Evanescence- Bleed (I must be dreaming) lyrics

one of Evanescence's demos

[@Liliinbloom21]

Only true Evanescence fans know of the existence of this song

"Even in Death" "Understading" "Bleed" Holy hell, I love the old creepy songs of Evanescence. I miss her old songs.

[@jessicariderrules]

I love them to but I don’t want her to experience negative situations that are required for her to either write those kinds of songs herself or pay someone else to write them. She was in a horribly, horrifically bad place when she made those songs. She doesn’t deserve to go back to that kind of situation.

[@ginociambotti9256]

@@jessicariderrules Please could you elaborate on why she was in a horrible situation back then? Is there any site where I can read deeper about it? I'm very interested in Evanescence's and Amy Lee's background to all stages of their artistic production.

[@jessicariderrules]

@@ginociambotti9256Yes I can elaborate. So according to the website that I found one of her little sister's died as a baby, her other sister was in an abusive relationship. Her older brother who epileptic died from a severe seizure, and of course Amy Lee herself was in an abusive relationship with Mr. Moose. Now I might be wrong about her sister being in an abusive relationship, but that's part of what I know and remember hearing and part what I read online from that website, whose url I can't remember.

[@luciusdenovan8099]

Lies and away from me are awesome.

[@supremeoverlordtwizz7925]

I love when she says, "We all live and we all die, but that does not begin to justify you."

[@tawanahickey9234]

Ok

[@christopherbernal5977]

it's like there is no reason to kill someone, I made a cover: kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4K1aYqqlNqdh80

[@tawanahickey9234]

High school is going to go over there at about it but he said that he will not

[@tawanahickey9234]

Highest level and see how much

[@hakimdu07]

SHE'S EVERYTHING ❤

[@saviitrius]

This song makes me want to cry. Amy sounds so helpless when she sings "no" in the chorus. :'(

[@RuruFIN]

Nothing wrong there, I shed few tears also. Just love this.

[@p.sohanaakhter8562]

Her voice is always soothing but here, it's more than just soothing. It's like a miracle.

[@yourmomasaurus]

p.sohana akhter Yeah, she must be an angel!

[@p.sohanaakhter8562]

i know =)

[@RuruFIN]

Amy should do ASMR :3

[@tawanahickey9234]

Okay with me coming in to town tomorrow for you have any

[@tawanahickey9234]

Highest level and see what happens when we get back in touch when we can get it in a good way up there at

[@Spencer.esque_.]

Amy Lee is a goddess. NO ONE can compare to her beautiful voice. Every song by Evanescence is meaningful and soothing.

[@MemKeehl]

this is actually my favorite song from Evanescence.

[@savannahjohnstone9923]

Same

[@rachelcobbett9999]

Mine as well

[@goated-yt2370]

tengri ata this the best song from them besides understanding

[@jereilysmarinitororiosrios1528]

OMG I LOVE THIS SONG😋😊😊😊😄😄😷

[@tawanahickey9234]

Hi

[@guimb1994]

Not many people know this song from Evanescence. I love it.

[@christopherbernal5977]

I have a cover on my channel: kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4K1aYqqlNqdh80

[@grim7379]

This song is awesome. Why was this never released. This is an absolutely amazing song.

[@christopherbernal5977]

I prefer old Evanescence songs, they seems more reallistic and deeper, I made a cover: kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4K1aYqqlNqdh80

[@erizamisorafujoshi7002]

Idk It's one of my favs songs of Evanescence

[@Merdicano]

Still such a haunting song after so many years, the edge of the lyrics and beautiful scenery just made it what it is, and it's a spectacular song

[@Kheirudin92]

I agree, the outro gives you the feeling of the song coming after you

[@loyandle3405]

This is my favorite Evanescene song, hands down.

