Educating Myself To Become Ho Chi Minh's Finest Warrior

[@nddragoon]

from the couple that brought you "idealism is when hypotheticals", a new take: "dialectical materialism is when the laws of physics"

[@wynoglia]

Mind. Blown. I am now a changed man and have ascended to the next plane

[@Sugarman96]

I didn't know Newton's third law of motion was such an important part of socialism, thanks Luna Oi.

[@amellirizarry9503]

damn can’t believe Marx invented Gravity

[@hichaelhyers]

Sophistry is when Luna makes me sleep in the shed

[@ladyvanda]

It’s not even a new take - EJ already said that in his response to Vaush last year lol

[@thcrmsnchn1056]

To Luna’s framing of civil rights - “The south” is not a country nor did it represent a majority of Americans. The democratic majority of Americans supported the civil rights act and voted for pro-civil rights politicians. It was explicitly BECAUSE of democracy that segregation was ended.

[@alexgray2482]

also the Civil Rights and Voting Rights acts were about ensuring that black people could participate in civic life - ie democracy.

[@GalacticNovaOverlord]

Wrong. It was justified because of the PRESSURE of loads of populist, worker and civil rights movements in the country. That's why the intelligence and police state crushed them all. Do you know how UNPOPULAR even MLK was in the country at the time? He had less than a a 50% approval rating.

[@GalacticNovaOverlord]

@@alexgray2482 "Democracy"- that was the wish. That was not the objective of those who passed the laws.

[@alexgray2482]

@@GalacticNovaOverlord so the voting rights act wasn't about democracy???

[@thatdarnskag5043]

@@GalacticNovaOverlord zwhat was the objective of the those who passed the laws, in your opinion?

[@leek6927]

Luna “landlords are socialist because we said so” oi

[@qymeanjaishelaal1731]

What the fuck are you talking about?

[@moongirl-d9h]

Luna "nazis had a point" oi

[@endtimessupportgroup5685]

@@moongirl-d9h you mean when she was quoting vaush ?

[@usucculentcow2988]

@@endtimessupportgroup5685 and vowsch was quoting her 🤔

[@moongirl-d9h]

@@endtimessupportgroup5685 that's not what i mean, i mean when she said it of her own volition. i don't know how you quote someone on something they never said

[@SSJKirik]

Once again, Luna Oi proving to me that she abuses the term dialectical materialism so hard that the universe re-aligns itself so that the concept has no meaning.

[@blue5had0w]

It's the metaphysical substrate of the fart.

[@Kropothead]

@@blue5had0w Underrated comment.

[@Kikasitsu]

Let me know when Western “Leftists” (such as yourself), will promote the first “successful” “Socialist” “Revolution”, *by not addressing* the history of Class Struggle. I’m certain if Vaush keeps promoting a mealy-mouthed, watered-down version of Liberalism (by calling it “Socialism”), *EVENTUALLY* we’ll get Socialism, right?

[@EE-jp5ev]

Just another reminder Luna Oi is a landlord

[@JamesRoyceDawson]

Oh boy, last time this spawned 3 months of drama. Looking forward to seeing the results of this

[@Sugarman96]

I wonder who she'll convince to hop on and defend her honor this time.

[@varisleek3360]

@@Sugarman96 i volunteer as tribute

[@Iloveguitar07]

I'm ready for it

[@themajesticspider-man6116]

@@varisleek3360 Noooooooo

[@misirtere9836]

@@varisleek3360 down horrendous

[@nohbuddy1]

Socialists/Communists need to stop tying themselves down to old figures from the past.

[@MrGksarathy]

Or at the very least, stop mindlessly regurgitating their ideas with no context or actual analysis.

[@Lambda_Ovine]

That, plus our inability to coalesce amongst the different factions to attain any sort of real material gains whatsoever have been the worst and most crippling tendencies across the left that I can think

[@FelisImpurrator]

It is a trait of the authoritarian mind to think of ideas only as essentially tied to the name of an individual - as if an idea is given essential character by its inevitable descent from a Great Man. There's no difference between how Luna Oi talks about Ho Chi Minh or Marx, and how Charlie Kirk talks about John Money as the "inventor" of "trans ideology".

[@nohbuddy1]

@@FelisImpurrator It's like quoting Darwin for 21st century biology. There have been improvements since then

[@caesarplaysgames]

Socialism without Marx or Engels is not socialism, it’s something different.

[@JARV9701]

So, Vaush actually made NonCompete sleep on the couch. That or Luna got NC into a bar fight that he loose.

[@karimC35]

If you’re a grown ass couple that changes your Facebook relationship status to “it’s complicated” you deserve the chair

[@manuelmialdea5127]

What happened?

[@atropa6053]

@@manuelmialdea5127 it became complicated

[@DavySolaris]

Using Facebook in 2022: cringe Having a Facebook relationship status in 2022: cringe Actively changing said relationship status to "its complicated": just fucking kill me

[@rogerboyd1297]

@@atropa6053 RIP my sides

[@YokaiX]

It's not the complicatiom of the relationship that's bad imo, but it's telling people (and in Facebook no less) that publicly that's cringe lmao

[@Ar1AnX1x]

she's the ultimate Pepega of politics she was literally talking about some law of physics and talking about it like it has anything to do with Sociology and Economy LMAO

[@MegaBanne]

Well technically the Newtons Laws of motion has something to do with everything haha.

