Every city over 1 million visualized

[@jtcowboy5518]

I think some cities you're using the city limits while other cities, you're using the metro area.

[@ibrothedragon]

Not with nyc.

[@oscarg2692]

Yeah the two biggest examples I caught of using the metro area instead of the city limits were Toronto and Buenos Aires, each of which have close to 3 million in their city propers.

[@Rafin889]

@@oscarg2692 yea also Vancouver too

[@batzal9459]

I sure you're up to something

[@jackskora6476]

Yeah like Richmond’s city limits is only about 200,000 when it’s metro is just a little over 1 millions

[@axelube]

A geography teachers dream to show this instead of holding 3 classes

[@jaflischannel]

True

[@victorfonseca9599]

10:15 is not Rio de Janeiro lol

[@Sofiascheffer2203]

Kkkk ne, o cara vacilou

[@alexandrealencarm8772]

It's Italy

[@bartolomeubovie5479]

Rio de Janeiro plano com prédio baixos estilo europeu?

[@TheRennes]

@@alexandrealencarm8772 I think you meant Spain, That's barcelona for sure

[@ourificando]

@Terra Gamer da pra perdoar vai, deve ter dado um trabalho desgraçado pra fze o video

[@Dankfort]

The metrics used for this are highly inconsistent. Some are obviously cities proper while others are clearly metro areas.

[@BMS866]

In China, Russia and India you've used metro area population, while in the US you have used the official city limit even though both Los Angeles and New York City have metro populations above 10 million

[@welrann]

In Russia, he used city borders. Moscow metro area is 17 millions. And in China, city governments usually control very large territory, many times more than the urban area itself. Chongqing for example is larger than Austria.

[@kushal4956]

this isn't a fair comparison you've used metro areas for some cities while the actual city limits for others

[@darkalligraph]

Hello from the 234th most populous, and 4th most populous city in Australia, Perth. Perth has just over 2 million people, but the entire state of Western Australia, being nearly as large as India has in total just 2.5 million. So nearly everyone lives in Perth..

[@yay1401]

I'm from Adelaide! Australia gang!!!

[@ben3359]

im from melbourne! Australia gang!

[@shibanjan8984]

I'm from 15 largest city in world Kolkata, india

[@Naveen-tq7cg]

Western Australia has an area of 2.646 million sq. km, while India has an area of 3.287 million sq. km, so it's actually smaller, not twice as large :0

[@Fylnnn]

@@Naveen-tq7cg well India's land size is actually just 2.9m km which only slightly larger than west Australia, keep in mind that those are only a state of Australia, and having the size of a country with population of a city is just crazy

[@bartolomeubovie5479]

10:15 Rio de Janeiro? Error 404.

[@SmallCirclesForward]

I know, I know.. feels quite stupid when it was pointed out to me

[@MaxHohenstaufen]

@@SmallCirclesForward It must have been a real pain to put this together, so a few errors are ok.

[@mauroxo6130]

6:19 cali , COLOMBIA* de todas formas buen video

[@lightofruin1938]

This is so amazing, my man here is hugely underrated.

[@watermelon540]

Finding 11 Korean cities 498th 창원, Changwon 1.0M 488th 고양, Goyang 1.0M 480th 용인, Yongin 1.0M 378th 수원, Suwon 1.3M 325th 광주, Gwangju 1.5M 311th 대전, Daejon 1.5M 215th 대구, Daegu 2.1M 161th 인천, Incheon 2.8M 144th 평양, Peyongyang 3.0M 122th 부산, Busan 3.4M 033th 서울, Seoul 9.9M

[@jakehoganOW]

My only gripe with this video is that it’s inconsistent whether you’re using metro area or city limits, because you’re clearly using metro area for places like Paris, Toronto, and Tokyo, but clearly not for New York, London, and Los Angeles. Edit: I guess it’s the UN that’s inconsistent

[@lennoxtvthingy7408]

You deserve more praise than you get. Stacking 20+ counters without disturbing a board of 1000s of counters must be difficult.

