Echoes of Exclusion: The Plight of Religious Minorities in Pakistan

Step into the heart of a pressing issue in Pakistan - the escalating violence rooted in religious intolerance. As we go through this growing challenge, it’s evident that religious minorities face mounting insecurity. Are we overlooking their struggles? Why does each administration seem helpless in confronting these issues head-on? Why is there alarming silence surrounding this issue?
Let’s explore the plight of religious minorities and confront the complexities of this critical matter.
Panelists: Harris Khalique, Dr. Shoaib Suddle, Samuel Bashir and Ms. Jaaya Jaggi
Moderator: Dr. A. H. Nayyar

[@tapanthakur]

The attendance itself shows how serious are these people for minority rights. And they never fail to lecture us.

[@anjan67]

Pakistan should never lecture any other country till they improve their own human rights issues!!!

[@calmcurrent1998]

I find myself short of words to appericiate the courage of people arranging the black hole and people who speak with courage under serious threats.

[@mohsinafzaal7159]

I cannot believe that we have made a living hell for own citizens! What a tragedy! How did we got here? What is the cause for this shameful thing? Will it ever come to an end????

[@mikesheth5370]

Quaede Azam's speech was just idealism at. best and cheap propaganda at worst. The first speaker quoted as if it has legal implication!

[@MunawarAzaad2025]

Bismil sahib aur Shakeel Chaudhary Saheb ne ankhen kholne wali baten ki hen. Shakeel Saheb ko to guzarish hai k in topics p tafseel se tareekh batate hue programs Karen

[@SachinKumar-so8cw]

that is why I like this channel. you and we need to be educated more.

[@kpdwivedi1672]

The attendance in the room conveys some message about the interest on the topic.

[@shishirtamotia3992]

“Kafir” word se boo ati hai badtamiji aur behudgi ki! Aaj ke Black hole mein itni kam attendance kis baat ki or ishara karta hai?

[@PR-pu7pv]

Haris sir, The things in education in india 6 fully secular and non religious.. Only scientific teaching.

[@adin6514]

Positive thoughts 🌺🌼🍀❤️🍀🌼🌺

[@MunawarAzaad2025]

These discussions are needed too much in this society

[@tahirmirza8521]

After listening to this, definitely "Islam Khatrey mein hai" !!. Excellent discussion. We are heavily paying the price of the 2nd Amendment. All the generations born after this, educated or illiterate, have been brought up on hate filled upbringing.

[@somnathde8680]

V important ,topic.

[@MunawarAzaad2025]

Buht hi ala

[@DollarBill1981]

Abolish blasphemy laws.

[@youknow6968]

The last speaker amongst the audience is pure gold, trying to bring a semblance balance to the discussion rather than the usual rona randi Pakistani self loathing. But, overall, this discussion was better than most I've heard on this forum.

[@ChefbyMistake]

Jinnah’s Fault.

[@vikasb1400]

When will it start

[@geeksatish8010]

Pakistan sudarega nahi

[@dollartreeshark6786]

Zero comments after 5 hours of posting

[@gillgarry1442]

Paxtan me minoritys ka ek bhi numainda kabi Kahi nhi dekha jis ko ye bulae. JAISE India me har jagah par Hindu musalmaan Sikh christian ke numainde har jagah, har conference har debate me, har tv program me hote ha. But paxtan me never allow. Hum musalmaan ha hum kalma go ha

[@random_gunner.9064]

No point having discussion on minorities in pak because more than 90 percent muslim majority won't believe this.

[@khaistagul5950]

Parvez sir may Allah bless u .

[@criticalthinker5764]

Religions that are strong don’t need blasphemy laws . Weak need blasphemy law to protect the cult l

[@sulemanalikhanliaqatal3073]

Jaranwala jesy waqeat punjab m to hoty rehty hn or sb sy zada ulma/molvi b usi punjab m hn or sb sy zada jahalat b punjab m h.. Is digital dor m b itni jahalat h afsos h

[@bhaveshpatel7042]

# of audience in your show tells what majority of Pakistani think about non Muslims in your state. Pakistan Islamic constitution and education system reflect soul of your society. No change is coming, you are dead man walking polity.

[@saeeddeen7304]

Being Muslim, we must protect rights of all the citizens of Pakistan. They are part of us.

[@gopalramanathan7062]

The plight is trapped and driven to extinction and will be so as long as the 🐫Cult virus 🦠 exists 🛑 That’s the tragedy of being caught in The Black Hole 🕳️

[@Manasi_1983]

As long as the philosophy of the ‘lesser religion’ pertains, nothing will change with you Muslims. Truth is you guys feel only you deserve rights because of your religion; others are famously called kafirs. Imagine that someone as educated as Dr. Pervez doesn’t understand RSS philosophy … says a lot about your religion and it’s core.

[@hotfun07]

1:47:38 - 1:48:05 THATS THE SPIRIT BROTHER. WE SHALL OVERCOME AND HINDUS SHALL LIVE A LIFE OF DIGNITY IN THE LAND OF INDUS AGAIN!

[@virendraSingh-je3sx]

Jinna was not secular and was communal. He destroyed subcontinent. First reform your history and religious books full of lies and hatred towards non-Muslims.

[@DWAGON1818]

Sad to see Ahmadis not being represented. When will we stand up for all minorities. Are we being exclusionist over here aswell. Nothing good can come out of Hoodbhoy

[@HOG1070]

Looks like lost cause.... Pakistan as a Nation, unless...

[@mikesheth5370]

Cabinet mission planwas rejected by Muslim league! One speaker is wrong!

[@pramodkumarparida4575]

Speakers are more than Audiences.

[@ShreeRam12783]

Educated person needs in Pakistan.

[@mannusingh1045]

bahut der kar di Pakistanio apne ne

[@hotfun07]

1:41:11 Uncle ji, Aap Kashmiri nahi hain, aap Mirpuri hain! Aapko Kashmiri bolni nahi aati 😂 Aap to Pahari bolte hain 😜 Kashmiri sirf Hindustan mein hain ❤

[@ishwaryadav7231]

Lethal dose of religion is always fatal. Four intellectuals are speaking before a crowd of fifteen only. This only shows how receptive are people of Pak ,over these issues. Any way good to hear saner and human voices.

[@somnathde8680]

I think, Black Hole should be made popular in the subcontinent including India.

[@mnbcpoiuytt5284]

😂😂😂😂😂😂