Every MXGP Game Ranked From Worst To Best

[@ravioli-bamboli]

MXGP 3 is a very good game, I’m surprised you didn’t talk about it’s terrain deformation system that we didn’t see in other games after it.

[@acm9302]

Sorry didn’t realize I was replying to your post man 😂

[@odisii6685]

MXGP 3 the best!!

[@abdurrahim7539]

2019's last update have the best terrein deformation in all mxgp games. try it out now. you wont be disspointment

[@jasonschwartz9481]

@@abdurrahim7539 seriously? I've never heard anyone even mention this. When did the update come out?

[@jasonschwartz9481]

@@abdurrahim7539 also, since they were able to do that to mxgp 19, did they also implement it in 20?

[@RayMetalcore]

MXGP PRO and 3 give me a great sense of speed watching you play. All the other ones felt so slow and felt like you werent even moving

[@jojo609]

Too much speed is not realist, its too much arcade like Only mxgp 2019 has à realistic speed.. Just my opinion

[@joelvisande7041]

MXGP 19 very Worst

[@simcadebiker6214]

These are the 2 best games they made in my opinion!

[@peanuthead4493]

Yeah I agree

[@tacobellbajablast69]

Mxgp 2 feels like you’re going 10 mph when the game says 60

[@ErikKarlstrom]

MXGP pro easily the best games simply due to the facts that you could hit some really hard to pull-off lines which was very rewarding. Like the double before the goal in Qatar, the two huge doubles in the Russian gp. Only thing that was bad in that game was the random corner crashes like you hit a rock or something.

[@storionesauro753]

Since I noticed MXGP PRO has terrain deformation with ruts and bumps (try the extreme career and see how rough the track gets in the motos and how real the ruts and bumps feel), it became my favorite mx game ever. I'm not sure it was there already from the release but now on the Steam version the terrain deformation is present and pretty realistic, not overexaggerated as in MX vs ATV.

[@markbaum3388]

100% and in first person it feels real, I ride amature motocross on a national track gp pro is likely still the best although I havnt tried 21. Propbaly wht pro is still 60$ on steam.

[@CatTrashRacing]

Mx vs ATV is absolute garbage

[@ascherit]

I don't like mxgp pro because you have to use the sponsor paint on almost the entire bike in career mode

[@o-SPECTRE-o]

MXGP 3 was my favourite too. 19 and 20 are about equal, both fun. And for some reason I played PRO the most, I think mainly because I wanted to learn it and it was harder than the others. I skipped 1 and 2 because I hated the demos.

[@milkshaki8628]

I waited so long for this. thank you, windham

[@W-26]

Jus found this channel yesterday So glad I did, love ur work💯

[@xacvhFAs]

Mxgp 2019 is def my favorite one. I really liked how the bike actually feels like it has weight to it and some useful ruts.

[@dominikhanzek7119]

Yea isnt it, in mxgp 2020 bike just didnt feel right, it was not smooth it feels to ride like a fcking tractor

[@ImRickyIWin]

MXGP3 is still my favorite too, I have hundreds of hours put into that game, the rest on the list I haven't really played or haven't played at all. I never really saw the point in buying other MX games since I liked mxgp3 so much. I did rent a few of the other ones but never bought them, besides the 1st supercross and mxgp2.

[@MotohUS]

So personally and probably unsurprisingly I'd say my number 1 has been and always will be mxgp 2 followed by gp3 and then gp 19 in third, gp 1 in 4th, gp 2020 in 5th, gp 2019 in 6th and gp pro in last. Gp2 will always be my number 1 because of how big the revolution of it was in comparison to what they have introduced sense. Being fair GP 1 was fresh off mud yes but them adding full bike and rider customization aswell and being able to run what ever team you wanted was HUGE for the series. Much like how MW2 is one of the most revolutionary and most fan favorite in COD history, I feel that GP 2 is just overall the OG classic. Now I understand that people didn't like it and that other games are very good too but I will always remember the amount of fun I had on it not to mention it helped start my channel lmao. I do like your list though, you made very very good points and I definitely think your list is s tier 🤍

[@that_drummer_guy647]

Homie mxgp pro is def 1 wym...