[@ΒΑΣΙΛΗΣΚΑΡΑΤΖΑΝΟΣ]

Actually in Greece we have 2 cities with over than 1 million inhabitants. The other being Thessaloniki

[@EasT3kk_Official]

Oh, I didn’t know that. I always thought it got like 500k but apparently it’s bigger than I thought.

[@R1IY2N]

I'm pretty sure its around 800k+

[@ΒΑΣΙΛΗΣΚΑΡΑΤΖΑΝΟΣ]

@@R1IY2N the metropolitan area has 1million

[@nashwagemakers]

If you call Tokyo one city you could call most of the netherlands one metropolitan area with over 10 million people.

[@brucex.5254]

The urban areas of the netherlands are not continuous, but those of Tokyo are.

[@zahidnawazeliassameja1842]

Another brilliant video. 50% Talent . 50% Hardwork .

[@hoangduy1692]

4:03 Ho Chi Minh City🇻🇳 13M not 1,3M :)) Ha Noi City🇻🇳 10M Hai Phong City🇻🇳 1,6M Can Tho City🇻🇳 1,4M Da Nang City🇻🇳 1,2M Bien Hoa City🇻🇳 1,2M

[@SmallCirclesForward]

I can only appologize, I should have recognized that mistake in my source (they seem to have corrected it by now)

[@abhisekdas435]

For Mumbai you use city limits and for Delhi you use metropolitan area... otherwise Mumbai should be at no 4 or 5

[@C-Money_Tiers]

Wouldn’t North America have 3 city’s above the populous of 10 million? Los Angeles, New York City, and Mexico City. 12 million, 18 million, and 21 million respectively.

[@sebiwis7032]

Chile have 3 cities with more 1 million population: Valparaiso: 1M Concepción: 1.1M Santiago: 8M

[@litrr8609]

This is 6 months ago and Valparaiso only recently when above 1m

[@Yyodajedimaster]

This is the most underrated channel I have ever seen!

[@ianeons9278]

Why is Kim Jong Un so aggressive? Because he doesn't have a Seoul, he has a Pyongyang!

[@titus_philemon]

South America was basically Brazil then! lol Why was he saying "Reo de Ranero"? And at 10:15 that's NOT Rio lol that's Barcelona, in EUROPE (Our Christ is on top of a mountain & way larger).

[@SmallCirclesForward]

Of course that isn't Rio, I see that now.. I can only appologize for my Portugese, I'll have to work on that! 😊

[@titus_philemon]

@@SmallCirclesForward Just read it in the same way as in English (J as in Junior, January & in this case, JANEIRO), I think you'd be closer that way!! As for the "Fake Rio", it happens my man (But I won't lie that ya got me LOL)... Ur vids have an AMAZING quality & are obviously a time consuming work, but keep up w the great job as vids as informative and fun like yours are hard to find it here in YB! Good job.

[@SmallCirclesForward]

@@titus_philemon Thank you so much for the support!

[@The_Soviet_Onion]

Let me guess, Brazilian?

[@titus_philemon]

@@The_Soviet_Onion No.. I was correcting his Portuguese & pointing out wrong images from Brazil 'coz I'm from Slovakia! Of course I'm Brazilian.

[@JugglerBlend]

5:48 That's me along 2,9 millions of people

[@bigcockpapi]

Actually Caracas have 4 millions of people and Maracaibo 5 millions, the data are wrong. Can you speak spanish?

[@JugglerBlend]

@@bigcockpapi no

[@pinklasagna8328]

@@bigcockpapi it doesn't count metropolitan area. So it's not the same city you see in a map

[@martinavila3473]

@@bigcockpapi tenés hambre??

[@maximzaporojan6966]

Am I the only one who was surprised Mexico City was more populous than New York City?

[@miguelangelcastillobello208]

You have Made a good video, it's amazing 👌✨ greetings from Tlaxcala de Xicoténcatl, México ♥️👌🏻✨🇲🇽

[@thhomm]

5:01 West Yorkshire isn't a city it's a county with big cities like York and Leeds

[@Tommasso_]

Córdoba (Argentina) should appear here. It has a population of 1.5 million inhabitants.

