Why does Switzerland have SO MANY guns?

Рет қаралды 12,170

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 97

@alpenjon 23 күн бұрын

Key difference: We in Switzerland are if only minimally involved in wars (peacekeeping, black ops), so the psychological trauma, glorification of violence and dehumanization of "enemies" is not happening. Compare this to nations that have been in wars for 60+ years, and it becomes evident that some aspects of this will spill over into civil society. I hear so many foreigners talking about reasons that make countries like Switzerland special, but foreign policy / being a war state is often overlooked.

@crabethenight8092 Ай бұрын

hey, I'm swiss, sniper in the military and was finalist at the 300m competition in switzerland. At the age of 15, every man or women receives a letter from the army saying they can follow a 1 year shooting training. This is a big factor as in why so many swiss like shooting, from our early age we are invited to, and for free. Plus, a lot of families have very traditional values. For me, i started shooting competition at 12 years old.

@derraucherhase123 Ай бұрын

geile siech

@flx0o0o0 29 күн бұрын

Well I didn‘t get that letter…

@killian954 29 күн бұрын

@@flx0o0o0 in most Cantons it is not the army that sends the letter but the local shooting range, if they have the facilities to train young people; sometimes, even if they have the facilities they don't send the letter and you can only enter if you know someone that shoots there. It is called "Jungschützen (DE)" or "Jeune tireurs (FR)" and you can do it from 15yo to 20yo. Hope it helps !

@crabethenight8092 29 күн бұрын

@@killian954 yeees, i checked it up and it is indeed the canton's association that sends the letter.

@crabethenight8092 29 күн бұрын

@@derraucherhase123 meaning?

@SaltTM 29 күн бұрын

Anytime a person from a non gun-country comes to switzerland and does a report it usually does leave a bad mark. Except this one. We have 0 to none gun violence even though our guns are spread widely. Congrats!

@rob9528 16 күн бұрын

Guns are not spread widely in switzerland stop actin like it's the Usa you wished your country was tough but it's not.

@petergaskin1811 15 күн бұрын

The Swiss have more guns per capita than any Country in the World apart from the US. They just don't acquire them for personal defence. So they are not frightened all the time. They are, from the perspective of the UK, fairly lightly regulated, but the penalties for breaking the regulations are extremely serious.

@jessetorres8738 Ай бұрын

Trivia note: The U.S. game show The Amazing Race has been on for 36 Seasons, & they have been to Switzerland for 8 of them; 3, 14, 18, 22, 24, 28, 31, & 33.

@connorsharpless3997 Ай бұрын

If only Americans could have the same level of respect for firearms as the Swiss seem to. Not to say that there aren't a lot of Americans who take gun safety very seriously. But there are also a lot of people who think theyre Clint Eastwood...

@enentr Ай бұрын

@@connorsharpless3997 it seemed to us that it’s possibly a gun “right” versus gun “duty” narrative! That’s why the Swiss case is so interesting!

@mysterioanonymous3206 Ай бұрын

That's precisely it. And I'm a swiss gun owner btw. We have a totally different gun culture. No one here is expecting or training to shoot someone irl, unlike the US where people just wait for someone to break I nso they can pop someone legally. The mindset it's completely the opposite. Just showing that intent publicly would get you a police visit real quick, and yes, they'd take your guns 100%.

@dunbar555 Ай бұрын

@@mysterioanonymous3206 "No one here is training to shoot someone irl" i am swiss and i can tell you not only you are wrong, but you are very wrong. don't talk about things you dont know

@dunbar555 Ай бұрын

@@enentr We as swiss have gun RIGHTs as well. MANY more guns are privately owned than military issued. WAY MORE

@moritzebert6118 29 күн бұрын

@@dunbar555doch er het recht

@jcc1184 29 күн бұрын

Tellement fier de mon pays ! Vive la Suisse 🇨🇭

@nouhailaamari3204 Ай бұрын

Super interesting topic as always !

@enentr Ай бұрын

Thank you for watching!

