Every fake/made up name in Red Dead Redemption 2 (including Rip van Winkle, Tacitus Kilgore...)

A scene of every made up or fake name of the gang in order to hide their identity.. or atleast I think so. If I forgot something, please write it in the comments.
.
.
.
Game: Red Dead Redemption 2
Platform: Xbox One
.
.
.
#rdr2 #reddeadredemption #reddeadredemption2

[@maxhenkner7149]

There were many people in the comments pointing out I forgot some names, like Archibald Smith or Lancelot, so here is Part 2: kzbin.info/www/bejne/jXuvoqmHf7V_irs Subscribe for more RDR2 and Tacitus Kilgore content!

[@axdde6428]

forgot agent moron

[@ThePastaBolognese]

John had no problem just going "Rip Van Winkle" when Milton asked him what his name was but kept struggling with saying Jim Milton during the epilogue lmao

[@naughtybear2187]

Give him a break it's been a while since he's been in the game.

[@STOOOOOOOOOOOOOPPPPPPP]

Jim Milton is similar to John Marston. That's why.

[@deutschvanderlinde6900]

@@STOOOOOOOOOOOOOPPPPPPP Jim Milton is an extra "fuck you" to Agent Milton, who asks John for his name

[@syntax2004]

The funny part is everybody knew he's lying during the epilogue.

[@matthewjohannes3509]

@Michael Cordova exactly

[@elnavas6036]

i lost it when arthur said leviticus cornwall

[@doomerius1300]

Best one

[@My6119]

I actually guessed it before he said it and I got the last laugh

[@mikerotch8375]

Nice to meet you Johnjim

[@spacechimp3199]

Self preservation. It was one of the reasons they didn’t kill him

[@silentnquiet]

That was smart actually

[@crisis3120]

I laugh so hard everytime I hear the name *r i p v a n w i n k l e*

[@BlackRider115]

I thought straight up for a second that this said Rip Van Winkie

[@XxriroxbaixX]

:c

[@vvalenxav2336]

rIP Vån wÎņkel

[@mrtecnhimuyo]

But that name is from a short story

[@96kami31]

_h u h , g o o d d a y s i r_

[@ponraul1221]

The 3 main protagonists of RDR: Tacitus Kilgore, Rip Van Winkle, and Lancelot Milton.

[@Johnnysmithy24]

Lmao hopefully the 4th protagonist will be their father figure Aiden O'Malley

[@Uaveatz2]

@@Johnnysmithy24 Or Caroline

[@evilchild1851]

I wish Red Harlow had his own fake name

[@foodafen7406]

@@evilchild1851 He does. His fake name is "Uncle"

[@andristo206]

Archibald smith

[@legatelanius9762]

Isn’t it weird how you never see Rip Van Winkle and Jim Milton in the same room?

[@Notto-tn9dy]

Didn't expect to find the Monster of the East here

[@legatelanius9762]

@@Notto-tn9dy Monster of the East? I quite like that name. Although my friends just call me Legate. No one but Caesar and the legion Courier can call me Lanius.

[@parasitadoentio9638]

Glory to the NCR

[@literallymemoviesenjoyer]

@@parasitadoentio9638 Glory to House

[@saintmichael2805]

A new settlement needs your Help I marked it on your Map

[@diobrando7774]

Can we appreaticiate that Geddes knew John was hiding his past and gave him a second chance

[@firstescobar6863]

Yea he's pretty likable

[@kiasj1794]

How do u know

[@rascallygoose4926]

Kiarash SJ Because he brings it up in nearly every epilogue 1 mission?

[@firstescobar6863]

@@kiasj1794 he even gave his old furniture to the Marston family near the end of the game.

[@firstescobar6863]

And told John that he knew the bank manager in Blackwater so then he could take out a loan for his newly established ranch.

[@Brubarov]

I like how Dutch easily lies and how hard it is for John.

[@evangelostse2477]

It's not just a personality thing. Dutch was a professional con-man before he had the Van der Linde gang, so it's just part of his criminal skilset. John meanwhile hadn't been anything other than a gun.

[@asylumskp4391]

@@evangelostse2477 Hosea was the con man, Dutch himself said so. Dutch was more of a leader or strategist.