[@martinavila3473]

Mal culiau, la re cagó ahi

[@connorvdl5512]

Great video. However a lot of cities were rather inaccurate for their population. For example melbourne and Sydney from Australia have 5 million and 5.3 million people respectively.

[@raqatfilani8726]

I appreciate you !! good video ...

[@doiboiplayswarthunder3980]

Tbh with u this channel is massively underrated and deserves somewhat 100k subs

[@tomaspugliacastro626]

And Córdoba? It has 1.7 million inhabitants and is the second largest city in Argentina.

[@10willdude]

this channel is really impressive and deserves more views but here the metro area vs city borders and claimed population issue lets this down, for example, it's misleading to suggest Paris is bigger than London or New York

[@SmallCirclesForward]

Yep I know this video has some issues.. thank you so much for the support anyway!

[@gialt840]

Actually Peru 🇵🇪 has 3 cities over 1 million. Trujillo with 1.1M, Arequipa with 1.3M, and Lima with already about 11M. 😉 Chiclayo and Callao have both 0.9 so might be passing the 1M barrier soon.

[@pingz2454]

Damn Cairo is huge, had no idea

[@sayedmahbub8933]

Your informations are incorrect..For some cities you are counting the metro and just the main city for others..

[@adityanagare9700]

Pune, India recently crossed 10 million(If I am not wrong)

[@Luca-hb5xs]

Since when does Oslo, Stockholm and Helsinki have over 1Mio?

[@alguemanonimo5592]

Hello from the 132th most populous city!! Campinas - Brazil 👋

[@willcragg]

Sydney and Melbourne both have over 5 million. Australia has 5 cities with over 1 million people. Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth and Adelaide

[@LuchoCastle_11]

Good to see my city made it, Cheers from San José, Costa Rica 🇨🇷

[@andresgarciaperez1313]

4:27 366 Queretaro :D

[@claudia.179]

Just imagine a city with twice, or thrice, or four times the population of your whole country. Really cool video.

[@kenji4330]

If you are gonna include metropolitan for some cities, do it for all of them, i saw my city not counted with metro have more than 2 million less than a city that without metro has the same population

[@Chrischi4598]

Alright mate you got me confused pretty early. So I assume you don’t use the metropolitan area for your number of inhabitants, based on the fact that you don’t include either London nor New York (the definition of a mega city) on your map. But then again you include Paris as a mega City? So based on what number do you take your Numbers? Because if you use the metropolitan area you missed 3 megacities alone in the US (The aforementioned NYC, but also LA and Chicago)

[@rankingresearchdata]

In my province "Uttar pradesh" In India having 6 cities

[@AyushSingh-mr5cs]

I'm from Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh!

[@AyushSingh-mr5cs]

I think more than 6 cities from UP have a million plus people.

[@rankingresearchdata]

@@AyushSingh-mr5cs i was there till august 2019 but now kanpur

[@suryanshsingh4533]

From varanasi

[@Abheeeeee9]

The fact is the city of jodhpur which is in desert have higher population than lucknow which is in ganga plains😐 They are in india

[@anshul6168]

no lucknow has aroun 4 million people while Jodhpur less than 2 million

[@ramitbudhraja1370]

Kudos! Very well made video with real physical visualisation. Just a small correction at 6:21 Cali is in Colombia, not Bolivia.

[@dimitri4888]

If we are talking about Metropolitan Area, Santo Domingo has actually over 4 million, and Santiago (Dominican Republic) has over 1 million and you didn't include it.

[@samanvithveeravelli7512]

I never realized just how many cities are in China and India.

[@dustin628]

I've watched a couple videos now, just wanna say great job and good on you for sticking it out you are getting recommended!

[@sonicvenom8292]

Metro Manila in the Philippines though can technically be considered multiple cities with more than a million, or one mega city.

