Every American Idol Winner Audition From Kelly Clarkson To Now - Who's Your Favorite?

[@TalentRecap]

Who is replacing Simon Cowell on America's Got Talent? Read more HERE: talentrecap.com/kelly-clarkson-will-replace-simon-cowell-on-americas-got-talent-after-bicycle-injury/

[@pieroneit260]

Kl

[@cookingwithsamontheblackst3282]

@Brian Simmons 0]

[@enatasaputra]

@Brian Simmons the creator of the show is Simon Fuller..... Not Simon Cowell

[@khliehshrieh4777]

Nobody

[@alotashoes]

⁸7 it 8,ì

[@emppu1012]

Kelly using expressions like "cool beans" and "score!" makes me feel old and young at the same time XD

[@emilykirk9890]

*cough no one cares @First Last cough*

[@EvanRockwell1]

@@k819849 I was like 15 or 16 in the Midwest when she was on and "cool beans" was a phrase back then.

[@LaurenJayx0]

I am old, yet never said things like that 😆

[@LaurenJayx0]

@@k819849 Same here, I remember when I was young only old ladies would say things like that. 😆 it wasn't just that it was "uncool" it was just a but ridiculous if I'm honest.

[@EvanRockwell1]

@@LaurenJayx0 Well..you've never ever been cool.

[@singtorres6049]

Kelly is my all time favourite. Bless her soul. Kelly was so talkative and likeable from beginning. Kelly was meant to be a judge from before.

[@nolimitkk2715]

Ikr when she sat in the chair I was like she sealed her faith 👏🏾👏🏾

[@libradawg9]

I could've swore that after her audition Simon quipped *I don't like her * despite sending her to Hollywood. Weird, he loved her almost as much as Randy did.

[@rogersmith434]

Cool beans.

[@nickriddle4566]

Kelly Clarkson's audition alone was monumental it showed how amazing she was but also showed her fun loving side which is why she now has her own talk show

[@TopWorldTalentHD]

Cool beans, LOL.

[@lindykaz8921]

Didn't you see the devil horns and her tongue sticking out after her audition? She fit right in with most idols before she even got on stage. My God is Jesus Christ I don't think hers is. Just saying...

[@cayliiiiii]

@@lindykaz8921 she was doing the “rock on” symbol lol. Lay off the kool aid.

[@davesworld7961]

@@lindykaz8921 The devil symbol has the hand facing the other direction

[@dasmuss6174]

Lindy Kaz geez ease up would ya haha

[@abuvveUaLL01]

Crazy how the audition etiquette/protocol evolved. Loved how they used to do it. The "stop" by the judges because they knew what they needed to hear. It was a real talent show. Now it's all for production moments. Everyone that goes far has to have a "story". The OG winners were flat out good and were turned into superstars.

[@faiththesequel]

THIS - if it's about talent, it shouldn't be about the person with the most drama/heartstrings but a lot of reality shows have gone down that path.

[@phillipt1697]

Watching this I feel like the last couple were "plants". Like picked by the producers to win the show or at least make it to the final group.

[@abuvveUaLL01]

@@phillipt1697 I always feel similarly with these shows in recent years. They find their marketable people and ride them to the end for viewership. Alejandro IMO wasn't the superstar singer that should be an AI winner like the OG seasons saw. VERY talented man yes I will not take that away from him. But he's someone that was very easy to market for the new generation.

[@marysmith5133]

The early years were real. As time goes by, it becomes rehearsed and directed. The singers still sing great...but it's all been written out. Too bad.

[@JesusRelentlessLove]

Couldn't agree more

[@ThatHowTo]

I literally love Kelly Clarkson so much omg. the best part is she was 20 then and she has not changed a bit! She’s amazing!

[@shariahall2011]

And the fact she just turned 40!!! And still amazing

[@trueschrider5823]

no she literally looks the exact same

[@ivorysisco9467]

@@trueschrider5823 then yes

[@Mostopinionatedmanofalltime]

She has changed whatcha talking about? She's fat now bless her heart ❤️

[@xxoxEMxoxx]

@@MostopinionatedmanofalltimeAnd you have an awful personality. Bless your heart ❤️

[@m8trxd]

Kelly Clarkson should get a percentage of American Idol profits. She really launched the show for them.

[@lucyanderson329]

HOW DOYOU FIGURE THAT

[@XxFWLxX311]

@@lucyanderson329 who tf you yelling at

[@cougarelli]

You realize Kelly was a nobody...until this show...right?