[@MariusBoss11458]

Also Aiden O'Malley is a Character in GTA 4 you get to kill after getting out from the Cops because of Derrick McCreary (Packie's Brother)

[@RafaelMunizYT]

@@MariusBoss11458 aiden must be dutch's grandson lmao

[@goatcar4599]

no shit he easily lies he worked with hosea for a long time who was a con man and hes literally one of the most dangerous criminals in the country. Of course hes gonna have some sort of lying skills

[@diegopacheco5063]

1:46 Micah run a way, like a scared rat.

[@user-ij8wb5bw3q]

While the whole gang is getting nervous, Michah is just casually walking behind lol

[@emtee7138]

"Aah, I can deal with this later. Later y'all! I'm going to grab a beer!"

[@phillipwalling7470]

This would make great Foreshadowing to Chapter 6.

[@twistedtabor]

I never liked Micah. I hated him from the start he always looked shifty

[@1eye1tear95]

Lol he was walking around like a bad ass tho

[@dylancampbell52203]

Just the way he says “Rip Van Winkle” gets me every time. Like he says it with such certainty like it’s a real name but you can tell it was thought of on the spot.

[@petepyrotechnic6150]

Rip van winkle is from a old folk story written by the same guy who wrote sleepy hollows iirc. Its sorta like how tony stark called one of thanos’ henchmen on earth squidward

[@IceTactics]

Often I work "Rip Van Winkle" into my daily conversations in honor of John

[@ghostenthusiast7792]

1:46 , quite peculiar that everyone in the gang is paying attention to the feds while Micah is in the background not giving a fuck

[@ShadesMF]

This is chapter 3 tho, milton said micah started with the pinkertons after guarma

[@DaPeanutButter]

Its because he's a rAT.

[@rickgrimes8870]

Its a bug. He's meant to be in that scene with the group in the circle

[@Yung-plague]

@@GlitchedRebellion its meant to be insinuated in the game that he /may/ have ratted to the feds as early as the Blackwater job, many times people refer to it as a setup, and Dutch talks about potential rat as early as Horshoe

[@huhjalapeno7469]

That made me lmao when I saw it😭

[@ripvanwinkle760]

hm lies ?, Rip Van Winkle isn't a made up name is totally Original.

[@doggo1726]

How come John Marston and Rip Van winkle are never in the same room together 🤔

[@danyort1014]

@@doggo1726 same about Jim Milton

[@diobrando2507]

I don’t understand that joke

[@arthurmorgan7924]

@Rip van Winkle Hey, Marston!

[@lookzx_]

rip rip van winkle

[@willow2]

3:19 nervously sweating

[@RolandBon]

Its John. With 2 J’s

[@xicegod6297]

You hear that John Jim? Extra work

[@Elden-Bear]

J.J. Milton

[@professionalpizzaconsumer5419]

They have more fake names than I have with friends

[@SPQRcat]

They have more fake names than I have friends

[@skeeterfromsouthpark1414]

Rip Van Winkle, Arthur Callahan, Hoagie Macentosh, Fenton, Jim Milton, Tacitus Kilgore, and others

[@lobaandrade7172]

...walk into a bar

[@Justme-pt1ld]

...Then suddenly!

[@butitwasmedio]

:)

[@STOOOOOOOOOOOOOPPPPPPP]

Hoagy Macintosh *

[@skeeterfromsouthpark1414]

@@STOOOOOOOOOOOOOPPPPPPP and others

[@Icy_Princess]

You missed one. It's the first encounter with Cornwall when John and Strauss get captured and Arthur and Dutch confront Cornwalls henchmen. Dutch says it's a case of mistaken identity and that his name is 'Archibald Smith'.

[@adisalaka]

and lancelot

[@maxhenkner7149]

Yes I missed it, because I shot too early while playing the game.

[@theundisputed3671]

“My name is Archibald Smith, a lay preacher!”- Dutch

[@MariusBoss11458]

@@adisalaka And Agatha.

[@DannyDeVito69-]

I laugh at Miltons “Huh” after John says “Rip Van winkel”

[@calebstevens7487]

John not only disrespected Milton by giving him a fake name but taking his surname after his death.

