Every Supercross Game Ranked Worst To Best - Direct Comparison

[@nick-knock]

I think the camera angles and the feeling of speed on the first game was the best. They need to bring that back. The weird lack of momentum feeing in supercross 3 and 4 when you land is disappointing

[@evanjanse4038]

God bless, Jesus loves you. Yeah I agree

[@j627MX]

@@evanjanse4038 stfu

[@critfiend4736]

@@j627MX 🤣

[@tylerbryant8012]

SX1 looks the best. The lighting is just perfect. When you race outside at night you get a glare off your bike. Haven't played SX4 yet. Looks like it plays the best. They should combine the lighting of SX1 in SX4 and I think it'd be straight 🔥🔥

[@ravioli-bamboli]

Supercross 1 wasn’t perfect but the overall aesthetic is the best so far imo

[@evanjanse4038]

God bless, Jesus loves you

[@brendancarter3453]

It also exceeded all its expectations. However it set even higher expectations for the following titles that none of them imo have ever met.

[@Cr1ngedClient]

I forgot what one had it, I want to say Supercross 2. But I loved the fact that we could equip hats and all that, it felt more realistic

[@Rotwold]

03:20 - #1 Monster Energy Supercross: 3 00:25 - #2 Monster Energy Supercross: 1 04:51 - #3 Monster Energy Supercross: 4 01:30 - #4 Monster Energy Supercross: 2

[@ds6329]

Funny how in SX4 your rider is already dirty on lap 2, by himself.

[@tybolin4302]

And it looks like it came out in 2007 and it’s like the new Mxgp games where you just slide out

[@ausy1356]

Finally something I have been waiting for for ever

[@CHODE_PRODUCTIONS]

Completely agree supercross 3 was the best imo, I loved how u could scrub the jumps and be faster by using the sticks and being on the back of the bike

[@jessebecton1058]

You should rank the Daytona tracks from 1 to 4

[@Michael.Joseph]

Lol, I was literally just watching one of your ranked worst to best videos and then got the post notification for this.

[@evanjanse4038]

God bless, Jesus loves you

[@Michael.Joseph]

@@evanjanse4038 I really needed that. Thx u brother!! 😇🙏

[@judybueno3702]

Is it just me or I thought 1 was 4 for a minute?! Lol

[@doncadieux480]

Thats cuz its the best looking graphically

[@joewatts3876]

Supercross 2 has the most realistic physics I love it

[@tomasgallardo3687]

In why opinion the 2 is the best because I like the physics a good heavy bike

[@Death_To_Kong]

I only have 1 and 4, but I think the first is way better. The only thing I like in 4 is the use of the Dualsense on PS5. 4 seems stiff and has a major learning curve imo. I also prefer the look in SC1. It has a grimy, dirty look and feel. SC4 is too clean and bright.

[@brennanschroeder3010]

My favorite part about SX1 compared to the others is that the AI would actually get consistent finishes and give you a championship fight. In the newer games you'll see Tomac Webb and Roczen getting P20 every other week

[@ethanwhisman5459]

Wow Vince frazee is pushing me off the track for absolutely no reason at absolutely oh wait no that that's him torpedo torpedo in me But yes since supercross one the AI has been basically s***

[@evanjanse4038]

God bless, Jesus loves you guys

[@Tooez._.]

SX2 at 4 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮

[@Zackrey507mx]

Trick question, reflex takes the cake

[@maxxiatm4340]

My order: 2,1,4,3

[@AshtonG2022]

I’m playing Supercross 3 for the first time in a while and i forgot how much fun it is compared to Supercross 4. My favorites in order are Supercross 3, Supercross 4, Supercross 1, and then in last place Supercross 2.

[@joshuahodge1773]

Everyone has 2 last but it’s by far the best to me. I’m talking about the graphics and gameplay. I thought it would be higher.

[@butterlegs]

I feel like 4 has the most potential for longevity for me; it took the longest to get the hang of, and I'm still enjoying the standard tracks. I also can really feel the difference between regular laps and when I try to lay down a heater. I still really enjoy 3, too, but I feel like you can pin it a little too much for my liking. 2 was clunky and got boring really quickly. I did enjoy 1, and I think the novelty of it being the first official Supercross game in nearly 20 years really helped it. However, a lot of the rhythm sections lacked options, and the whoops might as well have just been a straightaway. Love them all, but I've felt improvements in the gameplay (at least for me) with each release. I usually don't play online for ages, but the career bug kinda forced me to. It's all resolved now, and I'm enjoying doing 20-minute mains.

