*Even better than last time!* EVANESCENCE🎵 MY IMMORTAL REACTION

[@drummerjosh2112]

While Amy Lee’s sister did pass away when she was very young, this song was written by the guitarist (Ben Moody) about a family member passing away. Amy Lee wrote “Hello” about her sister, and shockingly enough, it’s even more heartbreaking than My Immortal. I highly recommend checking that one out as well. Her voice is hauntingly beautiful and it penetrates straight to your soul. She really is a one-of-a-kind talent

[@robinlynnfox2807]

It was her brother.

[@dirtysmity]

@@robinlynnfox2807 As a child, the Evanescence singer lost her sister Bonnie to an unidentified illness. Two decades later, in 2018, her younger brother Robby died after suffering severe epilepsy.

[@rodoxag9117]

Also, her song 'Like You' is also dedicated to her sister, and what a powerful song that is.

[@jeremylarson6267]

thankfully we all die eventually

[@kevenbridges9433]

Joshua you are right Ben Moody did write this. He wrote it when he was 17 after his grandfather died.

[@williamschluderberg3695]

Her voice is both angelic and haunting at the same time. I'm convinced that she is proof that elves once existed.

[@Lycanthromancer1]

Not enough egotistical hatred in her soul for that. Unless you're taking about Keebler elves.

[@IceMetalPunk]

@@Lycanthromancer1 I think many fey myths have them being more mischievous than truly hateful.

[@Lycanthromancer1]

@@IceMetalPunk "Haha, he accidentally slept in a mushroom ring and got stuck in Faerie for a day, and when he returned, it was 100 years later and he crumbled to dust!" Innocent little scamps, the lot of them.

[@IceMetalPunk]

@@Lycanthromancer1 I mean, but... it's not the faeries' fault time runs differently in their world! As my favorite fey creature once said, "time is a weird soup" 😁

[@Lycanthromancer1]

@@IceMetalPunk The original faerie tales were horror stories. They did such things on purpose, because they were all murderous sociopaths that enjoyed pulling metaphorical wings off of metaphorical flies. Disney just about threw their backs out whitewashing it all.

[@TonyHavenMusic]

Very underrated studio vocalist, she really holds up decades later, so emotive

[@MikeB12800]

Really don’t think she’s underrated. Think it’s well recognized thats she’s an amazing singer. Just cause she doesn’t go mainstream and sell out doesn’t mean people don’t know and say she’s an incredible singer!

[@keithlabeau8790]

I feel like she's pretty well celebrated. Maybe not mainstream but I'm pretty sure she's lauded as a top tier vocalist by many.

[@jamesy1979]

Not just studio, she sounds amazing live as well

[@fletcherleroux5387]

Not even joking, this song makes me cry everytime I hear it. Not because I have anything associated with the song but because Amy Lee has a way of putting so much of her emotions into her singing I can't help myself. And I've been listening to them since they started and it still hits just as hard

[@elizabethluker8356]

Me too! Cry every single time!

[@da_blade5040]

It Pulls on Your Heart Strings!! 😢😢 Soooo Beautifully

[@jericoba]

Same. Crying every time.

[@brutisfletcher]

Same!

[@brettkenschaft4239]

Ditto. Queensryche's "Silent Lucidity" too.

[@opethdan2408]

I love this reaction couple. Two beautiful people just enjoying new music together. Who could ask for any less or more?

[@seandobson6221]

Amy Lee has one of the most amazing, beautiful, and haunting voices of ANY female artist in existence. If you listen to Amy and you don’t get chills you have no pulse or soul.

[@jamesmcd71]

I love watching these 2 because you see the different ways music impacts people. Brad analyzes the words and looks for the message. Lex surrenders to the music and allows it to consume her.

[@ps5392]

This song fits me every time I hear it. Amy’s vocals are so unbelievably, perfectly haunting.

[@krisfrederick5001]

The best part is she's incredibly shy and real, you can't fake this emotion or auto-tune it.

[@twisted2291]

The proof of this is this song done live. The video shows some of the realness of her voice that isn't fully polished with studio work. Live performances will always show the real talent. The interaction with the crowd can not be faked. Amy Lee is one of those "You have got to see live" shows. It take her awesomeness to the next level.

[@PanglossDr]

Why the hate?