[@austinn2062]

Pro was the best of its class imo, smoothest and best graphics, speed sense was great, terrain and ruts were realistic and plenty more, did lack on the compound and campaign depth but thats okay for what it is

[@CMyLongShot]

I personally love mxgp2019. The physics with the bikes in the corners felt realistic. Ya jumping was a bit off until you tuned your bike just right for each track. That was definitely the kicker was tuning. I spent more time tuning than racing which I enjoyed because I could get faster times on each track. Good list though!

[@lumpyferret]

Was shopping for mx games and mx3 was on sale 80% on steam, thank you for your reviews :D

[@Leeroy_Mercer]

Oh my god the original 3 had some of the best tracks I miss those old tracks and MXoN

[@codyhill6791]

I remember playing mxgp on my xbox 360 everyday after school….brings back memories

[@josephfrancis1924]

Same 🤧 the old days

[@jamespickthall3371]

MXGP 2019 has by far the most realistic physics

[@djsmurff63]

finally.........someone said it. the face i made watching after he said its the worst in his opinion

[@spamming4484]

No it's mxgp2020

[@René.831]

That’s what I’m saying

[@niklasisokaanta]

I ride motocross and 2020 is most realistic

[@IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII-3]

@@niklasisokaanta my friend rides with Tommy searle and he said the same

[@cristianc6005]

I'm the only one who keeps playing mtx mototrax for ps2? that game was insane back then, with the 4 free ride areas, you have 4 bikes for unlock in the carrer mode.

[@davespringer777]

On ps2, just for fun, they're maybe not realistic, but check out Ricky Carmichael 2002 and Freakstyle. Both are just over the top dirtbike fun.

[@cristianc6005]

@@davespringer777 i take a look, thanks

[@DjTinnio]

I focused only on the way the rear wheel is simulated. It looks okay in 1 and 2. 6:13 In MXGP Pro, it is looking too slow when driving fast, it just looks off, and like it is floating in the air at times it should look like being on the ground. In 2020 it looks okay again. 10:46 In MXGP 3 it looks so bad, i mean look at it. It spins slowly at all times. How does a whole collective of developers not see that. I like Milestone, but how did that happen, lol. Thanks for the video. It helped me to figure out, having MXGP 1 is good, and will not improve much with the other titles. I will check out MX Bikes with these shader mods, and Supercross 1 and 3. Supercross 1 because of how the bike moves over the multiple small bumps, we call it washboard in my language, and Supercross 2 because of how the driver moves more realistic. What i want to see more, personally, from all these games, is, the suspension working more, and the tires digging really deep into the dirt, throwing it up. I want more action visually. If you land from a high jump, the wheel should sink all the way into the suspension, but in these games it looks so stiff. I don't know if that is settings related, but in your videos it always looks too bumpy, what the bike does from impacts.

[@markbaum3388]

Why are you using third person /

[@GhostfaceMMA]

Would you go back to MX vs ATV reflex for a vid ?

[@solorunner1389]

Best mx game ever made

[@liljimmy40]

@@solorunner1389 cap

[@dirtbikebloggers9032]

Yuck

[@trereddinger9879]

MXGP 3 is so fun one of the best dirt bike games I have ever played

[@DClassDad]

Went from 19 to 21 from a ps4 to a series x so far 21 is awesome

[@408jc]

For me it’s mxgp pro, mxgp 3, mxgp 2019, mxgp 2021, mxgp 2020, mxgp 2, mxgp 1. I like mxgp pro because something about it just reminds me of mx bikes.

[@GameBrainMedia]

GREAT SUMMARY of the different versions. I bought MXGP (2014) and never bought another until MXGP 2020 (because I read they added tracks & improved physics - but still no terrain deformation). The original game was OK, but as an SX fan, I want more track variety in new game versions & the MXGP series was basically same tracks each year. Also, as a USA MX fan, I really didn't like the GP tracks. They're mostly WFO w/ out much timing, rhythm, flow or "sections"... IMO. Thanks for a GREAT VIDEO!

