Every Type of Government Explained in 10 Minutes

Go to ground.news/tpe to easily deep dive on any topic from every angle. My link gets you 40% off their unlimited access Vantage plan. #sponsored #ad #sponsor
Every famous type of government gets explained in 10 minutes!
Join my Discord to discuss this video:
/ discord
Subscribe and activate the bell!
💼 Business Mail: [e-mail]
- TIMESTAMPS -
00:00 Oligarchy
00:40 Confederation
01:01 Federation
01:30 Plutocracy
01:41 Monarchy
02:05 Republic
02:29 Aristocracy
03:08 Authoritarianism
03:27 Totalitarianism
03:52 Theocracy
04:11 Technocracy
04:35 Democracy
06:42 Feudalism
07:12 Demarchy
07:28 Kleptocracy
07:54 Anarchy
07:57 Corporatocracy
08:34 Socialist State
09:00 Communist State
09:31 Geniocracy
09:52 Noocracy
- SOURCES -
docs.google.com/document/d/1t...
- DISCLAIMER -
Do not use this video as your only source of information. This video is for entertainment/edutainment purposes, and some information could be too oversimplified or incorrect. This channel's goal is to spark your curiosity and let you do your own research on these topics.

[@ThePaintExplainer]

Go to ground.news/tpe to easily deep dive on any topic from every angle. My link gets you 40% off their unlimited access Vantage plan. #sponsored #ad #sponsor

[@C.A._Old]

this is best for i wait it. now i can watch it. :-')

[@elizabethdavis1696]

Please consider doing a video on direct democracy

[@c02c02]

sincerely really good sponsor segment, didn't skip a second of it

[@MrRono19]

How is this video different from your previous Political ideology one?

[@death-istic9586]

Hi.😊

[@aporifera]

They are not mutually exclusive. For example some countries are publicly democracies, practically republics, and secretly oligarchies, plutocracies, aristocracies, kleptocracies, corporatocracies all at the same time.

[@sprintfoxy1240]

Like 99% of all current countries

[@GuywithabadenglishOfficcial]

America is barely a democracy ngl

[@KyleGD]

literally all governments or countries

[@beaverjedi1236]

Hmmm... I wonder who he could be talking about.. 🇺🇲

[@SPAnComCat]

I Absolutely Agree! Especially from the Context of Late-Stage-Capitalism!

[@AngryCaesCorporation]

It's frightening to see the amount of clones this channel has created.

[@noseque2]

Channel in spanish copy paste of this 💀

[@ahmedshaharyarejaz9886]

I think its a good thing to have many channels that explain complex topics briefly and clearly. Most people only have a short time to learn such things.

[@DrSpaceman69]

Right?!?!

[@DollyNipples]

You sure this one ain't a clone?

[@AngryCaesCorporation]

@@DollyNipples I checked the date of creation, this is by far the oldest one of the several ones I saw.

[@0ld_Scratch]

it also must be noted that some of these are not mututaly exlusive, for example: You can have a democratic republic or a democratic monarchy, Germany or UK

[@eyweiuai]

I'd say this should be pinned but this video already has a pinned comment

[@aw3046]

Germany isn't a monarchy.. do you mean "A democratic republic like Germany or a democratic Monarchy like the UK"?

[@silviocupica2521]

​@@aw3046 Probably OP meant "respectively"

[@DreerKarler]

yeah, like the united states of america which are a kleptocracy, a corporatocracy and a federation.

[@eyweiuai]

@@DreerKarler this is the best kind of political humor, the kind that's funny no matter which party you're on

[@Luizz07]

3:48 >"Usually governed by a charismatic dictator" *>Draws the most disturbing and horrifying face ever*

[@SPAnComCat]

[I] Hope Adolf Hitler wasn't the one to do that Scary face.

[@johannsanchocuevas7854]

Hey... He may be creepy but he could be a cool dude... Don't judge others

[@zye.]

Nah, he's chill and looks like someone you can have a beer or two with.

