’re RED, his mask thing was part red and is still red, isn’t red supposed to go white- Or maybe he’s just getting “controlled” or something by the egg, and isn’t actually infected) Tommy has his discs, he has Tubbo, pretty much everything he wants. Tubbo has Tommy and Idk if there’s anything else that he wants. Ranboo stepped on the blood vines and nothing happened so I’m assuming he’s immune, he has a home, he has his pets...I think that’s also pretty much what he wants. So here are some people that can get infected. Niki: wants to kill Tommy Jack: wants to kill Tommy Dream: power (but he has to get out of Pandora’s Vault first) Techno: people to be free (no government) Fundy: people to notice/care about him. And alsooooo, does Sam have anything that he desires? And does Puffy?

[@oscar_1729]

Do you think that it is possible that the egg will spread into the prison maybe breaking it and allowing dream to escape.

[@SkellyViper]

I think the spread will take a while to reach into the prison, as obsidian slows it down.

[@manuelbonelli3690]

I actuall think is the opposite, the prison ,might be one if not the only safe place from the egg

[@sierrxxas.]

Theory: the reason tommy isn't effected is because he has the most attachments on the server (the discs and tubbo)Tubbo has tommy. Sam was kinda effected but he has Fran skeppy was suppose to in the vault so he got fully enffected.Skeppy is enffected so bad got enffected too.Ant I'm not too sure yet. Puffy was enffected but then foolish joined and is now anti-egg that's all I could think of for now

[@desmondabbott506]

Everybody already knows this. He doesn’t like the lore BadBoyHalo made, heck, even Technoblade doesn’t care about the egg lore and neither does more that 1/4 of the Dream SMP members. There almost isn’t any lore to Tommy’s immunity to the egg. When he touched the egg, he didn’t care enough to role play being affected by the egg and that’s the case with most immune SMP members so they just made it part of the script to create some lore. By the end of the day, everybody’s immune.

[@atuliyengar9638]

i think it's because Tommy has a constant voice (or voices) in his head that affects his actions, such as the first L'manberg war, where Wilbur told him not to do anything rash, but perhaps, a voice in his head said: "No, Dream deserves ass." and caused him to challenge him to a bow duel. So when the Egg entered his head, there was another voice in there that was stronger and made him immune to it cause it really wasn't a major influence. This also happened with Technoblade, who most recently visited the egg. he already had a thousand voices in his head, and therefore canceled out the egg. WOuld like to see a vid on this theory if possible. (pls do, it'd make me happy)

[@justalix6429]

Tommy has the power having a cracked immune system as a zoomer

[@otterbanana1556]

I think tommy might be a balance because he wears red but has blue eyes and he also is the one that dealt with dreams manipulation the longest other than erit but he probably is the only one that can resist like during the exile arc in where he realized he was being manipulated by dream

[@Megan_Grayson07]

Ok here is my theory on Tubbo, I think Tubbo is/will be infected because from what Bad and Ant plan to do is to get the haters on their side and Bad has tried to lock Tubbo down in the egg. This will be a dramatic change in the story as well. Tubbo has said in other streams the egg made me sad or something at least similar. Tommy on the other case, I feel as either your theory was correct or that since Dream want Tommy alive he did something to Tommy to be immune and maybe that happened while Tommy was in exile, Dream knew about the egg before he was put in prison. And from what I believe, the prison protects Dream form it's effects or spreading into the prison. So yeah, also I think it might be possible that Tommy or someone else will break Dream out of prison so Dream can help get rid/fight to get rid of the egg or at least bring someone back that was killed because of the egg. I think if someone where to die it would be either Tommy, because the people effected by the egg kills him since he is immune and Tubbo might get Dream out to revive him. Or Tubbo, because if he gets effected by the egg, Tommy might have to kill him and later get Dream to revive him. What do you all think?

[@felitus2564]

this is actually a good theory

[@SkellyViper]

Thank you :D

[@kalamitinoiz9251]

Someone said this before that the red makes people happy,the more hurt the more immune,tommy has had the worst of it

[@eagan_1902]

Lmao "Might have a chance against the egg" Considering that Ranboo gonna be 100% infected might be there only leverage to not die immediately to Technoblade and Puffy

[@starblaze_3609]

Someone should go to bbh and tell him about this, since they know church Prime stuff nullifies the effects of the egg. If he finds out Tommy is the closest to the god of church prime, then he could realize that there is absolutely nothing he can do to make Tommy love the egg.