Einstein's PhD thesis 👀👀

[@tibees]

Timestamps: 1:45 Einstein's PhD thesis, 2:14 The dedication, 5:18 Section 1, 7:50 Section 2, 8:55 Section 3, 9:44 Section 4, 11:23 Section 5, 11:58 An error in the thesis, 13:22 Einstein's paper on Brownian motion, 14:31 Reviewer's comments, 15:17 Einstein's unsuccessful dissertation, 15:58 Letters to Michele Besso, 17:59 Patron Cats of the Day.

[@heavenbounddaughter1125]

I really like this timestamp feature on your video. I've never seen it anywhere before.

[@shurbrrt]

I'm pretty sure I saw somewhere that if you put them in the description line after line ( ) it cuts the video into chapters

[@rohansonawane7634]

Plz make video on jee mains January solution

[@richiegrey5377]

Tibees a new cat 🐱 2020 😉😷🧼🦠🤚👩‍🦳👩‍🦳👩‍🦳🗽🍾🍸

[@tripp8833]

Can you do a video on the EPR paradox? Might be interesting

[@JoeBob79569]

_"There are so many fake quotes attributed to me on the internet that I've given up believing any of them."_ - Albert Einstein

[@wandaperi]

Normie

[@THEMATT222]

Lol, the self reference.

[@eggxecution]

"yeah I agree with you bro!" - Albert Einstein

[@Punisher_0911]

@@eggxecution" lol underrated reply" -albert Einstein

[@sundeutsch]

@@eggxecution haha

[@sergior.m.5694]

When I was little my mom used to read fantasy stories, a few decades later I get Tibees reading to me old research papers. Times have changed

[@Corbenik2nd]

Your comment turns me on

[@johnx8796]

@@Corbenik2nd Why would you say that.

[@AlexandrBorschchev]

Corbenik2nd 🤢🤢🤮

[@RanEncounter]

@Veron Singh Or just has an Oedipus complex...

[@Corbenik2nd]

@@RanEncounter You are absolutely right!

[@wandererswanderingdaughter1756]

"pardon my handwriting, I wrote this in bed" is the most university student thing I've seen in a while

[@akashalbert36]

could you timestamp that?

[@brandonsaavedra8959]

@@akashalbert36 16:10

[@Chaboo22]

Toby, your wholesome positivity and inspiring curiosity is wonderfully refreshing. Thanks for all the content you create and continue to create!

[@tibees]

I appreciate that!

[@khalidwalid658]

How old is she?

[@khalidwalid658]

@This is the best name i could come up with why u said that?

[@user-in1yw9ty5t]

​​@@khalidwalid658 2007. Year 1. Do the math

[@dylancosto]

“The true sign of intelligence is not knowledge, but imagination”- Albert Einstein

[@AlexandrBorschchev]

bs

[@human8612]

Who?

[@tgmtf5963]

@johnixdragon yeah. Intelligence has many forms.

[@petitpanierdosier]

Imagination is linked to knowledge though

[@appleslover]

Tbh I don't trust any of these quotes these days, don't get me wrong but 97% of them are misquotation for the sake of sounding smart.

[@ohedd]

In March 1905 he published the Photoelectric effect, in May Brownian motion, in June Special Relativity, and in September E=mc².... He was truly the man of the century...

[@cembirler]

Grossmann: the real MVP

[@punchnazis3268]

Riiiiiiiiiiiight!? Wish I had a Grossman T_T

Nonsense. Where was Grossman when Einstein was creating condensed matter physics (my field) in 1916/1917 with his genius paper on Spontaneous and Stimulated Emission, the foundational paper for the LASER? Einstein would STILL be the greatest scientist of all time even if Grossman never existed. He was just special.

[@hungryeylash6952]

@ the reason Albert did well in his school was because he used Grossmans notes when he didn’t attend his lectures, and Grossman was able to get Einstein a job when none of his professors wanted him as an assistant. Re-think your comment.

