Everything Wrong With Happy Death Day In 16 Minutes Or Less

[@SpeedyGD5]

Basically, this movie is like a video game. You die, you respawn and while walking you activate the same triggers that triggers the sequence or cutscene.

[@gtaacsoliddude3230]

Good point Speedy but tree can stop getting killed but video game protagonists can't stop it because it's in the programme so unless you mean tree is like monika from ddlc or flowey from undertale that doesn't work. P.s sorry for being a game lover.

[@somedankboi6093]

@Malik Shepherd more like Edge Of Tomorrow : College Edition

[@brunobruno-c1d]

@@gtaacsoliddude3230 depends,if its a scripted scene yeah no one can stop it bare mods/glitches/changing the code but if those deaths werent 'forced' (aka you died to a boss that you were meant to kill) then you could stop yourself by being killed by winning over the boss,which is kinda what she does

[@dumpeeplarfunny]

Edge of Tomorrow was better.

[@stayhydratedkingsqueens]

*EEEEEEEEEENTER THE GUUUUNGEOOON!*

[@davidmatheny1993]

How is Jessica Rothe not gaining other roles beyond this franchise? Her performance is the best part of both films.

[@perdasche]

David Matheny I agree

[@philippebeauchamp2827]

Doesn't mean she can act in a different kind of movie. Doesn't mean she has contacts all over hollywood. Also, the movie is aimed at teenagers. Don't expect her to get a role in Dune or whatever.

[@freesir91]

God no

[@gmoney66]

@@philippebeauchamp2827 " Don't expect her to get a role in Dune or whatever." Yeah! Don't expect her to get a role in Highlander, either! Or any other strangely somehow over and under rated movie from the 80's, for that matter!

[@Sm4rsh]

Nah i like the indian kid that says oh no my yoohoo

[@RuneTraverse]

First sin should have been the fact that she goes by "Tree."

[@rogerscott8211]

XD

[@sadem1045]

I love the fact that someone named Tree didn’t sign an environment activism petition.

[@RuneTraverse]

Bwahaha, I hadn't thought of that, but yeah, that IS pretty funny. xD

[@jamieswafford977]

Lol yeah, but I think it's short for Theresa. Just say it fast and you can kind of hear it.

[@coffeepoweredkatie6290]

I had a friend in school everyone called Tree, she was just over six foot with crazy bushy hair. This obviously doesn't apply to this chick though so. *shrug*

[@bernardomansoldo2978]

You missed a sin! She has a heartfelt moment of character growth with her dad and then it's all erased by her next death.

[@j.p.6932]

Bernardo Mansoldo It’s not erased if she’s learned from it for the next time. That’s what the entire movie is about.

[@MidnightFallz]

After the final loop, you can assume she did most of the good things again like Telling Tim he’s gay Making up with her dad But you can assume she didn’t: Help the frat guy with a pillow Sign the petition Warn the couple about the sprinklers

[@tacobanana6538]

@@Stackali there is some things you can do about global warming, it's just that nobody is trying to give a fuck and be lazy about it.

[@raconbacon5649]

Its not exactly all erased. I mean from tress side it happened bit the dad hasnt experienced it. Tree keeps avoiding her dad on her birthday and after this conversation she wont feel like she has to anymore. Its simple character development.

[@elenavukovac9745]

@@MidnightFallz She actually told them about the sprinklers in da movie

[@66DoodleGal]

She tried to kill her over a man who was already cheating on his wife?????

[@frostyfilmwatcher2148]

CartoonGoddess626 let's face it, it's not the dumbest reason someone has tried to kill someone over.

[@66DoodleGal]

Frosty Film Watcher yeah, why would you waste your time falling for a guy is clearly not a loyal man

[@heedmywarning2792]

+CartoonGoddess626 "...why would you waste your time falling for a guy is clearly not a loyal man" and the number one answer is.... sex!

[@Ch50304]

Agree, just a stupid reason.

[@mechasentai]

We have seen it happen in real life. Not saying it's a good reason just that it's something people really would do. Just saying.

[@raydunakin]

When she said she didn't know who Bill Murray is, you should have played that scene from "Zombieland", where Abigail Breslin says, "Who's Bill Murray?", and Woody Harrelson says, "You know, I've never killed a kid before..."

[@IwillfixyourGrammar]

raydunakin “hit a kid” the line is “hit a kid”

[@itsisabel7303]

raydunakin thank you!!!

[@raydunakin]

Thanks, it's been a while since I've seen it so my memory was a bit fuzzy.

[@mrpeijay]

Agreed.

[@sirjenkochhar5371]

raydunakin I didn't know about groundhig day until last year when people compared this to groundhog day as well as both legends of tomorrow and agents of shield mentioned it.

[@hopel4461]

Not to mention in this movie Tree never lifted her killers mask before she was murdered. She was close enough to lift it. And she already knew she would live if she got killed so why fight and not just find out who it is

[@Aleksiway]

Well she fights 'cause dying does not feel nice

[@hopel4461]

Aada Wulli good idea, but finding out who the killer is and dying definitely beats not knowing and dying multiple times

[@diegoignaciomunozvalenzuel3013]

@@Aleksiway didn't she walked out naked from the dorm room? To me that was like "yeah, probably died today, but whatever"

[@silverwolf2643]

That's the whole damn point of the movie omg, find the killer, stop him, get out of limbo.

The movie would only be half an hour if she did that

[@orionwesley]

Lmao that "SILENCE!" bit gets me every time.

[@GBmovieluv]

I'm sure they were going with some other reference but the first that comes to mind for me is Invader Zim

[@zerolayne8245]

*"SILENCE!"* Dumbledore said calmly.

[@j.p.6932]

I seriously don’t know where this line came from or why it was supposed to be funny.

