Dude, Where’s Her Car?

The plaintiff is dating the defendant’s cousin. She says she gave the defendant money to help her buy a car, but he never got it for her. The plaintiff claims the defendant threatened to shoot her when she asked him about it, so she’s suing for her money back, the value of a dog, and emotional distress. The defendant argues he bought the car, but then the plaintiff called the cops on him. He’s countersuing for house locks, a car ignition, and damaged car windows.

[@Bray_Jay]

She brought his keys to court, proving his claim. Judge turned a blind eye to that because viewed him as a dopefiend.

[@nancycobb342]

True true the judge missed that one 😢

[@elishamartin7090]

Just came to say this. JM did him dirty.

[@estellesery8378]

The judge has a tendency to pick a favorite according to the back story. Then he just goes for whatever his favorite says.

[@lovelace4512]

@@estellesery8378 so true. He can be VERY biased and moody

[@ajaba8393]

You do realize that was after the verdict. He got his property back. Case closed

[@TatiBak]

I believe the defendant. 😢 I’m not usually irritated with judge Mathis even on his long ass rant days but this was just a wrong verdict.

[@TeamofMe]

Judge Mathis quick to call out a man before the man opens up his mouth....how do you spend $400 on a dog but $600 on a car. Her priorities were in the wrong place!

[@sexytrinny52]

NEVER Mind

[@sherilynflowers8967]

Why would you trust or give a dope fiend money to buy you a car? Makes no sense!

[@anastacia0189]

"when you're abbreviated, you don't know what's going on." 😭😭🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 she thought she ate that up

[@chiquitabroxkman231]

Omg my people my people 😮😢

[@prydefitpire]

LMMFAO 💀

[@K_Cole0128]

😂😂😂

[@GoodFellazDMV]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@K_Cole0128]

Where was her long term boyfriend when his cousin was threatening to shoot her?

[@latricebrown7942]

I really hate how Judge Mathis makes his rulings. He's purely an emotional judge

[@aprilshines9521]

Right…He was also showing out because he had family in the audience, too!

[@yolandajones6789]

​@aprilshines9521 this was the comment I was looking for! He does it every time.

[@teeellington1332]

So he just ignored the fact that she proudly had his keys.

[@leondra]

“when you’re abbreviated you don’t know what’s going on” 😂😂

[@ashleynesbitt4740]

After Judge Mathis said he didn't prove his case she handed him the keys that he said she stole , wow i would sue judge mathis a** !!smh

[@Bray_Jay]

I'm glad that you caught that too.

[@ak24553]

Right!!! She stole his keys

[@HeyMe75]

He should have sued her for the keys

[@ashleynesbitt4740]

@@HeyMe75 He did he brought some old locks to show he had to change em all out plus get a new truck key and judge Mathis was like you didn't prove your case sir and right afterwards she gave him the keys back lol

[@wordplay6665]

😂

[@K_Cole0128]

He played her on a car before this case and sold her dog and she continued to do business with him. She didn’t deny she took his keys, she held them up in court .

[@KayB-l5h]

Both actually proved their case and judge looked stupid as usual in front of his niece tryna get a laugh about a dope fiend and not listening. The plaintiff stated earlier she took his keys and judge patted her on the back for it.

[@ashleynesbitt4740]

He made me so mad about the dope fiend thing because he's usually for weed and weed is not crack , he passed judgement on that man just because of her opinion of him I would sue him for calling me that if I was the guy !!

[@mrpitts15]

“When you’re abbreviated you don’t know what’s going on” . Definitely the wrong word. Hilarious 😂 😂

[@QMusicSTL]

I cant wait to go out this weekend and get "Abbreviated" 😂😂😂

[@TheeMichellesMind]

😂😂😂

[@SANDRABUFORD]

While you're at it, 3:14; Go on your proceeded🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@29blaquegurl]

The fact that she said he was “abbreviated”😂😂😂😂😂

[@k.tmoney9915]

😂😂

[@tshiruh5]

What does it mean

[@brennenjones6658]

​@@tshiruh5he misspoke. He meant to say "inebriated".

[@tshiruh5]

@@brennenjones6658 damn that’s embarrassing 😳 🤣

[@brennenjones6658]

@@tshiruh5 yep! 😂🤣🤣 I knew what he was trying to say so I wasn't too hard on him. Maybe he was nervous, lol.

[@brenttucker3933]

“The guy that shot me” 😂😂😂😂 I burst out!!

[@ickieyon1254]

"YOU A MONEY HOANGRY... SUCH AND SUCH!" 😂😂😂 He let's you decide what a such and such is.