[@alaspooryorick9946]

@@hungryeylash6952 then he taught him differential geometry so he could formulate general relativity. What a wonderful friendship hey... I don't know what MVP stands for, but yeah... Grossman and Einstein. Pretty boss combo

[@manuelbenito1700]

@@alaspooryorick9946 MVP stands for Most Valuable Player

[@michaeljames4904]

_“Mr. Einstein has proved that he is capable of working successfully on scientific problems...”_ talk about academic understatement! 🤣

[@compuholic82]

It may be an understatement but it is nevertheless an important statement to make. A PhD is supposed to be a certificate that shows that you are able to independently conduct scientific research. So it is important that the reviewers make that connection to his work.

[@aaromal_rs]

@@compuholic82 He was just joking man🤦🏽‍♂️

[@senselessnothing]

I guess not anybody can plagiarize poincare and hilbert.

[@maxwellsequation4887]

Imagine being the person to write this

[@johnsolo123456]

@@senselessnothing This is such an utterly stupid contrarian claim for anyone familiar with the literature.

[@leftenanalim]

16:13 " Pardon my bad handwriting, I wrote in bed" - Albert Einstein Now I have a good reason for my handwriting.

[@ironfbody]

Einstein spent a lot of time in bed.

[@Spextori]

@@ironfbody ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

[@abdusabdud8218]

@@ironfbody don't joke with us

[@wandaperi]

I thought that he wrote in German

[@vaibhavsingh-qx8qd]

Toby, your love for math, science and legendary scientists, mathematicians is much appreciated. Thanks for your videos.

[@engboy69]

So cool that he dedicated it to Marcel Grossmann!

[@RAILWAYS_6469]

"Logic will get you from A to B, imagination takes you everywhere" -A. Einstein

[@jimi7837]

'' Einstein was such a guy that every phrase that you put his name in the end, will sound that he really said that. '' - Albert Einstein

[@Punisher_0911]

Ok

[@sundeutsch]

I almost died laughing

[@luisrivera8211]

Thanks!

[@sesom1828]

Danke!

[@xeonviento9778]

German guy here. It says "A new determination of Midichlorians".

[@SuperNovaJinckUFO]

Don't give away our secret!!!!

[@coot33]

It's heroine.

[@sMASHsound]

dude, u made me rewatch... lollllllllllllll

[@miniibeto]

It is not a story the German would tell us

[@leeannmina5353]

It's so nice to have these kinds of info from your channel. -coming from an Einstein enthusiast

[@tibees]

Glad you enjoy it!

[@emidio5373]

17:20 You can read "The university here is a pigsty" LOL

[@mandar_desai34]

Pigs 🤣

[@asparagoquantistico8753]

I really am in love with those Einstein's videos of yours. Also, your voice is super soothing and calm: love also that ☆

[@amy-bethtaylor2656]

Hi, so after youtube suggested you to me, I've been watching your videos and you have motivated me to do my science bridging course for university next year. It's already April and I've been struggling to find motivation to do my modules daily (I do one module per day, and I'd rather do about 3). It has been a slow and painful journey with lots of procrastination. But now I pretend I'm you doing my science (physics and chemistry) and I'm thouroughly enjoying it haha.

[@tibees]

Best of luck!

[@amy-bethtaylor2656]

@@tibees Thank you, it's going well so far!

[@MHF786]

@@amy-bethtaylor2656 YO! how did uni go?

[@amy-bethtaylor2656]

@@MHF786 in my third year now, it's slowly becoming more enjoyable 🤣.

[@MHF786]

@@amy-bethtaylor2656 no way you replied 😮😮. I hope it keeps getting better. I'm going to college In a couple of months so I'm a bit scared.

[@bryce902]

Wanna tell u i really like the way u present. The voice, tone, delivery and eye contact are just perfect n calming

[@tibees]

thanks!

[@Fantasma25]

I have massive respect for the people that make thorough reviews of thesis and paper works and are capable of figuring out why they are wrong.