[@wile123456]

Don't forget that she is a landlord renting out a tourist resort. She is a capitalist by her own logic

[@atm1947]

@@MegaBanne the general contradictory nature of human relationships and political institutions doesn’t follow strict laws like physics or most hard sciences

[@MegaBanne]

@@atm1947 My comment was dumber than you think haha. And sorry for the overtly long answer lol. If you look at the foundation of the social sciences you have psychology. If you look at the foundation of psychology you find neurology (biology in other words). If you look at the foundation of biology you find chemistry. If you look at the foundation of chemistry you find physics. The laws of thermodynamics and Newton's laws of motion, which are first just the same things viewed from two different perspectives, are two scientific definitions of causality. Everything happens for a reason. Just basic assumptions you have to assume are true when doing science. These principles adapt to what ever form of physics you apply it to. Thermodynamics in plasma physics is vastly different to that of an ideal gas. Still same underlying principles. So technically Newton's laws of motion applies to all fields of science. The laws of thermodynamics are the statistical versions of Newton's laws of motion. But it is just the physics equivalent of saying "everything happens for a reason".

[@mYnAME-ww9iv]

Well depends what laws are we talking about. Quantum mechanics, no. Law of equilibrium and thermodynamics does actually. You sociology majors simply don't understand it

[@herzeleid9525]

I have a great admiration for Ho Chi Minh. He wasn’t perfect by any means, but he fought tirelessly for the independence of the Vietnamese people. That’s admirable just on its own.

[@danieltobin4498]

If I remember correctly the only reason he was an “ally” of Russia and China was because the US ignored his pleas for assistance in Vietnamese independence

[@MegaBanne]

@@danieltobin4498 Heard that to. Similar to how unfair US embargos forced Fidel Castro to turn Cuba in to a soviet puppet state to avoid a complete societal collapse.

[@It-Will-All-Be-Okay-I-Promise]

@@danieltobin4498 Ho Chi Minh was VERY keen on being a US ally post Vietnam war so that doesn’t surprise me much. He probably knew that Vietnam would eventually come into conflict with China (as has happened a gazillion times before) and wanted some sort of protection from any attempt at Chinese annexation of Vietnam. Maybe some other reasons too.

[@themightymcb7310]

@@danieltobin4498 yep, HCM wrote FDR semi-regularly, was in Paris on VE-Day, and also attempted to write to Truman after FDR died. Truman never got those letters.

[@aigarsjevers1274]

@@danieltobin4498 @Esteban Tomlinson He was an ally of the US during the WW2. US operatives helped to train his man and saved his life when he got injured. Makes you wonder had US approached cold war not with a hammer, but a scalpel maybe we would live in a different world

[@epimisti]

I‘m a Vaushite with Ho Chi Minh thought. Bow before the supreme ideology of the Goblin army.

[@Kropothead]

Where there’s a whip, there’s a way.

[@HenrythePaleoGuy]

@@Kropothead The underrated banger.

[@thomaswikstrand8397]

As an Anarcho-Brandonist, I declare you my eternal enemy.

[@embrikchloraker8186]

Does that make Goblin Slayer an ancap?

[@ryanweible9090]

@@HenrythePaleoGuy i was impressed with the one line "we dont want to go to war today, but the lord of the lash said nay nay nay" clearly the cartoon was the first to whip and nay-nay.

[@akaroth7542]

I look forward to Vaush learning Ho Chi Minh thought better than Luna in a fraction of the time.

[@zagreus5773]

Luna: "Though it may shock you to hear me say this, but democracy is not always a good thing" Somehow I am not shocked 🤷‍♂

[@GalacticNovaOverlord]

Yep, though it is absolutely justified to be against western "Democracy" since power isn't centered to the people. I am critiquing it from the left though, not from the right like Luna. A few certain things should be limited though to a democracy of technical, scientific and mathematical experts though to functionally run a society.

[@zagreus5773]

@@GalacticNovaOverlord A democracy of experts is not a thing... Democracy means "rule of the people", so "rule of the people of the experts" is nonsensical. What you mean is "rule of the experts", ie. a technocracy. Or a "rule of the best", ie. an aristocracy. Both are terrible, because it allows for unchecked corruption. Democracies work, because the people serve as a check against corruption. The people can also become corrupt (see America), but it is much harder to corrupt millions of people than a few hundred of experts. Lenin tried a "rule of the best" and it was a disaster. Technocracies and aristocracies always devolve into fascism.

[@thesecond4767]

Well technically this is true. What if one day a majority of people voted to lynch or oppress minorities?

[@zagreus5773]

@@thesecond4767 Yes, that can happen and in America it is happening right now and on an even worse level in the past. There is no system that cannot become corrupted, but democracies tend to be harder to corrupt than technocracies or aristocracies, simply because of the number of people involved and the consequential importance for a rule of law. The less people are in power, the less important the rule of law is. Feudalism (ie. Aristocracy) had no rule of law, laws were just made up on the spot by the ruling elite. The rule of law is what in the end is stopping (or hindering) the majority to just lynch a bunch of minorites. It is not perfect, but obviously better than the known alternatives.

[@donaldhysa4836]

Why are you booing her she is right!

[@uniball5667]

So, I'm pretty sure she's confusing dialectical materialism with philosophical materialism. Which explains a LOT lmfao

[@zerologic7912]

They're related concepts, and Marx was actually influenced by philosophical materialists (after all he literally wrote his dissertation on the Difference Between the Democritean and Epicurean Philosophy of Nature), but the two theories are obviously not the same, and they serve completely different purposes.

[@donaldhysa4836]

What even are any of those things?

[@robinpage2730]

​@@donaldhysa4836 philosophical materialism is the view that the universe is a purely physical system, with no supernatural elements. Dialectical materialism is the concept that the universe evolves as a physical system by resolving contention between opposed parts of that system, like an argument between people that changes the arguments as it unfolds. It's conceptually related to the dialectic of Socrates.