[@FilmFan-iv7sz]

Yeah 😂

[@reapergaming7680]

@@GBmovieluv SILENCE,GIR!

[@michaelj1729]

The best part about this is Jessica Rothe's way of portraying an unlikable character then slowly turns into a character you root for by the end of the movie

[@darkkoakuma]

Lori always knowing where Tree would end up was hinted at by the fact she changed Tree's ringtone on her phone : she had access to her phone and could thus have installed a GPS tracking app on it without Tree knowing. So she'd know where Tree was without needing to follow her or assume she'd take the same path each day.

[@kaaiho]

Or could also just be snapmap

[@earthplanet403]

thisssssss bruh xx

[@wisvai279]

How about literally everyone else

[@cunningsmile4166]

Uh isn't her phone off at the time?

[@zippedmouthgaming5637]

Tree being able to remove the GPS app was hinted at by the fact that she was watching a video of her mother on the phone and would have noticed a suspicious app. We can reach to defend the writers as much as we want, doesn't make us right.

[@miagomoski2739]

My friend: what did u do this weekend? Me: I watched movies then I watched someone rant about how it’s not a good movie

[@thepickygamer4450]

From their you just existed until your friend asked you a question?

[@thepickygamer4450]

@@ChiefAlday Circumference

[@youling_fozer7855]

Just Some Jew wtf u saying bro?

[@FeralRaccoon.]

@@youling_fozer7855 jew? That's racist

[@youling_fozer7855]

willow tree how is me asking wtf the other person is saying racist?????

[@montreal961]

"What are the chances she'd be accosted by someone with a clip board, witness wet-couple nookie, hear a car alarm, and see a frat pledge fall over in the span of walking a hundred feet" I seen far worse just looking out my college dorm room window on frosh week.

[@linnmarie3851]

it's all good

[@ziljin]

She would have been arrested and interrogated after threatening the cop and killing Tombs. Then she would have survived the day but in jail and never knowing Lori was the real killer.

[@coffeepoweredkatie6290]

And then probably wake up repeating the day again. Finding the killer made it stop, for whatever reason. I don't think this movie is meant to be taken seriously.

[@ziljin]

@@coffeepoweredkatie6290 in the movie she only repeated the day when she died. She didn't die in the end so she didn't repeat the day. The movie never said she had to find the killer.

[@nojaybay]

Was gonna say that there's no reason why Lori couldn't kill Tree after she got out but when I did some research I realized that max jail time for manslaughter is 40 years and 1st degree murder is either death or natural life imprisonment. So, if anyone wanted to know jail time when it comes to manslaughter/first degree murder in Louisiana, there you go. *Evidence for me knowing where Tree goes to school is found on Film Herald's "6 Ways to Beat the Killer from Happy Death Day" and his pinned comment*

[@Lilbit0912]

But then Lori would have came after her and killed her after she was released.. so then she’d have to go back to the beginning of her birthday anyway to stop the whole chain of events from happening

[@icebergmagno3321]

X

[@atronixz]

Surprisingly, TREE hates global warming...

[@asuutora]

Good

[@mariopokemon955]

captcoolYT sin cinema sins for making a worse pun than sans

[@blackpinkluv9869]

I get it now 😂

[@jesselovato9791]

DING

[@MrElionor]

@Diana Page FUCK YOU!

[@arfansthename]

"I'm definitely the killer" face. That cracks me up.

[@TheTaintedWisdom]

9:33 - That bugged me too, but he explicitly mentions "scar tissue" and "lesions." From his perspective, he's just seeing the signs of _previous_ trauma, not open wounds, broken bones, etc. The idea being that she bears the scars of her previous deaths, but it's not as though she's constantly bleeding internally or something like that. So when he said "You should be dead" he likely meant it in the context of "You should not have been able to survive whatever caused the scar tissue and lesions to form in the first place." 10:49 - Yeah, that was one little detail I wish the filmmakers had accounted for considering all the nice little pieces of attention to detail they paid in the movie. 10:54 - No, that's a completely different candle from the one that was on the cupcake, that one was solid red, this one is blue and white to keep the audience from suspecting her roommate. 12:36 - She mentions at the end that Lori resorted to stabby-stabby psycho shenanigans because Tree didn't eat the cupcake. But she *also* gained the opportunity to kill Tree while being able to pin it on Tombs, she doesn't go after Tree in the instance where Tree kills Tombs because the scapegoat she wanted to use is f*cking dead. Thus, Lori likely would've resorted to another attempt at a less confrontational means of murdering her later. Keep in mind that, from what can be seen in the movie, Lori *never* tries to kill her until _after_ 9:23 P.M. when the blackout hits. With that same blackout being the moment when Tree got the upper hand on Tombs.

[@Falling_Stars64]

_"TaintedWisdom would be great at Cinema sins"_ *_ding_*

[@patrickhanlon3404]

"GOOD THING TREE HAD A ONE NIGHT STAND WITH ENCYCLOPEDIA BROWN" IM DEAD LMFAO

[@RatedPGforOG]

Patrick Hanlon Thank you for helping remember who Encyclopedia Brown....holy shit I love that kid

[@Moonbeam143]

If there was a killer after me, I would just go to a police station. It's a pretty good place to be protected from a killer.

[@andthentheresmaria8393]

Moonbeam but like true tho

[@PhoenixEternal1337]

"Incompetent Movie Police Ex Machina"

[@hookoffthejab1]

Just buy a gun. Get $500 and go to the gun store and buy one

[@arielfridman9743]

not all of us are living in countries that allow guns. you might wanna read about my little country. its called: "Every country that isnt usa"

[@imAwareOfYourAddress]

Ariel Fridman Lmao

[@Bokks87]

"How can someone look so happy in this video and not know about Groundhog Day or Bill Murray?" That was the best part of the video

[@HABO2210]

indeed :D

[@mmorpger0558]

10:12 That's not Lori, that's the actual captured killer in the hospital. The one that escapes and also wears the outfit? The one that's down the hallway? That escaped, killed the security guard, then killed everyone he saw on his way out? She escapes from him, and runs into Lori, who was driving in the opposite direction of the street. She killed the cop and set the car on fire. My theory is that Lori put some kind of tracker app on her phone, to be able to find her wherever she goes. Only in one timeline, did she ditch the phone early on.

