Egyptian Activist: "Arabs Are Not Antisemitic, It's More Complicated"

Dalia Ziada, Egyptian writer, human rights activist and JCFA Senior Fellow, joins David Harris to discuss the changing relationship between Egypt and Israel and the current situation in the Middle East.
Discover more JBS @ jbstv.org
Follow us on X: / jerusalemcenter
Like us on Facebook: / jerusalemcenter
Join us on Instagram: / jerusalem_center
We're on LinkedIn: / jcpaisrael

[@rebeccaaharon776]

Dalia Ziada, you are wonderful I admire your honesty and your truth. Be safe

[@johnf.1969]

"This conflict is not merely a Palestinian-Israeli conflict but rather a Muslim-Jewish conflict. The Islamic sources, the Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Sira show that the Islamic deep seated enmity towards the Jews and Israel, is profoundly Qur'anic, inspired by Allah as claimed by Muhammad."

[@Endtime-dh9lk]

_ inspired by Allah as claimed by Muhammad_ The real name of Islam's God is MOHAMM-ALLAH 😁

[@leonnozik]

💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

[@annysons]

@@Endtime-dh9lkI call him pedo-mohammad

[@Rajul_Jamil]

Today all the hatred is coming from the Muslim Brotherhood.

[@Endtime-dh9lk]

@@Rajul_Jamil The Mullahs from Iran are not Muslimbrothers though. Also the Iranians are now less than 50% identifiying with Islam since whenever the ruling Clerics in Islamic societies obey Muhammad to the letter it means suffering for the people.

[@markusd.7409]

Thank you for your post. I just wanted to clarify: Antisemitism is a term on its own and means anti-Jewish. It does not mean against Semites (Jews, Arabs etc.) in general. The term was coined in Austria at the end of the 19th century (to "sound more intellectual") and has a stand-alone meaning.

[@johnf.1969]

They are putting into action what they have been taught in the Islamic sources, the Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Sirah inspired by Allah as claimed by Muhammad. Eternal enmity towards the Jews

[@louisdeniau8571]

they are not christians. you are talking about them like they are christians. christians do that bro

[@jalemairliha]

​@@louisdeniau8571No. The church has reformed in large part. Did you listen to her? She provided receipts.

[@jimjames4348]

@@louisdeniau8571 She didn't mention them, they are irrelevant to this conversation. They also evolved.

[@jonlenihan4798]

Egypt was conquered by Arabia, and forced to convert to Islam. The native Egyptian language has been erased and replaced with Arabic.

[@MrIrrepressible]

Well said! The copts are the native egytptians

[@jonlenihan4798]

@@MrIrrepressible Also native paganism and a ruined synagogue on Elephantine Island dated to 600 BC.

[@NoMadKid]

And they are Arabs now, stay mad. The French, Brits and Turks ruled them and couldn’t take away their Arabian identity.

[@AndrewTota]

Based on National Geographic DNA analysis shows that only 17% of Egyptians are arabs and the rest are indigenous to this land . The arabs came with 2000 soldiers and there were 500 arabian who moved to Egypt when the Egyptian population was 4 million so how come are we Arabized ?

[@AndrewTota]

@@MrIrrepressibleim muslim and im 86% coptic Egyptian and got 0 arabic genes 💀

[@shptz]

Bless her for fearlessly telling the truth.

[@propheticpeoples]

Bold brave truth telling sister, may God protect you !!

[@ruthtepper8431]

Thank you Dalia for such a clear explanation.

[@vvvvel]

Arabs are semitic themselves they can be anti Jewish.

[@DavidForeman-mo1px]

She is historically incorrect about the Khaibar issue. Khaibar was the place where Mohammed's troops beat the last of the 2 Jewish tribes in Arabia. That's right, 2 Jewish tribes. One tribe was basically metal workers and jewelers, the other tribe was date tree farmers. The story of Khaibar is a bloody one. All of the remaining captured Jewish men were slaughtered when they refused to convert to Islam, and the women and children were taken as slaves. So this "Remember Khaibar" saying expressed by these Muslims is as ew hating as it gets.

[@pamelakoretsky9909]

And according to the Hadith Mohammed eventually paid for it with his life. Sophia poisoned him and told him if he was ttuly a prophet he would not be harmed, he was sickened ever after and when he died said that Sophia's poison was the cause. So he in essence admited himself a false prophet.