[@donaldhysa4836]

@@robinpage2730 So the universe is a physical system that evolves hats dialectical materialism

[@claires1063]

She's not confusing anything. She's just lying.

[@TheRoseThorn]

Oh dear gods I can't wait to see the new wave of Luna Oi drama 😭

[@seththeawesome3366]

The only state ideology I bow to is Vaushist-NATOism. We must hold strong before this revisionism

[@Iloveguitar07]

Vaushist natoism with Vo Chi Minh characteristics

[@MickGallJr]

I prefer the the derivative of Vaush thought known as Anarcho-Lockheadism

[@eldritchowl1061]

@@MickGallJr Lockheed-Leftism*

[@Solaris_Paradox]

NATO = Nazi Atlantic Terrorist Organization

[@nerag7459]

Vaushite NATO Ho Chih Minhism

[@MegaBanne]

I call them radishes. Since they are red on the outside and white on the inside.

[@atransarcticfox]

Genius.

[@MegaBanne]

@@atransarcticfox ❤

[@thewitchcoven]

"Democracy is when a lot of people" - Lunar Ow

[@GalacticNovaOverlord]

Democracy is when social credit score high

[@OatmealGrillBlazer]

democracy is when capitalism

[@oishyundai]

@@GalacticNovaOverlord Thats china

[@Finnboy-ml5jv]

The famous anti-capitalist land owner Luna soy. What a great example of socialist thought.

[@herzeleid9525]

She was selling the land to redistribute the profits to poor rice farmers. So now Communists can’t own 3 million dollar homes? Buy a Porsche? Sell a piece of land?

[@Solaris_Paradox]

Vietnam is closer to socialism than the United States, witch is a surveillance state, a "country" that is builded on the genocide of native americans, industrialized by the kidnapping and enslavement of black people, have the most powerful military industrial complex and have a brainwashed population of 70+ years of Goebbels' media propaganda.

[@NotoriousLightning]

What a childlike comment.

[@vlagerio7921]

Whaaaat ? You use KZbin and you're a socialist ? Contradiction much ?

[@Solaris_Paradox]

@@vlagerio7921 Capitalism doesn't make anything, labor does ans youtube was made by a Bangladeshi.

[@nataliearcadia]

"Newton's laws of thermodynamics" Vaush PLEASE 😭

[@TheSurrealist.]

Yeah I’m no Luna fan but her definition of dialectical materialism seemed fine. I mean, causality would be a factor in the social forces that create material conditions within society.

[@Afri_Pandora_Archieve]

@@TheSurrealist. thats not dialectical materialism

[@chasesigler9885]

@@TheSurrealist. dialectical materialism is about the mind and reality not science

[@vicarious4231]

Well well well if it isn't Luna "The Nazis had a point" Oi

[@nanowithbeans2511]

The long awaited new episode of the "I'm a hypothetical girl" arc is finally here! I'm a hypothetical bimbo girl in a hypothetical world physics me up, make it causation, I'm your ragdoll You're my ragdoll, rock'n'roll, feel the hypothetical in pink hypothesize me here, colonize me there, hanky panky

[@anonymousinfinido2540]

I laughed then I thought then I laughed after reading this. Intellectual Barbie Girl intensifies.

[@gabriellegoodwin4422]

How dare you for making me read this

[@thunder-san1377]

As someone with a philosophy degree Luna's description of dialectical materialism hurts. Not much of what she's saying about it is untrue, it's just unrelated or related in a way that she doesn't make clear in any way.

[@boomzy9532]

I would ask to see it but I assume you have already used it as kindling to keep the campfire going at your tent.

[@Kikasitsu]

I’m certain you know. Next you’ll tell me that we can vote Socialism in (without addressing a single contradiction that Capitalism left behind over the last 500 years.) Remind me why Western Countries *turned* toward Fascism before supportting Socialist revolution again?

[@thunder-san1377]

​@@Kikasitsu I'm sorry, I am genuinely confused. How is "Luna is not clear in her explanation of dialectical materialism, leaving out crucial relationships between her examples and the theory she's discussing. Because she leaves these relationships to the listener, it becomes unclear if she has a proper understanding of the theory herself," related to what you just said?

[@Kikasitsu]

I’m sorry… *You didn’t cite a proper example of D.M. at work either…* Your point? A perfect example is Capitalism (Private Ownership over the means of production), using Racism, Sexism, and other class divides to exploit the masses. Then Fascism (a means of governance), sweeps across Europe, Japan, Southeast Asia, and the Americas - as a means *to protect* Capitalist interests. Either via overthrow of prior governments (France, Nazi German, Norway, Sweden, etc.) Absolutism (the United States and Canada, post-WII), or client state coups [*Insert Latin/South American and/or Southeast Asian country here.*] But hey, I’m certain the Indian population (*serving the Nazis*) would have faired better than under the British (who’s Prime Minister thought of them as a “Beastly people with a Beastly religion”, condemning a population to starve to death in 1942…) But hey, “MuH HoloDomOr!” am I right? History isn’t Black and White. Vaush (and people like yourself), ought to know that. But *unlike you…* I don’t think Vaush cares about learning FROM history. (But what do you expect from a guy that repeats Nazi propaganda when it comes to the Soviet Union and *uncritically* supports a Nazified Ukraine?) I mean, if he supports U.S. Military supremacy (against China), then CLEARLY he must know *why* the Chinese populace elect members - based on merit (and not campaign promises), or why Russia *doesn’t trust* the West when it comes to Peace Talks, right? (See? I’m providing EXAMPLES of Dialetical Materialism at work.) “Things happen, THEREFORE, we get results. Now, we must learn *why* they happened in the first place, in order to prevent these horrendous mistakes in our next attempt at changing human society.” Let me know when you finally get past the initial hurdle of “Why do “Leftists” (like Vaush), *keep repeating Nazi propaganda,* when it comes to talking about Socialism and the Soviet Union?” I’m certain you’ll figure THAT out. (Unlike him.)

