Every Milestone Dirt Bike Game + Ranking Worst To Best

[@juliusrademann1494]

Thank you that you are driving my Track ar 24:22. Hope you enjoyed it. :)

[@pippo-1073]

To anonym I played this the other night. Superb track. Well done

[@sbowley3964]

They really need to slow down on releasing these games, its overwhelming

[@KidaMilo89]

Say that to almost every sports game franchise there is.

[@baboon_tekesvortex6465]

I got mxgp3 for 10 bucks on ps4 store

[@KidaMilo89]

@@baboon_tekesvortex6465 I thought MXGP3 was garbage. Sad cause I like motocross more than supercross but that game was meh. Grinding skills and shit, it got annoying.

[@hunter.repa1]

It's like madden or cod. Super repetitive. (Except for Sx games)

[@ay-leck1369]

@@KidaMilo89 I thought MXGP3 was FANTASTIC. My favorite one of the MXGP franchise thus far. I didn't play to grind or anything, I just played to race with the different teams and bikes. Grinding usually came afterwards because I had already racked up so many credits from just spending hours on the game for the fun of it.

[@PurgatoryInc]

MUD, MXGP 2, MXGP PRO, MXGP, MXGP 3, and Supercross All I want is an MXGP with the controls like Supercross, the Whips like MXGP3, the Graphics like MXGP PRO, and the content like Supercross (Track Editor)

[@qdn7720]

Mxgp 3 whips xddddddddd

[@dkosthorst]

Free whips Would bei the best 🙌🏽

[@qdn7720]

@@dkosthorst I was hopeing it for sx2 when they said they had improved whips but again the same.... now i only hope they made better terein deformation in my opinion this is two biggest problems of their games and ai could be faster

[@brandon.mx2784]

Purgatory someone finally talking sense and thinking realistically

[@ms8ff153]

MXGP PRO and Supercross already have the same physics. I have. Milestone already said that when they released it

[@acetracer2417]

I just want a milestone game where you cant start a lap behind and still win on realistic difficulty

[@tp1_philler179]

100

[@SIRiAlerion]

I really enjoyed MXGP Pro. The best customization yet and by far the toughest game where I don't lap the entire field twice in a race. I didn't experience the inconsistencies you mentioned. The gameplay is very different then MXGP 3 and took me awhile to learn how the physics differ but I found my time spent on that game the most rewarding.

[@gwmechanical7402]

AlerDaBear agreed

[@ay-leck1369]

That's really interesting. I didn't dislike MXGP Pro, but I definitely enjoyed MXGP3 a lot more. In fact, 3 is my favorite MX/SX Milestone game (I haven't played all of them though). I did run in to some of the issues in Pro that wind mentioned, but for the most part I just think it's a mediocre game. For MXGP the grind can get kind of annoying after a while, but the gameplay is just so ridiculously fun. Every time I hop on that game I have to purposely stop myself after like the third hour otherwise I'd just waste my day playing it.

[@edmontonoilers4096]

Reflex Physics + Supercross Graphics = Heaven

[@brandon2037]

and thats a fact

[@christianheath4498]

does anyone remember ricky carmichael supercross from like 2002

[@alexCandela_]

my first videogame for ps2 of my life

[@sixteenstone007]

What about VMX Racing on PS1

[@DeeRok35]

YESSSS

[@sawyertilley1026]

yes

[@polpnorbit]

We have that on our ps2 and I can say that is still has tons of fun aspects for being so old

[@Coregasm]

Am I the only one who absolutely adores MUD? It’s one of my favorite games to always come back to. Soundtrack also shreds.