[@n00b_n00b_]

​@@pamelakoretsky9909 I'm surprised more people know this story. MO basically died because of complications from the poisoning years earlier, which the hadith admits.

[@pamelakoretsky9909]

@@n00b_n00b_ i met a muslim man seated next to me on a plane when I was about 19. He noticed my star if David and started talkjnv with me . We had a l ok ng conversation about the two faiths. He hadxa lot of wrong ideas about Judaism. I knew little about Islam. He gave me his Quran to read sbout it. I read the whole thing. Could never get my mind passed the Hadith stiry about Mo bein ggv approached by a demon in a cave, runn in ng in suicidal terror, and being convinced by (his cousin?) that it was an emissary from Hod and that he was a profit. Pretty sure people in sny culture know the difference by instinct when they have encountered a demon vs an angel! Moses knew he stood in thr presence of God when he approached the burning bush.

[@pamelakoretsky9909]

@@n00b_n00b_ and by ssying Sophia did this he admitted he was no profit, just a war lord.

[@pamelakoretsky9909]

@@DavidForeman-mo1px another point is that apparent victory over the Jewish people ultimately resulted in Mohammed's death and the revelation that he was a false prophet by his own admission..."Sophia did this". And it is recorded in the Haddith that when she had poisoned him she said if he was truly a prophet it would not harm him. Apparently the ability to do some amazing mental gymnastics around the truth started as early in Islam as their hatred of Jews.

[@Kunno-f7q]

Wow! Not intimidated by hama$$ But still worrying how long this arab hatred goes back and how ignorant the west is of its roots And how much education needs to be done Brave woman!

[@herticate8579]

Pretty sure it was Europeans bullying Jews for the longest time, pretty sure it was Europeans who allowed 6 million of them to perish into obscurity, pretty sure that Europeans (well since Christianity at least) hunted down Jews. Every time the crusaders took over a city, they massacred all Muslims and Jews. Every time the Jews were living in fear in Europe. The Muslims at the very least had no major Jewish extermination for no reason and the Muslims were not blood hungry mongrels who heartlessly massacred everyone when they conquered cities. Yes, Education needs to be done indeed.

[@ArtLogins]

Extremely beautiful and intelligent woman.... This conflict has another layer - western civilization vs violent primitives.....

[@1000YearsofPeaceplan]

I'm in Pentagon City with an Israeli flag and 1 got a gift with a note saying "made with love from the people of Palestine and South Lebanon"

[@BonjoureClaireBonjoureCl-mz8mk]

Dalia Ziada, thank you for approaching this difficult topic with your intelligence & educating us with your knowledge. May God bless you.

[@rojoeditor]

I don't understand the title of the video. It is completely different from the speech.

[@Dakini31]

Dalia is a gem 💎 I pray for her safety and prosperity

[@noa-wu9sn]

Dalia is such a brave and dissent woman.

[@solomore]

God bless this woman

[@Omkuskom]

thanks

[@RichardPepperman-kk9yb]

Coulda' fooled me. History proves otherwise.

[@CVBv-j4p]

👏👏👏🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱🙏👍

[@avramwurf5804]

Main peoples of Semitic origin: Acadians, Chaldeans, Babylonians, Assyrians, Amorreus, Arameans, Phoenicians, Arabs, Hebrews, Jews, Samaritans, Nabataeans, Syrians, Hyksos, Egyptians, Ethiopians and Ugaritic.

[@pamelakoretsky9909]

@@avramwurf5804 but the term antisemitism has a very specific meaning of hate of Jews. And BTW Hebrews and Jews sre the same thing.

[@avramwurf5804]

@@pamelakoretsky9909 it was William Marr who first coined the term antisemitism. Plus, the term antisemitism is a European thing.

[@sachinrhode]

JESUS LOVRS YOU.. YESHAU HA MASSICH

[@----jiz7048]

The ancient egyptians were not semitic, but rather the descendants of ham.

[@yomama5656]

That’s religious fiction. Not real history

[@AndrewTota]

As an Egyptian she doesn’t represent us AT ALL

[@herticate8579]

When has this become religious? Wasn't this a land dispute?? Why blend in religion politics???