[@carpediemearth]

Amy wrote a lot of the Fallen and Pre-Fallen Evanescence material about her inner conflicts and abuse and gaslighting she was suffering in a horribly abusive relationship she was in (when asked, she later confirmed that Ben Moody was the abuser. Ben has also abused other women since including his ex-wife who divorced him in 2022 because of that). I think this is very much about that helpless state of being abused. I remember her saying in an old interview that she felt trapped, trying justify things to herself, trying to fix the other person while suffering herself, trying to get help but not knowing how

[@CS-op3vu]

No one really knows and can confirm your statement. I guess that song has many different interpretations.

[@saxumbonum]

Thanks for this, I remember so many people used to speculate and spread as fact that this was about her witnessing the abuse and death of her younger sister.

[@carpediemearth]

@@saxumbonum The two songs Amy wrote about her state of mind around her sister's death were Hello and Like You

[@carpediemearth]

@@CS-op3vu For this song Bleed, yeah no one knows what exactly she wrote it about. But everything I said Amy stated herself. And I think the lyrics of this songs are very relevant to what she said of her experience back then. Plus, she called this period of her life (from 90s to 2003) when she was writing these songs "a time in my life that was both wonderful and terrible".

[@saxumbonum]

@@carpediemearth you're right, but this song specifically is what people used to use as example decades ago.

[@lisajoye5721]

The best part about creating anything is the dance of perception. To be able to reach into the level of the unknown, yet make it relatable. This masterpiece (which all of the demos are) does this perfectly. Beautiful, haunting, arrangement...Love Ben's guitar and vocals. No other music touches me like Evanescence. Origin was the brilliant beginning.

[@alexanderchildrey1305]

shes an angel. plain and simple

[@marmarsan1616]

I remember listening to this song while i was in elementary and I completely fell in love with evanescence and now im a junior in highschool and my music taste has changed drastically but i found my old albums and its such a throwback and i feel as if im falling in love all over again

[@marmarsan1616]

And its currently 4:30 am i might add

[@xxdarkmidnightrosexx]

Same listen to this in elementary school and now a junior in high school. time passes by quick. ☺

[@CommunistHam]

Listened in Elementary school and am now a Freshman. You said your taste change, rap?

[@max_trashpanda]

it's funny because I was listening to some of Evanescence's songs when I was in elementary school (like 8 y.o.?) and i'm now 22 xD

[@leoqu1nn]

marmarsan16 me too. \m/

[@zurirobinson2749]

When I was 11, I saw a KZbin video about JonBenet Ramsey's murder that had this song as the backing track. The video terrified me so badly that I could not fall asleep that night, and had trouble sleeping for the next month or so. 12 years later, it still chills me to the bone.

[@randybobandy5538]

Does that video still exist?

[@zurirobinson2749]

@@randybobandy5538 I've never looked it up since and don't want to. It was a very traumatic time in my life made even worse.

[@michellekareis8755]

I love the music. The music is haunting.

[@christopherbernal5977]

I have made a cover: kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4K1aYqqlNqdh80

[@moviedudexd5579]

Evanescence: Bleed Linkin Park: Bleed it out Slipknot: Wait and Bleed

[@LexiSanat]

moviedude XD my 3 favorite bands ever haha

[@alastoria_va]

Evanescence - New Way To Bleed

[@mushroommagic1697]

Canibal Corpse - I cum blood

[@sohaibalmahagri589]

@@LexiSanat Slipknot is nothing even in the same category but hey if you like it you like it

[@babioliveira3515]

soulfly - bleed

[@HappyBar11]

Before more debates continue over the meaning of this song, remember that the lyrics can mean one thing to the writer and many things to many different perspectives. personally, it's obvious to me that it's about witnessing someone you loved being a murderer or some kind of violent evil. but everyone absorbs the song differently, and you can relate it to anything that you feel. I think this is one of the best songs by this band, such a shame its only a demo

[@Eva-iv6cd]

+Reject Sar agreed, I honestly don't care about the song meaning, all I know is that I love this song and the lyrics so

[@tawanahickey9234]

Ok

[@tawanahickey9234]

High school and college of education for a few weeks ago but it will not let us know

[@illuminatedmind1570]

I know the true meaning outside hive minded nature...