[@mythoslys429]

But... If she knows she is gonna die and "respawn", why not pull the killer's mask off right away to try and avoid being killed again? Hm...

[@Kainmaster]

You're trying to apply *logic* to a *horror movie*? Because logic is rarely (if ever) present in horror movies.

[@cathycreamer9370]

Because there would be no plot to this movie. Also everyone's a dick ok?

[@hellras]

Because they needed the movie to last longer then 20 minutes.

[@SageLatrans]

Well what would u pay more attention to, a knife in the stomach, or seeing the killer

[@irllcd13]

@@Kainmaster Horror movie characters can't act logically, everyone knows that. But that doesn't excuse it when they act like they're literally retarded.

[@homefront1999]

7:26 That dude just took a fucking hammer to the side of the head. This entire movie should be over already

[@CharlesTheCorgiKing]

Just Monika that lady* oh shit whoops spoiler alert

[@homefront1999]

The fuck do you watch. I'd also imagine someone in a fight for their lives would use pretty extreme force even if it's a girl behind the force.

[@peanutbutter-td8nq]

What I don’t understand is why didn’t Lori give her a chance to eat the cupcake. Killing her should’ve been her last resort lmao

[@homefront1999]

Yes i am aware it's a lot but it's not like you have to actually crush the skull to cause brain damage. People barely hitting their head on counters have gone into coma's and i believe died.

[@brandonlyon730]

I’m wondering why this girl didn’t buy or borrow a gun, or any tool that can kill someone with enough force this movie should have been over in like after 4 deaths.

[@antmanplays387]

you forgot that the cops gun only had 3 BULLETS in his gun what cop only has 3 bullets

[@gigithetoaster2344]

*ding*

[@jameswest4692]

one thats already shot the black guy

[@MikeJ2023]

antmanplays A cop that’s in a very cliché horror movie.

[@air6665]

Yeah he used the rest to shoot a black guy

[@air6665]

@@jameswest4692 beat me to it

[@hikaruk.981]

It's kind of interesting that the 2nd movie answers a lot of the 1st's "sins".

[@marmikemp3767]

Yed

[@VernonMaxwellsfriend]

The second movie made no sense to me. Was that the one with the time travel machine?

[@FilmFan-iv7sz]

@@VernonMaxwellsfriend yes

[@manueltapia1859]

The second one was similar but in other person perspective and alternate world

[@tacoclaus8168]

The studio saw this and went, “let’s make a second movie explaining all the sins, that’ll show em”

[@musicf3b]

I can't help but feel like avoiding a killer you knew was coming would be incredibly easy. Simply avoiding everyone you know wouldn't be difficult.

[@9annax]

musicf3b antisocial skills

[@kingsakoura6241]

musicf3b true. I already avoided my mom for a day, and de live in the same freaking house

[@bibbytenbillion]

Or like, a police station.

[@13lack_Rose]

get yourself arrested

[@B_Skizzle]

Exactly. Hell, I do it every day.

[@fnaflife8498]

this really was a funny movie not horror

[@snailmucus3921]

fnaf LIFE it is more of a comedic slasher movie

[@dxrlza]

Yeah 😂

[@tymonster183]

Stephen King commonly says the line between horror and comedy is a razor blade. the two go together.

[@missawsum4918]

Ikr lol

[@ShadowReaper-pu2hx]

fnaf LIFE, it’s PG-13 so it’s not really supposed to be horror.

[@doctoryarn]

For all it's flaws, this movie was still fun to watch.

[@theguytoyourleftspacebar528]

More or less

[@SadesBD]

This movie made no sense 🤦🏾‍♂️

[@randomhuman8649]

*its

[@DuskPShermanWallaby123]

@@SadesBD so?

[@SadesBD]

Carnivorous Turtle So?

[@billieeilishfan0272]

Who else watches scary movies with cinema sins so i don't get scared and crap my pants? Only me? K

[@ZBall.2507]

Naaaah, I do it to

[@itsbrody3151]

BillieEilishFan 02 hell nah I do this to

[@innndi2468]

Me lmao

[@froggy2311]

Me 😂

[@Nonyah123]

when I make the mistake of watching the scary movie I come here after to get unscared

[@itsnotemy]

This movie was actually really entertaining and far surpassed my negative expectations. I can tell by your sins you somewhat enjoyed the movie.

[@MegaZeta]

Yeah, agreed on both points... you have to laugh at both the fans and the haters who take these videos as serious criticism

[@MrFlip2247]

Mega Zeta the problem I have with this channel is that there’s really no disclaimer that you should still support the original source and that these aren’t reviews, they’re extreme nitpicks for comedy. I mean the channel trailer (and the literal videos themselves) is telling enough but that obviously isn’t enough for far too large an amount of people taking these videos as real criticism. And you see the “Good, now I don’t have to waste my time seeing this.” Comments and the like way too much. A short little disclaimer at the beginning of the video wouldn’t hurt. Or even if he said a word or two about what he actually thought about the movie at the end of the video would be fine also.

[@kingajgames3171]

@@MrFlip2247 read the description that usually tells you how the movie is

[@aldar8240]

having seen the Groundhog Day plot adapted into a horror just gave me an idea. what if there was a comedy movie where someone was going through a Groundhog Day loop, but they have such a boring life that they don't notice for half the movie?

[@MeyerLeah990]

That would probably be rather boring since the same things would just happen over and over again.