[@mynameislola6098]

@@XxFWLxX311 whyy was that so funny😭😭

[@chrissisk88]

She didn't even know what she was auditioning for lol

[@ZoeyPaigeLunaPhD]

Kelly wasn’t remotely nervous as the show wasn’t “a thing” yet

[@itsalljokesman9884]

See you can say this but also understand that because it was so new she had every reason to be nervous. First season, dude. That’s enough to make me crap my pants. You set the tone for the show.

[@actuallyterry]

Kelly Clarkson is the GOAT She seems like her personality hasn't really changed.

[@christinecorney]

Does GOAT stand for something?

[@actuallyterry]

@@christinecorney Greatest Of All Time

[@christinecorney]

Thank you

[@AliceA333]

I do really like Kelly's personality AND voice, she's really cool on "the voice". My GOAT is Jeremiah Lloyd Harmon because Kelly wasn't writing songs when she auditioned. Jeremiah is a prodigy.

[@StewNWT]

@@AliceA333 jeremiah is the single best person on not to win the show aside from Adam lambert and JHud

[@saraanneaz]

Wow! Carrie Underwood's voice has not changed, it is still just as amazing.

[@missaamane8580]

Agreed

[@melissacobb8805]

I still get massive goosebumps when I hear Carrie's audition.

[@raelanhoops9070]

😂😂😂😂

[@UltimoDogLover]

As it should. Carrie is 40. A woman's voice naturally peaks in her 30s and with good technique and diligence can stay at that peak for many years before age starts taking its toll.

[@Joe_Parmesan]

She straight up dominated her season. Not one week in the Bottom 3

[@taylorneal6209]

All I have to say is Fantasia KILLED it when she sang killing me softly!

[@damaxpowerway]

Kelly walked in and took over Hollywood from her first 5 seconds on set with Ryan... Complete with joking tiffs with Simon and Ryan as if they had been show biz friends for years. "Come-on Man! Pull through!"

[@katscratchfever3506]

💯 💯 this competition was made for her.

[@rydbthatsme]

Kelly is legit the best IDOL hands down. Everything about her is so effortless!

[@kylebrennan6028]

I dunno, Carrie's voice acapella, alone could of won the whole competition.

[@rydbthatsme]

@@kylebrennan6028 she’s only really good for country music tbh

[@imemotionallystable7109]

@@rydbthatsme i adore carrie but i cant help but agree

[@smiley3303]

Carrie says hold my beer.

[@dinarubaiyak8962]

100% Agreed

[@brendamj28]

Jordan Sparks is so beautiful with a voice to match.

[@jannananaa]

Sooo beautiful ❤️

[@Laura-pi8ro]

Agree.

[@xoxoemilyxoxo3922]

I love how Randy told Carrie to work on her stage presence 😂 I went to a concert her concert this past summer, and she was the most ENGAGING performer I’ve ever seen!

[@KFWeld40]

Working with performance coaches most definitely enhanced her. It’s funny, her Heart performance on the show was one of her best but she was uncomfortable outside her country zone. She’s come so far and just gets better.

[@christar9527]

She didn’t have it back then. Maybe she’s improved by now. I’m not a fan.

[@JplayboyJ]

Sounds like she took his advice

[@youtuber-zt1fq]

I saw her when she first got big and she was amazing!

[@frankinsaneandmyrrh1202]

this was a long time ago, she was more awkward and unsure back then. biiig stage presence now though!

[@jessicakelly6452]

Carrie gives me goosebumps anytime she sings A cappella. She’s incredible then and now. 🥺💗

[@jamiesung4755]

She really is amazing 💕

[@twinkstar7738]

I love how sweet and humble she was on this audition.

[@websrfr8454]

Have been thru her hometown on my way to TX. There is a sign at the North end of town says "Checotah, OK - Home of Carrie Underwood American Idol Winner 2005

[@twinkstar7738]

@@websrfr8454 I went to Burleson soon after Kelly won. The sign on their Dairy Queen said, “Congratulations Kelly!”

[@websrfr8454]

@@twinkstar7738 I have friends in Burleson, Texas. Did not realize she is from there.

[@jordanmichelle9042]

I was in TEARS when the last girl went on. Such a talented, beautiful, and kind soul. She deserves every bit of success and so much more!

