Elijah Craig Barrel Proof 2019 Series | Blind Mash-Up

[@robertbrangan9617]

This is my favorite whiskey channel. Thanks for the great content

[@ADHDWhiskey]

Great review, Jason! Was looking forward to you doing this! ECBP is everything that is right in the bourbon industry. Adding the Larceny Barrel Proof this winter earns Heaven Hill some big fanboy points from me!

[@TheMashandDrum]

All your words are fantastic. Lol. Cheers buddy!

[@ADHDWhiskey]

@@TheMashandDrum Boobs ....just to further your point....about my words

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@ADHDWhiskey lamp

[@seckler17]

I just compared my C917 vs B518, for scientific purposes of course. C917 won for me it was sweeter, lots of caramel, brown sugar and chocolate with some fruity notes and a bit of oak on the finish, not as much spice, oak and tannin's as the B518. The B518 had more spice/cinnamon, almost prickly. I have A119 and B519 but have not cracked them open yet. Great video, ECBP is definitely a great value and probably my favorite generally "available" bourbon currently on the market. Cheers.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Oh the 2017 B and C were special bottles as well. I think you nailed it...some come across as more sweet while while some come across with that peanut and oak flavor. The C918 is still my fav ever so far but this C919 came close. incredible mouthfeel. Cheers!

[@joachimkoka5030]

Having my first pour of Elijah Craig barrel proof right now, it’s the B519 so I’m happy to have this to drink to. What a whiskey. So good.

[@PizzaTwinsReviews]

It's awesome how you show on the screen what you are describing during your blind. Great content

[@TheMashandDrum]

Thanks so much! Got alot of feedback on that so just added that. Cheers.

[@juliussharrock8943]

Don't have to tell you this is an amazing lineup... REALLY enjoying the '20 B batch and the A121!!

[@jameslikins3591]

Thanks- my B519 just came from Amazon! Looking forward to cracking it open this evening. Love your videos!

[@rclem21]

Thanks, Jason. I always love ECBP. I can't wait to try the new c-batch!

[@TheMashandDrum]

Its soo good. Thanks for watching Dave!

[@timgargis7565]

Great review. Of course the one that I don't have is in first. Keeping my fingers crossed that my store is correct and that they will have it in 2-3 weeks. Still with ECBP is hard to be disappointed. Truly one of the best offerings there is. Cheers!

[@TheMashandDrum]

Couldn't agree more. I got lucky and got one early. I'm sure it will start dropping everywhere soon. Cheers.

[@rdh5961]

Your content is fantastic! Great job, as usual.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Thanks so much!

[@moose7611]

Thumbs up for ECBP best bourbon for the money, may they keep them coming for the same $$$$.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Amen to that!

[@moose7611]

The Mash and Drum - We need a C batch double bass 2018 vs 2019

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@moose7611 Ohhh yes...Its coming...I may do that on livestream. Maybe throw in Stagg as well.

[@newmennium]

Stagg Jr 9 vs 12

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@newmennium still love 9.

[@larryfairbanks7783]

Got all 3 in my cabinet. ECBP best bang for the buck. Love all 3!!!

[@TheMashandDrum]

Nice!!! Comparing all 3 is a fun blind to do.

[@gman5986]

Hi Larry! Haven't had much luck finding it at this time and my birthday is in a few days on 11/6. Any suggestions where I can find those two???..........S'lainte!

[@mark1836]

Mark, Iowa. You do a great job! Love your review’s and having a package of C919 coming this week. Can’t wait to see how the C922 is when released hopefully sometime in late October or in November!

[@socoblue1988]

Finally pulled the trigger on buying a C919 last night. Most expensive bottle I've ever bought but I'm so excited to pop it open in the future :) Definitely going to get a 2020 bottle as well. Awesome review, Jason.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Congrats...let it sit in the glass for about 20 minutes before you go in. Opens up really nicely.

[@socoblue1988]

@@TheMashandDrum thanks, I'll make sure to do that!

[@mybourbonjourney]

Well Batch C sounds absolutely delicious. Basically everything I/we love in a bourbon. Great review as always. Like you said a little water with these proofs can help. Looking forward to picking up Batch C. Cheers Maverick!

[@TheMashandDrum]

Yeah man. Batch C strikes again! Lol. Delicious. Honestly anyone can like any of these. Just depends what you like. But the mouthfeel on C is amazing.