[@chocolatelighting1]

I think so too

[@fallenreaper3112]

I feel that this song is about her witnessing a friend being abused by someone who swears she's wrong and that it isn't what it seems, and she needs to tell someone

[@poleless_poledancer]

Raven/Lost In The Upside Down that’s a great theory I never thought about it that way.

[@BloodPwn3r]

God can you imagine her doing this live now with falsetto in the chorus it'd be angelic

[@renataravenhorst_5819]

Totally agree.

[@Ethentent]

I would be bawling

[@ahumanbeing8714]

Amy Lee must be a dark Angel 😍😍

[@some_metalhead]

This song is a bit disturbing, but in the hauntingly beautiful Evanescence way. The lyrics sound like she's witnessing a murder . . .

[@ColdRising]

***** wtf we both have WolfSpirit °O°

[@saltywitch3699]

hippotrot123 the song is about her witnessing someone dieng. It silently references to 'death' itself.

[@Braidedheart]

hippotrot123 so true yet I am swaying side to side loving it o.O

[@redspirit17]

or a possession...

[@FlinchOp]

hippotrot123 exactly I'm back

[@helenzambrana]

to me it's about betrayal, not necessarily in a relationship maybe something a little deeper. but beautiful words.you can hear the pain and fear in her voice.

[@Bruh-qg1xy]

I'll love evanescence till i die This band will always be in my heart So meaningfull songs i just love it P.S.sry about my english if anything is wrong

[@jeanbobbb]

+Elenour Emma yoo apolegie acceptet.

[@xeightlawyerx3575]

jeanbobbb ._. ok i think you are being sacastic...i hope

[@kittycatlolipop2930]

Elenour Emma same

[@thelvadum509]

Elenour Emma Capitalize the i's, when i is alone it gets capitalized always. idky. And between So and meaningful, add many. The rest is perfect english. And yes, I agree. Evanescence is a great band, too bad they don't make any new songs anymore.

[@darchangel2136]

It's okay about your English. We forgive you. :P

[@RookieGlasses]

I love this song... It's so... Dark.. Perfect... Just.. Wow.

[@grilledpook]

+ Yao Wang China!

[@RookieGlasses]

Brianna Denver Hello!

[@grilledpook]

Yao Wang Hi there!

[@RookieGlasses]

Brianna Denver Hello~! What's up, aru?

[@grilledpook]

Yao Wang Welp, I just came back to school after being sick and I have a lot of makeup work -.-;

[@tarahj478]

Back when i heard this sooo long ago it was, and still is the closest song ever to something that ,to this day, I can't explain- it was a premonition, it ended up happening..changed my life forever & I will never let that person's memory be forgotten.

[@_FearNoEvil]

This song has taken on a new significance to me over the last couple years. One word: gaslighting. To the t. One of my favorites of Ev's.

[@NikittyKatAkatsuki]

I love this song... when my friend sings the chorus she actually sounds almost exactly like Amy Lee. She's really good and I wish I could freaking sing like that!!!

[@charliee-]

I remember first listening to this song when I was a kid and very naïve. I assumed she'd seen some guy kill someone and even now I can't get that image out of my mind. Even so, it's a brilliant song and probably one of my absolute favourites by them

[@zuzakrzak4296]

It might be about killing someone. Or any other violence towards other person

[@yogawarriorgirl]

Surface analysis says she witnessed a murder, but what if she witnessed abuse? What if she's a victim of gaslighting? I.e., she saw someone being abused, and she was convinced it was all okay, even though her conscience railed against it. Or, she discovered someone's cutting scars. Or witnessed a suicide. This song has some serious flexibility. It could be any of these things.