[@carlhiller9659]

The fact that Edgar Ross meets John Marston as Rip van Winkle is just hilarious to me

[@themadvillain9318]

“Hoagie Macintosh” I love that XD

[@duckysprouts]

rip van winkle is actually an old folks tale about a man of the same name who was tired of his nagging wife, so he and his dog went into the woods, got drunk with some dwarves, and woke up 20 years later to a world without a nagging wife. the man proceeded to spend the rest of his life happily in a bar and telling his story to anyone willing to buy him a drink. i think john is using the name not only to make fun of milton since it’s clearly not his real name (like if you tell someone your name is cinderella), while simultaneously jabbing at abigail for being the nagging wife for interrupting his drinking

[@plutosmash6068]

It’s also name of a very expensive bourbon, old rip van winkle

[@scoutman66]

Rest in peace Jim Milton Hoagy Macintosh Arthur Callahan Fenton Aiden O'Malley Leviticus "Arthur" Cornwall Rip van Winkle

[@flow2me667]

So after Arthur's death you won't play John Marston, you will play as Jim Milton. Or Rip van Winkle.

[@bng1022]

first of all, the "Arthur" who dies is called Fenton

[@flow2me667]

@@bng1022 Callahan?

[@bng1022]

@@flow2me667 No, that's his cousin. I Believe the one you play with is Fenton MacIntosh

[@everydaylightskin5983]

@@bng1022 no thats uncle Tacitus

[@adamgondrong503]

Leviticus Cornwall in Guarma.

[@mrsnrub282]

I think Leigh Grey is the only person in this whole game who genuinely believed the fake names

[@Johnnysmithy24]

🤣

[@asymbolofpurehatred]

That dude that tortured Arthur probably believed it too since he had some second thoughts about torturing Arthur

[@mrsnrub282]

@@asymbolofpurehatred oh that's true, forgot about him. I don't think he completely bought it, but he was thinking "if this is really Cornwall, then I am a dead man"

[@iEnderJaysonTDA]

@@mrsnrub282 He'd never heard the name "Leviticus Cornwall" in his life and Arthur knew that. That's why he used it. Easier to pull a name you know well than think of a new one-especially after being tortured.

[@bladeserrated]

my NAme is LeviTICus cornWaLL

[@MeepmcarthurtheSECOND]

IM A MAN THAT SHOULDN'T BE ROBBED 🤓

[@e_brophy6575]

Rip Van Wrinkle is one of my all time favorite gaming moments ever

[@Erri_17]

You should read the book

[@kevinhicks8455]

“I am Archibald Smith, a lay preacher.”

[@maxhenkner7149]

Seems like I forgot about it. In which mission was this?

[@kevinhicks8455]

StuhlDefekt the last mission before leaving camp in chapter 2. The sheep collecting one. When Dutch is confronted by Cornwall, he “spins the yarn” until Arthur eventually shoots the men holding John and Strauss hostage. If you let him talk long enough you’ll hear him say it. Pretty funny lol.

[@kevinhicks8455]

StuhlDefekt kzbin.info/www/bejne/kGPXn5iEqLdlgrM

[@maxhenkner7149]

@@kevinhicks8455 thanks

[@kevinhicks8455]

StuhlDefekt no problem!

[@Isiauwuehrifi]

John being called John Jim makes me laugh so hard

[@pennywisegrey330]

1:46 it looks like Bill is checking out Edgar lmao

[@Johnnysmithy24]

Wtf xD

[@IrisWasTaken1]

real

[@vassililenincostales372]

aiden o malley is actually a character in gta 4

[@maxhenkner7149]

Just looked it up, pretty funny

[@Hossein7r]

He also die like Dutch... falling from a cliff.

[@hellosonmrsadler]

@@Hossein7r holy shit

[@sharkygreatpowered8630]

@@Hossein7r I remember he was killed by Niko and Packie on a cliff and he finally dropped into the water.

[@kden2925]

I wondered why the name sounded familiar, now I know. Thank you

[@RAEconLumbagoTeSodomiza]

Señor porfavor

[@maxhenkner7149]

"We are no one"

[@connork7335]

MAMACITA POR FAVOR YO SOY DESPACITO MARIAMIA

[@elpolodiablo5486]

Arthur is no more

[@dutchplanderlinde2779]

Dutch was high as shit when he named himself " *HoAgY* "

[@Anatoly_Dyatlov3_]

You’re always high Dutch

[@CMPF4]

"You hear that John Jim... Extra Hard".