[@roxanardh]

Me too, she was so genuine and pure 😢

[@richardbradley6038]

I agree

[@aubreybondoc]

The way she cried when telling how most people just pretend to care when they need something :( Idk what kind of childhood she had but I'm sure that made her a strong and genuine person

[@sazennonumber]

Yes. And I was in tears too. I felt how much it meant to her. And what a great singer she is.. wow!

[@unikkorns]

FML applying my make-up while watching this 😂

[@sleepforever9793]

12:16 "work a bit more on the emotion" Carrie: I DUG MY KEY INTO THE SIDE OF HIS-

[@AndySaenz]

Pretty little souped up 4 wheel ride...

[@riss5693]

This comment 😂😂

[@meganarey6883]

😂😂

[@bzleo2003]

Lol yes!

[@elliewillow4556]

The more boys I meet the more I love my dog - Carrie Underwood

[@SpiralMystic]

Never mind predicting a successful singing career, Kelly’s audition predicts a talk show host!

[@stephy369]

FR

[@ithamarlowe2629]

🤣 She just has that energy

[@yaboi156]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@morgan.bullock]

I was so fortunate to have been interviewed by Kelly on her show and she is 100% the same bubbly, super genuine, extremely kind person she always has been!! forever a kc fan💕

[@lucasortiz6826]

Wow I just searched you and you're legit! 💯🙏🏽💜

[@aishac6790]

You are extremely talented as well!

[@rachexl]

comment aged poorly lol

[@lifem2038]

Jordin with that voice at 16 was insane!!

[@otondreus1032]

Yes!! Jordin can sing her ass off

[@bratschebread]

Love the fact that Simon was like "this guy is never going to make it to public voting" after Taylor and the next camera shot when Jordin sings, theres a huge picture of Taylor Hicks right behind him.

[@mariamarrero4179]

Yes!!! I noticed that too!!!!

[@Ceares]

Simon literally pushed Taylor through, he's one of the few contestants that I think Simon genuinely hated his style/schtick(whichever you consider it) and since people loved to hate Simon, they sided with Taylor. Not to say Taylor doesn't have a nice voice, but the more Simon hated him, the more people voted for him.

[@aaronbrooks1232]

😂😂😂 I thought the same thing when I noticed that as well.

[@MrAntoniocanada2002]

Karma is a bitch! :) Simon must have learned his lesson.

[@frederickgeneroso4254]

Taylor actually beat a lot of good singers in that particular season of American Idol. These include Chris Daughtry, Katharine McPhee and Kelly Pickler... Nobody could have predicted Taylor would win it all the way and his biggest critic was Simon Cowell of course.

[@autumnatlas7467]

When Kelly said "Score" was so cute 😂

[@jcee6886]

Totally

[@queenoftheworld1]

I remember the year with Phil Phillips. He went through a lot medically during this and he powered through like a champ. It was pretty inspiring.

[@kimhiatt1294]

So true. And he was really the first to blaze the trail for being unique!

[@ilovebabyyoda712]

@@kimhiatt1294 He was great! But I wouldn't say he was very unique...he obviously was very inspired by Dave Matthews Band(which wasn't a bad thing, I enjoyed his cover he did on the show)but yeah he was good, just not unique in my opinion.

[@lesterpark7539]

@@kimhiatt1294 Unique? As a White Boy With a Guitar? LOL. Jessica Sanchez should have won that season.

[@makaylagardner5794]

Jordin Sparks is one of my favorites. It was great to see her audition!

[@shefaf]

Phillip Phillips will always be my favourite winner. I remember him winning so damn well. We now own all his albums.

[@wagonmaster1974]

Broke a guitar string and never missed a beat or slowed down. Very good!

[@dazem8]

I liked Thriller so much better... showed his creativity in how it was arranged and also playing the guitar. idk why he didnt choose that to begin with. That was the last AI season I watched.

[@Lori_in_CT]

He was suffering from kidney stones the whole season. I had one last year and I thought I was dying and couldn’t imagine doing anything other than lying on the floor. Home was a great song. My friend gifted me a cat named Phillip that year. His song was Home. Recently he was very ill and was hospitalized for four days. I was panicked when I brought him home because I had to feed him through a tube. As I was driving back P-Squared was on the radio. I knew he would be fine. I never had a cat who had his own song.

[@conniesandel7820]

Carrie Underwood's simplicity is her greatest gift that gives her voice range that brings her sound to the basic of ordinary life. She has a very wholesome disposition! Easy to like personality.

[@tcconnection]

Yes when they said more stage presence, I thought her voice speaks all we need

[@kc26119]

It is too bad it went to her head big time!!!!