[@nofxceghxst9192]

MUD (obvious reasons) Mxgp 1(lacked a lot of what we expect now in milestone games especially in terms of customization but was still quite a challenging and fun game) Mxgp 3 (best track deformation of them all excluding pro, great customization, ability to ride for pro teams, introduced the weather system, had the easiest ai of all the games depending on the track you were on) Mxgp 2( first game to introduce riding for pro teams, greatly expanded customization from 1, best bike models of the series in my opinion they felt heavy and you had to know how to maneuver them, most dlc content and launch day content before supercross) Mxgp pro (i know a lot of people say it regressed in some areas but i respectfully disagree. The in air was way more lose and dynamic, you could reposition yourself correctly before landing everytime for people who say you crash every 5 seconds. Relied solely on your skill and your setup, i can't tell you how many days it took to find the right gearing, suspension and braking for each individual bike not to mention figuring out what works for each track. The hardest ai to date, people say milestone don't listen but they turned the ai up to 11 in this game like people supposedly wanted. Had the best bike sound quality i think of any moto game ever, especially the 2 strokes, whoever did their sound design that guy deserves a gold medal) Supercross (oh man, i could play this game til the end of time and never get bored. Customization is the best and most expanded besides maybe pro, the game just looks beautiful, the bike models i would say are my second favorite besides mxgp2. Endless amounts of user generated content from the track creator even though it lacked some basic features. Best scrub/whip animation they've produced, i wish they would just stick with it and expand upon it in some way but it just looks so nice when you scrub perfectly in this game. Better than reflex

[@Matw1606]

For me it's defiantly MUD, MXGP 1, MXGP 2, (Could be switched with 1) MXGP Pro, MXGP 3, Supercross. MXGP Pro and 3 could be swapped in my opinion. Just MXGP 2 is really bad in my opinion, sure the bikes felt heavy but it just wasn't fun, great looking bikes though, but tracks looked like complete shit in some of them. I really liked the air physics with Pro, and 3 was just pretty good, loved supercross just all together great game for the tracks

[@skolskjutare971]

Mud mxgp 2 mxgp1 thats the only ones i have played

[@ReduxClips]

Bro when i got the first mxgp I thought it was the best game EVER .LOL😂 but now that i realise its graphics dont look that good

[@weplayOldschool]

unfortunately supercross the game has just indoor tracks (cuz of the theme) which all look super boring IMO...i think i´ll get mxgp3 then.

[@arig589]

du hier

[@eza7944]

Free roam is outside

[@eza7944]

@Jaxcax123 yes it is. It’s outside free roam area in number 3

[@inclantayakajackie284]

Stupid i love supercross dum dum

[@grasshopper0274]

play both

[@fullypinnedfilms2910]

If mxgp pro’s air physics and customization were combined with mxgp 3’s ground physics and mesx’s whips it would be a perfect game

[@nigeldean1813]

You're spot on about pro, I just picked it up and idk how I'm feeling about it yet, three is definitely my favorite I'm gonna have to pick it up again, never played the supercross games but I just ordered the third one so I'm hoping I like it

[@Anthropophagus]

As far as the Supercross games go, 1 and 2 are good - 3 and 4 are not, at least in my opinion.

[@Albelzen]

I completely agree with Pro's inconsistency on the pro physics setting. I feel putting it to standard or semi-pro takes away some of that inconsistency and makes it much more fun imo

[@carlospoveda77]

The best game ever is the MXvsATV Reflex,the whips are...🔥🔥🔥✊👊✊👊

[@ThePhunkymunkie]

I've always enjoyed MX Superfly - its old but theres just something about it

[@kingperfection1868]

Totally agree it was awesome

[@nigeldean1813]

Hell yeah that and MX 2002

[@motomouth33]

They should make a game with reliable servers that don't crash or kick you every time you play the game. Fix the damn net code too.

[@iamflake-official]

I have to disagree on your opinion on MXGP Pro. In the beginning, I also thought its very inconsistent. But the more I played the more I realized where I was going wrong. On the 250s, its a lot easier but with the more powerful bikes like the 450 and 2-strokes you really have to be careful with your throttle and the way you turn into corners. Spurting your throttle in corners will kill you. Nonetheless, I know a lot of people dislike it for these and probably other/more reasons and that's respected, to each his own. I have to admit though, MXGP Pro is my first MX game in a LONG time. Like I'm talking about Motocross Madness 2 long ago. xD But I like the look of MXGP Pro due to the more realistic grounded physics and graphics and looks. I get that the whips/scrubs aren't that open feeling, I mean, even someone that only learned what a "scrub" is due to this game, it does feel like its a bit on rails. BUT, I am enjoying it and thats the selling point to me. Your opinion respected. :)

[@windham151]

Thanks for the thoughts on the game man! Yeah, I know some people that really do love it. I know some people that absolutely shred in the game. Glad to see you join back into the moto games.