[@Rockzilla1122]

@@Kikasitsu deranged babble

[@Lambda_Ovine]

I will never buy this idea that MLs always try to push that Lenin just so happens to be ultimate logical conclusion of Marx and Engels's writings and everything after him is "revisionism."

[@LimeyLassen]

Just another word for "heresy" lol

[@vlagerio7921]

Yeah, I've been reading a bit of ML lately And yeah, it's like, Lenin is the logical continuation of Marx, if you deviate much from that you're a revisionist, but if you're an orthodox Marxist you're ALSO a revisionist XD Then again, I also like some ML on KZbin, even if I don't like the leftist infighting (from Vaush or these people or others)

[@chasesigler9885]

It's not that lenin is the revisionary which he absolutely is

[@Rockzilla1122]

@@vlagerio7921 ml is red fascism

[@wile123456]

All the Harmony talk just makes me have PTSD from trying to balance Harmony for Cathay in Total War Warhammer 3

[@StefanBacon]

Luna supports the death penalty for drug possession.

[@shrub8644]

Fash do fash stuff

[@Solaris_Paradox]

​@@shrub8644Liberals and fascists go hand-in-hand, they love their privatization and smashing labor unions.

[@dKumfi]

MY WIFE

[@averagecitizen4122]

you can see the fascist tendancies when Luna Oi describes "harmony" as a central characteristic of "democracy". The necessity to homogonise (and by extension repress all that is considered alien) and subordinate the broader society to the state to exist under a system of "unity" and "harmony" is core to the fascising aspects of capitalism.

[@bobo2.2]

Will Vaush be the one to lead the USA to a victory against Vietnam? Find out in the next episode of dragon ball V

[@SystematicChaos713]

MLs will literally rage at Vaush for ironically promoting anarcho-NATOism, but yass queen over Luna Oi championing democratic centralism.

[@GalacticNovaOverlord]

Both are cringe

[@BlueTyphoon2017]

@@GalacticNovaOverlord how exactly?

[@RemixedVoice]

Only part of her video I agreed with were her cool hair thingys. 0:08

[@benh2339]

I really don't understand how she's able to get away with just pretending concepts mean things they don't mean while presenting herself as an educational channel. It takes so little effort to just look these concepts up and realize she's explaining them incorrectly.

[@Kikasitsu]

That’s because you’re not Leftists. Never were. You’re just pretending to be such, but as soon as SHE comes onto your screens, you suddenly reveal your Closet-Nazi mindsets, and foam at the mouth, hoping to start another Vietnam War again. (But use excuses like “Freedom”, “Democracy”, or some other shit.)

[@okiepc6328]

I just cannot grasp Luna Oi's definition of dialectical materialism, it's completely incoherent and nonsensical and I think if I was able to ask her that question she would be unable to give an actual definition and instead would start going off about some completely incoherent shit for 35 minutes straight

[@Dave102693]

“ Scientific socialism”

[@JebeckyGranjola]

Absolutely. I've argued with noncompete about this. Finally I found some obscure Marxist who wrote about Dialectical Materialism in Cartesian terms that I could understand, and quoted that to him and he had no idea what it was talking about. I mean that's fine, I don't expect everyone to know philosophy, but you maybe should if you're trying to sell everyone on your epistemology.

[@Ohhelmno]

“Our system is all about forced compliance and making the people get on board with what the peoples party is doing, with violence if necessary… building unity. Because everyone is scared to disagree they go along with what the peoples party is doing… you know, Democracy.”

[@joshuajennings4070]

Uh, uh, I'm noncompete

[@fuzzybuzzy3159]

It pisses me off that my uncle turned into a tankie and loves Luna Oi.

[@rainbowkrampus]

Vaush pill him in his sleep.

[@GalacticNovaOverlord]

Oof, though Vaush isn't good either on non social issues.

[@BlueTyphoon2017]

@@GalacticNovaOverlord … such as? About why co ops are good?

[@Gloomdrake]

@@GalacticNovaOverlord I don't know which non-social issues you're referring to, but Luna is shitty on social issues too, considering her homophobia

[@fuzzybuzzy3159]

@Fundamentally Unorthodox Leftist turned tankie through severe internet brainrot.

[@atlantiswolf]

Okay, someone correct me if I'm wrong on this, but isn't Democratic Centralism basically where you have a one party state and the only people who get to vote are bureaucrats or people who are party members, but you call it like "The Workers Party" or "The People's Party" or something like that?

[@TheSurrealist.]

I hope this gets answered as well.

[@alexgray2482]

The idea is (i think) that once descisions are made by the party (in theory these are made democratically by the membership of the "worker's party" in a "party congress", in practice usually by a single leader or an elite), they are binding on all party members and no one may publically disagree with it

[@Dave102693]

This is pretty much it.

[@oishyundai]

According to what Luna Oi said, it's when everyone contributes but then respects the decision once it is made. So basically just normal democracy in which people also respect the democracy.

[@mathiasbartl903]

Didn't Erich Honecker vote for his own removal, just so the vote would be unanimous?

[@KidNamedVashin]

He was insulting MAI WAAIF

[@ScarceCastle2]

"okay mods, BAN everyone who disagrees with me"

[@eddiejobes8449]

Woah…. Ho Chi Minh needs me? Alright I’ll go to bat for you Ho Chi Minh.