[@dianeschultz3229]

@@kc26119 I believe you're talking about Kelly Clarkson.

[@toughtaurus7270]

@@dianeschultz3229 Proof?

[@gavino681]

@@dianeschultz3229 hold up.... what? Carrie and Kelly are some of the most humble artists in today’s industry

[@absisfabs873]

Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood are the best this show had ever produced.

[@angelaforshey2224]

Adam Lambert..and fantasia were my favorite also

[@Jennisch55]

Chris Daughtry.

[@kerizmahnicholle2349]

Jennifer Hudson Phillip Phillips

[@yuukirin3758]

Adam lambert

[@jaivionparks4988]

And Jordin sparks

[@theonlycontessa8771]

Fantasia, is, and always has been a class act. Her tribute at Aretha’s funeral said it all.🌟

[@treyjones1958]

Rih Right some of these people only going by skin color cause it's clear that Fantasia is the best

[@theonlycontessa8771]

@@treyjones1958 absolutely! The rest of them only wish, they could ‘sang’ like her. Fantasia touches your soul and shines mightily more!

[@nina_summers]

Omg yessss it’s like a beautiful lullaby

[@ryanmitchener275]

Fantasia is a stunning artist! Ahhhhh I love that woman 👑

[@jonhanson6128]

i never really cared for her . and i just dont know why

[@markgwapo2918]

I really like the diversity of the winners from Season 1 to 7.

[@katscratchfever3506]

And the best part is that the judges didn’t choose the winners; the voters did. I think that’s one reason this show gained such popularity!

[@marissadonelson2035]

they still do a great job with diversity...? whether its the type of music genre the winners sing, or race/background diversity.

[@markgwapo2918]

@@marissadonelson2035 i mean genre

[@bruceleeroy8302]

Yeah, it became super predictable after that. Just a twangy accent and a guitar would get you the win past season 6 or so.

[@madamnoire7464]

After that it was known as WGWG (white guy with guitar) era lol

[@PeppaTeaPig]

Kelly had such a cute audition! She's such a genuine sweetie, always has been. And dang those pipes, that's a genuine gift and hard work!

[@ShirtlessPinoy]

3:30 Kelly is so natural as if she’s been in showbiz for several years already.

[@ΠολύχρωμηΑλεπού-δ4ι]

Tbf at the time shows like these didn't exist she was the first big name from the first ever TV singing competition so ppl were much more chill since they didn't feel it would make my much of an impact.

[@katscratchfever3506]

@@ΠολύχρωμηΑλεπού-δ4ι ....ok? But his statement is still true. She sang as if she’d already made a career out of it. She didn’t (and still doesn’t) have to try...it all comes natural to her. She will always be the GOAT. She’s the most successful and least big headed over it.

[@tabatha5554]

This is the first time I’ve seen Jordan Sparks audition and I’m blown away! I know she’s a great singer but I was shook at how good she did in the audition. I can’t believe Simon didn’t like it.

[@ginapetolicchio2684]

Jordin

[@dazem8]

He was right tho... I didn't feel any soul in the way she sang. She has a great voice but it's "generic" with the lack of emotion imo. She could have been singing a cereal commercial jingle with the same enthusiasm.

[@annamineer2521]

She was chubby and Simon is biased against chubby girls.

[@imissnj2]

I liked her from Day 1. She's so beautiful and talented, love her voice, and do to agree that is was "too sweet." She was just a kid, what did he expect? I picked her to win it when I heard her audition. I also picked Taylor Hicks from Day 1, I told my husband that he would win and he did.

[@OksanaBelle]

Best part of this whole video is seeing the person you just watched auditions face in the background of next audition

[@brfr12]

Lmfao I had to go back to see this

[@brikachu3]

SAME 🤣

[@selftaughtflippingtwins8501]

American idol is great ❤️🥰🥰

[@kaitlinmanley151]

Oh my gosh I remember being OBSESSED with Phillip Phillips. Such a cool guy and voice!!!

[@nina_summers]

David Cook is a different beast ! He doesn’t need a microphone he is the concert himself! Kelly’s is my fav it’s just so cute and real and of course the voice is given!

[@brandiclarkson7571]

my favorite is the OG herself Kelly Clarkson! just adorable as can be, the best personality and of course incredibly talented 💙

[@therocklau]

Those who got snub'd, Adam Lambert, Chris Daughtry, and most important of all Jennifer Hudson

[@Anonymous-yw8wd]

Yet Adam Lambert got to tour with QUEEN

[@anikkafuglie9945]

and Jessica Sanchez

[@qeproductions1]

@@Anonymous-yw8wd it's better if the artist doesn't win, they don't get stuck in a year long contract after the fact. Adam is just one of the best AI has ever had.

