Elsa VS Pepa - Who is More POWERFUL? | Disney Film Theory

This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp - go to betterhelp.com/... to get started with Betterhelp today.
Go to meundies.com/TH... for 20% off your first order and free shipping.
Today J dives into the magical world of Disney to find out who is more powerful: Elsa from Frozen or Pepa from Encanto! Both can wield the weather, but Elsa can only access ice while Pepa can control any element at all!
#supercarlinbrothers #Disney #Encanto #Frozen
Edited by :: Riley Murtagh
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrot...
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlin...
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: [e-mail]
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Ok how bout this one.... Luisa vs Hercules?

[@coolnerdlll6053]

Hercules. He's invincible and Luisa is not.

[@MovieMadness23]

Luisa vs Mr. Incredible

[@ccproduction1230]

Hurcales is a god though

[@harriot996]

​@@coolnerdlll6053 Hercules got burned alive...

[@shadowmarauder6033]

Another one I’ve thought for a long time: Ultron vs Mewtwo.

[@trinaq]

I find it fascinating how the triplet's powers reflects their birth order. Julieta heals the pain of the past through her cooking, Pepa represents the ever changing present, and Bruno is the Future, something we never want to talk about.

[@addictedtoJB]

They're triplets...they were born within seconds of each other.

[@thephony1651]

@@addictedtoJB Time still passed lol

[@addictedtoJB]

@@thephony1651 heal the pain of 1 second ago...

[@thephony1651]

@@addictedtoJB 1 second ago is still the past. And what the amount of time between doesn’t affect anything. Just the fact that there IS time between.

[@Link-to-the-Smash]

​@@addictedtoJB seconds are units of time. Any amount of time still passes, no matter the context.

[@adamrabe3105]

The thought of Elsa being a Peloton instructor is priceless. If Casita can form a treadmill for Luisa, who knows what Elsa was able to do for herself in that castle.

[@k49821]

I laughed at that too 💀Although since she's running over snow & ice she could be using her powers to help move her body?

[@MovieMadness23]

If we’re doing character comparisons from Encanto with other characters then they should do Mr. Incredible vs Luisa

[@taylerlong2995]

I think this would be better than Hercules as a comparison, since I feel like their backgrounds are more similar. Y'know, not gods.

[@charleswhisler59]

Do a 3 way battle. Hercules Mr Bob and Luisa. I think Luisas powers work more like Nothing is heavy for her. So her strength goes up and down. I kinda think she wins.

[@shockedbucket]

@@charleswhisler59 no you can see struggle whenever she picks things up like yes she can pick them up but there is definitely a limit

[@Mcnerd213]

But mr incredible is so much weaker, no contest, he can’t pick up churches, or 20 donkeys with ease, closest thing we see him do is the trains in the workout scene, in which he is using his whole body, pulleys, and only for short periods, luisa picks up the church, walks like it’s nothing, sets it down, picks up 20 donkeys like their nothing, balances them like their nothing, and walks around town with them. NO CONTEST. Hercules is more akin to this strength, knocking quartz pillars on accident, carrying a single donkey like it’s nothing, and i think he picks up the giant and throws it, but I may be thinking of kingdomhearts, which is unfortunately non cannon. Mr. Incredible struggles with feats greater than 10x a normal persons limit.

[@shockedbucket]

@@Mcnerd213 actually at the end of the movie he lifts the robot which is super heavy if you want the numbers check out matpats video who’s the strongest incredible

[@mar111333]

In Tangled, Rapunzel’s song says “change the fate’s design…” - do you think she could’ve fixed Merida’s problem?

[@IzukuMidoriya38855]

That'd be cool.

[@FenDweller13]

No, that line is just a part of her incantation, she power is to heal not literally defy fate

[@AlphaFX-kv4ud]

@@FenDweller13 it actually is more than just healing as reversing age isn’t exactly healing so rapunzel could probably turn Meridas mom back to a human but not solve the original problem

[@FenDweller13]

@@AlphaFX-kv4ud perhaps, but healing and returning youth is just reversing natural ailments, her mom’s curse was caused by an unnatural spell so there’s no guarantee it’d work

[@daltoncasey]

@@FenDweller13 I get what you're saying... But I feel like magic could probably cancel out magic. Through Brave it is seen almost like a curse (don't quote me on that, I havent seen it in years) and something that needs fixing and healing. Thats exactly what Rapunzel's hair does. Heals and fixes

[@redyoshicraft]

This is a.. weird, suggestion. But.. Anna vs Mirabelle? Y'know, pitting the 2 *non* Magical Sisters with Magical Siblings against eachother? I suppose at that point it'd be more about how well they handle various situations and whatnot. I dunno, seems oddly intriguing to me!