[@hey_its_horacio]

Nice video good job man. Plus I agree with your list

[@Reflexnation590]

I’m a person for realism in motorcross games so 2019 was the best you can get it had really good track graphics and rider movements but I can see how people didn’t like it, it’s more of a simulation than a competitive game to be honest

[@PaddyMcQueen]

You must be a real dirt motocross rider to appreciate mxgp2019. If not it s over. Totally agree with u

[@zon3394]

Mxgp 3 probably because it feels so much faster then all the other games

[@breckendudley2067]

Ikr

[@fredkurszewski782]

Fantastic review. Helped me a lot. Do you ride? If so what bike? I have a KX 112 at the moment, working toward a KTM 250.

[@Threekings96]

MXGP pro is unmatched, you just have to turn all the assists off and really master riding the bike or you’ll crash 60 times per moto

[@alkqk4103]

wdym turn all the assists off?

[@bamgaming3342]

Only thing I’d do is swap 2020 with Pro, I played over 250hrs on Pro and did extreme career for like 8 seasons or so, won both championships and got the exclusive gear. It was an absolute grind and I feel you could get away from the “inconsistencies” in the turning and jumps with bike set-ups, it was the first game I really learned how I like a bike to feel in game. By the time I finished my last season on 450 I was winning by 15+sec every race, other than France, idk why but they were always fast there, it’s the only trophy I never got on that game.

[@Hyde446]

Have you played mxgp 1? I want to buy mxgp 1 or pro, but I can't decide which one is better.. Some say 1 had better physics, pro had speed etc..

[@IBLESSU]

@@Hyde446 pro all the way

[@thecvhsricer3121]

The whips in mxgp1 were sooo good. Honestly their a lot worse now and if they would’ve just kept it the same I wouldn’t even be mad.

[@TmeupTeddy]

They were aight but all the same

[@tp1_philler179]

Agreed on MX GP3 in 1st, I've played that game more than all of the others combined.

[@moerxl]

How did you get the Redbull helmet in mxgp pro and That Grapcit

[@FruMonkey018]

MXGP 3 was my #1 was as well. I didn't like the bike's reaction to the mud, until I adjusted gearing to make a gear high work. There were too many mud races in the premier class championship though. Seemed like every event was a mudder. Then my complaint with all of Milestone's games is the interval between you and the AI. You could start 30 seconds back and still win. But if you raced for real with similar lap times, you wouldn't win by a large margin.

[@corlienboshoff5736]

How does the profile look of MXGP 3

[@coatsyboi125]

completely agree with mxgp3 being top i have so much fun in this game just seems to make you smile when you finish the race rather than just rushing to the next one to get it over and done with

[@shawnoconnor9692]

We went from the 360 playing reflex to the ps4 playing mxgp. I was blown away and imo mcgp is one of the best mx games all time. The nostalgia plays

[@jensvincent2060]

I agree with your list but I would switch Pro around with mxgp 3. And I was wondering if you are going to do one with the supercross gamers or then combined😁

[@windham151]

Fair enough. Ive done a combined one, but it was a while ago when the newest game was Supercross 1 at the time. I guess it depends on what you all would prefer to see!

[@andrewktm1043]

@@windham151 I would like you to do that video again where you do your ranking on all the milestone games when supercross 4 comes out

[@René.831]

I’d say 2019 is my #1

[@rydereads5872]

Mxgp 3 was so fun the bike felt like it was floating around track a lot tho

[@semu8030]

Where would you put MXGP 21 on the list?

[@louiedangelo3843]

2019 is the best for me. 2020 was a disappointment.

[@trooperhugge9122]

I liked 2019 spent 90 hours in it but I also enjoyed first person in 2020 except I only got 30 hours in it anyways best mx game I played is mx bikes where I have 100 hours

[@risingspeed-b7j]

that is very good game everyone can enjoy when play this game

[@MrSamadolfo]

Thank you for the list, appreciate it 😊

[@CatTrashRacing]

MXGP 2021 is bomb!!!!