[@jennifercoleman6218]

Absolutely

[@marieking-stevason1775]

I thought that was Adam (judge on #14) though I’m not a fan. There’s only one Freddie Mercury....he’s okay though.

[@edwarddiaz9724]

All the Winners have an inner confidence that couldn't be shaken.Never let their nerves get in the way of a good performance.

[@mangos2888]

Well you have to be able to get on that stage and sing.

[@ticketyboo2456]

edward diaz That Jordan girl could have done with more humility at audition. She seemed to think her farts were roses. Maybe it's because her father was a famous sport person in the USA maybe. She sang well but was a bit snooty.

[@katscratchfever3506]

@@ticketyboo2456 I agree! There’s confidence and then there’s arrogance.

[@carmencitaphillips6323]

Kelly really have everything, voice,personality, she's fantastic talents. Look at her reality now,she sure made it.

[@elisabethm9655]

Jordan Sparks - now that’s a voice. At 16 she was exactly as sweet as she needed to be!

[@gregoriojrdiokno9376]

Kelly had the voice and the personality.

[@madeline_dg]

Jordan Sparks at 16 can sing better than most extensively trained singers like dayum

[@jenny5309-k3j]

I remember watching season one, and I just knew Kelly was going to win right from the start. She just had it - the talent, the personality, and the looks. It's so weird to see her go sit at the judge's table, considering she ends up a judge on The Voice. And wow, Simon looked so young. I feel really old right now, lol.

[@WheelchairWolverine]

Ruben will always be one of my favorite winners. His voice melted you like butter in a hot pan. It’s a shame he didn’t go on to be a bigger star. Mostly because he wanted to do gospel. Another thing I love about the voice over idol. Is there have been some rock solid gospel/ Christian singers. Who were allowed to sing praise and worship music on live television and received standing ovations! 👏 🙏

[@prayforukraineplease7605]

+1

[@annamineer2521]

God gives them the gift. It's only right to give it back to God. Ruben didn't need to be a bigger star. His heavenly reward will be bigger.

[@westelevenlane]

Thank you for putting this together! Jordin Sparks got me - my son used to hum himself to sleep as a baby, and now he sings through life as a five year old. So cool to hear of another baby who did the same!

[@stellamantikou4978]

Simon giving legit advice and constructive criticism while the other judges trying to be likable is the reality in these shows...

[@dazem8]

Exactly 💯 in this compilation telling Jordin Sparks she was "perfect" when she had no soul in that audition. And I liked Kris Allen but he was right about him too... he didn't have a "Star" personality.

[@adoranidua2038]

Carrie Underwood was born singer, gifted with gold. The moment she enter in the audition and start singing sparkled her humble personality. But Kelly Clarkson is the legend. Her personality is brilliant, a total package. She carry the best American Idol tittle and reliven those unknown winners.

[@mariamarrero4179]

Just Sam made me cry!!!! Omg!!! Beautiful!!! Lionel Richie is so sweet!!! 💕

[@imissnj2]

unpopular opinion, but it was annoying. You can't just burst into tears when you audition, you need to have poise. That is what Simon was there for, to tell the truth and keep it real. The judges are such pansies now, they play right into those sad background stories. And they don't tell people the truth when they sing badly (like Lucy Love in the current season), just keep telling them they're winners.

[@Sailorlyoko4life4ever]

When Just Sam cried, I cried. As someone who understands how not feeling safe and loved feels, it took a lot of courage and self-motivation just to stand in front of those judges. I'm glad that the judge that asked her if she ever felt safe sensed it too. I'm proud of her. And I'm glad that the judges were respectful and loving to her. That's what we need more of in this world right now. Great job Just Sam. 🥰👏

[@MeMeDaVinci]

Beautiful person.

[@imissnj2]

Everyone feels that way, especially the current season of auditioners. The best way to get the Golden Ticket? Just say you were bullied. Or bring your toddler along because you're a single parent. Or have had a bad accident, illness, or financial difficulty. It takes a lot of courage for anyone to stand in front of the judges, cameras, and TV audience.