[@slavkingonyoutubesavetf2130]

He said „charismatic” not handsome…

[@mr.keleton9710]

Just see Charles Manson ad the Austriac Painter that you'll see that one don't need to be beautiful to command a bunch of people

[@deltha_the_1st]

Among all the copicat of your videos that emerged after your initial success, you managed to stay at the top and finally become finacially stable with your first sponsor ! Congratulations!!

[@Zephyr314]

It's crazy how many copycat channels I've seen lol but this one is still the best by far

[@mojolmao1752]

@@Zephyr314it happens everywhere now

[@moamal9267]

They are not really copy cats, they are just inspired

[@littleoreoofficial8022]

redeemed zoomer is the og. but at this point their not copycats it’s just a trend like lukethenotables 100 days Minecraft videos

[@user-kv4ev6qs3i]

@@littleoreoofficial8022yeah I was going to say idk why people are saying this one was the og when their oldest videos are like 4 months old like people totally haven’t been making these videos for years so many historians have a bunch of videos like this

[@Dannymon]

SHOUTOUT TO DEMARCHY ALSO KNOWN AS LOTTOCRACY!!!!!

[@DreerKarler]

nobody calls it lottocracy.

[@Dannymon]

I first heard about it in a vsauce video and that's what he called it

[@DreerKarler]

@@Dannymon ok.

[@aryan__989]

Your profile picture tells a lot about you 😂 ​@@Dannymon

[@Dannymon]

@@aryan__989 Thank you!

[@hkayakh]

6:48 me when the overlord (my landlord) is trying to revoke my land (my appartment) because I haven’t given him the majority of my crop production (my rent money)

[@johannsanchocuevas7854]

Neo-Feudalism am I right?...

[@saadahtsham7]

@@johannsanchocuevas7854 imo its all kleptocracy and we SERIOUSLY need to do something about how much the people in power exploit and abuse their power

[@Cybercerialdestroyer]

Actually yes your correct

[@snowdust5382]

Not your land. Majority of you're money? Get a better job ya bum

[@samuelfaint7841]

that’s not your land tho

[@infamous7223]

The paint explainer is filling me with his paint and I like it

[@cobralexis]

What

[@punchthecake82]

😩😩😩

[@raijutama6520]

daddy's paint

[@idarkstarx6939]

Hol up

[@Thendless_Void]

read what you just wrote, slowly, several times

[@Emanon...]

Monarchies and Republics are systems of government. The rest are systems with which power is distributed within that framework. North Korea: Totalitarian Republic. Belgium: Constitutional Monarchy, parliamentary democracy Russia and the US: _Both_ are federal republics, but is dictatorial whilst the other is, well, complicated...

[@huskadog7748]

Thats what a government is, a system of power. A Republic is inherently democratic by definition, north Korea is a monarchy that wants to call itself a Republic to make itself seem democratic. A country officially calling itself something, or running sham elections does not actually make it a Republic. A totalitarian Republic would be a government with absolute control of the country that is nonetheless elected by the people in a democratic fashion, think electocracy

[@JMaher393]

More or less the official government of the USA is a Constitutional Republic. Since we’re supposed to follow the constitution but we got corrupt politicians 🙃

[@Cynd3r_]

Kleptocratic

[@elizabethdavis1696]

Please consider doing a video on direct democracy

[@armanada7600]

DID I HEAR DEMOCRACY?!

[@demi172]

isnt a directly democratic government just the concept of anarchy

[@bjrnstrottman5637]

@@demi172 A direct democracy is a government where laws are decided by the vote of the general public.

[@DaDARKPass]

Direct Democracy is a terrible idea.

[@demi172]

yeah exactly, thats what anarchists are in support of, a stateless government of no representation but instead direct vote of the people@@bjrnstrottman5637

[@badeamihai366]

Dude. I am Happy to see that this channel still goes on. I've been watching your videos from the first one : Every Political Ideology Part 1 In 8 minutes I am happy that I found you back in that day and I Hope that most people will think the same once they get to discover you and the golden content you made.