[@spud76]

I have completed mxgp3 and that was an pretty good game, and then i played mxgp 2020 and used more time on fighting the handling of the bike, the back end ruined the handling all the time. And then i played mxgp pro and felt the handling were a bit off some how and then i played mxgp 2019 and the handling was spot on, it was an orgasm on to wheels, and the AI was awesome to work with, and the way the ground changes lap by lap was awesome. So my list of those mxgp game i have played is: 1. mxgp 2019 (perfect handling and very good AI) 2. mxgp 3 (Very good handling) 3. mxgp pro (Handling is kind of strange) 4. mxgp 2020 (Jumpy rear end) have not played mxgp 2021 yet, but for now i totally love the handling in mxgp 2019, all the other things in the game are not much to write home about.

[@enearox1687]

Did you play mxgp 2021? 2019 or 2021? Which you prefer?

[@Jimbomies]

So glad I saw this video. Mxgp3 is on sale on steam for 4.49. I’ll grab it for sure

[@rafael_araujoxz7]

agreed, on point... 🤙

[@Max2corde]

Can you make the same with supercross game ?

[@Max2corde]

For me it’s the second

[@windham151]

I'll probably wait for Supercross 4 to officially release first and put some time into it. But we can for sure make that happen.

[@silverado1117]

@@Max2corde personally I prefer the 3rd

[@Max2corde]

@@silverado1117 i like the third too But, the physics are a litlle bit better in the second for me

[@daniellopezpostigo9144]

MXGP 2019 is the best of all, with a huge difference.

[@42mx85]

@Jack Messina yea same

[@peleliuvet]

yea there is no rolled jumps

[@dmmz3534]

Bro shall i buy it on xbox one

[@dmmz3534]

@@42mx85 bro shall i buy mxgp2019 rn?

[@daniellopezpostigo9144]

@@dmmz3534 Sure

[@louispouliot4102]

As said bellow, MXGP 3 with terrain deformation is for me the best one in the serie.

[@Tj-nr9jh]

Ruts actually grab the bike wish for a remaster

[@1934tw]

Looking at MXGP 3 on Steam sale (sept. 2024)… this vid is three yrs old… is MXGP 3 still atop of this list? Tx

[@turtlenso404]

Thx for vidéo. For me the best is MXGP 3 (more fun) & MXGP 2019 fine (but physics slip a bit too much). Others : MXGP 1 is good but old. MXGP 2 slow gameplay and too rigid motorcycle, MXGP pro I didn't try (I played too much MXGP 3 lol), MXGP 2020... (i play 2 hours with lot of different motorcycle and the physics drove me crazy 🤪 (is an MXGP game with a physics of super cross(incompatible in my opinion)).

[@xChaoSVictoRx]

Best choice to buy mxgp 2020 or mxgp3??

[@windham151]

MXGP 3 for sure.

[@ravenhawke5]

The only MXGP games I've played is 3 and recently started playing 2020. MXGP 3 is by far one of my favorite MX games. 2020 is ok but the track editor sucks no matter what the custom tracks have an overly generic feel to them, more so than the SX track editors which are at least fun to play of they are built right.

[@markbaum3388]

I ride and Pro in first person feels real, and if you dont understand why your falling in corners or whatever its simply cause you dont ride and race motocross, thats the reality of it.

[@roamablee]

i was about had the opinion between MXGP 3 and Mxgp2021. mxgp 3 for me graphic wise is not good but in gameplay it was the best ever. in mxgp 21 the graphic is the king but i find the uncomfortable in the gameplay the physic was too hard for me and so unenjoyable. so ive got find the solution about those minus and plus. And U KNOW WHAT MXGP 19 is my choice. i know the bike sound is poor. but its graphicly good and i enjoy the gameplay physic. even ive done some career mode in it.

[@TivAu]

I was waiting for u to do MXGP Compact

[@greg6162]

MXGP 2021 is fantastic!!! Gets frustrating on late laps and I’m not sure how to keep from falling. I’m new and I play with manual/advanced everything and no assists. It’s amazing railing a berm with the clutch boost

[@Dustygolem]

I’m having a little trouble with the clutch boost on like how to do it lol

[@kyleplayz834]

I just recently downloaded MXGP Pro after beating Legends, and I’m having a blast with it. But holy shit what a challenge it is

[@beeemmdoubleu-n05]

MXGP Pro has the Best 2 Stroke Sounds and I Still Have this Game

[@AshtonG2022]

I ordered the game from GameStop did I make the right choice or should I have found a different MXGP Game?