[@stromboli1234]

Wow

[@stromboli1234]

Agreed

[@stromboli1234]

Dat super cool d a two on magical sisters with oddly powerful family members

[@user-bs2ds9vm2m]

That would be fun. Just a fist fight

[@user-bs2ds9vm2m]

👊

[@Cangwen]

I think Elsa and Peppa would probably have a chat over some coffee. It's also worth noting that we don't know what schooling Elsa received growing up.

[@nmoney6655]

Possibly Elsa didn’t receive any schooling-she could’ve had private tutoring because her parents were literally king and queen they had the money

[@bluu7964]

While I don’t think Peppa could ever beat Elsa, I think just like everyone else she isn’t at her full potential during the movie at all. She has had to suppress her powers her entire life but in a different way then Elsa. She could never make any other type of weather, only sunny all the time. She has had to suppress her emotions always because any time she felt something other then happy (I assume that is what sunny is) it would be ‘bad for the village’ It’s like Bruno said, he told her it looked like rain to get her to let go and be free. That’s why she had the hail cloud at the end, she stopped trying to control it and just let go.

[@stromboli1234]

Yeah , peps did’t have that TURN AROUND At the end

[@stromboli1234]

I feel like they could make a movie about 2 point o Elsa 😂

[@stromboli1234]

It would be a hit

[@archangel996]

ngl, saw the title of this video in my notifications and thought you were matching Elsa up against Peppa Pig for a moment

[@coolnerdlll6053]

Elsa would turn Peppa into frozen sausage links. Can we watch that fight next?

[@lola.stanley]

pls i spit out my drink reading this comment XD still chuckling a min later

[@thatonepossum5766]

Peppa Pig, if you squint, is just a hairdryer glued to a body. She would turn the temperature and air to max, then go to war.

[@Loaderdani]

You're probably right, but I think you undereastimate the danger of lightning; Elsa barely blocks the crossbow in time and naturally occuring lightning travels 100s or 1000s of times faster than crossbow bolts (~130 m/s vs ~500 000 m/s, if my memory serves)

[@neocat81]

just looked it up. there is a 90% chance of surviving a lightning strike. they have verying strengths but also access to a hospital. it would probably slow her down

[@dsengupta6189]

Emphasis on the ‘natural’. Peppa zapped Camillo by accident and he definitely survived it.

[@bangerxshane]

Elsa can create blizzards. What's stopping her from generating her own lightning?

[@markchapman6800]

​@@bangerxshane Thundersnow is definitely a thing. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thundersnow

[@purplea8737]

Yeah and don't forget that she can do lighting but also can summoned an hurricane and tornadoes at the same time elsa can battle them all individually but if all of those attacks her i think she would get overwhelmed

[@chrishall5570]

Another big factor is that Pepa needs to be feeling certain emotions to change the weather in certain ways and while I have no doubt that she could its not really sustainable for a long term fight especially since Elsa can just make a quick army, build a ice castle and then go take a nap or get something to eat if she wants to while idly sending waves of ice monsters at Pepa. Elsa can just go about her day for the most part while Pepa would need to be constantly awake and making herself feel certain ways in order to fight. The wave of ice monsters would eventually get Pepa as her quality of life continues to go down.

[@izzysmith105]

Please say I wasn't the only one who yelled "Yes!" when Anna punched Hans? I'd forgotten how much I loved the original Frozen, and this video used so many clips that I love!

[@baystated]

Maybe Encanto could have a sequel for each magical sibling fully coming to terms with the power potential, and then an Avengers-Level final film where they conquer the world and everyone hugs it out.

[@thatonepossum5766]

If done correctly that would actually rock.

[@yarielgomez2697]

Since you’ve brought up the idea of a versus, you could do a Disney Battle Royale between the movies! You wouldn’t have to mention all of them (nobody in Snow White is gonna put up a fight) but discussing which movie team would ultimately prevail, like Hercules, Moana, The Incredibles, Encanto, or Soul

[@Cherri_Stars]

Incredibles vs Big Hero 6 would be epic

[@bangerxshane]

People in Hercules could cut their hair or sumn, it's a massacre.