[@MyLifeRideorDie]

Agreed! Kelly's got it all from the start! She's awesome!❤️

[@lexiirand2120]

David Cook was super talented! Went head to head with David Archuleta, but David Cook had that rock raspy voice going for him and I love him for it!

[@angelablack7946]

I was a David Cook fan from day one. He’s so good.

[@dazem8]

Same here. He was my fave from the beginning of that season. He adapted all the songs to his style that he performed during the live shows.

[@dakotamiller9417]

I remember my whole family sitting down watching American idol, praying for fantasia💕💕

[@rper324]

Powerful fam getting her to the top 💛

[@mitchellL1]

Man, Lionel Richie is a truly great human being

[@StewNWT]

Simon saying 'God that was good!' to Carrie's clucking will never fail to crack me up

[@70smusicjunkie]

Same 😂😂

[@stricklyfashion]

Scotty is so damn talented. “Five More Minutes” always has me in tears wishing I had 5 more with my granddaddy each time I hear it.

[@vanillaghetto]

I like his engagement song, too!

[@paulabarrows7023]

My absolute favorite is Kelly's audition. Funny, fabulous and authentically Kelly!!

[@myhighladyofthenightcourt]

and i think she was able to be more relaxed since american idol wasnt really a "thing" yet

[@ivoryp8304]

It's so cool seeing them end up on the backdrop as the video progresses.

[@kelleyspartiatis5323]

FRIENDS series finale aired here in England the same night the Idol finale did the year Fantasia won. I spent the whole night crying

[@weesh4645]

🤣 that is a crime

[@lashawnablanton4649]

Just Sam watching your audition made the years flow down my face. I could feel your pain and your faith at the same time. God bless you!

[@fatmagulildan]

It’s very inspirational to see back to back how they come out the first time and behind them all of these previous winners’ photos, little they know they will be on ‘em next year. Some know they got it, some are little too humble, some worked hard and got better during the process. Beautiful inspirational way of reminding us that it all starts with one short step of trying and it can take us to places we never have imagined. Whoever worked on it, thanks for the edit!

[@lovebug3078]

Kelly Clarkson, all around best!! This girl can sing and is a natural performer!!

[@sydney2236]

Jordin’s been doing this since 16. she’s set forever. and her stage presence was amazing

[@lovelymels2471]

Fantasia’s voice gives me chills! 🥰

[@JplayboyJ]

She was set before she was born, her dad played in the nfl for 9 years and was actually a good football player.

[@yxngbt387]

It’s almost like Kelly Clarkson knew she was gonna be famous lol

[@sleepwell4334]

Ya think

[@Nostalgio]

She went to LA to launch her career, and didn’t make it, but American Idol launched her career for her.

[@Kayla1992]

Fantasia never fails to induce goosebumps.

[@Btash97]

she was the worst winner lol

[@Kayla1992]

@@Btash97 to each their own, my friend.

[@jamesmarkham1887]

@@Kayla1992can’t be mad some people Don’t got no soul. Fantasia got the voice of an angel

[@johncrowe6489]

Taylor Hicks walked in a star… voice gives goosebumps 👌🏻

[@jmymars8080]

Among of all, Kelly and Carrie are the best ever produced by all of the winners. They all have their own personalities. But these two ladies, Carrie & Kelly, they both still releven until today.

[@cashette]

Adam Lambert is now the lead singer of Queen…

[@Joe_Parmesan]

@@cashetteHe also technically didn't "win" the competition (He should've though.)

[@kevinwilliamc5244]

Carrie always sings like she's screaming when she hits high notes. She's good, but not great.

[@katscratchfever3506]

@@kevinwilliamc5244 agreed! She doesn’t deserve any of the fame she has and she’s really let that fame go to her head.

[@lanawheeler1654]

Jordan Sparks was born to be a star! That girl can sang!

[@hectormsk9463]

And omg that head voice at that age. Iconic

[@leeirby3857]

And wasn't Jordan Sparks at one point part of Britney Spears The circus starring Britney Spears tour?

[@imissnj2]

I loved her from the beginning and predicted she would win.

[@thatfunnypotato6766]

I literally love Kelly Clarkson she is so funny and she has such a bubbly personality and she is so unique!

[@JustKareli]

Ruben shouting out his whole family is so sweet. He had no idea what was coming ❤️

[@007amy-n1b]

I love Scotty's voice he almost sounds like instruments.

[@sasukeuzumaki3191]

Something about how this show changes lives is just so touching. Just imagine if one of these auditions was canceled for some reason. They would all lead completely different lives. Kinda crazy

[@midlifeandnailingit6342]

Fantasia is so unique. She should be a much bigger star than she is.