[@akuhyytiainen8921]

I played mud 5minutes and then deleted it

[@zacmurray1247]

Aku Hyytiäinen MUD was a good game because MUDA did insane backflip

[@the300exc]

Haha

[@AshtonG2022]

MUD WAS ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE.

[@matthewnetherland6542]

I agree with you 100%.i love mxgp 3

[@Matthewmm110]

Matthew Netherland mxgp 3 is the best still

[@sketchy7films602]

Watching in 2020 when supercross 3 is out

[@austinjordan258]

Does it take number 1 or nah?

[@sketchy7films602]

Austin Jordan For sure

[@damon991]

6. MUD 5. MXGP 4. MXGP 2 3. Supercross 2. MXGP 3 1. MXGP Pro FIGHT ME

[@bpmotard1458]

This is my list too, don't understand this #5 stuff... oh well

[@Matthewmm110]

MXGP3 before the MXGP pro

[@gavingraham1439]

Mxgp 1 and 3 where my favorite. I didn't even get through mxgp 2s first race cause of all the crashing as you said

[@jedisaki730]

Wanted to buy a Milestone mx game for ages, however I'm a MX vs ATV fanboy through and through since my PS2 days, so I just didn't know what to choose. I'm really glad I watched your video, your ranking of the MX vs ATV games was nearly exactly the same as mine. And I too put Reflex at the top. Because of this, I went straight to buy MX Supercross on steam, and thank go I made that discussion, because it's currently 70% off xD.

[@jimtorstensson5477]

Mxgp 1 with pro physics and better sound of the bike is the new game!

[@Francisco_997]

Mud, mxgp, mx vs atv reflex, mx vs atv supercross, mxgp 2, Supercross 2, mx vs atv alive, Supercross 1, mxgp pro, mxgp 3 Ist my opinion✌🏻

[@stefanochiodi8800]

all MXGP games i love. I saw Supercross, Saw East Rutherford, NJ, Saw u can get state flags, saw myself entering my credit card into for Supercross 3, and yes, im New Jersian

[@b1gbeppe]

Should do the ATV off-road fury games?

[@gabewilliams5993]

You should this on all of the MX VS ATV games!

[@elliotpierson8350]

He already did, he mentioned it at the beginning

[@MeGuess_Adventures]

Yep you’re list is spot on. Keep it up! I think it also had a ton of good feed back for the public and milestone.

[@S_Chassis91]

MUD whips are better than the push button whips we have today haha

[@natekitchy]

I liked that in mxgp 1 you could ride in the pits and look around in it. The closest game that almost is like that is mxgp pro but still couldn’t ride into the pits

[@sixteenstone007]

So the best one is the game we just got for free with PlayStation Plus? There's so many of these I get the names mixed up.

[@jacksonlee9895]

Same

[@LoganBarth.]

You mean supercross the game 1

[@-a-9785]

The time with Mxgp and the PS3 was nice, but now Supercross is my favorite Milestone game.

[@gwmechanical7402]

I like mxgp19, the best one yet for me it feels like, let’s hope they bring out a new one everyone loves👍

[@blue_berry_6830]

Yeah me too, i think supercross 3 handling Is weird

[@Cr1ngedClient]

MXGP 1 was awesome. Super OG game, but I loved it. Had factory teams, even helmets to match like Rockstar Energy and what not. I probably got that 1 and supercross ranked 2 followed by MXGP 2 at 3.

[@N75911_]

I'm pretty hyped for MESX2, I skinned half a dozen bike replicas for the first game, which were a pain to figure out how to get into the game. But one thing that makes me feel uneasy is the fact that all of the whips I've seen for MESX2 look just like MXGP PRO...