[@isabellagust6305]

@@Cherri_Stars for the early movies like Snow White or Sleeping Beauty it depends if the bad guys count for their fight because yes otherwise it's gonna be though

[@lloyddragon2036]

nobody in snow white, uh you mean except for the queen right??? assuming we're not caring if characters survived their movies or not

[@dangernoodle9882]

@@lloyddragon2036 I mean she can make poison fruit disguises and other elixirs but what is she going to do against maleficent? Bake a poison apple pie for her and wait for her to hopefully eat it?

[@thecosplaycrafter8017]

I feel like an Encanto sequel focused more on Pepa and her children is in order. Dolores, Camilo, and Antonio got way too little screen time, and most of what makes Elsa so formidable comes out of Frozen 2. Elsa has an unfair advantage in having two whole films.

[@archerelms]

I think Pepa, if she could fully control her powers, could potentially be more useful than Elsa? She could just make the weather whatever it needs to be for whatever it may be needed for, like crops or building. But yeah if we're focusing on combat I don't think it's ever a contest. I do think Pepa would be pretty useful as a line of defense, though. Give your people the perfect conditions for defense, while giving the enemy the roughest conditions for attacking? Blowing away whatever is coming at them while possibly speeding along your own people? But I find it hard to imagine her controlling her emotions enough for that level of control while being actively in danger.

[@crazyinvaderfangirl1]

Elsa literally became a goddess at the end of frozen two. Enough said.

[@jeshuarestituyo284]

Not really a goddesss, she most likely became inmortal as she’s a spirit now

[@marsfreelander5969]

So you mean to tell me it's a immortal fighting a mortal? Wow I wonder what the outcome will be in 80 years from now...

[@jeshuarestituyo284]

@@marsfreelander5969 inmortal doesn’t equal omnipotent. It’s just someone who doesn’t dies, doesn’t ages, can’t get sick. But can still be killed by someone else. She can still get killed but since she also happens to be the new spirit she’ll still exist as a spirit. So Pepa can defeat her human body

[@lilac3266]

I thought she became a bridge?

[@lorenapacora1526]

spirit, not goddess

[@annekaandersenmusic]

That makes sense to me, except for your theory about how the Magrigal family can only use powers inside the house. Louisa was literally carrying armfuls of donkeys two blocks away. And Camilo shapeshifted into Dolores at the family’s food stand in the town. And let’s not forget that Bruno went around telling the townsfolk their futures. So personally, I don’t think the powers inside casita theory makes sense.

[@Loaderdani]

13:35; He suggested the powers were limited to the Encanto/Valley not Casita. You might be thinking of the line where he suggests Elsa wins, even inside the Casita, which I think is a little far-fetched, given the only way Pepa is caught alone in the Casita is if all (or at least most) of her family is dead or captured, in which case her emotional state would (in my opionion) result in an impenatrable storm.

[@ConfesserDubs]

He said the encanto which includes the area where the other villagers live. It extends all the way to the mountains (before they split towards end of the movie) we don’t know if their powers work outside that area (on the other side of the mountains)

[@Mr1991bbk]

Interesting how the triplets have a correlation to the Past, Present, and Future. Healing the wounds of the past, weather based on how she presently feels, and seeing the future.

[@ben6217]

We gonna talk about how physically capable Elsa is at all… like for someone who spent a lot of time in her room she makes those jumps look easy. I don’t think she had a gymnastics gym in her bedroom Update: Being a Disney character gives you automatically great physicality

[@deshawnedwards6412]

Else can control ice and snow, Pepe can control the weather, rain, wind, storm, hail, hurricane, she can make it sunny or cloudy. But we don't really know how strong Pepe really is or how well she can control her power, also she's portrayed being somewhat unstable which make her unpredictable. Elsa was able to create a premiment Winter and bring being to life with her power like an god, Pepe can't anything like that. So I have to go with Elsa with this.

[@arielvaldez1050]

But do we really know what Pepa is capable of? Like he mentioned, most of her powers were displayed when she was not in control, which is pretty impressive. Lol.

[@raebaby4600]

@@arielvaldez1050 idk when he mentioned she was in control bc there wasn't really many moments that she was in control of her powers at all tbh and he mentioned THAT. I think that if Pepas powers weren't controlled by her emotions she would be extremely powerful but throughout the entire movie she is shown being controlled by her powers rather than her controlling her powers. Even when elsa is completely out of control she does way more extravagant things than Pepa does and when she's by herself she creates even more powerful magic. If Pepa actually had control over her powers then she'd beat elsa without a doubt but even at the end of the movie her powers didnt seem good enough to defeat elsa. It is also seriously worth mentioning again that elsa had to hide her powers for years when Pepa was given thanks for her powers and was told to grow them... yet still failed to figure them out after even longer than elsa was locked away

[@raebaby4600]

@@arielvaldez1050 i misread the not in control part as in control but the last part of my comment still stands

[@macmay3042]

Hailstorm: I don't think she did that on purpose, I think the whole point was, it was just what her emotions expressed. The lesson for Pepa (and Abuela) to learn wasn't "here's how Pepa can just do whatever she wants." It was "Learn to celebrate whatever Pepa's powers whip up because they are an expression of her authentic self." So at that moment her soul wanted to express itself as a hailstorm. This didn't bother Luisa, and Pepa and Felix decided to rejoice in it instead of fighting it.

