Ep 253 - How One Man's Greed Shook India's Last Great Empire | Dr. Uday S Kulkarni (Author)

[@debashishbramha]

I"m a Bengali from Calcutta.I studied in Calcutta University,though I studied Finance and Mathematics,I have deep love for History. Actually in Calcutta University,Sir Jadunath Sarkar was a great and great scholar student and Prof of Calcutta University long time back. A renowned Indian historian and scholar. He was most distinguished historians of medieval India. Sarkar's work on the decline of the Mughal Empire and the rise of Maratha power remains influential in Indian history. The Marathas indeed faced a historic defeat in the Third Battle of Panipat on January 14, 1761, against the Afghan king Ahmad Shah Abdali (Durrani), he got the permission from the Ottomans,very few Historian knew it . This battle was a turning point in Indian history, weakening the Maratha Empire and setting the stage for British colonial dominance. MARATHAS LOST IN THE ANGLO -MARATHA WAR. Before the battle, the Marathas sought alliances with various regional powers, including the Jats, Rajputs, and Sikhs, to counter Abdali's forces. However, these groups, wary of Maratha expansion and due to their own regional concerns, refrained from joining the Maratha cause. The lack of support isolated the Marathas, making their defeat in the battle even more decisive.HINDUS WERE DIVIDED AND STILL TODAY THEY ARE DIVIDED. This intense conflict resulted in tremendous casualties, marking it as one of the largest and bloodiest battles fought in the 18th century. The Marathas' defeat drastically weakened their influence in northern India, enabling British forces to strengthen their hold on the Indian subcontinent.THE MARATHAS ARE THE BRAVEST PEOPLE IN INDIA. Kulkarni Sir,a great knowledgeable person. Thanks Sir.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do subscribe to this channel for similar content and also share this episode with your friends and family.

[@ubuntuber1619]

💁🏽‍♂️🐟➰🙋🏻‍♂️ "enjoy!"

[@srivsnow4990]

Marathas were also very headstrong and not strategic thinkers! They were also seen invaders by the common masses because they looted too much to common folks. That is the main reason they had to fight main battles alone, without support of the people around, and without supply lines. Defeat of Panipat is also because their supply lines were cut, and locals kings did not ally with the Marathas! Another issue was, they had a big contingent of old,women,children who were piggybacking to go to pilgrimage in North India! * All these issues and infighting, caused their downfall. * Sikhs on the other hand, helped EIC during Gadar, and never found the British when they were strong ... * Unity is strength, technology is strength, stealth/cunning-ness is strength - which were ALL not used when EIC fought these post mughal "semi" powers of Hindustan. * And that's why, now I have to live in NJ ! * Luv4rmNJ *

[@dharmayodha4436]

Also read about Noakhali and direct action day

[@jsm3692]

Hindus are divided...: On one thing they are 'united': loot, Vasooli, paisa pisa paisa .. Marathas were leaders of loot loot loot, vasooli vasooli vasooli, paisa paisa paisa, leading to the present day sobriquet: Lochlach Rao Vasoolikar? Ask Sharadbhau, Ajitdadaji, UddhavSahebji, Raja Raj Sahebji 'Hindu Samrat' Bala SAHEBji et C.

[@arvindkla]

What a surprise....we served on the same Indian Naval Ship. What a fantastic and intelligent person. He is a very nice person and a good singer.

[@ckcariappa]

Indeed! (Didn't know about the singing! 😊) Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@jitendivgi2761]

Dr Uday Kulkarni continues the glorious intellectual heritage of Maharashtra established by such scholars as Rajwade, Parasnis, Sardesai, Sarkar, Bhatkhande, Ratanjankar who came from outside the field to lay the foundation of research into our cultural heritage. By writing and publishing in English, Dr Kulkarni has done the country a huge service. I hope he gets the success and recognition that he richly deserves. The Marathas were the last people of India to taste political and economic power. Their history must be understood to appreciate where modern India has come from.

[@ckcariappa]

Glad you liked it! Thanks for watching, do share this channel and content with your friends!

[@jsm3692]

The Marathas perished because they turned their back on Modernity.

[@jitendivgi2761]

@@jsm3692 my reading of history is a little more nuanced. The rapaciousness of the BEIC meant that the Indian subcontinent was convulsed with too much conflict. Leaders like Ahilya Devi and Mahadji Shinde, if allowed a few more years of peace, could have changed things around. Mahadji Shinde was probably the wisest of all the Maratha potentates after Shivaji, Baji Rao Peshwa, and Madhav Rao Peshwa. He eclectically chose the best of European inputs to improve his administration of North India from his base in Gwalior. As long he was around, the British were kept confined to a smaller role as his military power more than matched that of the British. In the ultimate analysis, Britain's trajectory was on a sharper rise compared to that of India and eventually succeeded in overwhelming India. But Britain destroyed India's well being within 150 years and reduced the subcontinent to a state to penury and misery. The part of India that the Marathas brought under their control became the modern Republic of India, and the parts they lost to the Afghans and the British became Bangladesh and Pakistan. If it weren't for the Marathas, the Radcliff line would have run along the entire length of the Grand Trunk Road south of the Yamuna from Punjab to Bengal and modern India would have been limited only to the peninsular portion of India.

