Ep 27: The First Revelation: How Bukhari and Tabari Insulted Prophet |

Things you'll learn in this episode of Our Prophet:
00:00 - Five objections to the narration in Sahih Bukhari
05:58 - Tabari and the Prophet's contemplation of suicide
11:54 - Did other Prophets react similarly upon receiving revelation?
12:53 - Other disturbing narrations found in Sunni Hadith books
15:42 - Examining narrators of such hadiths and their political motives
Help us create the most comprehensive biography of the Prophet of Islam. Dedicate episodes in the memory of your loved ones by visiting thaqlain.org/ourprophet.
#ProphetMuhammad #PropheticBiography #OurProphet
================================================
► MAKE THAQLAIN REACH 100K SUBSCRIBERS:
bit.ly/SubscribeToThaqlain
► BECOME A MEMBER ON KZbin:
/ @thaqlain
► HELP US CREATE MORE CONTENT:
thaqlain.org/support
► CONNECT ON WHATSAPP:
wa.link/hfcf0g
► FOLLOW US:
Facebook: / thaqlain
Instagram: / thaqlainmedia

[@Thaqlain]

Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S: I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt). II) Subscribe: Connect with us on KZbin & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/447897047062 III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support

[@murtazabandali5609]

Prophet had every thing in the world, money and health and a faithful wife like Khadija who was dedicated to him, suicide theory is ruled out totally.

[@hasanbilgrami5735]

This is what happens when you quote hadeeths from a book written 200 or 300 years after the Prophet's (saww) shahadat. Alhamdulillah we are extremely thankful to Allah (swt) for guiding us through the path of Ahlul Bayt (as).

[@koroglurustem1722]

He didn't bring the opposite of what's narrated in Bukhari, except using his false logic. That's nothing but attacking Islam itself.

[@tazboy1934]

Yeah ​@@koroglurustem1722

[@muniraalqamar]

اللهم صل على محمد وعلى آل محمد وعجل فرجهم thank you so much Thaqlain.. Allh swt bless you all❤❤❤❤❤

[@Thaqlain]

JazakAllah. Ameen :)

[@tasneembootwala8308]

Alhamdulillah we are followers of school of Ahlebeit a.s. Ya allah Send blessings on our prophet Muhammad s.a.w.w.s. And his family peace be upon them

[@Thaqlain]

Ameen :)

[@whyphy2213]

ameen

[@sadafali17]

Thank God someone is speaking about the elephant in the room. Half the ex- muslims i have seen on internet quote from sahih bukhari. The biggest controversy is about bibi aysha marrying at age of 6. Next is about maria qibtiya Dear scholar, please address all these issues bcz its humiliating to see our Prophet's integrity questioned and doubted.

[@Thaqlain]

InshaAllah all these will be address in detail. Don't forget to share this series with your family and friends :)

[@sonabarnes6670]

Thank you, God bless you!

[@Manmoon399_5]

Thank you. I am sunni but me, my husband and dad have always had issues with thes Hadiths. These hadiths make muslims leave Islam unfortunately

[@nicaisedagan5047]

It seems like truth is hard to accept when it hurts. Hadith may have said truth about your prophet because in Koran he is summoned to ask forgiveness of his sins,past , present and future. So he was a sinner according to Allah while Jesus was sinless according to the same Allah. And you guys say Muhammad was the best of mankind despite his sins. Unless you believe that Jesus was not created. No matter what this man is shunning, Jesus has high status in Koran than Muhammad. If he's Shia,let you know that Shias hadiths have more popo than those of Sunni's. Islam is something else!

[@kebab7023]

@@nicaisedagan5047 Shias believe all prophets were sinless, and Muhammad is the greatest of creation. May Allah guide you Inshallah.

[@nicaisedagan5047]

@@kebab7023 does Koran say Muhammad is sinless?

[@OmarOharris]

I also had this I started to read the Quran without the Hadith and Allah opend my eyes

[@user-eh2pv4sc7h]

Quran and alhul bayt. Mentioned in sahih muslim and tirmidhi.

[@abudujana13]

JazakAllah khair

[@alishaan2417]

Thank you for sharing this beautiful and important information 😊😊😊😊

[@Thaqlain]

Don't forget to share it with your family and friends 🌹

[@alawibhb]

احسنتم سيدي 🤍🤍

[@ZwaneMakki]

These scholars are an absolute God send. Makes a lot of reasonable sense. This scholar is explaining a religion and way free from the filth of doubt.