[@milkshaki8628]

this is going to be fun

[@jakedover7726]

Just going to say the most fun I have had playing any of these games is running time trials on suppercross 2 at Daytona

[@Doublep507]

I just bought 1 and I don’t have any of the others but I’ve been playing mxgp 2 for a while and the only thing I didn’t like about it was it felt so slow. But wow I really love monster energy 1 so far

[@wmcdade9444]

A summary: Supercross 2 is realistic. Supercross 1 was solid all around. Supercross 3 is a fast paced experience. Supercross 4 is fast paced with a bad editor and revamped career.

[@Dr.PhDeez]

Honestly I feel like they just get better with each release. But the track editor was best in 1 and 2, they haven't done anything with it since.

[@evanjanse4038]

God bless, Jesus loves you

[@themanstan0785]

they’ve gotten worse imo

[@Dr.PhDeez]

@@evanjanse4038 who's Jesus?

[@GAMERDANKAR]

Good video Wind, here is my list: 3 2 4 1 I can see why you love 1 for me it felt too floaty, 3 is definetly the best of them all, keep up the good work!

[@windham151]

Thanks for watching man. For sure. Do like 1, but 3 was sooo good.

[@121speeden]

@@windham151 I felt like three had the best physics too.

[@namanswag9658]

I was thinking of getting another Supercross tbh, cuz I have the first one only.

[@Intimidator6474]

I just got number 3 since it was on sale on the playstation store, a much more difficult game and takes a lot of getting used to, especially the cornering. I feel like it could be really fun though once I get the hang of it

[@namanswag9658]

@@Intimidator6474 it's on sale for Xbox! I think I'll get it

[@gavbone524]

i think supercross 2 is the most competitive for multiplayer but lacking in every other aspect compared to the other games

[@broplayz15]

LOVE YOUR VIDS DUDE!

[@hallowedbethygains1208]

When you think about it, longevity is what they don't want you to have. It's a tactic to keep more people buying each year's game.

[@windham151]

True. Very true. But having a bad track editor with no opinions isnt a great look either. If they upset enough people, theyll just stop buying the games altogether.

[@hallowedbethygains1208]

@@windham151 yes indeed. I kind of feel like they will eventually start making dlc's for the track editor and charge like 10 bucks like they do for other content. Alot of these game developers know how to get a little bit more out of things that people like. Or maybe they will see how unhappy people are with it and make the next one better, I have seen a few little things here and there they worked on due to enough complaints. Either way I just love mx games so I'm glad we have been getting a ton of them.

[@hallowedbethygains1208]

And when I say I love mx games, I mean I still like to throw mx2002 featuring Ricky Carmichael into the ps2 every now and then lol.

[@SchruteFarms]

My personal list is 3,4,1,2. 3 had the best gameplay but the absolute worse career mode. 2 was the one I had the least amount of fun playing. 1 has a special place in my heart as it’s the one that got me into milestone games.

[@rb6277gamingSSRforfun]

In my opinion the two first supercross games were the best. In one I enjoyed most the first person camera angle and in supercross 2 the gameplay was great and made for everyone, even for casual as hardcore gamers. The physics in supercross 4 are an disaster and a difference between the AI on very easy and realistic are hardly to find. Supercross 3 is reasonable but not really top!!

[@PapahCloud]

just got 4 and then bought 1 after and so far it seems better. I have never played any of these games till recently and 1 looks better to me movements and whips

[@CMR617]

I like 3 cause the rhythms are the most accurate to real life and it was fun to find fast lines

[@BigCat5]

how bad is supercross 4's training section?? i have 7 stars left to get on the whipping and scrubbing section and for the life of me cannot get it

[@ethanwhisman5459]

I feel your pain I gave up on that after the 15th try I was like I just gave the middle finger I was like I'm done with you The biggest my biggest problem is I can't get enough pop to do the scrubs But there's an easy fix turn of Scrubs in the whips But personally I would rather turn that into like endurance training or loop speed I think that would be a much better fit for the game

[@BigCat5]

@@ethanwhisman5459 lol thats where I’m at😂

[@BigCat5]

@@ethanwhisman5459 guess im not getting 100% in this game

[@ethanwhisman5459]

@@BigCat5 you may or you may not it's if you want to try it and keep getting at it you can but it's not worth it I mean that's just my opinion though

[@windham151]

They made the training challenges so awkward to do, especially on some of those tiny little tracks in the compound.