[@noneofyourbusiness4698]

A comedy.... with half the movie consisting of boring repetition... Sounds comedic to me! :l

[@nina149141v]

Me

[@aldar8240]

okay so in hindsight it wasn't a really funny idea.

[@nina149141v]

I think it's a funny idea! Just needs a bit of intelligent writing so it isn't boring. But with good writing this could be awesome and relatable

[@rewer]

Personally the only bright spot of this film is the actress performance. Kudos to trying to act professionally even you are in a B grade film. Edit: apologize for calling this a B grade film, what I really mean is a budgeted film, no offense to this film lover. Have you notice every time she walks out from the hostel she clearly become a different person? Most actors/actress will just repeat the same acting for 10 times, but she clearly did her homework what changes in her personality every time she woke up.

[@darth_kal-el]

rewer learn what B grade means. And get some taste.

[@SteelSpurs]

Darth Kal-El Learn what an opinion is. And get some taste.

[@jarvislinarez1251]

steelspurs111 Something being B-grade can’t really be an opinion. B-grade films are made with little to no budget(which this wasn’t) and is objectively bad

[@Jadedgems]

rewer "B grade" yet the budget was millions of dollars and it was played in all major theatres..... with tons of advertisement

[@AmatoGore]

rewer ikr? I’m impressed with the lead actress performance when she’s talking in under the bridge. You can see that she’s acting as a scared girl pretending to be brave. Amazing

[@killer-ablaze9424]

Roses r red, Ketchup is too, Wherever there are logos, Cinemasins will be there too

[@chronee5390]

You get a sin for rhyming too with too

[@MrMikeyfromstl]

@@chronee5390 seriously lol

[@carlwebber4094]

*ding*

[@smwatertasteslikewater]

That doesn’t even rhyme properly

[@SpikeStarkey]

Did someone say, sequel?

[@arathalexander8851]

SpikeStarkey hYAAASSS IT'S COMING!!!

[@symonalex2152]

NO, it was a fine one time watch, maybe i'll watch it in future for guilty pleasure but don't try to start another franchise and ruin the original.

[@symonalex2152]

@@AAAAAAAAAA8931 yeah, i saw the trailer after commenting here, looks interesting, hope it doesn't get worse

[@spilledtea1640]

When Happy Death Day 2U comes out he needs to make everything wrong with that movie.

[@gingersnap6004]

It looks like it’s really taking advatange of the “Tree is so done with this shit that she’s gonna do stupid deadly shit because why the hell not.” Premise this film dabbled in and make that the focus. Looks like it’ll be a kickass comedy.

[@BurgerInParadice34]

I think Tree's dead mom was the one giving her the opportunity to live from the afterlife. It was like a birthday gift from the beyond! ALSO the frat pledges were counting down bottles of beer on the wall which led me to believe she had 46 chances to guess the killer before dying (it eventually went down to 41 bottles of beer on the wall etc.) ALSO ALSO that card was written by Lori but PLANTED on Danielle for a misdirection (and she put the mask in the doctor's desk).

[@Resi1ience]

Her mother gives her the gift of early-death immortality. If someone comes to kill her, it activates and for the day and she cannot stay dead. That would explain a lot of things.

[@cunningsmile4166]

No. Seee the sequel. Time and space warped.

[@kevinnac1]

Nahh,time machine,explained in the sequel

[@sherrycronin2873]

The squeal explains everything, but good theory!

[@j.p.6932]

That’s a pretty big leap

[@ActorsWithIssuespodcast]

Honestly loved this movie, sure there were some plot holes but the lead actress's performance was career-making, at least in the horror genre, and it was pretty well-written and made except for the cop-out of the real villain. Solid 8/10

[@MegaZeta]

Yeah it shocked me how much i enjoyed it

[@mechasentai]

Juan Ayala Yeah I agree it was fun.

[@__THRILLERAUDIO_]

It wasn't scary but I thought it was a fun movie!

[@RogueCowTurd]

well written? are you kidding? CS even pointed out how terrible the writing was at 13:58

[@deffdefying4803]

@@RogueCowTurd "Pretty well written" = terrible? Please give me an example of what you consider to be a "pretty well written" movie. I'm curious.

[@itsjustmenova]

4:57 “Okay guys, today’s game pits the Dingoes versus the Babies” Happened in Australia mate, didn’t go down so well

[@TechnoScorpion]

Anyone else catch that a movie about branching timelines stars a character named Tree?

[@xsomili5501]

aresgow23 her name is Teresa

[@TechnoScorpion]

aresgow23 Yes, it's literally the only reason they gave her that nickname.

[@theamazinggrahamcracker5865]

*ding*

[@adamfernandes4312]

I think I read somewhere that it's because she grows into a better person as the movie progresses

[@TechnoScorpion]

Adam Fernandes Yeah, now that you mention it I can see that too. Good point.

[@thekingslayer1831]

Sinned because there was a fart joke in this movie and it wasn’t sinned

[@bloodybutterflygaming1242]

The Kingslayer Eh I'd debate whether it really counts as a "fart joke". Felt more like an indicator of just how much she no longer gave a fuck and was giving up than really meant to be funny.

[@thekingslayer1831]

BloodyButterfly That’s a pretty clever way of thinking about it... but did the director think of it that way? I doubt it.

[@bloodybutterflygaming1242]

The Kingslayer you could be right, maybe I am thinking too deep into it lol

[@TheJoeSwanon]

That would be a quick way to end a date

[@robertolanzone]

Sinned because the fart joke didn't count as a minus sin. That was the funniest fart joke I've seen in my life.

[@Gameface9782]

“Who takes their first date to Subway” uh, broke ass college students that’s who

[@vick7868]

Like yeah, what was she expecting? Fogo de Chão? XD

[@j.p.6932]

I have to agree with the sentiment that most college students would only be able to offer a cheap date. Although I do think only a dork would take a first date to Subway (why not just pizza and Netflix?). Plus, no gay guy would ever take a date to Subway.