[@andycostanzo8057]

A part of me likes the idea of a technocracy.

[@joaovitormatos8147]

Technocracy is great in theory, terrible in practice

[@hebercluff1665]

​@@joaovitormatos8147 I don't know any examples of a technocratic government. Why are they bad?

[@-Oddity]

​@@joaovitormatos8147To be honest, that's a good to describe pretty much every political ideology.

[@crawlback]

If a war breaks out it's over

[@G0thCrayon]

The concept certainly has its merits, but I'm curious to see how it can go horribly, horribly wrong... Peterson Principle being what it is.

[@canimanamino2433]

That sponsership took me by such a surprise. I mean, obviously it was gonna happen, but the format just totally changed suddenly

[@capulet5580]

nice, this was an informative video. It’s nice to learn about these things without any snide remarks or political opinions being thrown in

[@Zaffr3]

"SAY HELLO TO DEMOCRACY" Fellow Citizens we must spread "Managed Democracy" across the galaxy. FOR SUPER EARTH!

[@blue_blood2885]

Way to go helldivers!!!

[@LordDanielG]

RAHHHH no one can say no to 500kg of pure freedom ⬆️➡️⬇️⬇️⬇️

[@Shori_YT]

Have a cup pf liber-tea!

[@SPAnComCat]

That would sound like a Bourgeois NeoConservative who Colonises the Galaxy and Pretends to spread "Democracy" but in Reality that would be just be Imperialism that forces the will of the Imperialist Ruling Class/Imperial-Capital at the Expense of Potential Lifeforms who are might be Sentient beings with an Organised Group that is Similar to our own. Who Knows? It's just my Opinion and a Thought Experiment.

[@baraka629]

I prefer the federation of citizens as portrayed in Starship Troopers to Managed Democracy as portrayed in Helldivers. Though unfortunately we are more likely to end up with the latter than the former, seeing as things are going.

[@user-qm6fk6zy3f]

i love your explanation so much because you explain with easy way to be understanded

[@user-jo5pl9lx5z]

There are so many rip-offs of this guy...

[@captainpelmenientertainment]

content farm

[@dodonpa-1]

thus is youtube.

[@skemmy215]

He is a rip off

[@dodonpa-1]

@@skemmy215 of who?

[@mikethearchangel11]

@@dodonpa-1Redeemed Zoomer started this trend a year before this guy was even on youtube

[@arrun5125]

The last two (Geniocracy and Noocracy) are usually more commonly referred to under Epistocracy.

[@thevlogger4523]

Absolutely amazing videos !

[@Republic_Of_Vicoria_Official]

My dad is an anarchist, and he says a common misconception in the general public is that an anarchy doesn't mean "no rules", it means "no rulers".

[@CliffCardi]

Ochlocracy: government by mob rule Pedarchy: government ruled by children Coulrocracy: government ruled by clowns

[@-RandomAnonymousPerson]

So the US is a Coulrocracy

[@seanmalloy7249]

It's missing gerontocracy -- rule by the most elderly, which is an associated characteristic of many other forms of government.

[@TheSpooncer]

I think the inca had that

[@Narut0Namikaze]

Spartans had "γερουσία" but if i recall correctly was a branch of government .

[@bsbmakesmesmile84]

Nice transition to the sponsor of this video!

[@tejasbag5506]

Subscribed!

[@Explazor]

shesh his first sponsor! they grow up so fast.

[@aw3046]

Reminder to everyone that none of these governments work perfectly, and that you should always think about human nature and realism before saying "tHiS sYsTeM sOuNdS PeRfEcT!?!?!"

[@nathandensley9104]

Precisely. Technocracy, we all become lab rats for the newest idea.

[@argusy3866]

In paper everything works perfectly. I believe thats the reason people are so obsessed with socialism, sounds so just and worried about the community... and then...

[@ibraheemshuaib8954]

The best solution lies not solidly with one ideology, but is a little bit of everything.