[@jitendivgi2761]

@@jsm3692 my reading of history is a little more nuanced. The rapaciousness of the BEIC meant that the Indian subcontinent was convulsed with too much conflict. Leaders like Ahilya Devi and Mahadji Shinde, if allowed a few more years of peace, could have changed things around. Mahadji Shinde was probably the wisest of all the Maratha potentates after Shivaji, Baji Rao Peshwa, and Madhav Rao Peshwa. He eclectically chose the best of European inputs to improve his administration of North India from his base in Gwalior. As long he was around, the British were kept confined to a smaller role as his military power more than matched that of the British. In the ultimate analysis, Britain's trajectory was on a sharper rise compared to that of India and eventually succeeded in overwhelming India. But Britain destroyed India's well being within 150 years and reduced the subcontinent to a state to penury and misery. The part of India that the Marathas brought under their control became the modern Republic of India, and the parts they lost to the Afghans and the British became Bangladesh and Pakistan. If it weren't for the Marathas, the Radcliff line would have run along the entire length of the Grand Trunk Road south of the Yamuna from Punjab to Bengal and modern India would have been limited only to the peninsular portion of India.

[@ckcariappa]

History writing is a contentious topic and is the reason for much debate and discussion. Over the years a new breed of Historians have begun to challenge the status quo through books that look at periods of our history from an indigenous/non-Colonial/non-Marxist lens. Dr. Uday S Kulkarni is an eminent example - he has written 10 books on Maratha History and has done painstaking research on the period. Although we have hosted him on Bharatvaarta many times, this was our first in person interaction. We discuss many aspects of the fascinating episode of Narayanrao Peshwa's assassination and what followed after in this very engaging conversation. Thank you to my friend, Amit Paranjape, for his support in enabling this interaction and also the production crew for their meticulous effort. Hope you enjoy this podcast, friends! If you do, then please so share it with your friends and family - and please also buy Dr. Kulkarni's books (links in the description). Happy Deepavali in advance! 🙂🙏 PS - In the intro, I have mentioned Naraynrao as son of Madhavrao, while he was the younger brother. Regret the error! 🙏

[@monkeymindat]

❤ this podcast cause of huge knowledge from Sir ❤ For you to brother

[@RadhikaMula]

Definitely we r going to buy ur book sir we want u to write more books about great by gone days with correct research n interpretation

[@ckcariappa]

​@@monkeymindat Thank you so much! Glad you like our content - please do share our videos with friends and family. :)

[@ckcariappa]

@@RadhikaMula Indeed! Please support Uday sir's endeavours - he's doing fantastic work!

[@Johnny-pi1vk]

We can never study history from reverse because the conditions prevailing also culture was unimaginable Also we can never trust the Bramins who treated Sc St people like animals

[@vamanonlinespokenenglishco4467]

Have not seen the podcast but just the introductory sentence "Tombs were made instead of cannels and wells" is such a BIG EYE OPENER. Those vandalizers who tried to rule our country did such big abuses with people, culture and courtry as a whole. Now we are truly trying to recover . We people must bear in mind that all those who abuse us now must be countered unitedly by all.KEEP making such PODCASTs.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 Today's people who complaint about current Govt. must give the reply to the majority positive humans that would they prefer "Tombs to Tools" ?? People today are unnecessarily abusing governments should get ready for consequences...

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for checking it out, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@paradevparadev5371]

For whom u are building roads and infrastructure and all, for those who will come to power with population increase and with votes then wat we will be 10th class citizens in our own country while buslims will rule us right, first teach kshathra dharma to our kids and start ur own eco system as they have halal economics, own eco system in every field

[@truthsayer5824]

They did not build a single educational institute .

[@jagdishramanathan2091]

@@truthsayer5824 tombs and brothel outside every garrison was the hallmark of northindia during muslim rule .schools colleges university were nowhere .

[@vamanonlinespokenenglishco4467]

@@ckcariappa Sir kindly also invite Mr. Sangram Indore , he also has a good hold on the deccan history .

[@sushamak6030]

पानिपतच्या लढाईत मराठ्यांचा पराभव झाला हे अगदी आवर्जून सांगितले जाते पण हरता हरता देखील त्यांनी अब्दालीला असे पीटले की त्यानंतर तो पुन्हा कधीही भारतावर स्वारी करायला आला नाही ही गोष्ट सांगितली जात नाही.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends.