[@Thaqlain]

Hope you are sharing this with your family and friends 😊

[@ZwaneMakki]

@@Thaqlain Bruh, I converted to shia islam in a prison cell as a convicted thief, aint no one want to hear anything from me about religion LOL. Just using your website and taking notes for a Shia Convert Superhero movie, game and graphic novel my startup company is working on. Hope you don't mind. #getoffmyneck

[@Thaqlain]

@@ZwaneMakki all our content is copyright free :)

[@user-nf9sz6cy7l]

@@ZwaneMakki I -- really?

[@user-nf9sz6cy7l]

@@ZwaneMakki Good Luck though.

[@herefirst3687]

MashAllah such an informative lecture I've seen so much more worse hadiths in Bukhari

[@hammadhussain4422]

no prophet in history ever reacted to the revelation in him like what is told in this narrations.... not even the one who got revelation in cradle

[@Thaqlain]

Indeed. Sadly some Muslim authors wanted to belittle the Prophet.

[@pedo_muhammad]

Muhammad the omniscient divine , holy man. Even before creating everyone he existed with allah . He was there when allah laid foundation of earth. The divine eternal Muhammad, who knows everything 🙏🙏

[@Mister_Hassan]

❤️🤲🏼

[@aliayache8954]

Thank you very much dear sheikh and sayyed for these lectures. I really cant stop watching them. Let me please ask one question. Why didnt the imams (as). Especially imam al baqeer (a.s.) and imam assidiq (a.s.) publically condemns these hadiths? As they had so many students studiying from them. How can the other schools of thought accept these narrations, if the own family of the holy prophet( saas) said thart these hadith are wrong. Thank you very much.

[@Thaqlain]

Some of these narrations have been condemned. As to why Ahlal Sunnah accept these hadiths and not the one given by the Ahlulbayt, well..... 🙂

[@cosmicguy4929]

where in the tabri was it written that he prophet tried to commit suicide cause i would like to show this hadith to my friends

[@Thaqlain]

Taareekh at-Tabari (1/532, 533)

[@amerj5243]

❗Bukhari lived and made his book 240 years after the prophet died! That's a fact & it's a looooong ass time, & not only that , but he also narrates his alleged Hadiths from ordinary people simply because they say it goes back to anyone who lived at the time of the prophet! Imagine taking something as important as the prophet's Sunnah & Hadiths which hold many details of how we should practice Islam, in addition to the interpretation of many verses in the Qura'an , Imagine taking it this lightly and base it on a Book with no grounds whatsoever, and even call it Sahih. No wonder we see many Muslims going astray in their lives and behaviour!

[@yugaosenpai2089]

Hadith existed long before imam bukhari all he did was collect the authentic ones with the strongest chains of narration some times support ie by different narration chains and collected them in a single book others did the same long before him ie imam Malik in Muwatta Imam Malik Ahmad one of the earliest caliphs of Islam umar ibn abdulaziz ect

[@amerj5243]

@@yugaosenpai2089 He did a poor job, partly by being incompetent & partly by being pressed by the Caliphate at that time! And who says he collected the authentic ones? Do you know that in his book, Bukhari narrates ❌ that the Prophet tried to commit suicide by throwing himself off a steep cliff several times!!! ❌ That the prophet was bewitched and was under spells several times!!! ❌ That on the first day of revelation, the prophet didn't know what hit him & that he had to go to a Christian old guy named Waraka to tell him what was going on and that he was becoming a prophet!!! ❌ That Umar ordered the prophet that he better cover his wives because strangers were looking at them!!!! ❌ That the prophet slept with Aisha while she was on her period!!! ❌ That God will show his leg on the day of Judgement and immerse it in Hell! fire!!! This is a small sample of the outrageous Hadiths Bukhari narrates! You can google each one if you're in doubt! Goodluck to every Muslim who wants to take the details of his religion from that Book!

[@fj6026]

Weird..

[@tazboy1934]

I heard some sufi said that their were some secret or strenght that were being transmitted to the holy prophet saw wen the angel squeezed him

[@Thaqlain]

How can Jibrael give strength to the Prophet when the Prophet is higher in status than Jibrael :)

[@sarkarhaider]

May be sunni muhaddithin historians spread lies but dont u think that is the ONLY NARRATIVE known to muslims and non muslims alike bigger question is if you have alternate narrative what kept shia scholors from publicising their version for all these centuries !?