[@DreerKarler]

human nature is inheretly good for most people.

[@CuntDku]

Cope Feudalism is perfect

[@zaktan7197]

Pretty good video. I would like to add that an important variant for most of these types of governments is whether or not they have a written constitution.

[@stanleylayzell2506]

Good point! I believe that, as far as democracies go, the only ones without a constitution are Canada, New Zealand (Aotearoa), Israel, the United Kingdom and San Marino. In some cases (NZ and the UK) there are aspects of constitutions in several different laws/statutes

[@PunkerTrottzEltern]

Nice Video. Could you include Anarcho-syndikalism in the next one?

[@sonnyraine3445]

Lobbying is a fancy word for bribing, change my mind

[@IsaacIKE]

100 percent correct

[@dylanwillmon5672]

Nah you right

[@charliekahn4205]

Calling your representative is technically lobbying

[@dylanwillmon5672]

@@charliekahn4205 ☝️🤓

[@Ggdivhjkjl]

You missed an electocracy, which is where the people vote for candidates but the candidates are under no obligation to represent their voters.

[@julianalexander2667]

Great i was hoping for government after the political ideologies video. I love politics.

[@gytuxas9060]

You should explain every movie genre

[@Narut0Namikaze]

Very nice video and a good introduction to the concepts . One thing though that I want to comment on is about "voting" and what everybody calls "democracy" . Voting either works as the medium to express the public choice in a specific subject or a representative. If the "representative" doesnt do what the public wants we can no longer call it democracy. And the public voting for someone doesnt give him "rule" over the public. It only makes him a representative to do what the public commands him. The moment I understood that i cannot say we have democracy as many people like to say we do. I can only view it as elected monarchy.

[@jeremyroland5602]

The fact that there are people in this world who believe anarchy is a legitimate form of government is extremely disturbing. Anarchy is literally the antithesis of government, and any form of individual or group exerting control over others, or making agreements with each other, immediately means there is no longer anarchy and there is instead some form of government or ruling body.

[@richardcaves3601]

Common misunderstanding of the term. Anarchism states that there is no other government than natural government which is limited to what is agreed between individuals or groups. Anarchism has been mythologised to nihilism, which is completely inaccurate. One is everyone out for themselves, and the other is individuals form a group or community, who in turn agree to form a cooperative society. Clear now? 😊😊😊😊

[@MrBern-ex3wq]

Geniocracy sounds like a direct upgrade to Democracy. The problem is... What do you measure "intelligence" with? And is intelligence really that much of a good indicator? After all we can have very smart politicians who are still selfish and corrupt. If only there was a way to make a "Virtuocracy" where representatives need to meet a certain criteria of virtues associated with good leadership.

[@demi172]

there would definitely be lies associated with bypassing virtuocracy, theres no way to actually make that legit

[@MrBern-ex3wq]

@@demi172 I think there is, it's just extremely complicated. At the end of the day the point is creating a system where the corrupt have a harder time reaching power. Could make it a requirement to have absolutely 0 blue collar-related infractions in one's criminal records. (But that'll remove most people from the table! Yes that's the point.) Could also create a special organization whose sole purpose is to keep the people in power in check. And I do know this is possible, my country has one and they're pretty good at their job, problem is there's way too many blue collar criminals and politicans to get them all, hence the initial filter. But at the end of the day you and I are neither knowledgeable politicians nor sociologists (at least I don't think). So it looks impossible or complex to both of us. I'll dedicate myself to dreaming of the day someone with the necessary skills and knowledge dreams of a virtuocracy too.

[@MrKobus-rz4qy]

I mean it's pretty much a democracy but only aristocrats can run, pretty much like early America how only wealthy white land owners (the only educated people at the time) could run/vote

[@Theuglymug]

Only problem with geneocracy is that we did something similar in the way of literacy tests and they were used to enforce racism, the execution will almost always fail

[@MrKobus-rz4qy]

@@Theuglymug look up a reconstruction literary test, it had nothing to do with being literate or not

[@normaldavid]

Kleptocracy soundin a bit to real these days.