[@sydhenderson6753]

Like Perrin?

[@rnnyhoff]

What a delightful discovery on KZbin, such a refreshing and insightful look at the nascent genius of the 20th century, the individual who rocked the world of physics. Thank you Toby.

[@quantumecho2456]

Always glad to see a new upload from you pop up in my notifications

[@tibees]

I appreciate that!

[@choojunwyng8028]

You drew a beaker without a ruler and used a pen, I'm calling my teacher right now.

[@mateuscoldeira5409]

Toby, thanks for the amazing video! I really got curious about that PhD attempt in 1901 because I'm a big fan of Boltzmann and statistical mechanics. It's weird that Einstein did so much work in statistical interpretation and in that time there were so many critics about the theory of atom (Gibbs had to talk about ensembles to not be criticized) that probably there were a few problems going this way. I wonder if this topic (History of statistical mechanics and kinetic theory of gases) may be a topic for new videos!

[@malihamasoud3730]

Toby, you inspiring and motivating human, something about you just makes me happy with school and life in general!

[@PsychoSocialCreation]

To see equation of diffusion of molecules was a great beautiful breakdown thank you🙌🏽

[@HamroSamajOfficial]

OMG, the positive attitude level is infinite. Hi Tibees: I've followed on Twitter. Please keep doing the great work. :-)

[@BelgianGeneral]

Loved this video. Please do this for the other four essays from the miracle year!

[@tibees]

🤓

[@sydhenderson6753]

@@tibees I know you did one on E=mc^2, but did you do one for his paper on the photoelectric effect?

[@이무동-f4z]

Hey, I have never seen Einstein’s PhD thesis before... Thanks for showing me specifically what is it about. BTW I subscribed your channel recently because of youtube algorithms. I genuinely feel your love toward physics. I’ll look forward to watching your new videos :)😘 from South Korea

[@LaCienciadeEmprender]

You are just mindblowingly good! You bring physics on youtube to a new level!

[@SalarymanNoMore]

This is so interesting, thank you! It’s also crazy to think that an Einstein-like intellect might end up being inspired by this or one of your videos.

[@Allu_-sl1zv]

Poor Einstein. Doesn’t even has privacy for his letters

[@alberteinsteinthejew]

Amazing! I just finished watching all episodes of Genius season 1, it's awesome!

[@arturogomezchavez6746]

You are like the (science) history's detective :) Very interesting! Hope you are safe and healthy, hopefully I'll remember to send you "my" cat's picture soon. Cheers!

[@jakethesnake17]

How did you comment before the video was uploaded?

[@AstroB7]

Wait what ??? 9 hours before the official release lol

[@tibees]

Doodle Cob - He is a Patreon supporter

[@Epilogue_04]

@@tibees so are you telling me they get a time machine by being patreon supporter? Nice 😀

[@felipeignaciocastrojara5065]

No, maybe she just released the video on private before she allows the other people to watch the video.

[@QuestionEverythingButWHY]

"Intellectuals solve problems, geniuses prevent them.” --Einstein

[@6900xx]

"ok."- Einstein

[@DK-tv6rk]

“I’m not kidding I actually really said that” - Albert Einstein

[@zenithland7422]

The way you talk is so calming!

[@baateinaurcharcha]

Wow seems like this is the KZbin channel we need and especially this is what I was searching for

[@Hambxne]

How fascinating! Thank you for putting this together!

[@kidcompany]

Your videos are so addicting. Must be your calm, pleasant voice. Thanks.

[@PapaFlammy69]

bruh

[@blazedinfernape886]

Papa translate the german thesis and show it on your channel maybe? XD

[@alexisrodriguez7127]

Your my favorite German

[@SnoozeTheRecluse]

Bruh

[@hungryeylash6952]

@Kisara Kodithuwakku 😐

[@tomkerruish2982]

@Kisara Kodithuwakku He was Austrian.

[@alfong8279]

Thanks for helping every Einstein fan in understanding his life's work better!

