Everything Wrong With Mary Poppins In 15 Minutes Or Less

With the new Mary Poppins sequel upon us, we decided to test our motto and go looking for sins in the original. And we found some. A bunch, actually.
Next week: Something super and something seasonal.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
•CinemaSins website: www.cinemasins.com •
•Channels•
--TVSins: / @tvsins
--MVS: / @musicvideosins
•Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• teespring.com/stores/cinemasins
•Podcasts•
-SinCast A weekly chat with Jeremy, Chris and Barrett about their love and hatred for movies and entertainment. cinemasins.libsyn.com/
--Behind the Sins: CinemaSins writers Aaron, Jonathan and Deneé, give a behind the scenes look at what it takes to release the previous week's videos across the CinemaSins brand. redcircle.com/shows/behindthe...
•Writers Social•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris: / sincastcinemasins
Barrett: / musicvideosins
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé / deneesays
•Discord: Request on Facebook or Reddit!
•Reddit: / cinemasins
•Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com/book

[@aarishowton8037]

"Though we adore men individually, we agree that as a group they're rather stupid." "That's- well, can't argue much with that one." *Sins anyways*

[@martinlawson6421]

Aaris Howton I was hoping he’d take off 2-3 sins for that true realization ha

[@bluegenes2273]

Thaaaaat's racist. *ding*

[@airplane6417]

@@bluegenes2273 No, that's sexist.

[@bluegenes2273]

@@airplane6417 bleargh

[@Meatfrequency]

As a male, that line is the funniest thing I've ever heard

[@Nogdog945]

‘Releasing a sins video before a related or sequel comes out in theaters’ cliche *DING*

[@demmazx1475]

Thank you!

[@juansarria6478]

Beautiful

[@LordVulcan93]

Ooooo, Releasing a sins video before a related or sequel comes out in theaters’ is TIGHT!

[@dominickperez2952]

'Using cliche' cliche *ding*

[@Nogdog945]

Dominick Perez good one, well played

[@kerbonaut2059]

12:09 'You never knew how large the chimney-sweep mafia was, did you?' *That's how mafia works*

[@nikitherowboat5892]

No thats how chimney sweepers work

[@galleryofrogues]

THERE IS NO MAFIA. GOT IT?!

[@alexthegreat8001]

@@galleryofrogues Very good, here's your 50 dollars, now 'op it, and if I catch you spreading tales, your'e a dead man.

[@Ultra_Diamond66]

you can really tell that this comment was made 5 years ago XD

[@hazbinotakusimp2182]

I heard Dick literally paid Disney to get a role in this movie, he wanted to do it so badly. That makes me appreciate his character and him as an actor soooo much

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

And apparently it worked out for him, as he ended up playing two characters (the other being Mr. Dawes Sr., the crotchety old geezer at the bank).

[@hobbitpeddler4267]

Yes! He paid to portray Mr. Dawes. And he did an excellent job!

[@LyleFrancisDelp]

Untrue. Disney wanted DVD to appeal to American audiences. DVD wanted to play Dawes senior, and did that for free.

[@lucygarrett9785]

Yeah I read about it in his biography He paid to play the old man

[@dianehansen9526]

If he paid them, did they pay him back or did he do it for free?

[@vanquish5023]

In retrospect, this movie is super odd but man, Julie Andrews is so damn charming.

[@bbgun061]

-500,000 sins for Julie Andrews, and -600,000 sins for Dick Van Dyke!

[@jiv32]

Julie Andrews is perfection. A national treasure.

[@margaritam.9118]

Did you mean so damn hot?

[@tophatgorilla2716]

@Desolark The Feathered Apparently, she can.

[@daRiddler32]

Yeah she won a well deserved Oscar for the role (in a unique bit of poetic justice)

[@kikedragoon]

Nononononono. He got his job back because shaking hands with a chimney sweep makes you lucky. At the end of Step in Time ALL chimney sweeps shake his hand, making him the luckiest man.

[@savannahchampagne6186]

I am incredibly confused by this fact.

[@Isarai1705]

You sir, win the internet.

[@jepiene]

A sweep is as lucky as lucky can be Good luck will rub off when I shakes hands with you

[@mph419]

Henrique Zen I have seen this film maybe a few dozen times (though not in 15 years) and I don't think that realization ever dawned on me. So thanks to you; shame on me.

[@airplane6417]

Until he dies of black lung, NOW who's lucky?

[@vwgames49]

6:33 You say "a spoonful of SINS off" (Implying multiple sins off) yet you only remove one. "Jeremy doesn't know grammar" DING

[@thepickygamer4450]

Unless a single son fills an entire spoon, spoons don't hold very much of anything.

[@LadyOnikara]

@@thepickygamer4450 Or there IS no spoon!

[@GathKingLeppbertI]

@@LadyOnikara way to move the sugar cubes ma'am.

[@lolapop170]

As depressing as this sounds, "feed the birds" is my favourite song of the movie.

