Everyone is right about Trey Lance.

Use code FILMROOM14 for up to 14 FREE MEALS across your first 5 HelloFresh boxes plus free shipping at bit.ly/3wMyvgQ
Also, all my fantasy rankings can be found on my Patreon. The position rankings and overall combined PPR and standard rankings are now up to version 3.0, with version 4.0 still to come! You can find those Patron-only rankings here: www.patreon.com/user?u=3409713
All Film Room merch is available at www.brettkollmann.com/filmroo.... Check them out, and let me know which plays or designs you want featured on merch for your own teams in the future!
Instagram: @brett_kollmann
Twitter: @BrettKollmann
TikTok: @brettkollmann
One last thing, check out my podcast - The Bootleg Football Podcast! We are more than 60 episodes deep so far, and it can be found anywhere podcasts are distributed (Apple, Google, Spotify, Stitcher, KZbin, etc).
BFP on Apple: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
BFP on Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/6w5Geni...
BFP on Stitcher: www.stitcher.com/podcast/boot...
BFP KZbin page: / @bootlegfootball

[@BrettKollmann]

"The Californio" - a recipe of my own that's kind of a riff off a Gold Rush that I've been developing just for this episode! -1oz Mezcal, preferably a smokier one -1oz Reposado Tequila -3/4oz Lemon Juice -1/2oz home made Jalapeño Honey Syrup (recipe for that below) - Shake over ice and strain into a chilled coupe glass, or even into a rocks glass with a large rock (however you prefer it if you want more dilution) Jalapeño Honey Syrup: kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaGXeqJne6qXhaM - Slice two jalapeños - Combine 5oz water and 3/4 cup honey in a pot and heat it up while mixing - Add in the jalapeños and bring to a boil while occasionally stirring - Once at a boil, bring down to a simmer for five minutes, then take off the heat to let cool - Put that in a blender, add an ounce of white rum, and then blend well - Fine strain out the remains of the jalapeños and you are just left with the spicy honey syrup! - Bottle the syrup for use later

[@cedricmitcgell6240]

Mac Jones preseason review when?

[@SuperStarTidus18]

Hey Brett! I think the 49ers will probably make an assessment mid season to evaluate: 1) What are our playoff chances looking? 2) How far along ins Trey Lance in terms of learning the offense? If their playoffs hopes are gone, Trey will start from that point forward. Otherwise, I think he sits the whole season except for the last week when they rest the starters. I believe this is probably the best way to handle the situation. Week 1 in Las Vegas. I will not be attending the game because I dont think I can afford it. However, if you decide to meet some of your fans postgame let me know and I will definitely be there man!

[@fcpchop88]

Hey Brett, I posted a question on your last Patreon rankings post but didn't get an answer, would be awesome if you help a brother out before his draft hah

[@silentrift63]

Which smoky mezcal do you recommend?

[@anthonymendez1997]

Trevor Lawrence film???

[@griffenharbolt5629]

As a Houston Texan historian, Kyle Shanahan was the OC for the Texans in 2009, and he managed to turn Matt Schaub into a Pro Bowler 💀. I'm sure Trey Lance is in good hands

[@jessepusatero5511]

I remember that lmao

[@adamrielh]

As a colts fan, I remember that. He had that nasty connection with Andre Johnson, then he got an upgraded version of that with Matt Ryan and Julio Jones lol but man, when they had Arian foster, they were fun to watch.

[@Nikillem]

Coach worshipping put in overdrive

[@jeremiahbell6461]

“In good hands” nah fam he’s in GREAT hands

[@ryanbeer2374]

I was at that pro bowl😂😂

[@maxmersmann-jones1222]

Nothing to comment, just commenting to increase your engagement numbers so that the analytics encourage more 49ers videos.

[@BrettKollmann]

They just might 👀

[@thebeasters]

Nniinnaazz

[@alexjohnson-fry3778]

damn should i dislike every video that isnt about the vikes?

[@arthurmorgan1126]

Fact

[@tommunist10]

That’s not…. actually you know what? Never mind. You do you, champ.

[@hansoskar1911]

People need to chill about rookie QBs. Even Peyton Manning had more Ints than TDs his rookie year.

[@eldiannat7374]

Imagine the Twitter takes about Peyton if Twitter was around back then

[@ronaldomendoza7578]

@@eldiannat7374 Theres a gimmick account that goes with that premise but with the NBA and its pretty funny at times

[@Terror832]

Terry Bradshaw rookie season (1970) 83/218 (38.1%), 1410 yards, 6 TDs, 24 INTs, 30.4 rating These are not typos. Even Ryan Leaf had a better rookie season.