[@carpcatcher]

I love mud its always been my if bored go to game yet it was really hard

[@BarrieBuskruitZV]

Who remembers MTX Motorex on the psp. Travis pastrana's compound. Omg. Loved the game somuch

[@Getoffmycloud53]

09:30 well spoken - refreshing.

[@Vahisofficial]

Mxgp3 is by far the best. And one minus in Pro was that theres no Official teams.

[@imperfectclark]

Upvote Gnarbike as arcade-style moto (2.5D scroll) as best option on phone (Android/iOS). Gnarbike 2 just released, seems promising.

[@nocoastmotocross2863]

Do you suspension and gearing and you wouldn't not like the "inconsistency" of cornering and crashing. You wouldn't go down as much

[@boengel5342]

That's my opinion too. Once I tuned and put more time into It I loved it. Otherwise in the beginning I felt the same as he did.

[@Koen1702]

I really want to buy a Supercross game, but which one should I pick. Almost everyone says different games are the best. Some say the first, some the second, etc.

[@dewiiittle7951]

I wish they would make a good Mxgp game with mxon and and the mxgp 2 rut system

[@grantmarshall566]

Dude, I like MXGP3 and MESX1, but I think when MESX2 comes out, it will be better!!! So hyped for MESX2!!!

[@frankfurt2812]

do you mean mxgp 2 is your favorite ?

[@dustinstorms5930]

Literally agree with you 100% about everything! I also thought supercross was going to be mxgp3. Was hoping mxgp pro was going to be like supercross and now I'm praying that supercross2 is NOT going to be like mxgp pro. Still like milestone though

[@rickvisser8296]

What i would like, is that milestone put some random tracks in, for practice between the GP's. I would also like to see Supercross and MXGP combined and if they gonna throw away those awful airmovement... it wil be great.

[@obeseraccoon843]

Rick Visser so you mean kinda like Reflex did, they should do that because the loading times for every milestone game is long as crap.

[@rickvisser8296]

@@obeseraccoon843 yeah kinda like reflex, but then real tracks so you dont get bored and click off some laps! But yeah it is too long.

[@ericw7287]

I love your videos man. You-tubers like yourself are a huge inspiration to me. Keep up the great work!

[@windham151]

Thanks for the support man!

[@BrankoP85]

Personally, im MUCH more excited to see a Ride4 unveil soon (hopefully)!!!! Loved Ride2 and Ride3!!

[@keons1585]

When I was playing mxgp 3, I was doing career mode and was in first place by like 5 seconds and everytime i completed a lap I saw a mpc just glitched on the side and then I finished the race I got second and I was apparently behind the glitches mpc by like 2 minutes

[@jasontibbs2832]

T#gf

[@torpedocyclonetom217]

Watching this now and seeing the direction milestone went, makes me wish we wish we weren’t SO harsh on on milestone about Pro, makes sense at the time but they fumbled moving forward

[@xVampyreMoonx]

I mostly agree with you, but. I'd swap the top 2. Mainly because I like Motocross style tracks better than Supercross style tracks... But Track editors add a lot to any racing game.

[@graham6853]

Was most of the inconsistency of Pro fixed with patches? I bought it with the recent psn sale and have no issues with crashing as long as I land straight. I agree the whips and scrubs are tough to pull off though, but as long as I get the bike back around straight and don't jump into a hill (case), I do fine.

[@alfredorodriguez4539]

Only use mxgp pro for the compound using the yz250 haha supercross 1 was the best like doing triples and quads even whipping felt so fun and enjojable also mxgp 2019 its fine.

[@SchruteFarms]

I agree for the most part. I honestly liked Pro for the graphics and the realism but it was just too inconsistent. Felt a little rushed to me. Super cross the game is one of the few games that I can play over and over and over and never get bored. No pro teams to join in career was a bummer though.

[@richey4801]

Mx vs ATV Reflex somehow has the best feel for the ride, like there aren't any like whips and that is good cuz you have the freedom to like kinda make awesome whips on your own.