[@tgrsklz]

MXGP 3 is the only game I have a platinum trophy for, that's saying something.

[@D1I.]

Is mxgp 3 60fps on ps5?

[@2strokerippin01]

THE MAN THE MYTH THE LEDGEND windham151

[@HankBaxter]

I used this guide to decide which MXGP to dive into for the first time. 2020 it is for me, because 3 (as well as 2019 and Pro) screwed up the rear wheel spin speed, which is insane considering the original and second game did it properly. Total immersion breaker.

[@Modoholic]

I might catch some flak for this but in my opinion mxgp 2019 was hella fun. I loved that game it was so much fun and i basically had the game figured out to a T man. I dont really see where everyone hates on that game. I guess they must have experienced things in that game that i never experienced. But in my opinion that game would have been 2nd with gp3 in 1st and either gp 2020 or gp 2 in 3rd

[@JustEdit22]

I agree MXGP 3 was my fav to

[@linusnilsson2734]

I completely agree with this list tbh.. Although I would put MXGP2020 first I think

[@joedavidjarvis7617]

I agree, everyone hates on 20 but it seems more challenging and I am enjoying it alot. I waited after all the issues and just got it last week. I am having awful lagging/freezing issues when it rains. Other than that I like it! I have all of them except Pro

[@xChaoSVictoRx]

@@joedavidjarvis7617 better to buy gp 2020 or mxgp3?

[@nicholasbarbieri3566]

Mxgp 2019 has probably the most realistic physics so I really like it

[@qdn7720]

hahhahahahaha, no free rotation in the air, no ruts, and sliding everywhere REALLY REALISTIC

[@nicholasbarbieri3566]

@@qdn7720 do you ride a dirt bike? The free air rotation in games like supercross 3 is way too much, you can't do that in real life. Also if you ride on a track without ruts and you go full throttle all the time with a 250 or 450 you probably will slide more than you do in the game

[@nicholasbarbieri3566]

And for the ruts, there aren't neither in the others mxgp

[@qdn7720]

@@nicholasbarbieri3566 in mxgp3 you have some ruts but i would more like to have more rotation than nothing

[@qdn7720]

@@nicholasbarbieri3566 and in real life you dont have flat tracks without ruts

[@rbolton_1018]

I do badly wish glen Helen was in mxgp2020 it’s such a good track or even like pala or something

[@aidenj8968]

Red bud would be the best with larocos leap

[@Darrylx444]

Do any of these work in VR? Are there any VR motocross games anywhere? Thanks

[@tonixuk]

This and some of your other videos pretty much got me into milestone mxgp games. I'm now the owner of MXGP 3 (PS4 & PC) MXGP PRO (PC & XBOX) MXGP 2019 (PC & XBOX) and MXGP 20 (PS5 & PC). My order from best to worst (love them all) 1. MXGP PRO 2. MXGP 3 3. MXGP 20 4. MXGP 2019. Like you I love them all. Thanks for introducing me to such a great game series

[@markbaum3388]

Pro 100%, thats why its still over $50 onsteam also its 15 gb and the newest one is only 15gb, kinda a shame really.

[@kodiens87]

MXGP 3 MXGP pro MXGP 2019 MXGP MXGP 2020 MXGP 2 my list

[@Jason_Bover9000]

Have you played mxgp 2021 version

[@masonlattie1938]

Mxgp 2 is the first one I ever played still it's the only one I have I'm looking for ideas on the games to buy I ride in real life but ya thanks for ur ideas man helped me alot

[@namewithdrawn3148]

MXGP was and still is the GOAT

[@jl0699]

Do you mean MXGP 1, yeah im prefer that mxgp more than other. The physic very more realistic. The bike seem very solid and heavy, other mxgp its kinda arcade. The bike is light.

[@julienrool]

Thanks for your vidéo ! Wich one IS the most arcade ?