[@parag_Parag]

ह्यात शीखांचे खूप न विसरता येणार योगदान आहे

[@sohailrekhy2658]

So wonderful to see Dr. Kulkarni here. Stupendously informative as usual.

[@ckcariappa]

Thank you, glad you liked the content! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@Johnny-pi1vk]

@@sohailrekhy2658 don't trust these cunning Bammans

[@shripadparab1483]

Fantastic analysis by the author himself. Shows how complex the subject itself is.

[@ckcariappa]

Indeed sir! Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family. Happy Deepavali! 🙂

[@PravinAmbardekar]

Excellent. Thank god you are talking in English. I am tired to those people mixing Hindi, English, Marathi, etc. Many have pronunciation like इतिहासा, अर्जुना, पुराणाज, रामा, रावणा, etc. Please continue with any one language with correct pronunciation like this one.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@Indian-n1m]

Extraordinary podcast. so much to learn about the Maratha century.

[@ckcariappa]

Glad you liked it! Thanks for watching, do share this channel and content with your friends!

[@526Nitin]

very very interesting tidbits - thought would watch for 10 minutes but ended up watching all of it with mouth wide open despite having more than just a passing interest in Indian history :)

[@ckcariappa]

Glad you liked it! Thanks for watching, do share this channel and content with your friends!

[@526Nitin]

@@ckcariappa definitely.. happy Diwali and have a great year ahead with great content coming every now and then... I am pretty sure you will have no dearth of topics especially with the kind of year that lies ahead 🥵🙏👍😎😉

[@vamanonlinespokenenglishco4467]

Have watched the full podcast , firstly was very much impressed by the easy of language both of them were using . It is possible only when you have good hold on your language. As for the content of the podcast , pointwise explanation was quite impressive . History has always a good impact on our mind and Maratha history which is a gem on the cap as it had turned tables of our existence for we Indians.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please share this episode with your friends and family!

[@Nationatheart2023]

The empathy of connect with people reappeared, after 1000 years, in 2014.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@vivekbhurke4282]

Well it was a fantastic and interesting history of Marathas and Peshavas where you come closer to the fact that happened in the past and how lost our rich heritage due to some silly mistakes.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@ShreeRathod-ez7gx]

Maratha make akhand bharat❤💪💪💪🙏 har har mahadav🙏🙏🙏

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@nirvanabliss73]

how did maratha make akhand bharat? am confused

[@ranapratapsingh3416]

@@nirvanabliss73 Stay in ignorance.

[@ranapratapsingh3416]

Marathas failed because of the bastard Raghunath Rao Peshwa.

[@nirvanabliss73]

@@ranapratapsingh3416 ok. So you also don't know

[@sushmajyotipuri2317]

This video needs to b seen and heard by all

[@ckcariappa]

Thank you, Ma'am. Glad you liked it! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@rjrangani]

best......looking forward for more

[@ckcariappa]

Thank you! Glad you liked the content - do share our videos with friends and family. Also, let us know your suggestions on who we should host / topics we could cover. Thanks again! :)

[@Johnny-pi1vk]

Never trust the cunning Bammans who play behind the curtains

[@VARADBEDEKAR-s5w]

Some people say that Marathas went to fight Abdali just because Najeeb and Abdali killed Dattaji Shinde (one of sadars of Marathas in North) and not to defend the nation. So, even then I mention about Ahamadia Karar (1752) between Marathas and Mughals in which Mughals declared Marathas as their protector from its adversaries like Afgans, can there be any better counter argument to the point that some say about Marathas and their will to defend the nation, all the people who spread this narrative that Marathas didn't want to defend the nation but take revenge of Dattaji's murder by abdali and najeeb are mostly found to be lefitist its my observation

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@Marathayash8672]

Today on the western front or boarders of western India is the extend of Maratha empire were Hindus and others were not slaughtered by the mogols then.

[@RG-un2vl]

Narayanrao Peshwa was not Peshwa Madhavrao’s son as mentioned by the host. He was his younger brother. And he was not ‘ very young’; he was 18 years old, married, with a son who later became Peshwa himself. These are extremely well known facts. I’m just surprised and a bit disappointed at the level of research that these podcasts do.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@jagdishramanathan2091]

Raghoba had a great desire to be peshwa .he was bajirao 1 son and younger brother of nanasaheb .when vishwasrao died in panipat ,his brother madhavrao became peshwa .when madhavrao did of tb, his brother Narayan Rao was coronated .by this logic raghoba who was brother of nanasahib should have been peshwa as per his desire .it did not take place.in anger he took the criminal path and surrendered to the British .