[@JJJV292]

If one goes even deeper into emotion, with abstract thoughtforms to accompany, the blood can be viewed metaphorically and the need to tell someone of their witness could be a friend or/and stranger of the pain behind the 'blood'....i love how interpretations are endless when it concerns an individual and a song. So personal for each.

[@JJJV292]

...she could also be speaking of herself as a second party in the lyrics of the very beginning.

[@lisamarieligreci-newton7804]

I actually always assumed it was about a person who had been abused herself (either physically or sexually) but then dissociated and told herself it just wasn't real/happened to somebody else. It's actually kind of interesting to see how many people view it as something completely different.

[@taylorlong112]

I think this song is about witnessing a murder. "We all live, we all die; that does not begin to justify you." Just because people die eventually doesn't give the murderer the right to take someone's life. Also, the chorus sounds like denial, as in denying to believe that you just witnessed a murder.

[@elliesykes6816]

The "I saw her bleed" may also contribute to that theory, aha xD

[@kittycat-ly9jd]

+Ellie Sykes what do you mean it contributes to the theory

[@brtzcake]

that it confirms more than the song is about witnessing a murder

[@Frankie2Jersey]

It's a shame this didn't make it to an album, because it's really good Is it about hallucinating?

[@JackieTheVampire]

I think it's about Amy experiencing a loved one or a really close friend murdering someone, and any is trying to convince herself that it didn't really happen

[@JackieTheVampire]

I hope I helped

[@ipekkomurcu]

back vocals on this are everything

[@sierraeakins3776]

Everyone has their debates but no matter what anyone says I'll always believe it's about cheating and she's using a metaphor of murder or death. Especially with the "I saw her bleed, you heard me breathe and I froze inside myself, I must be dreaming" acting as if she caught him in the act. And of course the chorus, the well known words of the cheater "it's not what it seems, not not what you think". I feel people take songs to literal and need to think more on the metaphorical side of things, especially with music.

[@starlitsky7027]

Well, everyone has their own perspective. It's not wrong to have a different opinion about a song.

[@delilabella8660]

I agree with you

[@tyrahgoltz5221]

Can I ask what you think "I saw her bleed" means in terms of cheating because I'm confused. I'm not having a go at your opinion I just want to know what "I saw her bleed" means in like a cheating sceneries.

[@TheAkatsukibitch]

+Sierra Eakins People are allowed to have different perpectives. It would be boring if everyone had the same point of view, don't you think?

[@izzy3995]

+Tyrah Entertainment maybe it means that she saw her be hurt because of the cheating as well.

[@leonaldasixkiller1196]

Got to love Amy. She's genius!

[@dianac5162]

This song is just so amazing!

[@idabneyboy26]

why isnt this one on an album, one of the best ones!

[@cassieshaffer9083]

Beautiful like the night stars

[@AcroSstMe]

this song and "understanding" are my favorites

[@nicoledasilva1257]

This is the first time I've listened to this song and I loved it

[@parkerschleh]

nicole dasilva same here. Well second time, I listened to it once earlier

[@kikyoleagan]

Just in my mind, not in real life, I must be dreaming. Definitely reminds me of a vampire scene she just witnessed! Lovely song!

[@jcpeters8072]

Every time she says "we all live" I think " we all live in a yellow submarine" every time.

[@caity4153]

HEY HEY HEY HEY!! Another pokemon fan! lolzz

[@jcpeters8072]

***** Cool :3

[@caity4153]

Jc Peters :3333

[@jag0wnsu]

Jc Peters 😂

[@pandoraaphrodite3375]

28 now ...jammed this out in middle school blasting through headphones waiting for the bus good times

[@Melissa-818]

Jesus loves you and he died for you. The Love of God Love is sooo big. He can listen to your sorrow, to your doubt, to your depression, to your joy, to your anxiety... Literally everything ! He cares about you, start to care more about him. Read the Bible if you want to learn more ❤

[@silvergoth1834]

I love it when the lyrics are done in neon letters cause it resonates well with "Evanescence " ❤️

[@chapniak7977]

I love Evanescenes!!! she's the best singer EVER!!!