[@Wesley_H-Lourens]

for me it was 1.sx3, 2.sx1, 3.sx4 and sx2 wil be mine least favourite. but yeah i loved them all.

[@TBUD_mxb]

Supercross 1 had the best whips they got to bring those back

[@RZxDnB]

First one I played was 1 and just now started playing it and still am playing it, currently playing career and I’m having too much fun with the game. I wanted to skip to 4 but idk just by gameplay lol I really don’t like it, might finish 1 and hop on 2, supercross 2 by gameplay looks really good then hop on 3 then 4 haha

[@tybolin4302]

Yeah 4 does not look could at all

[@thisseagamer8165]

Don’t get 2, it’s horrible. I haven’t played 3 or 4 yet but don’t get 2

[@snxgsmoving647]

Love the vids

[@windham151]

Thanks for watching.

[@darrenmcconnell6970]

i love number one it’s definitely my favourite

[@haydenscobie4533]

I have played 2 3 and 4 loved them all. To rate would be kinda hard. I wanna play 1 to warm up for 5. Even though the physics will probably be way different.

[@critfiend4736]

I got 3 based on ur reviews. I was going to get 1 until I saw this. I’m coming from mxgp3, so it was a HUGE learning curve. But once u give it a few hours, hitting a rhythm section correctly gives quite the dopamine rush. I can see myself enjoying this game if I keep a REALLY open mind to it and give the physics a chance. But god why didn’t they just take the physics they ALREADY HAD with MXGP and run it.

[@windham151]

It definitely feels different. I wish I knew you were coming from MXGP 3. Supercross 1 was the game right after MXGP 3, so it looked good and played similar to MXGP 3. I still stand by my rank for Supercross 3, but had I known, I might have suggested Supercross 1 to you.

[@Kikoholl]

i bought sx4 and played for 30 minutes. refunded. bought sx3 for that money and played for 30 minutes. refunded. bought sx1 and played for 30 minutes. refunded. and then lastly i bought sx2 and played for 30 minutes and guess what... i refunded. as someone who plays alot of mxbikes i cannot find enjoyment in these arcade mx games no matter how hard i try

[@tybolin4302]

I wish milestones would listen to their fans and put what the fans want not changing everything every year cause that just either goes good or looks completely bad

[@Trey_.z]

Stream reflex or all out?

[@haydenscobie4533]

3 your in the air forever. 1 is looking like the best so far to me. Whips and goggle glare go a long way.

[@jacobandrews4867]

Only played 3/4, I don’t like how light the bike feels in 3 compared to 4. Seems more skatey, where on 4 it feels like the bike sticks better. Also somehow the scaling feels better overall on 4 than most of 3.

[@coleburnett6018]

Hi windhim keep it up

[@marekberec564]

I have only MXGP 2021 .. which of these games Monster energy supercross do you recommend? I haven't had one yet.

[@trentonmcmillan4431]

Put 4s physics and graphics 3s compound into 1 and it’s the best

[@michaelblack1925]

Look how the visual are way better on SC 1 WOW

[@Koen1702]

I own the first game, but that has horrible framerates on ps4. Are there any other speedcross games that run on a stable 30 or 60fps on console? And one that has better physics than the first one?

[@blakebolton4852]

i havent played number 1 or 2 so i cant speak on them but as far as 3 and 4 go I think the content in 3 blows 4 out of the water but the physics in 4 are more realistic and you actually have to have flow to win a race

[@shadowm4g334]

1,4,3,2 I just enjoy 1 the most with 4 I had no bugs with 4

[@stmboat]

In no order mxgp3 mxgppro sx 1 are top for me. Funny the best outdoor course is compound at sx 1

[@frankfurt2812]

yes sx1 compound its so wild wild west 😍😍

[@alyssagale1511]

I played supercross of one this morning at a mates

[@ethanwhisman5459]

