During a rare encounter in 1907, an NPC actually mentions Strange Man

#rdr2 #reddeadredemtion2 #gaming

[@nugsymalone1247]

What if you rode up to this dude dressed in black with a top hat on?

[@mohammedmahinsaeed6710]

This NPC said the total opposite of what would happen to tumbleweed and armadillo . 💀

[@codgodxl5937]

The strange man is either the grim reaper or the devil they make it very obvious that he is one of those things

[@Player-lm9ij]

Lol

[@Beagle20]

Or Cain from the bible

[@quickquranrecitations3091]

Bro ain't a superstitious, religious, or betting man, what else is there in Red dead?! 😂

[@Sankrityayan07]

Fighting and whoring

[@Captianpluto]

He said what he said😂

[@corey-bird3489]

The first of his kind, whatever that’ll be!

[@mjwillin]

bro it annoys me when the npc's at like they don't know you right after they just had a whole conversation with you

[@flyingblades2426]

Nobody can experience all things in 1 playthrough I bet ❤

[@JOHNMARSTON-1]

Yeah it’s impossible, for example you either get the money or help John in the last mission as Arthur

[@user-sf2tb5vi4x]

Yes but you can replay the mission too​@@JOHNMARSTON-1

[@JOHNMARSTON-1]

@@user-sf2tb5vi4x oh yeah forgot you could do that

[@JustSendMeLocationPlease]

Well I tried to explore Armadillo and Tumbleweed as Arthur. And I know there’s dialogue for Arthur there. Like he was meant to explore past Blackwater and they changed it

[@DkE4gleDk]

@@user-sf2tb5vi4x But your choices have an impact on the story when you get further, so you'll have to miss out on some stuff eventually.. Also, he said 1 playthrough, if you redo your missions, then its not really 1 playthrough

[@user-oo2co1hk3n]

Just subbed

[@mistersirlogan2004]

Guess we”ll never know who this “Strange Man” really is 🤔

[@Beagle20]

I personally believe the theory that he is Cain from the Bible. He talks about having seen many before, he appears to have strange properties such as being immortal and other such things. Another theory that he is death would also make sense, in the final encounter, John fires three bullets, all seemingly passing through him, each representing a person who dies later, one for Uncle, one for Abigail and a final for himself. His gun jams when he goes to fire another, representing how jack is spared.

[@mistersirlogan2004]

@@Beagle20 My theory is that this “Strange Man” looks just like Trelawny from RDR2 but knowing him, he probably died sometime later in the game and came back as a ghost and met John in RDR1 and tells him that he has seen John before meaning, he remembers him and Arthur together so that’s my theory on this.

[@DkE4gleDk]

@@mistersirlogan2004 Arthur wasn't even a character in rdr 1, and why would trelawny decide to kill an entire town lol. Beagle's theories are valid

[@Beagle20]

@@mistersirlogan2004him being Trelawny is a great theory that I’ve heard before but there are two holes in the theory: 1. John doesn’t recognise him in 1911, surely he would recognise him if they’ve been together in a gang for years. 2. In RDR Online, which takes place one year before the story mode in 1898, and in Story mode you can find the cabin that belongs to the Stange man and he is actually seen if you visit multiple times in story mode (until the painting of him appears to be finished) he can be seen behind you if you look in the mirror. Meaning he couldn’t be trelawny since he exists while trelawny is still at his own cabin in Rhodes.

[@Beagle20]

@@DkE4gleDkArthur wasn’t a character but some people speculate that the “others he’s forgotten” could technically mean Arthur so I get where he’s coming from.

[@therider2050]

You can actually see the strange man in grizzles near the trapper. When i saw him the first time i immediately turned off my game and went to sleep.

[@user-ux3qy9ze5q]

Cap 🧢

[@ItsMeJohnMarston]

trapper near the grizzlies?

[@redpanda8058]

I don't think so 🤔

[@thesilentassassin1167]

Things that didn’t happened

[@chadd990]

@@user-ux3qy9ze5q No cap actually. He was getting rizzed up by members of the brood, but then he swerved up out of there on a white arabian. on god fam fr fr