[@wwehulk8798]

@@j.p.6932 unless you know all gay guys you are wrong

[@j.p.6932]

@@wwehulk8798 No, of course I don’t know all of them. But at nobody I know would take their first date to Subway. The joke was supposed to be that gays have better taste. And mostly avoid carbs.

[@wwehulk8798]

@@j.p.6932 oh ok

[@astro6492]

Does she just keep restarting that suspect list? Why would she keep rewriting the names of the people she already confirmed? *ding*

[@Yashwanthh]

Because after she dies everything resets like nothing ever happened

[@scpbr25]

@@Yashwanthh the paper would be clean then,wich means the names that are already cleared don't need to be rewriten,but she does anyway

[@donovanmartin906]

I really wish they used "In Da Club"

[@crystalchuu]

10:16 that wasn't Lori killing Gregory that was the psychopath cause he came out of the hospital after Lori drugged him to come alive again to escape

[@tjnolen1]

크리스탈 I would actually be perfectly okay with this explanation, if it wasn't for the shoes. The killer that kills Gregory is wearing the same shoes as the killer that blows up the cop car later. Also, in the clock tower scene, Toombs is wearing the exact same shoes as the cop car explosion scene. It's possible that Lori put the same shoes on Toombs, but I doubt it. It was just the movie trying to trick the viewer into thinking that Toombs was really the killer. So... *ding*

[@JorgetePanete]

크리스탈 'cause*

[@ziljin]

The cupcake candle though.

[@ambitious6963]

There goes Barry fucking with the timeline again

[@elizakohl8922]

This comment is far too underrated, tbh.

[@cattledogandstaffy]

SAVE ME BARRY

[@TohriuFuzuki]

I've seen that profile pic somewhere... Oh yeah from a nutaku game Jk but really I saw it there

[@BoulderPunchPodcast1]

Goddammit Barry! How many Savitars did you just make?!

[@thesenate2482]

😂 such an underrated comment

[@vinceb8041]

11:17 that "SILENCE" was gold

[@disasterdoctor819]

If there are a bunch of continuity errors than maybe this could be an example if the multiverse theory? Every time she dies is a new universe. Still doesn't explain everything but it explains the continuity errors.

[@killerbee2562]

I was thinking of this too when Jeremy pointed out the when the criminal's name changed.

[@booboochicken786]

Disaster Doctor I

[@drarryshipper4life445]

Who in their right mind would name their daughter Tree?

[@bloodybutterflygaming1242]

Pam Northman when Gregory introduces her to his wife it's shown her name is actually Theresa. Tree is just a nickname.

[@davekp6773]

Old joke. Theresa Green.....trees are green.

[@rosestar1324]

Same people who name their daighter Willow?

[@irllcd13]

@@bloodybutterflygaming1242 That's still not an excuse. Only someone who really doesn't love their daughter lets them use the nickname "Tree"

[@bloodybutterflygaming1242]

@@irllcd13 like anyone can control what nickname their kids answer to, especially when they're adults lol

[@omaricarter7323]

The real sin was why her name is tree

[@brianaguilar8283]

It's a nickname. Her full name is Teresa

[@haileijohnson9267]

Her full name Is Teresa, dude. Tree Is her nickname

[@itzstormy9733]

Well, you know what they say. Sam is to Samantha as Tree is to Treeantha

[@omaricarter7323]

Teresa = tree? Huh?

[@jameswormsley460]

illuminati confirmed!!!

[@waitselljones8068]

Missed one: Why was Danielle ruled out as a suspect when they were both killed by a bus?

[@emilyhendriks7104]

8:33 is basically it. the sin is why danielle has the envelope

[@andrewbresnan1449]

How long before the "day continuously resets until character gets it right" plot becomes a cliché?

[@MegaZeta]

Years and years and years ago, like probably before you were born?

[@hillhouseproductions]

Andrew Bresnan I’d say at least another 10 years.

[@Sakaki98]

Andrew Bresnan In the fandoms, it already is. It’s only a matter of time until Hollywood follows suit.

[@benjaminfricke4791]

Andrew Bresnan Well, I can name at least three movies that have it as a plot point, so we’re getting REALLY close.

[@emberparadox458]

Between movies AND TV shows using it as a plot point, it became cliche back in the late 80's or early 90's at the very latest when Star Trek: The Next Generation had no less than two episodes used that exact plot.

[@mechasentai]

I love how movie protagonists can ALWAYS find a love interest who will believe even the craziest shit. Anyone would be concerned for this girl.

[@carlamitce443]

I literally couldn’t remember any of the character’s names during watching this so I didn’t predict Laurie cause I didn’t know who she was

[@Aleksiway]

Isn't it Lori?

[@Pretty.Biology.Princess]

Aada Wulli it’s Lori

[@Getmetofollowerswithacoupleofv]

SPOILER

[@missawsum4918]

@@Getmetofollowerswithacoupleofv This video is a spoiler 😂

[@carlwebber4094]

I only remembered Tree

[@papawuise6820]

8:36 missed sin: Why would Tree cross out Danielle from her "possible killers" list just because they both died?

[@MidnightFallz]

Papa Wuise Danielle didn’t fight her one bit at all you can see that, and Tree believed that if she killed the killer the loop would be closed so this would be why she was crossed off

[@abercuss2279]

Tree is dying Screaming Guy enters room n does nothing Movie sins: Baylor

[@lil-mochi1579]

is it sad that I knew the killer just from the trailer

[@JaegerMatthias]

well what gave it away?

[@meepysama9951]

Me too, i called it because the cupcake thing with that fake smile seemed so obvious to me.