[@Suprixia]

I think it was be really fun to do a madrigal family battle royale

[@shaunawidding8259]

How did Peppa create a hurricane in a remote, mountain surrounded village? Hurricanes need the ocean or at least some large amount of warm water to form…that’s why they loose energy when they hit land. So how could Peppa have made a hurricane in an isolated mountain village?

[@anonymouscreature9483]

I don't know, a lot of rain maybe? It honestly doesn't make sense, maybe they simply use the wrong word by mistake and maybe it sound better in the songs?

[@allisondavis2475]

First of all, probably an exaggeration for thier point and yes, bc it fit in the song better Second as Jackie said, she is controlling the weather and forming its required elements, so no it probably didn't last long but I fee like she could form the start of it.

[@darthtigris2783]

I’m loving all the new content the Carlin Brothers are coming up with. It’s a breath of fresh air that I didn’t know I needed.

[@shadowmarauder6033]

How about Ultron vs Mewtwo, humanity’s greatest weapons?

[@brandibastian4193]

Elsa can use her ice powers in a number of way Peppa just makes the sky her mood ring XD

[@laurenholt5076]

How about Mulan vs Luisa or isbella

[@O._its._dre08]

Elsa can just shoot pepa’s heart like in frozen, Battle over

[@lahlybird895]

No because she has like a thousand people who truly love her who would be able to save her

[@Mysic97]

I'm sorry but I will not stand for the insinuation that Felix doesn't do at least two dozen things a day that qualify as an act of true love. She'd be cured before she knew what hit her. Shooting her head would be incredibly effective, though.

[@hannahmiller09]

What about Elsa and Frozone, their powers are similar but also different

[@balrighty3523]

Elsa is straight up a powerhouse over Frozone, but I think he gives a better accounting of himself than most people think. Her powers aren't environmentally different while his are, but he has ammo for his powers anytime she uses her's. Elsa can only deny Frozone water for his ice powers by not using her's, and I have to think he can handle unarmed melee better than she can. She also has a wider array of powers at her disposal (especially creating life), but I also have to think he's faced enough varieties of bad guys that he can leverage his more limited ice powers effectively. We know he's faster (she catches a crossbow bolt whereas he freezes a bullet in midair). I think her best advantage is the magic blasts to the body, but the most dangerous one of those is a shot to the heart, and that didn't kill Anna immediately, so Frozone would have a chance of stopping her before freezing solid (although he might just be immune to that, anyway). And there's the X factor: heroes in the Incredibles know to take advantage of when the villain monologues and Elsa started doing that all alone on a mountaintop with music. The soaring beautiful music will play, Elsa will burst into song, and Frozone would have at least that opening.

[@robinarmstrong685]

Counterpoint: Elsa does not actually conquor the ocean, but needs to get a ride from the (pooka? The water horse).

[@LaXja-eh3dt]

At the end of the second movie she has the whole ocean frozen though

[@haileym5912]

prior to watching the video: I think Elsa is more powerful than Pepa because even if Pepa can overpower her in a fight (like say sun melting ice) but Elsa can create LIFE with Olaf and Marshmallow and the Snowgies whereas there is no evidence Pepa can

[@rossjones8656]

Elsa can create ice that can't be melted.

[@samanthaworthen1845]

Day 33 of asking supercarlinbrothers to please bring back google auto fill videos!

[@Nurichiri]

You made me realize a parallel between Elsa and Bruno. Both stifled their powers for at least a decade under the belief that using them hurt people. If Elsa is allowed to call on the other spirits then Pepa should be allowed to call on her family and that might level the playing field a bit, even with just four. Luisa, who can take on armies, is a given. Every good army needs a healer, so that's Julieta. Isabela's power's over plants are terrifying and Camilo can screw with Elsa by changing to Anna.