[@Thaqlain]

The 3rd episode answers this 🙂

[@reynoldfranks4332]

Any man written book cant be followed. Just read and dont ever think that the prophet said follow these books. Are we saying the quraan is not sufficient.

[@4dotjogi224]

Bro first of all yes the prophet did had the burden of the dawah and he couldn’t handle it and after some thim surah al duhha revealed and a same thing you can find in quran about hz Yousaf as as the quran mentioned if he wasn’t protected by Allah he would have gone for zulekha so there us a possibility in human nature about that as well and he didn’t commit suicide this just popped in his mind just because you want to admit your own mistakes these are just accusing bukhari of blasphemy.

[@Thaqlain]

Do you realize you are comparing Adultery (a sin) but Prophethood (a divine status)?

[@yoursolosquad6283]

You are insulting the Prophet (PBUH&HF) in order to defend bokhari, brother have fear of Allah (SWT).

[@Rafida_Twelver_Shia_Muslim]

*"the prophet did had the burden of the dawah and he couldn’t handle it"* he couldn’t handle it? Are kidding? Do you think Allah would choose for Prophethood someone who cannot handle it? Are doubting Allah's wisdom?

[@thetruth4855]

To me, this shows that the events happened to him were real. Imagine, if he came out with a lot of confidence out of the cave. People would've assumed that he's planning something or being self deluded. It would've looked ridiculous! Come on. And then somebody from the audience said that Musa A.S. was not traumatised or afraid when he talked to Allah. And the speaker confirmed her. But that's a lie! Musa A.S. was in fact, traumatised and scared to the point that he was running away from the fire and didn't look back according to the Quran itself! Allah obviously called him back and reassured him. But how come you don't talk about this? You are living in this delusion that everything that the Prophet did was angelic and most interestingly, "Imam Ali A.S." woud be with him everyday and everywhere. At this point, I wouldn't be surprised if the speaker says that Imam Ali went to Miraj along with the Prophet and they both met Allah. I wouldn't be surprised if he also says that Imam Ali delivered half of the Final Sermon of the Prophet during his last Hajj. All of this sounds deceitful and laughable, sorry to say. Yes, I do agree with a lot of arguments and perspectives of this speaker, but I think sometimes, he steps out of the line. I am a Muslim, and not involved in sectarian conflicts. I believe in the Quran, and yes, take Hadith with a grain of salt like the Ahlul Bayt.

[@Thaqlain]

Can you please share the Quranic verse that mentions Musa as "traumatised and scared to the point that he was running away from the fire and didn't look back according to the Quran itself! Allah obviously called him back and reassured him".

[@tazboy1934]

​@@Thaqlainwat about Mariam who was shock and scared wen jibril came in form of a man to her? In bible when angel appeared the prophets or servant of God were afraid or shock...then the angel reassured them by saying "be not afraid"

[@koroglurustem1722]

You're just using your "intellect" to criticise these narrations.. Haven't you read chapter Muzzammil?! Who's Allah talking to? Isn't that our beloved prophet? With your half baked logic, prophet shouldn't be wrapped up like that..

[@Thaqlain]

Where did we say that revelation did not impact the Prophet?

[@koroglurustem1722]

@@Thaqlain use daleel from Quran and truthful sunna to prove otherwise. Your false logic is not a source of religion.

[@Thaqlain]

The truthful Sunna comes from the Prophet's progeny. And their narrations are already shared.

[@koroglurustem1722]

@@Thaqlain majority of imams of ahlul-bayt didn't write books.

[@fj6026]

Is this men shia?

[@Thaqlain]

Is he saying something untruthful?

[@kokemyt]

Lol stop spreading hatred 😊 remember one day u will be questioned about it

[@mohamedkashwani950]

I guess the jokes are a bit inappropriate but other than that these things have to be spoken about especially because most people don't know about these narrations

[@corpsefoot758]

Abu Bakr spread the first hatred, by trying to harass Lady Fatima in court Don’t try lecturing others about hatred

[@corpsefoot758]

@@nickmansfield1 I’m always torn between trying to use vinegar or honey against these people, sorry The fact that they lie about words/intent constantly (like he literally just did above, with his “hatred” allegation), while shamelessly sidelining Imam Ali & his supporters, makes me seriously question their moral compass overall

[@yoursolosquad6283]

@@corpsefoot758 God bless you brother, its our duty to dispute these allegations against our beloved Prophet (PBUH&HF) while ofcourse maintaining their teachings and trying to imitating their pure behavior to showcase them in our actions. 🌹