[@IfWhatYes]

You can be his top guy

[@aweirdwombat]

Good video. Honestly it sounds like tankies are starting to get confident because they're talking about things they usually try to hide. I used to loosely follow Non-compete's channel back before Luna got her own channel and I never saw them talk about stuff like this so openly. It was why I initially followed them. It took some inspection to see what they really believed and advocated for which is what caused me to leave shortly after following. Though on an aide, I'm not a regularly follower but what's with the the videos that contain multiple topics? I've seen a couple lately. Wouldn't it make more sense to have the Cuba stuff in its own video?

[@FelisImpurrator]

NonCompute was a lolcow before the MAI WIFE arc. I never get tired of talking about how he posted screenshots on Twitter of his own unhinged, capslock-containing rant to KZbin Support. As in he malded in the fucking support mail, screenshotted it, and presented it as if it made him look good. Why? He got copyright striked by the company Trevor Noah's comedy bits are owned by, for a video where he accused Noah of being some kind of anti-progressive pro-slavery shill. The bit was an edgy joke about diamond miners or something. Not even as edgy as a Vaush joke. EJ proceeded to rave about how Trevor Noah had to personally have an interest in *ruining his career* (his words from what I remember) and maliciously took down the video to sabotage him. Seriously. I'm not making that up. The man has main character syndrome like no one's business. He thought an ultra-famous lib comedian was personally out to get him. This will never not be funny.

[@Solaris_Paradox]

@@FelisImpurrator TL;DR Hope Vaush becomes a lolcow like Mundane Matt.

[@FelisImpurrator]

@@Solaris_Paradox ok fascist, lmao

[@Solaris_Paradox]

@@FelisImpurrator "Red fascist" Unscientific nonsense that your Vaush the Wikipedia major made up with zero credibility.

[@Dave102693]

@@FelisImpurrator I remember that video. Did he really openly begged to YT like that?

[@jloiben12]

Gonna be honest, I love seeing people posture as being a leftist but just doing the full right wing, pro-authoritarian, thing. I wish these people didn’t exist but watching them is absolutely hilarious

[@smileyp4535]

EJ got me into anarchism so let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater here, they've gone down a bad road for a while since then, obviously but they came from a good place. It's really sad actually what happened... 😮‍💨

[@Gloomdrake]

@@smileyp4535 hell is paved with good intentions, as they say

[@nektariosorfanoudakis2270]

"Right-Wing, pro-Authoritarian", you mean like Vaush supporting Joe Biden, Zelensky (a dude that makes Donald Trump look like a Leftie in comparison), NATO and the destruction of Russia and its replacement by many different nuclear-capable states run by Mad-Max-esque Fashy Warlords (like Zelensky🤣)?

[@christian2i]

It's almost like there are multiple dimensions at play

[@wvu05]

​@@smileyp4535 But he insists that Vietnam is the ideal. And for someone who "doesn't do hypotheticals," it's odd that at one point he wanted to make a movie based on _The Conquest of Bread,_ which might be the most Underpants Gnomes thing I have ever read.

[@matthewbrennan9758]

Good ol' Newton and his Thermodynamics

[@DaVinciwithaphaser]

"I can't understand your upside down talk." Voosh 2022

[@tabryis]

Oh my God yes I've been waiting the return of this arc

[@tabryis]

@@Solaris_Paradox seethe

[@BlueTyphoon2017]

Honestly? I don’t, because there’s no point, I feel like we settled this last time, I honestly think this is a bad decision on Vaushs part as this may cause a domino effect causing pointless drama for no fucking reason.

[@tabryis]

@@BlueTyphoon2017 who cares they're red fascists, besides it makes good content

[@gustavchambert7072]

Also, a big reason why the populations of many non-western countries tend to associate democracy with social equality rather than sociopolitical freedom is because they have been gaslit into it. Communist dictatorships all around the world spent the entire second half of the 20th century indoctrinating their populations to believe that democracy is when the state eliminates the worst forms of economic insecurity and that opression in the name of this goal is freedom, actually, because the people doing the opressing kind of dress like regular workers. Appealing to the fact that different countries have different conceptions of democracy becomes kind of dishonest when you realise that the understanding of democracy has been intentional in manipulated in many countries. There also isn't a contradiction in democracy between sociopolitical freedom and economic equality. At all.

[@alexgray2482]

The ML view of democracy is that it is the power of the "public" (i.e the state) over that of the "private". It's weirdly similar to the view of lot of the "it's not a democracy, it's a republic" types

[@nektariosorfanoudakis2270]

No, actually, Westerners have been gaslit into thinking that Democracy is not the "Rule of the People". Even Aristoteles, that reactionary Philosopher, who actually lived in Ancient Athens, considers the defining feature of Oligarchy as "voting for your rulers", while the one of Democracy is "Rulers are chosen by Lottery". Western systems are by *definition* Oligarchic, not Democratic.

[@DrHotWarLove]

Aaron's in the doghouse again? Oh boy.

[@darnfrick3354]

NonCompete over here with his deranged dictator gf "donta insult mah wyfe"

[@derdurstbursch]

KEEP MY WIFE OUT OF YOUR MOUTH

[@derdurstbursch]

*släp*

[@davec1406]

🎵 🎶 "Uh Uh... I'm Luna Oi... Uh Uh..." 🎶 🎵

[@czechmeoutbabe1997]

Not gonna lie, the way she talks about “developing” and “discovering” these concepts like they’re natural laws of physics really scares me. It sounds exactly like the stories my mom has about living in ML Czechoslovakia, where party officials always explained contradictions and authoritarianism by saying “society is developing” and that all of that was necessary to promote that dialectical development. It’s open-minded, academic soft-sounding language weaponised to justify complete bullshit and simple greed and power.