[@Terror832]

@@ronaldomendoza7578 @oldnbatweetz Love that account

[@jasonhalland5357]

@@Terror832 I don't think Terry bradshaws a good qb to bring up yes he won superbowls but his stats are crap and would have been benched now days he finished his career with 212 tds to 210 ints

[@CrewsTheWildDawg]

With Jimmy G on the roster, there’s no rush to start Lance. Is Lance more talented? Absolutely. But Jimmy G is way more experienced. Lance has a lot to learn, so why put him in when he’s not ready?

[@joshuacrockett4172]

He may be ready only the coach knows his understanding of the offense

[@paulc7400]

@@joshuacrockett4172 Patrick Mahomes sat for a little while behind Smith and he turned out alright. So did Rodgers behind Farve.

[@GorchaxGaming]

Trial by fire.. People learn better from making mistakes than from imagining them. Best way to learn and adapt is to experience it, thats why he should start as soon as possible, and no one can tell me that Mahomes would not have been good to go year one, no one goes from raw-cannot-start to 50TD MVP by sitting behind Alex Smith for 16 games. Mahomes would have been good year one, no doubt about it.

[@BarriosDerek]

@@paulc7400 Peyton Manning played his first year and was terrible yet he tyrned out alright as well. The decision isnt the same for all players its a decision the coach has to make for each player

[@CrewsTheWildDawg]

@@GorchaxGaming You don’t know that about Mahomes.

[@TexasDragon]

Brett…I swear to Christ if ANYTHING bad happens to this kid, I know who I’m pointing the fingers at.

[@BrettKollmann]

😂😂😂

[@TheSoundwave92]

Don't worry I think Brett is fully aware of what power the curse can do lol. Let's just wait and see but I love Trey working with Kyle Shanahan. He can absolutely maximum his strengths but his weaknesses are plentiful.

[@Eric-jz1cv]

@@TheSoundwave92 didnt he curse Tevin Jenkins 😂 As a panthers fan im convinced Jaycee Horn is on a ticking time bomb

[@TheSoundwave92]

@@Eric-jz1cv bro don't remind me man. After seeing that video I thought tevin was going to be awesome this year but alias, the curse is too strong. If Jaycee horn gets taken out I think Brett needs to build a fucking bonker to hide himself. 😂

[@FOT2010]

Yourself 🤨

[@terry7907]

He will start soon enough-Garappolo will not stay healthy. But while he does, I would be starting him. He has spent years seeing NFL disguised coverages, and Lance still has a lot to learn. Also, if I am Shanahan, my calculus is simple: if JG starts and does well, it is good for the team and good for his trade value; if he starts and does poorly, it can eliminate second guessing on making Lance the Starter. So JG starting is a win-win.

[@BarriosDerek]

I see what you mean personally i think having Lance out there opens up shanahan’s playbook. lance’s ability to run and his ability to throw down the field will lead to more games won in my opinion. People also act as if jimmy is not super inconsistent and inaccurate. He throws a lot of interceptions and it does not seem like he is getting any better. The defense should win games in both situation

[@sammythemortgageguy928]

we’ve seem what JG can do in this offense, his value is capped as there is enough film on him, if JG gets benched due to bad play they lose trade value on him, it’s about winning and which qb gives them the best chance of winning, throw lance out there from the start so he gets to warm up with detroit and philly then he’ll be more ready to go against green bay in game 3, lance looks like the type of qb that benefits more than being out there and get the pt then sitting back with the clipboard, maybe the chiefs could’ve won the super bowl a yr earlier if reid started mahommes in his rookie yr over alex smith

[@williamlarese3010]

@@sammythemortgageguy928 Jimmy gives them the best chance to win. He took them to a Superbowl in his FIRST SEASON AS A STARTER. Is Trey going to do that? Probably not! How many good QB's in the past have had a good defense and running game but couldn't get to the Superbowl cuz when it was time for them to make a play on 3rd down or at the end of the game THEY COULDN'T DO IT? Jimmy has ice in his veins and was the BEST IN THE NFL on 3rd down in 2019. It's called being a WINNER and that's what Jimmy G is! Trey isn't there yet so anyone saying Jimmy shouldn't start just wants to see the 49ers lose imo. The only reason they drafted Lance is because of Jimmys injuries. Jimmy will play well this season, take us far, and get traded for a 1st round pick next off-season and then Lance will take us from there.

[@bouji_]

Minshew just got moved for a 6th round pick, so it's safe to say Jimmy doesn't have any trade value. I keep hearing about Jimmy's statistical efficiency, but Minshew has been better than Jimmy over his career so far, and he is way cheaper.