[@TheLivingstons]

Just picked up the C919 a few minutes ago. Dropped in VA today!

[@TheMashandDrum]

Ohhh you will love it. A bit hot at first but even adding some water makes it sweet and delicious.

[@gman5986]

Haven't had much luck finding it at this time and my birthday is in a few days on 11/6. Any suggestions where I can find those two???..........S'lainte!

[@TheLivingstons]

The Mash and Drum I’m a huge fan of A119 so I have no doubt I’ll love C919. Looking forward to trying it tonight.

[@TheLivingstons]

G man VA just got theirs in today. Anywhere near a VA ABC store?

[@gman5986]

@@TheLivingstons Hi Amanda. I'm in SoCal. I'll check if they ship to me....thank you!!

[@Wolf6151]

My wife just bought me a C919 for Christmas, haven't opened it yet, but really looking forward to this bottle.

[@johnfreed9167]

Just like DbeatDano below, I just picked up the C batch as well yesterday at a little liquor store in Indiana. I was like a kid on Christmas morning! Can’t wait to open it and have a pour with the wife. Great review as always Jason. Love all the history and all the great content you provide in your reviews. Thank you!

[@TheMashandDrum]

Thanks john! appreciate that!

[@LitoCortes]

Glad to see the batch I recently found (C919) was the one that felt the most balanced to you. Cheers!

[@jeffmills822]

hey Jason. I found 6 bottles of the discontinued 12 year red tag in the back room of my market yesterday that I thought was just wine... I haven't found any barrel proofs. But, I bought 5 bottles of the original 12 year 94 proof...with the original label...not the one they put the 12 year statement on the back. It sure crushed the small batch. Boy those 3 you have look incredible!!! i paid $40.50us no tax 70cl bottle.. cheers from Cambodia!

[@TheMashandDrum]

I have one bottle of that 12 year and your right. It does crush the small batch. Delicious and amazing you found so many. Cheers to you in Cambodia!

[@jeffmills822]

@@TheMashandDrum Thanks pal. Your barrel proofs look like they all are way above the original 94 proof and it proves they made a great business decision and have even better products!

[@the_snicklefritz]

Nothing like ECBP! Amazing stuff. Great video!

[@mattmckane6741]

Gonna pick a bottle of Barrel Proof on Friday. Fortunately, I found a liquor store that has healthy stock of all three batches. I'm thinking C Batch after this! Thanks Jason!

[@Ungart404]

First time viewer here. I like your style. Excellent head to head presentation of excellent bourbon! Subscribed.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Thanks so much! Welcome and glad you enjoy the content.

[@dbeatdano498]

Just picked up the C at a little liquor store in Wisconsin. Can't wait to try it. Great review!

[@johncannon3593]

C919 was the one that made me fall in love with the series. I recently (May 2021) came across a B519 on a shelf at MSRP, so I grabbed it for posterity, but haven't opened it yet. C920 is still my absolute favorite I've tried so far.

[@brmicmatthews8398]

You try that B519 yet? Picked one up about four months ago and still haven’t opened it yet.

[@johncannon3593]

@@brmicmatthews8398 no, not yet.

[@michaelerazo245]

great review! loving the C batch! love that heat!

[@brandontempleton55]

Always love these ECBP matchups you do! Great job! I can’t remember if you ranked the B519 over the C918 in the last one. Either way they keep putting out some bomb ass bottlings with this series! Cheers!

[@TheMashandDrum]

Will be doing a LIVESTREAM with the C918 vs the C919. And some other barrel proof legends. Cheers buddy

[@BourbonLiberty]

I loved the A119. Haven't tried the B or C yet. To me, in general, the higher the proof the better! More room to open up flavors suspended in the alcohol with a splash or two of water. Looking forward to adding the C to my shelf.

[@Dustydanswhiskeyreviews]

I cant wait to try all of these from this year. Everytime I've been to my store they are sold out. Great breakdown of these beauties. Cheers buddy

[@TiFiber]

Another great review and match up and I'm with you on Elijah Craig and I love my C917 barrels proof.

[@nvrp813]

See you in the 2019 top ten C919. Great job Jason. I get a lot of lime citrus on B519. Haven’t been able to locate the C919 yet. Cheers 🥃

[@bourbonapprentice]

Great breakdown on these. Still looking for the C batch in NC

[@TheMashandDrum]

Keep those eyes peeled! lol

[@larryfairbanks7783]

Just found a bottle of c918 on the shelf the other day . Had no choice but to pick it up. Haven't broke the seal yet. Maybe save it for Christmas?