[@superpunkrotten6650]

Lorinda Marrian looking on KZbin at Mary poppins sings Pink Floyd

[@ethanschoales6563]

Walt Disney thought so too

[@LunaGamer25]

Plus it literally is the point of the movie. Giving a little kindness can go a long way. Even if your just paying a tuppence.

[@arikgershon]

I remember thinking "What the heck is a tuppence" until the bank scene. But yeah, it's a nice song

[@faerlywell]

Not depressing at all!! It's a beautiful song. And pretty sure it's a lot of peoples favorite. It might be mine, frankly haha

[@ShaudaySmith]

I did NOT remember the maid so casually suggesting Mr. Banks committed suicide like that... I gasped and lol'd at the same time.

[@NeonWabbit]

@PorkyYT 13:22 the maid says the bridge is popular with "jumpers" as in people who jump off to commit suicide

[@happysavage6660]

kids asking their parents: "Mommy, daddy, what's a jumper?" Parents: "oh look at the sky! look at all the stars!" lol And yes, this is a family movie, talking about people "jumping" a bridge committing suicide. WTF?!

[@tejaswoman]

@@happysavage6660 - Note also the mention of "dragging the river," i.e., in order to recover the dead body.

[@UTU49]

@@happysavage6660 kids asking their parents: "Mommy, daddy, what's a jumper?" Parents: "Well, kids... a "jumper" is a ... um... type of sweater."

[@soriyaboyloy3291]

Shauday Smith Z

[@geraldgrenier8132]

A Nursery was a suite of rooms, that includes their bedroom, their playroom, their school room, plus the private space of the Nanny/Governess.

[@TrippyGSR]

@R4- P17 in America, a nursery also refers to a room for a newborn/infant. This is just a difference of word meanings between the US and Europe. Neither is wrong.

[@tgguitarguy]

I would've taken all the sins off just for Step in Time. It's just so damn perfect.

[@sailorplanetos3075]

I'd actually add a sin for that----it was an epic scene visually, but I never did like the song.

[@victoriak.4932]

Excuse me since when is it step in time, I thought it was steppy time

[@bananabuttersomethin]

Especially when they get down into the house. "Votes for Women, step in time!" "It's the master, step in time!" "AAH! Step in time!"

[@sarahmurabito9391]

tgguitarguy i had a classmate who was obsessed with it

[@olijovelmacdonald]

69 likes

[@dzarthedemon4855]

"Though we adore men individually, we agree that as a group they're rather stupid." "No, no. She's got a point"

[@mr_oreoman]

When he started singing Alexander Hamilton 😂😂

[@Hana_H]

Ikr😂😂😂

[@hiimtrash391]

I screamed so hard

[@RoseLily0603]

You right 😂😂

[@u.darkhelm9101]

Cuz Lin-Manuel Miranda is in the second one

[@743d43ladyfae]

I was like “YASSSSS DADDY HAMILTON👏👏👏”

[@williamallen5570]

Jeremy sins a musical for having musical numbers cliche *ding*

[@ameliahaynes-standeven5284]

THANK YOU. I love his commentary a lot but damn, like, it's kinda part of the genre?

[@TheStevenlhargrove]

you guys as most people don't get the joke. Watch EWW Cinemasins....like i tell everyone.

[@ShroudedWolf51]

What's the issue, though?

[@almandinefox5160]

that Hamilton reference really caught me off guard lmao

[@LeafRazorStorm]

5:02 In the older days of television, it was relatively common practice for the subtitles to condense dialogue so it could be read at a slower pace. Transcribers didn't care too much about point-for-point accuracy, since the only reason you'd have to read those captions is if you couldn't hear what the film was saying to begin with. Honestly, as long as the "meaning" of the dialogue isn't changed, I wouldn't care too much about it.

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

Once I was watching _Futurama_ and Amy asks Fry, "What business is it of yours?" And the captioning said, "It's none of your business." I mean, fair enough, the latter sounds more natural anyway.

[@paulbennett2284]

When Mary snapped her fingers in the outtakes , I was expecting a Thanos reference.

[@ichangedmyname2739]

Paul Bennett YEEEEEEEES

[@catluvr2]

As was I. In fact, the people who weren't... well, the Gauntlet got them.

[@devineaaron]

I was waiting for the Thor screaming No sound lol

[@l0ganb3rry_]

There was though... Peter Parker's line "I don't want to go" at 14:46

[@thedoctor5777]

technically there was

[@Imaginita]

5:59 I prefer the idea that Mary Poppins is a Time Lady. The bag is bigger on the inside, after all.

[@douglasdaniel4504]

I like it.

[@mojeimja]

I'd like to see her as a Marvel character :) She snaps like a boss!

[@spriken]

Nope, she works for the ministry of magic, investigating kids that might have magic to screen the for hogwarts...