[@Johnny-pi1vk]

How can we trust this man if his basics are wrong

[@RG-un2vl]

​@@Johnny-pi1vkbecause the guest is very erudite.The host got a few basic things wrong in the intro which just requires more proof reading . The info given by the guest is perfectly fine and well researched. So there's a context to what I had pointed out.

[@ajaytelang8886]

Married with a son ????

[@krishnaprasad7963]

Super narration

[@ckcariappa]

Glad you liked it! Please do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@shyambajekal8084]

I'm sure he has referenced these but I would like to point out to him that Mudhoji College in Phaltan (State of the Nimbalkars in Satara district) also has several original Bakhars and such documents in its library. I have seen them myself but did not know their importance, till now.😃

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this channel and content with your friends!

[@tempuser109]

Awesome podcast

[@ckcariappa]

Thank you, glad you liked it! 🙂🙏 Please do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@sanatanotaku8194]

Jai Maa Bhavani 🙏🙏🚩

[@ckcariappa]

🙏🙏🙏

[@anniikketdaftardar9939]

chaan aahe explanation our is also torted alot

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family!

[@pranav_chalotra]

That one man was Raghunathrao.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@bholanath785]

Fantastic. Write something on partition and atrocities on Hindus...

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please share this episode with your friends and family!

[@manisharadwad3538]

I think your thumbnail photo is of sadashivrao bhau and not of raghoba

[@ckcariappa]

Source: theindianportrait.com/artwork/shrimant-raghunathrao-peshwa-1734-1783/

[@omkar-chanchle]

No, It is Nana sahib first's (Balaji Baji Rao) photo, son of Shrimant Bajirao. The sarpech in turban is different from Shrimant Sadashivrao bhau.

[@VARADBEDEKAR-s5w]

​@@omkar-chanchle yes even I think the same

[@ArnabChowdhury-k8t]

The time has came that we should and we must overcome the colonial hangover and face fearlessly the real history of india

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@aravind1550]

I believe Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj is a greatest general of those Times because he United 12 CASTS and make it a single force "The Mighty Marathas"....

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@amrithkumar1918]

I felt that I was seeing some dream about crashed from the narration of Maratha kingdom. However, people should get many of these facts to learn from our mistakes & maintain Bharaths freedom

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this channel and content with your friends!

[@jagtaphimanshu09]

Small correction on coronation year of Shivaji Maharaj - 1674

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@ubuntuber1619]

No Jaggu, there were two coronations, one natural and another one by cunning greedy Brahmins.

[@lordoftherings7443]

​@@ubuntuber1619did they made u their slaves 😂 may be ur ancestors used to serve chugals that's why burning here .....Brahman jhansi ki Rani, peshwa bajirao who defeated nizam 3 times,seized red fort for 3 days, defeated Portugese navy, defeated sidhhis ,his son peshwa Raghunath Rao won lahore, multan, peshwar, kandhar etc his grandson Peshwa Madhavrao bhatt defeated hyder Ali and tipu sultan....bamboo letkar chai neem been talentless army always comes to get humiliated everywhere as they and their ancestors never did anything great against Any invaders but saaaaaars brainwashed by Britishers af 🏳️‍🌈

[@lordoftherings7443]

​@@ubuntuber1619did they made u their slaves 😂 may be ur ancestors used to serve chugals that's why burning here .....Brahman jhansi ki Rani, peshwa bajirao who defeated nizam 3 times,seized red fort for 3 days, defeated Portugese navy, defeated sidhhis ,his son peshwa Raghunath Rao won lahore, multan, peshwar, kandhar etc his grandson Peshwa Madhavrao bhatt defeated hyder Ali and tipu sultan....bamboo letkar chai neem been talentless army always comes to get humiliated everywhere as they and their ancestors never did anything great against Any invaders but saaaaaars brainwashed by Britishers af 🏳️‍🌈

[@lordoftherings7443]

​@@ubuntuber1619Boo ba shba talentless army used to serve Britishers 😂but Brahmans mangal pandey , Chandra Shekhar Azad, lokmanya tilak, lala lajpat rai, Shastri Ji, Nana saheb peshwa,tatya tope, madan Mohan Malviya,bankim Chandra Chatterjee,and pinglai ji who designed tiranga too were Brahmans.....Get some burnol if u need.....World knows why u achieved nothing anywhere in the world... without begging

[@vivekraut476]

Reality is after 1749, means after Chatrapati Shahu Maharaj Thorle(Satara)passsd away, Maratha Empire got more decentralised, which obviously is helpful for administration purpose. But it created more independent powers, who wanted to overpower each other, which unfortunately leads to peshwa bajirao 2 signing a stupid treaty with brits in 1802 and empire starts falling down.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@kdshak4904]

Monuments were great source of employment Same employment based construction of churches and monuments were carried out all over the world.