[@ferrarigirl666]

you mean evanescence and amy is fantastic! i had a meet and greet with the original band... i said that she saved my life....

[@imaeditdatout8791]

You are lying +ferrarigirl666.

[@chapniak7977]

Jeff The Killer how do you know you don't know other people's lives

[@kennedywarren9347]

+'Ima Edit Dat Out Bitch Evenescence helps me survive everyday without feeling like I have to die, or even without hurting myself If I'm lucky

[@jasmijnariel]

Amy is always there... When am in pain, in tears, in loneliness, a broken heart, etc. Amy is ALWAYS there

[@spiderheart8638]

I wish people listen to this when it comes to know about the band. My Immortal and Bring me to life are ok, but this song is beyond this universe especially in 3:42

[@elliesykes6816]

I was playing this infront of my sister and when it said "just in my mind, not real life" she screamed JUSTIN BIEBER!!! I disowned her.

[@derekpayneszubliminals7723]

good!

[@kargirl33]

good

[@avahall4013]

Ellie Sykes good!

[@MakotoKinoSailorJupiter2020]

Dan McMaster I hated him then too

[@gerardwaytrash855]

Screw Justin Bieber

[@TheKathlyn76]

I'm very attracted to this song.I don't really know why. It's interesting

[@christopherbernal5977]

It's like gothic, I have a cover on my channel: kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4K1aYqqlNqdh80

[@Ms4everMyself]

This song makes me think of someone trapped inside their dreams screaming to be released because the nightmares are slowly killing them while on the outside, they look like they are in a peaceful sleep. BEST. SONG. EVER!!!!!!!

[@georginajadepalmer4597]

she is truly a great rock and soul singer in the rock music Amy in my eyes in the queen of rock music she makes rock music sound and feel great out and in side of the soul and heart got to love her and the band

[@aleighmae13]

This reminds me of someone who's depressed and self-harming for the first time in a while, or self-harming on a regular basis and they want someone to see them.

[@darkmoons2905]

Her voice touch the soul 💔

[@MarcosPaulo-jc6gi]

Yesssss...falou tudo viu

[@Animeshyforever]

I find more and more songs by Evanescence everyday, I am so happy!

[@GainedData]

My first impression on the song was that something happened and she tries to tell herself that it never happened. She tells herself that it was just a dream. Correct me if I'm wrong.

[@chapniak7977]

+houstonfam11 That's probally the meaning, although no one knows the true meaning

[@vanessap25]

I don't know how this came of idea of the song. But I think it's relating to her sister Bonnie who died at age 3 from an identified illness when Amy was a kid. She took her sister's death to heart and hard. It devastate Amy Lee and was very hard for Amy to deal with and handle.

[@laurenkuelker4612]

I think the song you are referring to is Hello (by Amy Lee), but I do also think that Bleed could have been the earlier version of Hello (before it got scrapped for whatever reason) or had the same themes as Hello. I think so because the chorus could be referring to denial (which is part of the grieving process and knowing that it was Amy's first time dealing with the concept of death after Bonnie passed away). Also, some artists use the same themes over and over again in their songs. For example, Melanie Martinez talks about fake people in her songs: Dollhouse, Pacify Her, Drama Club, Lunchbox Friends Firedrill, and Copycat. Which they're all different from each other, but the same theme is present throughout those songs.

[@deaclavilis6760]

Like you is for her sister. I think it is about an abusive relationship with a cheater which is the subject of denial by the abused.

[@flitterwit]

I love the way you did "we all live and we all die but". You just made this my favorite lyric video of all time.

[@largo3232]

The Guitars !! Her Voice !! Bit Most Importantly The Message!! This Is ART!!