[@thedoctor5777]

spriken nah the doctor who theory is better

[@Dargonhuman]

@@thedoctor5777 You're screen name makes you a bit biased, but why can't she be both? She's a Time Lady who is posing as an agent for the Ministry of Magic in order to prevent the Time Turners or other temporal magic from being abused to alter the timeline and she goes out to the Banks house to get close to Bert as he's been flagged as a threat to the timeline.

[@drag0nerd]

The children freak me out *THEY HAVE NO EYEBROWS*

[@adde9506]

Actually blonde people: DING

[@2Ten1Ryu]

Yeah, me too. Especially the girl. Her face sometimes looks downright emotionless. But it's not because of the eyebrows. It's just her face. It's creepy.

[@hudson132]

How did I never notice that?! Can't unsee!

[@ghostlead1598]

How did I not notice that it looks so creepy

[@ZillMob]

Mary poppins is the devil and one of those kids is the antichrist. I’m just kidding. Maybe

[@sucons4254]

Does anyone else smile whenever a sin gets removed?

[@sweepyourspeech8350]

He Had no choice after the medicine went down

[@ClanImprobable]

Yes! :-D

[@garthdavis2502]

Fun Fact: The penguins later appeared, once again as waiters, in Who Framed Roger Rabbit.

[@daverobson3084]

Then they went bad and helped THE PENGUIN in his assault on Gotham city. Luckily they were fairly inept and easily fooled into turning their back mounted rockets against their leader.

[@Top_Hat_Man]

Then penguin's duckmobile fell into a bath.

[@aslothnamedfish]

The penguins then realised that they immortal and could not die, this leading them to for the penguin mafia, and that's why I hate penguins

[@oryonrex9838]

Dave Robson then realized they can do good and lived under code names Kowalski, Skipper, Rico, and Private

[@omnishambles_0]

The absolute best part about this video was the animated horse rant, hilarious

[@jimb.7523]

Fun fact: That horse was based on President Taft's horse.

[@feedninjacat3206]

I loved it as well. I was cracking up

[@spencerf7188]

Jeremy was having fun with that one

[@superevilscientistgamer5939]

That horse is THICCCC

[@scarclem]

HE STARTED SINGING HAMILTON!!! YOU NEED TO DO THEATRE SINS

[@oracle6162]

Yes.

[@princesslomboy3512]

Yes. (2)

[@oracle6162]

@@princesslomboy3512 we *NEED* theater sins

[@princesslomboy3512]

@@oracle6162 E X A C T L Y

[@oracle6162]

@@princesslomboy3512 if we don't I don't think I'll survive

[@danboyle116]

"We apologize for ... Those responsible have been sacked." That is just freaking hilarious! (Well, to any Python fan ...)

[@bluegenes2273]

møøses noses wiped by bjørn irkenstrøm slater-walker

[@ninjabluefyre3815]

Add the fact that the subtitles were wrong in the actual movie, and it's even funnier.

[@kennykiller]

The only thing I was flat expecting was Willy singing I'm a maniac. Big letdown was expectin that outtake the whole sins vid lol

[@BlaiddDrwg2009]

6:25 - you need to add a sin because they're American Robins. British Robins are dumpier, have browner feathers and a bright red breast.

[@Just4Fun-Zocker]

Also, Robins without a Batman.

[@mattwoo556]

And without hoods

[@sandran17]

2:22 'its grand to be an Englishman in 1910!' give it four years mate

[@matthewfredericks1640]

World war one

[@iancuypers8856]

​@@paooldermes3683 yeah hey um... what the fuck?

[@pendagar449]

@@iancuypers8856 Links without reference = spam

[@Whensheopenupthatwindow]

Noel .Burns Not even, give it two.

[@sandran17]

@@matthewfredericks1640 you got it!

[@slytheringingerwitch]

RIP Matthew Garber (Michael Banks) 25 March 1956 - 13 June 1977

[@yousureboutthat1271]

How did he die?

[@slytheringingerwitch]

@@yousureboutthat1271 He died of pancreatitis at the age of 21.

[@yousureboutthat1271]

@@slytheringingerwitch Oh, okay, thank you.

[@17moonbeams]

@@slytheringingerwitch What is that? I mean the diease. 🎵

[@slytheringingerwitch]

@@17moonbeams Its hepatitis that affects the pancreas.

[@ubergeek1968]

Because Julie Andrews is the most beautiful woman to ever walk this Earth, possessing a wonderful voice, beautiful personality, excellent acting talent, and being damned gorgeous... I hereby VETO CinemaSins ruling and remove 91,000,000,000 sins!

[@sarahmurabito9391]

Edward Maumbauer me too

[@nctpti2073]

I strongly suspect that CinemaSins have never actually had a spoonful of sugar, or if they had, they tried to snort it or something rather than let it just melt in the mouth offsetting the taste of the medicine. They also likely do not realize how many modern childrens' medicines have the proverbial 'spoonful of sugar' built in to the formulation.

[@marnie5700]

ABSOLUTELY 👍

[@hootle4641]

The movie isn't great despite that I love it but Julie Andrews remains biggest reason to watch it.