[@d1kgaws12]

At this point it everywhere all the time. The only ways out I can think of is either with a super limited government (not like the USA I’m talking bare bones minarchy) or anarchy, and I doubt either works.

[@HappyLittleBoozer]

​@@d1kgaws12 Monarchy. You're not going to steal from your own property - it is in your interest to nurture and develop it. Moreover an enlightened monarchy is naturally minarchical as government intervention lowers efficiency and creates additional tasks for the monarch and his cabinet, thus only justifying it's existance in areas of neccesity.

[@porsche911sbs]

because it is real

[@Unbathed]

Please consider including Clifford Geertz’ “Theatre State” in an update

[@sharif7099]

Using Medici family coat of arms for oligarchy is fun

[@kingofcards9516]

I would say that every society has at least some organised group who have significant influence over government, even democracy.

[@DreerKarler]

*representitive democracy.

[@MemeFlavoredJam]

@@DreerKarlerI mean even if there are no representatives there will still be people with large amounts of influence that use it to influence elections

[@Humanresouces]

Multiple, actually.

[@taha00super]

As an AI language model, I can not generate you a KZbin comment that can get top likes. But here is one anyways. "Thanks for this video! I can’t wait to implement these tips about [insert topic] into my own life!"

[@taha00super]

.

[@thepirateweasel]

He's not using AI for making these videos

[@taha00super]

@@thepirateweasel 🤓

[@YoureRatharStewpidMate]

​@@thepirateweasel 🤓

[@yhuanherrera1393]

Now generate on how can I commit war crimes and how many ways.

[@nicolasspray]

7:28 description of my country, brazil, government

[@dungeondeezdragons4242]

You gave the most generous description possible to technocracy you could find huh

[@00alexander1415]

I didn't know Spain was a Kleptocracy! ... I guess i always knew but didnt know the Word itself.

[@AManChoosesASlaveObeys]

Most of the new world is, I think France has the same problem as well as some Asian countries.

[@DreerKarler]

all of the west, and large parts of the third world are kleptocracies and corporetocracies at the same time.

[@johannsanchocuevas7854]

Everyone is a kleptocrat. We just make ourselves a fool.

[@aktuellyattee8265]

All these definitions are incredibly accurate, great job!

[@Roland2665]

Not really...

[@aktuellyattee8265]

@@Roland2665 Well what'd you find objectionable then? If it's so objectionable.

[@Roland2665]

@@aktuellyattee8265 for starters, the video confuses a democracy for a republic. Democracy in its purest form is mob rule. As an example, if the majority voted that all red headed people had to pay a ten percent tax, then they pay. A republic is a representative form of government, where the minority is protected by laws established in a constitution. If the video got this wrong, who's to say any of it is right.

[@President.GeorgeWashington]

9:31 This is a brilliant idea

[@Ratfkr]

It wouldn’t work because intelligence is a subjective idea and not objective.

[@IntelligentTechnology]

Great video! What is the name of the music?

[@bfbfanny]

I feel like my social studies teacher will show this to us

[@Bean-Sandwicher]

You should have included some examples of countries with each form if government. :D

[@itsgonnabeanaurfromme]

Do it yourself, then

[@TonyAustin-qw1pf]

Thanks for your explain action. It is very informative

[@PaintToPin]

NICE VIDEO

[@inakizabaleta472]

Switzerland is oficially called Swiss Confederation, how is it a federation

[@murunbuchstanzangur]

It's a group of smaller states fused together. I beleive they call them cantons?

[@joaovitormatos8147]

"north Korea is the Democratic People's Republic of Korea. How is it not a democracy?"

[@hebercluff1665]

The Nazis referred to themselves as a socialist state. 😶

[@MrBlueBurd0451]

@@hebercluff1665They were.