[@Kevin-qp6ow]

@@PanglossDr what?

[@randybaker6042]

Not even Brad is immune to My Immortal. Just goes to show.

[@stevensimpson8231]

You should really watch the video you will definitely enjoy it

[@rastomasstanford7708]

No one is.

[@rastomasstanford7708]

@@stevensimpson8231 I mean fell in love with the Cranberries lol.

[@dizzle7558]

He loves female vocalists..

[@Darkaria668]

@@stevensimpson8231 wow didn't think of that so I'm not supposed to eat the video?

[@herringtonfarms5927]

Ben and Amy together are magic. That sound and song structure of the original Evanescence will never be replaced. It just hits home on so many levels.

[@Axetwin]

When this song was new, my sister's passing was still fresh and this song broke me. Hard. Twenty years later and this song can still get me if it catches me at the wrong moment.

[@dabbadoo2226]

Nobody cares

[@alexthegemini666]

@@dabbadoo2226 I care.

[@dabbadoo2226]

@@alexthegemini666 you care about people looking for sympathy from KZbin comments? Gooooood for yooooouuuuu your probably the guy writing comments to dead people on KZbin telling them you miss them, get a life guy find a hobby

[@alexthegemini666]

@@dabbadoo2226 Sure man 👍

[@ronaldmorgan7632]

'Hello' and 'Like You' are about her 3yr old sister who died when Amy was 6. This song is about Ben's grandfather, as others have said.

[@williamwhitley3400]

The songs that bring tears to my eyes is this song and Hate Me by Blue October.

[@joecrowder1334]

the live version of Hate Me in Texas is awesome!

[@Jaster832]

Add Last Kiss by Pearl Jam and Stand By Me by Ben E. King for me.

[@andrewlangendorfer2925]

This song always breaks me...Amy Lee is a goddess...I love her,not a crush...LOVE her,all their songs

[@Leftylobber]

I have a crush on Amy Lee. How can you not???

[@da_blade5040]

I'm there with ya! ☹️ She's Amazing

[@martypadilla3470]

I’ve loved Amy since Bring Me To Life came out. One of the highlights of my life was seeing Evanescence live on Valentine’s Day 2004.

[@andrewlangendorfer2925]

Psh I've been a fan of hers since the 90s

[@thebrhinocerous]

Very beautiful song, and the official video is just as beautiful. I never got deep into Evanescence, but they really are a great band.

[@galerios1]

Amy Lee is arguably one of the most amazing artists of all time. And she definitely doesn't get the credit she deserves.

[@paulshaw9953]

Live this is fun... look around and sooooooo many people crying their eyes out

[@gavynchapman1808]

😂 Brad’s reaction when Lex said she thought it was maybe about an imaginary friend

[@annaoswald5943]

Brad: What??? You think it's that???

[@Pugiron]

Lex is kinda stupid

[@gavynchapman1808]

@@Pugiron asked?

[@chaddon7685]

My reaction, too lol

[@Ntrock459]

@@gavynchapman1808 Lex is lowkey not all there i think. her comments are just so like elementary, if you didnt see or hear her you'd think she was like 9 yrs old.

[@patmullen7597]

I thought Lex's idea that it may be about an imaginary friend was brilliant. Lex's mind is so open and deep that it makes me sad I don't encounter more people like her in the world. You're a very fortunate man Brad, to have the love of such an amazing woman.

[@rossmudie9298]

You can see where lex is coming from, i chuckled initially but after the thought was installed in my mind you start thinking, lyricism is great.

[@JoyoSnooze]

He struck pure gold.

[@chaddon7685]

I mean... it's outside the box but makes no sense. The entire chorus involves physical touch and what she did for them. Imaginary friends are about what the IF does for the kid.

[@traviswilliamking]

They already have a song called "Imaginary" You should hear that one.

[@UnLinK3D]

It's about her cat 🐈 who's gone

[@Bubbs1234]

I love this song. Heard it 1000 times but still makes me cry and gives me goosebumps.

[@filipinodad6837]

Lex- “I see dead people” 😱 Brad- “you talking to your imaginary friends” Lex- “uhhuh, yeah”

[@amymeyers8090]

Such a beautiful talent. Pianist, writer, composer, amazing vocalist, rock band leader!