[@zerologic7912]

Authoritarian revolutionaries have always treated society like a fucking lab experiment, it's unfortunately a very old trend

[@michaellevitas6112]

Well, she's right Marx didn't invent dialectical materialism he analyzed and contributed to the knowledge that has been developing for over a thousand years. Society is always developing. Stephen Jay Goud a biologist wrote about how to apply dialectical materialism to the hard and social sciences

[@Wedneswere]

yes, but my wife.........

[@ShadowDragon1848]

I´l take a hard guess and say it because it´s the same. I´m a leftist myself, but tbh sometimes I can really understand why people dislike socialism. Because when you see countries who called themselves socialist and are like that, what would you think?

[@avinashreji60]

@@michaellevitas6112dialectical materialism is not a scientific theory it’s a philosophical method of viewing human society

[@howtocami]

"MAH WIFE"

[@Lerasium]

we must not forget that luna said “nazi’s have a point”

[@lljkgktudjlrsmygilug]

Stop with your gamerphobia.

[@shaan702]

What was the context? What did she agree with the Nazis about?

[@fachriranu1041]

@@shaan702 in the contex of if Jews people really take ovee banking in Germany.

[@HobGungan]

@@shaan702 Basically when NonCompete had his "discussion" with Vaush, Vaush pointed out the fact that Jewish people were overrepresented in German banking prior to WWII as a way to set up a larger point about how nothing justifies genocide, and NC immediately disconnected and on his own platform he and Luna tried to make it seem like Vaush had apropos of nothing been claiming that they controlled the banks as the nazis tried to claim...and they did it in a way that implied they thought the nazis would have been justified if the claims had in fact been true.

[@shaan702]

@@HobGungan ah ok. Thanks for the context. That’s definitely very cowardly and bad faith on the part of NC and Luna.

[@justanothergamer7918]

Vaush continuing the nam arc.

[@TheSurrealist.]

From now on it’s Luna arc flashbacks.

[@justanothergamer7918]

@@TheSurrealist. tru

[@MrTheWaterbear]

Tankie Jordan Peterson in the ways she abuses definitions like nobody’s business.

[@smaakjeks]

When I affect something, that something affects me. Therefore the state should rule supreme and we should submit! I get it now.

[@ryle4h]

I see someone talking about "tyranny of the majority" and my fists clench involuntarily.

[@stephennootens916]

There has long standing rumours that JFK was high on pain killers during the missile crisis, while it was true that he used pain killers under doctor's supervision because of injury during WW2 the idea of him being stoned on pain killers is hard to believe. I have dealt with a person stoned on pain killers and they can barely walk straight let alone give and order. Also Kennedy order those missiles in Turkey before the crisis but the military for some reason they had not done it.

[@highshelf]

these guys use vibes based definitions for everything, theyre like me in middle school, lmao 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Solaris_Paradox]

That's Vaush your projecting buddy lol

[@hornet1065]

Sadly we won't get anymore "My Wife" memes 😔

[@GalacticNovaOverlord]

Guess you gotta step up 😏

[@hornet1065]

@@GalacticNovaOverlord I can't. Every time I try my comments get removed 🤷‍♀️

[@telesticTroublemaker]

i feel stupid, Vaush meant the rock eyebrow raise gif. whenever i heard "get the rock" i thought it was like saying "the wall" (in roblox)

[@Coraltide]

Oh god I have the same issue with accents. It really isn’t a racism thing, I have just as much (if not more) trouble understanding the rural/southern accents and I grew up in the south. plus oddly i have trouble understanding old people

[@rainbowkrampus]

Difficulty parsing accents is usually a result of low exposure to a diverse range of vocal inflections. Listening to more foreign language content will help train your brain to sort through the peculiarities.

[@kzinful]

Rainbow Krampus + My mother was from Northern Spain and over the years her English improved but it was spoken with a very heavy accent, so when friends dropped by they really couldn't understand her. And I became the translator, now, the wickedly funny part was when a friend would ask her a question and she particularly didn't like him or her, she ( through me ) would reply what a dumbass thing to ask ( or an even uglier comment..ha! ) and I would spin in it English, and they smile never knowing what she truly said...Lol.

[@wickedAberration]

@@rainbowkrampus I can't parse my own family half the time. You can only say "What?" so many times before you just accept that you didn't hear them, and deal with the consequences.

[@rainbowkrampus]

@@wickedAberration You, uh, you ever looked into symptoms of autism before?

[@hobosorcerer]

I'd really like to see Vaush go over those studies on US oligarchy.. Could make for a fun watch.

[@amellirizarry9503]

Be like the Kurds in Rojava: Reject Centralism, embrace Direct Democracy and Federalism

[@DerPlaystationZocker]

When Vaush talked about Fidel Castro trying to phone in to the negotiations I could only think of Castro doing the "DO IT" Shiah Lebouf Meme.

[@grahamsmith5396]

my city is small less than 100K population, , but we have an huge percentage of various Asian, Latin American, African, Islamic, and European peoples here, who are college students, Walmart cashiers,truck drivers, engineers, lawyers, home care attendants,professors ,doctors, welders ,etc, etc. An newcomer having an " thick accent" isn't necessarily an barrier to communication, almost of all these newcomers already speech two or more languages while they're learning English also.