[@lil-mochi1579]

MeepySama thank you someone understands

[@tippythedog8143]

Yeah! Me too especially since she’s like the only person who has access to the room and all...like Lori is just a bad actress.. 😂 ( not the real person but in the movie)

[@brandonwhite1021]

We must have seen different trailers, then, because I don’t remember even seeing that chick in the trailer.

[@vicg2652]

Interesting note and I know I’m way late on this, but nursing students NEVER “pull double shifts”. You’re there as long as your professor or preceptor are there and then you leave. You can’t work on your own and so you don’t stay later than the person responsible for you. Never. Also, totally hear you on nurses being around at 9:30pm, but 9 is generally the time nurses do all their shit on general medicine floors than aren’t the ICU and she wasn’t in the ICU. Nurses do their once over of patients at 8, 12, and 4 and except when a medication is due, they try to let them get their sleep. That said, the hospital is super empty at 9:30, and only a super human nurse on a med-surg floor, which is where she is, would be able to get 9pm meds to all their patients before 9:30. So fine. Take the sin.

[@Gabriellaella23]

Maybe she was able to because the professor was still there "working late."

[@datnguyen3441]

13:14, in that loop, Tree apologised Lorie so Lorie didn’t offer her the cake. This means that Lorie didn’t have an intention of killing Tree, Tree picked the cake up herself on that loop as in the previous loops, Lorie offers it to Tree.

[@boiledkettles6066]

Why call your child tree 🌳

[@shadowmystic6717]

Apparently it’s short for Teresa

[@poppin3015]

Firecustard Why put an emoji?

[@boiledkettles6066]

Javi Duarte why not :)))))))

[@m33zerella]

Well, why *wood-n’t* you? Get it? I’ll leave.

[@boiledkettles6066]

Wishbear 4444 AHAHAHHAHAH love it owo

[@SgtSupaman]

12:04 They clearly just couldn't be bothered to use his full name: John Joseph Jingleheimer Tombs.

[@waterywingz]

SgtSupaman hahaha xD

[@cloud8521]

his name is my name too

[@jonathanredford215]

Whenever we go out, the people always shout..

[@theflufftalk9507]

Wait... So every good thing thing she did the day before she found out who the killer really was, was erased right? So that means she's still a jerk in almost everyone else's eyes?

[@nixiscartwright5521]

Joe-C Robinson clearly the writers had no intention of doing any sort of research of how the space time continuum works. Lol

[@MegaZeta]

...

[@rhionpinto6849]

Exactly. And the beautiful moment she had with her dad never happened either. The romantic day she had with Carter also never happened.

[@tjnolen1]

Rhion Pinto well, actually, both of those happened. After she kicks Lori out of the window, it shows her spending the day with Carter and explaining everything to him, then she gets a call from her dad, and says she will see him at the restaurant soon.

[@beanie9167]

The best feeling is watching a scary part but a relaxing voice of SinemaSins comforts you

[@Evelyn-jd8cu]

"Happy death day: Tokyo drift " 😂😂😂😂

[@ravenlord4]

I could have sworn that I already watched this yesterday . . .

[@Blasted2Oblivion]

...stab...

[@SmokeymcJoint420]

BOOOOOOO, save the humor for people that are actually funny.

[@amber5070]

😂😂😂👍

[@justalittleturtle5600]

Do you remember dying yesterday too?

[@condemend2bloodshot]

i had weird dejavu while watching this video lol

[@sofiatudelaatyoutub1]

I watch these videos when I don't want to watch the movie

[@daniibp23]

Me too.

[@jowa1777]

Same, I can't sit through scary movies, but I still wanna know what they're about

[@CobraCartoon64]

Josey Wales Same. I'm too much of a chicken to go out of my way to watch horror movies, no matter how much people tell me how pathetically UNSCARY some of them are.

[@avagutterson5822]

Same!!! Or if I’m too scared to watch the actual movie I watch these because his commentary makes me feel safe lol

[@GreenStoneKnight]

4:54 Yeah....why would a campus have a BABY as their mascot? I mean...who wants to watch a bunch of drunk babys running around campus? Well actually, now that I say it, it sounds kinda fun!

[@ascendedcat260]

_slurred "googoo gaagaa" intestifies_

[@nthgth]

Babies already do pretty good drunk impressions just figuring out how to move around haha

[@Xjebin]

Aiden The Green Stone Knight dead meat quote ur not slick

[@mrmism7451]

Im the only one who understood the Dead Meat reference :(

[@Canadian_Zac]

Main problem with the chair kicking under the door is not how impossible it is, is not that the move is ridiculously hard, it's how she thinks that'd help. Someone comes to the room and the door won't open, then after a few seconds the door opens and she's in the chair acting innocent. Wouldn't take a genius to figure out what was going on.

[@SmokeymcJoint420]

Also, if the chair could slide into place by the door so easily, it would simply slide back out when someone tried to open it.

[@dua_junaid]

16:18 *While the entire video was amazing, this part had me DEAD.* xD

[@benlong9431]

Same lmao I love Urban Legend

[@psygn0sis]

You suck at time stamping!

[@brandonpollard8928]

Half The Heart lmao hell yeah ding ding ding no wayyy

[@nfgames8322]

*How can the person in this birthday video look this happy and somehow not know what Groundhog Day or Bill Murray is?*

[@calibursatsujin3112]

"who takes their first date to subway, i mean its not like you have a foot-long" DID make me laugh though

[@FuzzyStripetail]

Clearly, those BTA (better to avoid) buses never brake for anything except potentially poisoned cupcakes.

[@waterinmyotter6245]

You missed one. When she is making the list of potential killers, why is she rewriting the people she’s already checked just to cross them out again in each loop?

[@SmokeymcJoint420]

Because the people that watch these movies are fucking retards.

[@cosmicremix311]

You make a great point

[@Droooooo0]

So she doesn't forget who she's crossed off already.