[@DanielFrost21]

Amy's voice is hauntingly beautiful. As Lex said, I could listen to her sing anything.

[@thickasabrick2293]

She's definitely Gothic if that's the word you're looking for

[@rick5908]

This song is always painful to hear for me. You live through the surgeries, the chemo and she still looks healthy and strong and in three weeks you watch the person you spent 3/4s of your life with, since childhood, die. These words capture everything and almost 7 years later she's still here even though she's just ash. Believe me Imortal is the right name.

[@lordweldatron.9955]

Sorry for your loss .

[@PongoXBongo]

Same. Not for a partner, but for my father, and also from cancer. He toughed it out with over-the-counter pain meds until it was already at stage four (pancreatic that spread), by then of course it was was too late to recover from. And I never really gave myself room to fully process it because "I had to be strong" for my mother. So, it still bubbles up from time to time (especially with emotional songs like this). What's even sadder, for me, is that it happened in my college years, when I was still a young, dumb kid who was "too cool" to hang out with his parents. We were just starting to connect on an adult father-son level when he was snatched away in less than a year. I recently moved back to my hometown to be closer to my mother so that never happens again.

[@lorierush6561]

Condolences

[@Britbuldogg]

I absolutely love peoples reaction to hearing Amy for the first time.

[@eZTarg8mk2]

saw her play this live at the Apollo in London....barely a dry eye in the house. note perfect performance. she's just an incredible singer

[@primusfan87]

Amy lee's voice is so angelic, i have a hard time keeping from crying

[@greenpeasuit]

I once went to a training session for a job. One of the women there was married to a guy that had ended up in a car wreck, and suffered brain damage such that he was reduced to the IQ of a 5 year old. She was now responsible for a full grown toddler whom she loved but could not return the love as an adult. She opened up and expressed some of the feelings she had. The conflict of love, yet angry that she was robbed of what she once had and the responsibility thrust upon her, the loneliness of it all. This song took on new meaning for me since hearing her story.

[@thesentry3497]

My Immortal is and always will be my favorite song of all music. I have had a huge crush on her my whole life.

[@Isinforblood]

She really have a whole voice of a chillin dark angel 🖤

[@jocrisantos3541]

Thanks for reacting to Evanescence. I love her voice. Once of a kind.

[@titusprime5240]

You should definitely react to the song “Broken” by the band Seether featuring Amy Lee.

[@craigcroy4615]

No not broken. I think going under is a better next choice. Don't get me wrong broken is awesome, but going under heavier.

[@lindacolombo8364]

I agree Titus!!!

[@craigcroy4615]

I like broken more then going under. She just said likes the heavier stuff more. This is a play list thing. I think they should listen to her first and second CD back-to-back with broken in the middle would be cool with me. But I mean Evanescence is like my favorite band

[@southempireproductions5183]

They shouldve listened to Broken before this. She was in a relationship with what's his name from seether for a long time. She wrote this song about him after they separated.

[@craigcroy4615]

I could have swore that he wrote the song cuz he has a version where he just does it by himself. Yeah I know they were in a relationship.

[@Plan9-3127]

Truly one of the most beautiful songs ever put to paper.. It brings tears to my eyes every time I hear it. So full of emotion and embodies everything that music should be.... I enjoy your reactions very much, and one married man to another Brad that is one BEAUTIFUL woman you have sitting there next to you. Lex you are so full of life and genuinely fun. Congrats to both of you!!

[@tomjudge7920]

The video to this song her eyes are impossible to look away from .... so beautiful

[@litalchok1994]

One of the greatest love songs in history.

[@alexni1161]

one of the most beautiful things I have heard.

[@Angela-sq1jz]

This song is ridiculously beautiful! Makes me tear up every time.

[@danaberman6929]

She has one of the best vocal sounds.. Amazing.

[@MichaelFoster1969]

Close - it's about not being able to let go of the grief you feel for a loved one who has died because the love for them was so strong.

[@jeremyg8568]

Brad had to take deep swallow the first line Amy sang, me too, every time I hear her songs. Thank you guys for doing this band.

[@kristyperry6846]

Yes, her voice is both haunting & Angelic at the same time!!

[@jeffbolton9699]

That's why I love lyrics like this, it could be someone who left her or it could be someone who died. It could be a lover, or a friend or a parent, it inspires many different emotions to many different people.