[@ZillMob]

What if her and David Bowie had a kid? Oh no, what if you get Zoolander?

[@RobChappers]

Answer - Nothing, it’s practically perfect in every way.

[@xanderzmartini]

Except when you remember that it's not

[@lazulidrawzalot0616]

@Atom Yeah it was.

[@guystudios]

Atom But it is

[@guystudios]

Atom I’m perplexed as to what you’re alluding to

[@guystudios]

Atom I has no intention of mocking you, I’m sorry if you got that impression.

[@kimkallbrier9353]

All the sins removed for Jeremy actually saying Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious backwards! Genius bro! Pure genius! Color me impressed! ❤

[@randmiller88]

It's just reversed audio...

[@ohsinboi2721]

He didn't...

[@cmm07r]

After he said it, a demon was summoned next to me. Contrary to popular belief, hes cool and makes a mean casserole.

[@RainesFallen]

cmm07r but can he bake cookies

[@timbeaton5045]

Nah. He must have called on The Man From Another Place.....

[@jacqueline8288]

"We agree that as a group they're rather stupid." "That's... Well, actually I can't argue much with that one." *sins it anyway, despite the fact that he just agreed with the movie*

[@nnewt8445]

Honestly, the real sin is that he agreed with it.

[@ZaneTruesdale007]

I never caught that part growing up I just watched this yesterday and caught that and ive watched it over 100 times.

[@noneofyourbeeswax01]

They actually ding for a Sin whenever they make a joke, a comment or a reference, not just for faults. Because, as we're always being told, none of it is serious. Even the serious bits. _Especially_ the serious bits.

[@CoolPaDuke]

4:40 I can't believe you didn't point out that Mary Poppins literally blew the competition away.

[@sundeepkuntimad5339]

He actually brought that up with mob tactics. Also, how did no one else on the street see the big storm blow away the applicants?

[@GameHopping]

Those who sacked the people responsible for the subtitles have been sacked.

[@BlaiddDrwg2009]

We apologise again for the fault in the subtitles. Those responsible for sacking the people who have just been sacked have been sacked.

[@vectorsigma6757]

I hear they were bitten by a møøse... They were karving their initials on it... There were also some Llamas involved in the situation...

[@lumpwurtroot]

Literally watched that for the first time today, what a coincidence

[@crypticcryptid4702]

Møøse bites Kan be pretty nasti

[@laurapalmer511]

Seeing this the second I clicked on the video killed me.

[@andyjg13]

You're not fooling anyone. Under 100 sins means you loved it! 🤣

[@PheydraSunstar]

Haha! That's what I tell my husband when he watches an episode with me (or just hears the DINGS since those tend to be heard anywhere in the house). Anything under 100 is good to go!

[@danielgehring7437]

Just because a movie is sinful doesn't mean it isn't entertaining... a lot of the times, as with anything in life, the more sins the better it is.

[@Ro-gp8lj]

There's no meaning to the sins. That's the point. Look at their review of themselves

[@Predated2]

@@PheydraSunstar well, movies are about taste. I once saw a cinemasins vid of a movie they loved, but I hated, but they sinned parts of the movie that I enjoyed(and they probably enjoyed some of them too).

[@MrChaotic4]

@@Ro-gp8lj It's all for comedy. But you never watch any of these videos before watching the movie because of spoilers.

[@kennethfoster3913]

1:00 Criticizing a dude who jumps into paintings for breaking the 4th wall.

[@mcdonalds5972]

"There's a nice spot there by Suffolk Bridge, popular with jumpers." *" W H A T T H E F U C K "*

[@docilecrocodile6362]

4:36 well actually they wouldn't refer to the basking shark instead of the cod as the basking shark was only discovered by Japanese fishermen in 1977 while Mary Poppins came out in 1964. *DING*

[@lainiwakura1776]

And it takes place in 1910.

[@DeathnoteBB]

Well this is cinemasins, where the sins are made up and logic doesnt matter!

[@josephfisher426]

The cod is probably just a Peter Pan reference, or a reference to whatever *that* joke was about.

[@mstrainjr]

I am amazed that you actually researched that. Well done! =D

[@sokaybraun2188]

Disney theory #246-B: Mary Poppins is a time traveler.

[@joshuaknapp9109]

6:49-7:08 CinemaSins fat shaming an animated horse XD

[@qures5763]

😂😂😂

[@slarkel506]

Really though? Fat shaming? -_-

[@percyperanamus7432]

@@slarkel506 thats what he did

[@yellowbananago]

XD

[@pissapocalypse]

The horse was pretty fast though lol

[@srt10acrx]

Funny you should mention her saying it backwards wrong. The musical is one of my favorites and in the Broadway musical she actually says it backwards like a recording played in reverse.

[@erinbaldryvlogs1860]

Me when cinema sins makes a Hamilton references Me: *SCREAMS VERY LOUDLY* My family: Since when did we own a hyena

[@loogoos4894]

I find this incorrect because Marry Poppins is “Practically Perfect in Every Way”

[@carlosvalois8966]

They really should have taken all the sins off at the end for this alone. COME ON CINEMASINS, GET WITH THE PLAN!