[@abupinhus]

No, it was never land dispute. It was always relugious and idealogical dispute. The muslem society can not accept that weakest group of the West, jews, could create country on territory that was held by islam over 700 years. They hated when they were controlled by UK and France. But to live in or near country that controlled by jews is even worse. It projects weekness of muslim or arab force. So the problem is not in the real estate, the problem is in the head.

[@EvanHumphris]

It's never been about land. It's broader.

[@pamelakoretsky9909]

@@herticate8579 read the Hamas Charter. Read the Quran. It has nothing to do with land.

[@herticate8579]

@@pamelakoretsky9909 wasn't Hamas goal the destruction of Israel? The Quran states that their ancestors were once the chosen people of god but corruption and disobedience made them lose that title, along with the right to holy land. So from theological perspective, no they don't have a right, from a land/historical perspective they once occupied the land before going exile, so no they have no longer right to land either, from bloodline perspective they are fully European with barely any Middle eastern blood running through their veins.

[@shptz]

We, in the west, were made to believe it's national-territorial, so the conflict remains "rational" and "resolvable" in our perception. 7.10 was yet another wake-up call to the harsh reality. Many still refuse to awaken, however...

[@ArturoJoseph-hy3pw]

Brilliant woman

[@1czechit1]

Antisemitisme is a word meaning anti-Jew. It is not anti-language group. That trope is ridiculous.

[@TheGladiator125]

It's a religious war,it's all about Islam controlling Jerusalem and depriving Jews any access. Which is why the so called Palestinians were happy to coexist under Jordanian occupation and annexation,happy and content with Egyptian occupation,but drew a line with Jewish occupation,an Israel which in fact gave them more freedoms than they enjoyed under Jordanian and Egyptian rule up to 1967.

[@kelechijeremiah4465]

It's not about land😂😂😂

[@jimjames4348]

Only very the extremely naive still believe it is at this point.

[@koloni2862]

It was never about land ..only idiots on woke morons in the west who think it is

[@nagaxplorer2022]

Pro Mo was poisoned after Khyber, wasn’t he? By a jewess, no less 😅

[@guymalach5710]

Smart woman I hope you stay safe

[@JJ73100]

WHO CARES THEY ARE NOT MY CUP OF TEE DALIA LET GO .

[@Evantrop]

Lies lies lies.Your deeds speak louder than words.

[@susie5254]

Could you be more specific? I'm sure not 100% of the Muslim population of the world is proud of Oct 7th even if the vast majority are, so to what do you refer?

[@jeffrp8388]

When you say "Your" words you are speaking of her, this lady. So to call her a liar and say 'her' deeds speak louder than words, you are just showing ignorance.

[@PhilistineTheArtLuvr]

Well, yes and no, check out this interview with a former chief of the Shin Bet and how he urges Israel to listen to Hamas to find a final peace agreement: www.cnn.com/2024/06/24/tv/video/amanpour-ami-ayalon

[@kitcarpo4745]

She should be ashamed and punished for her faith and following of a violent religion.

[@islamawad1]

Dalia ziad is hypocrite

[@yaaraamozig4862]

Why?

[@mariussicone]

Bullshit

[@yaaraamozig4862]

Why

[@pongang3357]

This woman in a traitor. We Chinese abhor traitors.

[@jalemairliha]

Hahahaha. She's a hero who speaks about truth liberty and justice. You don't have those things in China so of course you're confused. 🖖

[@maxsever83]

A Chinese talking about loyalty 😂😂😂 Nice joke Mao

[@shlogoff]

Not everything is about team loyalty. According to your logic, if a German opposed Hitler he was a "traitor". Moral values come first, and this woman made the right decision.

[@pongang3357]

@@jalemairliha , you uninformed.

[@pongang3357]

@@maxsever83 , we are the most loyal people on earth that is why we are the most advanced and the most civilized nation in the history of mankind.

[@Joshua-k1t]

God bless Dalia ziada

[@jesusisgod5655]

GOD BLESS you sister you will one day become Christian.

[@Endtime-dh9lk]

Yes. What a beautiful soul. Let's keep her in our 🙏🙏🙏

[@louisdeniau8571]

@@Endtime-dh9lkchristianity is evil

[@jimjames4348]

or preferably a Jew?

[@seikomyazawa]

why should she change her religion?

[@jimjames4348]

@@seikomyazawa She shouldn't. These vultures think they're in a cult.