[@link1016]

6:42 that dude is my favorite character in the whole movie

[@Gam3rfreak1290]

Well, the whole "trauma is carrying over from each death" thing MIGHT be a plot point in the sequel.

[@imacheckneck]

Its one of the main plot points ;)

[@emeraldranger]

Though I like how one of the side characters in this movie experiences the reliving of the day for like two times and then is back to tree with reliving the same day over and over again it’s just ridiculously stupid

[@priscillajimenez27]

"Tree is a d*ck to global warming" lol 00:55

[@jameswormsley460]

hahahahaha

[@pietrolima3148]

Ah, the irony.

[@BlackHawk_-wv4ex]

You need to sin 47 meters, it is asking for it the entire movie

[@loveiskey22]

BlackHawk1159 _ worst shark movie ever

[@justinysrobotbutler4002]

The movie where the two girls get stuck in the shark cage underwater? I liked it even thought it was predictable as shit.

[@phatmantv]

I actually thought the movie was pretty funny & entertaining tbh.

[@hellras]

Nobody said it wasn't.

[@camerontrivett1772]

It’s no horror movie, but it stopped pretending to be by like half an hour in

[@millerblaylock]

Maybe Tree has the number of lives for each year old she is, that explains why she has so many chances to get it right.

[@ryeroyal]

How the heck did the fact that her name was tree not get a sin lol

[@ryeroyal]

Tyrell Suraiya ha then I'd sin the cruelty of the kids that made that nickname stick.

[@GlossArt]

tree is a pretty cute nickname tbh

[@shannoncatney5202]

I think her actual name is Terisa.

[@boobysr]

It was her actual name, in the credits, the character's name is just Tree.

[@awashington8447]

AGREED!!!! lmao Like, she was WAYY too entitled and conceited for her name to be "Tree" lmao

[@stephenbanks9543]

I fucking lost it at “Baylor”

[@mikayladennis4837]

XCaliber ME TOO😂😂😂

[@JAHamilton77]

Had to rewind to make sure that’s what he said......

[@stephenbanks9543]

Hakuna Matata There was a sexual assault scandal at Baylor University where university officials ignored/covered up complaints against football players.

[@bau7417]

They tend to cover up things like that in general, not just for football players.

[@CaptainRexySexy]

I go to Baylor and this had me dying lol

[@eliwaddell]

1:00 Right when he said “sorry... my internet’s slow” the video on my phone stopped because of said lack of internet on my side ;-;

[@Link9058]

same with me. fuck the internet >:C

[@diversity7057]

Ye

[@rinyazamaki3728]

Late, but Tree attacked Danielle because of the card.

[@emilyhendriks7104]

ya but why did danielle have the card? it’s never explored more, it makes sense that tree thought she was the killer but then after they get hit by the bus she just crosses her off the list.

[@MikeRosehart]

I just couldn’t handle how stupid this lady was. Why didn’t she just pull the mask off on the second death?? Or the 3rd... I was screaming on the inside!

[@LSB001]

Yeah, I can't watch films where the writing is so poor that they have to intentionally make the protagonist stupid in order to prevent the story from ending prematurely. The absolute most important thing to do in her situation is to discover the identity of the killer so she can plan accordingly.

[@taeyangshairdryer6478]

Even if she did she still gets killed🙄😂

[@jamalmilton142]

The point of pulling it off was knowing who did it from the get go to prevent it next time

[@waterywingz]

Cuz~~ in the words of Cinemasins, movie has to movie ;)

[@chexmix0101]

Unfortunately that’s a lot of “horror” films

[@collinfox8967]

If she doesn’t want people knowing it’s her birthday, why is her ringtone “It’s my birthday”. Way to keep it a secret

[@SuperJ3sus]

just watched this movie, and the answer is that her roomate changed it.

[@bloodybutterflygaming1242]

Lori changed it. They talk about it the first time she goes through the day.

[@heavenly7939]

Collin Fox you must be white

[@ericholysword8306]

heavenly what

[@godofthecripples1237]

So did you just not pay attention to the movie at all, or...?

[@pg13horrormovies51]

Why would Tree put Danielle off the suspect list after getting hit by the bus? When she was about to hang herself, she climbed up the stairs a little too fast... What if those red shoes she threw in the air hit someone in the head? It would be VERY awkward if Tim was bi...

[@bloodybutterflygaming1242]

PG-13 Horror Movies yeah the first time I saw the scene indicating he was gay I was like "Well all that disproves is what you assumed his motive to be, not whether he is actually the killer..."

[@jadeliu4992]

BloodyButterfly, but she was watching Tim in the room and turned around to get killed immediately. Tim couldn't have been in two places at the same time.

[@kyu_the_best]

I also thought that for the first one ! That absolutely doesn't prove that she's not the killer

[@bodybuild9768]

Kyu Jorand They both died by the bus, if she was the killer the loop would’ve ended.

[@kyu_the_best]

@@bodybuild9768 No, the loop ends if Tree survives the day. Not if the killer dies

[@helena_lang]

I honestly don’t understand why she doesn’t just go to, say, the police station, and say she thinks someone’s going to try to kill her. She’d be under protection, yay, safe, movie over.

[@emberparadox458]

One thing you forgot to mention, when Tree has her Holmesian reveal, she's doing a ton of expositing to Lori who, other than intending to poison her with the cupcake, hadn't even considered any further action yet because she had put all of her cupcakes in one basket at that point. It wasn't until Tree refused to eat the cupcake that all of those other death plans got worked out and implemented. So, basically, Lori would have absolutely zero clue about roughly 99% of what Tree was explaining to her.

[@jhjjhg1]

I actually loved this movie. I'm the type of person who hates watching a movie more than once, and I ended up watching this twice within a two day span.