[@windham151]

Pro is probably the least. All the rest are pretty similar. I think MXGP 3 has a great balance. You can also choose to have realistic or standard physics. That will give you more control over whether or not it feels more arcade.

[@lennmx911]

MXGP 1 has so much Potential Its is so much more as it looks like

[@jl0699]

The most realistic one than other mxgp. The physic, bike, including the track.

[@Freeridin07]

Hey man, so what is your best overall motocross game from all the different series like mx vs atv, mxgp, mx bikes, etc???

[@sbbeowulf8296]

1st mxgp game I loved

[@kadenschiller7549]

How did u get those graphics and what bike is that

[@TheCaptainBoat]

The main problem I have with gp3 is that the Hondas are a bit under powered compared to the other bikes, and the Ktms were way out of the other bikes leagues.

[@kirboturbo6932]

The lack of air in '19 gives me anxiety for some reason hahaha

[@duno22133]

20 and 21 have blown me away tbh.. but they're also my first games

[@Neko123Uchiha]

MXGP3 and Pro and my favorites by far! Pro is in second place, due to the consistency stuff... which is really weird. But 3 felt the best overall, even coming back to it after many years! 19 was ok, but a step back from Pro. And I actually refunded 20 because it did not feel right for me. Never played 1 and 2 though.

[@rmz250k7]

I agree, 19 was definitely a step back from Pro. I just put in 24odd hours in Pro to get all the trophies, and man did I have some fun with it! I feel the bike setup is probably the best on pro, so reactive with only 1 'click' on the suspension. Absolutely love the physics.

[@Neko123Uchiha]

@@rmz250k7 I somehow have 100 hours in Pro lol But I played the career with full length races a lot. Still come back to either Pro or MXGP3 here and there :)

[@MichaelThomas-xc6vy]

I would reverse mxgp3 with mxgp2020. 3 was a little too difficult for me in some rut situations. 2020 takes time to get use to them but they are great and easier to navigate. Pro was way too sensitive. Seemed way too easy to crash. Really enjoying 2020!

[@buffyvassey8112]

Great vid!

[@DustinNuttall]

MXGP 2019 is my favorite because it's the most realistic feeling and the ladt one with track rut making. MXGP3 is 2nd for me. MXGP 2020 is the worst one.

[@Jason_Bover9000]

Is this better then mx vs atv series

[@colby69420]

No

[@that_drummer_guy647]

Mxgp pro is and will still hold down to be the best mxgp... idc how many new one they make that ones on top

[@turdfurgeson5196]

Excitebike was the shit!

[@eriksforestryvision8751]

I agree with your choices and reasoning exactly.

[@Fishy_outside]

I love personally mxgp3 because the controls aren't so touchy

[@jsimo1431]

good honest review. i still only play mxgp 2.

[@Wetpocksandcussys]

How do u unlock online

[@erikrainieri1772]

I gave a try almost to all of those, to some way more than others, expecially mxgp2 and pro, but i had the most fun with MXGP. I think making a sim for dirtbike is something kinda impossible, on asphalt races and on 4 wheels races it's manageable expecially because you have steering wheels and pedals as controller to get a reference for the response and asphalt doesnt change as much as mud during a race. Recreating the feeling with motocross and supercross means recreating something very complicated, there are too many variables so it will never be possible to do an accurate sim as we intend it and it will always just be a subjective perception. That's why i don't care if a dirtbike game is called a sim or not, i like when jumps looks natural and not unnecessarily high or long, i'd like milestone to improve AI (expecially when you double pass the opponents they should make you pass easier), i like when watching the replay the animation looks real and i like most of all the fun and the satisfaction the gameplay gives me. For all those reasons i like most MXGP, the feeling of those drifts made my day every time i played it.

[@paprika8795]

mxgp3 is my favourite one still.

[@markustaylor1889]

I wish they had older bikes in this series like 1995-2010 like I grew up around and saw on TV

[@RZxDnB]

3 is my favorite one

[@brycessquare4208]

Mxgp is my favourite

[@itsjustaguy27]

Mxgp pro n 3 best

[@micah5156]

What gear was that in mxgp pro?