[@phillipwalling7470]

Rip Van winkle, Jim Milton, and Tacitus Kilgore are my favorite characters.

[@ThePuma1707]

That Jim Milton looks very suspiciously close to John Marston, even sounds like him

[@aleksthevoyager1260]

Dont you mean Rip Van Winkle?

[@NachoNator16]

Fun fact: the name Aiden O' Malley has already mencionated in another game of rockstar, especifically in GTA 4 in the mission where you have to kill the old friend of derrick, guess what his name is.

[@Ddd16942]

Rip van Winkle?

[@cem6730]

Jim Milton?

[@Abdaaru]

Leviticus Cornwall?

[@xhadex7509]

Fenton?

[@mrnk88]

It's clearly Hoagy McIntosh

[@Riley-td7ud]

the Rip Van Winkle had me dying of laughter

[@budiisnadi]

Today I learned that Rip van Winkle is actually a character from a short story written in 1819. So John actually read one of Jack's books.

[@R_-qs4fo]

My favourite dialogue in the entire game: Milton: And who are you? John: Rip Van Winkle. Milton: Huh... So funny lmao

[@ezioaltairac]

No, but it probably got Ross to investigate him further, leading to his obsession with John.

[@shadowskie4k985]

2:08 Dutch: señor por favor I mean, its kinda funny. Dutch went to some spanish lesons

[@TheAmazingCobalt]

Arthur saying his name was Leviticus Cornwall gave me the same vibes as when Archer says his name is Cyril Figgis.

[@BARRYAFLER09878]

2:14 gta 4 reference :D

[@BARRYAFLER09878]

1:09 strangers voice like saide

[@arkhamtony4469]

It is Sadie

[@BARRYAFLER09878]

@@arkhamtony4469 but subtitles says its stranger is that bug?

[@arkhamtony4469]

@@BARRYAFLER09878 Yeah , it’s a bug

[@javierescuella5804]

You missed the infamous Dutch’s “Featherstone Chambers” and Hosea’s “Alfred LaFonde” at the mayors party. Bill also came up with Albert Danielson.

[@yuriypotaychuk716]

Excellent work. I wish you good luck and creative success.

[@SekenStrm]

Lumbago!

[@maxhenkner7149]

Lumbago>Tuberculosis

[@TIMETECH07]

1:40 2:31 fair warning: Don't swallow anything, I choked after laughing at that

[@ibraben4146]

Lmao leviticus cornwall

[@deepth0t186]

My FAVORITE bit of foreshadowing is Arthur's original horse's name (Boudicca) and it's relation to Tacitus (Basded off of Publius Cornelius Tacitus the Roman History.) This is mentioned between Hosea and Arthur and the beginnig of "Exit Pursued by a Bruised Ego ." According to Tacitus, Boudicca was killed in battle via suicide (i.e. fighting Micah while dying from TB as suicide sacrfiice to avoid John being captured) or according to a different history (Cassius Dio) died of illness. The two endings of game where right that at a place called horseshow overlook. We overlooked it right away, so much foreshadowing in the camp

[@stevewilliams2895]

I'm sorry but the whole "my name is Leviticus Cornwall" is the biggest power play Arthur ever made. Cause that guy was just a locally sourced henchman and would have no doubt heard the name and known that he was in serious shit but also would have likely never met Cornwall himself due to his low status. Such a chad play on Arthur's part

[@KNOTTYBUDS]

I love how Sheriff Gray pretty much ignores Dutch until he says his name is Hoagy Macintosh 😂 like why did that catch his attention?

[@jonas-savimbi3765]

It's a Scottish name and the sheriff is of Scottish decent

[@TheyWantMeGone69]

Dutch named himself after a sandwich

[@abdulkadirjannes]

​@@TheyWantMeGone69😂

[@The_SmokeArtiste]

1:04 i ligit missed this part because I straight went sprinting towards the post office and I didn’t know it actually existed so basically my pov was: Arthur gets off wagon Starts sprinting towards the post office Sends mail Then sprints to the wagon Sees sadie in new clothes Then get on the seat of the wagon and drives off

[@maxhenkner7149]

I did it the same way as you, I had to take that part from KZbin

[@melvinlondon7787]

1:25 HEY that’s my name lol

[@jovanlarendosufian8087]

Hey fenton

[@yelirqwe]

Somebody mentioned Milton died thinking John's name is rip van winkle

[@russianspy5007]

“I’m Tommy, that’s my brother...” “Rip Van Winkle”

[@user-qf4du7lc4z]

The man of many names. John Marston, Rip Van Winkle, Jim Milton, and John Jim Milton.