[@arjun13Ten]

The loss of IIIBattle of Panipat was soley due to overconfidence of PM of Maratha Empire the Peshwa. Every important chieftain tried to dessuade him not to takr women and old with the army marching for battle. However he made it a pilgrimage and battle took a back seat. Resulting in loos of speed and agility.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@Sanjay-uh5hx]

@arjun13Ten... thanks for bringing up this important aspect of that war.. also they could not agree on the right Rana-Niti.

[@indiantourstar2978]

Sir, can you please suggest which book should I read for understanding the Maratha invasion of Bengal

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please share this episode with your friends and family!

[@prasanna_Bhat]

Immadi Pulikeshi 💛❤️

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Please do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@santoshkumarbhat3053]

Reminds doordarshan serial in 90s the great maratha

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please share this episode with your friends and family!

[@par5308]

All indians please watch the documentary BBC ON TRIAL, IT IS A MUST

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@vickyv4707]

is it good I have been postponing it

[@eklavyavyom]

Uddhav Thakre seems to have similar ideas.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@TIGER100001]

penguin s family originaly are from bihar...it seems in chandegupts time...they were under the cruel king Dhana Nanda....not sure if they were in cohoots with him...although his linage claims to be from bagwaan krishnas linage

[@anandshethi8742]

🙏❤️🙏

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@krisk4868]

Very well researched booked by non biased 👏 👍 person read Congi comminists

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@lundfakhri448]

When people started pointing out Americans & their followers started claiming it was "conspiracy theory". People started ignoring crimes & finally have to pay karma.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@viswambharannair5476]

👍👍

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@mylord3003]

Maratis like Gokale, Tilak were elder citizens who took up.the cause of Bharat and we're pained to see Mata Bharat chained. We owe them a lot. I respect them a lot.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@raghavkonda6175]

There were Bengali Leaders who took the leadership before these Maratha leaders

[@sagarj5743]

Tilak was casteist as hell. He ran a very long and vicious campaign against Chatrapati Shahu Maharaj who opposed brahminism, fought against casteism, and gave reservation in his presidency to bahujans for education. Tilak was dead opposed to bringing Dalits into mainstream politics. I am Congress supporter but I know history is not as it seems, tilak's casteism is carefully ignored

[@sagarj5743]

Tilak was casteist as hell. He ran a very long and vicious campaign against Chatrapati Shahu Maharaj who opposed brahminism, fought against casteism, and gave reservation in his presidency to bahujans for education. Tilak was dead opposed to bringing Dalits into mainstream politics. I am Congress supporter but I know history is not as it seems, tilak's casteism is carefully ignored

[@sachinvaidya9166]

​@sagarj5743 this is all media propaganda to defame Brahmins

[@puneetmishra4726]

Raghunathrao has to be on the top of the list of "most incompetent son of a great father".

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this channel and content with your friends!

[@board4164]

Dear g@@ndu puneet please keep your mouth shut about issues you don't know.

[@kaustaubh1234]

Raghunathrao was very competent. Only thing was his people did not supported him

[@puneetmishra4726]

@@kaustaubh1234 No. He was short-sighted and didn't get along with anyone. Exact opposite of his father. All he had was low cunning and ruthlessness of a cutthroat, that's all. Nanasaheb wasn't a genius either but at least he didn't make things worse. None of Bajirao's sons were as good as him

[@justahubby]

I would like to know more about Pindharis Also,in various excerpts also mentioned that marathas also were similarly involved in looting,idk which era it was but the delhi has seen that...need some clarity and truth

[@ckcariappa]

Glad you liked it! Thanks for watching, do share this channel and content with your friends!

[@patriot9981]

Kulkarniji missed to talk about Babasaheb Purandare. Rajwade history is always disputed.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@Jaihind699]

Centuries have passed but sadly the same tendencies are still carrying on ... the reason for continuous decline of Hindus and ultimate decimation in future 😢

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@vishnugold]

wow

[@arunstephan302]

Narayanrao was not Madhavrao's son. He was youngest brother of Madhavrao peshwa.

[@ckcariappa]

Indeed, Sir. I have corrected it in my comment. Thanks for watching, do share this channel and content with your friends!

[@satyajeetbhate8669]

By whatever name you gave peshwa. They created an empire ,a Hindu empire. And 1st bajirao was undefeated senapati of the entire world. So whoever hates peshwas , xxxxxxxx. Fill the gaps.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@A1-Driving974]

How many of you know about Sachwala Research about him and know more about the barbarians

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@aravind1550]

Deadly Battle of 3rd Panipat... which has changed the course of Indian history.... was the lost due to the CAST Supremacy attitude of Sadashiv Rao..... still marathas are dying in Balochistan because of that idiotic decision....