[@TheMashandDrum]

Ohhhh that C918 is a beautiful bottle. I would crack it open now..lol. Let it get some air in it before the holidays and thats when it gets pretty amazing. Cheers!

[@larryfairbanks7783]

Yes probably wouldn't hurt to give it a burp. Good excuse to break the seal and try a little.

[@LeatherDaddy97]

Picked up a c919 the second i saw it. Fantastic

[@GregsWhiskyGuide]

Very cool run down, Jason...interesting also because I might have to get soon a bottle in reserve of my current one (old packaging, French market, 67,4 % abv, awesome), and I've recently increased my US Bourbons & Rye "members of my collection" as it previously lacked of variety in terms of flavor profiles & styles...Cheers !

[@djbeacon1942]

Jason, great, detailed comparison. I still see lots of the "B519" around town. Our prices are $60 to 100 in Myrtle Beach. So how did they mix with ginger ale?? 😄 Since I still have a few bottles of the C918s I'll try the B519 and that extra peanut flavor. Cheers!!

[@TheMashandDrum]

60-100 isnt bad..Thats generally what I see it for. Dont joke...I know a few people that mix bourbon with ginger ale...probably not ECBP though. :) Thanks as always DJ!

[@djbeacon1942]

@@TheMashandDrum Dumb question = has anyone tried a Store Pick ECBP? I see lots of the small batch or standard EC Store Picks but never have seen or heard of one for the ECBP. Maybe I don't get out enough?!

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@djbeacon1942 no your not crazy. I've never seen any ECBP picks. Lol

[@zogzog1063]

Interesting. I was a always a Cabernet / Single Malt guy with a side interest in bourbon but after discovering EC ... I have a new best friend!

[@TheMashandDrum]

Nice man. This bourbon can definitely do that.

[@garylethbridge6220]

Great review. Unfortunately in Ontario it's 142.00 and I haven't seen it available yet. Maybe a lottery item.

[@RaulPerez1]

I can't find the C batch anywhere in Long Island NY. Just the B519. Sadness.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Nothing wrong with the b batch. I was in long island not too long ago and the store I go to told me they get them late so hopefully soon.

[@RaulPerez1]

@@TheMashandDrum which store do you visit?

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@RaulPerez1 I go to West Islip wine and liqours and union wine and liqours in West Islip long island. Great owners and fair prices.

[@RaulPerez1]

@@TheMashandDrum Awesome thanks for the heads up!

[@RaulPerez1]

The Mash and Drum stopped at both places today. Fair prices on most brands. Still just B519. Looks like I’ll have to wait

[@TheBanjoFlyBoy]

I haven't tried ECBP but I've recently become a huge fan of their small batch 94proof. I'm perfectly happy letting EC add water to create the proof and taste I'm digging🥃😜

[@TheMashandDrum]

The small batch is an amazing bourbon too for the price. Great proof and great flavors. The ECBP is just those flavors amped up to 200%

[@TheBanjoFlyBoy]

I'll look for some BP, but their SB is hard to beat for taste and price.

[@bourbonbuddies836]

Love these are all different, but it seems each batch is just straight solid. So consistent and delicious. Still looking for B and C. Can’t wait to get my hands on them! Cheers, Jason! Great job 🥃

[@PhatTrumpet2]

Crushed it as always.

[@johnd5669]

Hey Jason, great review as always. Wondering if you tried proofing the c919 batch down to the proof of the b519 and then comparing to see which is your favorite? I just wonder which would win if they had similar proofs?

[@TheMashandDrum]

Well when I added water to each the B seemed to get more peanut and the C stayed more sweet. Still has some peanut but more sweet. I would have to test that theory though.

[@gman5986]

Jason just cracked my first bottle of C919 now rewatching this video for the second time while sipping. Couple of ??s for you. 1.... I noticed on all my whiskies that they usually taste better once opened for awhile. How long does it take for ECBP to really open up after you crack the cork and get the bottle down to the bottom of the neck area? 2...My initial tasting today thinks its good but feels constricted somehow compared to my bottle C918 that has been open now for 8-10 months which tastes much better to me. What are your thoughts? Thanks for the great blinds of this ECBP

[@TheMashandDrum]

Absolutely. I let the ECBP sit in the glass for 15-20 minutes on a new bottle. It definitely needs time to oxidize a bit. The air does alot for most barrel proof whiskeys ... especially ECBP. Definitely let it sit in the glass for about 20. Cheers.