[@ZishPOE]

I actually am not a fan, at all - her voice sounds very grating/squeeling, almost nails-on-a-chalkboard-y. I barely think she deserved to pass this audition.

[@uchenwagbo20]

She has the most amazing unique voice of all the years

[@paulettaphillips3659]

Her story is absolutely amazing! She went all the way through American idol and never knew how to read. She was trying to sneak and learn how to read while she was on the show and she win. She had so much against her and she won. So I have to say Good job to her. Now on the flip side. I dont like her music but Im a rock girl and I would prefer someone like Chris Daughtry. But I still have great respect for Fantasia.

[@serenasimms1400]

@@ZishPOE ... Do you even listen to that type of music that’s literally how they are supposed to sound. It definitely is not nails on a chalkboard sounding .

[@ny8956]

I don't really like her voice.

[@rizbuste4230]

Fantasia's was the best audition for me. A different rendition she made to Killing Me Softly was awesome!!!

[@easeondowntheroad7158]

Yeah you could hear all the music with her

[@jcee6886]

She did the fugees version but she was absolutely stunning.

[@hectormsk9463]

My thoughts at exactly 💯

[@ws8080]

Different strokes for different folks. I found her generic, but that's just my view. Good singer for sure, but so many contestants are like so many others over the years. But props to all the early contests for singing without any accompaniment - difficult ! And has everyone missed the point? This is a collection of the winners from every year - not a competition between their auditions, so just enjoy it already.

[@MrChucklepuff]

Least favorite.

[@lauratoneykee7072]

Just Sam you have the best audition I've heard on this show out of all auditions ever. Your voice is amazing and so are you.

[@jamestnov41945]

Just a brilliant presentation. Real talent shows through almost immediately. Kelly Clarkson was incredible.

[@Cocokatpie]

Phillip Phillips is still my all time favorite - like a young Dave Matthews, fancy footwork and all ❤️

[@JaneGiesbrecht]

Just Sam. She sends shivers. She is so outstanding. She feels safe when her grandma hugs her.

[@mangos2888]

I hope she got rid if that neck tattoo. She’s absolutely amazing but that neck tattoo is such a turnoff

[@mattsanderson107]

Holy shit this show has changed lmao walk in sing yes or no gtfo, today it's literally a drama series 😂 i love it though 😂😂

[@comicblossoms]

SO TRUE now all these talent competition shows are soap operas oml

[@SousChef77]

I can't stand to watch any of them now.

[@Nostalgio]

Bring back reality tv without the drama and sob stories honestly.

[@imissnj2]

I like the original format. There shouldn't be any in-depth back stories until the final 12 is announced. All you need to do now to go through is say "I was bullied," and the judges fall all over themselves to vote you through to Hollywood. I was truly bullied, so much that as an adult it is still hard to enter a high school, but it doesn't define me or get me favors like it does these auditioners.

[@mikedembs1123]

Taylor Hicks was very underated. Did you know he was never in the bottom three. Saw him in concert and he was awesome.

[@katymcginn4644]

YES! VERY UNDERATED! I TOLD MY SON AS SOON AS I SAW TAYLOR'S AUDITION, HE WAS GOING TO WIN! HE'S AN AMAZING TALENT. LOVE HIS VOICE, THEN WHEN HE STARTED PLAYING HARMONICA LATER! THAT WAS IT FOR ME! HE'S ONE OF THE BEST. ☺❤

[@wallacezu1]

Right! Simon says he won't make it when the public votes🤣

[@imissnj2]

@@katymcginn4644 That's exactly what I said after he auditioned! Love his voice!

[@sonnychauhan1447]

i disagree he is the worst winner in my opinion daughtry should have won

[@EvilLeprechuan]

Just Sam, if you're reading this, you broke my heart and repaired it in the time you were on our screens. Those of us given up by our parents all feel like you, it's hard to let others in when those who were supposed to love us unconditionally didn't. I'm 45 later this year and these feelings never go away, but they can and do become less frequent when I started letting others in. I'm glad you are making your way through life on a good note. Much love and respect to you young lady.

[@katymcginn4644]

BLESS YOUR HEART 💙 VERY SWEET WORDS. I HOPE YOU WILL ALWAYS HAVE ALL THE LOVE YOU DESERVE. YOU ARE SUCH A KIND & LOVING SOUL. I WISH YOU ALL THE HAPPINESS LIFE HAS TO OFFER. SENDING YOU LOVE & HUGS 🤗 STAY BLESSED 🙏💙

[@Jeng4280]

Kelly’s audition gave me chills! Beautiful.