[@ellawissa]

Still, they are humans. Elsa could just potentially freeze them all alive. Nobody in Encanto is invincible

[@lilac3266]

@@ellawissa nobody in frozen is invincible either I think pepa has potential to do some real damage. She has control of ALL the weather: tornadoes, hurricanes, cyclones, extreme heat, sandstorms

[@jessesass6028]

@@lilac3266 earthquakes, humidity. she could win by attrition lol.

[@lilac3266]

@@jessesass6028 omg I didn’t think of earthquakes does that include tsunamis?

[@ellawissa]

@@lilac3266 In fact - quite the opposide. In Frozen to we get evidence, that Elsa is not a human in the way that she can outlive the extreme cold of Atohallen and she IS the 5th spirit itself.

[@balrighty3523]

I'd like to know what ya'll think about ATLA Kitara's chances. Specifically, could she bend Elsa's creations (her static iceforms, the living ones like Olaf, the dress made of ice)? Would she have to melt them first? Does her (I would have to think) greater battlefield experience give her an edge? Does she have to resort to bloodbending? And could her water-healing cure Elsa's magic bolts to the heart? Or would the comparison need to be Aang or Korra?

[@neocat81]

i think that Katara could certainly counter Elsa. but she would go in as innocent and trusting as a puppy.

[@SgtSupaman]

Water benders are shown bending ice in the show, so, yes, Katara could use Elsa's ice against her. Even the living creations (like Olaf) wouldn't be immune given that water benders can control living beings with blood bending, so they could absolutely control creatures made of snow.

[@bangerxshane]

ATLA's power system lacks in scale. Elsa can freeze entire landscapes. Bending on that scale requires either the Avatar State or Sozin's Comet.

[@balrighty3523]

@Banger X Shane Why would that be an issue? The contest isn't "Who can apply their power to the largest scale?", it's "Who wins in a versus battle?" Katara's doesn't need to be able to affect as large a region as Elsa as long as she can still do things against Elsa herself. At most, she needs to be able to survive Elsa's larger scale abilities (which would be freezing a large region and making a large army). She's a waterbender who was raised in the South Pole who has fought large groups of bad guys who weren't made of water, so I think she's covered. Heck, I think Sokka could handle Elsa's larger-scale abilities.

[@jonathanclark2160]

Awesome! Now Elsa vs Darth Vader or Darth Vader vs Thanos.

[@shanelocsin9906]

7:28 According to the book A Sister More Like Me, Elsa studied geometry in her room all these years. She loves it and she used her knowledge in creating her ice palace. ❄

[@firemaker282]

While I agree that Elsa ultimately wins, I disagree with how easily she wins. I think the biggest thing holding Peppa back is training. If Peppa spent even just a little while training her powers specifically for combat I'm fairly certain she would wipe the floor with Elsa.

[@lilac3266]

agreed pepa was forced to suppress her powers WAYYY longer

[@georgiancountryball202]

Well maybe she would not wipe the floor with her considering Elsa is a semi immortal being that as a soul of an element has a connection to the other souls of the elements it’s an innate connection with them so I believe if peppa had the proper training to MASTER her powers then sure she might win low difficulty

[@RyanHaney55]

I like the idea of a VS. series and hope there is eventually a playlist on this channel.

[@tgbluewolf]

After accidentally hitting Anna in the head, you could say that Elsa was ice-olated 3:47

[@troperhghar9898]

Lets hear it for Frozen 3: Elsa goes to war

[@lavendernightshade5631]

to find Samantha

[@troperhghar9898]

@@lavendernightshade5631 who?

[@Kelarys]

I want frozen 3 to be the reveal that the trolls were evil and Hans was set up, but that's a little high concept for a kids movie, so it will stay in the realms of fanfiction

[@troperhghar9898]

@@Kelarys I dont support that theory in the slightest but I do want to see hans come back in frozen 3 with an army to take Arrendale ... Only for Elsa to destroy him and his warships with a flick of her wrist

[@christineapplegate4873]

I'm just going to say now, Elsa would win hands-down! She has perfect control, Pepa not so much

[@timothyreaddean3474]

Haven’t watched the video yet, but when I got the notification earlier, all I could think of at first was Elsa vs Peppa Pig😂 imagine them squaring up

[@aaronkendall2706]

Of course Elsa wins. She's been in more movies. It's the same principal as when Spider-Man ran rings around the Xmen during that brief skirmish in Secret Wars and all they could do was complain about how they were somehow off their game. (This was waaaaay back in the 80s, and Spider-Man had at least three, maybe even five comic books he was starring in.) ☺

[@aaronkendall2706]

*principle

[@christopherdunn3553]

The brothers just went all “Death Battle!” on Disney, and I’m about it 😎 #TeamElsa

[@DavidRay39]

Just watched Encanto yesterday. I'm partial to Pepa at this point.