[@thetruealex7478]

@@bouji_ that's a stretch. Jimmy has a way better arm, and Minshew is coming off of a terrible year. Jimmy took them to a super bowl. I think a first rounder is rich for him, but he's definitely worth a 2 or 3

[@richboss_]

I remember being so hyped about Trey coming to SF back in 21. Seeing how it all ended up playing out two years later just makes me… sad.

[@Teddypain20]

I honestly thing that all the rookie QBs went to the right place. Lance in particular went to a great situation. It’s just a question about how the QBs are developed by the organizations that drafted them. We shall see

[@samrosendahl392]

Trevor didn’t go to the right place. Man oh man Urban is horrible.

[@BanterMan101]

Fields didn’t either, it may be a great scheme, but he’s getting lit up by the line.

[@imhotepnixon]

@@BanterMan101 he’s just adjusting to the speed of the game once he starts getting the ball out quicker it won’t be a problem

[@jordanp4134]

@@BanterMan101 he’s only taken one bad hit that was mostly his own fault. Once he gets to play with the starters and gets the ball out quicker, he will be fine

[@aaronTGP_3756]

Everyone but Trevor will be fine. You could argue that the Jags trade down a few picks and keep Minshew and draft Sewell.

[@connorladds9130]

everyone is right about brett kollmann, he's elite and accurate

[@jberczi6]

Pretty trunky with a real Midwest ethos

[@NoobMaster-or5ub]

@@jberczi6 bro…

[@plartoota4584]

@@jberczi6 thicc trunky and coastal

[@Fier07112]

Yup! My favorite guy if I’m looking nuanced breakdowns!

[@jrworthy]

Two words: Justin Herbert

[@pmizz7959]

I’d vote for splitting the difference. With a roster that intends to win now and a locker room which supports Jimmy….If Trey comes out and inevitably makes his mistakes the team is going to get frustrated that they may be losing a super bowl season to a rookies growing pains. If you start Jimmy and he plays great then awesome. If he falters or gets hurt then at least the team can point to Trey as someone who can potentially save that season.

[@bouji_]

This is why keeping Jimmy around has been a mistake so far, at least imo. He took all of the first team reps over training camp, so they have to start him now.

[@pmizz7959]

@@bouji_ after essentially losing 2 of the last 3 seasons due to injuries the risk of wasting a super bowl roster on a rookies growing pains was too great. At the end of the day the goal is winning games, not just the development on 1 player. If the Niners were to Jags or Jets and you have no super bowl chance then sure. Start the rookie. It is just a rare situation where a super bowl caliber roster is drafting a QB in the top 3

[@bouji_]

@@pmizz7959 If the 49ers truly believed they could win the Super Bowl this year, then moving a huge portion of their chips into the center of the table for a QB was a mistake. What happens if they do win the Super Bowl with Jimmy? They have to keep him around at that point, do they not? I suppose that's a dumb question because it isn't happening.

[@pmizz7959]

@@bouji_ I guess I disagree with your pretense. If they win a super bowl then nothing was a mistake. They won the super bowl. If they won the last one then people still would have said that the team won that Super Bowl and it wasn’t because of Jimmy. And Jimmy is a flawed QB but one you can win with when healthy. He just hasn’t been healthy. The 49ers lost 2 seasons to his injuries so putting chips in to ensure you have a viable healthy QB going forward doesn’t seem all that crazy to me.

[@bouji_]

@@pmizz7959 Sure, it makes perfect sense if they drafted a new starting QB. Trading that much for a back up is bad process. Of course, tbf, I don't think the 49ers actually planned on having Jimmy for this long. The problem is that the cap took a hit this year, and Jimmy's contract is still in asset in case someone gets desperate.

[@goode.110]

Andy Reid went full villain and tried to spook Trey into staying on the bench…the man is truly 8 steps ahead

[@bullscott12]

No kidding eh? “This will set him back at least a couple weeks” lol I kinda love it

[@mittromney8750]

love mental games by players/coaches

[@kx4998]

I guess that is kind of his "Welcome to the NFL" moment.

[@adembroski]

I wouldn't be surprised if Kyle asked Reid to bring it.

[@Kai_soze]

“Welcome to the NFL rook” was the play

[@mamilx6607]

49ers have a brutal slate of schedule ending early November, against 5 playoff teams from last year and Cards on the road. Jimmy G will start the year, with Lance coming in on certain packages but my guess is Lance will become the full time starter sometime during or after that 6-game stretch.