[@gman5986]

@@TheMashandDrum How many months do you think you notice a noticeable improvement?

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@gman5986 I dont think it takes months. Maybe a couple weeks or so after you have a couple pours and let it get some air in the bottle.

[@gman5986]

@@TheMashandDrum Thanks Jason....Now its onto my experimentation and continuing tasting and comparaison..??...Do you also like Scotch Whiskeys??

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@gman5986 I do! Been learning more and more each year and will be doing some more scotch reviews in the new year.

[@stevenlharris]

Do you have matching ball lifters for that hat?

[@TheMashandDrum]

Wow. Are you from Michigan? Lol

[@stevenlharris]

@@TheMashandDrum No, I'm from THE state of Georgia but went to Michigan for school and drove through Ohio enough to develop a dislike for it. I do enjoy your reviews though and will keep watching! I've had some good times tailgating with OSU fans and bourbon. Can't seem to finish off each bottle of ECBP before the next comes out.

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@stevenlharris well if it makes you feel better, I love here in Ohio but grew up in NY so Im not a huge fan. I didn't learn about the religion of OSU until I moved here. Definitely try and find the new ECBP when you can. The C batch.

[@WhiskeyQuests]

Found the B519 yesterday for $70 🤘

[@dccoletrain]

I can’t even find this stuff in my stores. One employee told me they get one shipment at about 3 bottles a year.... it’s a well established store at that.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Wow that's crazy. There are a couple stores online that you may be able to get from.

[@matthewmcnab322]

seems that the c wins every year, b middle and A last place fairly consistently, I wonder if it's when they were distilled or just what stage the barrel was in when they are pulled, ie outside temp if wood pulling or push the juice?

[@TheMashandDrum]

I've been trying to figure that out too. But I think all three give something for everyone. The B I feel is most universally loved each year but the C to me is on another level.

[@matthewmcnab322]

I would agree that b has the most common bourbon flavors that everyone can get behind, A gives more of the weller or four Rose's type of flavors and C is for more of the die hard proof drinkers looking for more complex flavors.

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@matthewmcnab322 my thoughts exactly. Cheers.

[@rdh5961]

A117 was the best batch I ever had, and I've had a lot.

[@matthewmcnab322]

interesting, I sought out the c917, never tried the a117, going to have to go hunting now, thank you

[@gman5986]

Jason how would you compare the C918 to the C919 or even the B519 ??.........cheers!

[@TheMashandDrum]

I still think the C918 is my fav but I'm going to do a LIVESTREAM and compare them both once the C919 gets a bit more air in it.

[@antroque35]

Now I have to go to the store

[@drammanky2418]

How would you rate c919 over c 918 I definitely love them both but the 19 fell a little short for past c batches id love to see a c batch blind .

[@TheMashandDrum]

Yeah I'm gonna do that on a live stream. But not blind...I still liked the C918 over the C919

[@mpatton997]

Awesome. Awesome. Awesome! I was locked in the this blind and the big reason was because I was able to match ur impressions to the specific bourbon. I have the B, now I need to go find the C! Question C919 or Kitchen Table? I know where that one is but only have enough for one of them.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Glad you enjoyed it buddy! Hmmm. I think I would take the C919 over the kitchen table. Definitely

[@mpatton997]

@@TheMashandDrum Thank you! I'll leave the Booker's and go hunting. Thanks my friend. Go Mets.

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@mpatton997 yeah buddy!!!

[@djbeacon1942]

@@TheMashandDrum I've tasted Kentucky Chew and Kitchen Table and they are close to KC 120 SiB but the Country Ham is over the top with so much butterscotch to me. Very unique. But I would go ECBP and the extra $20 you save over Bookers gets you halfway to a bottle of KC SiB 120 proof. Cheers!

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@djbeacon1942 I agree. But yeah...the country ham is a special batch.

[@XscarpettaX]

Jason, when's the new Maker's Mark RC6 review? no one has a review out yet. That stuff is a real treat! love the EC BP blind selection. i have C918 and A119. I'll be on the hunt for the new C.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Probably my next one. Tuesday. The C918 is Soo good. The C919 is close. I need to compare. Cheers.