@RenanEdu123 25 күн бұрын

Switzerland is the heaven on earth

@huexley 27 күн бұрын

Its also very easy to learn and train in almost cities. Shooting range, private schools, you name it.

@volcomny Ай бұрын

We also keep our pistol some millitaire

@MumieVideo Ай бұрын

i am also in the millitary i am a Radio specialist for the Military intelligence Service :)

@ReekohMcZero 29 күн бұрын

I am sorry, but this report does not answer the question of why there are so many firearms in Switzerland. It only deals with the storage of the weapon at home, even though some people who have completed their military obligation do not keep their weapon afterwards, and many people only keep their weapon as a souvenir without being used or even abandoned in a cellar or attic. It is also worth mentioning that 300m shooting ranges are not open to non-ordinance weapons, and their attendance is decreasing, whereas that of recreational and tactical shooting ranges is increasing. If you come across a Swiss person returning from a shooting range, it is more likely that he has an AR-15 or an AKM in his bag than a SIG550. The reason why there are so many weapons in Switzerland (and I should point out that in addition to being a shooter in Switzerland, I am also a member of ProTell) is the particularly liberal legislation that Switzerland has known, in particular until the tightening of 1997, then that of 2008. A time when the importation and alienation of firearms was subject to very light regulations. We must also not forget the number of hunters who own firearms solely for hunting, as well as collectors who own firearms but do not use them. The truth is that we do not have formal statistics in Switzerland on the number of firearms in circulation, their type, their use, etc. We too simply reduce these numbers to military and sporting weapons, we too simply reduce the rigor and supposed education of the Swiss on weapons to the use of military and sporting weapons. This image of Epinal is false.

@enentr 29 күн бұрын

Hi! Thanks for your comment! For this piece, we made a choice to focus more on gun culture rather than gun ownership. What you’re saying is true and interesting, we decided not to include it as the tightening of the restrictions in ‘97 and then more recently to abide to EU demands would have demanded a long time to explain - we chose to focus on the culture instead! Thank you for expanding 🙏

@SwissBloke 26 күн бұрын

Actually there are no regulations that say the 300m ranges that ban the use of non-ordinance rifles. It's just that most ranges are run by old fudds that think the Verzeichnis der bewilligten Hilfsmittel applies to regular range practice even though it's only for military-related events

@dnhug Күн бұрын

This story again?

@SwissBloke 26 күн бұрын

Kinda sad I hear (and read on the article) things that I corrected with the law on hand when Elena asked about it online... also I see that she was in Geneva so the interview we were supposed to do online could have been done in person (when in fact it was never done entirely as I was kinda ghosted)

@enentr 26 күн бұрын

@@SwissBloke Hi - all the info in this piece has been supported in research and writing by Swiss neutrality experts and history professors. We’d be glad to clear up any info that seems incorrect to you!

@SwissBloke 26 күн бұрын

@enentr not to be disrespectful but what do Swiss neutrality experts and history professors have to do with that? Now, first of all, it is not mandatory for soldiers to store their issued weapon at home as per art. 5 VPAA, unlike what's said nor is it mandatory to serve armed (section 6 VMDP). Also, as per numbers provided by the army (and posted in the thread Elena made on Reddit), barely the majority of men do serve: 61.6% are deemed fit, 86% choose to serve -> 53%. Including those who switch during and after ER we're down 74% so 46% overall I've also provided, not to her directly, but in the same thread, numbers from the government and the army in regards to how many permits are issued for former-issued gun VS how many are for "regular" purchases (military acquisitions are outnumbered by a factor of 15:1 to 40:1) which give clear indicators that the gun culture isn't because of the army I also linked to a study published at the end of last year by the Zurich University of Applied Sciences on what is owned by whom which could have contributed to the part where she says we don't know anything about it And, well, again, it's a bit of a shame that the interview we planned fell to the side, even when I contacted her again And nota bene for the article: the formulation "The vast majority of guns in Switzerland are owned by professional shooters, either for sports or hunting and by people in the army" is dubious as sport shooting and hunting aren't professional occupations (except for a very select part of hunters) and the fact army-issued weapons aren't owned by the soldiers. Also regarding "It’s important to note that soldiers don’t own or keep any ammunition.", it's simply that soldiers aren't issued ammo to get home with, they can legally own and get home with ammo just like everyone else