[@williamdread391]

If you can't hear the beauty in that, I have nothing for you. The talent in that woman needs to be encouraged.

[@anondandalus]

I have probably heard this song hundreds of times. I still get goosebumps listening to her voice on this song.

[@emmett-amber5456]

My mom passed when I was 17. This was a reminder of our day to day relationship when the song first came out and it screams even louder now that she's no longer here. I wrote these lyrics on my bedroom wall when it came out (I had to use a cassette tape to record it when it came on the radio and write the lyrics before I bought the CD) and can honestly say it's still there to this day.

[@TheRustyGuitarist]

Amy is just such a talent!! Love her voice!!

[@nickscott478]

Hello and Lithium are amazing as well

[@SimonTrepanier1]

I love that you guys listen to music with open hearts, fun to watch !

[@davidsanders5788]

You mentioned she’s an angel. You need to see the video and it will definitely give you that feeling.

[@alexaverson3655]

Love the Evanescence reactions. This song brings back so much memories, I get emotional everytime i hear it. I'd love for you to react to Lithium next, or Call me when you're sober.

[@paulgourdie]

Very time I hear this song gives me the chills she is one of my favourite hard Rock singers she is awesome love amy lee ❤

[@clintjo2377]

Amy Lee has a voice of a angel !😇

[@sleven909]

This song came out when my mom was passing. It's so sad I almost cry everytime I hear it.

[@Z_Snowball]

to me this song transcends the romantic. lifelong childhood friend/sibling or parent and child, or any relationship that was years upon years and built on experiences both good and bad that cannot be faked or described with words really, Amy's voice is what makes these words so effective. a lesser voice that couldn't hit those high notes would not bring me to tears every time I hear it.

[@sheridetiveaux1839]

I WISH when people request songs they would suggest WHICH VID TO WATCH!!! This video is BEAUTIFUL and makes the song even BETTER!!! UGHHHHH

[@amyaeschbach3581]

This song always touches so deep. Cried many times to this. Yes that someone she speaking about is truly gone to another place. From an older sibling to a younger sibling who passed away at a young age from cancer. She help take care of her, wiped away her tears, sat with her when she screamed. Wish you guys would’ve talked about Emilio’s voice. Most beautiful female voice around, always hunting and always perfect. Classically trained. I beg you guys to start watching the videos on your channel even when you’re worried about getting blocked. The small screen and pausing helps. But watching Amy sing this song I had so much, as in a quite a few songs I’ve seen you react to without the videos. Love your reaction lex! ❤️❤️✌️✌️😢

[@impek667]

EVERYBODY'S FOOL NOW PLEASE ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@craigcroy4615]

Everybody's fools a very good choice to another heavier song from the first album

[@_type1rider]

Amy Lee is absolutely amazing. Her voice is incredible!

[@Dormy69]

Amy Lee is one of a few that can make you feel the pain with her voice , she is and angel love her voice

[@joseantoniolarrea7152]

Perfect song. Haunting... after all these years

[@yrankin1]

Great reaction to a stunning song. Love y’all.

[@gerbie42]

It's time, I think you guys would love Alter Bridge. Their vocalist can sing sing, they have meaningful songs, greatly composed, just all-round great stuff! Try Alter Bridge - Blackbird

[@omarhtiouech3505]

you are my guy , blackbird is so underrated , for me it's one of the best songs ever, better than most legendary songs like bohemian rhapsody

[@leeana6394]

Amazing song!!

[@fishfood8719]

"Words Darker Than Their Wings" Live at the Royal Albert Hall. The epic high note!

[@alanmitchell6302]

Sometimes hearing the story behind a song can surprise you and like it even more because you like your taught on it and the real story

[@pmcclaren1]

This is one of the Most Beautiful LOVE SONGS of all time. Amy Lee has a GOD-given gift that she shares with the world. She in attractive lady. This a voice that musically-trained people go to Juillard School of Music for example. This is just her; touches the soul and spirit; INCREDIBLE and Beautiful.

[@eddyc9339]

Such a great band and your reaction is so genuine. I hope to see more evanescence reactions. Going under or imaginary are some of my personal favourites.

[@craigcroy4615]

I love imaginary to that's like one of my favorites too

[@vholcomb78]

You have to checkout Halestorm (the have a great female singer). Love Bites and I Miss the Misery would be good songs to start with.