[@cows543]

I’m always a fan of teams having their rookie quarterbacks sit the whole season or at least most of it

[@o.t.t5172]

Why 💀

[@cows543]

@@o.t.t5172 because Patrick Mahomes, Tom Brady, and Aaron Rodgers are all incredible and all of them rode the bench for at least a year before playing. Plus many quarterbacks who are thrust into the game immediately end up getting hurt or just suck because they’re not ready yet, Joe Burrow is the most recent example of getting injured

[@BarriosDerek]

Theres also examples like peyton manning who got thrown into the fure had a terrible year and improves drastically afterwards. I dont think this is a decision you make based off of what other situations were like. I think its a decision each coach has tk make for each player

[@yeahr1ghty]

@@cows543 counterpoint: Aikman, Manning, Watson, Baker, Herbert There's no doubt Mahomes would've been awesome as a rookie, only know-nothings assume sitting made him better. Rodgers sat multiple seasons, yet still played like a rookie his first season. There's no correlation between sitting and success, people just cherry pick.

[@Tubalcain422]

@@cows543 so you are saying that Mahomes would not have been as good a QB if they started him most of his rookie season? Interesting. And Rodgers and Brady had star QBs ahead of them.

[@Joel-bb6og]

lotta QB talent in this draft class. excited to see who will end up the best

[@user-ed7gg9eq8o]

Mac 👀

[@dgun13]

Fields

[@Aaron-wq3jz]

Joe

[@thedarkknight9153]

Fields

[@OscarUnrated]

I think Wilson will be most talented, Fields will do best and Lawrence will be great but struggle with the Bengals

[@nelsonw2096]

I think that we follow what Shanahan hinted at from the beginning. Jimmy starts. Jimmy stays the starter unless/until he screws up a lot or gets hurt. Then Trey starts. Evaluation is week by week after that and situational.

[@pricesamford]

Peyton Manning said spirals are overrated, I’ll take Manning’s word over Simms

[@kamareaton]

Let Jimmy start cuz if history is a show for anything that he might not play the whole season

[@williamlarese3010]

And if he does, he takes us to a superbowl

[@JJ-zr6fu]

@@williamlarese3010 It's really weird how fast the 49er fans have turned on Jimmy.

[@salamander337]

If history taught you anything, Jimmy takes us to a SB if he's healthy.

[@artigarcia9257]

@@salamander337 he hands the ball of to the superbowl

[@salamander337]

@@artigarcia9257 Exactly. The point is if he's starting we win. A lot. 😂

[@tvtda1]

i love that you went into this discussion for your video, and honestly actually totally agree with you, i'm on the side of theres no need to rush this, but theres no denying this team is currently built to basically raise a young QB. they have the defense (they need to get healthy) They have the running game (Trey will make that better) and they have a top 10 offensive line in the nfl. (at the very least a top 5 offensive tackle blocking for him.) on the other hand i think its just better if he flat out conquers jimmy, like he not only is simply more talented than him, but when he just starts out skilling him, and for that to happen he needs more work on his motion and his release, and it wouldn't hurt taking a year to clean that up necessarily if thats what it takes, and it only takes about a year to fix that one aspect. the wait is worth it with this talent.

[@deedsonseeds5517]

Damn it brett its 1 am you just had to keep me up love australia time zones

[@darthmanfred7292]

If his issue is just being able to establish confidence, start him right now. Kittle, Aiyuk, and Deebo are amazing players for a young QB to lean on and make plays for him at first while he's still learning to play in the NFL

[@thedarkknight9153]

Kittle = elite Aiyuk = quite good Deebo = injury prone and not that great anyway

[@yeahr1ghty]

@@thedarkknight9153 Deebo is without a doubt the best YAC player the past 2 years, his efficiency as well as yards created is absolutely insane and no one is even close to him. He's injury prone af but if anything Deebo is kind of underrated, he's a decent route runner and catcher but pair that with his elite YAC and he'd be great if he were healthy consistently. Regardless, he's a great 2nd/3rd option to have for a young QB. Btw I'm not a Niners fan, I'm low on Lance relative to most people but he should be fine to start over Jimmy.

[@MalakianM2S]

I agree but I wouldn't full on start him right away, I'll give him time in games from week one and see what happens. Putting all the weight on his shoulders from the get go may be too much for him, but you need him ready though because Garappolo is going to break sooner or later sadly.

[@kx4998]

From what this video shows, he has not adjusted his eyes to NFL defenses yet. So maybe start him after Jimmy Garappolo is injured again might be the best choice.

[@HH-le1vi]

He's way too raw to start right now. I'd strongly prefer to have him split reps with the 1st team than just throw him to the wolves.