[@Ajhng]

Great choice of guest .Pls call him to talk about all his books

[@ckcariappa]

Yes, we've hosted him multiple times before! Thanks for the support, do share this episode and channel with your friends and family.

[@NYChoudhary]

Narayan Rao was the younger brother of Madhav Rao Peshwa and not his son as being stated.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@Chiga-lt6vq]

The loss of panipat still feels bitter We have never won any decisive battle from terain in 1191 Only rulers I know is maharaja ranjit singh and peshwa bajirao who won decisive battles and war and yes the ahoms Rest all are just foolish bravado or some childish folklore

[@SidhantDhagare-gw3fj]

Our warrior class rajputs were the biggest supporters of mughals so no one was there to fight muslims.

[@Chiga-lt6vq]

@@SidhantDhagare-gw3fj early rajput chieftains and kings did fight against invaders but they all lost badly

[@kumarankiteshwar9716]

Even Raghunath rao won Delhi , Lahore, attock Multan Peshwar. Again marathas won in 1771 captured Delhi. RaghuJi Raje Bhonsle defeated and captured southern India, and defeated Nawab Alivardi khan of Bengal. Vijayanagaram Samarajyam Krishna Dev Raya, Kapilendra Gajpati also won battle, Maharna sangram Singh also won the battle

[@ramkrishnan8476]

​@@SidhantDhagare-gw3fjvery true. If only they had supported the Marathas at Panipat.

[@ramkrishnadash4467]

​​@@ramkrishnan8476The problem in case of Marathas was that the way they dominated other ruling classes without any respect prevented others to side with them...There overconfidence was seen when they ignored Surajmal's advice and paid a hefty price in Panipat

[@ushabhende4040]

It is wrong to refer to to ascent of a new peshwa as"ascending the throne". Peshwa was a 'hudda', a post to which the official was appointed. Peshwa was not a monarch. The Chatrapati was the monarch.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please share this episode with your friends and family!

[@Ajhng]

For history pls call surya roy sir and praveen mohan they are amazing and talk about dharmic revival. Besides the veducation founder can also be great guest at your amazing podcast who is working to re establish gurukul school.Also Sahana singh who is based in usa to talk about ancient indian education.Venkatesh rangan sir is a great historian too who has published three books and worked upon ancient indian conquests and our great civilization.Raghava krishna ,the founder of brhat is doing great work.Also rajeev malhotra of USA who wrote the book Snakes of Ganga Also ,Capt praveen chaturvedi who made sahib movie is great person who advocates for our santana cause and tells how it has been systematically destroyed.Shaleen wadhwani is a great art educator,curator and talks greatly on how British looted of our riches and how it can be repatriated Also vedveer arya who talks about correct chronology of Indian history.Abhijit jog who is an author also challenges the leftists ideology snd fake history still taught in india.Jay vardhan singh a phd scholar from jnu is also a great history buff

[@parampreetmib2011]

With due respect to the Marathas...the last great empire of India was the Sikh Empire...the last one to fall to the British

[@jagdishramanathan2091]

@@parampreetmib2011 the fact that Sher e panjab ranjisinghji massacred the Afghans no end was the evidence that Afghans were in the decline .nadir shah succeeded because of infighting of Mughal commanders and abdali succeeded because of infighting among the marathas,ladies and no food ,total ignorance of northindia battle ,weather conditions .....for abdali it was equal loss and only a phyrric victory .

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family. Happy Deepavali!

[@RR-pc7yv]

@@jagdishramanathan2091 There was no infighting among the Marathas in 1761...

[@RR-pc7yv]

Marathas were the last great empire of India. Not the Sikh Empire aka the Empire of Western Punjab. It was a regional power. Marathas at their peak ruled over lands stretching from Khyber (with plans of capturing Kabul & Kandahar) to Cuttack and parts of Bengal. From Jammu & borders of Sindh to all the way to Tamil Nadu. Only Marathas ruled so much territory at that time. No other Indian Empire achieved that. That includes Sikh Empire too. So Maratha Empire was the last great 'All-India' Empire. So it was in this sense that the author aka speaker is referring to the Maratha Empire as the last great empire of India. Also, Nepalese Empire aka Nepal remained independent. It suffered territorial losses but survived and remained independent...

[@rajsinghji-84]

I did BA Hons in History. Took me 20 years to unlearn all that BS we were fed.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do share this content/channel with your friends and family.