I can say one is my favorite because I played it the most But I think three is probably my second favorite because it's the one probably the most comfortable with and one through three I like all the tracks on them even if one had two tracks that I was terrible at and had to actually create setups in To be competitive Before just it feels miserable I don't think you're supposed to supposed to hate tracks when you're playing a game and I can tell you Tampa is literally at the top of the list followed by Oakland followed by Phoenix followed by San Diego now because I am completely irritated with And it's the first game that I don't actively play the career mode But yes since to the track editor has went downhill there's no doubt about that And honestly in my personal opinion before has took a step backwards in the part that in my opinion is important which is the writers the ground physics the bikes on the ground and fine for some people but I enjoyed super Cross three I was fast on it I can have anywhere from a 9 win season two of five win season I've never had less than a 5 win season on supercross 3 actually that's true in 250s I've had less but that's because I wasn't good at the 250s on that game The one thing supercross 4 has done right as they has has improved the 250s and gave us more teams for multiplayer as far as I'm concerned to choose from But you could just grind in the game and and get that so I'm still on play supercross 4 Mainly because of all the new numbers and I don't I don't know For some people it's never going to be perfect but I was comfortable with supercross 3 But in supercross 4 it's just I cannot figure out how to make the front the front stick and rotate the way I want it to It's just my biggest problem is in the game is I feel like the tracks that come with the game are built poorly and that bothers me And the compound I kind of wish there was more variety there I love the little track in the tunnel I don't want that to change but the rest of the compound I feel like could have been used better and I love the motocross track I kind of wish you could run the compound in reverse so the tracks will be more fun I just I wish milestone would clean Also I do have a problem with some things I feel like tough placement is been a problem But what do I know I don't design games I'm just a racer but I haven't made a mod at different game but I haven't made a mod though so have some idea

[@jbrat122]

The need to give us more options when it comes to gear and customization. The selection has been getting worse with each game. And they need to have an option to customize the gear and bikes, even when you are riding for a factory team, real riders don’t wear the same gear setup every race, why should we? The career needs to be a little deeper too but Everything else I love about the game

[@OASISMXB]

Mesx5 1st, Mesx1 2nd, Mesx 3 3rd, Mesx4 4th ,Mesx2 last place

[@Teremei]

Just bought the original monster energy supercross the game.

[@tylert8062]

My order is 1,4,3,2

[@tygembler]

i really like how 4 went with the career and to me it’s the best thing about the game (plus the 2strokes) but the amount of cut content breaks it for me. i understand covid could have played a factor in it but they could have used the assets from 3. my list would be 3,1,4,2 but if 4 just had more content like 3 it would be too top of the list

[@windham151]

Good ranking. The biggest problem I have with the newer games is that the track editor keeps getting worse.

[@tygembler]

@@windham151 yeah i’m not to big into making my own tracks and what not so that’s why i didn’t mention it, but it is super bland and could be 100 times better

[@jamenbrooks95]

Supercross 3, Supercross 1, Supercross 2, and then 4

[@bitopaldi]

First place: 2 Second place:3 Third place:1 Fourth place:4 (cause I don’t have it yet)

[@dc3763]

one and three looks the best for me :)

[@phifedig34]

supercross 4 the rider was so stiff!! i just feel like these games are cash grabs at this point. 1 and 2 were great, mxgp 3 was awesome… things just started going backwards after that…

[@dalesimmons2789]

Hey man, the only game I own is #1. I think I want to buy another, which one should I get? I’m kinda thinking #3. Any suggestions? I just want some new content from 1. Technically speaking, the tracks and riders are out dating in every game so that isn’t an issue for me

[@christianheath4498]

supercross 2 ai was super easy on realistic but it was still fun

[@ethanwhisman5459]

That was the thing about the first three I find it hard to find the fun part about supercross 4 Can someone point that out to me because sometimes I find it a chore to race

[@christianheath4498]

Ethan Whisman racing in 4 is hard because it doesn't matter what difficulty you're on it's gonna be hard, 3 was actually perfect in my opinion because your leading and wreck you have to fight your way back and it ain't easy

[@ethanwhisman5459]

@@christianheath4498 yeah that's a normal opinion I think it's worse on console than it is on PC I know on my Xbox One I get torpedo by Vince freeze almost every race especially when I have to come through the pack My biggest problem is the way they build tracks I mean milestone hasn't learned how the community actually builds tracks it's like they never look I mean if they actually looked at how we build tracks they might actually learn something like Because I can point at the full race tracks I hate the most and I'm I add more on to it it feels like everyday That's Phoenix actually Tampa's at the top of that list and then it's Phoenix Oakland and San Diego I'm just not fun to me I wouldn't have a problem with the Oakland if it was built right

[@6VIERTE9]

Yeah supercross 1 is the best for whips and scrubs and bike stability. But the newer games have more realistic features like ruts and square edge

[@bodice999]

in sx2 marvin looked insanely small on his bike

[@mototoad1242]

So now that 5 is out where does it fit on this list?