[@lusteraliaszero]

the idea of harlemchiminh is genuinely funny

[@KazmirRunik]

It really doesn't take much time to look into exactly what problems conservatives have with social policy. There are Fox News broadcasts on KZbin from a decade ago trying to slam ObamaCare under the grounds that the higher taxes will make it harder for you to gain any wealth, making it harder for you to succeed in life, which many people already do not. There are a lot of conservatives who would like to move out of their trailer homes someday, along with a lot of people in general who owe debts, so a health care tax for people outside of their families can easily be made to sound like the snuffing out of their glimmer of hope for financial stability & mobility. From this position, even if the conservative believes that you have good intentions, they also believe that the cost outweighs the benefit. Ever since Bernie, we've also dealt with the "socialism" term being thrown around, which is a sort of triple-edged sword. On one end, states that have called themselves socialist have a tendency to fail, which is easy ammo for anti-socialists. On the other end, the term "socialism" has lost a lot of its stigma. On the third end, a lot of the actual policy positions described with the "socialism" label are completely doable (and even beneficial) under capitalism, though socialists haven't really sold it that well. A lot of people DO want minimum wage that's livable in their areas, affordable health care options, greater aid for student debt, homelessness relief & job opportunity support, and a bite out of the huge wallets of the "elites" of society, but not nearly as many people want to identify as socialists, even though those are the exact real-life policies being pursued by socialists. In other words, you don't need to be a socialist to be a socialist, to pursue social policy. This has the effect of allowing the left to pursue palatable policy positions while also allowing the right to slap the "socialist" label onto anyone who wants to pursue ANY form of social policy. Now, when you want to support an infrastructure bill to replace & maintain the half-century-old power lines and provide funding for neglected school districts, conservatives can label it "socialism" and say that you're destroying the country by bringing its policies closer to the many failed socialist nations of the past, obfuscating the actual letter of the bill along with where the money is coming from, in order to say that they're taking the money from "the American taxpayer" when that taxpayer is entirely people in the top 1%. That's more or less the basic problem conservatives have with leftist policy, aside from the apparent frivolity of having them pay taxes for things they've never personally experienced in their own real lives, like health care for transgender people or abortion clinics.

[@aaronmarks9366]

I like how Luna's first image of the Jim Crow south was George Lincoln Rockwell's American Nazi Party goons, and not just, like, actual everyday racist southern shopkeepers and town council members. She really sold the horror short there.

[@stuartsmith4369]

The study on US democracy was not about the interests of the poor, it was about their expressed preferences. Manufactured consent only explains consent.

[@GalacticNovaOverlord]

Yep

[@Sivanot]

smh i cant believe vounch would actually say he cant effortlessly understand a really thick accent that factually is harder to understand without having grown up around it, such a racist omg

[@oishyundai]

He has also actually made fun of her accent in a later stream

[@GrayTimber]

Vaush probably has auditory processing disorder. I have it and have the same issues with accents. Even if the accent is light I may have issues with understanding what the person is trying to say. It's definitely not racist to have an auditory disorder 😂 I swear

[@Dave102693]

I never heard of that before. Is it the reason why I find accents very hard to understand?

[@BrandonPilcher]

That may be it too. I think I have that too. Apparently it’s more common among ASD peeps like us.

[@christopherabiuso3723]

Or maybe…maybe it’s possible for someone to be wrong without a clear reason.

[@seanbeadles7421]

I mean isn’t he on the autism spectrum? Audio processing issues are a common comorbidity.

[@emdivine]

6:00 so what Vaush is saying is this is a sentiment better expressed in Kay(f)bop(t)

[@tofusoybearleftyhugmonster2273]

I would like to know what horrors Vietnam has committed? Just asking... they apparently have, but I feel like I should know in that case. Was it toppling the Khmer Rouge?

[@Nyrinx]

Talk about harmony makes me think of positive and negative peace. Luna seems to think harmony or a lack of visible discourse is itself good, not the context it comes about.

[@MrxstGrssmnstMttckstPhlNelThot]

"Dialectical materialism was used by Marx, and Engels and Lenin." Literally just not true. They had a materialist theory of history, sometimes referred to as historical materialism, and they did have a dialectical worldview inspired by the ideas of Hegel. There was a guy called Joseph Dietzgen who referenced, I think, a "materialist dialectic" and Marx and Engels called him one of their favourite contemporary philosophers; but that's the closest it came to "dialectical materialism" until Stalin who even his fellow party members said to his face was shit at reading theory (which he was: he has notes in a piece by Engels where he says the state should eventually disappear before socialism can be said to be achieved and Stalin just wrote next to it "no"), yeah not until Stalin started writing his own versions of theory to justify his rule do we see much in the literature the series of words together "dialectical materialism" and that's where the Communist Party of Vietnam gets their idea of it being a Stalinist party. As far as I can remember Lenin didn't use the phrase either. Now, their concept of historical materialism was based in their dialectical ideas but they did not use the term itself and the term as Stalin used it in his texts such as "Historical and Dialectical Materialism" did not conform at all with how Marx or Engels may have used it if they were asked about a specific phrasing.

[@wynoglia]

You should rly connect with kavernacle He's now in the final bastion of the socialist paradise on earth, Vietnam But also, pretty cool fellow

[@20xx-mm-dd]

I agree, I like his channel. Although I get the feeling he wouldn't like vaush very much. Maybe I'm wrong.

[@woobiefuntime]

@@20xx-mm-dd he did anti vaush videos before

[@wynoglia]

Shhhh guys Trying to build a bridge here Edit: glad to find ppl who have also watched him here tho Tbf I was into more of his meme-y cancel vids But he also makes decent progressive commentary And nice to have a view on the other side of the pond that isn't a video essay like Adam or contra or Mia Mulder etc.

[@xuxuang8574]

@@woobiefuntime he did? Oh bum. He seemed not-stupid.

[@lemon93]

@@xuxuang8574 vaush just needs to offer a chocolate orange as a offering

[@Nerobyrne]

You notice how she was going to explain to us how Vietnamese democracy works, and then she just ... didn't? Maybe she does later in the video, but considering she spend like 20 minutes ranting about how "freedom bad", I doubt it.