[@Tonynch_783_49]

BEFORE BLOODY MUSLIM CAME TO BHARAT,, BHARAT WAS 45% OF TOTAL ECONOMY ,, WHEN THEIR DOWNFALL THEN ALSO 25% ECONOMY,, IN SPITE OF STARTED SO CALLED REVOLUTION, RENAISSANCE AND OHTER THINGS

[@Chiga-lt6vq]

Nothing bloody innit They came they conquered it was our bloody kings and ancestors who could not defeat them

[@Chiga-lt6vq]

The spanish did a whole thousand year war to kick the muslims out The muslims had invaded them till the last square mile they had even reached france But thier kings stood and and won battles unlike ours who just kept losing

[@Sunny12-23]

Please dont exaggerate and give wrong facts. The entire rechristianisation of Spain took 1 generation - the reign of Isabella and Ferdinand. The same Ferdinand and Isabella who financed Columbus' expedition. Yes our rulers made mistakes. We all do. Giving gyan from hindsight is easy. s@@Chiga-lt6vq

[@royenlawyer6045]

If our kings lost, how is it that Hindus are still in existence?

[@balasahebsuryavanshi6848]

In their down fall india was 14 percent of world GDP and before they came in the gupta kal or mauryan reign india was 35 to 36% of world GDP followed by song Dynasty china at second place.

[@ZoonChenar-lw5hx]

Indigenous people were NOT caste Hindus. Indigenous were dravidian aboriginals so called shudras achhoots liberated by Islam Vedic Arya samaj were INVADERS Muslim were liberators of shudras achhoots

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Please do share this channel with your friends and family.

[@sushantgunjal2]

both the Anchors are Brahmins...and they are still not ready to accept and tell everyone that....due to Peshwas ....Marathas lost in Panipat 1761.......

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@extra2ab]

जय गोमाता

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please share this episode with your friends and family!

[@shivfloyd]

Peshwas were servants of Chattrapati not rulers. Use your word 's carefully

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@Sudeep.Manerkar]

Prime minister not servants

[@vivekkulkarni8679]

Peshwas were the CEOs whereas the Chhatrapati were the chairman… You be mindful of the words you choose… also, make sure you speak in correct way, whatever language you speak…. For example, you should have said “words” instead of “word’s”

[@pranav_chalotra]

​@@vivekkulkarni8679 पेशवे स्वतःलाच छत्रपतींचे सेवक म्हणून घ्यायचे.

[@jyothiprabhu8411]

Check your vulgar language...Floyd...yeah says it all.

[@SaDa-kn3ni]

सर मराठीत पण बनवा व्हिडिओ ❤🇮🇳

[@ckcariappa]

हाँ भाई. हम यह करना चाहते हैं, शायद आगे चलकर कभी न कभी।

[@ZoonChenar-lw5hx]

You could have asked local waqfs about mausoleums before making ignorant accusation. As in any modern economy construction such as mausoleum is the biggest source of employment and patronage in an area. The endowment gardens and agricultural land generated fruit produce water sources and its revenue was used for LANGAR free food while a shelter or school was attached to the tomb. The purpose was to earn continual SAWAB OR MERIT even after death through providing ongoing construction and maintenance employment, free food, shelter, and literacy for the benefit of the economy and local people. The British confiscated waqf lands to reward collaborators in 1858 but the tombs were welfare centres You don't understand the philosophy of mausoleums at least ask the waqf people before talking

[@prashantkumarsingh285]

Greediness is reason behind fall of Maratha empire, greed of money, power & land. Lack of admistrasion or qualify in admistrasion. They should focus on school & college in country, then temple 🛕.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family!

[@kalukutta]

Baji Rao brahmin peshwa erected a law that banned mahars from army and forced the mahars to wear a pot in front of their head and broom 🧹 on their bottom. Because they were untouchable. Brahmins never considered local people as their own. That's why they solidified cast lines. Mahars joined the east india company when given the opportunity to live a dignified life. That's why the Maratha empire came to an end

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@mr-jf3qt]

Please mention as Bajirao ll because please thinks that it can be bajirao I who was one of the greatest leader.🙏

[@abhishhk.]

British bhi nhi aa pate agar Maratha empire hota 🚩

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@anurag9666]

Sorry but Maratha Empire was there during the British too, but not as strong as it once was

[@abhishhk.]

@anurag9666 exactly there were cracks already. best leadership like Chatrapati, peshwa bajirao, sambhaji raje all were gone. That's why British dare engulfed maharashtra and india

[@rahulnagarkar8237]

पानिपत के युद्ध भुमि मे छत्रपती के वंशज प्रत्यक्ष रूप में शामिल हि नहीं थे। वो तो कोल्हापुर में बैठे हुए थे। अब्दली तो प्रत्यक्ष रणभूमि पर तैनात रहा । जरा सोचने कि बात है।

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Please do share this channel and conversation with your friends and family.

[@narenmenon6906]

The oldest surviving "democracy" is the Swiss model. They have four official languages. They hold regular plebiscites/referendums. All men know how to use fire arms and can be be conscripted. Perhaps we need to study its History. Not much is written about it.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family!