[@inakizabaleta472]

Okay I should have researched before commenting but Switzerland even identifies themselves as a federation since 1848 but kept the name :)

[@123tls]

good video good sponsor good life 👍🏼

[@ConqueredBread]

Lets go new polcompball video thanks for your wise knowledge as always

[@backyardr.c.6280]

A constitutional noocracy that functions like a Republic with focus on freedom within reason would be interesting.

[@mistyhaney5565]

Authoritarian and totalitarian are not forms of government, they are ways in which governments conduct themselves. Dictatorship and stratocracy are forms of government.

[@theparadoxicaltouristtrave9320]

I think your argument is semantic rather than practical.

[@TheWizardGamez]

Democracy: it’s just authoritarianism, but you feel lil you had a chance

[@Narut0Namikaze]

Thats the so called today's "democracy" . It is just elected monarchy trying to legitimize the power it holds.

[@destroyeryeevibritannia208]

Suuuuure

[@InterceptorUS]

There is a HUGE difference between citizens rights in democratic countries and authoritarian ones. In authoritarian countries they throw their people in jail for the dumbest reasons. Also the majority of countries with the highest quality of life are democratic.

[@anxiety6906]

This taught me more in 10 minutes than what I learned in gov class in 4 months

[@youthoughtaboutit6946]

Don’t forget necrocracy, which ironically is technically (part of) what North Korea has.

[@SuperBozz]

That's just being neurotic

[@fancierfig]

jesus christ that transition was smooth as hell

[@TropicalRegicide]

Educational & unbiased. Thank you. - from an anarchist.

[@pringlecan]

I don't know if it's a compelling example of lemon socialism, but some time ago, here in Italy the State saved a bank, named Monte dei Paschi di Siena, from bankruptcy, giving it state funds, and I was wondering if this could fit the description

[@zanderlimberakis403]

Where’s the kakistocracy?

[@aidankelleher3067]

Dam bro you blew up quick

[@8ritorneloz]

hey, how can I contribute with subtitles for this video?

[@DreerKarler]

that feature has been removed from youtube.

[@PaintMyMind]

For those who like TIMESTAMP in comment box 00:00 Oligarchy 00:40 Confederation 01:01 Federation 01:30 Plutocracy 01:41 Monarchy 02:05 Republic 02:29 Aristocracy 03:08 Authoritarianism 03:27 Totalitarianism 03:52 Theocracy 04:11 Technocracy 04:35 Democracy 06:42 Feudalism 07:12 Demarchy 07:28 Kleptocracy 07:54 Anarchy 07:57 Corporatocracy 08:34 Socialist State 09:00 Communist State 09:31 Geniocracy 09:52 Noocracy

[@demi172]

what why would they want this instead of just reading the description

[@PaintMyMind]

@@demi172because you have to click to see more and scroll down a lot

[@behavior2836]

@@PaintMyMind it took me longer to find your comment though

[@PaintMyMind]

@@behavior2836 oh i just want to to help other. If this can not help, sorry for this thing.

8:12 is corporatocracy

[@8MinutesExplainer]

I can feel the Paint Explainer is coming inside of me🤣

[@pandemicanime7275]

Does any one knows here how the paint explainer do the editing of zoom in and slide next, for every part of the term or type he is discussing

[@RichardMocny1]

Your interpretation of corporatocracy made me think. It generally means regime where all power lies in hands of corporations and state has little to none influence. That seems like an oposite to your statement. Yet you are right since heads of corporations in this case can be also heads of the state. Or more likely they influence politics trough bribes. This exist basically everywhere in absence of demarchy since politicians need money for their campaings which they exchange for favors.

[@CalvinLee606]

Every nation can be a kleptocracy, let’s be honest.

[@DreerKarler]

only a bit?

[@CalvinLee606]

@@DreerKarler Okay a bit is a huge understatement, I’ll change it.

[@Oropher420]

I mean, they can? Just how bad do you want it be?