[@adamqazsedc]

Thanks for uploading this today! This made my day!

[@tibees]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@onthecover5042]

This takes me back

[@Jerry113]

there's something noice about old typeface

[@soulledits4873]

You have no Idea how you helped me with this video. Thanks !!!

[@v.9505]

You are incredible, I love your videos ❤️

[@tibees]

thanks!

[@RalphDratman]

This is my favorite video of yours, because I learned so much from it that is of interest to me. Truly excellent. Thank you!

[@tibees]

So glad!

[@RalphDratman]

​@@tibees I guess what I like about this episode is that we are examining, together, a document of small renown but great interest. We get to see Einstein before the miracle year. He is hoping, with an imperfect thesis, to attain the credential of PhD. Einstein is looking up to those with prestige to grant him a certificate. This is the opposite of our usual view of Einstein, as a lofty figure far above ourselves, possibly above anyone else on Earth. The usual Einstein we learn about can ignore objections all day long and no one will think the worse of him. But this Einstein -- the one you have summoned -- must humbly wait for praise or blame. For that reason I feel as though we are standing next to him in your story about his thesis.

[@tarunluthrabk]

Nice videos, every video is really inspiring in the sense that it teaches what really is required to be a good researcher.. - A masters student from India

[@alessandropalma6111]

Thank you for making youtube a better place

[@Eweyhen]

Gonna be real: The main reason I watch you is that your voice is relaxing.

[@ElijahBerg0011]

Kyle A agreed

[@LeBeautiful]

Using this as a reference for everything in life. Hell, even for a job cover letter this will do 🧠

[@c.gauderes8349]

Marvelous! Thank you so much.

[@TheSharkyBoyCostyn]

As a chemical engineering student I can say that we did a laboratory work related to this paper. The discipline was fundamentals of mass transfer.

[@abdelfadi2703]

Great inspirational video. What i learned: if you love what you do, stick with it and improve yourself into. You will succeed for sure .

[@peternolan814]

Hello Toby, I'm almost 67 and I didn't know till I saw this video that Einstein actually got a doctorate. We never say Dr. Einstein. All the best and many thanks, Peter Nolan. Ph.D.(physics). Dublin. Ireland.

[@dominikjachimczuk8397]

Oh man at about 4:00 this is making so much sense all of a sudden! In the pharmaceutical industry we use 0.22 micron sterile filters for filtering solution to be filled into vials. We use what is called a bubble point test to verify that the filters are the correct filters with the right size pores by measuring the pore size. To do this we put pressure against the solution in the filter membrane until it diffuses through to the other side. The pressure at which the diffusion happens is recorded verifying the integrity of the filter and confirming that the membranes have the correct size pores.

[@cesarjom]

This was very interesting to step through the original thesis! Thank you!

[@manofscience4927]

Hi Toby, I am a huge fan of you. Keep on making such awesome content.

[@harryni8115]

Prof: I have no idea what this kid writing about.

[@Dk-ie4te]

You have calm and positive vibes.

[@scanurasiri1]

you a naturally gifted teacher plus something which I do not have a word to explain ....

[@deepakjoshi823]

Thanks Miss Toby! 😊I needed this.

[@alemaassm]

These videos are great!

[@moudhafferbouallegui]

It's crazy to think that Einstein considered his general relativity paper inferior to what he actually put forth as his doctoral thesis. It's even crazier to consider people actually didn't like his abstract mathematical approach..

[@costyakurlaev9473]

Never give up! You are very precious for the all of us!

[@abdusabdud8218]

Thanks

[@horstlohner2055]

THX to show the original Papers.

[@Risulfur]

Thats a good content. Waiting for more

[@sarah-cx6mc]

imagine he grows up to be a scientist who found out the speed of light and was the brain of the century

[@Refuse2Lose33]

wow, I'm actually studying this right now in my engineering chem class

[@ankurgiri7589]

I love ur content u always make me happy with these videos😍😍😭😭

[@c.r.palihakkara7179]

Thank you.. Highly appreciate your work!!