[@jasonsoemantri9299]

Woahhhh I’m a hawks fan in Seattle, didn’t expect you to be coming up here Brett, would be great to meet up with you and a bunch of other hawks fans

[@austinbrunette8773]

This video was uploaded when I was asleep, as I expect from a Kollmann bomb. I always chuckle when I used to hear about this draft analyst wizard named Brett Kollmann from football channels and website articles. Every video confirms my belief that Brett is the best player analyst the NFL has ever seen!

[@andrewwolfert922]

I love Lance, and was calling for the 49ers to take him as soon as they traded the farm for the number 3 over all pick. Explosive wild card with the greatest young coach in football? Sign me up. But, I do think he could benefit for sitting behind Jimmy for this year, and really learn and adapt to the speed of the nfl, and that’s everything from game speed, to pre-snap, to inside the huddle, to the work load and speed of film study and new game plans week to week. He hasn’t had to be in a full season in 2 years, and especially in the nfl, regular season speed and offseason (including preseason) speed are so far apart it feels like a different game entirely. Let him grow, study, and build chemistry with his team for a year, and then let him lose on a world who at that point would only have 3 preseason games on him over the past 3 years. If San Francisco plays their cards right, they might just have a royal flush on their hands.

[@robysuryatama6662]

I'm always finished your vid for the beautiful cocktail recipes

[@haydens7764]

I was pretty mad with how often Spagnuolo was dialing up blitzes against Trey in his first game. On top of that, the niners had no starting O-line and the Chiefs had Jones and others in - probably the niners fault in this instance. But I think it was great thing for Trey to see all of those exotic blitzes before the regular season and it will only help prepare him for the long-run.

[@davidjohnson7373]

YESSSIIIRRR. Haven’t even watched the vid yet but I love your content 💪🏽

[@NoSystemGaming]

I just turn on, let the video run for like 4 secs, paused, let all the impressions sink in for a few moments and thought: "God damn, I love you Brett." The ambience, the drinks, the topics, your presentation. Thanks, Brett and warm regards from the arising Football-Nation of Germany!

[@iurhviusdfavhi]

Can't believe you JUST got an editor, you are gonna blow up this season dude, grind hard. Let the editor handle all that so you can just focus on watching tape and writing. I need to see NFL players react to your video's on them, seeing Lance watch this would be amazing.

[@patrickrichardson4765]

Mezcal fan here. Gotta try the "Ilegal." However, wondering why mix the Tequila and Mezcal when they have different characters/flavors etc. Seems what each would bring to the cocktail would get lost. Well, I've got to give it a try anyway. Great video. Give me hope for Lance. He needs to develop his "off-speed pitches" and touch, although that sideline pass to Surfield was terrific.

[@pillowspam]

Fully understand being torn. i think i flip flopped my choice 3 times just starting this post. I think the best way to delve into it is perspective based. However (despite my waffling) both perspectives landed in the same direction. 1. What's best for the Niners? Given that this is a team built to win right now. i'd say that slowly integrating Trey into the offense (semi similar Lamar his rookie season) & then "IF" there is full confidence that Trey has ironed out some of the confidence issues highlighted w/in this video, they can pull the trigger on giving Trey the reigns late season. This way if Jimmy G is playing well, The organization should accumulate wins, & it drives up his trade value. While at the same time showing Trey they have confidence he can be "THE GUY" for a winning team. This gives the team optionality to feel Trey's progress out as time goes on w/o compromising their win now mentality. 2. What's best for Trey? As a very physically talented QB, with limited starting experience against substantially lesser competition. I do think that developmentally, taking away the pressure to produce right away would serve Trey better than throwing him into the fire & allowing him to play through his mistakes. While learning a job by doing it, usually is the best way to get good faster. it can also cause more harm than good (i'd point to a QB the Niners cut recently as a solid example.... Josh Rosen.) Josh was tossed out there on a team w/ a sucky OL, w/ minimal / no Coaching stability & it wrecked his confidence. While the niners are a more stable franchise than the Cardinals were at that time. we've already seen some examples where mistakes caused a drastic shift in how Trey approached playing the game. These are tendencies that can be driven out of him as time goes on. So while i think that Trey will be a good QB. & it's counter to today's NFL to hang tight on a QB prospect for long (b/c of the Age old adage of "Capitalize when you have a cost effective option at QB" still exists. i do feel that for Treys development. Giving him time to learn, process, & grow before getting meaningful game action is the best approach.

[@gavinpostich591]

Most unique football channel on KZbin, keep it up 👍🏻

[@diducthesizeoftahtchicken]

AMAZING film review!! New subscriber after this one.

[@keenanmccracken6758]

Just moved to Seattle. Not a Seahawks or titans fan but still look to see you there!