[@zacharietshileu7482]

In 2 the bike felt really heavy but in 3 the bike didn't have as much weghit so it was easy to corner in 3 in 1 the scrubs and whips were my favorite part and the track editor but the only good the about 4 was the graphics the gear with the teams were looking good especially the redbull ktm with cooper webb monster energy kawsaki with eli tomac and honda crf 450 with ken roczen.

[@KZ14.420]

where would you rank supercross 5? Cornering is so much harder for me in supercross 5 than all the others.

[@CadenK15]

Supercross 3 Supercross 1 Supercross 4 Supercross 2

[@s1nonnn589]

Which one has the best rider customization? Sx2 only $1 on my steam, is it good customization wise?

[@windham151]

They are all pretty similar. Obviously different gear from different years, but still very similar. Supercross 2 has good customization.

[@yuhzach2436]

this might be weird but can you please do a tutorial on how to download reflex gear and bike skins bc i cant find a tutorial that works bc they are old

[@HemlockRC]

What? Absolutely nothing has changed. The old videos are still applicable

[@EDJUNIOR399]

Supercross circuit 1999 ❤️

[@coltoncoghill3925]

1 was obviously the best

[@fedthegoon]

He did see me comment 😁

[@kevinsnow9157]

2 , 1 , 3 , 4 . I absolutely hated 4 . I took it back to game stop and got something else .

[@windham151]

Fair enough. I liked 3 more than you did so I didn't mind 4 even if I thought it was a step or so backwards.

[@Sinister_Salamander]

if they would remaster reflex id pay $100 a copy lol

[@Felipe-ik2xf]

1-3-2-4

[@DaytonaPrototypes]

3's physics were ok but the career sucked. Every time you completed a season all your gear and bike upgrades were removed and had to be reapplied. Also had to complete the pointless "bootcamp" race before each season. Liked the first 2 games but 3 kinda killed the franchise for me.

[@llgarboll3570]

I hated 2 based on my experience with it. I got the game played it a bit and eventually got to a certain point where no matter what I couldn't finish the race, if I got first it would still make me repeat the race, must have gotten a lemon copy and even after some bug updates it still did the same thing

[@SenorNariz]

Why do these games look like you have a parachute on when you're in the air?

[@Dax2222]

My favorite is supercross 1

[@lucyshaw9850]

I have a Nintendo switch but they haven’t released supercross 4 on switch so I have number 3

[@teenaschoneck2806]

Same but I would switch 3and1

[@Sjekkema]

I would just rank them on release, 1,2,3,4 4 is just really bad. It looks fake, and it feels super weird. 3 is really good looking but its still weird with how the rider is. 2 is great because of al the career options, like you could do a media thing and all what we had never seen before. 1 is my favourite because i enjoyed it the most. It had fun tracks, the bike didn’t feel weird and it felt fast.

[@cadenmonroe7103]

What track did u use for suppercross 4

[@windham151]

Im pretty sure it was Arlington.

[@Dom34007]

1 looks better than 4

[@karlsylvain]

where would you place supercross 5 ?

[@pay2000]

Please make sx4 big lines

[@windham151]

Hey man. Thank you for the mods you have been making in Supercross 4. Really do appreciate all the work you put into them. Working on something for next week or the week after!

[@pay2000]

@@windham151 Thanks man!! i really apreciated it, please check the lastest mods, hope you like them.

[@jtibbs6517]

I went from super cross 1 to 4 and was expecting it to be super good so I pre ordered it, and I regret it, I should have just stuck too 1 but no one plays online anymore.

[@burkelankford482]

The whips in sx1 are the best

[@blythe1599]

For me its 1. MESX 4 2. MESX 3 3. MESX 1 4. MESX 2

[@foxfmx117]

1,3,4,2

[@brohganlong8281]

1 is by far my favorite, and 3 is my least favorite

[@oliviamaguire6386]

Can u do more mx vs atv encore

[@windham151]

I try to get a video out on the new custom maps that are good when they first come out!

[@sirquaxalot3927]

And the first one is still better