[@tastybritches6644]

Bitch lies right to your face, She's also stuck up her own ass, and she's a partypooper. Also medicates the children without parents permission, practically perfect my ass. That measuring tape came from her, I bet she made it because she HAS to be practically perfect in every way.

[@haru5257]

@@tastybritches6644 she's a fictional character, don't worry...

[@gachakate7396]

I agree it’s just a movie

[@BLKBRDSR71]

The key word is "Practically". That said, she deliberately put the kids lives in danger by bringing them to the roof. Unless she was planning on getting her self fired. Then job well done.

[@deilhif8522]

I would like to sincerely thank you for correctly naming Elizabeth Tower. I don’t really blame people for not knowing because I live in Scotland and most of us here don’t even know.

[@lucariomew365]

@@dadeleemurphy85 The clock tower is Elizabeth's Tower, the giant bell (called the "Great Bell) located inside the tower is known as Big Ben, while the clock itself has no name.

[@spamman9923]

1:38 Yes...just yes. I live for that Hamilton reference.

[@oracle6162]

All the theater kids do

[@Someonewe7lv]

A Hamilton reference? Respect to you dude

[@James.Stark.Ben.Edition]

You HAVE to sin The Sound of Music now.

[@zeithandnetopia9037]

Oh God the worst movie in existence HAS to be sinned

[@James.Stark.Ben.Edition]

@@zeithandnetopia9037 you think the sound of music is bad? You must hate musicals as a genre then because it's one of the best out there. It's right up there with the best.

[@James.Stark.Ben.Edition]

@@zeithandnetopia9037 also, it's not even close to the worst movie in existence. You've never seen bad movies.

[@giulia2503]

@@zeithandnetopia9037 how dare you

[@zacharyschwartz5037]

There is nothing wrong with that movie, it is so wholesome and beautiful

[@sarahvanorden670]

In defense of feed the birds: It was Walt Disney’s absolute favorite song he ever heard so... also that and stay awake always help me sleep when insomnia is just too powerful

[@drewwelker2044]

Yas Hamilton references! My wig is snatched

[@thomassaldana2465]

12:15 "I would like to make one thing quite clear; I never explain anything." She should've been sinned for explaining that she never explains.

[@DeeTheRobotOwnz]

Am I the only one seeing comments from 13 hours ago, though the video was posted like 21 minutes ago?

[@jamesbaucom9295]

Premier

[@LordVulcan93]

And here I thought I was the only one that needed to check my glasses :/

[@MichaelBerthelsen]

Patreon supporters get early access.

[@twitch.razor_raze1666]

Ye

[@stopshootfilms4196]

Hey I'm an up and coming filmmaker. I recently just put out a short film about A young African American husband who has to deal with dire consequences after losing his job and benefits. I'm looking to start a base, if you would please check it out. kzbin.info/www/bejne/j2Gnh4WqerimmbM

[@DrNeonGaming]

You saying Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious backwards summoned Cuthulu, great job

[@violetchaos364]

This is why we can't have nice things.

[@dawnmayflower4422]

violetchaos364 Lol

[@frustywitanegg]

Lmao I cried at this, that's great

[@joemurdoch4138]

Great movie, probably one of Disney's best. One of the few musical movies where most of the songs are good. No director would probably do that three minute walk to Mr. Banks firing, but it draws sympathy and demonstrates just how lonely he feels.

[@austinnix4416]

it also demonstrates the fact that this is his movie. It's not about Mary Poppins or the children. This is Mr. Banks' story.

[@heyjude6680]

​@@austinnix4416 but...the movies literally called "Mary Poppins"

[@bigjohn08865]

Here is my beef about this film. The film suggests that George Bank is a workaholic with no time for his children. So at the end of the film while flying a kite with his kids He is given a promotion? Wouldn't that job require even more time and commitment?

[@Mr12Relic]

His promotion was from Junior Officer (probably approving loans) to Junior Partner, a managerial oversight position. He'd have far greater control over his schedule.

[@thepickygamer4450]

Maybe not, have you ever seen a store director doing work? I haven't, and that position is considered a promotion.

[@mii_kay4514]

The best part for me is simply that he is so happy after losing his job. This feels too much like my own life xD *trashes away*

[@sorcerykid]

But do we really know whether he took the job? It's not revealed to my knowledge.

[@joeyjerry1586]

George working a lot though doesn’t correlate to him not spending time with his children though. Even when he’s not working in the morning and evening, he’s cold to them. His arc is not about realising he should stop working because it’s taking a toll on family time but he comes to appreciate and love his children more

[@quantuminfinity4260]

2:50 I mean, have you seen kids? They can be both at the same time, they can flip from being obidiant perfect kids and then raise hell on earth for a nany or some one else.