[@moncey1120]

If the other elements can help Elsa, can't the other Madrigals help Pepa?

[@addictedtoJB]

Ummmmm...I think you missed something. The only element helping Elsa is ice. J's argument is that we've seen Elsa conquer those elements before.

[@moncey1120]

@@addictedtoJB he said that she could call them to help her

[@moncey1120]

@@addictedtoJB 13:00

[@ur0nlif3sup0rt]

The other madrigals really wouldn’t be much help at all

[@TheTideKing004]

Pepa could just summon a massive lightning storm to just vapourize else and her ice. Easy next question

[@LaXja-eh3dt]

Peppa can’t summon anything, her emotions do and you can’t just decide to be happy or whatever. Elsa’s emotions are not as relevant to her powers as pepas are. She lost control while being scared but she learned to control no matter her emotions, while pepas powers are quite literally only responding to her emotions. There is no learning to control that. Also Elsa could just send one spark of ice towards the candle and none of the madrigals would be able to do anything. Next

[@erinfaye2780]

On that last comment, we know all it takes to reverse, "any touch of Elsa's magic at all" is an act of true love. I think Pepa with her loving husband and family is pretty much immune/can be healed quickly and easily enough.

[@LaXja-eh3dt]

Elsa need love to thaw HER powers. No one else can just feel loved and do that lol

[@Freyalise50]

additionally Peppa isn't immune to her own powers. she starts a hurricane? she's getting blown away

[@yubelious5584]

The Frozen sequel was absolute horror. Elsa is a devastating monster to be reckoned with. Probably the most dangerous villain in Disney history. In a one on one fight, she'd probably hold back. Maybe let her opponent live and get bored of them. But she could invade Casita, with maybe a few minions, even with the entire familia present. And once Gale discovers the candle, it's all over.

[@thewordslinger1181]

Imagining the Encanto turning into a Punk Hazard-esque half desert half arctic after the fight

[@janpokorny7698]

*Inhales, Southern accent It's time for a DEATH BATTLEEEEEE!

[@parkersmith7478]

I very much approve of this content and would love to see more of it.

[@johnjacobjingleheimerschmi6655]

You know what you could have just ended the episode just by saying, she could just do what she did to Anna at the beginning of the movie, but I appreciate the entire spectrum of their power difference being displayed.

[@Bonzu_Pip]

Family Madrigal vs. the Incredibles Family

[@tobyfroerer4655]

these are great you need to keep doing them

[@kellymun6757]

Besides, Pepa is still human. How long would she be able to survive under unbearably hot weather? Great video by the way!

[@coolnerdlll6053]

Think about this. If Pepa controls all weather, that includes hurricanes, tornadoes and tsunamis. Assuming Elsa doesn't know what's coming, any of those would kill her instantly without Pepa even showing up. Even the element spirits wouldn't be much help.

[@LaXja-eh3dt]

Why would any of that kill her? All these things literally did not kill her before.

[@leohuddle7994]

My one thought, if Elsa can call upon Gale and all the other elements, why can't Pepa call upon the rest of her families, I could see Elsa beat Peppa alone but Elsa VS every single Madrigal? That is a bit more of a struggle. She could probably still win, but it would be harder.

[@ur0nlif3sup0rt]

The rest of the family’s powers aren’t really helpful against Elsa’s the only one that might be helpful Luisa’s but that’s about it

[@jacintacapelety9600]

"You know what's not survivable? ANY touch of Elsa's powers!" Proceeds to show a clip of somehow who survived Elsa's powers (albeit with help).

[@pablosuarez7602]

When I lived in Colombia, hail was tons of tiny little dots. Not like the hail and hail damage you get here in the US. It's akin to snow, and it a treat to get it

[@Maniac4Bricks]

7:32 my guess is, like Frozone, she used her powers to help her sprint or glide up the mountain faster

[@spanktank_1735]

Let's settle it once and for all, Dumbledore vs Gandolf...

[@jhardman1876]

I mean, since Pepa did have children, she is definitely also capable of creating life...

[@GoldenRoseSkies]

Not Reeeallly the same thing

[@lavendernightshade5631]

lol,but she needed help to make kids meanwhile Elsa created life all on her own.