[@leelarkinreti]

It all comes down to how well Jimmy's playing and how fast Trey's developing if Jimmy has us winning like he did 2019 and rolling to the playoffs you let the rookie sit and gets reps late in games and when games are in the bag could play him in certain situations to utilize his skillset and strengths like near the redzone to confuse the defense like the Saints did but not all the time like we seen in the preseason.If Jimmy's struggling then he may get a shot midway threw the season but the goal with this squad should be to win and start the qb that gives you best chance.

[@GRodPericles]

The drink making outro is 🔥

[@slipknottin]

Always love watching Spags defenses.

[@phillyscorpio3804]

I like Lance... as a Bills fan... I see alot of Josh & Mahomes in this kid. Just give it time... he has a smart coach & good OC. The Lance pick was a hand pick by Kyle Shanahan himself...he's never had his own QB to work with... it was always a QB that was handed to him that he had to work with. Smart OC's with high talented athletes = success. Gone are the old school coaches like Rex Ryan...that don't know what to do with athletic talent QB's.

[@currensea9094]

AYE! Seahawks fan here in Seattle, would be so sick to meet you man!

[@yashpatel1115]

Love the vids, as an eagles fan AlexRollins video on hurts kept me up at night. I was wondering if u could make a vid on hurts too. Thanks.

[@Rainioss]

I’ll be in Seattle week 2! (Titans fan) hope I can see you there

[@liamkelly4684]

Brett. You’re telling me to make a drink at 8 am. Imma go with a bagel instead.

[@BrettKollmann]

😂😂😂 Irish coffee baby

[@natewoods4566]

I'm not going to the Seattle game but I live 3 blocks from the stadium and can set you up with some kickass Chinatown restaurant recommendations

[@goclbert]

To me, it seems pretty clear that if the 49ers want to win more games this year, they stick with Jimmy. If they don't care about winning this year then it's fine to start Lance. I feel like if you're paying Jimmy all this money, you might as well use him when he's your best option.

[@kima3555]

Facts but I feel like they’re gonna do what the dolphins did & put Lance in towards the 2nd half of the season just to see if he’s worth the investment, finally cut jimmy and move on with the newly versatile offense

[@thebeasters]

Multiple decade Niner fan here. I think Trey should probably sit for just a couple games, get over the clutching, the mistakes all that. We have a pretty easy schedule so letting Jimmy Coast for a bit is fine

[@fluffEfoxProductions]

Awesome vid Brett and I love the bootleg football podcast too bro

[@BrettKollmann]

Thank you! I'm glad you like it!

[@brettco20]

Well... I already drafted trey lance in a dynasty superflex so.... I'm in it

[@michaelhanabusa6558]

Love your analysis bro! Did you play in college or ever work for NFL team? Where did you get all develop your analysis skills?

[@kevindunn6019]

Amazing.....great break down..thank you

[@zanderb3340]

Hey Brett I was wondering if there was a Mac Jones video in the future and who should be the pats starter week 1, love your videos!

[@federicofilmroom]

I like the edition of this video, and the Trey Lance analysis even more, good stuff!

[@49erMinded]

Thank you for the film breakdowns. I learned a lot by watching.

[@01mattdavenport]

Love your stuff Brett

[@ryanhenshall3158]

Video on why cam went from MVP to now people calling for him to be a back up for the rest of his career plz

[@BabyHippoSwag]

he fell to me in the 5.10 pick in my dynasty superflex startup draft last night, hoping he ends up being awesome!

[@jasonwarren516]

Hey Brett! I'll be at the Seahawks vs Titans game. I won't be able to grab drinks (Since I'm only 18) but I'd still love to meet up and talk football with you at the game. Go hawks!

[@danielcarmichael7002]

I'm in the sit Trey Lance camp. If you wanted him to get pt, I would have him study a specific part of the playbook ( like just the 2 min drill or just play action plays or shotgun) and just play in those situations. Like what the saints did with Taysom while they had drew healthy... Taysom would only come in for particular looks.

[@bpdub21]

As a big Zach Wilson fan it always bugged me that level of competition was CONSTANTLY brought up for Zach and yet I feel like I didn't hear it all that much for Lance. Even with Zach playing a G5 schedule in his junior year that G5 schedule is still a much higher level of competition than Lance ever had playing in a lower division. People also acted like Zach only had one season of playing time, which is legitimately what Lance had in college, Zach played for much of his freshman year after he stole the starting job from an experienced senior, and his sophomore year other than missing some games for injury.

[@rochboucher6528]

I think the most realistic option is with him in gradually with some Trey specific packages and when Kyle sees he’s ready, he’ll be in after the bye some time.