[@scotty3837]

Thanks Toby! So good.

[@yuslaven89]

To be honest I'm into social sciences like history, politics and sociology. Natural sciences and I have turbulent history. But I came across this channel totally randomly, and just in time. Whole this bug situation make me so anxious that I have problem to fall a sleep and sometimes goes into little panic attacks (I hate myself for that and I'm a bit disappointed in me). But just listening to your voice makes me relaxed so I finally make some quality sleep and have energy to go through the day. Thank you! And stay safe. Servus.

[@miriamn9657]

That error in the thesis sneaked across 2 highly skilled mathematicians (Burkhardt & Einstein) before it got trapped by a third (Hopf was prof for math and mechanics in Aachen). Einstein himself didn't find it and asked Hopf to look at it with a unbiased mind. Too bad Hopf's answer hasn't survived nor Einstein's "Thank you, how could I be so blind."- letter.

[@Unidentifying]

this was very interesting thank you, he was really like a wizard. Really amazing synchronicity because I am reading his GR paper myself :P

[@varmamahesh9725]

Einstein's letter to professor: .. Pardon my handwriting. I wrote in bed.

[@MITOMANOx]

Thanks for sharing!

[@michaelherbert2642]

Thanks for the amazing videos

[@mevenstien]

Thank you for making your vids :)

[@nandalalghosh8902]

Could you please make a video on Dirac's phd thesis.

[@1eV]

why not every famous physicist's thesis

[@dylanparker130]

I really enjoyed this - I think everyone loves Einstein more than they do other scientists because his early struggles are so well known & give heart to all of us!

[@AlphaFoxDelta]

Thank you very much again.

[@tibees]

No worries!

[@abdel46]

I really like your videos . You have such a calm voice, it goes right through my heart. You should do some asmr hagahgaah.

[@johneonas6628]

Thank you for the video.

[@drup-ys6ry]

Tibees, please review the other four miracle paper of Einstein in 1905.

[@bigmo9313]

Regardless of how impressive this thesis is, we can't ignore tibees epic handwriting

[@rohitashwadey4510]

What a co incidence it was the last day that our school physics committee was thinking about you to revies Einstiens thesis, and the same u did.. Thank you And lots of love and support from India

[@rohitashwadey4510]

*review

[@Tod_oMal]

Who continues to listen while not understanding, only to hear that beautiful voice?

[@Tod_oMal]

@tommy cane115 Ok, I respect your opinion, but which scientist would you understand/trust then? If any?

[@sabithasan7830]

"Time is a stubborn illusion" Albert Einstein

[@Satabdikakati]

Continue making videos on research paper it is really so inspiring.... 😇

[@mizzyroro]

Here's an idea for a video. So I've seen derivation videos of E=mC^2. I would like to see a video of what was known before Einstien. What did he add to what was known to get to E=mC^2. What was so challenging that it hadn't been done before. What was the brilliance that Einstien brought to the existing challenge to get to E=mC^2.

[@ornestebuitkute9720]

That's very interesting! Could you do more videos going through papers?

[@meow75714]

lovely research, thanks for sharing

[@TermoMecanica2023]

Your English is so clear that even I don't speak English (not so good), I can understand you very well. Hugs from Brazil!

[@rafaelgonzalez4175]

I finally realized why I was pushed out and away from the educational system. I would have written the paper proving all this wrong. Here I am at 58 years old and looking at this and yep it is right in front of my eyes. Thanks for the epiphany.

[@mrtitanium427]

Shall we pressure Trent University into helping me complete a doctorate? They're ignoring me. I don't like that.

[@alexjbriiones]

Although Einstein’s initial application for a doctorate at the University of Bern (he had previously been awarded a PhD by the University of Zürich in 1905) was indeed rejected as insufficient in 1907, and it was not until the following year that he completed a new dissertation that resulted in his being awarded a doctorate by the University of Bern and given a position as a lecturer at that school.