Dumb Decisions: The DUMBEST Timeout Management of Week 4 | Cowboys @ Giants (2024)

[@tywalraven4936]

I’m just numb to McCarthy’s stupidity at this point. There needs to be a “regular” Dumb Decisions series and then a Big Mac Idiot Attack series just for him.

[@into_play3226]

That game was a chore to watch. Felt like there was a flag on every other play.

[@hatuletoh]

I was laughing my ass of at Al Michaels' jokes about all the flags, and the general incompetence of both teams. Michaels has become the grumpy old man of sports commentators. Probably a natural reaction to calling the stinky piles of donkey dung that are most TNF games.

[@cmdrflake]

This was a dog of a game. Both teams lost to the Zebras!

[@Hodaggium]

Hey Dallas, he's your problem now. Signed, a Packers fan.

[@Briguy75]

lol, I keep seeing that.... I think he probably won't be renewed for another contract.. But, it's jerry, so who knows. Yes, I like the Cowboys, too.

[@kaleckton]

If I was a fan of either team I would demand a refund to all merchandise.

[@classicrockbeagle]

My question isn't why is McCarthy still coaching. My question is why does he keep winning.

[@williambryant6175]

If you’re an old school fan: because they’re God’s favorite team If you’re more practical: because the devil has a sick sense of humor

[@classicrockbeagle]

@@williambryant6175 Funny, even though I'm from Buffalo, when I was a kid, the Cowboys were my favorite team. I grew out of it in the early 80s. There is something to it.

[@SSJasonX]

Because Aaron Rodgers and Packers defense made him a Superbowl Champion.

[@scottybbadd]

He's a lame duck coach

[@lightsabermetrics]

For my money, the best Dumb Decisions video ever made was when McCarthy lined up Zeke Elliot at center on the last play of the Divisional Round game vs the 49ers. I don't think that decision will ever be topped by any coach.

[@nautgamingnautgaming9949]

Mccarthy had learned that genius from 2015 colts at patriots fake punt attempt where the famous 1 center 1 qb n the rest lined up wide vs 3 down lineman on new England n 8 wide on New England

[@Bruce12867]

Seriously, there's enough videos there to make a Mike McCarthy playlist.

[@arizonawrestlinginterviews1040]

I'm about to create one now

[@eliice1715]

I don't think I've ever seen ScooterMagruder sweat out a game vs the Giants the way he did last night

[@adamthespinygiant]

I’ve seen this before. 11 times as a matter of fact.

[@hunterbolton2680]

Mike McCarthy is BACK! :D

[@marquan1976]

I am the king of Dumb decisions! Yeah, that’s not something to be proud of. 😂

[@jacksonmcmahon4147]

He’s baaaaaaack

[@Koops17]

I love it how whenever you have Dumb Decisions featuring Mike Mccarthy where you have the intro featuring a meme of SpongeBob it's so hilarious you should do a Playlist of Mike Mccarthy being on Dumb Decisions when his coaching job is done

[@Tubewings]

I've said it before and I'll say it again--these videos should be required watching for ALL football coaches.

[@SeanDavid-w5n]

I've been a Green Bay fan all my life I'm over 50 now! McCarthy was always bad at clock management and his use of timeouts . So this been his primary problems for all his career.

[@TheMailmanOfSteel]

Time to make a "Mike McCarthy Dumb Decisions" playlist.

[@KevinThomas-qu6bz]

You should make a Mike McCarthy Dumb Decisions playlist at this point.

[@nautgamingnautgaming9949]

Mike Mccarthy is KEEPING your channel properly employed Hes making sure you have content n video's n work for you to do

[@brianevans6328]

The Gmen's play calling in the last 28 seconds was questionable also. I don't know if it was done by the coaching staff or Daniel Jones' boneheaded actions.

[@guttmana9767]

The 22 yard field goal was far, far dumber IMO. Go for it and either take the lead or pin the cowboys deep.

[@martincaidin4166]

The other question is why they weren't set at :08. Were they expecting Fat Mike to call a timeout?

[@maplemiles3381]

Hank Hill will be saying "I can cough the cowboys better the McCarthy I tell yeah what"

[@mikehunt8997]

That FG was manipulated and thus the game was rigged, scripted plus fixed. Dallas has enough points to win the game now trying to beat the point spread, while at the same time potentially blowing the game. THE nfl = WWE.

[@andrewpadaetz5549]

that's 12 by my count. Enough to fill a box of Krispy Kremes..

[@kevinramsey417]

Mike McCarthy lives in the penthouse of the Dumb Decisions apartment complex. He is the undisputed main character of the Dumb Decisions series. You know you royally screwed up when you're playing the Giants and the Dumb Decisions video ISN'T about them.

[@Roll-Tide-99]

How do the Cowboys keep winning despite McCarthy’s constant dumb decisions

[@Crosroad]

The giants are a team carried by one rookie, and also one of the worst calls of all time on that facemask

[@timharwell6803]

They win in spite of him, not because of him. I can't understand why Jerry Jones kept him. His leash is way too long. He should've been fired after whatever the hell that final play was in the divisional round not too long ago. As long as Mike McCarthy is the head coach, the Cowboys will not make it to the Super Bowl with his dumb decisions.

[@Briguy75]

@@timharwell6803 lol, they kept Jason Garrett for 10 years. Yes, I like the Cowboys !