@enentr 26 күн бұрын

@ thanks for this, apologies if you felt the interview fell through but by the time you got back to us we already had conducted interviews with other experts to support our research and we were already filming. It was simply a matter of timing. None of what you highlighted goes to show wrongful data provided in this piece (except for the fact that it’s not mandatory to serve armed, which is true, and we never say otherwise). Of course, not the majority of civilian-owned armed are military. But there’s a reason we didn’t go into gun purchases and acquisition, and that’s because a) we didn’t want to talk ownership, but culture. Going into the permit issue would have opened a need for very extensive explanation, which we felt wasn’t the point for us on this occasion. B) the data isn’t available, the last truly extensive research is from before the new regulations of 2019 so it’d have made it even harder. Unfortunately video explainers like these can’t be as nuanced as we often hope they could, time is a constraint, it can be frustrating for us too! Thanks a million for the info and clarification, it can be very helpful for anyone wanting to expand more on the topic! This piece is simply an overall view for those who didn’t know much about it.

@Wollerz Ай бұрын

Their's a thing called ''hollyday passport'' and you can do a lot of different types activities,visits, learn a new sport or skill. SOme of these activitis are with the army

@anthonyhickman6391 Ай бұрын

I wanna move to the Alps

@lordofabanshee6791 29 күн бұрын

With this attitude, You're welcome brother. CREDE ET AUDE

@rob9528 16 күн бұрын

Loser

@dunbar555 Ай бұрын

because we CAN and have the right to

@flx0o0o0 29 күн бұрын

weird comment

@rob9528 16 күн бұрын

Wannabe tough guy

@dunbar555 15 күн бұрын

@ the weaklings speaking

@chmuen4832 29 күн бұрын

How about over 150 Years of peace and Freedom! Adolf Hitler would have been never be posible in switz becouse of a real chare of power between the people and the government.

@manyman7827 Ай бұрын

Non avevo idea che una persona deve tenere l'arma anche dopo il servizio di leva

@MatteoZappa Ай бұрын

In realtà non è obbligato, un cittadino svizzero non in servizio può decidere di tenere l'arma a casa oppure di depositarla in un centro logistico dell'esercito. Una volta terminato il servizio può decidere di acquistare l'arma presentando il permesso di acquisto armi.

@Braun30 29 күн бұрын

L'acquisto dopo gli obblighi di servizio avviene con regolare richiesta come in caso di acquisto di arma. L'arma viene demilitarizzata, cioè viene rimosso ogni meccanismo che permette il tiro a raffica. La cessione, in dono o vendita, di tale arma sottostà all'ottenimento del permesso di acquisto da parte del compratore.

@mnk9073 29 күн бұрын

Switzerland is the antithesis to the US: In Switzerland a rifle is first a sport equipment and later a responsibility to defend the motherland with. In the US it's a fetish, a means of compensating percieved inadequacies and a problem solver. Switzerland literally hands you a rifle when you join a shooting association as a teenager and later when you start your military service but Switzerland makes it a point to drill responsibility and safety into you and also has a very close eye on you and the slightest evidence to irresponsible actions or dangerous ideas will have that rifle immediately removed from your hands. We had a guy in our platoon who muttered something about "imagine those targets are refugees" under his breath, instructor heard him, immediately took his rifle, gave him the dressing down of a lifetime and he was unceremoniously kicked out of the army the very next day and no doubt got the occasional visit from the nice men in the unmarked cars in the years to come.

@roughiness 27 күн бұрын

Ah yes, everone in the US buys a gun solely because they are inadequate. Self defense, sport shooting or simply having an interest in firearms is non exist and everyone just wants to compensate. That is so dumb and you have most likely based that opinion solely on what you see in the media.