[@panimeda245]

It is such a sad story to listen to Maratha empire the hope of Bharat becoming a sovereign state with Sanathan dharma. Due to mere infight and bigoted thoughts handed the land from Mughals to British.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode and channel with your friends and family.

[@ybrengade802]

I am waiting for listen or read about Maratha navel warfare against Portugal, British and may more and protect west coast of India mostly in time of when Maratha Capital in Thanjavur when Kanhoji Angre.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@soumiktarafdar6160]

7.05, it's not 1774, it's 1674 when Chatrapati Shivaji was crowned, guess it's a slip of tongue.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Please do share this channel with your friends and family.

[@567ghj_X]

Episodes like this and internet has made Gaddars afraid of being so . Ex : Modi era post 2014

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@AB-vx4hk]

I would highly recommend ‘Yalgaar’ by Arnold Boleman that details the play of wits between Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj and Afzal Khan that culminated in the great battle of Pratapgad where the Marathas decimated the Sultanate army, and the greT king disemboweled and decapitated Afzal and established a Hindvi Swarajya

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@patelatulramanlal-z5l]

17 18 TH CENTURY RAJ PUT HIS NOT CONSEDRRD HE PART OF INDIA.HE IS HAR SEPRET STATE IN WORLD.

[@KrishnaSuryawanshi]

Hi

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@jsm3692]

Dr.Kulkarni: 'Saheb' has remai ed with us, Baia SAHEB, 'Shinde SAHEB. ALL the Peshwas are pictured in Muslim Attire? What about the cultural renaisance ostensibly spurred by the Marathas?

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@shrikantwathare2651]

Panipat defeat weakened Maratha empire

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please do share this episode with your friends and family!

[@sushantgunjal2]

Peshwas were responsible for the defeat of Marathas at Panipat 1761.... Sadashiv bhau was fully responsible for that....and including his Father Nanasaheb Peshwa

[@anurag9666]

Yea he was an emotional fool, not suitable for the battlefield with his mental state

[@naseemsoherwardy2534]

It becsuse military science was not taught to the people who were selected for army plus poor training n innocation in militery sc.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@anamelessmonster]

It were peshwas who backstabbed marathas

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends.

[@rajatnirkhe6321]

Why is it that there is no jelicy within the British

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@KEDAR412]

Narayan rao was Madav Raos younger brother and not his Son... Pls get facts right

[@ckcariappa]

Appreciate the feedback. Thanks for watching, pls do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@ram76157]

1 hr ? Who has time

[@ckcariappa]

We have uploaded shorts/reels as well - do check it out! Thanks for stopping by, do share this channel and our content with your friends and family.

[@jaimineerajhans9897]

All holkar clan was responsible for debacle of marathas.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@ubuntuber1619]

माला विश्वास पानीपतात गेला।🤦🏽‍♂️💔

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this channel and content with your friends!

[@ubuntuber1619]

@ckcariappa chima ji appa cariappa👍🏼

[@shaileshdhuri4166]

I have watched first 55 minutes. Not a single new fact that I did not know. These podcasts are becoming waste of time. 😢

[@ckcariappa]

Appreciate the feedback. Do read his books - covers a wide variety of facts and anecdotes! Thanks for watching, please do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@rajendraprabhudesai3382]

Mr kulkarni is wearing acoat to perhaps make an impression of authotication of what he says

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Please do share this channel and conversation with your friends and family.

[@kdshak4904]

Maratha Anglo war always to go in favor of English.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this channel and our content with your friends and family.

[@GAUTAMPANSARE]

Narayanrao was Madhavrao's son 😂😂😂

[@ckcariappa]

That was mistake sir, I've mentioned it in the comments. Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@Ajay-ib1xk]

peshwa were stooge of britis and fought war for them

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Please do share this channel and conversation with your friends and family.

[@Perumanian]

I am not right wing at all😂

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family!

[@mumbaitree2801]

UT

[@thetruth8630]

7:01 - wrong date - its 1674 NOT 1774 when Shivaji was crowned chatrapathi.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@madleon81]

Even now Bharat is soft on gaddars 😂

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@sharayutravels]

Pehswas were administrators on behalf of throne, the chatrapati gadi lineage of Shrimant Chatrapatri Shivaji Maharaj. If you want to speak about history pls get the facts right

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family!

[@Rpatqd6bi]

English Governors never overturn Queens power but Loyal to Queens, as against peshwas never loyal to Maratha king, they ditched ch Shivaji grandson. Brahmin Peshwa was very greedy for power and hence Marathi people don't respect Peshwa , that's reflects in today's politics.

[@ckcariappa]

Thanks for watching, please do share this episode with your friends and family.

[@kaustaubh1234]

If Peshwa were not governed well Maratha empire did not survived so long. Do not mix your hatred with facts.