[@timoedsel]

John: Rip Van Winkle Agent Milton: HUH...

[@ronweasley3156]

You forgot one from the Chapter 2 mission where Arthur and John rustle sheep for an auction, Strauss and John are held hostage by Cornwall’s men and Arthur and Dutch are being prosecuted if you wait long enough there is a string of dialogue where Dutch says his name is “Archibald Smith”. I believe it’s the first fake name the gang uses in the game.

[@mora14033]

"And who are you?" "Rip Van Winkle"

[@user-pp6dc6he5n]

Look at Micah when Milton speaks to John...He is walking away! Is this an easter egg?

[@vinizin8291]

Thats anything but an easter egg, Easter eggs are supposed to he hidden

[@user-pp6dc6he5n]

@@vinizin8291 well its not easy to notice

[@haileynmt]

Bruh I never noticed

[@Annie-rg4if]

HOWDY UNCIVILIZED CITY FOLK. MY NAME IS JOHN JIM MILTON READY TO TEACH U HOW TO HUNT PIGGIES

[@novembervoid.2768]

meet mah boi F E N T ON

[@firstescobar6863]

"He's an idiot, killed momma by mistake but don't make him mad"😆

[@bingisbahn3374]

Everyone is memeing rip van winkle but I found intriguing it’s symbolic of the gangs inablity to move forward in time and it’s struggle between the past and the industrialisation

[@FelipeNolascco]

Fun fact: Rip Van Winkle really existed. It's a short story from 1819 that tells the story of a man who decided to run away from his evil wife (obviously 😂). He runs away to the forest and has many adventures. Then he falls asleep and wakes up twenty years later and decides to return to his village. He soon gets into trouble when he applauds George III, not knowing, however, that the revolution had taken place and that the monarchy should no longer be saluted.

[@therealsirdj5934]

Rip van Winkle has to be my favorite fake name of the lot. Don't get me wrong, Tacitus Killgore was great, but just coming up with Rip van Winkle on the spot... also John: Why the hell would you change John to Jim, it's a mix up waiting to happen.

[@TippedScale]

Rip van winkle was a popular story back then. Everyone would know the name was fake. Also he wanted to keep the same initials.

[@leviticuscornwall8991]

Where’s Archibald Smith, the lay preacher

[@davidle4936]

Fun fact: The alias that Dutch took during his time at Guarma is the same name as a character who was killed by Niko Bellic in GTA IV!

[@firewolf0065]

Had me dying when John said, "RIP VAN WINKLE"

[@Nightbeat9123]

John: Rip Van Winkle. Edgar Ross: 🙂

[@bamcki991]

I LOVE playing as Fenton.

[@micahbell7763]

I honestly love playing as Leviticus Cornwall, but i enjoy playing as Arthur Callahan too

[@Sontronite]

one time i got off a stagecoach as john Marston to fast travel and as i got off the driver said "Alright Rip Van Winkle wake up for your stop

[@foodafen7406]

Arthur Callahan Hoagy Macintosh Fenton Melvin Aiden O'malley Leviticus Cornwall Albert Danielson Alfred Lafonde Featherstone Chambers Tacitus Kilgore Mr and Mrs Kilgore Uncle Tacitus Caroline Archibald Smith Rip Van Winkle Agatha Lancelot And last but not least Jim/Jimmy Milton

[@pedroh7361]

Guys I have a crazy theory... Rip Van Winkle and John Marston might be the same person

[@richardinkheart9138]

No way you silly Although Rip Van Winkle reminds me of Jim Milton somehow...

[@maxhenkner7149]

Get off my channel you disgusting conspiracy theorist

[@johnny8566]

you sir, are a genius

[@charlietownsend2826]

@@richardinkheart9138 | No way, good ol’ John-Jim Milton is a respectable guy. Honest man looking for honest work to feed his son, Lancelot. Nothing like that thug Rip Van Winkle.