[@zee-pj7vs]

🇿🇦🔥🔥🔥 I love Amy her voice she is truly a Goddess ❤

[@JackValentinenope]

It may not be murder. Domestic abuse maybe? Or even rape.

[@hugobatista3704]

I was just thinking the same. Nowadays, domestic abuse is a very actual issue in Portugal. Just this year (2019), more than fifty women were killed by their husbands or former husbands. This song seems to describe the drama of someone that is having a hard time understanding that she / he is being abused by the one she /he loves.

[@keving358]

I always felt like she or (the imaginary character in this fictional situation) testified some kind of crime, perhaps a murder or something like that

[@gamingafton2012]

You can do things that can make the soul bleed and no outward evidence....

[@lenkagamine4145]

the line "we all live and, we all die, but that does not begin to justify you" would strongly suggest its murder.

[@midtwilightblue]

I think it might be murder because the pre chorus; “we all live, we all die” and saying that doesn’t justify what “they’ve” done

[@raylenegarcia8830]

Forever gonna listen n love Evanescence....if she’s making more music please let me know

[@ZemeckisTEN]

They did make more music. Back in 2021, they released their 5th studio album (if you count Synthesis) The Bitter Truth. It’s honestly their best album since Fallen (which is saying a LOT).

[@Litji12]

she is so good and i love her voice

[@amalaljohari9358]

I miss THIS evanescence

[@BiomeLeb]

I must be dreaming :(

[@rockmetalpe294]

How can I pretend that I don't see What you hide so carelessly I saw her bleed And you heard me breathe And I froze inside myself And turned away I must be dreaming We all live, we all die, That does not begin to justify you It's not what it seems. Not what you think No, I must be dreaming. It's only in my mind, Not real life. No, I must be dreaming. Help you know I've got to tell someone, Tell them what I know you've done. I fear you, but spoken fears can come true. We all live, we all die, That does not begin to justify you It's not what it seems. Not what you think. No I must be dreaming. It's only in my mind, Not real life. No I must be dreaming. We all live, We all die, That does not begin to justify you It's not what it seems Not what you think No I must be dreaming It's only in my mind Not real life No I must be dreaming Not what it seems Not what you think I must be dreaming Just in my mind Not real life I must be dreaming Add to playlist Size A A Tab Print Correct

[@carmenita5040]

Thanks ! I had it in my head but forgot the title 😊 Only remembered "I must be dreaming "

[@wesleysilva187]

8 years that i absolutely love evanescence

[@ayseturkuvardar7258]

my favorite depression song. i was listening this in my hard times.

[@jasmijnariel]

Going under and My heart is broken are mine...

[@casey7625]

Origin is my favorite Evanescence album💜

[@MissDiva911]

Her voice is too beautiful!! Omg:3

[@maritsa98]

Ok. That's it. This is my favorite song. I can't help it-it's just so BEAUTIFUL :')

[@ashlyncollins7607]

Beautiful.

[@jessicasimplicioreis3824]

Everybody listening??☔☔☔

[@xdark_wings]

That outro... 🖤

[@_FearNoEvil]

This is an anthem about living through gaslighting. One of my favorites.

[@jasminklein2320]

The Song is Amazing

[@jakomioftherose2434]

Gotta love Not For Your Ears. One of their greatest albums.

[@starlitsky7027]

Wait, that's an album from them? I know Origin, Fallen, Anywhere But Home, The Open Door, and Evanescense as their albums. I guess you're talking about some fanmade album. I dunno.

[@jakomioftherose2434]

Caliya Ledesma No, it's a legit album. Have a look on their website. It's an awesome album.

[@starlitsky7027]

Jakomi of the Rose Okay then... Uh, what is it?

[@jakomioftherose2434]

Caliya Ledesma What is what...?

[@starlitsky7027]

Jakomi of the Rose Um, never mind. I was asking for the website. Found it already. I guess that album is new.