[@dkerwood1]

I think we've been misunderstanding Elsa's powers all along. She doesn't have ice powers. She has water and heat manipulation, straight up telekinesis that occasionally manifests as air bending, matter transmutation, and can create life (as well as some level of magical influence on human life- notice Anna doesn't get frostbite or other related cold injuries from Elsa's blast). As the fifth element, it makes more sense that she would have dominion over the other four. Heat and water are easy- remember she manipulates the liquid water on the ship before turning it into an ice sculpture memory. Wind is also pretty clear as Elsa blows ice and snow around at will. So what about earth? And why does everything manifest as ice? It's because of Elsa's childhood trauma with Anna. Her powers first manifested as ice manipulation, but after injuring her sister and the ensuing decade of isolation and guilt, Elsa has put a mental block on full control of her abilities. When she is able, I believe that her abilities will extend to earth/stone... After all, are the rock monsters really unlike Olaf or Marshmallow?

[@sovereign2989]

Nope its ice magic. It's not that deep. Also papa's powers are far greater they encompass all of Elsa's and then some the only thing is that she cant control them. Weather is not just on earth there is space or cosmic weather and that is a whole can of worms. Solar flares, meteor storms, geomagnetic storms, solar wind...etc. it's such a broad power that it is impossible to fully comprehend how large an ability it is.

[@dkerwood1]

@@sovereign2989 In Frozen 2, Elsa levitates liquid water droplets in the crashed ship. That's not an ice power. In Frozen 1, she hits Anna in the head with her powers, but Anna doesn't freeze or take any injuries associated with frostbite or hypothermia. In fact, the danger is said to be the memory of the magic, which is why Anna is restored when the memory is removed. This has nothing to do with ice. When she hits Anna in the chest, she doesn't actually freeze; instead, she TRANSFORMS into ice. This is far beyond "ice powers," at least as presented by Frozone in The Incredibles or Iceman in the X-Men. Instead, it's a magical timebomb that ends with transmutation of cloth, leather, hair, flesh, and bone to solid ice. It's sophisticated magic that manifests as ice. Then, of course, we have the fact that she creates sentient life. Unless Olaf, et al, are just sophisticated puppets (which would require Elsa's subconscious to project itself across significant distances), that's not really "ice powers" any more than Pinocchio's Blue Fairy has "wood powers".

[@izzysmith105]

That Thor clip is awesome! Loved that.

[@thekueken]

I loooove the ripping on Elsa's stamina XD What *was* she doing in her room all those years? ...apparently climbing the walls, literally, considering those parcours skills of hers...

[@amicban]

I want a part two/ response video from Death Battle. Just so we can see if the math adds up. Love this video concept though

[@rheabruen]

there at the end I thought you said "anna had a sled...and a guy!" not "guide" and it cracked me up 😂

[@milessaxton]

I’d bring up weather report but I don’t think I’d get over the fact he made it rain frogs that one time

[@spencerhiginbotham7538]

She probably just left behind a recording of herself that said, "Go away, Anna" on loop.

[@BlueJay2]

6:00 Oh my gosh I was dying I request a full SuperCarlinBrothers cover of the Immigrant Song please 🤣

[@Kiarean]

Yeah, for battle you'd definitely want Else. Pepa does better in more rural setting (making it rain on the crops and such). As for the lightning and those noting it speed - the lightning may be fast, but Pepa still has to invoke it, which causes a certain minimum use time Elsa could react to. If there's one area Pepa might accel at in combat if she could control it properly, it'd be as a Delta Strike to end a fight before someone even becomes aware of her.

[@SgtSupaman]

Yeah, Elsa beats Pepa easily, but mostly because Elsa is combat ready. Storm (which is basically what Pepa could potentially become) would sweep Elsa. Elsa vs Iceman would be an interesting fight.

[@LaXja-eh3dt]

Pepa would never become storm because there’s no controlling her powers. It’s always just her emotions that make the weather and you can’t just decide to be happy or mad or whatever. Also her powers seem to have very little range. While Elsa in the end of the second movie hast the whole ocean frozen. I think at that point she could put the whole world in an entire winter if she wanted to.

[@gryphonsong4082]

The nature of their powers are magical, except for Iceman’s and Storm’s. Though the end result is similar, it matters in how to handle it. If you negate the magical source, then you can beat them. Storm/Iceman’s come from within, so just tiring them out from overuse is generally a long but provable tactic. Iceman would loose btw. Even though he’s limited only to imagination and knowledge of how something works, he can only have so many objects around (Marvels Book of Powers). Elsa can SNEEEZE and get more done with the minis in shear numbers. Storm is more of a match, though might stalemate on the weather changes. She’s better off using lightening for a quick victory and staying faaar away with AOE.