[@craigc6933]

Won’t be at that Hawks game but would be down to come drink beer and talk football!

[@ikey1119]

I wish these comments could break through to Niners fans, the majority of the faithful want Lance to start immediately because of media propaganda. It’s crazy. You could ruin the kid by throwing him out there right away. And it’s true The Chiefs weren’t vanilla AT ALL on defense. And the entire fan base snapped on our young OLine and in turn blamed Kyle for trying to sabotage Trey. It’s unreal how gullible and sensationalized we are as fans. I’m glad someone with an actual command of scheme and recognition can explain what’s going on through chalk talk.

[@nichwe]

Are you gonna hit all the rookie QBs? I would love to see a Zach Wilson vid

[@jcorc14]

dude, incredible stuff as always

[@gatorboy21king]

Another great video 🔥

[@jedroberts10]

I don’t know if I can make it up to Seattle or even Vegas, but if you’re going to any Cardinals home games I’ll be there

[@BrettKollmann]

Perhaps week 18!

[@cloutgod2888]

Man it’s crazy to be in college being a top player in a low division just another college player that watched your videos now i’m getting them made on me

[@anthonycaruso6065]

The way they went between the 2 qbs was really interesting to watch

[@sacstatesfinest]

Can you do an updated analysis on Trey’s game against the Cardinals? Thanks!

[@3pointstance484]

Was about to do some sunday homework, but this video was posted so..

[@lukeyates7425]

god damn what a thumbnail. trey area = bay area for the niners and gray area for the conflicted debate convo. masterclass

[@abdulrehmanmubarik3856]

Bruh you literally have the best analysis videos on youtube. so underrated need millions of followers

[@diegomagellan]

I love these shows such as yours. It’s the anti ESPN stuff and it’s awesome. Keep up the good work

[@glennlassiter3600]

He needs to seat the year out period. We DO NOT want to stunt his growth. Let him learn organically

[@thebeasters]

I don't know about a year, but certainly probably not till the bye week. He's still way shaky and we have a Super bowl caliber roster

[@nicolaszito4506]

Hey Brett! Any recommendations for websites, resources for watching film? Basically how/where do you watch film?

[@petromavro9154]

Given that Shanahan has confirmed to the media that Trey will play this year a plan that seems logical to me is that Lance will have specific small packages tailored for him in the first couple of weeks, and dependent on how he handles those reps Shanahan will know if he's ready to become the full-time starter (in essence it seems like the Garoppolo-Lance QB competition will remain competitive well past next week when the rosters are "official", and Jimmy is on a TIGHT leash).

[@gatorhighlights4]

My reservations about Lance was 318 throws to his name and not having played recently and I think the preseason games highlighted both of those. Passes are coming out wobbly or too strong or a combination of the two. A few were behind guys. People are mentioning the drops by receivers but most of those were precisely because they weren't great throws. Jimmy meanwhile has looked fairly comfortable. There is no universe where Lance should get the start week 1 but I wouldn't mind throwing him in for some specific packages like that fake handoff where he ran for a TD in the red zone. Those plays are going to be hard as hell to defend so I say make it a regular part of the offense. That way Lance still gets some experience.

[@seeno1]

9 drops total. 1 of them I can credit was on lance. The rest were blatantly on the receiver.

[@droach5241]

Jimmy G gives the 49ers the best chance at a Super Bowl. Jimmy G can perform well and the Giants, Eagles, Washington, and Texans may want to trade for him. The 49ers are a true Super Bowl contender. No rookie has ever reached a Super Bowl and Lance is not better than the ones that came close

[@danielrutstein2316]

Once you start Lance it’s hard to go back so I’d keep jimmy until the niners are sure Lance is ready and has adjusted to the weekly preparation routine

[@samuellolango9720]

jimmy might want to leave if he realizes that the starting job is not his anymore.

[@DarthTrethon]

I don't know that I can say "he's ready" but even if he is ready I can absolutely say he should not start now...ideally in a perfect world he can sit on the bench and learn from Jimmy G. and to learn more about NFL defenses for a year before he's thrown out there. The big questions are whether Jimmy G can both stay healthy and play well enough to not force Shanahan's hand to start Lance.

[@mrmojorisin241]

Not drinking a drink named after California while I live in Virginia/North Carolina. But I still wanna try it so...