[@carlrood4457]

Especially, since the whole point of gas lighting nannies is to get their father's attention.

[@mchoovy6146]

Exhibit A, my little brother

[@DaveDexterMusic]

the fuck is a nany

[@KhanMann66]

Google it you ignorant fool.

[@elweasel2010]

CinemaSins 8:12 Disney scooping up Fox and running. LMFAO :)

[@KnightsaysNi]

This one was my favorite bit in the entire video, hahaha! XD

[@kdenny9101]

Are we gonna ignore the fact that her glove changes from white to black then white again at 4:24

[@vivianeallen3334]

Honestly, "feed the birds" gets stuck in my head more than "supercalifragilisticexpialidocious".

[@superpunkrotten6650]

Viviane Allen looking on KZbin at Mary poppins sings Pink Floyd

[@jobiggle4039]

That big horse bit had me rolling, haha.

[@michaelbelcher8805]

Jo Biggle in which case you bit off more than you could chew. But hay thats just my opinion

[@katilyntullos8147]

It's actually said in the bonus features of the anniversary Mary Poppins release that the song "Feed the Birds" was one of Walt Disney's favorite songs by the Sherman brothers. Richard Sherman actually recalls that Walt would come into his office and have him play this while Walt gazed out the window. If you also saw the movie Saving Mr.Banks you would know that Marry Poppins was there to save Mr.Banks and not the children.

[@princessthyemis]

I didn't know that. Super cool!

[@perpetuallylydia1241]

That movie made me cry so hard

[@UncleMikeNJ]

Wow, just like in the 1990s CBS sitcom "The Nann-- " ... Oh... Ding. Also, like Julie Andrews again, filling in for Broadway's Mary Martin, in "The Sound of Music." Ding. Also, like the butler was in the 1980s ABC sitcom "Mr. Belvedere." Ding. Of course, this got turned on its head in the Batman story, where Robin "saves" Batman every bit as much as Alfred does.

[@Joel23901]

This video should be 15 seconds long and that 15 seconds should be for the intro to the video because this movie is practically perfect in every way

[@curi0kills]

1:33 cinema sins has just become my favorite KZbin channel for that bomb ass Hamilton reference

[@luna_belle]

Blackcanary 017 YES

[@Sweetthang9]

I always thought she said "caught fish".....which made sense to me seeing as they generally have their mouths open as they slowly suffocate to death.

[@HankD13]

Cod because it is what they are the fish that go with chips out of - not many sharks to be seen the fish mongers.

[@BlaiddDrwg2009]

I thought it was goldfish.

[@scarffoxandfriends9401]

He had the subtitles on, they probably say cod fish

[@daddydevito8305]

Damn you went to the archives for this one

[@thecrazygecko4783]

1:35 So then, Lin-Manuel Miranda becomes an actor in Mary Poppins.

[@fatesvagrant768]

I remember liking Bedknobs and Broomsticks much more than Mary Poppins as a kid.

[@rochelleclark3169]

What about Chitty Chitty Bang Bang? These three were my childhood! They all have good actors/actresses and catchy songs. I literally just sang Feed the Birds to some kids I was babysitting; so yeah I'm one of those ppl that absolutely adores all 3 movies...

[@fatesvagrant768]

@@rochelleclark3169 I actually don't really remember Chitty CHitty Bang Bang, I think I have seen it but I was younger.

[@kenhollis6197]

Totally agree. Mary Poppins never appealed to me when I was a young'un, but I absolutely LOVED Bedknobs and Broomsticks.

[@johnivanoplimo5172]

"I'm Mary Poppins, y'all!" Oh, wait. Wrong movie.

[@efcfan4649]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@davincent98]

It is an outtake

[@tehgundulf9394]

Lol

[@ghostcityshelton9378]

😑🙂☺😁😃😄😆😂 Maybe it's in the re-make. Ha,ha ah....no.

[@Jamie_Jewel]

You will respect the song “Feed the Birds!” That song is notably Walt Disney’s favorite song!

[@patiencewallace8453]

him hating on the horse got me 😂😂😂

[@tgguitarguy]

10:17 Feed the Birds was Walt's Favorite Song that the Sherman brothers wrote for the movie. It's deep, meaningful, and fantastic, if it bores you, you are watching the wrong movie dude.

[@loulou7963]

tgguitarguy 👍👍👍👍👍❤️❤️

[@leeswigert8158]

I love the song. Truly one of my favorites in the whole of Disney movies.

[@SteveCarras]

@@leeswigert8158 Me,too, so nicely powerful!

[@sorcerykid]

Same here. The other songs get much more praise, but I think this was the most heart-felt song of the whole movie.

[@brigitrogers5857]

You sin this movie for making the ONLY good case you've ever seen for having a Home Owners Association, but in the video for My Big Fat Greek Wedding you sin the movie for being the first time you were made to see the value of an HOA because of the Greek flag painted on their garage door. This means that this movie is the SECOND good case you've seen for an HOA... *ding*

[@nicklynch216]

Wow first time I saw cinema sins get called out

[@James.Stark.Ben.Edition]

The movie is actually really good. Considering I saw it for the first time ever last year, it's an excellent movie. And I don't have nostalgia glasses.