[@BigGoronSword]

Super Carlin Bro video idea: just like your Pixar theory, maybe try and see if all the Studio Ghibli movies are connected (yes, I know some movies are based off of books, but let's have fun anyways)

[@nisa18508]

BUT what if the battle ends up being a dance battle?? Pretty common in movies. Elsa would have Anna and Kristoff on her side and unless Kristoff has some secret talent for dancing, Elsa's team has no chance. Pepa on the other hand has her family. The Madrigal seems to be a family of dancers! Pepa wins :)

[@wompusslompus5424]

The trolls in Frozen: "good thing you missed her heart" Also the trolls in Frozen: we'll just help you replicate the emotional damage to her heart by visually misleading the family with our advice.

[@rebeccawilliams1334]

Don’t forget about the little brothers from the Christmas short!

[@ugly-duckling123]

11:20 Um... What about the giant hoard of Snowgies she created (when she was sick in *Frozen Fever* ) who are now living with Marshmallow?

[@n0dr0gs49]

Could Elsa be the Blue Fairy (Pinocchio) and the Fairy Godmother (Cinderella)? All three wear blue, Olaf's arms are wood so she can animate wood, and her clothing change makes it seem she can transform items.

[@ChronoXShadow]

Elsa also froze the atmosphere(maybe? Something happened to the blizzard.) when Hanz told her that Anna died.

[@neomehollow1391]

I hear what you're saying, however water is a conductive I could see lightning severely harming Elsa even if it was unintentional

[@derekrudd3233]

1. The dragons from Raya vs. Elsa. Firs the dragons, individually (where I think else would win) and then Elsa vs. The army of dragons at the end. 2. This is exploring a new area, but the dragons from Raya vs. The dragons from How To Train Your Dragon

[@Thomas_H._Smith]

I wanna see this again, but with Maui vs Camilo, or Julieta vs Rapunzel, or or Te Fiti vs Isabela.

[@user-bs2ds9vm2m]

Adding onto what they said about lightning being survivable, Camilo gets hit by it and survives

[@ryukiravenwing8530]

Not at the end yet: but my thought is initially Elsa will whip Peppa until the point that her power is too much, she loses control of it and it endangers Peppa's family in some way. Than she'll show her true powers to counteract Elsa's. Ice can only stand up to so much sun and heat

[@LaXja-eh3dt]

nah Elsa’s ice can stand up to anything, especially at the end of frozen II. But actually all she would have to do is send one spike of ice to the candle lol

[@chadanujp.5011]

If they have cross path I wonder if how that would go... I hope they're friends. It would be a fascinating interactions for sure.

[@alexd8532]

What about Elsa and all the madrigals against Wanda waximoff when she is at her most powerful state

[@IzukuMidoriya38855]

What a battle that would be! I just hope that Antonio isn't involved. He is legit five years old.

[@mylespope6203]

Peppa definitely has stronger potential but Elsa would win in a fight 9/10 because she can actually control her powers while Peppa can't at all. It's like blindfolding someone and giving them a shotgun that only goes off randomly and giving someone else a pistol, the pistol will win even though the shotgun has more power.

[@DarkChaos1986]

Powerscaling Disney movies was not something that I was waiting for... Please continue...

[@stevenmartorana1970]

Stitch vs Mr. Incredible Jafar vs Ian Lightfoot

[@Zoogore6777]

Icing on the cake…You also forgot the Snowgies Elsa can also make. They could pose a chaotic distraction.😉

[@Rocio.Suarez]

Pepa's mood affects wheater so if she doesn't control her emotions it will be bad, it seems that this character is pretty moody Elsa can create life, fight other elements, control her own element (she's the element lol) since she started controlling herself something that Pepa is struggling to do during the entire film!

[@danieloconnell695]

If you’re adding the other 4 spirits, you have to add at least casita if not the family. Completely agree though on end result.

[@chrystalchristie1515]

@supercarlinbrothers giving us theories we didn’t know we needed 😊

[@gracewiley3975]

What about Camilo vs Ursula? They both exhibit shapeshifting abilities

[@gracewiley3975]

How far can Camilo’s powers go? Can he become giant like Ursula did?

[@taygang8068]

Elsa even accidentally creates life in one of the shorts where she literally sneezed little snow babies out

[@kimberlysymonds7517]

When you spliced the songs together you should of did Pipa: we don’t talk about…. Elsa: Let it go!😊

[@thatonepossum5766]

Elsa as a peloton instructor is something I never knew I needed.