[@dubwavy6386]

jhjjhg1 technically you watched it 18x2 so like 36 times cause it just repeated over and over and I thinks she finally survived on the 18th repeat

[@FercPolo]

Specifically the part about her accruing injuries, I thought "Okay, here's where the movie actually stops being terrible.". Nope. It actually makes it even worse because they never bring it up again even though it was the one thing adding urgency to her situation.

[@brianaguilar8283]

This plot point was supposed to come up again in the alternate ending, but by removing it, it no longer makes sense. Bad editing.

[@LexiDancerina3]

What was the alternate ending?

[@brianaguilar8283]

LexiDancerina3 tree is taken to the hospital after she kills Lori because she is succumbing to her accumulating injuries, and her professor’s wife pretends to give her treatment before she kills her out of revenge for sleeping with her husband.

[@audhd_incarnate8001]

That would have been a way better ending!

[@brianaguilar8283]

Roseanne Topaz it was originally screened for test audiences but they reacted negatively to this ending, because after Tree spent the whole movie redeeming herself and finally becoming a better person, she dies anyway meaning the whole journey was for nothing. This ending was scrapped and reshot to the current one we have now. Another scrapped ending was Tree wakes up after killing Lori, indicating that killing her didn’t stop the time loop and that it could be a never ending cycle.

[@kourtneylily]

I AM SO GLAD HE SAID IT! I was dead ass wondering when tf “in da club” was going to appear in the movie but NOT once did we hear it in the movie.

[@makeda6530]

Since most college students aren't exactly high rollers where's she think a first date would be? I don't know why that line annoyed me enough to comment.

[@erikgardner4777]

cami while you could, where are you going to do that in the city? Also nobody is that cliche where they would do anything like that

[@simon-patrickjohnson]

I think the point of that line was to establish Tree as kind of a bitch

[@aileenrobertz4367]

sheldon pereira no, subway is bomb

[@Lumaweh]

Erik Gardner It was an example, you don't actually have to watch stars. Going on a walk or buying ingredient for a home made dinner are pretty cheap and romantic ways. Also it may be cliche, but it works.

[@xlectraheart]

sheldon pereira If someone took me to subway bought me a footlong and payed without a coupon I'd be chill with that date and probably marry him on the spot Subway is expensive

[@dojix96]

"the Dingoes versus the Babies." Oh boy, any other Australians here?

[@bobbyclark3000]

Lazarbeam

[@HIERARCHYOFMEMES]

I'd say "Hallelujah" but we say "OI OI OI" like the cunts we are!!!

[@KaladinVegapunk]

Haha I mean, you don't have to be an Aussie to know that he was intentionally doing a dingo took my baby joke

[@timmyteaches7663]

Dojix everyone in the world knows this joke.. starving Ethiopian children in Africa know this joke...

[@spikejrb7572]

Go Space Broncos!

[@midgetkangaroo5795]

“OOOH I WANT TO WATCH THIS MOVIE” *watches cinema sins on that movie* “I can’t believe I wanted to watch that movie”

[@PolyBiBadger]

Midget Kangaroo pretty much

[@estebk]

Watch it anyways... I might not be a masterpiece but it's fun. And by Jeremy's tone I think he thought it was fun too imo

[@rossharrison2148]

On the day where Tree confides in Carter, one of the first things she does is smash her ringing phone in Carter’s dorm room in a fit of panic and terror. You can even hear the sound of it smash into what sounds like thousands of pieces. When he finds her wandering around outside, he returns her top, bracelet and shoes, but not the phone (as it was obviously destroyed). Yet a few minutes later as the two sit in the cafeteria, her phone begins to ring on the table as though it has the ability to respawn too.

[@LnPPersonified]

I actually really liked this movie. It had its cliches, but the main character was smarter than she appeared and had a decent character arc. I thought the fake-out with the serial killer was clever, and it had a satisfying payoff. I also liked Carter's trick at the end, though it would have been a better ending if catching the real killer didn't fix the time loop, and she was stuck in it forever anyway because the two are unrelated. It would have been a proper horror movie ending, but I like the happy ending anyway.

[@IlikeTrainsguy100]

Pokerface You should check out the deleted ending

[@boobysr]

Imagine actually thinking this.

[@lunamaster123]

But it wouldn't make sense. She would wake up after death, not after a certain point. Having her die after the day and not reset would be a more natural horror end.

[@HIERARCHYOFMEMES]

Pokerface It's a horror comedy film, so that type of ending wouldn't work out for fans. The test screenings included an ending in which Gregory's wife ended up killing Tree after she (Tree) needed to go to the hospital after she (Tree) killed Lori. Audiences were not pleased. I think it's mostly because people got around to really liking and feeling sorry for Tree, which makes sense.

[@brianaguilar8283]

I like how you just state you like this movie even after the video gives away all of the narrative flaws, almost as if you know you have nothing left to say.

[@DeniseF]

It was good watch..reminded me of the good old 2000s

[@korbywhoisnotkirby5717]

Denise F its from 2017s though

[@foggy9900]

Half the characters feel like they could be in a American Pie film though.

[@brittanyvictoria681]

I expected that this would be funny of course but I didn't burst out laughing almost in tears almost spitting out my food until... he said [WET DREAM] lmao f* hilarious!!

[@bethanywhite247]

Lori changed the ring tone not tree

[@saucemann5196]

15:44 Perfect opportunity to use the outdated "Deja Vu" meme here.

[@ahamilton3435]

Not using 'In Da Club' pissed me off so bad.

[@nxtcosmic6081]

Lmaoo you officially made this movie a joke when u pointed out the baby mascot 😂😂😂😂

[@nidhalsormali3051]

CinemaSins: "Why did she not explain why she KNEW there was poison in the cupcake" Tree literally 2 seconds ago: "I didn't eat it the other times....but i ate it last night and died....YOU POISONED IT"