[@Channel-lv5hl]

Yeah same as Metropolitan Cities such as Metro Cebu,Metro Davao,Metro CDO and Metro Clark

[@ilregulator]

you're clearly not listing cities with more than 1 million inhabitants, but metropolitan regions.

[@weltherrschaft]

Wow. This channels needs much more views.

[@Darkboss10k]

Where is Lucknow 🙄

[@EasT3kk_Official]

Fun fact: the Guangzhou metropolitan area has about 45 million population (but only if Shenzhen, Dongguan and Foshan are counted in)

[@iraqman5456]

What happened to London and on Google it says Bogota has a population of 7 million making it too small to be a megacity

[@MartinMizner]

So many large sites to destroy and aliens and super villains always choose New York.

[@unused_unsubscribe]

new york is a popular filming location for american movie producers and for the moviemaking industry in general, which explains its high presence in sci-fi films

[@polarbear3940]

This deserves millions of views !

[@gilgameshthekingofweebs5924]

Great presentation, but it's so wrong. You keep mixing city population with metropolitan population. In some cases you counted city population, while in others you counted metro... You are all over the place.

[@zulfikar0499]

Yeah, greater Paris only has a population of 7.5 not the 10.3 in the video, not to mention that Greater London is larger at 8.3 (not 9.3).

[@sakariahonen9623]

Little correction:I saw you put one piece in Finland even though the biggest city there aka Helsinki has population of just about 700k.

[@michelangelobuonarroti4958]

That's because he's inconsistent. Uses city limits sometimes and metro areas other times. The reason is that if he was consistent he wouldn't have been able to put 500 in the title.

[@eduardollanoszarria2058]

Arequipa and Trujillo also have a population of over one million

[@Mr_Kiwi]

Nooooooo Auckland is 301. So close to top 300. RIP to my fellow kiwis, we were so close

[@MrDude826]

NYC metro area has 22 million inhabitants. Most of theese global cities use their metro area population. London has 14 million. Moscow has 20 million. Los Angeles haa 18 million Sao Paulo has 20 million.

[@SwampThing585]

If you’re doing Tokyo’s metropolitan area but nearly no one else’s, I thought I’d give you a few: NYC-20.1 mill. LA-18.7 mill. Shanghai-24.9 mill. Chicago-9.5 mill. Istanbul-15.2 mill. Big fan of the channel but this pissed me off.

[@ianeons9278]

Remember me when you hit 1 Million

[@SmallCirclesForward]

Always 😍

[@ntinoskioses6271]

Thessalonikis metropolitan area is slightly over a million but you only placed one marker on Greece.

[@mullethater4223]

10:15 I've visited Rio a bunch of times and I can say that this is not Rio de Janeiro lol Edit:Your channel deserves more views and subscribers,great channel

[@JuanC486]

Wait, so are you talking about cities or metro areas? Tokyo City has around 9 million people but the Tokyo Metro has the 37 million people.

[@nilxargay6341]

Barcelona doesn't have 5.5 million habitants. The Barcelona province has that many, but it's a very big area to consider it as a city.

[@veyrontan3566]

Damn Kuala Lumpur be lookin beautiful with modern tall buildings lmao

[@Mrbatlefield4]

You not counting Istanbul as a European metropolis made me mad Af ngl

[@SmallCirclesForward]

Well it's in both but mainly in Europe. So you are right, I should have counted it in Europe

[@jonasarnesen6825]

When I was born the two biggest cities where both in Japan.

[@AlejandraRamirez-jh4it]

Bruh barcelona doesnt have 5 million, we're 1.4 million, 5 in the province

[@leox8038]

It's a very great video, but unfortunately there are some errors... For example for Rome you didn't considered the 'city' which has 2.9 million inhabitants, but the entire province which is way bigger and has 4.4 million inhabitants. I think some misinterpretation of data could have be done for other cities as well, however, the general overview doesn't get much afflicted by that. Keep up the good work!