[@basedcody781]

The dumbest timeout of week 4 so far 😂

[@JavierVelez2007]

He’s back!!! Mike freaking McCarthy.

[@seethemiddlefinger2759]

Only a matter of time. Mike still has a place in Door County, right? Hes gonna need it.

[@Cramhead43]

Colts game last week made me nauseous. This game was a mix between ennui, mild interest, and exasperation.

[@anthonyjkenn6319]

What, you thought LomHoodie McCarthy was going to just sit back and let this young gun pretender Nick Sirianni just walk in and take *his* crown? Really and for true? 😂😂😂

[@victorpope8278]

Hate to say this, but Mike Mccarthy is king of dumb decisions.

[@PeteTheRock2002]

Aside from his date mishap (The game was September 26, not 27), good vid.

[@brennanbeyer5645]

Packers fans tried to warn you, Cowboys!

[@hanschristopherson8056]

It is actually shocking that McCarthy has coached 18 seasons when he is clearly terrible at in game management

[@KevinT7274]

McCarthy won a SB, that's why? Almost the same way the 'Music City Miracle' led to the Titans making the SB and bought Jeff Fisher 15 years as a HC.

[@rugbynut5536]

Didn’t mention how in the 4th the Comboys are up a score and are snapping it with 10+ seconds on the play clock

[@rngfootball759]

Had Cowboys -6 and Aubrey missed 😢

[@KevinT7274]

Rigged!🤣

[@danielbowden6330]

Call a timeout like every other coach? I'm not so sure about that. Dumb Decisions would be over if that was the case.

[@allthingssports4957]

He’s the first coach ever to get a baker’s dozen on DD!!

[@nintendopeachgaming1647]

Dude, the Giants were so bad on offense and they can't find the end zone at all just for 1 TD to beat the Cowboys. The Cowboys slightly missed the FG on 4th down Aubrey doesn't miss many FGs, besides the Cowboys weren't threated to lose the game outside of just being good enough to win on TNF.

[@afbocc]

Wasn’t there going to be on McCarthy from the second quarter?

[@Terrell070]

That was as bad as using a timeout in the 3rd quarter or right before you're about to punt.

[@marcus813]

If McCarthy keeps doing dumb stuff such as this, you'll have to find your Dumb Decisions content elsewhere because he would receive a pink slip soon enough.

[@TimEric4d3d3d3]

12:24 Dak double fisting some Gatorade

[@iomnibus]

Mike McCarthy is the GOAT of DD.

[@ParadiseCity1329]

The Cowboys won this so i thought this video was on the Giants... (sighs) dunno what i was thinking.

[@msarzo]

Guess we can shut the whole Brandon Aubrey is the real G.O.A.T. discourse down now

[@metpach]

Dude is still like 99% 😂

[@KevinT7274]

Since the FG doesn't totally shut the door on the Giants I would be ok with a pooch punt there. Make the Giants have a longer field with no timeouts.

[@BridgeBum]

That would very reasonable but so is going for the FG, which means it doesn't qualify for the criteria for this series. 😁

[@jamesmullen1259]

I wouldn't have even tried the FG I would of pooch punted because a FG can be block or in this case missed and so the Giants get better field position. I would have punted and pin them deep! I don't think the Giants can go 80 yards in 30 seconds with no timeouts

[@Michael-sb8jf]

Hell they were better off taking the penalty

[@yamingizzo7186]

Who holds their team back more: McCarthy or Sirianni

[@big4horry]

Mike McCarthy is probably not gonna make it to the end of the season. Also, did you use AI for the SpongeBob clip?

[@nicholaswalsh4462]

Can we have Dumb Decisions organized by Seasons?

[@scottybbadd]

JG9, I've got nothing

[@architect011_3]

I have the cowboys -5.5 and they win by 5. Unbelieveable.

[@Ironcabbit]

That’s because, somehow, the New York Giants are worse.

[@nengehtardzer2839]

Are the 2024 Jaguars a historically bad team ?

[@brycelandon3699]

How are you holding up with Hurricane Helene?

[@arizonawrestlinginterviews1040]

JG9 lives here in Arizona, so I'm sure he's doing alright

[@OfficialJaguarGator9]

I don’t live in Florida

[@nautgamingnautgaming9949]

​@OfficialJaguarGator9 It's a miracle we won a super bowl with THAT coaching in green Bay Mike Mccarthy has accounted for 25 percent of your episodes THIS YEAR ALONE

[@nicholaswalsh4462]

Of course it was the Cowboys.

[@Jason_Maier]

So this is appearance #12 (unlucky dozen) on Dumb Decisions by Mike McCarthy?

[@arizonawrestlinginterviews1040]

13, including this video

[@SeanDavid-w5n]

Get ready to make more he will 4 to 6 times a year coaching

[@Neaglebeagle200]

What did I tell you

[@mattram88]

Bit of a stretch on this one to be honest

[@BridgeBum]

I think it qualifies for the premise but less for the 2 seconds and more for needlessly rushing your FG team when they weren't set.

[@chamuuemura5314]

They had 4 choices: 1) field goal w/timeout 2) field goal w/out time out 3) punt 4) try to draw offside w/fake play All of them could be justified. Maybe the kicker told him he’d be ready and didn’t want the TO. Imagine if he missed after his own coach iced him.

[@ericradford2142]

Another Thursday night meh. #GetRidOfThursdayNightFootball

[@Whereyahidin]

😂😂😂😂