[@hombreleon]

Cool review. ECBF is one of my favorite bourbons. Would you mind saying the names of the bottles instead of “this one”/“that one”. I enjoy listening while I’m driving. 🙏

[@TheMashandDrum]

That's the 2nd person who's asked me that. When it's blind I can't really call it out because I don't know. But if it's not blind I will be sure to say the bottle. Really appreciate the feedback. Cheers.

[@hombreleon]

Got it. Thanks for replying. You’re killing it this year. 👍🏼🥃

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@hombreleon thanks Leo! Cheers buddy! Got some fun stuff planned for next year.

[@WhiskeyQuests]

The C batch is what I’m looking for. I keep seeing the A batch but no B or C. Lol. Cheers Jason 🥃

[@TheMashandDrum]

The C batch just released not that long ago so keep your eyes peeled. Lol

[@newmennium]

We're drowning in B519 down here, but no C yet!!!

[@AlphaOneActual]

I want to try an Elijah Craig Barrel Proof someday, unfortunately when I find them they’re $120 plus... but hey I’m heading to Ironroot Relublic tomorrow for their Ichor so that’s a bourbon worth having!

[@TheMashandDrum]

OMG YES!! The Ichor is amazing...Im trying to find someone that can grab me one. I think its one per customer.

[@AlphaOneActual]

The Mash and Drum I spoke with Josh Gollady earlier sounds like 2 per person, man I gotta get there early!

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@AlphaOneActual yes I reached out to him and he is sending me a bottle so I'm super excited. Thanks for looking into it. Yeah you may have to get there early. Lol

[@AlphaOneActual]

The Mash and Drum Hell yeah! Can’t wait to sip it with ya on stream man!

[@newmennium]

Jason, what has been your favorite ECBP batch of the last 3 years?

[@TheMashandDrum]

Definitely the C918. B517 close 2nd. But this new C919 I have to compare.

[@gman5986]

Great review Jason!. Now how the heck can I find A119 and C919? Haven't had much luck finding it at this time and my birthday is in a few days on 11/6. Any suggestions where I can find those two???..........S'lainte!

[@TheMashandDrum]

Not sure. These releases really vary eon where you live. You can find them online sometimes as long as they can ship to you.

[@gman5986]

@@TheMashandDrum Would you happen to know of any online retailers that have the "C919 Batch" I'm searching now for my Bday gift to myself!....:)

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@gman5986 try Ace Spirits

[@WhiskyMystery]

Great round up. Are these all say 8/10's or is one a 6 and another a 9? I presume these are all pretty close to each other in reality. ECBP was a big hit on our Scotland tour.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Yes these are all 8-10s. They are all a bit different but something for everyone. One of the if not THE best value in bourbon. Just hope it stays that way.

[@WhiskyMystery]

@@TheMashandDrum Yes hope so also

[@neckpour5479]

Is that Ron Swanson looking over your shoulder?

[@TheMashandDrum]

yes sir! Review coming soon!

[@BretSimmons]

I don't have C yet but I did prefer B to A.

[@craig42069]

Yeah B batch super peanutty.

[@marlanefigurski2032]

In the Columbus are, please advice liquor stores where I can find some of the items that are unavailable in Eastern Ohio. Thank you

[@SentMyOwnWay]

Keep growing bro

[@TheMashandDrum]

Trying to buddy!

[@mikelisac]

who wins? you win.

[@TheMashandDrum]

Oh thats right!! LOL. Thanks for becoming a Patron! I shouted you out on my last LIVESTREAM! CHEERS!

[@mikelisac]

Thanks. I had to catch it on replay. Curious to know what you think of the SCN Wild Turkey

[@TheMashandDrum]

@@mikelisac It was delicious! One of the most butterscotchy Wild Turkeys Ive had. Oak, cinnamon, very well balanced.

[@jimidrammer4187]

I guess I'm a proof whore because I like A119 over B519 so I'll probably seek out a case of C919! I noticed the Offerman Lagavulin on the barrel, picked up one today and while it doesn't pull away from others in the range, it is solid. Great Head to Head as always Jason.

[@Claire_III]

You say water wrong. There's no D in water 😂

[@TheMashandDrum]

LOL!! Can't deny it.

[@moose7611]

Yes there is - Wada