[@thebindingblade777]

Nah I'm pretty sure he's Jim Milton, John Marston got killed by the government.

[@lucwijngaard8413]

Jim Milton, Rip van Winkle, John Marston

[@ashlovestolaugh5149]

🤣😂I laughed so hard when I first played the game and John was like “ rip van winkle” he says it so perfectly it gets me every time idk why 🤣🤣🤣😂

[@SeriousDragonify]

You forgot one where he met Alvernon and said his name. And another when he said to writer after Calloway's death.

[@kwc0435]

To this day I had no idea that there was extra dialogue if you follow sadie into the store

[@ethanfuego9648]

Imagine if they just killed Milton and Ross then dumped the bodies in the lake or sum

[@gamergrill4933]

They probably had like 20 guys hidden in the bushes with their guns pointed at them, pinkertons are not stupid lol

[@ethanfuego9648]

@@gamergrill4933 and the gang would've took them out, they've literally survived worse

[@gamergrill4933]

@@ethanfuego9648 yes but not when there are guys pointing at their heads, plot armor doesn't work that way

[@ethanfuego9648]

@@gamergrill4933 except it does work that way bruh. Plot would've had the Pinkertons miss most of their shots, only killing or wounding one or two of the gang members, then the Pinkertons woulda died. Gang has been through much worse like I said.

[@FlownXp]

Hoagy Macintosh, at your service I'm scottish too.

[@remyrichardson8614]

"hoagy macintosh" just sounds like dutch was hungry when he made that name up

[@MrJoeBlaze]

Tacitus Kilgore VS. Tobias Rieper. Who would win?

[@-The-Void-]

1. Hoagy Macintosh (Dutch) 2. Arthur Callahan (Arthur) 3. Tacitis Kilgore (Arthur) 4. Mrs. Kilgore (Sadie) 5. Melvin (Hoesa) 6. Fenton (Arthur) 7. Rip Van Wrinkle (John) 8. Adin O'Malley (Dutch) 9. Leviticus Cornwall (Arthur) 10. Uncle Tacitis (Arthur) 11. Carealline (Sadie) 12. Jim milton (John)

[@bionicleapple1254]

This, "John Jim Milton" guy looks a lot like Rip Van Winkle, don't you think?

[@NotMeLolYT]

So is the John Marston guy

[@harleyplus]

If only Joel can use his fake name in The Last Of Us 2...

[@Heisenhulk_80]

John's best fake names: Jim Milton, Rip Wan Winkle.

[@Wolfgodmak]

Notice how Jim Milton, Rip Van Winkle and John Marston are never in the same place

[@bloatersnake9787]

R.I.P John Jim Milton

[@fernandorosas1257]

Rip van winkle was a real person

[@kingkongweiwei7669]

I wish they said like Corey lahey or randy Trevor or some shit for trailer park boys lmao

[@IBRXH1M786]

RIP VAN WINKLE

[@christiandk09]

1:43 best part

[@Banus-]

It’s so funny to see agent Milton’s reaction to that, it’s the most “okay???” reaction ever

[@blackstardragon_]

HOAGIE MACINTOSH Will always be my favorite

[@awsomemodels]

It suits him so much 😂

[@JFTSwiertz]

I love how Hosea always calls Arthur stupid.

[@johnnystankiewicz295]

Idc that rip van winkle is actual thing. For me it will always be the goofiest, most devious, bizzare and ridicolous name that john could come up with

[@TookaSmoker]

2:26 I was cross faded out of my mind when playing this part I couldn’t stop laughing like a hyena

[@Pain_train_wielder]

Arthur Callahan, Hoagy Macintosh, rip van winkle, Tacitus Kilgore, Melvin, Fenton, Aiden O’Malley, Leviticus Cornwall, Caroline, John…Jim Milton,

[@leithmascari5053]

John-Jim Milton is quite a creative name, really must’ve had the Pinkertons’ heads spinning

[@kosc88]

John during epilogue: I'm Jin Milston

[@thestonedwitch]

Don’t forget “Archibald Smith” during The Sheep And The Goats

[@deadeyeliam1238]

Tacitus Kilgore might be the coolest fake name I've ever heard

[@tacituskilgore9135]

Well, I don't know about Arthur Callahan, but Tacitus Kilgore sounds a lot like a real name.