[@Virgolady1993]

Why does the defendant sound like Lawrence Fishbourne playing Ike Turner??😂

[@Bossthedoss]

Facts

[@theflygemini]

He also sounds like lil meech from BMF!

[@SANDRABUFORD]

Because he is Abbreviated😁😁🤣🤣😱😱

[@tom11zz884]

Once the Plaintiff said the Defendant was a hot head and " Intimidating", I knew it was over for the Defendant, no matter how he presented his case, the Judge was going to rule against him. Judge seems to have a lot of personal issues that he brings into these rulings.

[@K_Cole0128]

She said he’s a pill poppin animal. 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@lia8006]

😂😂😂

[@NubianP6]

It’s sad to think of a poor, innocent puppy falling into the hands of someone who doesn’t want to care for him/her. 😢

[@Virgolady1993]

The plaintiff: When you’re ABBREVIATED you don’t know what you’re doing. 😂😂😂😂😂

[@adrianknight1406]

I see why Mathis was canceled. His behavior is too much. Overly emotional tyrant

[@TopherGrant]

Crybaby😢😢😢😢

[@TopherGrant]

You're cancelled

[@badseedent4827]

He's a male feminist what do you expect

[@timothyjacob6381]

So, was the Peoples Court and Judge Judy. 🙄

[@sexytrinny52]

​@@timothyjacob6381 He doesn't have smoke for them.

[@K_Cole0128]

20 years of dating?? Damn!!

[@dariustownes9817]

That’s wild

[@marieprince3994]

Right who dates for 20yrs😢

[@TopherGrant]

Because marriage is a severely outdated ritual. It has no effect on anyone's attitudes, actions, fidelity. It's expensive, it's stressful, it serves no real purpose. The ONLY reason is for the woman's feelings.

[@tom11zz884]

Getting married certainly isn't the answer giving the high divorce rates in America and men getting shafted in the courts.

[@LeolaGlamour]

Probably for welfare purposes

[@lafiosamusic5531]

He has enough restraint not to call her out her name at the end though. “Such and such”… if he was really as bad as she tried to portray him to be he wouldn’t have cared at all. I see some holes in her story.

[@misterbee66]

The bottom line is that she never denied taking his keys. 🔑 He still should not have gotten rid of the car that she paid him for.

[@ib722]

Smh wtf kind of car can you get for 600 $???????😂😂

[@chrispendherassdown]

Auctions sir police tow cars ppl never pick them up then they sale them... Places like that good day😅👌🏿

[@LeolaGlamour]

​@@chrispendherassdown auctions no longer have nice cars the dealers by them all up. What gets left is crap.

[@chrispendherassdown]

She obviously looking for a point a to b not something nice ma'am😏🤔

[@LeolaGlamour]

@@chrispendherassdown 600 will you get a car that doesn't even drive. When I say nice I mean driveable.

[@chrispendherassdown]

@@LeolaGlamour I spent 600 at an auction for 2 cars that ran for 3 years 🤷🏿‍♂️😏 then I sold them both still running then...so🤔

[@Emerance_]

Judge Mathis be overlooking and making judgements way too early

[@papalegbasson2447]

One of ladies from Detroit has a dent in her face so we know she doesn't play.

[@Fatmasters11]

haha

[@anonymouslee8287]

😂😂😂... Cut, crown, or curse you!..😮

[@TopherGrant]

She got lippy with her man. Once

[@youmakemelaugh1797]

Knew I saw something, be over there moving furniture on a daily..

[@andreawashington5430]

That’s a deep dent in her face I’ve never seen that before…

[@Iamwhoiam993]

There's no way in the world I would leave a 6 week old 🐶 with someone like that! 🤔 6 weeks is almost like a newborn. Way too young! 😒👎🏾

[@_MoneyMike_]

You know he’s on drugs and give him money for a car?

[@Iamwhoiam993]

AND a 6 week old little 🐶! 😒👎🏾

[@donnabethea8164]

Wow the defendant’s demeanor changed when JM called him a dope fiend. He held his composure though. That woman should have never trusted him knowing he was such a bad person

[@K_Cole0128]

The defendant does seem under the influence of something. Idk if he’s high or drunk.

[@latashawilliams2859]

And mixed with a little, "I don't give a damn!!!!!!! 😂🤣

[@andreawashington5430]

Yeah you must be mindful on how to represent yourself in court…

[@amybrooks2604]

Not abbreviated🤣🤣

[@patsyjohnson2064]

They act like they go together. More than friend.