[@skoot859]

Could not agree more with your list! MXGP PRO was one of the biggest let downs and a HUGE step backwards for the company! Love monster energy supercross and play it to this day!

[@NikGamesHD]

Its funny how the MUD Terrain Deformation is the exact same as in MXGP 2021

[@blznmtl]

I think we need a updated video of this with supercross 4 and mxgp2020 included...... if your here in 2021 like for his attention

[@windham151]

Funny you mention that...have been working on something for MXGP games.....

[@blznmtl]

Very cool looking forward to it..... enjoy your vids keep it up

[@blznmtl]

Out of all the games what would you say is the best in your opinion? I have all but the two newest ones and I still feel like supercross 1 is the best.

[@smirnov___ice]

What I really miss in today's milestone games is the clutch. In MXGP 2 the clutch was amazing an pretty usefull but for some reason in today's games it does literally nothing. Also the first person pov today is trash, I played MXGP 2 first person only (there is a mod for pc were the field of view is bigger so you can see the handlebars) and it was sooo much fun.

[@oumsami8722]

Yesterday i had the choice between MXGP PRO and MXGP2019 i bought MXGP2019 and now that you said MXGP Pro isn't the best im so Glad that i picked MXGP2019 XDXDXDXD

[@sir_rick_dickpump]

I got MXGP(the FIRST ONE) for 4 pound now that’s a steal

[@chris4087]

Exactly mud was pure arcade I enjoyed it. Realism doesn't mean instantly the best. Reflex in my opinion had the best of both worlds and most fun. The steep learning curve in reflex I almost missed the best racing games ever. When I first got it I played for 2 hours and thought this sucks. I did this about 3 times then the 4th or 5th time it just clicked. Was the first I played utilising the twin sticks that threw me off but when it clicked was heaven. Could make best looking whips too.

[@alexbrand7181]

The only thing i didnt like about MESX is the whips, it felt like the front end would dip so far down and you couldn't fix it sometimes but they really nailed that game though

[@iwanttocomplain]

I enjoyed your video. i was curious about motocross games but only became so after looking for a trial bike game. After seeing the trials in Wales some years ago I was wondering if there was a video game that replicated this insane trails/trials going up sheer rock faces and such but there is no game like that after the 8-bit era at least. I would enjoy a video on either *all* the Milestone games (Screamer onwards) or either a top 20.

[@coryjd1970]

also for GP 3, wasnt there also the monster, rockstar and red bull helmets

[@colinlande1640]

I play MXGP 2 on the Xbox one and MXGP Supercross Rush on my Galaxy S7 active. I don't know which one I like better.

[@MotohUS]

MUD (never played it), GP1, GP3, GP Pro, GP2, Supercross GP2 is the best GP game and if you don’t agree I get it but that game was my start in KZbin. I found my Nich in content creation! Supercross is great, still making videos on it right now!

[@frankfurt2812]

why mxgp 2 is the best for you ? (buying mxgp 2 today)

[@William.S-k2b]

thanks for uploading this!

[@nogad8909]

Of course you gonna put Supercross on top you are a American that like to fight the tough blocks all race!

[@bpmotard1458]

I don't have a lot of stuff to complain about MXGP Pro -> #5 lol. You really went subjective here, I know you did not enjoyed it a lot, but this one was more sim than the others... It's like saying DiRT Rally 2.0 is worse than DiRT 4 because you crash a lot more.

[@jacksondevries6180]

bpmotard or because the only thing improved from 3 was the graphics

[@jameszbierski391]

I didn’t like MXGP PRO in the beginning but over time I loved it

[@afistfulofpimples1745]

I think Pro was made for the homosexual community. That's why it's so bad.

[@nikahmedkamil6608]

My opinion suppercross when you ride you feel little bit realistic compare to MX , But MX is fun if you don't care much about realistic physic and just want do cool stunt and easy handle. Both have a unique ways to present the game. Both are Great games to me.