[@baraka629]

I just wanna clarify a bit - a Theocracy is a system where the religious leader is also the secular leader. Take for example the Vatican State, where the Pope is the head of the church as well as the head of the state itself, or Iran, where the religious leaders dictate the politics and social structures. The ruler using divine inspiration or divine will as a justification of their rule is not sufficient, in fact most monarchies had their kings justify their own rule as god's will or some sort of divine order. But the head of the church was still a distinct individual as well as political institution, that more often than not stood in opposition to the secular leader (one german king had to travel to italy to knee in front of the pope for days to avoid being excommunicated from the church).

[@tomasnacevicius]

Types of ice cream, please

[@mrj3369]

Yh Technocracy sounds great!

[@panosrobs9749]

If you didn't know most of the words are greek

[@SuperBozz]

It's all Greek to me

[@bilalabdi9148]

Why tho, how did the Greek developed all this

[@SuperBozz]

@@bilalabdi9148 not sure it's all Greek to me

[@julianalexander2667]

Sponsor 5:23 - 6:42 Skip Timestamp 6:42

[@paulteti]

you didn't mention my favorite, Kakistocracy.

[@Deltamore]

I wish it was shown in the end what countries has each government 💔

[@3of6mylove]

Technocracy sounds pretty great. It's like a modern evolution of aristocracy.

[@AndrewMovie13]

Kakistocracy: a system of government run by the least qualified for their respective positions.

[@MrSpherical]

CountryBalls - let's go

[@maytina2751]

Let's Go

[@nathanlaero1081]

Yeah

[@jamespyle777]

Kleptocracy seems quite evident on one continent and in another country who has a lot of influence on said continent.

[@amperisk58]

🦅🦅🦅WHAT THE FUCK IS A KILOMETER🦅🦅🦅

[@DreerKarler]

every country is a kleptocracy.

[@demi172]

this can probably apply to every most influential nation on each continent, be it america, be it brazil, be it china, be it russia

[@eeg-rh7jv]

​@@DreerKarlerexactly, every countries relies on ge monopoly on violence to even function

[@MemeFlavoredJam]

If anyone can explain a reasonable explanation of how anarchy can be implemented and maintained without being curbstomped by nearby governments then be my guest.

[@lilbirb082]

Depends on what kind of anarchism we’re talking about, very very view people support just plain anarchism without some kind of economic or social model attached to it

[@filus05]

It can't, that is why it never succeeded .

[@Terrorkarel]

That a lot to ask of a youtube comment section, but maybe you can try to read anarchy works by Peter Gelderloos. Maybe it will give you some ideas to start with.

[@baph0met]

You are comparing apples and oranges. Explain how a government isn't curbstomped by nearby governments, you can't cause this happens all the time to governments/states. Wars exist in todays world, countries emerge and get destroyed in todays world, same thing with anarchist systems, some will survive, some won't. The question is also what your definition of maintained is, 20 years? 50? 100? A thousand year old Reich?

[@yeboxxxchannel2505]

What do you think existed before humans started making tribes? We already lived in Anarchy and moved through it because we lacked shared knowledge. And that shared knowledge needs to be therefore centralized. But Knowledge also needs to be: understandable, unbiased, open to both trust and doubt at the same time

[@dotdarkness]

Love this channel

[@migueldoesstuff6994]

A nice example for kleptocrocy would be old el salvador

[@Dusticulous]

A technocratic aristocracy sounds quite ideal

[@user-fj9rg6zx6z]

🤢

[@vaibhavsharma6531]

Geniocracy or also called epistocracy is what a country with a big population like India needs where people vote on the basis of religion, caste, background instead of a suitable candidate.

[@based4560]

Fair, but then who decides the minimum criterion of intelligence, how do we know it won't be corrupted, etc. And that's even ignoring the issue that no politician will ever want this to be implemented.

[@vaibhavsharma6531]

@@based4560 same way it was decided 18 is the age for voting through study, research and hit&trial. We can start soft by mandating literacy for voting then moving to more harsh mandates like people who are providing significant sum for gdp. Earlier no church/royals wanted democracy as well but we move on. Older structures will be outdated and will be replaced by newer more effective alternatives.