[@RedwoodTheElf]

Did you also watch "Saving Mr. Banks?" The excellent dramatization of how Disney convinced the author to let him make the movie?

[@SPM0717]

@@RedwoodTheElf Yeah but it's not wholly accurate.

[@mid-sizesedan488]

Aditya Upadhye it’s good but Cinema Sins just wants to make money.

[@EchthelionII]

I have never seen this movie, this is the closest I ever got to watching it.

[@lauralyrics5536]

Adityaltykjgk

[@reythejediladyviajakku6078]

Mary Poppins always a win. When I was a kid, I wanted a babysitter like her

[@MandyBuglet]

Not gonna lie...when I was a tiny child, I thought Dick Van Dyke's accent was real.

[@bellascerpe933]

Okay, I sat through you sinning my favorite movie from my childhood with a smile *BUT **14:47** WAS TOO FAR, JEREMY*

[@ColdWarAviator]

Lol

[@jessicafritts9280]

That's hilarious what are you talking about

[@caitlinrix294]

No it wasn't.

[@_jd_261]

"Mr Stark.... I don't feel so good"

[@AdmiralFerret]

I read this about 11 minutes in.. can't wait to see what it is lol -lmao! Had to listen a couple times

[@urielseasalt1776]

Alexander Hamilton My name is Alexander Hamilton and there's a million things I haven't done. But just you wait.

[@lonsdaleitepolitics9597]

When he was ten, his father split,

[@mythofreadiness2213]

You got a boyfriend ,but I bet he doesn't kiss ya muah

[@itsjustmenova]

That bit when he started singing Hamilton had me laughing

[@Hensynslose]

Alexander Anderson My name is Alexander Anderson And I like killing things because it's fun So just you pray Just you pray

[@royaltycomics]

13:29 Every time Cinemasins makes a "college girlfriend" joke.

[@Kaaaaaaafire17]

I truly love how some people still don’t get the point of this channel.

[@russelldodd6087]

Yep, random observations counted as 'sins'. This particular vid is still crap and desperate though.

[@David-bc4rh]

It's like they come here expecting an academic presentation on film discontinuity, but are disappointed to mostly find jokes and insults to the writers and directors.

[@magicman205]

I truly love how some people still use the argument "it's satire" as a valid defense. This channel is awful.

[@adventurebonni5]

@@magicman205 later you said this movie is .....

[@jimpadgett8233]

@Jak Stone exactly right?! 😂😂😂

[@BeanBag343]

Mary Poppins is practically perfect in every way 🐧 💖

[@dy1ansually345]

BeanBag343 kzbin.info/www/bejne/kJyTh5J_ptCniJo

[@oliver297]

When he started singing Hamilton at the beginning I got all hyped then he stopped

[@seraphinadavila2090]

AND A SCOTSMAN DROPPED IN THE MIDDLE OF A FORGOTTEN SPOT IN THE CARIBBEAN BY PROVIDENCE, IMPOVERISHED, IN SQUALOR GROW UP TO BE A HERO AND A SCHOLAR?

[@geesus1271]

@@seraphinadavila2090 THE TEN DOLLAR FOUNDING FATHER WITHOUT A FATHER GOT A LOT FARTHER BY WORKING A LOT HARDER

[@seraphinadavila2090]

BY BEING A LOT SMARTER BY BEING A SELF-STARTER BY FOURTEEN, THEY PLACED HIM IN CHARGE OF A TRADING CHARTER

[@oliver297]

@@seraphinadavila2090 AND EVERY DAY WHILE SLAVES WERE BEING SLAUGHTERED AND CARTED AWAY ACROSS THE WAVES HE STRUGGLED AND KEPT HIS GUARD UP. INSIDE HE WAS LONGING FOR SOMETHING TO BE A PART OF. THE BROTHER WAS READY TO BEG, STEAL, BORROW, OR BARTER

[@seraphinadavila2090]

THEN A HURRICANE CAME AND DEVASTATION REIGNED OUR MAN SAW HIS FUTURE DRIP, DRIPPING DOWN THE DRAIN.

[@brandonlangevin6449]

This has to be one of my favorite cinemasins I've watched!!

[@Texelion3Dprints]

I really expected Fiona making the bird explode in the outtakes when Mary sings with the bird.

[@Steveofthejungle8]

No sins for American Robins being in England?

[@Dr.Zoidberg_2914]

You'd be excellent at cinemasins

[@nighton3]

I have a friend who has mentioned that every single time we've seen the movie.

[@brycevo]

I'm *Mary Poppins* Y'all!

[@queencandymampane7604]

Dammit U beat me into saying it

[@mypal1990]

Yondu should be given that title.

[@giggityking6505]

I AM GROOT

[@aculeatus]

@@giggityking6505 I am Groot.