[@nylavalentine8667]

I love this song.

[@djeto2525]

This song brings me to tears and this song saved me.

[@maggieirwin1563]

scrolled for 5 min n only saw 1 other comment feeling like its about abuse...I guess thats a good thing to know what its like to live when part of u has died from being abused. u can very easily bleed when being beat w.o dieing

[@maggieirwin1563]

also "what u hide so carelessly" (marks) and "its not what its not what u think" applies to hiding/denying abuse im kinda shocked not many ppl see abuse being the subject as plausible

[@husseinmohammed8654]

I'm crying 😭

[@ayseltina5055]

"to justify you" and "no,i must be dreaming" she saw.

[@Cookieznothere]

2013-2017 still love this song

[@user-hk3eu7bg5y]

Every life has value. Every life is important.

[@avahall4013]

This song reminds me of my past

[@courtneyjohnson7716]

I think this song is about witnessing a murder.

[@SpazzShell]

Kinda got the same vibe. I just thought it was about abuse, seeing as someone called for help but was turned away by the witness because they didn't want to believe it, or didn't want to get caught up in that situation. Evanescence songs are fun to interpret lol

[@alexandramusienko5976]

i don't know why but i think that the song about a mother who find out that her son is a murder and can't believe it and shr don't know what to do because she loves him and don't want to go to the police 😂 this is just what i think (and sorry for my bad english)

[@valentineshorror]

It is

[@xenos_5571]

Touché

[@gemingsimzpletsmurf2108]

I've heard Amy writes some of her songs based on vivid dreams so maybe she had a nightmare which inspired her or something.. I don't know

[@ninaramirez6805]

love this song just got me out of my writer's block. Thank You Evanescence!

[@WhiteKoneko]

The song makes me think of a hero in a story that witnessed a very bloody betrayal at the hands of somebody they least expected, killing or hurting the hero's romantic interest maybe? That's the feel I get every time I listen.

[@Nagome1]

Maybe this song is about suicide, or self harming. Finding someone who commit suicide and these are her thoughts 'no, i must be dream' like its a nightmare she cant wake up from

[@TheMorgueDonator]

why dislike it just dont listen to it and leave -.-

[@kittycat-ly9jd]

I love this song it has so much powerful lyrics in it.:-D

[@anassa79]

Love the song, love the music, love everything!

[@leafericksson6422]

The darkest song by Evanescence

[@ninap1806]

the sounds at 1:35 not the violing but some sort of ringing in the background makes me think that my phone is ringing

[@stefanoskosmos7104]

:-) :-) :-) :-) :-) +&+&+&.&+&!39%

[@stefanoskosmos7104]

:-) :-) :-) :-) :-) +&+&+&.&+&!39%

[@zekethomas3108]

Thats just a bass with alot of Wah

[@TheLastRealch1ck]

this song is so haunting i love it so much :)

[@ashleysmith5169]

i just love all of their old songs. no idea why. so good.

[@WingedDarkWolf]

The thing I love about the whole Evanescence band is that their music is just so.... Real. Unlike those Lady Gaga songs. These are about life, death, and things inbetween!

[@ericworley4361]

The only thing I can come up with that fits all the aspects of the lyrical story is this: A child witnesses her father abusing her pregnant mother, and causing her to miscarry. That's why it says "we all live/die, that does not justify..." Those two lines are key to understanding what is actually going on, and fittingly, are very difficult to explain with any of the other possible scenarios the other lyrics bring to mind. If not for these two lines I would be inclined to say it's about one family member, (either the mother or another sibling) catching their husband/dad molesting their daughter/sister, and wrestling with the fear of what might happen if they tell someone.

[@benitawillliamsthebtsarmy7628]

I miss this song so much

[@juliodarkestden3848]

This song represent what was my life 2 years ago!

[@elliebrooks1510]

Oh why?

[@chapniak7977]

+Julio darkest den how?