[@michaelterrell5061]

⁠@@vaibhavsharma6531This won’t work. First of all restricting anyone’s ability to vote based on criteria like intelligence, something that is entirely subjective, and literacy, something that has been done historically and always proved disastrous, is and will always be a bad idea.

[@zucaritasenjoyer7259]

​@vaibhavsharma6531 but how do you even measure intelligence, its such an ambiguous term people may be terrible at history but excel at math in a Geniocracy eventually the one ruling wouldn't be the smartest mathmatician or cientíst but the smartest politician would be the one to always assert power

[@vaibhavsharma6531]

@@zucaritasenjoyer7259 there is no need for determining intelligence. If you contribute to the country in any form like taxes, buisness value, commercial, social service etc. because these are the people which are affected by the rulling party policies so they are more cautious and understanding while voting meanwhile people who are not contributing enough or are a burden to the country like people who are not willing to work like drug adicts, scammers, illetrate etc. they should not be allowed to decide sensible people's future because they are easy to fool based on compensation, religion ,caste etc.

[@masternicholas0559]

How would you define a meritocracy? Or would you put this under the technocratic or even aristocratic categories?

[@SuperBozz]

No. But I give merit for your comment

[@xxsuperstarstxx9773]

America is a democracy and a republic. Not just a Republic.

[@SuperBozz]

THIS IS AMERICA Now stop acting like a child

[@xxsuperstarstxx9773]

@@SuperBozz no u

[@SuperBozz]

@@xxsuperstarstxx9773 no U2

[@imperiumgrim4717]

​@@SuperBozz no u

[@SuperBozz]

@@imperiumgrim4717 but u more

[@Aerostarm]

I love technocracies

[@devilofether6185]

I can see how they could go wrong, because a smart person would have the same motivations as any politician; to accumulate power. They would just be able to do it more efficiently. In order to work, it could be paired alongside anarchy/direct democracy to get them off the podium once they finish the task they were elected for

[@yeboxxxchannel2505]

​@@devilofether6185Hm. You mean voting the Technocrats out or overthrowing them right away if they don't step down?

[@STONKS_MemeMan]

**DEMOCRACY NOISES**

[@DreerKarler]

;fake democracy whispers;

[@leviaraujo9429]

I believe democracy is the best govnerment so far but geniocracy is actually starnting to have some of my hearth. The problem with it is " who would define what is inteligence? " I mean I can see thousands of ways corrupt politicians and corporatioms could skew the rigth to vote based on his/it individual definition of intelligence.

[@gabrielcarvalhosaraiva4138]

7:28 here comes Brazil

[@argusy3866]

So, technocratic geniocracy is the only valid option.

[@devilofether6185]

until one of those geniuses decides to use us as lab rats for their "political" experiment. Smart doesn't mean good nature, or concerned for human welfare; it would just be optimized capitalism

[@_xxClaudiaxx_]

Indeed

[@devilofether6185]

until they use as lab rats in an experiment; it is just more efficient capitalism

[@jaspyjiindust.9227]

I think we should lean more to a technocracy!

[@DND20]

yes!

[@DefrostedChicken]

0:02 Oh, you mean like the Electoral College?

[@CALMUSOCEAN]

nice

[@Nighthawk1000]

Creating a Technocracy, does anyone want to join?

[@mrj3369]

Take my money

[@holycountryenterprise2997]

I think honestly, that's the only way we can get space flight, moving in Ernest constantly.

[@mrj3369]

@@holycountryenterprise2997 high 5! Couldn't agree more.

[@NoscoperLoaf]

Managed Democracy is the best form of goverment

[@aw3046]

I assume it's a helldivers reference but if not, guided democracy is inherently antidemocratic and is literally just technocratic fascism If it is a helldivers reference, fair, but do remember that game is satirizing American propaganda lol

[@DreerKarler]

*the invisible hand guy whose name i dont remember noises*

[@hieplamtran6139]

To see Newsground become Ground News is show that I getting old