[@TheSpearkan]

me: ooh, an EWW for Mary Poppins! I wonder how far I'll go before someone quotes Yondu? "literally one comment in" me: Oh.

[@MiniKitty27]

14:46 I shouldn't be laughing but I am omg I'm a terrible human being XD

[@Nimwei]

That Monty Python reference made laugh a lot harder than I should have

[@ovs4744]

My friend said he knew a man with a wooden leg named Smith. So I asked him "What was the name of his other leg?"

[@Lord_Skeptic]

Sounds like a 2 ronnies joke

[@davincent98]

Wesson

[@damammacat1632]

After my daughter watched Mary Poppins for the first time, she would constantly say that joke!

[@BenOnBass]

Gotta love how many times an old Disney movie makes Jeremy say WTF?

[@PalataoBola0]

CinemaSins - Negative Sins Supercut Part 1 (January 2018 to June 2018) kzbin.info/www/bejne/g6C0iKWZa7KcY9E

[@wulfezz8010]

Benjamin Brown how did u comment 13 hrs ago if the vid came out 10 min ago

[@calebproductions1264]

I keep seeing you everywhere Matt, can you stop with these fake advertisements?

[@BenOnBass]

@@nehemiahhoward8230 Nailed it. Totally worth the Patreon btw

[@jestaplushgal3528]

How is your comment 16 hours old when the vid was posted 2 hours ago

[@jahaliel]

okay so you doing supercalifragilisticexpalidocious backwards was incredible XD

[@pennydreadful7732]

You tried so hard to find flaws in this, but you just love it - it's practically perfect in every way.

[@Hiraghm]

Banks' song about his orderly life was meant to demonstrate A) how oblivious he was to his home (because he was working himself into an early grave providing for that wretched family) and B) how when he was there to run things up until the coming of Mary Poppins, things seemed to go smoothly because _he made them go smoothly_ when he was there. And thanks to her, he's now able to see how things are when he's not controlling them.

[@Doctor_Odin]

It was essentially enlightening the parents with a heavy focus on the father (because tradition / relatability) the dangers of distancing yourself from your offspring and what happens when you do. With the song being a means to demonstrate his gullibility in still believing that he can control them while being a stranger to them. The the end result of the movie has them all happy content and orderly. when he stopped being a stranger to his kids.

[@gozzilla177]

Those subtitles are superfragileisticexbealAtrocious!!!

[@MariaMaria-sr8zg]

I love the laughing scenes on the ceiling.

[@broondoonphooloon]

The monty python reference has me rotfl😂😂😂

[@Giarcnek]

Mary Poppins went to Hogwarts. She's a Class A Witch. Dick VanDyke is a Squib. Anyways....How cool would that be?

[@princessthyemis]

oh my GOSH yes

[@leiwolf27]

Fuck that Hogwarts shit, she’s a timelord with timelord technology

[@Vaole]

Screw her being a timelord, I do say she is a witch. She is not good enough to be a timelord.

[@leiwolf27]

John so you are saying witches are not good enough? She has timelord technology, how else do you explain her bag?

[@priscillajimenez27]

That'd be really cool...which house?

[@spilledmilk4461]

Lol the best thing about the Hamilton reference is that Lin Manuel Miranda will be in the new Mary Poppins movie

[@mr.bluependant1871]

Lin Manuel Miranda sucks.

[@okay._.._.9351]

@@mr.bluependant1871 no u

[@itskirstiswani98]

I love Hamilton

[@Kaaaaaaafire17]

Monsieur Bleu Pen okay, that needs an explanation. You can’t just say he sucks without saying why he sucks. Why do you think he sucks?

[@graceliz865]

Monsieur Bleu Pen ExCUSE me? Lin is a GIFT to humanity. Win two Tonys for best musical and write two beautiful scores and also be a triple threat and then say he sucks.

[@oswin5775]

I had forgotten how trippy this movie is 😂

[@julitaylor3452]

14:47, THAT WAS UNCALLED FOR SIR

[@micahphilson]

6:00 Nice try, but Google at least tells me that Charles Manson is a full half foot _shorter_ than Julie Andrews! Aaaand the joke's on me, I now have "Charles Manson height" on my search history.

[@TheYasmineFlower]

If anyone asks, just tell them you mistook him for Marilyn Manson.

[@uzivertical9880]

@@TheYasmineFlower lol doesnt make it much better

[@Menaceblue3]

So what was his height? I'm scared to look myself.

[@BartHartful]

Julie Andrews, 5'8". Charles Manson, 5'2". Marylin Manson, 6'1". I need a life.

[@NoArtisticLimitation]

Crap... I’m 5’2”...

[@trinepetersen5435]

This changes nothing. Mary Poppins is f*cking gold

[@HolyCross9]

I'm honestly suprised that CinemaWins has done a video for this gorgeous masterpiece of a classic film.

[@sabrinaduckett5057]

This is one of the funniest commentaries of this series!