[@marhar101]

He came to court high with a big ass shirt tucked unevenly ....he definitely don't give a damn 😂

[@JamilaMusa-xz6ss]

You are so funny 😂

[@Ms2010collegegurl]

From reading these comments and listening to the plantiffs voice, i knew this would be a case to skip ✌🏿

[@skettistraps1108]

Judge Mathis: "He has crackish ways!" Defendant: 😡😡😡

[@bryanjohnson8982]

He didn’t prove his case but she got the keys? Lol JM is a an emotional wreck

[@victoriamask6113]

How did he not prove his case omg

[@leondra]

why would they pay $400 for a dog they couldn’t take care of? i don’t believe her!

[@valeedadavidson678]

DEFENDANT HAS A LOT OF RESTRAINT. I WOULDN'T BE STANDING THERE WHILE CALLING ME A CRACK HEAD. JM DOESN'T LISTEN HE SAID FROM THE BEGINNING SHE TOOK HIS KEYS. THEN SHE GIVES THEM TO HIM. MEANING HE WAS TELLING THE TRUTH. SHE SHOULD'VE PAID HIM.

[@TheeMichellesMind]

Baby, not abbreviated instead of INEBRIATED! Ma’am goodbye 👋🏾. 🙄😳😩🤦🏽‍♀️🥴

[@therealshesofly3374]

I couldn’t have been in the audience I would’ve been dying laughing the whole time 😂

[@lotusgsxr750]

I hope the puppy is in a better place because both of them dont make sense.

[@HCJServices]

The fact that she had his keys he should’ve got a little something for that. That was proof that she took the keys and the truck windows did get left down.

[@courtnaetwyman2686]

How did she get away with that? Wowwww aye the judge makes me not interested to watch his shows anymore that’s crazy I can’t believe I just watched that

[@meccadavis935]

A such in such… lol I love him even mad he didn’t disrespect…and she was the abbreviated hot head lol

[@kjayelindsay9931]

Why he sound like Lawerence fishburn in what’s love got to do with it? 🤣

[@juniorstarks7494]

@ 9:13 the plaintiff said “when you’re abbreviated you don’t know what’s going on” I believe she meant to say inebriated 😆🤣😂

[@thesavagery6696]

The defendant sound like Laurence Fishburn

[@tom11zz884]

Looks like a young Fishburn as well.

[@TeamofMe]

Boyz in the hood Laurence!!!

[@thesavagery6696]

​@@tom11zz884I just noticed that as well let me find out that's his long lost son lol

[@thesavagery6696]

​@@TeamofMe "What you bring me to eat?" "U know I don't eat that swine" lol

[@misterbee66]

​@@thesavagery6696Lol.

[@Trey3times]

Wanna win your case ?? Prove the other side is on drugs 😂

[@lucipeters8639]

The boy is mad

[@K_Cole0128]

What kind of a car did she find for $600? Even during the time of the tapping

[@nettricegaskins1871]

Why would anyone buy a dog that they can't take care of?

[@rubyjaez]

Why is this woman dealing with this man? She’s dating his cousin. His Cousin should’ve been the one communicating and conducting business with him not her. These Women get with Grown boys and still have to take on the roles of A Man.

[@nae80West]

That’s very mean rude and disrespectful to KEEP calling someone a dope fiend…..

[@thesugarcase7431]

The guy was so disrespected. I don’t agree with this verdict.

[@sharellmathis419]

I feel like the plaintiff isn’t innocent like she can get her drug and alcohol on too handing that man his keys after the verdict is insane did they ever show the purchase date to compare it to the police report I hope he don’t talk her anymore she seems annoying if you ain’t trust him why you give him your money if he such a drug fiend JM wasn’t listening at all it’s always the worse when he lets personal feelings get involved

[@josettempc7719]

"When you abbreviated you don't know what's going on"😂

[@carolharris5455]

Shameful Judge is horrible for this verdict

[@hevinamber]

At the end he acted like he was going to hit her 😢

[@oluwayomiolubola7148]

For those criticizing the judge and his biased ruling, he had a good case even though he was wrong but had to dope before coming to the court. Come on

[@bestrong8543]

He was emphatically on some type of drug how embarrassing to come on national tv high 🤦‍♂️

[@Bee-hg9qp]

Are you special?

[@heavyqueen9524]

Wait so she did have his keys??!!! Which means she did take them???! WOW! She’s asking for trouble! And the crazy thing about it he’ll be the blame!

[@filiciaball6951]

He ignored that part about his keys. This is one of the main reasons that I'm glad his show is no longer being aired and the new show ain't worth the film it's filmed on. Straight garbage!!!