[@rakeenan3]

Candice Glover gives me head to toe CHILLS! What a powerful and expressive voice! Incredible!

[@kelqueen9998]

Agreed. It's really too bad a truly good producer didn't get a hold of her. Or if American Idol would actually promote their talent.

[@jareddepew1467]

Her cover of love song is the best American idol performance of all time

[@kelqueen9998]

@@jareddepew1467 I agree!

[@carlabrooks5877]

I wonder what happened to her??

[@tarajamchenry171]

It's Thriller for me! I didn't want it to end

[@josephlewis9237]

Kelly Clarkson remains as my all time favourite American Idol winner. She's absolutely wonderful, fantastic and I really, really like her.

[@nancygillard5961]

Great fun to see all the American Idols.

[@glee4327]

Why is no one talking about Phillips Phillips, hes audition was awesome

[@danaelizabeth4751]

Agreed. That dude felt the music. I am sure he has worked very hard, but he makes it looks like it comes easily-- just a natural.

[@BTWitsRAE]

I literally checked the comments just for this

[@mariamarrero4179]

Wow! I had never heard of him and just saw his audition. Amazing!

[@MsMegsc]

He's fantastic in concert as well

[@janjamesramos247]

True. I really loved it. Sooo cool 😎

[@sydney2236]

Fantasia’s voice gives me chills! 🥰

[@lovelymels2471]

Jordin’s been doing this since 16. she’s set forever. and her stage presence was amazing

[@rainydays6675]

@@lovelymels2471 That has nothing to do with this comment XD

[@JayMonaeee]

@@rainydays6675 🤦🏽‍♀️🤣🤣🤣 ppl are such haters!

[@rainydays6675]

@@JayMonaeee Fr

[@wesman422]

Paula telling Fantasia to watch her pitch is insane. She was pitch perfect. Didn’t miss a note.

[@liba]

I forgot just how good she was until I watched this. Anyone know what she's up to now?

[@quincyhickman6169]

Facts ... I'm looking like 😦

[@shawnuel]

@@liba She has been on Broadway and won a Tony. She is, probably, the 3rd most successful winner along with Jordan Sparks.

[@rednblak06]

WAS JUST THINKING THIS EXACT THING 🤣

[@taylorcoyle33]

@@liba her PTSD song is a bop!

[@jessicapitts2215]

Never watched Kelly's audition or that season of idol( learned of her and the show after) but she was so good and who knew that when she sat in that chair she would end up a judge on a singing show years later. She straight manifested it right there, wow!! I love Carrie, Fantasia, Jordin and Mr. Studdard as well. I didnt see any of their auditions( heard of them after). Havent watched the show in years but really like the current judge line up. Not sure but think I have heard of Scotty M. before( think he is a country artist now if im not mistaken) Wow everything about Just Sam's audition made me cry. She is a beautiful soul with an amazing voice. I love how gentle they were with her and omg the prayer at the end🙌🏾🙌🏾

[@aubrineetv5326]

I love them all but Jordan Sparks literally made me choke up , very moving ✨

[@tajalanijackson]

Justice for Candice Glover she did not get the Star treatment she deserves. Absolutely Beautiful voice

[@cjPagan87]

My favorite audition was Jordin but Kelly is the first and best idol ever.

[@amerbaig4533]

Last audition made me cried ! And That’s how you make your name For yourself!!!!

[@stephanied6451]

When you think you watched every season but then you realize there's a handful of winners you've never heard of

[@Linnie217]

Carrie Underwood has such a beautiful voice. She also has the personality to go with it. She’s still as down to earth as she was on her first interview ❤

[@cathyfutch5993]

I don’t see her as down to Earth! She is rude to fans. Many people who meet her say she seems uninterested and like she wants to get away from them.

[@MsMcCoolio1221]

Kelly is my favorite since she appears to be a great woman and mother as well!

[@millec60]

Jordin Sparks had best audition voice in my opinion. That voice is incredible

[@brad4231]

Fantasia killed it. Love her voice.

[@treyjones1958]

Get her latest album Sketchbook

[@bigred3096]

Our DFW, Texas girl Kelly, really set the stage. We love her here in Texas. 🤠👍🌹 A big AMEN Just Sam, dear sister. ❤️🌹❤️