[@JohnDoe-xv9du]

Anarcho-Monarchism, lesgoooo

[@Turalcar]

46:18 Russian revolutionaries were big fans of the USA before the latter joined with the rest of the Entente to invade Russia

[@sirusmunjak-khoury1425]

MAH WIFE

[@ZHike360]

17:29 literally Paulsego

[@kennedyshotfirst2534]

Literally Paul Zego

[@thumbwarriordx]

I grew up watching british/canadian/american mishmash television off PBS with their comedy nights and masterpiece theater. I have observed that my ability to deal with accents is well above average. (for an American) Not a flex, I didn't get to watch Spongebob and I would never flex on that. But if you don't got it, you don't got it. I tried to get my friends to check out UK Shameless back in the day and they needed subtitles lol

[@chicken29843]

It's the don't tread on me Ben Franklin bullshit

[@AnimeGIFfy]

this was like vietname dub of azumanga daioh

[@shrub8644]

11:59 Luna Oi admits she's a fascist in one sentence

[@Solaris_Paradox]

Bourgeois democracy is oppression.

[@expandinga7960]

I can't believe Luna called it "Taiwan University", Western Chauvinism at it's finest...

[@FaylunaRaRa]

I hate when people get upset at you for struggling to parse out their accent... I think it may have been from somewhere around like the Middle East or India? Something like that... Like, I had this one class with someone and was put in a group with them and they had a really thick accent that I was struggling with and when I was asking them to repeat some stuff a few times I explained it was because I had a hard time making out what they were saying due to their accent they were just like "What!? I don't have much of an accent!" and then this other person who looked like they might've been from the same country but with less of an accent was like "I can understand her just fine!" and it was like... I've never felt such gaslighting in my life... I think there may have been others too agreeing with them and I was just thinking like "How do they not hear it? It's so strong?" And like I got the impression that they were viewing me as a bit racist or something, but I just genuinely had a hard time making out what they were saying... I'm pretty sure the professor who was white might've said he can understand her fine, but like... Was he just trying to offend the other student or something? I didn't even mean for it to become a big thing I was just off-handedly explaining that the reason I kept asking her to repeat things was because of the accent... I don't really care about her nationality or accent, but regardless it just makes things difficult sometimes... It's not a racist thing since I'd ask it of someone with a thick enough Irish or German accent too... Mentally though it was really confusing how no one else seemed to not only minimize the existence of her accent, but act like it barely existed at all... And they're looking at me like I'm crazy when I'm just thinking about how they're all crazy BECAUSE ITS SO SELF-EVIDENT any time she speaks...

[@yummyjackalmeat]

I worked in Vietnam and capitalism runs those streets its crazy.

[@BrandonPilcher]

I went there on a sort of humanitarian field trip during my high school senior days (this would have been back in 2008). We met these disabled kids at an orphanage who made their living working on tea plantations for international consumption. The experience gave me the impression that, in a lot of tankie countries, a large proportion of the population does cheap labor for Global North businesses while their supposedly revolutionary governments look the other way. I bet Africa and most of the rest of the Third World is the same way.

[@BlueTyphoon2017]

@@BrandonPilcher yeah, we keep them poor by keeping they’re wages so low, it’s how capitalism robs developing countries to keep them subservient. Idk why these people keep saying these “”communist”” countries are somehow not capitalist.

[@maxcormier7821]

one thing i don't understand is how you can reconciliate the view that poses democracy as the freedom to express oneself's political views and alignments and the one that poses centralism as the need for unity over authenticity in one's political expressions. seems like in order to maximise centralism you have to compromise the expression of democracy itself.

[@maynardwayward12]

"Harmony" = everyone thinks and acts the same

[@marinooliveira4204]

Imagine having a definition for Dialectical Materialism that doesn't use dialectics

[@Solaris_Paradox]

You don't even know what Dialectical Materialism is lol

[@marinooliveira4204]

@@Solaris_Paradox doesn't it use dialectics?

[@Azdroc96]

Castro played with model trains? So he was just Adam Something?

[@ShadowTasos]

lol at 10:20 she says democracy translates into "people's power", which is simply not true. Democracy translates into "people's rule" or "people's state", refering specifically to political rule. Power and rule are not the same, rule refers specifically to decision making within the system of governance. This type of playing fast and loose with definitions is very bizarre on her part.

[@witchflowers6942]

last line of the video- *also taking care of his cow and eating icecream

[@micixduda]

This guy confusing 3rd law of motion and thermodynamics. and then talk about revisionism. Priceless.

[@m3gAnac0nda]

Cope

[@micixduda]

@@m3gAnac0nda i'll try why would you defend stupid?

[@m3gAnac0nda]

@@micixduda cringe

[@micixduda]

@@m3gAnac0nda That is better

[@mandel94]

4:42 Newton's law of motion, not thermodynamics

[@NoodleBerry]

Well, a lot of stuff is attributed to Isaac Newton due to historical revisionism lol. Optics, calculus

[@BlueSun_]

40:10 The reason for the improvement is because they were no longer blocked from trading with the rest of the world. Vaush should know better than to confuse global specialisation and trading with market capitalism. If the world was filled with state capitalist nations that sanctioned the few remaining market capitalist nations than the latter would suffer for it and obviously you would see an improvement if they got in line with the global hegemony.

[@jbc00per]

Oh no, not again.

[@gabriellegoodwin4422]

We should spend more time talking about Asian politics. It’s really not niche, China and Japan are very important in American politics, but I don’t think most people understand their politics outside of “communism” and “not communism”.