[@shanemwood]

Her dad used to work for my business as a spokesperson. Super nice family. The video for this song is a 'must see' - it brings it to another level.

[@brianbrooks1285]

Her voice is pitch perfect

[@murmuratingmemories]

Yo, when metalheads do ballads, magic happens.

[@woodywoodman2319]

Absolutely Loved watching Lex get into thier Call Me when You're Sober!!! So purdy... and she obviously felt those words! Cudos!!!

[@GotSyncV]

Brad you hit the nail on the head. It’s truly about a loss of life. Weather it’s a loved one or a widow. This song means so much to me. And to so so many others.

[@woodywoodman2319]

She can SANG!!!! Plus her lyrics have such a deep meaning!

[@3rdjrh]

Lex hit it on the head with the dark disney princess analysis 💯

[@stephenspiers5086]

She's got one of them voices that could bring you out of a rage .

[@michaelpalma6346]

Damn I remember listening to this song when it first came out. You know a song is good when all these years later it sounds even better. Pure emotion.

[@craigcroy4615]

I remember I listen to the original version on the CD and then when the band version came out on the radio, I was singing every word to it. It was awesome

[@craigcroy4615]

She's going to love Evanescence. You should listen to Going Under next that's one of her heavier songs. I love the whole first album 😍

[@greeneyes674]

I cry every time I hear Amy sing. It's just that emotional.

[@coynieuk]

All he Best and keep up the imaginative and highly articulate descriptions of these tracks you are right more then you are wrong Long Live Brad & Lex

[@myopicseer]

Brad and Lex. The men always analyze the lyrics, the women just hear the voice and music (mood). Brad is like a hound dog on those lyrics, sniffing out every nuance of meaning.

[@tinaprice3497]

This song is about losing a love one through death, I believe, but trust me it can mean so much more as well. When I went through my divorce, of a 15 yr marriage, and child together, this song carried me through so much. Like I felt every ounce of that song in my body, soul, and mind. There were so many nights that this song got me through some of the loneliest of nights. Heart wrenching nights where I just wanted to die physically cause emotionally I was already dead with the pain inside me. I was so numb. This song was the only way of healing, this song and God Almighty. So this song is an out of that pain on so many differet levels. It can be for anyone's reasoning.

[@crazyjacobins305]

Amy is such a ROCK STAR!

[@marktringale6951]

This song is about losing a child. Listen with that context and it’s even more emotional.

[@davidkamer745]

Amy Lee has one of the most hauntingly beautiful voices I've ever heard.

[@robinschulze934]

I can’t listen to this song without crying for my son who passed away a few years ago!!!!

[@mysticsopath6075]

I dead ass was watching your bring me to life reaction yesterday and thought damn they gotta hear my immortal

[@jacobbritt3835]

When I read the song title it makes me think of a person that I love that you believe will always be there (my immortal).

[@marioMartinez-kp4it]

It’s awesome when you love most genres of music but most don’t give other genres of music a chance

[@lldrax2]

The lines about wiping away tears and fighting away fears made me think that someone did die, not a friend or lover, but a child.

[@scarce911]

Like before listening... I'm a 47 year old metal head, and this song makes me emotional every time..

[@Robett11]

U just feel ur heart racing up when that drum hits...❤️🖤

[@ronolson2820]

This song always makes me cry , having suffered the loss of 3 older siblings at young ages. .

[@AndreaStote]

Before she even starts singing i get tears in my eyes.... this song!

[@nateaurand1601]

If you're looking for that vampire vibe in Evenesences, check out the song Going Under. But make sure it's the music video. The video really drives home the vampire theme

[@slongf15]

Amy's voice along with her eyes....😍

[@matthewkendall5235]

I love the video of her performing this song - she looks like an angel, no one notices her moving through the scenes of this video and if you look carefully - her feet never once touch the ground...

[@TheGolfbum4]

Oh man you should have watched the official video. Beautiful and haunting at the same time.

[@VigorMortis413]

as someone who grew up learning to sing to evanescence, i struggle singing this song simply because ill start crying while singing it. the notes are very powerful when youre feeling grief

[@joeschwartz4826]

so fun watching your reaction to great music. keep it up