[@hevinamber]

Wow a ton of lawyers in the comments 😂 ⚖

[@gt43025]

Mathis wrong; should’ve gave him something for the lock change. How can u sleep peacefully knowing someone has your keys 😮smh

[@carolharris5455]

Hair over the eye says she lying 😅😅😅😅😅

[@Karimi1able]

He's handsome and intelligent. The judge tearing down a fellow black man for the sake of entertainment is petty.

[@blessedwomanof1447]

YES HES NICE LOOKING, AND PRESENTED HIMSELF WELL

[@Ericechild1979]

DA DAUG PUPEE😂😂😂😂this case is hilarious 😂

[@junebutler1933]

Judge Mathis you try to make a mockery out of people and listen to people based off of how you feel

[@theprettyone9474]

A “pill poppin animal”😂😂😂😂

[@treymcgee2611]

That’s why his shit was cancelled

[@DJ-vj4vi]

You gave a person $600 in CASH? How are you going to prove your case with no documentation?

[@shawandam8213]

She said he be abbreviated 😂

[@lunacy3]

Dope fiend story🤣

[@badseedent4827]

when he said he knew not to come on this show he shouldve followed his first mind .. bkuz judge sassy knew he proved his case but rulled against him anyways

[@andreawashington5430]

Yeahhh it sucks to have your case on National Tv… But if you get on the show your claim is paid by the show… so she got paid from the show it, she still didn’t get it from his pockets…🤷🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️. Why buy a dog if you can’t tend to it, shame on her and want to blame him. Once she saw him not treating dog right she should’ve went got the doggy 😢that says a lot about her/him😮. She should be happy the judge ruled in her favor

[@dontaerahn4774]

Once he call you a dope fiend, you lost the case

[@sweetcandykane1]

The fact that she had his property that's theft, what I noticed is anytime Judge Mathis has family members or friends in the audience he acts up. She shouldn't have gotten anything as she stole his property. Smh such a shame.

[@PutGOD1st-h7d]

I just came here to say judge mathis is bias, moody and most of his rulings are based on emotions not evidence. I’m starting to think this dude has daddy issues. And this ruling was wrong smh!!

[@highlander666]

It's too bad he's always "abbreviated", hope he gets help soon😂

[@wadilotus]

The defendant was seething and i can see why, leave him in a room alone with Mathis and he would tear Mathis to shreds, crackhead or no crackhead. Mathis was deliberately trying to get under his skin when he heard the Defendant is a fighter and tougher than him. Mathis is so easily intimidated and envious of guys with real street cred. All that talk about his little petty crimes as a teenager and the “game” that he purportedly “knows” and yet he still feels inadequate to guys who aren’t even in his peer group. Clearly he secretly fantasizes about the life of a kingpin that he never had, because he obsesses about it too much.

[@dadabg8747]

She messed his car up and he's his keys proving his case. Everything should have been dismissed

[@delonjuan]

Woman holding the keys but defendants didn’t prove case judge be tripping sometimes

[@Phoenix-tl6tr]

For some reason I believe the defendant not the plaintiff

[@fOrEvErLaTiNa]

He got the 50 cent laugh 😂🤣

[@tonyayoung2702]

Her body language screams that she is uncomfortable to be that close to him. Crackish ways. Judge M is hilarious.

[@LeolaGlamour]

His niece is gorgeous

[@misterbee66]

She is.

[@keektini]

JUDGE MATHIS WRONG

[@reewritten7]

8:49 When you’re abbreviated you don’t know what’s going on 😂😅 Perhaps the plaintiff was inebriated when she made that statement 😅🤣🫠

[@TiaChea]

It makes sense. Okay so what he didn’t buy the car the first day. He bought the car but can’t drive two cars at once. Maybe he was going to call an Uber back up there after dropping his car off.

[@adriagray9427]

The defendant look and sound like Laurence fishburn lol

[@Destiny-yw6rt]

mathis is so disrespectful and acts like an emotional woman. he hates to be wrong and he knew the defendant didn't know what to say. I will not be watching again. when is this show getting canceled ?

[@bing7play]

Judge don't make sense smh

[@Mrs.Blessed]

Normally I agree with JM verdict , this time i do not.

[@williamgolston5399]

She said abbreviated 😂😂😂😂😂

[@KIYAQUEN]

She better stay humble and stop taunting that man. He looks like a stone cold killa!!👀👀😫😫

[@BoogieDown-q5f]

Tem Method man!!!😂🤣🤣

[@misterbee66]

Taking his keys does not mean that she broke his truck windows.

[@smbdyhadtosayit]

Where the hell you getting a $600 car from? That sound like a crackhead move!

[@SalmaisshakMead]

Justice was not served. She had his keys..