[@gammaray004]

The problem is even more complicated. It's defined as a metropolitan city, but that is a replacement for the province, so it's effectively a city with cities inside. It's the same thing with Milan, Naples, Turin and even other cities that are below the million

[@crashgoblin2877]

Hello from 59th most populous and 1 of canada, Toronto

[@YasinTheDuke]

I live in Istanbul Europe. Population here is 16m.

[@Dr.Kraig_Ren]

So much work. You earn bot only subscribers...but respect.

[@Grason20]

What is the other million population city in Malaysia? I only know that Kuala Lumpur exceeded 1 million.

[@priyanshgautam9971]

Plz tell me the name of background song

[@SmallCirclesForward]

You can find all songs in the description, thank you for watching!

[@priyanshgautam9971]

@@SmallCirclesForward Yeah thanks can you plz make a video about like representing GDP of every major country through small circles.

[@Gendolf_UA]

Ok, but for some cities you used actual city population, but for some other you counted metropolian area population. I don't think it's fair

[@normarafael9072]

My city is the 532th place :D 3:18

[@lamroid4730]

Tampico esta chido

[@kp05YT]

8:55 This is my home city, we stand proudly at number 28

[@ianeons9278]

1:25 London and Istanbul: Am I a joke to you?

[@adeptechozz1512]

Paris only has a population of 2.161 million people in 2019 so it can’t have over 10 million now

[@Elmo_000]

10:16 Um.. Sorry, this isn't Rio de Janeiro, this city is Barcelona

[@JXY2019]

This is really messed up. You’re using metro areas for some countries and city propers for others. That is an apples to oranges comparison. Really the US has 50 cities with more than 1 million people.

[@SmallCirclesForward]

Yes for some nations unfortunatelly the source I used counted city limits. I don't know why but next time I'll be more careful in getting all numbers right

[@matigamer329]

I realize that Buenos Aires has more population than Moscow.

[@yeahok3233]

You mixed the cites and the metro areas, because the USA has two metro areas above 10M, and Paris is only 2 million if you are talking about the city limits, and the London metro also surpasses 10M

[@Victor-ol1zu]

Arequipa in Peru has 1 million inhabitants

[@tigerliu3923]

Hi everyone, from the 3rd most populous city, Shanghai.

[@baishakhichandra4842]

4:33 my city Asansol

[@REElondoner]

just saw this but for the Philippines, i don't know why you used metro areas. granted, we would lose the mega city of Manila but it's actually of around 15(?) cities that most are over 1M with Quezon City being the largest at over 2M.

[@tayperrygagianajepsenlordl944]

hOW R U SO UNDERRATED MY MAN!

[@Atlantique59]

For everyone who doesn’t like they did city proper instead of the metropolitan area, remember this is to show urban density not population. He has great videos for that

[@gob_idk6117]

he used metro area for some of them and for others he used city proper

[@charlesthrush8134]

Richmond doesn’t have 1.1 million people in its urbanized area tho just for example, this is just an incredibly inconsistent video

[@Dankfort]

They used both with seemingly no rhyme or reason as to why.

[@Dankfort]

And the urban density doesn't check out either. LA and NY urban areas are very densely populated even outside of the city proper.

[@HolyRomanEmpire962-1806]

Broooo you deserve like 2 million subs

[@rickberglund2134]

Why did you exclude all the U.S. cities with over 1M ?

[@SmallCirclesForward]

Bad source, I can only appologize for a mixup of city propers and metropolitan area.. I try to make it up with a video on the cities of the US coming out tomorrow :)

[@calumfulton9414]

This video completely ignoring Australian and NZ cities 😂

[@maximvazhenin3345]

So why for example metropolitan area of Tokyo counts bringing number to 37 million (in its administrative borders Tokyo only has 14 million people). While for Moscow only official numbers are counted? Moscow has long ago spread past its borders and have 18 million people if metro area is included but in the video you're using population of administrative borders of Moscow (12,5 million).

[@jlpack62]

Paris city is not over 10,000,000. Its city proper is about 2.1 million. It seems as if different ways of measuring population are being employed here.