[@DJTWIST25]

I would start him. There’s a long list of HOF QB’s that had an up and down rookie season. Except, no…for 1 reason. The division he plays in, has 3 teams with really really good defenses, and top shelf QB’s. If he didn’t have to face Arizona’s D & Kyler Murray, Seattle’s much improved D & Russell Wilson and that Rams D (he’ll certainly get acquainted with Mr. Donald) & the gun slinger that is Matthew Stafford, I’d say starting him would be the move. Literally any other division. Just not the NFC West.

[@andrewbrasuell8589]

happy to hear you were able to hire someone. you created a job :)

[@TheTEN24]

Don’t know which is better, I’d say halfway through the year seems like a good middle ground

[@lordpigg4069]

Seattle here!! I think Trey is like Kap 2.0 lol but with a better arm. He will be good 👍but would probably benefit from sitting like Pat did.

[@jscott300]

The Niners need to start Trey. They have been working on a Ravens style rushing offense featuring Trey and it will probably be nearly unstoppable in its first year. Jimmy G, on the other hand, is still unable to pass downfield and is prone to a few unspeakably bad throws per game. He has the experience, but doesn't have the mental processing speed to use it effectively. They need to start Trey to help him gain the experience he still needs to become an effective NFL passer. Sitting him won't help much with that process.

[@d.j._holman]

Have you considered breaking down other QBs rookie preseason tape (if you can) and use it as a barometer on how current rookie QBs are developing/managed? I remember distinctly Cam Newton did not show much in his preseason and then threw for like 450 yards his first game. Be interesting to see if some of the criticisms of Lance, Fields, or others ends up being unwarranted once they start their first games...

[@JJ-zr6fu]

Cam played and won against NFL talent this guy played and won against benchwarmers two years ago. And Cam was an athletic freak.

[@blackops2875]

I’m planning on going to the Titan’s game!

[@TylerMcVeigh1]

If the 49ers intend to play him this season, let him come in midway only if they need a spark on offense. Otherwise, let him sit the year. My take away from the video and what little I've seen of him is he struggles with how quick defense shift and it causes him to either lose sight of defenders or doubt his reads and causes him to be off target. Putting him in too early could really shake his confidence moving forward as it seems to compound over time. Give him some time to learn from Jimmy G and Shanahan and lets see where it goes.

[@fineapple_esq]

Put em out there!

[@jdw5706]

Dude your breakdowns are elite

[@masonsalio4442]

I think I’ll be in Seattle for the Titans game!

[@gggamer7460]

This may be a dumb question, but where do y'all get your all 22 from? Used to use game pass for it, but I can't seem to find it anymore.

[@evilh0mer23]

hopefully you can make a quick video following Lance's first start this Sunday.

[@oliverhann6815]

Amazing commentating for more niner breakdowns

[@matome3050]

I personally am a big fan of letting rookie QBs learn for one season to get used to the speed. This reduces the public pressure to perform but gives the opportunity to learn and improve.

[@spencer_1727]

I would like to see Trey Lance study film and learn from Jimmy G this year. He has the arm talent, the explosiveness and the swagger Kyle was looking for. They just have to make him more comfortable reading defenses and being prepared for fast, sneaky defensive calls. Nothing shakes a rookies confidence more than starting and feeling like they are not ready. I think Lance should be put in the same situation Mahomes was. Spectate a year, learn, understand what Shanahan is looking for and wants then come out.

[@itzanopinion]

The real question to ask is.. "For as much as SF gave up to even GET the 3rd overall pick, how long would you expect any other team, in that same situation, to 'sit' their #1 pick, especially when that #1 pick is a QB and your current QB (JimmyG) has had health issues and even when healthy, he's not scaring defenses with his arm?" answer that and you'll have the answer to "how soon should Trey Lance start?"

[@mantalksball]

GOOD JOB EDITOR hoping you see this you did a good job with this video

[@mrfrenchfry20]

I think to me it was evident that lance is the least pro ready out of the bunch. Wilson and Mac have been decisive and seem very calm and understand what they’re looking at. Trevor in his most recent outing also looked as if he corrected some things and while the offense may struggle he should be out there. Fields has been a little heavy on his legs early and throwing him out there when it’s not needed could lead him into some bad habits with escaping and looking to run before passing. Lance has looked RAW to say the least. Very little touch on his balls(probably due to indecisiveness in his reads and trying to force things). I’d say Jimmy should start if he’s healthy and have a high quality backup in lance for a year.

[@emilianogaeloj]

Can you do a Jordan Love one??

[@jojosmith1097]

I'll stick with an Old Fashio/Bourbon n or a Sazerac/Rye

[@garco1527]

I only see Trey Lance seeing the field more often than not in RedZone packages. How you gonna start a 21 year old in the NFL who hadnt played in 2 years facing NFL defenses. Playing QB is single hardest position in all of sports.