[@Moonayyy]

Ive only play mxgp, mxgp3 and monster supercross. For sure mxgp 3 and monster supercross are best (best for outdoor motorcross and best for indoor supercross) after playing these 2 i find it hard to go back to any other motorbike games.

[@Ravenv177]

I like mxgp 3 and pro and supercross but im waiting for them to add proper deep ruts around small corners like on downhills it would be cool

[@Stars_Excella]

So on MXGP Pro.... We cannot use official bikes anymore on the race and career too.....

[@52foreman52]

I get where you are coming from 100% on how they mislead everyone with what MXGP Pro was really going to be like. I loved GP3 and SX was really solid as well. I guess my only difference would be I would have GP Pro in third, GP2, GP1, and Mud. I never found Pro as bad as a lot of people, but I understand it. It's hilarious hearing you go on about it hahah. I don't think I've ever heard you so passionate about disliking a game. In tears over here LOL.

[@alexanderfriberg4881]

We need an update on the mx vs atv ranking now that all out is finished🙏

[@jessemulock1163]

Damnit Windham! I was going to do a video like this today!! I mean I still will cause it isnt the same concept

[@RizzemwiththeTism589]

I say mxgp pro deserves at least a top three spot. However I still think that mxgp 3 is better.

[@ItsCozi]

They should honestly release the games after the supercross seasons so we have the tracks for that year. I think more people would like it better being able to race the current tracks and no the old ones.

[@nolan13mx34]

Milestone needs to make an AMA game

[@yoinkisboinkus4825]

I would love for and updated version of this list

[@windham151]

Indeed needs to happen. For sure one game I would add to the top would be Supercross 3. The game has really grown on me. Just my opinion, but feels like the best one out of the 3 Supercross games we have gotten.

[@austinlewis5584]

This man stole my monster energy gameplay

[@BMXrider915]

1. Supercross 2. MXGP Pro 3. MXGP 3 4. MXGP 2 5. MXGP 1 6. MUD

[@King2Stone]

I'm in a solid agreeance with you on PRO, that game is more or less the saddest. . .

[@SouthernR0cker4Life]

Realistic Crash Physics where if one falls off, they have to actually get up, walk back to the bike, get back on and continue would be nice.

[@megaboomnetwork9383]

Mxgp pro in my opinion is one of the better milestone games I have not play the other MXGP games though

[@reubenbishop5832]

Haha the Eli tomac joke

[@x.v3n0m.x]

MX vs ATV Untamed will always be my favorite 😂

[@austin10310]

Love your videos man. Keep it up

[@d3tach3d]

The only thing MUD has thats badass is deformation of the terrain. Even newer games dont do that. The Tessalation tech came out around 2014 and any racing game should have ground deformation.

[@BoardingMold446]

Perfect list.

[@simonhaslinger8601]

Love your vids❤❤❤❤

[@ryanwebley741]

Unpopular opinion but mud might have been a terrible game but that didn’t stop it from being extremely fun, if you look at it like a complete arcade game then you will have an awesome time

[@janineboyce1857]

1 mxgp pro,2 mxgp 3,mxgp 2, 4 mxgp 1, 5 supercross,6 mud

[@Ahzafera]

Guess arcade games have seriously gone down in quality because Excitebike 64 would have been my definition of an arcade game, and I loved that game.

[@Psychona-sf2rq]

windham and everyone else. I'm a ROOKIE (beginner) trying motocross. Since there are so many to choose from could the consensus *everyone) tell me what one do you recommend for begineers? I have a ps4

[@windham151]

MXGP 3 is a very solid game to start with. Outdoor tracks are easier to ride around if you havent played moto games very much. Supercross The Game 1 is also very good, but maybe will be tougher if you are just getting into these games.

[@Endi7]

Mxgp pro was a disappointment for me. Especially compared to 3 with the ruts. No idea what they were thinking.

[@boengel5342]

I feel that was the only thing wrong with it compared to 3 lol. I like how fast it feels on pro. The bikes actually go lol.

[@SB3Videos]

Once SX4 has been out for a while you should re-look at this list & do a new video!